Analysis of Fasciola cathepsin L5 by S2 subsite substitutions and determination of the P1-P4 specificity reveals an unusual preference

Fasciola parasites (liver flukes) express numerous cathepsin L proteases that are believed to be involved in important functions related to host invasion and parasite survival. These proteases are evolutionarily divided into clades that are proposed to reflect their substrate specificity, most noticeably through the S(2) subsite. Single amino acid substitutions to residues lining this site, including amino acid residue 69 (aa69; mature cathepsin L5 numbering) can have profound influences on subsite architecture and influence enzyme specificity. Variations at aa69 among known Fasciola cathepsin L proteases include leucine, tyrosine, tryptophan, phenylalanine and glycine. Other amino acids (cysteine, serine) might have been expected at this site due to codon usage as cathepsin L isoenzymes evolved, but C69 and S69 have not been observed. The introduction of L69C and L69S substitutions into FhCatL5 resulted in low overall activity indicating their expression provides no functional advantage, thus explaining the absence of such variants in Fasciola. An FhCatL5 L69F variant showed an increase in the ability to cleave substrates with P(2) proline, indicating F69 variants expressed by the fluke would likely have this ability. An FhCatL2 Y69L variant showed a decreased acceptance of P(2) proline, further highlighting the importance of Y69 for FhCatL2 P(2) proline acceptance. Finally, the P(1)-P(4) specificity of Fasciola cathepsin L5 was determined and, unexpectedly, aspartic acid was shown to be well accepted at P(2,) which is unique amongst Fasciola cathepsins examined to date.     

Selective inhibition of the collagenolytic activity of human cathepsin K by altering its S2 subsite specificity

The primary specificity of papain-like cysteine proteases (family C1, clan CA) is determined by S2-P2 interactions. Despite the high amino acid sequence identities and structural similarities between cathepsins K and L, only cathepsin K is capable of cleaving interstitial collagens in their triple helical domains. To investigate this specificity, we have engineered the S2 pocket of human cathepsin K into a cathepsin L-like subsite. Using combinatorial fluorogenic substrate libraries, the P1-P4 substrate specificity of the cathepsin K variant, Tyr67Leu/Leu205Ala, was determined and compared with those of cathepsins K and L. The introduction of the double mutation into the S2 subsite of cathepsin K rendered the unique S2 binding preference of the protease for proline and leucine residues into a cathepsin L-like preference for bulky aromatic residues. Homology modeling and docking calculations supported the experimental findings. The cathepsin L-like S2 specificity of the mutant protein and the integrity of its catalytic site were confirmed by kinetic analysis of synthetic di- and tripeptide substrates as well as pH stability and pH activity profile studies. The loss of the ability to accept proline in the S2 binding pocket by the mutant protease completely abolished the collagenolytic activity of cathepsin K whereas its overall gelatinolytic activity remained unaffected. These results indicate that Tyr67 and Leu205 play a key role in the binding of proline residues in the S2 pocket of cathepsin K and are required for its unique collagenase activity.     

Recombinant human cathepsin X is a carboxymonopeptidase only: a comparison with cathepsins B and L

The S1 and S2 subsite specificity of recombinant human cathepsins X was studied using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) peptides with the general sequences Abz-Phe-Xaa-Lys(Dnp)-OH and Abz-Xaa-Arg-Lys(Dnp)-OH, respectively (Abz=ortho-aminobenzoic acid and Dnp=2,4-dinitrophenyl; Xaa=various amino acids). Cathepsin X cleaved all substrates exclusively as a carboxymonopeptidase and exhibited broad specificity. For comparison, these peptides were also assayed with cathepsins B and L. Cathepsin L hydrolyzed the majority of them with similar or higher catalytic efficiency than cathepsin X, acting as an endopeptidase mimicking a carboxymonopeptidase (pseudo-carboxymonopeptidase). In contrast, cathepsin B exhibited poor catalytic efficiency with these substrates, acting as a carboxydipeptidase or an endopeptidase. The S1' subsite of cathepsin X was mapped with the peptide series Abz-Phe-Arg-Xaa-OH and the enzyme preferentially hydrolyzed substrates with hydrophobic residues in the P1' position.     

