Latitudinal differentiation in the effects of the toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium spp. on the feeding and reproduction of populations of the copepod Acartia hudsonica

Blooms of the dinoflagellate Alexandrium spp. increase in their frequency, toxicity and historical presence with increasing latitude from New Jersey (USA) to the Gaspé peninsula (Canada). Biogeographic variation in these blooms results in differential exposure of geographically separate copepod populations to toxic Alexandrium. We hypothesize that the ability of copepods to feed and reproduce on toxic Alexandrium should be higher in copepods from regions that are frequently exposed to toxic Alexandrium blooms. We tested this hypothesis with factorial common environment experiments in which female adults of the copepod Acartia hudsonica from five separate populations ranging from New Jersey to New Brunswick were fed toxic and non-toxic strains of Alexandrium, and the non-toxic flagellate Tetraselmis sp. Consistent with the hypothesis, when fed toxic Alexandrium we observed significantly higher ingestion and egg production rates in the copepods historically exposed to toxic Alexandrium blooms relative to copepods from regions in which Alexandrium is rare or absent. Such differences among copepod populations were not observed when copepods were fed non-toxic Alexandrium or Tetraselmis sp. These results were also supported by assays in which copepods from populations both historically exposed and naïve to toxic Alexandrium blooms were fed mixtures of toxic Alexandrium and Tetraselmis sp. Two-week long experiments demonstrated that when copepods from populations naïve to toxic Alexandrium were fed a toxic strain of Alexandrium they failed to acclimate, such that their ingestion rates remained low throughout the entire two-week period. The differences observed among populations suggest that local adaptation of populations of A. hudsonica from Massachusetts (USA) to New Brunswick (Canada) has occurred, such that some populations are resistant to toxic Alexandrium.     

Testing for resistance of pelagic marine copepods to a toxic dinoflagellate

With few exceptions, the evolutionary consequences of harmful algae to grazers in aquatic systems remain unexplored. To examine both the ecological and evolutionary consequences of harmful algae on marine zooplankton, we used a two-fold approach. In the first approach, we examined the life history responses of two geographically separate Acartia hudsonica (Copepoda Calanoida) populations reared on diets containing the toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium fundyense . One copepod population was from a region, Casco Bay, Maine, USA, that has experienced recurrent blooms of highly toxic Alexandrium spp. for decades; whereas the other population from Great Bay, New Jersey, USA, has never been exposed to toxic Alexandrium blooms. The life history experiment demonstrated that when the copepod population from New Jersey was reared on a diet containing toxic A. fundyense it exhibited lower somatic growth, size at maturity, egg production and survival than the same population reared on a diet without toxic A. fundyense . In contrast, toxic A. fundyense did not affect the life-history traits of the Maine population. Fitness, finite population growth rate (), was significantly reduced in the New Jersey population, but not in the Maine population. These results are consistent with the hypothesis of local adaptation (resistance) of the historically exposed copepod population to the toxic dinoflagellate. In the second approach, we further tested the resistance hypothesis with a laboratory genetic selection experiment with the naïve New Jersey copepod population exposed to a diet containing toxic A. fundyense. This experiment demonstrated that the ingestion and egg production of adult females of naïve copepods fed A. fundyense improved after three generations of being reared on a diet containing the toxic dinoflagellate. The results of the present study have important implications for understanding how grazer populations may respond to the introduction of toxic algae to their environment, and suggest that grazer resistance may be a feedback mechanism that may lead to bloom control.Co-ordinating editor: Hurst     

Copepods induce paralytic shellfish toxin production in marine dinoflagellates

Among the thousands of unicellular phytoplankton species described in the sea, some frequently occurring and bloom-forming marine dinoflagellates are known to produce the potent neurotoxins causing paralytic shellfish poisoning. The natural function of these toxins is not clear, although they have been hypothesized to act as a chemical defence towards grazers. Here, we show that waterborne cues from the copepod Acartia tonsa induce paralytic shellfish toxin (PST) production in the harmful algal bloom-forming dinoflagellate Alexandrium minutum. Induced A. minutum contained up to 2.5 times more toxins than controls and was more resistant to further copepod grazing. Ingestion of non-toxic alternative prey was not affected by the presence of induced A. minutum. The ability of A. minutum to sense and respond to the presence of grazers by increased PST production and increased resistance to grazing may facilitate the formation of harmful algal blooms in the sea.     

