Evidence of compositional differences between the extracellular and intracellular DNA of a granular sludge biofilm

Aims: Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) are an important component of microbial biofilms, and it is becoming increasingly apparent that extracellular DNA (eDNA) has a functional role in EPS. This study characterizes the eDNA extracted from the novel activated sludge biofilm process of aerobic granules. Methods and Results: Exposing the sludge to cation exchange resin (CER) was used for the extraction of eDNA and intracellular DNA (iDNA) from aerobic granules. This was optimized for eDNA yield while causing minimal cell lysis. We then compared the DNA composition of these extractions using randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) fingerprinting and PCR‐based denaturing gradient‐gel electrophoresis (DGGE). Upon the analysis of the genomic DNA and the 16S rRNA genes, differences were detected between the sludge biofilm eDNA and iDNA. Conclusions: Different bacteria within the biofilm disproportionally release DNA into the EPS matrix of the biofilm. Significance and Impact of the Study: The findings further the idea that eDNA has a functional role in the biofilm state, which is an important conceptual information for industrial application of biofilms.     

A dual role of extracellular DNA during biofilm formation of Neisseria meningitidis

Major pathogenic clonal complexes (cc) of Neisseria meningitidis differ substantially in their point prevalence among healthy carriers. We show that frequently carried pathogenic cc (e.g. sequence type ST‐41/44 cc and ST‐32 cc) depend on extracellular DNA (eDNA) to initiate in vitro biofilm formation, whereas biofilm formation of cc with low point prevalence (ST‐8 cc and ST‐11 cc) was eDNA‐independent. For initial biofilm formation, a ST‐32 cc type strain, but not a ST‐11 type strain, utilized eDNA. The release of eDNA was mediated by lytic transglycosylase and cytoplasmic N‐acetylmuramyl‐l ‐alanine amidase genes. In late biofilms, outer membrane phospholipase A‐dependent autolysis, which was observed in most cc, but not in ST‐8 and ST‐11 strains, was required for shear force resistance of microcolonies. Taken together, N. meningitidis evolved two different biofilm formation strategies, an eDNA‐dependent one yielding shear force resistant microcolonies, and an eDNA‐independent one. Based on the experimental findings and previous epidemiological observations, we hypothesize that most meningococcal cc display a settler phenotype, which is eDNA‐dependent and results in a stable interaction with the host. On the contrary, spreaders (ST‐11 and ST‐8 cc) are unable to use eDNA for biofilm formation and might compensate for poor colonization properties by high transmission rates.     

Mycobacterium avium Possesses Extracellular DNA that Contributes to Biofilm Formation,Structural Integrity,and Tolerance to Antibiotics

Mycobacterium avium subsp. hominissuis is an opportunistic pathogen that is associated with biofilm-related infections of the respiratory tract and is difficult to treat. In recent years, extracellular DNA (eDNA) has been found to be a major component of bacterial biofilms, including many pathogens involved in biofilm-associated infections. To date, eDNA has not been described as a component of mycobacterial biofilms. In this study, we identified and characterized eDNA in a high biofilm-producing strain of Mycobacterium avium subsp. hominissuis (MAH). In addition, we surveyed for presence of eDNA in various MAH strains and other nontuberculous mycobacteria. Biofilms of MAH A5 (high biofilm-producing strain) and MAH 104 (reference strain) were established at 22°C and 37°C on abiotic surfaces. Acellular biofilm matrix and supernatant from MAH A5 7 day-old biofilms both possess abundant eDNA, however very little eDNA was found in MAH 104 biofilms. A survey of MAH clinical isolates and other clinically relevant nontuberculous mycobacterial species revealed many species and strains that also produce eDNA. RAPD analysis demonstrated that eDNA resembles genomic DNA. Treatment with DNase I reduced the biomass of MAH A5 biofilms when added upon biofilm formation or to an already established biofilm both on abiotic surfaces and on top of human pharyngeal epithelial cells. Furthermore, co-treatment of an established biofilm with DNase 1 and either moxifloxacin or clarithromycin significantly increased the susceptibility of the bacteria within the biofilm to these clinically used antimicrobials. Collectively, our results describe an additional matrix component of mycobacterial biofilms and a potential new target to help treat biofilm-associated nontuberculous mycobacterial infections.     

