How common are common fragile sites: variation of aphidicolin-induced chromosomal fragile sites in a population of the deer mouse (Peromyscus maniculatus)

Aphidicolin (APC)-induced chromosomal gaps and breaks were analyzed for ten deer mice (Peromyscus maniculatus) from a natural population. The FSM statistical methodology was used to identify fragile sites as chromosomal loci exhibiting significantly non-random numbers of gaps/breaks in each individual and enabled an assessment of variation in fragile sites among the individuals. The individual deer mice exhibited as few as 7 to as many as 19 of the populational total of 34 sites. Two sites were fragile in all individuals and 13 sites were fragile in single individuals only. Defined by populational frequencies of greater than 50%, high-frequency fragile sites constituted 26% of the populational total. Approximately 35% of the total fragile sites were fragile in 20–40% of the population (low-frequency fragile sites) and about 38% were fragile in single individuals only. Analysis of the data pooled over all individuals identified significantly non-random breakage at 80 sites, 47 of which were not identified as fragile in any single individual. It appears, therefore, that fragile site identifications from pooled data have fostered an inflated estimate of the numbers and frequencies of common fragile sites. Comparison of the fragile site and spontaneous breakage (control) data suggest that APC-induced fragile sites represent regions of chromosomes that experience elevated levels of somatic mutation. Additionally, the occurrence of APC-induced fragile sites at or near the interstitial breakpoints of two pericentric-inversion polymorphisms in this population supports the hypothesis that fragile sites experience an increased rate of meiotic chromosomal mutation and are predisposed to undergo phylogenetic rearrangement. Received: 22 January 1997 / Accepted: 24 February 1997     

Cytogenetic studies in fragile X syndrome]

The main purpose of this work has been to find a method which would enable the diagnosis of FXS at the cytogenetic level. The studies are based on the analysis of chromosomes from 24 cultures on RPMI-1640 base with an addition of 5-fluoro-2'-deoxyuridine (FUdR) as inhibitor of thymidylate synthetase. The results indicate, that the cultures with the addition of FUdR could considerably improve the expression of fragile X chromosome. It is of great importance, particularly un the cases in which the presence of this marker is very low. It was possibly to specify the significant percentage and the exact position of breaks, gaps and fragile sites, mostly present in autosomes. It could mean, that such factors may play a significant role, apart of X chromosome, in the pathogenesis of FXS. The results of work prove, that this kind of method could be used as a screening for cases with fragile X syndrome.     

Population cytogenetics of folate-sensitive fragile sites

Summary The location and frequency of folate-sensitive common fragile sites (CFS) were studied in three populations: (1) 111 mentally retarded children of school age, (2) 240 mentally subnormal children attending special schools, and (3) 85 healthy children attending normal schools. Common fragile sites were found at 54 chromosomal bands including also the band Xq27, where gaps and breaks were detected in 4% of the children. The most frequent CFS were FRA3B (at 3p14.2), FRA6E (at 6q26), and FRA16D (at 16q23) seen in 73%, 65%, and 58% of the individuals totally studied. The frequencies of CFS-positive individuals did not differ among the populations. The variation found in the distribution of CFS among the populations was primarily assumed to be due to sampling differences and study method. The rate of expression of the most frequent CFS varied significantly among the individuals, seeming to suggest that polymorphism exists at those CFS.     

Chromosome breakage and recombination at fragile sites.

Chromosomal fragile sites are points on chromosomes that usually appear as nonstaining chromosome or chromatid gaps. It has frequently been suggested that fragile sites may be involved in chromosome breakage and recombination events. We and others have previously shown that fragile sites predispose to intrachromosomal recombination as measured by sister-chromatid exchanges. These findings suggested that fragile site expression often, if not always, is accompanied by DNA strand breakage. In the present report, fragile sites are shown to predispose to deletions and interchromosomal recombination. By use of somatic cell hybrids containing either human chromosome 3 or the fragile X chromosome, deletions and translocations were induced by FUdR or aphidicolin with breakpoints at the fragile sites Xq27 or 3p14.2 (FRA3B) or at points so close to the fragile sites as to be cytogenetically indistinguishable. Southern blot analysis of DNA from a panel of chromosome 3 deletion and translocation hybrids was then utilized to detect loss or retention of markers flanking FRA3B and to corroborate the cytogenetic evidence that the breakpoints were at this fragile site. One cell line with a reciprocal translocation between human chromosome 3 (with breakpoint at 3p14.2) and a hamster chromosome showed cytogenetically that the fragile site was expressed on both derivative chromosomes, supporting the hypothesis that the fragile site represents a repeated sequence. The approach described provides a means of generating specific rearrangements in somatic cell hybrids with a breakpoint at a fragile site.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Fragile sites induced by FUdR,caffeine, and aphidicolin