Differential responses of populations of the copepod Acartia hudsonica to toxic and nutritionally insufficient food algae

Nutritional insufficiency and toxicity are deleterious effects of phytoplankton on grazers. We hypothesize that toxic food is likely to have stronger evolutionary selective effects on grazers than nutritionally insufficient food. We explore this hypothesis in comparative studies of egg production and egg hatching of the copepod Acartia hudsonica challenged with both a toxic and a nutritionally insufficient alga. Experiments lasting 6 days, in which mixtures of different proportions of the suspect and a control alga were offered as food to female copepods, showed that the dinoflagellate Alexandrium fundyense, which bears paralytic shellfish toxins, was toxic to A. hudsonica. In contrast, the diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum was nutritionally insufficient to A. hudsonica. In another set of experiments, the effects of A. fundyense and P. tricornutum, respectively, as sole foods on egg production and egg hatching success of two geographically separated populations (Maine and Connecticut) of the copepod A. hudsonica were examined in common-environment experiments, after being raised under identical conditions for two generations. The location in Maine regularly experiences toxic blooms of Alexandrium sp. whereas the location in Connecticut does not. During a 6-day period, A. fundyense reduced the egg production rates of the Connecticut copepod population, but not of the Maine population. In contrast, the diatom P. tricornutum reduced the egg production of both populations. These results of this study are consistent with the hypothesis of local adaptation to toxic food, but not to nutritionally insufficient food.     

Alexandrium catenella and Alexandrium minutum blooms in the Mediterranean Sea: Toward the identification of ecological niches

Annual recurrent blooms of the toxic dinoflagellates Alexandrium catenella and Alexandrium minutum were detected from 2000 to 2003 in harbours along the Catalan coast. The interrelation study between the occurrence of the blooms and specific external conditions at the study sites demonstrated that different factors are required for the bloom of each Alexandrium species. Concentrations higher than 10⁵ cells l⁻¹ of A. catenella were only detected in Tarragona harbour. These blooms were associated with water surface temperature between 21 and 25 °C and salinities of around 34 psu or higher than 37 psu. A. minutum appeared widely spread along the Catalan coast, though the most intensive and recurrent blooms of this species were observed in Arenys de Mar harbour. Concentrations of millions of cells per litre of A. minutum were associated with water temperatures below 14 °C and salinities of around 34–36 psu. A. minutum cell densities showed a positive significant correlation with NO₃ but a negative correlation with NH₄. On the other hand, A. catenella blooms dominated when both NO₃ and NH₄ levels were high. The prevailing inorganic nitrogen form (NO₃ vs. NH₄) could explain why these two species rarely coincide in the same harbours. Accumulation of cysts in the sediment was found to be an important potential factor for the recurrence of these species. The 4.3 × 10³ A. catenella cysts cm⁻³ of wet sediment in Tarragona harbour and the 3.02 × 10³ A. minutum cysts cm⁻³ of wet sediment in Vilanova harbour were the highest concentrations observed from the cyst study. Confined waters such as harbours play an important role as reservoirs for the accumulation of cysts and vegetative cells, which contributes to the expansion of these dinoflagellates in the region. However, the particular environmental conditions are also decisive factors of bloom intensity.     

Isolation and characterization of a marine algicidal bacterium against the toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium tamarense

Interactions between bacteria and harmful algal bloom (HAB) species have been acknowledged as an important factor regulating both the population dynamics and toxin production of these algae. A marine bacterium SP48 with algicidal activity to the toxic dinoflagellate, Alexandrium tamarense, was isolated from the Donghai Sea area, China. Genetic identification was achieved by polymerase chain reaction amplification and sequence analysis of 16S rDNA. Sequence analysis showed that the most probable affiliation of SP48 was to the γ-proteobacteria subclass and the genus Pseudoalteromonas. Bacterial isolate SP48 showed algicidal activity through an indirect attack. Additional organic nutrients but not algal-derived DOM was necessary for the synthesis of unidentified algicidal compounds but β-glucosidase was not responsible for the algicidal activity. The algicidal compounds produced by bacterium SP48 were heat tolerant, unstable in acidic condition and could be easily synthesized regardless of variation in temperature, salinity or initial pH for bacterial growth. This is the first report of a bacterium algicidal to the toxic dinoflagellate A. tamarense and the findings increase our knowledge of bacterial–algal interactions and the role of bacteria during the population dynamics of HABs.     