Adsorptive immobilization of a Pseudomonas strain on solid carriers for augmented decolourization in a chemostat bioreactor

Pseudomonas GM3, a highly efficient strain in cleavage of azo bonds of synthetic dyes under anoxic conditions, was immobilized via adsorption on two types of carriers, porous glass beads and solid PVA particles. The cells were cultivated in a nutrient medium, adsorbed on sterile carriers, stabilized as biofilms in repeated batch cultures, and introduced into a chemostat activated sludge reactor for augmented decolourization. The microbial cells were quickly adsorbed and fixed on the PVA surface, compared to a slow and linear immobilization on the glass surface. The porous structure of glass beads provided shelter for the embedded cells, giving a high biomass loading or thick biofilm (13.3 mg VS ml-1 carrier) in comparison with PVA particles (4.8 mg VS ml-1 carrier), but the mass transfer of substrate in the biofilm became a significant limiting factorin the thicker biofilms (effectiveness factor eta = 0.31). The microbial decolourization rate per volume of carriers was 0.15 and 0.17 mg dye ml-1 of glass beads and PVA particles, respectively. In augmented decomposition of a recalcitrant azo dye (60 mg l-1), the immobilized Pseudomonas cells in porous glass beads gave a stable decolourization efficiency (80-81%), but cells fixed on solid PVA particles showed an initial high colour removal of 90% which then declined to a stable removal efficiency of 81%. In both cases, the colour removal efficiency of the chemostat bioreactor was increased from < 10% by an activated sludge to approximately 80% by the augmented system.     

Biofilm characteristics and evaluation of the sanitation procedures of thermophilic Aeribacillus pallidus E334 biofilms

The ability of Aeribacillus pallidus E334 to produce pellicle and form a biofilm was studied. Optimal biofilm formation occurred at 60 °C, pH 7.5 and 1.5% NaCl. Extra polymeric substances (EPS) were composed of proteins and eDNA (21.4 kb). E334 formed biofilm on many surfaces, but mostly preferred polypropylene and glass. Using CLSM analysis, the network-like structure of the EPS was observed. The A. pallidus biofilm had a novel eDNA content. DNaseI susceptibility (86.8% removal) of eDNA revealed its importance in mature biofilms, but the purified eDNA was resistant to DNaseI, probably due to its extended folding outside the matrix. Among 15 cleaning agents, biofilms could be removed with alkaline protease and sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS). The removal of cells from polypropylene and biomass on glass was achieved with combined SDS/alkaline protease treatment. Strong A. pallidus biofilms could cause risks for industrial processes and abiotic surfaces must be taken into consideration in terms of sanitation procedures.     

Development and dynamics of Pseudomonas sp. biofilms

Pseudomonas sp. strain B13 and Pseudomonas putida OUS82 were genetically tagged with the green fluorescent protein and the Discosoma sp. red fluorescent protein, and the development and dynamics occurring in flow chamber-grown two-colored monospecies or mixed-species biofilms were investigated by the use of confocal scanning laser microscopy. Separate red or green fluorescent microcolonies were formed initially, suggesting that the initial small microcolonies were formed simply by growth of substratum attached cells and not by cell aggregation. Red fluorescent microcolonies containing a few green fluorescent cells and green fluorescent microcolonies containing a few red fluorescent cells were frequently observed in both monospecies and two-species biofilms, suggesting that the bacteria moved between the microcolonies. Rapid movement of P. putida OUS82 bacteria inside microcolonies was observed before a transition from compact microcolonies to loose irregularly shaped protruding structures occurred. Experiments involving a nonflagellated P. putida OUS82 mutant suggested that the movements between and inside microcolonies were flagellum driven. The results are discussed in relation to the prevailing hypothesis that biofilm bacteria are in a physiological state different from planktonic bacteria.     