Summary The frequencies of common fragile sites (c-fra) induced in peripheral blood lymphocytes by fluorodeoxyuridine (FUdR), aphidicolin, or caffeine, in eight healthy controls were studied. There was a significantly higher frequency of breaks (P<0.05) in the latter two treatments than the former. Also, significant variation in total number of breaks was observed among the eight individuals within the three treatments. The relative frequency of a fragile site in relation to the total number of fragile sites in an individual rather than its expression in total cells was considered important. Use of a frequency of 4% or more of total fragile sites was proposed to eliminate apparent random breaks that were observed. Using these criteria, a total of 31 c-fra were observed in the three treatments. The distribution of the fragile sites was different in FUdR-treated cells as opposed to caffeine- and aphidicolin-treated cells. Sites 3p14 and 16q23 and Xp22 were the three most frequently observed c-fra. The higher frequency of expression of some fragile sites in normal controls, as observed here, suggests that any relationship between fragile sites and neoplastic transformation has to be carefully evaluated. A classification based on frequency in the population, rather than mode of induction, is suggested.     

Fragile sites and chromosome instability: the distribution of breaks induced by cis-diamine-clichloro-platinum (II) in Fanconi anemia lymphocyte cultures

Summary The distribution of chromosome breaks induced by the antitumor drug cis-diamine-dichloroplatinum (II) in lymphocyte cultures from Fanconi anemia patients was analyzed. Breakpoints occurred nonrandomly over an arbitrarily defined human karyotype of 319 bands. These bands were classified according to either their banding pattern or their fragile site status (whether or not a fragile site of a given type is located at a chromosomal band). A significant involvement of G-light and fragile site bands was detected. The preferential occurrence of breaks at fragile site bands was limited to common fragile site bands (essentially of the aphidicolin-type).     

Translocations of chromosome 12

Summary Human chromosome 12 has been used as a model for studying the distributions of sites of induced and spontaneous breaks. The breakpoints were determined from (1) translocations involving chromosome 12, (2) spontaneous breaks in untreated cultures, (3) radiation-induced breaks, and (4) spontaneous breaks in Fanconi's anaemia.Statistical analysis showed discordance in the results both between the eleven individual bands and between the four assessments. Also, the distribution of breaks for all bands was significantly diferent from random in each assessment. Certain bands added considerable bias to the results, and when analysed individually, only four bands (p11.1, q13, q24, and p13) showed distributions over the four assessments that were significantly different from random. These four bands are Giemsa-negative bands, and two (p13 and q24) are adjacent to telomeres, while p11.4 is adjacent to the centromere. The fourth band, q13, is a known fragile site.It is concluded that bands adjacent to centromeres, which are not C-banded, are peculiarly sensitive to breakage. Telomeric bands are variable in their response to different conditions of breakage, and both the physical structure of the telomere and the specific gene sequences of individual telomeres are probably of importance in determining this response. The fragile site q13 responds as if breakage at this site is due to the base composition of the DNA.     

Synergistic effect of aphidicolin and ethanol on the induction of common fragile sites

Summary The effect of ethanol on the frequency of aphidicolin-induced common fragile sites was studied using lymphocyte cultures from two normal women. Aphidicolin was added to the cultures at a final concentration of 0.2 M and ethanol at 0.02%, 0.1%, 0.2%, 0.5%, and 1%, both during the last 26 h of culture. The frequency of common fragile sites increased from 296% in subject 1 and 201% in subject 2 with aphidicolin plus 0.02% ethanol, to 765% and 823%, respectively, with aphidicolin plus 1% ethanol. Ethanol alone added to cultures did not induce common fragile sites. The gaps and breaks induced by aphidicolin plus ethanol were highly nonrandom. Altogether, 35 common fragile sites were identified. The addition of 1% ethanol to aphidicolin increased both random and nonrandom gaps and breaks as compared with that of 0.02% ethanol. Dimethyl sulfoxide added to culture at final concentrations of 0.02% to 1% did not change the frequency of aphidicolin-induced fragile sites. The frequency of fluorodeoxyuridine-induced fragile sites was not affected by the addition of 0.02% to 1% ethanol. It was thus concluded that ethanol enhances the aphidicolin-induced fragile sites, possibly inhibiting the repair mechanism of gaps and breaks induced by aphidicolin.     

