Acclimation to High CO(2) in Monoecious Cucumbers : I. Vegetative and Reproductive Growth

CO₂ concentrations of 1000 compared to 350 microliters per liter in controlled environment chambers did not increase total fruit weight or number in a monoecious cucumber (Cucumis sativus L. cv Chipper) nor did it increase biomass, leaf area, or relative growth rates beyond the first 16 days after seeding. Average fruit weight was slightly, but not significantly greater in the 1000 microliters per liter CO₂ treatment because fruit numbers were changed more than total weight. Plants grown at 1000 and 350 microliters per liter CO₂ were similar in distribution of dry matter and leaf area between mainstem, axillary, and subaxillary branches. Early flower production was greater in 1000 microliters per liter plants. Subsequent flower numbers were either lower in enriched plants or similar in the two treatments, except for the harvest at fruiting when enriched plants produced many more male flowers than the 350 microliters per liter treatments.     

Effects of High Atmospheric CO(2) and Sink Size on Rates of Photosynthesis of a Soybean Cultivar

The effect of sink strength on photosynthetic rates under conditions of long-term exposure to high CO₂ has been investigated in soybean. Soybean plants (Merr. cv. Fiskeby V) were grown in growth chambers containing 350 microliters CO₂ per liter air until pod set. At that time, plants were trimmed to three trifoliolate leaves and either 21 pods (high sink treatment) or 6 pods (low sink treatment). Trimmed plants were either left in 350 microliters CO₂ per liter of air or placed in 1000 microliters CO₂ per liter of air (high CO₂ treatment) until pod maturity. Whole plant net photosynthetic rates of all plants were measured twice weekly, both at 350 microliters CO₂ per liter of air and 1000 microliters CO₂ per liter of air. Plants were also harvested at this time for dry weight measurements. Photosynthetic rates of high sink plants at both measurement CO₂ concentrations were consistently higher than those of low sink plants, and those of plants given the 350 microliter CO₂ per liter of air treatment were higher at both measurement CO₂ concentrations than those of plants given the 1000 microliters CO₂ per liter of air treatment. When plants were measured under treatment CO₂ levels, however, rates were higher in 1,000 microliter plants than 350 microliter CO₂ plants. Dry weights of all plant parts were higher in the 1,000 microliters CO₂ per liter air treatment than in the 350 microliters CO₂ per liter air treatment, and were higher in the low sink than in the high sink treatments.     

Reversibility of Photosynthetic Inhibition in Cotton after Long-Term Exposure to Elevated CO(2) Concentrations

Cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L. cv Stoneville 213) was grown at 350 and 1000 microliters per liter CO₂. The plants grown at elevated CO₂ concentrations contained large starch pools and showed initial symptoms of visible physical damage. Photosynthetic rates were lower than expected based on instantaneous exposure to high CO₂.

A group of plants grown at 1000 microliters per liter CO₂ was switched to 350 microliters per liter CO₂. Starch pools and photosynthetic rates were monitored in the switched plants and in the two unswitched control groups. Photosynthetic rates per unit leaf area recovered to the level of the 350 microliters per liter CO₂ grown control group within four to five days. To assess only nonstomatal limitations to photosynthesis, a measure of photosynthetic efficiencies was calculated (moles CO₂ fixed per square meter per second per mole intercellular CO₂). Photosynthetic efficiency also recovered to the levels of the 350 microliters per liter CO₂ grown controls within three to four days.

Recovery was correlated to a rapid depletion of the starch pool, indicating that the inhibition of photosynthesis is primarily a result of feedback inhibition. However, complete recovery may involve the repair of damage to the chloroplasts caused by excessive starch accumulation. The rapid and complete reversal of photosynthetic inhibition suggests that the appearance of large, strong sinks at certain developmental stages could result in reduction of the large starch accumulations and that photosynthetic rates could recover to near the theoretical capacity during periods of high photosynthate demand.

     

Short-Term and Long-Term Responses of Crassulacean Acid Metabolism Plants to Elevated CO(2)

For the leaf succulent Agave deserti and the stem succulent Ferocactus acanthodes, increasing the ambient CO₂ level from 350 microliters per liter to 650 microliters per liter immediately increased daytime net CO₂ uptake about 30% while leaving nighttime net CO₂ uptake of these Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plants approximately unchanged. A similar enhancement of about 30% was found in dry weight gain over 1 year when the plants were grown at 650 microliters CO₂ per liter compared with 350 microliters per liter. Based on these results plus those at 500 microliters per liter, net CO₂ uptake over 24-hour periods and dry weight productivity of these two CAM succulents is predicted to increase an average of about 1% for each 10 microliters per liter rise in ambient CO₂ level up to 650 microliters per liter.     