Spore Formation and Toxin Production in Clostridium difficile Biofilms

The ability to grow as a biofilm can facilitate survival of bacteria in the environment and promote infection. To better characterize biofilm formation in the pathogen Clostridium difficile, we established a colony biofilm culture method for this organism on a polycarbonate filter, and analyzed the matrix and the cells in biofilms from a variety of clinical isolates over several days of biofilm culture. We found that biofilms readily formed in all strains analyzed, and that spores were abundant within about 6 days. We also found that extracellular DNA (eDNA), polysaccharide and protein was readily detected in the matrix of all strains, including the major toxins A and/or B, in toxigenic strains. All the strains we analyzed formed spores. Apart from strains 630 and VPI10463, which sporulated in the biofilm at relatively low frequencies, the frequencies of biofilm sporulation varied between 46 and 65%, suggesting that variations in sporulation levels among strains is unlikely to be a major factor in variation in the severity of disease. Spores in biofilms also had reduced germination efficiency compared to spores obtained by a conventional sporulation protocol. Transmission electron microscopy revealed that in 3 day-old biofilms, the outermost structure of the spore is a lightly staining coat. However, after 6 days, material that resembles cell debris in the matrix surrounds the spore, and darkly staining granules are closely associated with the spores surface. In 14 day-old biofilms, relatively few spores are surrounded by the apparent cell debris, and the surface-associated granules are present at higher density at the coat surface. Finally, we showed that biofilm cells possess 100-fold greater resistance to the antibiotic metronidazole then do cells cultured in liquid media. Taken together, our data suggest that C. difficile cells and spores in biofilms have specialized properties that may facilitate infection.     

Extracellular DNA in single- and multiple-species unsaturated biofilms

The extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) of bacterial biofilms form a hydrated barrier between cells and their external environment. Better characterization of EPS could be useful in understanding biofilm physiology. The EPS are chemically complex, changing with both bacterial strain and culture conditions. Previously, we reported that Pseudomonas aeruginosa unsaturated biofilm EPS contains large amounts of extracellular DNA (eDNA) (R. E. Steinberger, A. R. Allen, H. G. Hansma, and P. A. Holden, Microb. Ecol. 43:416-423, 2002). Here, we investigated the compositional similarity of eDNA to cellular DNA, the relative quantity of eDNA, and the terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (TRFLP) community profile of eDNA in multiple-species biofilms. By randomly amplified polymorphic DNA analysis, cellular DNA and eDNA appear identical for P. aeruginosa biofilms. Significantly more eDNA was produced in P. aeruginosa and Pseudomonas putida biofilms than in Rhodococcus erythropolis or Variovorax paradoxus biofilms. While the amount of eDNA in dual-species biofilms was of the same order of magnitude as that of of single-species biofilms, the amounts were not predictable from single-strain measurements. By the Shannon diversity index and principle components analysis of TRFLP profiles generated from 16S rRNA genes, eDNA of four-species biofilms differed significantly from either cellular or total DNA of the same biofilm. However, total DNA- and cellular DNA-based TRFLP analyses of this biofilm community yielded identical results. We conclude that extracellular DNA production in unsaturated biofilms is species dependent and that the phylogenetic information contained in this DNA pool is quantifiable and distinct from either total or cellular DNA.     

Cell death in Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm development

Bacteria growing in biofilms often develop multicellular, three-dimensional structures known as microcolonies. Complex differentiation within biofilms of Pseudomonas aeruginosa occurs, leading to the creation of voids inside microcolonies and to the dispersal of cells from within these voids. However, key developmental processes regulating these events are poorly understood. A normal component of multicellular development is cell death. Here we report that a repeatable pattern of cell death and lysis occurs in biofilms of P. aeruginosa during the normal course of development. Cell death occurred with temporal and spatial organization within biofilms, inside microcolonies, when the biofilms were allowed to develop in continuous-culture flow cells. A subpopulation of viable cells was always observed in these regions. During the onset of biofilm killing and during biofilm development thereafter, a bacteriophage capable of superinfecting and lysing the P. aeruginosa parent strain was detected in the fluid effluent from the biofilm. The bacteriophage implicated in biofilm killing was closely related to the filamentous phage Pf1 and existed as a prophage within the genome of P. aeruginosa. We propose that prophage-mediated cell death is an important mechanism of differentiation inside microcolonies that facilitates dispersal of a subpopulation of surviving cells.     

