Fate of transforming DNA following uptake by competent Bacillus subtilis. I. Formation and properties of the donor-recipient complex

Following uptake by competent Bacillus subtilis, transforming DNA is converted to two distinct slowly sedimenting molecular forms which possess little transforming activity (eclipse). A few minutes after uptake is initiated, a physical complex of donor and recipient DNA begins to form. The recovery of donor transforming activity following eclipse, and the appearance of recombinant activity, previously reported by Venema, Pritchard &; Venema-Schröder (1965), is shown to be due to changes occurring in the donor—recipient complex. This complex exists transiently in a form with low recombinant-type transforming activity. This transient form may be one in which the donor and recipient components are joined non-covalently. The donor-recipient complex is shown to be a heteroduplex structure in which the donor moiety has an approximate molecular weight of 750,000.     

Fate of Transforming Deoxyribonucleic Acid After Uptake by Competent Bacillus subtilis: Size and Distribution of the Integrated Donor Segments

A series of sheared donor-recipient complex samples were prepared from a competent Bacillus subtilis culture which had been transformed by using ³H, ²H-labeled deoxyribonucleic acid. Measurement of the molecular weights and buoyant densities of these samples led to the following conclusions. (i) The average size of the single-stranded donor segment which is integrated is 2.8 × 10⁶. (ii) These donor segments are not randomly distributed in the recipient genome, but are clustered in groups, each group containing several discrete donor segments.     

Single-strand breakage on binding of DNA to cells in the genetic transformation of Diplococcus pneumoniae.

Mutants of Diplococcus pneumoniae that lack a membrane-localized DNAase are defective in transformation because entry of DNA into the cell is blocked. Such mutants still bind DNA on the outside of the cell. The bound DNA is double-stranded and its double-stranded molecular weight is unchanged. Its sedimentation behavior in alkali, however, shows that it has undergone single-strand breakage. The breaks are located randomly in both strands of the bound DNA at a mean separation of 2 × 10⁶ daltons of single-stranded DNA. Both binding and single-strand breakage occur in the presence of EDTA. Single-strand breaks are similarly formed on binding of DNA to normally transformable cells in the presence of EDTA. The single-strand breaks appear to be a consequence of attachment. DNA may be bound to the cell surface at the point of breakage.A mutant that is partially blocked in entry also binds DNA mainly on the outside of the cell. In the presence of EDTA, DNA bound by this mutant undergoes only single-strand breaks. In the absence of EDTA, however, double-strand breaks occur, apparently as a result of the initiation of entry. It is possible that the double-strand breaks arise from additional single-strand breaks opposite those that occurred on binding. The double-strand breaks presumably result from action of the membrane DNAase as it begins to release oligonucleotides from one strand segment while drawing the complementary strand segment into the cell.     

An unstable donor-recipient DNA complex in transformation of Bacillus subtilis.

Summary In re-extracted DNA obtained shortly after uptake of transforming DNA by Bacillus subtilis, increased amounts of donor DNA radioactivity banding at the position of donor-recipient DNA complex (DRC) are observed in CsCl gradients, if the cells are irradiated with high doses of UV prior to reextraction of the DNA. Qualitatively, the same phenomenon is observed if lysates of transforming cells are irradiated. UV-irradiation of lysates of competent cells to which single-stranded DNA is added after lysis, does not result in linkage of this DNA to the chromosomal DNA. Two observations argue in favour of the formation of a specific labile complex between donor and resident DNA during transformation. Firstly, heterologous donor DNA from Escherichia coli, although being processed to single-stranded DNA in competent B. subtilis, does not seem to be linked to the recipient chromosome upon UV-irradiation, and secondly, the labile complex of donor and recipient DNA can be stabilized by means of treatment of the lysates of transforming cells with 4, 5¹, 8-trimethylpsoralen in conjuction with long-wave ultra violet light irradiation. This indicates that base-pairing is involved in the formation of the complex. On the basis of these results we assume that the unstable complex of donor and recipient DNA is an early intermediate in genetic recombination during transformation.     