Prechilling of Xanthium strumarium L. Reduces Net Photosynthesis and, Independently, Stomatal Conductance, While Sensitizing the Stomata to CO(2)

Greenhouse-grown plants of Xanthium strumarium L. were exposed in a growth cabinet to 10 C during days and 5 C during nights for periods of up to 120 hours. Subsequently, CO₂ exchange, transpiration, and leaf temperature were measured on attached leaves and in leaf sections at 25 or 30 C, 19 C dew point of the air, 61 milliwatts per square centimeter irradiance, and CO₂ concentrations between 0 and 1000 microliters per liter ambient air. Net photosynthesis and stomatal conductance decreased and dark respiration increased with increasing duration of prechilling. The reduction in net photosynthesis was not a consequence of decreased stomatal conductance because the intercellular CO₂ concentration in prechilled leaves was equal to or greater than that in greenhouse-grown controls. The intercellular CO₂ concentration at which one-half maximum net photosynthesis occurred remained the same in prechilled leaves and controls (175 to 190 microliters per liter). Stomata of the control plants responded to changes in the CO₂ concentration of the air only slightly. Prechilling for 24 hours or more sensitized stomata to CO₂; they responded to changes in CO₂ concentration in the range from 100 to 1000 microliters per liter.     

Growth Response of a Succulent Plant, Agave vilmoriniana, to Elevated CO(2)

Large (about 200 grams dry weight) and small (about 5 grams dry weight) specimens of the leaf succulent Agave vilmoriniana Berger were grown outdoors at Phoenix, Arizona. Potted plants were maintained in open-top chambers constructed with clear, plastic wall material. Four CO₂ concentrations of 350, 560, 675, and 885 microliters per liter were used during two growth periods and two water treatments. Small and large plants were grown for 6 months, while a few large plants were grown for 1 year. Wet-treatment plants received water twice weekly, whereas dry-treatment plants received slightly more water than they would under natural conditions. Plant growth rates in all treatments were significantly different between small and large specimens, but not between 6 month and 1 year large plants. Only the dry-treatment plants exhibited statistically different growth rates between the CO₂ treatments. This productivity response was equivalent to a 28% and 3-fold increase when mathematically interpolated between CO₂ concentrations of 300 and 600 microliters per liter for large and small plants, respectively.     

Effects of CO(2) Concentration on Rubisco Activity, Amount, and Photosynthesis in Soybean Leaves

Growth at an elevated CO₂ concentration resulted in an enhanced capacity for soybean (Glycine max L. Merr. cv Bragg) leaflet photosynthesis. Plants were grown from seed in outdoor controlled-environment chambers under natural solar irradiance. Photosynthetic rates, measured during the seed filling stage, were up to 150% greater with leaflets grown at 660 compared to 330 microliters of CO₂ per liter when measured across a range of intercellular CO₂ concentrations and irradiance. Soybean plants grown at elevated CO₂ concentrations had heavier pod weights per plant, 44% heavier with 660 compared to 330 microliters of CO₂ per liter grown plants, and also greater specific leaf weights. Ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (rubisco) activity showed no response (mean activity of 96 micromoles of CO₂ per square meter per second expressed on a leaflet area basis) to short-term (~1 hour) exposures to a range of CO₂ concentrations (110-880 microliters per liter), nor was a response of activity (mean activity of 1.01 micromoles of CO₂ per minute per milligram of protein) to growth CO₂ concentration (160-990 microliters per liter) observed. The amount of rubisco protein was constant, as growth CO₂ concentration was varied, and averaged 55% of the total leaflet soluble protein. Although CO₂ is required for activation of rubisco, results indicated that within the range of CO₂ concentrations used (110-990 microliters per liter), rubisco activity in soybean leaflets, in the light, was not regulated by CO₂.     