Chromosomal expression and localization of aphidicolin-induced fragile sites in the standard karyotype of river buffalo (Bubalus bubalis)

The present study reports on the chromosomal expression and localization of aphidicolin-induced fragile sites in the standard karyotype of river buffalo (Bubalus bubalis, 2n = 50) with the aim of establishing a 'fragile site map' of the species. Totally, 400 aphidicolin-induced breakages were analyzed from eight young and clinically healthy animals, four males and four females; these breakages were localized in 106 RBG-negative chromosome bands or at the band-interband regions. The number of breakages per chromosome did not vary statistically 'among' the animals investigated but the differences among individual chromosomes were highly significant thus indicating that the chromosomal distribution of the breakages is not random and appears only partially related to chromosome length. Fragile sites were statistically determined as those chromosomal bands showing three or more breakages. In the river buffalo karyotype, 51 fragile sites were detected and localized on the standardized ideogram of the species. The most fragile bands were as follows: 9q213 with 24 breakages out of 400; 19q21 with 16, 17q21 and inacXq24 with 15, 15q23 with 13 and 13q23 with 12 breaks, respectively. Previous gene mapping analysis in this species has revealed that the closest loci to these fragile sites contain genes such as RASA1 and CAST (9q214), NPR3 and C9 (19q19), PLP and BTK (Xq24-q25), OarCP09 (15q24), and EDNRB (13q22) whose mutations are responsible for severe phenotypic malformations and immunodeficiency in humans as well as in mice and meat quality in pigs. Further cytogenetic and molecular studies are needed to fully exploit the biological significance of the fragile sites in karyotype evolution of domestic animals and their relationships with productive and reproductive efficiency of livestock.     

Enhanced sensitivity of lymphoblastoid cells from individuals carrying the mutation for the fragile X syndrome to the clastogenic effects of FUdR

Individuals known to carry the mutation for the fragile X syndrome can sometimes be identified cytogenetically by the presence of a fragile site on the X chromosome at q27.3. The frequency of cells bearing this fragile site is known to be enhanced by culturing the cells in folic acid deficient medium and/or by introducing folic acid metabolism inhibitors such as FUdR. In this study FUdR induction of chromosomal aberrations other than the fragile X was investigated. Lymphoblastoid cells from an obligate carrier, a mentally retarded male and a control were cultured in folic acid deficient medium in the presence of FUdR and harvested at various times after culture initiation. The frequency of chromosome and chromatid breaks was found to be higher in cells from the individuals carrying the mutation for the fragile X syndrome. The frequency of micronuclei, an indirect index of chromosome breakage, was also more elevated in cells from these individuals than in cells from the control. These findings are of potential importance to carrier detection of this common genetic disorder.     

Human chromosome hot points

Summary Peripheral lymphocytes from 16 healthy adults, 9 pregnant women, and 3 fragile X syndrome patients were cultured in Eagle's minimum essential medium without folic acid (MEM-FA). The addition of 2mM, 4mM, or 8mM uridine 24h or 72h prior to harvest resulted in increases of chromosome gaps or breaks, especially at hot points 3p14, 16q23-24, and at fragile site Xq27. Pregnant women showed higher frequencies of 3p14 breaks and total chromosome breaks than men and non-pregnant women. The other chromosome regions, such as 6q26, 7q23, 7q35, 6p25, Xp22, 14q23 and 11p13, also frequently showed gaps or breaks. The results indicated that the unbalance of nucleotide pools was one of the causes of chromosome breakages. The higher frequencies of chromosome gaps and breaks under the condition of thymidylate stress may be due to the misincorporation of uracil instead of thymine into DNA.     

Expression of common fragile sites in two Ceboidea species: Saimiri boliviensis and Alouatta caraya (Primates: Platyrrhini)

Fragile sites are points of preferential breakage that may be involved in chromosome rearrangements. Induction of common fragile sites (c-fra) and spontaneous breakage were analyzed in two New World Monkeys species: Saimiri boliviensis (SBO) and Alouatta caraya (ACA). Spontaneous chromosome aberrations were analyzed on untreated lymphocyte cultures with Brögger''s formula (1977). SBO presented a low level of spontaneous breakage, while higher frequencies were detected in ACA in which bands 1q23; 2q13 and 11q19 were significantly affected (p < 0.01). The populational distribution of c-fra was analyzed by the Chi² test in FUdR plus caffeine treated cultures. A total of 21 c-fra was identified in SBO and 24 in ACA. Fragile sites A₁q33, B₁p21, B₄p14, C₃q23 and C₅q22 were identified in all analyzed SBO specimens. The most frequent c-fra identified in ACA specimens were 1q23, 1q31, 1q33, 2q22, 8q14, 12q31, 13q22, 14q15 and Xq22. Fragile sites A₁q31, A₁q33, B₁q14, B₃q13, B₄q21 and Xq22 identified in SBO and 1q31, 1q33, 2q22, 4q21, 6q13, 13q22 and Xq22 from ACA were the most conserved sites. A low coincidence between the location of c-fra and that of heterochromatin and breakpoints involved in euchromatic rearrangements known for these genera, was established.     