Ingestion of the dinoflagellate, Pfiesteria piscicida, by the calanoid copepod, Acartia tonsa

The dinoflagellate, Pfiesteria piscicida, can form harmful algal blooms in estuarine environments. The dominant copepod species usually found in these waters is Acartia tonsa. We tested the ability of A. tonsa to graze the non-toxic zoospore stage of P. piscicida and thus serve as a potential biological control of blooms of this algal species. A. tonsa grazed the non-toxic zoospore stages of both a non-inducible P. piscicida strain (FDEPMDR23) and a potentially toxic strain (Tox-B101156) at approximately equal rates. Ingestion of P. piscicida increased with cell concentration and exhibited a saturated feeding response. Both the maximum number of cells ingested (I_max) and the slope of the ingestion curve (α) of A. tonsa feeding on P. piscicida were comparable to these ingestion parameters for A. tonsa fed similar-sized phytoplankton and protozoan species. When these laboratory ingestion rates were combined with abundance estimates of A. tonsa from the Pocomoke Estuary and Chesapeake Bay, we found that significant grazing control of the non-toxic zoospore stage of P. piscicida by A. tonsa would only occur at high copepod abundances (>10 copepods L⁻¹). We conclude that under most in situ conditions the potential biological control of blooms of P. piscicida is exerted by microzooplankton grazers. However, in the less saline portions of estuaries where maximum concentrations of copepods often occur with low abundances of microzooplankton, copepod grazing coefficients can be similar to the growth rates of P. piscicida.     

Feeding on dinoflagellates by intermediate and late stage crab zoeae raised in the laboratory and collected from the field

Hatching stage crab larvae will ingest algae, including non-toxic and toxic dinoflagellates. We determined that later zoeal stages, obtained from both laboratory-raised larvae and natural assemblages, also ingest dinoflagellates and we measured the effects of prey density, prior feeding history and time of exposure to prey on incidence of ingestion. Both stage 1 and later stage larvae exposed to algal prey were examined using epifluorescence for the presence of chl a. Both stage 1 and stage 3 laboratory-raised Cancer oregonensis (Dana) and Hemigrapsus nudus (Dana) ingested both the non-toxic dinoflagellate Prorocentrum micans Ehrenberg and the toxic Alexandrium andersoni Balech, with no difference between the stages. Both species showed higher ingestion of P. micans than A. andersoni. Ingestion of both prey types occurred at prey densities as low as 200 cell ml^− 1 in C. oregonensis and 50 cells ml^− 1 in H. nudus. Samples collected in summer, 2004, provided both stage 1 and late stage Lophopanopeus bellus (Stimpson); stage 1, intermediate, and late stage Fabia subquadrata Dana; and an unidentified porcellanid. Stage 1 L. bellus ingested both prey, while late stage zoeae did not, although the latter apparently were not actively feeding. F. subquadrata fed on both prey, with no difference between early and late larvae. Both stages ingested P. micans more readily than A. andersoni. First evidence of ingestion of P. micans at 600 cells ml^− 1 occurred after only 0.5 h, while it took 2 h for ingestion at 50 cells ml^− 1. The model of larval feeding involving both omnivory and prey discrimination described previously for the hatching stage is sustained throughout zoeal development and is, perhaps, an adaptation to an uncertain prey environment, one that trades opportunism for inefficiency.     

Effects of Karenia brevis diet on RNA:DNA ratios and egg production of Acartia tonsa

Karenia brevis is a harmful alga associated with deleterious effects on zooplankton, but the exact cause (e.g. toxin, nutritional inadequacy or starvation) of these adverse effects is not clear. RNA:DNA ratios, fecundity and fecal pellet production of Acartia tonsa were measured on mono-algal and mixed-algal culture diets of K. brevis and Peridinium foliaceum to examine the usefulness of RNA:DNA ratios as an indicator of nutrition and to determine if adverse effects of K. brevis are due to the presence of toxins, poor nutritional quality or starvation. RNA:DNA ratios and egg production values were significantly higher for 100% P. foliaceum diet compared to 100% K. brevis diet. Significant differences in egg production, but not RNA:DNA ratios, were found between the various mixed diets, suggesting egg production is a more sensitive indicator of nutritional quality than RNA:DNA ratios. Changes in RNA:DNA ratios, fecundity and fecal pellet production of copepods fed two different toxic K. brevis strains were nearly identical, indicating that the presence of brevetoxins has little affect on A. tonsa. The similarity in RNA:DNA ratios, egg production, percent hatching and fecal production between the 100% K. brevis diet and starved copepods suggests that A. tonsa does not consume K. brevis when offered as its sole food source.     