Effects of Water Stress on Photosynthesis and Carbon Partitioning in Soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr.) Plants Grown in the Field at Different CO(2) Levels

The effects of water stress and CO₂ enrichment on photosynthesis, assimilate export, and sucrose-P synthase activity were examined in field grown soybean plants. In general, leaves of plants grown in CO₂-enriched atmospheres (300 microliters per liter above unenriched control, which was 349 ± 12 microliters per liter between 0500 and 1900 hours EST over the entire season) had higher carbon exchange rates (CER) compared to plants grown at ambient CO₂, but similar rates of export and similar activities of sucrose-P synthase. On most sample dates, essentially all of the extra carbon fixed as a result of CO₂ enrichment was partitioned into starch. CO₂-enriched plants had lower transpiration rates and therefore had a higher water use efficiency (milligrams CO₂ fixed per gram H₂O transpired) per unit leaf area compared to nonenriched plants. Water stress reduced CER in nonenriched plants to a greater extent than in CO₂-enriched plants. As CER declined, stomatal resistance increased, but this was not the primary cause of the decrease in assimilation because internal CO₂ concentration remained relatively constant. Export of assimilates was less affected by water stress than was CER. When CERs were low as a result of the imposed stress, export was supported by mobilization of reserves (mainly starch). Export rate and leaf sucrose concentration were related in a curvilinear manner. When sucrose concentration was above about 12 milligrams per square decimeter, obtained with nonstressed plants at high CO₂, there was no significant increase in export rate. Assimilate export rate was also correlated positively with SPS activity and the quantitative relationship varied with CER. Thus, export rate was a function of both CER and carbon partitioning.     

Carbon and nitrogen limitations on soybean seedling development

Carbon and nitrogen limitations on symbiotically grown soybean seedlings (Glycine max [L.] Merr.) were assessed by providing 0.0, 1.0, or 8.0 millimolar NH₄NO₃ and 320 or 1,000 microliters CO₂/liter for 22 days after planting. Maximum development of the Rhizobium-soybean symbiosis, as determined by acetylene reduction, was measured in the presence of 1.0 millimolar NH₄NO₃ under both levels of CO₂. Raising NH₄NO₃ from 0.0 to 8.0 millimolar under 320 microliters CO₂/liter increased plant dry weight by 251% and Kjeldahl N content by 287% at 22 days after planting. Increasing NH₄NO₃ from 1.0 to 8.0 millimolar under 320 microliters CO₂/liter increased total dry weight and Kjeldahl N by 100 and 168%, respectively, on day 22. Raising CO₂ from 320 to 1,000 microliters CO₂/liter during the same period had no significant effect on Kjeldahl N content of plants grown with 0.0 or 1.0 millimolar NH₄NO₃. The maximum CO₂ treatment effects were observed in plants supplied with 8.0 millimolar NH₄NO₃, where dry weight and Kjeldahl N content were increased 64% and 20%, respectively. An increase in shoot CO₂-exchange rate associated with the CO₂-enrichment treatment was reflected in a significant increase in leaf dry weight and starch content for plants grown with 1,000 microliters CO₂/liter under all combined N treatments. These data show directly that seedling growth in symbiotically grown soybeans was limited primarily by N availability. The failure of the CO₂-enrichment treatment to increase total plant N significantly in Rhizobium-dependent plants indicates that root nodule development and functioning in such plants was not limited by photosynthate production.     

Acclimation of Two Tomato Species to High Atmospheric CO(2): I. Sugar and Starch Concentrations

Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv Vedettos and Lycopersicon chmielewskii Rick, LA 1028, were exposed to two CO₂ concentrations (330 or 900 microliters per liter) for 10 weeks. Tomato plants grown at 900 microliters per liter contained more starch and more sugars than the control. However, we found no significant accumulation of starch and sugars in the young leaves of L. esculentum exposed to high CO₂. Carbon exchange rates were significantly higher in CO₂-enriched plants for the first few weeks of treatment but thereafter decreased as tomato plants acclimated to high atmospheric CO₂. This indicates that the long-term decline of photosynthetic efficiency of leaf 5 cannot be attributed to an accumulation of sugar and/or starch. The average concentration of starch in leaves 5 and 9 was always higher in L. esculentum than in L. chmielewskii (151.7% higher). A higher proportion of photosynthates was directed into starch for L. esculentum than for L. chmielewskii. However, these characteristics did not improve the long-term photosynthetic efficiency of L. chmielewskii grown at high CO₂ when compared with L. esculentum. The chloroplasts of tomato plants exposed to the higher CO₂ concentration exhibited a marked accumulation of starch. The results reported here suggest that starch and/or sugar accumulation under high CO₂ cannot entirely explain the loss of photosynthetic efficiency of high CO₂-grown plants.     