Differences in substrate specificities between cysteine protease CPB isoforms of Leishmania mexicana are mediated by a few amino acid changes.

The CPB genes of the protozoan parasite Leishmania mexicana encode stage-regulated cathepsin L-like cysteine proteases that are important virulence factors and are in a tandem array of 19 genes. In this study, we have compared the substrate preferences of two CPB isoforms, CPB2.8 and CPB3, and a H84Y mutant of the latter enzyme, to analyse the roles played by the few amino acid differences between the isoenzymes in determining substrate specificity. CPB3 differs from CPB2.8 at just three residues (N60D, D61N and D64S) in the mature domain. The H84Y mutation mimics an additional change present in another isoenzyme, CPB18. The active recombinant CPB isoenzymes and mutant were produced using Escherichia coli and the S1-S3 and S1'-S3' subsite specificities determined using a series of fluorogenic peptide derivatives in which substitutions were made on positions P3 to P3' by natural amino acids. Carboxydipeptidase activities of CPB3 and H84Y were also observed using the peptide Abz-FRAK(Dnp)-OH and some of its analogues. The kinetic parameters of hydrolysis by CPB3, H84Y and CPB2.8 of the synthetic substrates indicates that the specificity of S3 to S3' subsites is influenced greatly by the modifications at amino acids 60, 61, 64 and 84. Particularly noteworthy was the large preference for Pro in the P2' position for the hydrolytic activity of CPB3, which may be relevant to a role in the activation mechanism of the L. mexicana CPBs.     

Structural and functional relationships in the virulence-associated cathepsin L proteases of the parasitic liver fluke, Fasciola hepatica

The helminth parasite Fasciola hepatica secretes cysteine proteases to facilitate tissue invasion, migration, and development within the mammalian host. The major proteases cathepsin L1 (FheCL1) and cathepsin L2 (FheCL2) were recombinantly produced and biochemically characterized. By using site-directed mutagenesis, we show that residues at position 67 and 205, which lie within the S2 pocket of the active site, are critical in determining the substrate and inhibitor specificity. FheCL1 exhibits a broader specificity and a higher substrate turnover rate compared with FheCL2. However, FheCL2 can efficiently cleave substrates with a Pro in the P2 position and degrade collagen within the triple helices at physiological pH, an activity that among cysteine proteases has only been reported for human cathepsin K. The 1.4-A three-dimensional structure of the FheCL1 was determined by x-ray crystallography, and the three-dimensional structure of FheCL2 was constructed via homology-based modeling. Analysis and comparison of these structures and our biochemical data with those of human cathepsins L and K provided an interpretation of the substrate-recognition mechanisms of these major parasite proteases. Furthermore, our studies suggest that a configuration involving residue 67 and the "gatekeeper" residues 157 and 158 situated at the entrance of the active site pocket create a topology that endows FheCL2 with its unusual collagenolytic activity. The emergence of a specialized collagenolytic function in Fasciola likely contributes to the success of this tissue-invasive parasite.     

Interdependency of sequence and positional specificities for cysteine proteases of the papain family

The specificity of cysteine proteases is characterized by the nature of the amino acid sequence recognized by the enzymes (sequence specificity) as well as by the position of the scissile peptide bond (positional specificity, i.e., endopeptidase, aminopeptidase, or carboxypeptidase). In this paper, the interdependency of sequence and positional specificities for selected members of this class of enzymes has been investigated using fluorogenic substrates where both the position of the cleavable peptide bond and the nature of the sequence of residues in P2-P1 are varied. The results show that cathepsins K and L and papain, typically considered to act strictly as endopeptidases, can also display dipeptidyl carboxypeptidase activity against the substrate Abz-FRF(4NO2)A and dipeptidyl aminopeptidase activity against FR-MCA. In some cases the activity is even equal to or greater than that observed with cathepsin B and DPP-I (dipeptidyl peptidase I), which have been characterized previously as exopeptidases. In contrast, the exopeptidase activities of cathepsins K and L and papain are extremely low when the P2-P1 residues are A-A, indicating that, as observed for the normal endopeptidase activity, the exopeptidase activities rely heavily on interactions in subsite S2 (and possibly S1). However, cathepsin B and DPP-I are able to hydrolyze substrates through the exopeptidase route even in absence of preferred interactions in subsites S2 and S1. This is attributed to the presence in cathepsin B and DPP-I of specific structural elements which serve as an anchor for the C- or N-terminus of a substrate, thereby allowing favorable enzyme-substrate interaction independently of the P2-P1 sequence. As a consequence, the nature of the residue at position P2 of a substrate, which is usually the main factor determining the specificity for cysteine proteases of the papain family, does not have the same contribution for the exopeptidase activities of cathepsin B and DPP-I.     