Molecular Fate of Heterologous Bacterial DNA in Competent BACILLUS SUBTILIS. II. Unstable Association of Heterologous DNA with the Recipient Chromosome

In CsCl density gradients of lysates from competent Bacillus subtilis cells, which had been exposed to heterologous bacterial DNA, very little donor-recipient complex (DRC) formation could be detected. The present study demonstrates that photocrosslinking of such lysates by irradiation with long-wave UV light in the presence of 4,5',8-trimethylpsoralen results in a dramatic increase in the amount of heterologous DRC. This phenomenon may be interpreted as the stabilization of a pre-existing weak association between entered heterologous donor DNA and one recipient strand in unpaired regions of the chromosome. When a recombination-deficient mutant is used, the amount of stabilizable heterologous DRC is reduced to the same extent as the specific transforming activity of homologous DNA. Although the amount of stabilizable complex is related to the degree of homology between donor and recipient DNA, this relation is not a quantitative one. Probably the association is caused by very short regions of base pairing between the donor and recipient moieties in the complex. Heating of a lysate at 70° prior to photocrosslinking prevents stabilization, apparently because the regions of base pairing are rapidly melted out. The results described in this paper can be best interpreted as the fixation of a process in which entered donor DNA in competent cells tries to find homologous stretches in the recipient chromosome.     

Ultraviolet inactivation and excision-repair in Bacillus subtilis. II. Differential inactivation and differential repair of transforming markers

Ultraviolet inactivation of transforming Bacillus subtilis markers was studied with the aid of an eightfold auxotrophic recipient and its excision-repair-deficient derivative. The results allow the following conclusions. (i) Wild-type B. subtilis cells are able to repair approx. 80% of the UV-induced lesions causing inactivation of transforming activity in UV-sensitive recipients; (ii) Saturating amounts of donor DNA increase the apparent marker sensitivities. This phenomenon is most pronounced in transformation of UV-sensitive recipients; (iii) various markers are inactivated to different degrees, both when assayed on the wild-type as well as on the UV-sensitive strain; (iv) Various markers are repaired to different degrees in the wild-type recipient.     

Molecular fate of heterologous bacterial DNA in competent Bacillus subtilis: further characterization of unstable association between donor and recipient DNA and the involvement of the cellular membrane

Summary Although heterospecific transformation is extremely inefficient and very little heterologous donor DNA integrates into the recipient chromosome in a stable way, we have previously shown that B. pumilus DNA entering competent B. subtilis efficiently associates with the recipient chromosome in an unstable way. This association can be stabilized by photocrosslinking in the presence of 4,5,8-trimethylpsoralen; it depends on the recombination proficiency of the recipient strain and on strand-separation of the recipient chromosome (te Riele and Venema 1982b). The present study provides further evidence that the heterologous donor DNA and the recipient DNA are associated by regions of base-pairing. Based on the high sensitivity of the donor moiety in the complex to nuclease S1 (90%) and the high sensitivity of the complex to moderate denaturing conditions (Tm=48°C), we presume that donor and recipient DNA are associated either by several short sequences of 15–25 fairly well matched base pairs or by a region of base-pairing of about 200 bases, which contains 25% of mismatches. During incubation, the unstable complex disappears, probably due to nucleolytic degradation.The unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex (DRC) was found to be membrane-bound. However, in contrast to homologous DRC, the unstable heterologous DRC remains membrane bound during incubation. Apparently, the predominantly single-stranded character of the heterologous DRC prevents release of the complex from the membrane.Abbreviations DRC donor-recipient complex - TMP 4,5,8-trimethyl-psoralen - DNAase I deoxyribonuclease 1 - TCA trichloroacetic acid     

Heterospecific transformation in Bacillus subtilis: protein composition of a membrane-DNA complex containing unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex

Summary Previously it was demonstrated that, in contrast to the homologous donor-recipient complex, the unstable heterologous donor-recipient complex remains bound to the cellular membrane. To examine whether proteins known to be involved in the processing of transforming DNA in Bacillus subtilis are associated with membrane fragments which carry chromosomal DNA, a crude membrane-DNA complex was subjected to electrophoresis through a sucrose gradient. This resulted in the separation of membrane fragments associated with DNA and free membrane fragments. By means of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis several proteins, either uniquely present or considerably enriched in the purified membrane-DNA complex, were detected. Among these proteins we identified the 45 kD recE gene product, required for recombination, the 18 kD binding protein involved in the binding of transforming DNA and a 17 kD nuclease involved in the entry of transforming DNA.These results suggest that the membrane sites at which donor DNA integrates into the recipient chromosome are in the vicinity of the sites of entry of donor DNA through the membrane.Abbreviations DNAase I deoxyribonuclease I - DRC donor-recipient DNA complex - PEG polyethyleneglycol - PMSF phenylmethylsulphonylfluoride - SSC standard saline citrate - TCA trichloroacetic acid     