Distinctly different behavioral responses of a copepod,Temora longicornis,to different strains of toxic dinoflagellates,Alexandrium spp.

Zooplankton responses to toxic algae are highly variable, even towards taxonomically closely related species or different strains of the same species. Here, the individual level feeding behavior of a copepod, Temora longicornis, was examined which offered 4 similarly sized strains of toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium spp. and a non-toxic control strain of the dinoflagellate Protoceratium reticulatum. The strains varied in their cellular toxin concentration and composition and in lytic activity. High-speed video observations revealed four distinctly different strain-specific feeding responses of the copepod during 4 h incubations: (i) the ‘normal’ feeding behavior, in which the feeding appendages were beating almost constantly to produce a feeding current and most (90%) of the captured algae were ingested; (ii) the beating activity of the feeding appendages was reduced by ca. 80% during the initial 60 min of exposure, after which very few algae were captured and ingested; (iii) capture and ingestion rates remained high, but ingested cells were regurgitated; and (iv) the copepod continued beating its appendages and captured cells at a high rate, but after 60 min, most captured cells were rejected. The various prey aversion responses observed may have very different implications to the prey and their ability to form blooms: consumed but regurgitated cells are dead, captured but rejected cells survive and may give the prey a competitive advantage, while reduced feeding activity of the grazer may be equally beneficial to the prey and its competitors. These behaviors were not related to lytic activity or overall paralytic shellfish toxins (PSTs) content and composition and suggest that other cues are responsible for the responses.     

Consumption of toxic cyanobacteria by Potamopyrgus antipodarum (Gastropoda, Prosobranchia) and consequences on life traits and microcystin accumulation

Among the wide range of toxins produced by cyanobacterial blooms, microcystins (MCs) are the most common and are known to accumulate in aquatic organisms. Freshwater gastropods are grazers and likely to ingest toxic cyanobacteria, particularly Planktothrix agardhii, one of the most common species in the northern hemisphere. The study examines (i) the ingestion of toxic P. agardhii by the prosobranch Potamopyrgus antipodarum, (ii) the kinetics of MC accumulation and depuration in snail tissues during and post-exposure, and (iii) the impact of MCs on their life traits (survival, growth and fecundity). We showed that P. antipodarum ingested 71% of cyanobacteria available during the first 24 h in the presence or not of non-toxic food, and accumulated 1.3% of ingested MCs during the 5-week intoxication period. Elimination of MCs was total after 3 weeks of depuration. A decrease of growth and fecundity was observed during the intoxication period, but it was reversible after the end of exposure. Results are discussed in terms of variation of the response between prosobranch and pulmonate gastropods to toxic cyanobacteria exposure, and the negative impact of toxic cyanobacteria on natural communities of freshwater gastropods.     

Copepod feeding response to varying Alexandrium spp. cellular toxicity and cell concentration among natural plankton samples

We challenged four species of copepod grazers (Acartia hudsonica, Centropages hamatus, Eurytemora herdmani, Calanus finmarchicus) with natural water samples containing non-toxic algae mixed with one of three clones of Alexandrium spp.—A. tamarense GTCN16 (non-toxic), A. fundyense GTCA28 (moderate toxicity), and A. fundyense BC1 (higher toxicity), each at relatively high (10⁵ cells L⁻¹) and low (10⁴ cells L⁻¹) concentrations. Within any one copepod species, significant differences existed in copepod clearance rates and total food ingested between high and low Alexandrium cell concentrations, and between levels of toxicity, but feeding response did not follow a predictable relationship proportional to toxin levels—rather, the presence or absence of toxin was more important than the level of toxicity. C. finmarchicus behaved differently from the smaller coastal copepods, showing less selectivity and greater concentration dependence. In low Alexandrium concentration treatments, copepod clearance rates on Alexandrium were usually higher, and electivity indices for Alexandrium less negative (indicating less avoidance), compared to high concentration treatments. In high toxicity (BC1) treatments of all copepod species (except C. finmarchicus), total food consumption was consistently less at high Alexandrium concentrations compared to low concentrations, suggesting that high toxicity and concentration suppress overall feeding, while in non-toxic (GTCN 16) treatments total consumption was always higher at high Alexandrium concentrations. Copepod grazers do not follow predictable feeding rules throughout a continuum of conditions, but become more predictable at extremes of concentration and toxicity of prey, consistent with the conclusion that both factors are important. Results support the hypothesis that grazer deterrence imparted by toxicity is only effective at high cell concentrations, but even then will not protect against all grazers.     