Selective cleavage of peptide bonds by cathepsins L and B from rat liver

The selective cleavage of peptide bonds by cathepsin L from rat liver was examined with a hexapeptide, luteinizing hormone releasing hormone, neurotensin and oxidized insulin A chain as model substrates. The specificity of cathepsin L was compared with that of cathepsin B. Cathepsin L cleaved peptide bonds that have a hydrophobic amino acid, such as Phe, Leu, Val, and Trp or Tyr, in position P2. A polar amino acid, such as Tyr, Ser, Gly, Glu, Asp, Gln, or Asn, in position P1. enhanced the susceptibility of the peptide bond to cathepsin L, though the importance of the amino acid residue in position P1' was not as great as that of the amino acid in position P2 for the action of cathepsin L. These results suggest that, in contrast to cathepsin B, cathepsin L shows very clear specificity.     

Subsite specificity of trypanosomal cathepsin L-like cysteine proteases. Probing the S2 pocket with phenylalanine-derived amino acids.

The S2 subsite of mammalian cysteine proteinases of the papain family is essential for specificity. Among natural amino acids, all these enzymes prefer bulky hydrophobic residues such as phenylalanine at P2. This holds true for their trypanosomal counterparts: cruzain from Trypanosoma cruzi and congopain from T. congolense. A detailed analysis of the S2 specificity of parasitic proteases was performed to gain information that might be of interest for the design of more selective pseudopeptidyl inhibitors. Nonproteogenic phenylalanyl analogs (Xaa) have been introduced into position P2 of fluorogenic substrates dansyl-Xaa-Arg-Ala-Pro-Trp, and their kinetic constants (Km, kcat/Km) have been determined with congopain and cruzain, and related host cathepsins B and L. Trypanosomal cysteine proteases are poorly stereoselective towards D/L-Phe, the inversion of chirality modifying the efficiency of the reaction but not the Km. Congopain binds cyclohexylalanine better than aromatic Phe derivatives. Another characteristic feature of congopain compared to cruzain and cathepsins B and L was that it could accomodate a phenylglycyl residue (kcat/Km = 1300 mM-1.s-1), while lengthening of the side chain by a methylene group only slightly impaired the specificity constant towards trypanosomal cysteine proteases. Mono- and di-halogenation or nitration of Phe did not affect Km for cathepsin L-like enzymes, but the presence of constrained Phe derivatives prevented a correct fitting into the S2 subsite. A model of congopain has been built to study the fit of Phe analogs within the S2 pocket. Phe analogs adopted a positioning within the S2 pocket similar to that of the Tyr of the cruzain/Z-Tyr-Ala-fluoromethylketone complex. However, cyclohexylalanine has an energetically favorable chair-like conformation and can penetrate deeper into the subsite. Fitting of modeled Phe analogs were in good agreement with kinetic parameters. Furthermore, a linear relationship could be established with logP, supporting the suggestion that fitting into the S2 pocket of trypanosomal cysteine proteases depends on the hydrophobicity of Phe analogs.     