Analysis of size distribution and areal cell density of ammonia-oxidizing bacterial microcolonies in relation to substrate microprofiles in biofilms

A fine-scale in situ spatial organization of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) in biofilms was investigated by combining molecular techniques (i.e., fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and 16S rDNA-cloning analysis) and microelectrode measurements. Important parameters of AOB microcolonies such as size distribution and areal cell density of the microcolonies were determined and correlated with substrate microprofiles in the biofilms. In situ hybridization with a nested 16S rRNA-targeted oligonucleotide probe set revealed two different populations of AOB, Nitrosomonas europaea-lineage and Nitrosospira multiformis-lineage, coexisting in an autotrophic nitrifying biofilm. Nitrosospira formed looser microcolonies, with an areal cell density of 0.51 cells microm(-2), which was half of the cell density of Nitrosomonas (1.12 cells microm(-2)). It is speculated that the formation of looser microcolonies facilitates substrate diffusion into the microcolonies, which might be a survival strategy to low O(2) and NH(4) (+) conditions in the biofilm. A long-term experiment (4-week cultivation at different substrate C/N ratios) revealed that the size distribution of AOB microcolonies was strongly affected by better substrate supply due to shorter distance from the surface and the presence of organic carbon. The microcolony size was relatively constant throughout the autotrophic nitrifying biofilm, while the size increased by approximately 80% toward the depth of the biofilm cultured at the substrate C/N = 1. A short-term ( approximately 3 h) organic carbon addition experiment showed that the addition of organic carbon created interspecies competition for O(2) between AOB and heterotrophic bacteria, which dramatically decreased the in situ NH(4) (+)-uptake activity of AOB in the surface of the biofilms. This result might explain the spatial distribution of AOB microcolony size in the biofilms cultured at the substrate C/N = 1. These experimental results suggest O(2) and organic carbon were the main factors controlling the spatial organization and activity of AOB in biofilms. These findings are significantly important to further improve mathematical models used to describe how the slow-growing AOB develop their niches in biofilms and how that configuration affects nitrification performance in the biofilm.     

Microcolonies, quorum sensing and cytotoxicity determine the survival of Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms exposed to protozoan grazing

This study was based on the hypothesis that biofilms of the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa are successfully adapted to situations of protozoan grazing. We tested P. aeruginosa wild type and strains that were genetically altered, in structural and regulatory features of biofilm development, in response to the common surface-feeding flagellate Rhynchomonas nasuta. Early biofilms of the wild type showed the formation of grazing resistant microcolonies in the presence of the flagellate, whereas biofilms without the predator were undifferentiated. Grazing on biofilms of quorum sensing mutants (lasR and rhlR/lasR) also resulted in the formation of microcolonies, however, in lower numbers and size compared to the wild type. Considerably fewer microcolonies than the wild type were formed by mutant cells lacking type IV pili, whereas no microcolonies were formed by flagella-deficient cells. The alginate-overproducing strain PDO300 developed larger microcolonies in response to grazing. These observations suggest a role of quorum sensing in early biofilms and involvement of flagella, type IV pili, and alginate in microcolony formation in the presence of grazing. More mature biofilms of the wild type exhibited acute toxicity to the flagellate R. nasuta. Rapid growth of the flagellate on rhlR/lasR mutant biofilms indicated a key role of quorum sensing in the upregulation of lethal factors and in grazing protection of late biofilms. Both the formation of microcolonies and the production of toxins are effective mechanisms that may allow P. aeruginosa biofilms to resist protozoan grazing and to persist in the environment.     

Adsorptive Immobilization of a Pseudomonas Strain on Solid Carriers for Augmented Decolourization in a Chemostat Bioreactor

Pseudomonas GM3, a highly efficient strain in cleavage of azo bonds of synthetic dyes under anoxic conditions, was immobilized via adsorption on two types of carriers, porous glass beads and solid PVA particles. The cells were cultivated in a nutrient medium, adsorbed on sterile carriers, stabilized as biofilms in repeated batch cultures, and introduced into a chemostat activated sludge reactor for augmented decolourization. The microbial cells were quickly adsorbed and fixed on the PVA surface, compared to a slow and linear immobilization on the glass surface. The porous structure of glass beads provided shelter for the embedded cells, giving a high biomass loading or thick biofilm (13.3 mg VS ml^?1 carrier) in comparison with PVA particles (4.8 mg VS ml^?1 carrier), but the mass transfer of substrate in the biofilm became a significant limiting factor in the thicker biofilms (effectiveness factor η = 0.31). The microbial decolourization rate per volume of carriers was 0.15 and 0.17 mg dye ml^?1 of glass beads and PVA particles, respectively. In augmented decomposition of a recalcitrant azo dye (60 mg l^?1), the immobilized Pseudomonas cells in porous glass beads gave a stable decolourization efficiency (80 - 81%), but cells fixed on solid PVA particles showed an initial high colour removal of 90% which then declined to a stable removal efficiency of 81%. In both cases, the colour removal efficiency of the chemostat bioreactor was increased from < 10% by an activated sludge to ～80% by the augmented system.     