A new simple screening method for the detection of cytotoxic substances produced by harmful red tide phytoplankton

A highly sensitive, but simple and quantitative, cytotoxic assay method for the detection of toxic substances produced by red tide phytoplankton was developed by utilizing Vero cells which were the most resistant to seawater among the six cell lines tested. Heterocapsa circularisquama, which is known to be highly toxic to shellfish, showed cytotoxicity to Vero cells in a cell-density dependent manner when Vero cells were directly exposed to the cell suspension of H. circularisquama in seawater-based plankton culture medium, whereas Heterocapsa triquetra, which is morphologically similar to H. circularisquama but non-toxic to shellfish, showed no cytotoxic effect. Since the potent cytotoxicity was also detected in the cell-free culture supernatant of H. circularisquama, it was suggested that a certain cytotoxic substance is extracellularly secreted by H. circularisquama. Furthermore, by this direct exposure method, we found that Alexandrium fraterculus, Alexandrium tamiyavanichii, Alexandrium tamarense, and Alexandrium affine but not Alexandrium taylorii and Alexandrium catenella cause toxic effect on Vero cells with different extent depending on species. By gel-filtration and subsequent two cytotoxicity assays using Vero and mouse neuroblastoma cell line (Neuro-2a), we found that high molecular weight cytotoxic substance distinct from paralytic shellfish poisoning toxins is present in the aqueous extract of A. tamarense. These results suggest that our 96-well microplate cytotoxicity assay using Vero cells is useful not only as a primary screening assay for the detection of potential toxic activity of harmful phytoplankton but also as a quantitative routine toxicity assay for following the active substances during the extraction and purification processes.     

Effects of Grazer Presence on Genetic Structure of a Phenotypically Diverse Diatom Population

Studies of predator–prey systems in both aquatic and terrestrial environments have shown that grazers structure the intraspecific diversity of prey species, given that the prey populations are phenotypically variable. Populations of phytoplankton have traditionally considered comprising only low intraspecific variation, hence selective grazing as a potentially structuring factor of both genetic and phenotypic diversity has not been comprehensively studied. In this study, we compared strain specific growth rates, production of polyunsaturated aldehydes, and chain length of the marine diatom Skeletonema marinoi in both grazer and non-grazer conditions by conducting monoclonal experiments. Additionally, a mesocosm experiment was performed with multiclonal experimental S. marinoi populations exposed to grazers at different levels of copepod concentration to test effects of grazer presence on diatom diversity in close to natural conditions. Our results show that distinct genotypes of a geographically restricted population exhibit variable phenotypic traits relevant to grazing interactions such as chain length and growth rates. Grazer presence affected clonal richness and evenness of multiclonal Skeletonema populations in the mesocosms, likely in conjunction with intrinsic interactions among the diatom strains. Only the production of polyunsaturated aldehydes was not affected by grazer presence. Our findings suggest that grazing can be an important factor structuring diatom population diversity in the sea and emphasize the importance of considering clonal differences when characterizing species and their role in nature.     

Seasonal abundance, reproduction and development of four key copepod species on the Faroe shelf

The copepod community on the Faroe shelf is dominated by Calanus finmarchicus, Temora longicornis, Acartia longiremis and Pseudocalanus spp. The species composition, abundance and development of the copepod community varied considerably during the season 2004. These variations reflected to a large extent the different life strategies of the copepods. Both nauplii and copepodites of C. finmarchicus were most abundant during spring and early summer. The two neritic copepods T. longicornis and A. longiremis were present in low numbers during spring but dominated the copepod community later during the productive period. Pseudocalanus spp., on the other hand, occurred throughout the year, but showed no clear numerical response in abundance to the spring bloom. The egg production measurements of C. finmarchicus and T. longicornis showed some pre-bloom egg production, but as the spring bloom started the egg production rate increased significantly, especially for C. finmarchicus. There seemed to be a substantial loss of nauplii and copepods from the shelf ecosystem during the productive season. It was, however, not possible to determine whether this was mainly due to mortality or advective loss.     