FUdR induction of the X chromosome fragile site: evidence for the mechanism of folic acid and thymidine inhibition

Experiments designed to illuminate the mechanism by which folic acid and thymidine inhibit expression of the Xq28 fragile site in human lymphocytes are described. The fragile site is induced by 5-fluorodeoxyuridine (FUdR), a potent inhibitor of thymidylate synthetase, in the presence of otherwise inhibiting concentrations of folic acid but not in the presence of thymidine. These results indicate that the fragile site is expressed because of depletion of deoxythymidine monophosphate (dTMP) available for DNA synthesis.     

Chromosomal fragile site expression in lymphocytes from patients with schizophrenia

Schizophrenia is a common complex mental disorder. The lifetime prevalence of this disease is about 1% across different populations. The etiology is still unknown despite decades of intensive study. This report is aimed at studying the relationship between chromosomal fragile sites and the etiology of schizophrenia. Lymphocytes of 72 schizophrenic patients and 66 healthy controls were cultured in M medium, which is deficient in folic acid, and in medium RPMI1640 with distamycin A. G-banding was carried out on 100 metaphases of each individual. Fragile sites were characterized as specific chromosomal bands that exhibit nonrandom gaps or breaks. Culture in M medium resulted in significant differences in the total number of chromosomal lesions and the total number of cells with chromosomal lesions between patients and controls (P<0.001), while no difference was noted after exposure to distamycin A. In the case of M medium, 17 bands in both patients and controls were recognized as expressing fragile sites nonrandomly using a statistical method based on the relationship of the binomial and F distributions. Further analysis using Fisher’s exact test revealed a significant excess of expression of a rare fragile site at 2q11.2 among patients compared with controls (P<0.05). In the case of distamycin A induction, 13 bands were identified as having nonrandom expression of fragile sites using the same statistical method. A significant excess expression of a fragile site at 9q12 was identified among patients compared with controls by applying Fisher’s exact test (P<0.001). Thus, our data suggest that chromosomal bands 2q11.2 and 9q12 are interesting regions that may harbor important genes associated with schizophrenia. Received: 21 July 1998 / Accepted: 19 September 1998     

The effect of caffeine on fragile X expression

Summary Caffeine has been reported to enhance the expression of the fragile X [fra(X)] and common fragile sites in peripheral blood lymphocyte cultures (PBLC) treated with 5-fluorodeoxyuridine (FUdR). One of the effects of caffeine on replicating cells is inhibition of DNA repair suggesting that fragile sites may be regions of DNA with a high rate of misreplication under the conditions of thymidylate stress induced by FUdR. We have studied the effect of caffeine on the expression of the fra(X) and common folate-dependent fragile sites in PBLC from two fra(X) expressing individuals and in five lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL) established from individuals in families in which the fra(X) is segregating. Caffeine did not enhance the expression of the fra(X) in the PBLC or in the three LCL from fra(X) expressing individuals nor did it elicit fra(X) expression in LCL from a non-expressing obligate-carrier female and a transmitting male. However, in all cultures there was a marked increase of common fragile site expression due to caffeine treatment. These data suggest that the mechanism of expression of the common fragile sites and the fra(X) may be quite different.     

Folate-sensitive fragile sites on the X-chromosome heterochromatin of the Indian mole rat, Nesokia indica

Folate-sensitive fragile sites have been demonstrated on the X chromosome of the Indian mole rat, Nesokia indica (subfamily Murinae), utilizing peripheral blood lymphocyte cultures. All normal female individuals expressed fragile sites on the constitutive heterochromatic long arm of one of their two X chromosomes (heterozygous expression); in contrast, no fragile sites were found on the single X chromosome of normal males. Preferential transmission of the maternal fragile X to the daughters is therefore suggested. Four sites have been detected so far: fra Xq1, fra Xq2, fra Xq3, and fra Xc (centromeric). It is significant that their location corresponds to the regions where constitutive heterochromatic deletions occur that result in a variety of polymorphic X chromosomes in natural populations of Nesokia. Thus there is a correlation between fragile sites, deletion sites, and karyotypic changes. In individuals that did not reproduce in the laboratory, there were more fragile sites on both X chromosomes of the females (homozygous/double heterozygous expression) and also on the X of the males (hemizygous expression). This difference in fragile site expression from the normal situation could be attributed to one or more new mutations. However, the mechanism by which fragile sites influence reproductive performance is unclear.     