Acclimation of Two Tomato Species to High Atmospheric CO(2): II. Ribulose-1,5-Bisphosphate Carboxylase/Oxygenase and Phosphoenolpyruvate Carboxylase

Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. cv Vedettos and Lycopersicon chmielewskii Rick, LA 1028, were exposed to two CO₂ concentrations (330 or 900 microliters per liter) for 10 weeks. The elevated CO₂ concentrations increased the initial ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) activity of both species for the first 5 weeks of treatment but the difference did not persist during the last 5 weeks. The activity of Mg²⁺-CO₂-activated Rubisco was higher in 900 microliters per liter for the first 2 weeks but declined sharply thereafter. After 10 weeks, leaves grown at 330 microliters per liter CO₂ had about twice the Rubisco activity compared with those grown at 900 microliters per liter CO₂. The two species showed the same trend to Rubisco declines under high CO₂ concentrations. The percent activation of Rubisco was always higher under high CO₂. The phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPCase) activity measured in tomato leaves averaged 7.9% of the total Rubisco. PEPCase showed a similar trend with time as the initial Rubisco but with no significant difference between nonenriched and CO₂-enriched plants. Long-term exposure of tomato plants to high CO₂ was previously shown to induce a decline of photosynthetic efficiency. Based on the current study and on previous results, we propose that the decline of activated Rubisco is the main cause of the acclimation of tomato plants to high CO₂ concentrations.     

Effects of Atmospheric CO(2) Enrichment on Photosynthesis, Respiration, and Growth of Sour Orange Trees

Numerous net photosynthetic and dark respiratory measurements were made over a period of 4 years on leaves of 24 sour orange (Citrus aurantium) trees; 8 of them growing in ambient air at a mean CO₂ concentration of 400 microliters per liter, and 16 growing in air enriched with CO₂ to concentrations approaching 1000 microliters per liter. Over this CO₂ concentration range, net photosynthesis increased linearly with CO₂ by more than 200%, whereas dark respiration decreased linearly to only 20% of its initial value. These results, together with those of a comprehensive fine-root biomass determination and two independent aboveground trunk and branch volume inventories, suggest that a doubling of the air's current mean CO₂ concentration of 360 microliters per liter would enhance the growth of the trees by a factor of 3.8.     

CO(2)-Enhanced Yield and Foliar Deformation among Tomato Genotypes in Elevated CO(2) Environments

Yield increases observed among eight genotypes of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) grown at ambient CO₂ (about 350) or 1000 microliters per liter CO₂ were not due to carbon exchange rate increases. Yield varied among genotypes while carbon exchange rate did not. Yield increases were due to a change in partitioning from root to fruit. Tomatoes grown with CO₂ enrichment exhibited nonepinastic foliar deformation similar to nutrient deficiency symptoms. Foliar deformation varied among genotypes, increased throughout the season, and became most severe at elevated CO₂. Foliar deformation was positively related to fruit yield. Foliage from the lower canopy was sampled throughout the growing season and analysed for starch, K, P, Ca, Mg, Fe, and Mn concentrations. Foliar K and Mn concentrations were the only elements correlated with deformation severity. Foliar K decreased while deformation increased. In another study, foliage of half the plants of one genotype received foliar applications of 7 millimolar KH₂PO₄. Untreated foliage showed significantly greater deformation than treated foliage. Reduced foliar K concentration may cause CO₂-enhanced foliar deformation. Reduced K may occur following decreased nutrient uptake resulting from reduced root mass due to the change in partitioning from root to fruit.     

Minor Physiological Response to Elevated CO(2) by the CAM Plant Agave vilmoriniana

One-year-old plants of the CAM leaf succulent Agave vilmoriniana Berger were grown outdoors at Riverside, California. Potted plants were acclimated to CO₂-enrichment (about 750 microliters per liter) by growth for 2 weeks in an open-top polyethylene chamber. Control plants were grown nearby where the ambient CO₂ concentration was about 370 microliters per liter. When the plants were well watered, CO₂-induced differences in stomatal conductances and CO₂ assimilation rates over the entire 24-hour period were not large. There was a large nocturnal acidification in both CO₂ treatments and insignificant differences in leaf chlorophyll content. Well watered plants maintained water potentials of −0.3 to −0.4 megapascals. When other plants were allowed to dry to water potentials of −1.2 to −1.7 megapascals, stomatal conductances and CO₂ uptake rates were reduced in magnitude, with the biggest difference in Phase IV photosynthesis. The minor nocturnal response to CO₂ by this species is interpreted to indicate saturated, or nearly saturated, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase activity at current atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. CO₂-enhanced diurnal activity of ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase activity remains a possibility.     