Zooplankton interactions with toxic phytoplankton: Some implications for food web studies and algal defence strategies of feeding selectivity behaviour, toxin dilution and phytoplankton population diversity

This study focuses on the interactions between toxic phytoplankton and zooplankton grazers. The experimental conditions used are an attempt to simulate situations that have, so far, received little attention. We presume the phytoplankton community to be a set of species where a population of a toxic species is intrinsically diverse by the presence of coexisting strains with different toxic properties. The other species in the community may not always be high-quality food for herbivorous zooplankton. Zooplankton populations may have developed adaptive responses to sympatric toxic phytoplankton species. Zooplankton grazers may perform a specific feeding behaviour and its consequences on fitness will depend on the species ingested, the effect of toxins, and the presence of mechanisms of toxin dilution and compensatory feeding. Our target species are a strain of the dinoflagellate Alexandrium minutum and a sympatric population of the copepod Acartia clausi. Mixed diets were used with two kinds of A. minutum cells: non-toxic and toxic. The flagellate Rhodomonas baltica and the non-toxic dinoflagellate Alexandrium tamarense were added as accompanying species. The effect of each alga was studied in separate diets. The toxic A. minutum cells were shown to have negative effects on egg production, hatching success and total reproductive output, while, in terms of its effect on fitness, the non-toxic A. minutum was the best quality food offered. R. baltica and A. tamarense were in intermediate positions. In the mixed diets, copepods showed a strong preference for toxic A. minutum cells and a weaker one for A. tamarense cells, while non-toxic A. minutum was slightly negatively selected and R. baltica strongly negatively selected. Although the level of toxins accumulated by copepods was very similar, in both the diet with only toxic A. minutum cells and in the mixed diet, the negative effects on fitness in the mixed diet could be offset by toxin dilution mechanisms. The implications of these findings are the fact that mesozooplankton may not play an important role in phytoplankton blooms development. Phytoplankton endotoxin production does not seem to be an evolutionary stable strategy as a defence against some herbivores.     

Organ-specific distribution of dietary alkaloids in the marine opisthobranch Tylodina perversa

Specimens of the opisthobranch Tylodina perversa that were observed while feeding on the sponge Aplysina aerophoba were transferred to seawater tanks along with their prey and kept under controlled conditions. After one week the opisthobranchs were anaesthetized, dissected and studied for sequestered sponge-derived brominated alkaloids. All parts of T. perversa analyzed including feces, mucus and egg masses that had been produced during captivity contained alkaloids derived from A. aerophoba. The highest total alkaloid concentration (24.6 mg g⁻¹ dry wt) was found in mantles of T. perversa (compared to 51.2 mg g⁻¹ dry wt of total alkaloids in A. aerophoba). Hepatopancreas, egg masses and mucus (respective total alkaloid concentrations ranging from 20.4 to 12.5 mg g⁻¹ dry wt) were also rich in alkaloids. Whereas in A. aerophoba the isoxazoline alkaloids aerophobin-2 and isofistularin-3 were present in almost equal concentrations, aerophobin-2 constituted by far the major alkaloid (amounting to approximately 70% of all identified alkaloids) in mantles, mucus and egg masses of T. perversa, indicating selective sequestration by the opisthobranchs. Mantles as well as mucus also contained appreciable concentrations (approximately 20% of all identified compounds) of the brominated alkaloid aerothionin; this is not detected in A. aerophoba. It is possible that aerothionin originates from a previous encounter of T. perversa with the sponge A. cavernicola, the latter being closely related to A. aerophoba. The enrichment of aerophobin-2 (and of aerothionin) in mantles, mucus and egg masses that are vulnerable and exposed (mantles and egg masses) to predators and/or pathogens argues for defensive functions of the respective alkaloids even though this hypothesis still needs to be experimentally corroborated.     