On the Nature of Recombinants Formed during Transformation in Hemophilus influenzae

During the process of transformation in Hemophilus influenzae integration of donor DNA, i.e. the formation of recombinant DNA, involves the incorporation of single-stranded DNA. Evidence was obtained from cesium chloride density gradient centrifugation of DNA from donor-recipient complexes that integration was accompanied by the formation of hybrid DNA with a density intermediate with respect to heavy, ²H, ¹⁵N, donor and light, ¹H, ⁴N recipient DNA. On denaturation the position of the heavy donor DNA moved closer to, but not all the way toward, the density position of the original donor DNA. In addition to supporting the idea of single-stranded incorporation, this evidence suggested that the integrated donor DNA was covalently linked to light recipient DNA. The DNA was taken up in the double-stranded form and no detectable amounts of denatured DNA could be found during the transformation process. However, during the process of integration an amount of donor atoms, equivalent to the amount of hybrid DNA formed, appeared in recipient DNA, and indicated that while one strand of DNA was integrated the other was broken down and resynthesized. The density of the hybrid DNA, as well as rebanding of denatured hybrid, indicated that the size of the integrated piece of DNA was large, approximately 6 x 10⁶ daltons.     

Transformation inBacillus subtilis. Initial stages of the transformation process and their energy dependence

NaN₃ was found to inhibit transformation but not the irreversible binding of donor³H-DNA in competent cells of the original low-transformable strainBacillus subtilis 168trp ₂ . Addition of NaN₃ to cells of two mutantsBacillus subtilis HT39 and HT46 with an increased transformability decreased substantially the irreversible binding of the donor DNA to the competent cells. The decreased irreversible binding of DNA is caused by an increased osmotic sensitivity of competent cells of the mutants HT39 and HT46 in the presence of NaN₃, leading preferentially to lysis of the competent cells.     

Involvement of single-strand breaks in complex formation between single-stranded DNA and nucleoids of Bacillus subtilis

Summary RNase-unfolded chromosomes of competent Bacillus subtilis are able to take up single-stranded homologous donor DNA fragments in vitro to form donor-recipient DNA complexes (Van Randen and Venema 1981). The unfolded chromosomes behave as supercoiled DNA molecules. X-irradiation increased the formation of unstable and stable complexes between donor and recipient DNA during incubation at 37° C. The complex-forming ability of the unfolded chromosomes increased linearly with increasing X-ray dose, even after complete relaxation of the unfolded chromosomes had occurred. Limited DNase I action increased the complex-forming ability of the chromosomes as effectively as X-irradiation.Unstable donor-recipient DNA complexes can be distinguished from stable ones by their dissociation upon density gradient centrifugation in CsCl at pH 11.2. They are stable at pH 10 (Van Randen et al. 1982a). At an intermediate pH value during isopycnic centrifugation, a fraction of the unstable complexes were stable, suggesting that a range of stabilities existed among the unstable complexes. The donor moiety of the stable donor-recipient DNA complexes was far more resistant to nuclease S1 treatment than that of the unstable ones.     

Heat-sensitive Step in Deoxyribonucleic Acidmediated Transformation of Bacillus subtilis

Over 90% of the competent cells in a population of Bacillus subtilis lost their competence after being heated to 50 C for 5 min. There was only a slight loss in the number of transformants if the culture was heated for 5 min after the termination of transformation, but 90% of the transformants were lost after 1 hr at 50 C. The population as a whole grew at a slightly faster rate at 50 C than at 32 C. We postulate that a heat-labile factor is required for the uptake or retention (or both) of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) in the cell, since uptake of ³²P-DNA into a deoxyribonuclease-resistant form was inversely proportional to the time of exposure to heat. Cells that had lost competence after being heated did not regain their competence for at least several hours, although other cells in the population became competent. These data suggest that the heat-labile factor required for competence is synthesized only once during the period that a cell remains competent.     