Role of phosphorus in activated sludge

Monod's kinetic model was used to correlate the specific growth rate of mixed activated sludge with the limiting substrate of phosphorus for both batch and continuous-flow culture systems. In the batch reactor system, the specific growth rate varied from 0.092 to 0.617 h(-1) and the saturation constant changed from 25.5 to 117.5 when the COD: P ratio was controlled within the range of 10 to 788 and at the temperature 25+/- 0.5 degrees C. An inverse relationship between specific growth rate and cell yield was found. the maximum specific growth rate and the saturation constant obtained from this study were equal to 0.64 h(-1) and 0.378mg/L, respectively. In the completely mixed continuous-flow culture system, it was found that the substrate utilization, biological solids production, and sludge composition were markedly affected by the source of phosphorus available in the wastewater. The phosphorus-limited activated sludge is normally high in carbohydrate content and low in protein content. Also, sludge organisms growth under the severely restricted phosphorus condition usually possess a large capsule. These capsulated carbohydrate-like substances can be converted to cellular protein if the source of phosphorus is added. The values of cell yield in the continuous-flow activated sludge system are predictable by the use of kinetic constants that are generated from batch culture studies.     

Extracellular DNA in Single- and Multiple-Species Unsaturated Biofilms

The extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) of bacterial biofilms form a hydrated barrier between cells and their external environment. Better characterization of EPS could be useful in understanding biofilm physiology. The EPS are chemically complex, changing with both bacterial strain and culture conditions. Previously, we reported that Pseudomonas aeruginosa unsaturated biofilm EPS contains large amounts of extracellular DNA (eDNA) (R. E. Steinberger, A. R. Allen, H. G. Hansma, and P. A. Holden, Microb. Ecol. 43:416-423, 2002). Here, we investigated the compositional similarity of eDNA to cellular DNA, the relative quantity of eDNA, and the terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (TRFLP) community profile of eDNA in multiple-species biofilms. By randomly amplified polymorphic DNA analysis, cellular DNA and eDNA appear identical for P. aeruginosa biofilms. Significantly more eDNA was produced in P. aeruginosa and Pseudomonas putida biofilms than in Rhodococcus erythropolis or Variovorax paradoxus biofilms. While the amount of eDNA in dual-species biofilms was of the same order of magnitude as that of of single-species biofilms, the amounts were not predictable from single-strain measurements. By the Shannon diversity index and principle components analysis of TRFLP profiles generated from 16S rRNA genes, eDNA of four-species biofilms differed significantly from either cellular or total DNA of the same biofilm. However, total DNA- and cellular DNA-based TRFLP analyses of this biofilm community yielded identical results. We conclude that extracellular DNA production in unsaturated biofilms is species dependent and that the phylogenetic information contained in this DNA pool is quantifiable and distinct from either total or cellular DNA.     

Differentiation and distribution of colistin- and sodium dodecyl sulfate-tolerant cells in Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilms

During Pseudomonas aeruginosa flow cell biofilm development, the cell population differentiates into a nonmotile subpopulation which forms microcolonies and a migrating subpopulation which eventually colonizes the top of the microcolonies, resulting in the development of mushroom-shaped multicellular structures. The cap-forming subpopulation was found to develop tolerance to membrane-targeting antimicrobial agents, such as the cyclic cationic peptide colistin and the detergent sodium dodecyl sulfate. The stalk-forming subpopulation, on the other hand, was sensitive to the membrane-targeting antibacterial agents. All biofilm-associated cells were sensitive to the antibacterial agents when tested in standard plate assays. A mutation eliminating the production of type IV pili, and hence surface-associated motility, prevented the formation of regular mushroom-shaped structures in the flow cell biofilms, and the development of tolerance to the antimicrobial agents was found to be affected as well. Mutations in genes interfering with lipopolysaccharide modification (pmr) eliminated the biofilm-associated colistin tolerance phenotype. Experiments with a PAO1 strain harboring a pmr-gfp fusion showed that only the cap-forming subpopulation in biofilms treated with colistin expresses the pmr operon. These results suggest that increased antibiotic tolerance in biofilms may be a consequence of differentiation into distinct subpopulations with different phenotypic properties.     