Comparative study on specificities of rat cathepsin L and papain: amino acid differences at substrate-binding sites are involved in their specificities

Sixty-nine rat cathepsin L-susceptible peptide bonds were analyzed employing various peptide substrates. The proteolytic specificities of rat cathepsin L and papain were compared and the results are discussed in relation to differences in amino acid residues around their binding sites. The specificity of cathepsin L, which is characterized by a remarkable preference for hydrophobic amino acids at the P2 site of the scissile peptide bonds, was analogous to that of papain as a whole. This analogous specificity suggests that the binding sites of the two proteases are analogous, as expected from their homologous amino acid sequences. However, there is a slight difference in the preference for S3 site between them. That is, cathepsin L showed a greater preference for bulky and hydrophobic amino acids at the S3 site than did papain. Based on the computer-graphically deduced structure of the binding sites of cathepsin L, the preferences for hydrophobic amino acids at the S2 site and for bulky and hydrophobic amino acids at the S3 site of the protease are supposed to be related to the compensating amino acid substitutions at the S2 site (V133A and V157L) and the reduction in size at the S3 site (Y61Q and Y67L), respectively. The discussion of the effect of the amino acid substitutions on the proteolytic activities of cathepsin L and papain in this paper provides a basis for more advanced studies of the relationship between structure and function of proteases belonging to the papain superfamily by means of protein engineering.     

Substrate profiling of cysteine proteases using a combinatorial peptide library identifies functionally unique specificities

The substrate specificities of papain-like cysteine proteases (clan CA, family C1) papain, bromelain, and human cathepsins L, V, K, S, F, B, and five proteases of parasitic origin were studied using a completely diversified positional scanning synthetic combinatorial library. A bifunctional coumarin fluorophore was used that facilitated synthesis of the library and individual peptide substrates. The library has a total of 160,000 tetrapeptide substrate sequences completely randomizing each of the P1, P2, P3, and P4 positions with 20 amino acids. A microtiter plate assay format permitted a rapid determination of the specificity profile of each enzyme. Individual peptide substrates were then synthesized and tested for a quantitative determination of the specificity of the human cathepsins. Despite the conserved three-dimensional structure and similar substrate specificity of the enzymes studied, distinct amino acid preferences that differentiate each enzyme were identified. The specificities of cathepsins K and S partially match the cleavage site sequences in their physiological substrates. Capitalizing on its unique preference for proline and glycine at the P2 and P3 positions, respectively, selective substrates and a substrate-based inhibitor were developed for cathepsin K. A cluster analysis of the proteases based on the complete specificity profile provided a functional characterization distinct from standard sequence analysis. This approach provides useful information for developing selective chemical probes to study protease-related pathologies and physiologies.     

Protein kinase C-alpha and -delta are required for NADPH oxidase activation in WKYMVm-stimulated IMR90 human fibroblasts

Gene duplications in rodents have given rise to a family of proteases that are expressed exclusively in placenta. To define the biological role of these enzymes specific inhibitors are needed to differentiate their activities from other more ubiquitously expressed proteases, such as cathepsins B and L. Libraries of peptidyl inhibitors based upon a 4-cyclohexanone pharmacophore were screened for inhibition of cathepsins P, L, and B. The tightest binding dipeptidyl inhibitor for cathepsin P contained Tyr in P(2) and Trp in P(2)('), consistent with the specificity of this enzyme for hydrophobic amino acids at these sites in synthetic substrates. An inhibitor containing Trp in both P(2) and P(2)(') provided better discrimination between cathepsin P and cathepsins B and L. Extension of the inhibitors to include P(3), and P(3)(') amino acids identified an inhibitor with Trp in P(2), P(2)('), and P(3), and Phe in P(3)(') that bound to cathepsin P with a K(i) of 32 nM. This specificity for inhibitors with hydrophobic aromatic amino acids in these four positions is unique among the lysosomal cysteine proteases. This inhibitor bound to cathepsin P an order of magnitude tighter than to mouse and human cathepsin L and two orders of magnitude tighter than to human cathepsin B. Cbz-Trp-Trp-4-cyclohexanone-Trp-Phe-OMe can discriminate cathepsin P from cathepsins B and L and consequently can be used to specifically inhibit and identify cathepsin P in cellular systems.     