Short-Term Effects of CO(2) on Gas Exchange of Leaves of Bigtooth Aspen (Populus grandidentata) in the Field

The short term effects of increased levels of CO₂ on gas exchange of leaves of bigtooth aspen (Populus grandidentata Michx.) were studied at the University of Michigan Biological Station, Pellston, MI. Leaf gas exchange was measured in situ in the upper half of the canopy, 12 to 14 meters above ground. In 1900 microliters per liter CO₂, maximum CO₂ exchange rate (CER) in saturating light was increased by 151% relative to CER in 320 microliters per liter CO₂. The temperature optimum for CER shifted from 25°C in 320 microliters per liter CO₂ to 37°C in 1900 microliters per liter CO₂. In saturating light, increasing CO₂ level over the range 60 to 1900 microliters per liter increased CER, decreased stomatal conductance, and increased leaf water use efficiency. The initial slope of the CO₂ response curve of CER was not significantly different at 20 and 30°C leaf temperatures, although the slope did decline significantly during leaf senescence. In 1900 microliters per liter CO₂, CER increased with increasing light. The light saturation point and maximum CER were higher in 30°C than in 20°C, although there was little effect of temperature in low light. The experimental results are consistent with patterns seen in laboratory studies of other C₃ species and define the parameters required by some models of aspen CER in the field.     

Response of Two Wheat Cultivars to CO(2) Enrichment under Subambient Oxygen Conditions

Two cultivars of wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cvs Sonoita and Yecora Rojo) were grown to maturity in a growth chamber within four sub-chambers under two CO₂ levels (350 or 1000 microliters per liter) at either ambient (21%) or low O₂ (5%). Growth analysis was used to characterize changes in plant carbon budgets imposed by the gas regimes. Large increases in leaf areas were seen in the low O₂ treatments, due primarily to a stimulation of tillering. Roots developed normally at 5% O₂. Seed development was inhibited by the subambient O₂ treatment, but this effect was overcome by CO₂ enrichment at 1000 microliters per liter. Dry matter accumulation and seed number responded differently to the gas treatments. The greatest dry matter production occurred in the low O₂, high CO₂ treatment, while the greatest seed production occurred in the ambient O₂, high CO₂ treatment. Growth and assimilation were stimulated more by either CO₂ enrichment or low O₂ in cv Yecora Rojo than in Sonoita. These experiments are the first to explore the effect of whole plant low O₂ treatments on growth and reproduction. The finding that CO₂ enrichment overcomes low O₂-induced sterility may help elucidate the nature of this effect.     

Photosynthetic Rates of Sporophytes and Gametophytes of the Fern, Todea barbara

The photosynthetic rates of intact sporophytes or gametophytes of the fern Todea barbara grown in sterile culture were measured using an infrared gas analyzer. Sporophytes consisted of single whole plants with roots and leaves grown in tubes of agar. Gametophytes were grown as several plants covering the surface of the agar. Sporophytes had photosynthetic rates at light saturation of 8.50 microliters CO₂ per hour per milligram dry weight and 1,300 microliters CO₂ per hour per milligram chlorophyll, whereas rates for gametophytes were lower, 2.36 microliters CO₂ per hour per milligram dry weight and 236 microliters CO₂ per hour per milligram chlorophyll.     