Sister chromatid exchanges are preferentially induced at expressed and nonexpressed common fragile sites

Summary To investigate the relationship between common fragile sites and sister chromatid exchange (SCE), lymphocyte cultures were treated with aphidicolin and bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) and analyzed using a sequential GSCE staining protocol. A total of 1163 SCEs were mapped to their corresponding G-band sites, which were assigned to one of the following four categories: fragile sites expressed; fragile sites nonexpressed; nonfragile sites with breaks; or nonfragile sites with no breaks. The designated common fragile sites were found to be preferred locations for SCE formation, not only when these sites were expressed as visible gaps or breaks, but even when they were nonexpressed in the cell. SCEs were also more likely to occur at nonfragile sites with breaks than at nonfragile with no break sites. Further, SCEs were found to be distributed nonrandomly across fragile sites and nonfragile sites, and among the fragile sites, the high frequency SCE sites were highly correlated with the high frequency breakage sites. These data support the hypothesis of common steps in the mechanism of aphidicolin-induced SCE formation and common fragile site expression.     

Common fragile sites as targets for chromosome rearrangements

Common fragile sites are large chromosomal regions that preferentially exhibit gaps or breaks after DNA synthesis is partially perturbed. Fragile site instability in cultured cells is well documented and includes gaps and breaks on metaphase chromosomes, translocation and deletions breakpoints, and sister chromosome exchanges. In recent years, much has been learned about the genomic structure at fragile sites and the cellular mechanisms that monitor their stability. The study of fragile sites has merged with that of cell cycle checkpoints and DNA repair, with multiple proteins from these pathways implicated in fragile site stability, including ATR, BRCA1, CHK1, and RAD51. Since their discovery, fragile sites have been implicated in constitutional and cancer chromosome rearrangements in vivo and recent studies suggest that common fragile sites may serve as markers of chromosome damage caused by replication stress during early tumorigenesis. Here we review the relationship of fragile sites to chromosome rearrangements, particularly in tumor cells, and discuss the mechanisms that may be involved.     

Inhibition of topoisomerase I prevents chromosome breakage at common fragile sites

Common fragile sites are loci that preferentially form gaps and breaks on metaphase chromosomes when DNA synthesis is perturbed, particularly after treatment with the DNA polymerase inhibitor, aphidicolin. We and others have identified several cell cycle checkpoint and DNA repair proteins that influence common fragile site stability. However, the initial events underlying fragile site breakage remain poorly understood. We demonstrate here that aphidicolin-induced gaps and breaks at fragile sites are prevented when cells are co-treated with low concentrations of the topoisomerase I inhibitor, camptothecin. This reduction in breakage is accompanied by a reduction in aphidicolin-induced RPA foci, CHK1 and RPA2 phosphorylation, and PCNA monoubiquitination, indicative of reduced levels of single stranded DNA. Furthermore, camptothecin reduces spontaneous fragile site breakage seen in cells lacking ATR, even in the absence of aphidicolin. These data from cultured human cells demonstrate that topoisomerase I activity is required for DNA common fragile site breaks and suggest that polymerase–helicase uncoupling is a key initial event in this process.     

A common fragile site at Xq27: theoretical and practical implications.

The fragile site at Xq27 (FRAXA) is associated with a common form of X-linked mental retardation (Martin-Bell syndrome). It is induced in culture by conditions of thymidylate stress and is generally considered a rare fragile site found only in association with an X-linked form of mental retardation. Using a somatic cell hybrid system, we previously demonstrated that fragile-X expression can be induced by thymidylate stress in normal X chromosomes at low levels (4%-5%). In the present report, significantly higher levels of fragile-X expression (6%-28%) have been induced in lymphocytes or lymphoblasts of all seven control males using high doses of aphidicolin (1.5 microM). Similar high levels of expression (10%-12%) were observed in both of two normal male chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes). These data demonstrate that Xq27 contains a common fragile site (FRAXD) that is ancestral to the divergence of man and the chimpanzee. Presence of a common and a rare fragile site in the same metaphase chromosome band does not prove that they are identical and may, in fact, represent two unrelated fragile sites. However, the possibility exists that the common fragile site at Xq27 may be the substrate for unequal recombination events that produces the rare fragile site associated with Martin-Bell syndrome. In addition, presence of a common fragile site at Xq27 may explain the occasional observation of low-frequency fragile-X expression in normal control individuals. Caution is therefore warranted in the interpretation of low-level fragile-X expression in diagnostic and prenatal diagnostic settings.