Transformation in Bacillus subtilis: characterization of an intermediate in recombination observed during transformation.

Summary From recombination-proficient competent cells of Bacillus subtilis in which the donor DNA entered at 17°, and which were kept at the same temperature, a complex of donor DNA and the recipient chromosome can be obtained which has a relatively high buoyant density in CsCl gradients. Exposure of the isolated complex to nuclease S1 liberates donor radioactivity. The limited biological activity of DNA re-extracted from cells attempting to recombine at 17° is decreased upon incubation with nuclease S1. If recombination is allowed to proceed at 30°, the high buoyant density of the donor-recipient complex decreases to normal values and less radioactivity can be liberated from the complex by nuclease S1. Concomitantly the biological activity of re-extracted DNA becomes less vulnerable to nuclease S1 under these conditions. On the basis of these observations we assume that the intermediate complex partly consists of unpaired single-stranded donor DNA.Support for the correctness of this assumption is derived from experiments with a mutant, which is delayed in the processing of high buoyant density donor-recipient complex to normal buoyant density donor-recipient complex. This delay is reflected in the time of acquisition of resistance to nuclease S1 digestion of the isolated complex.     

DNA strand breakage caused by dichlorvos, methyl methanesulphonate and iodoacetamide in Escherichia coli and cultured Chinese hamster cells

The DNA damaging properties of dichlorvos (2,2 dichlorovinyl dimethyl phosphate), methyl methanesulphonate (MMS) and iodoacetamide (IAA) have been studied, using alkaline sucrose sedimentation. In a strain of E. coli deficient in DNA polymerase I (polA) both dichlorvos and MMS caused random strand breakage, MMS being about twice as efficient as dichlorvos on a molar basis. In pol⁺ bacteria, DNA strand breaks or alkali labile bonds were detected following treatment with roughly five-fold higher concentrations of MMS but at similar high concentrations of dichlorvos there was an all or none breakdown of DNA molecules to fragments of very low molecular weight which correlated well with lethality.DNA synthesized after treatment of pol⁺ and polA bacteria with MMS was of low molecular weight, indicating the presence of discontinuities. With dichlorvos, the effect was much smaller.Apparent all-or-none DNA breakdown was also found when the polA strain of E. coli was treated with low concentrations of iodoacetamide, an agent that does not detectably alkylate DNA. At higher concentrations the breakdown was suppressed and random strand breakage occurred instea. These effects did not occurr with pol⁺ bacteria and correlated well with the greater sensitivity to iodoacetamide of the polA strain in survival experiments. We suggest that the major DNA damage resulting from treatment with iodoacetamide and dichlorvos arises indirectly through alkylation of other cellular constituents and consequent uncontrolled nuclease attack on the DNA. Discontinuities in newly synthesized DNA and mutagenesis following dichlorvos treatment, however, presumably result from direct alkylation of DNA.Strand breakage caused by dichlorvos and MMS in Chinese hamster cells tended to correlate with the extent to which these agents alkylate DNA, but survivval tended to correlate with the alkylation of protein.     

Discrimination of competent Bacillus subtilis with respect to ribonucleic acids

Summary A study has been made of the affinity of double-stranded heliced RNA for DNA receptors in competent Bacillus subtilis. In competition experiments, using homologous and heterologous DNA samples which had been sheared to molecular weights comparable to that of the RNA (about 2×10⁶), and which still exhibited appreciable competition in DNA uptake experiments, the replicative form of phage f2 RNA showed no evidence of affinity for receptor sites. A second double-stranded RNA preparation from a widely different source, a mycophage of Penicillium chrysogenum, behaved similarly to the f2 RNA. Transfer RNA and 23S ribosomal RNA, which reduce transformation frequencies in pneumococcus, did not compete for B. subtilis receptors. Lack of competition was not due to enzymatic degradation of the RNA, since the latter was recovered intact following exposure to competent cells. Under conditions where homologous native DNA undergoes normal uptake, there was virtually no uptake of native double-stranded RNA. The results are examined in the light of reports on transformation by RNA and DNA-RNA hybrids, and also in relation to the characterization of the specificity of cell-nucleic acid interactions.     