Human leukocyte cathepsin G. Subsite mapping with 4-nitroanilides, chemical modification, and effect of possible cofactors

The extended substrate binding site of cathepsin G from human leukocytes has been mapped by using a series of peptide 4-nitroanilide substrates. The enzyme has a significant preference for substrates with a P1 Phe over those with the other aromatic amino acids Tyr and Trp. The S2 subsite was mapped with the substrates Suc-Phe-AA-Phe-NA where AA was 13 of the 20 amino acid residues commonly found in proteins. The best residues were Pro and Met. The S3 subsite was mapped with the sequence Suc-AA-Pro-Phe-NA by using 14 different amino acid residues for AA. The two best residues were the isosteric Val and Thr. No significant improvement in reactivity was obtained by extending the substrate to include seven different P4 residues. The kinetic parameters for cathepsin G are significantly slower than those for many other serine proteases. Changes in the reaction conditions and addition of possible cofactors or ligands were in general found to have little effect on the enzymatic activity, while chemical modifications and proteolysis destroyed the activity of cathepsin G. Cathepsin G hydrolyzed peptides containing model desmosine residues and prefers the hydrophobic picolinoyllysine derivative over lysine by substantial margins at both the S4 and S2 subsites but will not tolerate it at S3. Substrates with sequences related to the cathepsin G cleavage site in angiotensin I and angiotensinogen, and the reactive site of alpha 1-antichymotrypsin, were hydrolyzed effectively by enzyme, but with unexceptional rates. Our results indicate that the natural substrate(s) and function(s) of cathepsin G still remain to be discovered.     

Rodent alpha-chymases are elastase-like proteases.

Although the alpha-chymases of primates and dogs are known as chymotrypsin-like proteases, the enzymatic properties of rodent alpha-chymases (rat mast cell protease 5/rMCP-5 and mouse mast cell protease 5/mMCP-5) have not been fully understood. We report that recombinant rMCP-5 and mMCP-5 are elastase-like proteases, not chymotrypsin-like proteases. An enzyme assay using chromogenic peptidyl substrates showed that mast cell protease-5s (MCP-5s) have a clear preference for small aliphatic amino acids (e.g. alanine, isoleucine, valine) in the P1 site of substrates. We used site-directed mutagenesis and computer modeling approaches to define the determinant residue for the substrate specificity of mMCP-5, and found that the mutant possessing a Gly substitution of the Val at position 216 (V216G) lost elastase-like activity but acquired chymase activity, suggesting that the Val216 dominantly restricts the substrate specificity of mMCP-5. Structural models of mMCP-5 and the V216G mutant based on the crystal structures of serine proteases (rMCP-2, human cathepsin G, and human chymase) revealed the active site differences that can account for the marked differences in substrate specificity of the two enzymes between elastase and chymase. These findings suggest that rodent alpha-chymases have unique biological activity different from the chymases of other species.     

Internally quenched fluorescent peptide libraries with randomized sequences designed to detect endopeptidases

Identification of synthetic peptide substrates for novel peptidases is an essential step for their study. With this purpose we synthesized fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) peptide libraries Abz (or MCA)-GXXXXXQ-EDDnp and Abz (or MCA)-GXXZXXQ-EDDnp, where X consists of an equimolar mixture of all amino acids, the Z position is fixed with one of the proteinogenic amino acids (cysteine was excluded), Abz (ortho-aminobenzoic acid) or MCA ([7-amino-4-methyl]coumarin) is the fluorescence donor and Q-EDDnp (glutamine-[N-(2,4-dinitrophenyl)-ethylenediamine]) is the fluorescence acceptor. The peptide libraries MCA-GXXX↓XXQ-EDDnp and MCA-GXXZ↓XXQ-EDDnp were cleaved as indicated (↓) by trypsin, chymotrypsin, cathepsin L, pepsin A, and Eqolisin as confirmed by Edman degradation of the products derived from the digestion of these libraries. The best hydrolyzed Abz-GXXZXXQ-EDDnp sublibraries by these proteases, including Dengue 2 virus NS2B-NS3 protease, contained amino acids at the Z position that are reported to be well accepted by their S(1) subsite. The pH profiles of the hydrolytic activities of these canonical proteases on the libraries were similar to those reported for typical substrates. The FRET peptide libraries provide an efficient and simple approach for detecting nanomolar concentrations of endopeptidases and are useful for initial specificity characterization as performed for two proteases secreted by a Bacillus subtilis.     