Changes in Levels of Intermediates of the C(4) Cycle and Reductive Pentose Phosphate Pathway under Various Light Intensities in Maize Leaves

The rate of CO₂ assimilation and levels of metabolites of the C₄ cycle and reductive pentose phosphate pathway in attached leaves of maize (Zea mays L.) were measured over a range of light intensity from 0 to 1,900 microEinsteins per square meter per second under a saturated CO₂ concentration of 350 microliters per liter and a limiting CO₂ concentration of 133 microliters per liter. The level of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate (RuBP) stayed almost constant (around 60 nanomoles per milligram chlorophyll [Chl]) from low to high light intensities under 350 microliters per liter. Levels of 3-phosphoglycerate (PGA) increased from 100 to 650 nanomoles per milligram Chl under 350 microliters per liter CO₂ with increasing light intensity. The calculated RuBP concentration of 6 millimolar (corresponded to 60 nanomoles per milligram Chl) was about two times above the estimated RuBP binding-site concentration on ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase (Rubisco) of ~2.6 millimolar in maize bundle sheath chloroplasts in the light. The ratio of RuBP/PGA increased with decreasing light intensity under 350 microliters per liter CO₂. These results suggest that RuBP carboxylation is under control of light intensity possibly due to a limited supply of CO₂ to Rubisco through the C₄ cycle whose activity is highly dependent on light intensity. Pyruvate level increased with increasing light intensity as long as photosynthesis rate increased. A positive relationship between levels of PGA and those of pyruvate during steady-state photosynthesis under various conditions suggests that an elevated concentration of PGA increases the carbon input into the C₄ cycle through the conversion of PGA to PEP and consequently the level of total intermediates of the C₄ cycle can be raised to mediate higher photosynthesis rate.     

Effects of CO(2) Enrichment and Carbohydrate Content on the Dark Respiration of Soybeans

During the period of most active leaf expansion, the foliar dark respiration rate of soybeans (Glycine max cv Williams), grown for 2 weeks in 1000 microliters CO₂ per liter air, was 1.45 milligrams CO₂ evolved per hour leaf density thickness, and this was twice the rate displayed by leaves of control plants (350 microliters CO₂ per liter air). There was a higher foliar nonstructural carbohydrate level (e.g. sucrose and starch) in the CO₂ enriched compared with CO₂ normal plants. For example, leaves of enriched plants displayed levels of nonstructural carbohydrate equivalent to 174 milligrams glucose per gram dry weight compared to the 84 milligrams glucose per gram dry weight found in control plant leaves. As the leaves of CO₂ enriched plants approached full expansion, both the foliar respiration rate and carbohydrate content of the CO₂ enriched leaves decreased until they were equivalent with those same parameters in the leaves of control plants. A strong positive correlation between respiration rate and carbohydrate content was seen in high CO₂ adapted plants, but not in the control plants.

Mitochondria, isolated simultaneously from the leaves of CO₂ enriched and control plants, showed no difference in NADH or malate-glutamate dependent O₂ uptake, and there were no observed differences in the specific activities of NAD⁺ linked isocitrate dehydrogenase and cytochrome c oxidase. Since the mitochondrial O₂ uptake and total enzyme activities were not greater in young enriched leaves, the increase in leaf respiration rate was not caused by metabolic adaptations in the leaf mitochondria as a response to long term CO₂ enrichment. It was concluded, that the higher respiration rate in the enriched plant's foliage was attributable, in part, to a higher carbohydrate status.

     

Increases in Phosphorus Requirements for CO(2)-Enriched Pine Species

Pinus radiata D. Don (half-sib families 20010 and 20062) and Pinus caribaea var hondurensis (an open-pollinated family) were grown for 49 weeks at seven levels of phosphorus and at CO₂ concentrations of either 340 or 660 microliters per liter, to establish if the phosphorus requirements differed between the CO₂ concentrations and if mycorrhizal associations were affected. When soil phosphorus availability was low, phosphorus uptake was increased by elevated CO₂. This may have been related to changes in mycorrhizal competition. When the phosphorus concentration in the youngest fully expanded needles was above 600 milligrams per kilogram the shoot weight of all pine families was greater at high CO₂ due to increases in rates of photosynthesis. More dry weight was partitioned to the stems of P. radiata family 20010 and P. caribaea. At foliar phosphorus concentrations above 1000 milligrams per kilogram (P. radiata) and 700 milligrams per kilogram (P. caribaea), growth did not increase at 340 microliters of CO₂ per liter. Soluble sugar levels in the same needles mirrored the growth response, but the starch concentration declined with increasing phosphorus. At 660 microliters of CO₂ per liter, shoot weight and soluble sugar concentrations were still increasing up to a foliar P concentration of 1800 milligrams per kilogram for P. radiata and 1600 milligrams per kilogram for P. caribaea. The starch concentrations did not decline. These results indicate that higher foliar phosphorus concentrations are required to realize the maximum growth potential of pines at elevated CO₂.