Extracellular DNA Release by Undomesticated Bacillus subtilis Is Regulated by Early Competence

Extracellular DNA (eDNA) release is a widespread capacity described in many microorganisms. We identified and characterized lysis-independent eDNA production in an undomesticated strain of Bacillus subtilis. DNA fragments are released during a short time in late-exponential phase. The released eDNA corresponds to whole genome DNA, and does not harbour mutations suggesting that is not the result of error prone DNA synthesis. The absence of eDNA was linked to a spread colony morphology, which allowed a visual screening of a transposon library to search for genes involved in its production. Transposon insertions in genes related to quorum sensing and competence (oppA, oppF and comXP) and to DNA metabolism (mfd and topA) were impaired in eDNA release. Mutants in early competence genes such as comA and srfAA were also defective in eDNA while in contrast mutations in late competence genes as those for the DNA uptake machinery had no effect. A subpopulation of cells containing more DNA is present in the eDNA producing strains but absent from the eDNA defective strain. Finally, competent B. subtilis cells can be transformed by eDNA suggesting it could be used in horizontal gene transfer and providing a rationale for the molecular link between eDNA release and early-competence in B. subtilis that we report.     

Formation of Single-Stranded DNA during DNA Transformation of Neisseria gonorrhoeae

Neisseria gonorrhoeae is naturally competent for DNA transformation. In contrast to other natural prokaryotic DNA transformation systems, single-stranded donor DNA (ssDNA) has not previously been detected during transformation of N. gonorrhoeae. We have reassessed the physical nature of gonococcal transforming DNA by using a sensitive nondenaturing native blotting technique that detects ssDNA. Consistent with previous analyses, we found that the majority of donor DNA remained in the double-stranded form, and only plasmid DNAs that carried the genus-specific DNA uptake sequence were sequestered in a DNase I-resistant state. However, when the DNA was examined under native conditions, S1 nuclease-sensitive ssDNA was identified in all strains tested except for those bacteria that carried the dud-1 mutation. Surprisingly, ssDNA was also found during transformation of N. gonorrhoeae comA mutants, which suggested that ssDNA was initially formed within the periplasm.     

An endonuclease activity in Bacillus subtilis specific for UV-irradiated DNA

An enzyme activity specific for UV-DNA¹ was found in the extract of $\text{Bacillus subtilis}$(Marburg 168). The enzyme preparation obtained from the extract by ammonium sulfate precipitation acts on UV-DNA endonucleolytically and induces single strand breaks. The number of single strand breaks introduced in DNA is proportional to UV dose.     

Molecular mechanism of genetic recombination in bacterial transformation

Summary B. subtilis cells auxotrophic for two linked markers (ind-his, ind-tyr, his-tyr) have been transformed by means of DNA preparations obtained by hybridization of wild type DNA with the DNA of a strain auxotrophic for one of the linked markers. It was established that hybridization does not increase the transforming activity of DNA for the heterozygous marker. A genetic analysis of the progeny of cells transformed by hybrid or wild type DNA was performed. On the basis of the data obtained a model of genetic recombination in transformation is proved. According to this model both strands of the donor DNA interact independently with the chromosome, and either strand can be incorporated into the cell genome with equal probability. According to the estimate made on the basis of this hypothesis, the probability of integration of a single DNA strand carrying a particular genetic marker is 8%.With 3 Figures in the Text     

Regulation of repair of naturally occurring DNA strand breaks in lymphocytes

Mouse lymphocytes have been shown to contain DNA strand breaks that were repaired within 2h of onset of culture with mitogen. Inhibitors of ADP ribosylation prevented this repair and blocked cell proliferation. The mitogen concanavalin A caused the internal concentration of NAD⁺, the substrate of the ADP ribose polymerase, to rise to about double that of resting cells within 45 min of stimulation. Addition of 300 μm nicotinamide to the culture in absence of mitogen also resulted in a similar increase in internal [NAD⁺], resulting in increased ADP ribosylation activity (measured in permeabilized cells) and in joining of DNA strand breaks; however, none of the subsequent events of lymphocyte activation such as blast transformation and DNA synthesis occurred. These findings indicate that (1) cellular [NAD⁺] is a rate limiting factor in repair of DNA strand breaks in resting lymphocytes and (2) this repair is necessary but not sufficient for lymphocyte proliferation.