The S2 subsites of cathepsins K and L and their contribution to collagen degradation

The exchange of residues 67 and 205 of the S2 pocket of human cysteine cathepsins K and L induces a permutation of their substrate specificity toward fluorogenic peptide substrates. While the cathepsin L-like cathepsin K (Tyr67Leu/Leu205Ala) mutant has a marked preference for Phe, the Leu67Tyr/Ala205Leu cathepsin L variant shows an effective cathepsin K-like preference for Leu and Pro. A similar turnaround of inhibition was observed by using specific inhibitors of cathepsin K [1-(N-Benzyloxycarbonyl-leucyl)-5-(N-Boc-phenylalanyl-leucyl)carbohydrazide] and cathepsin L [N-(4-biphenylacetyl)-S-methylcysteine-(D)-Arg-Phe-beta-phenethylamide]. Molecular modeling studies indicated that mutations alter the character of both S2 and S3 subsites, while docking calculations were consistent with kinetics data. The cathepsin K-like cathepsin L was unable to mimic the collagen-degrading activity of cathepsin K against collagens I and II, DQ-collagens I and IV, and elastin-Congo Red. In summary, double mutations of the S2 pocket of cathepsins K (Y67L/L205A) and L (L67Y/A205L) induce a switch of their enzymatic specificity toward small selective inhibitors and peptidyl substrates, confirming the key role of residues 67 and 205. However, mutations in the S2 subsite pocket of cathepsin L alone without engineering of binding sites to chondroitin sulfate are not sufficient to generate a cathepsin K-like collagenase, emphasizing the pivotal role of the complex formation between glycosaminoglycans and cathepsin K for its unique collagenolytic activity.     

Species differences between human and rat in the substrate specificity of cathepsin K

Cathepsin K is known to play an important role in bone resorption, and it has the P2 specificity for proline. Rat cathepsin K has 88% identity with the human enzyme. However, it has been reported that its enzymatic activity for a Cbz-Leu-Arg-MCA substrate is lower than that of human cathepsin K, and that the rat enzyme is not well inhibited by human cathepsin K inhibitors. For this study, we prepared recombinant enzyme to investigate the substrate specificity of rat cathepsin K. Cleavage experiments using the fragment of type I collagen and peptidic libraries demonstrated that rat cathepsin K preferentially hydrolyses the substrates at the P2 Hyp position. Comparison of the S2 site between rat and human cathepsin K sequences indicated that two S2 residues at Ser134 and Val160 in rat are varied to Ala and Leu, respectively, in the human enzyme. Cleavage experiments using two single mutants, S134A and V160L, and one double mutant, S134A/V160L, of rat cathepsin K showed that all the rat mutants lost the P2 Hyp specificity. The information obtained from our comparative studies on rat and human cathepsin K should make a significant impact on developing specific inhibitors of human cathepsin K since rat is usually used as test species.     

HIV-1 Protease Uses Bi-Specific S2/S2′ Subsites to Optimize Cleavage of Two Classes of Target Sites

Retroviral proteases (PRs) have a unique specificity that allows cleavage of sites with or without a P1′ proline. A P1′ proline is required at the MA/CA cleavage site due to its role in a post-cleavage conformational change in the capsid protein. However, the HIV-1 PR prefers to have large hydrophobic amino acids flanking the scissile bond, suggesting that PR recognizes two different classes of substrate sequences. We analyzed the cleavage rate of over 150 combinations of six different HIV-1 cleavage sites to explore rate determinants of cleavage. We found that cleavage rates are strongly influenced by the two amino acids flanking the amino acids at the scissile bond (P2–P1/P1′–P2′), with two complementary sets of rules. When P1′ is proline, the P2 side chain interacts with a polar region in the S2 subsite of the PR, while the P2′ amino acid interacts with a hydrophobic region of the S2′ subsite. When P1′ is not proline, the orientations of the P2 and P2′ side chains with respect to the scissile bond are reversed; P2 residues interact with a hydrophobic face of the S2 subsite, while the P2′ amino acid usually engages hydrophilic amino acids in the S2′ subsite. These results reveal that the HIV-1 PR has evolved bi-functional S2 and S2′ subsites to accommodate the steric effects imposed by a P1′ proline on the orientation of P2 and P2′ substrate side chains. These results also suggest a new strategy for inhibitor design to engage the multiple specificities in these subsites.