Prorocentrum minimum(clone Exuv) is nutritionally insufficient, but not toxic to the copepod Acartia tonsa

This study tested whether the dinoflagellate Prorocentrum minimum is nutritionally insufficient or toxic to the copepod Acartia tonsa. Experiments were carried out with adult female A. tonsa and the P. minimum clone Exuv, both isolated from Long Island Sound. Initially, the functional and numerical responses of A. tonsa feeding on exponentially growing P. minimum cells were characterized. These experiments revealed that A. tonsa readily ingested P. minimum cells, up to the equivalent of 200% of body carbon day⁻¹, but egg production was relatively low, with a maximum egg production rate of 22% of body carbon day⁻¹. Hence, the egg production efficiency (egg carbon produced versus cell carbon ingested) was low (10%). In a separate experiment, ingestion and egg production rates were measured as a function of food concentration with cells in different growth stages (early-exponential, late-exponential/early-stationary, and late-stationary growth phase) to simulate conditions during a bloom. There was no indication that cells in the stationary phase resulted in lower ingestion or egg production rates relative to actively growing cells. Egg hatching success remained high (>80%) and independent of the cell growth phase. In a third experiment specifically designed to test the hypothesis that P. minimum is toxic, ingestion, egg production and egg hatching success were measured when females were fed mixtures of P. minimum and the diatom Thalassiosira weissflogii, but in which total food concentration was held constant and the proportion of P. minimum in the mixed diet varied. A. tonsa readily ingested P. minimum when it was offered in the mixed diet, with no detrimental effects on egg production or egg hatching observed. Supplementing P. minimum with T. weissflogii increased both the egg production rate and the egg production efficiency. It is concluded that P. minimum is nutritionally insufficient, but not toxic to A. tonsa. Finally, it is estimated that in the field grazing by A. tonsa is approximately equivalent to 30% of the maximum daily growth rate of P. minimum. Hence, copepod grazing cannot be ignored in field and modeling studies of the population dynamics of P. minimum.     

How does eutrophication affect the role of grazers in harmful algal bloom dynamics?

Population dynamics of harmful algal bloom species are regulated both from the “bottom-up” by factors that affect their growth rate and from the “top-down” by factors that affect their loss rates. While it might seem apparent that eutrophication would have the greatest impact on factors affecting growth rates of phytoplankton (nutrient supply, light availability) the roles of top-down controls, including grazers and pathogens, cannot be ignored in studies of harmful bloom dynamics. Lags between the growth of phytoplankton and zooplankton populations, or disruption of zooplankton populations by adverse environmental conditions may be important factors in the initiation of plankton blooms under eutrophic conditions. Grazers that avoid feeding on harmful species and actively graze on competing species may also play important roles in bloom initiation. Grazers that are not affected by phytoplankton toxins and have growth rates comparable to phytoplankton (e.g. protozoan grazers) may have the potential to control the initiation of blooms. If the inhibition of grazers varies with cell density for blooms of toxic phytoplankton, eutrophication may increase the chances of blooms reaching threshold densities for grazer inhibition. In addition, secondary effects of eutrophication, including hypoxia and change in pH may adversely affect grazer populations, and further release HAB species from top-down control. The Texas brown tide (Aureoumbra lagunensis) blooms provide evidence for the role of grazer disruption in bloom initiation and the importance of high densities of brown tide cells in continued suppression of grazers.     

Grazing on toxic Alexandrium fundyense resting cysts and vegetative cells by the eastern oyster (Crassostrea virginica)

In laboratory experiments, oysters (Crassostrea virginica) were fed Alexandrium fundyense (strain CB501) vegetative cells or resting cysts (from strains CB501 and GMT25) produced from laboratory cultures. The toxicity per cyst was 1.7 pg STXequiv/cyst and for vegetative cells 3.9 pg STXequiv/cell. The toxic, resting cysts and vegetative cells were removed from suspension in the experimental containers within about 4 h. Oysters fed toxic vegetative cells digested 72% of cells ingested, and 28% survived gut passage by forming temporary cysts. Toxin levels of oysters fed vegetative cells averaged 27 μg STXequiv/100 g meat. Resting cysts added to the experimental containers adhered to the walls so that only 40% of the cysts added were available to the oysters during the experiment. Of the cysts that were ingested, approximately 59% were digested, and oysters accumulated toxins (an average of 1.2 μg STXequiv/100 g meat), showing that consumption of resting cysts can cause toxicity in oysters. Direct consumption of resting cysts, thus, may explain shellfish toxicity in areas without known blooms, but with toxic resting cysts in the sediment. These results suggest a possible role of toxic cysts in mediating time-lags between surface blooms and appearance of toxicity in benthic grazers, and the possible role of benthic grazers in controlling seed populations, except in anoxic areas, which can serve as cyst “refuges” from grazing mortality.