Electron microscopic examination of the extracellular polymeric substances in anaerobic granular biofilms

Scanning electron microscopy revealed that collapsed extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) surrounded bacteria present in granular sludge. Treatment of granular sludge with whole-cell antiserum and staining with polycationic ferritin demonstrated that bacteria were enveloped by extensive EPS. Antibody stabilization permitted a visualization of the EPS which more closely resembled its natural hydrated state. The EPS was seen to completely fill the intercellular spaces in the microcolonies. Both pure and mixed microcolonies were observed to be enclosed by EPS. The presence of these large amounts of EPS indicates that this extracellular layer is important in maintaining the structural integrity of granular sludge.     

Detection of anaerobic processes and microorganisms in immobilized activated sludge of a wastewater treatment plant with intense aeration

Attached activated sludge from the Krasnaya Polyana (Sochi) wastewater treatment plant was studied after the reconstruction by increased aeration and water recycle, as well as by the installation of a bristle carrier for activated sludge immobilization. The activated sludge biofilms developing under conditions of intense aeration were shown to contain both aerobic and anaerobic microorganisms. Activity of a strictly anaerobic methanogenic community was revealed, which degraded organic compounds to methane, further oxidized by aerobic methanotrophs. Volatile fatty acids, the intermediates of anaerobic degradation of complex organic compounds, were used by both aerobic and anaerobic microorganisms. Anaerobic oxidation of ammonium with nitrite (anammox) and the presence of obligate anammox bacteria were revealed in attached activated sludge biofilms. Simultaneous aerobic and anaerobic degradation of organic contaminants by attached activated sludge provides for high rates of water treatment, stability of the activated sludge under variable environmental conditions, and decreased excess sludge formation.     

DNA Builds and Strengthens the Extracellular Matrix in Myxococcus xanthus Biofilms by Interacting with Exopolysaccharides

One intriguing discovery in modern microbiology is the extensive presence of extracellular DNA (eDNA) within biofilms of various bacterial species. Although several biological functions have been suggested for eDNA, including involvement in biofilm formation, the detailed mechanism of eDNA integration into biofilm architecture is still poorly understood. In the biofilms formed by Myxococcus xanthus, a Gram-negative soil bacterium with complex morphogenesis and social behaviors, DNA was found within both extracted and native extracellular matrices (ECM). Further examination revealed that these eDNA molecules formed well organized structures that were similar in appearance to the organization of exopolysaccharides (EPS) in ECM. Biochemical and image analyses confirmed that eDNA bound to and colocalized with EPS within the ECM of starvation biofilms and fruiting bodies. In addition, ECM containing eDNA exhibited greater physical strength and biological stress resistance compared to DNase I treated ECM. Taken together, these findings demonstrate that DNA interacts with EPS and strengthens biofilm structures in M. xanthus.     

Horizontal transfer of antibiotic resistance genes in a membrane bioreactor

Growing attention has been paid to the dissemination of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in wastewater microbial communities. The application of membrane bioreactors (MBRs) in wastewater treatment is becoming increasingly widespread. We hypothesized that the transfer of ARGs among bacteria could occur in MBRs, which combine a high density of bacterial cells, biofilms, and antibiotic resistance bacteria or ARGs. In this study, the transfer discipline and dissemination of the RP4 plasmid in MBRs were investigated by the counting plate method, the MIDI microorganism identification system, and quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) techniques. The results showed that the average transfer frequency of the RP4 plasmid from the donor strain to cultivable bacteria in activated sludge was 2.76 × 10⁻⁵ per recipient, which was greater than the transfer frequency in wastewater and bacterial sludge reported previously. In addition, many bacterial species in the activated sludge had received RP4 by horizontal transfer, while the genera of Shewanella spp., Photobacterium spp., Pseudomonas spp., Proteus spp., and Vibrio spp. were more likely to acquire this plasmid. Interestingly, the abundance of the RP4 plasmid in total DNA remained at high levels and relatively stable at 10⁴ copies/mg of biosolids, suggesting that ARGs were transferred from donor strains to activated sludge bacteria in our study. Thus, the presence of ARGs in sewage sludge poses a potential health threat.