Morphogenesis of insect-induced plant galls: facts and questions

Insect-induced galls (‘galls’ hereafter) represent highly regulated growth manifestations on plants. They present unique geometrical forms, which are, usually, unknown in the normal plant system. Galls are the best examples for modified natural structures that arise solely because of messages from an alien organism - the insect. Galls develop as an extension of the host-plant phenotype. But how the physiological networks and signal-activated subsystems work in coordination in expressing galls that serve the nutritional and shelter needs of the inducing insect are unclear. In galls and bacteria-induced tumors, the basic developmental events are essentially similar. However, tightly regulated specific differentiation processes occur in galls, making them different from tumors. Moreover variations in differentiation patterns occur in galls induced by insects of different taxonomic groups. While providing an overview of the control of shape and structure in galls, this article identifies the unanswered questions in gall morphogenesis.By analyzing the recognizable steps in gall morphogenesis, viz., gall initiation, stimulus recognition in host plants, signal transduction in host plants, growth of galls, and qualitative differentiation in galls, I have indicated that the insect saliva flushed on the wounded plant site alters the subcellular environment of cells and thus places it in a state of chemical shock. This shock induces osmotic changes, which establishes the first recognizable stage in gall induction. To repair the wound and neutralize the osmotic-change induced stress, the plant responds by establishing from one to a few metaplasied cell(s). Localized metabolic changes spread, from these cells, not throughout the involved plant organ, but in a limited manner around the immediate site of insect occurrence. When the shock is of low intensity, the plant responds with the development of one or more metaplasied cell(s) and gall development starts; when the shock factor is of high intensity, the cells under the insect action die, rejecting the inducing insect, defending plant tissue. These changes dictate the new morphogenetic events. Insects feed on gall tissue continuously for a specific period (synchronizing with their life history) and therefore, the osmotic-change related stress prevails for that span of time, which in turn triggers a sequence of plant-mediated changes including synthesis of growth promotors. Osmotic stress affects electrical properties of the plasma membrane and impacts on IAA activity, which in turn, alters H⁺-transport systems. During the physical action of insect feeding, the host-cell wall breaks down, and the degenerated wall materials act as elicitors.Using galls (e.g., ‘cecidial shoots’ on leaves, modified vegetative buds) induced on species of south and south-east Asian Dipterocarpaceae by different Beesoniidae (Coccoidea) as model complexity in gall morphogenesis is discussed. Manipulatory experimental studies done on the regeneration of epiphyllous buds on Pteridium, Begonia, and a Helianthus hybrid indicate that insect-induced neoplasmic shoots that arise on the leaves of tropical Dipterocarpaceae fall into the morphogenetic regulation of leaf, yet maintaining their freedom of differentiation. Even though a gall is a part of the plant - a multicellular organism made of the same genetic material - organismal development generates a range of cell types with dictated functions fitting into of Waddington's epigenetic-landscape model. As of today, our knowledge stops here.Plants as living systems display different strategies to mitigate and neutralize stress. Although these strategies exist in their genetic constitution, they are mediated by complex molecular interactions. Plants have a flexible short-term strategy to respond to stress; organisms that can modify gene expression reversibly have an advantage in evolutionary terms, since they can avoid rearrangements and species diversification. Mechanisms of DNA methylation and histone modifications possibly regulate inheritance of stress ‘memories’. Inherited genetic traits also play a role in gall morphogenesis, followed by roles played by correlating morphogenetic factors. An articulated reconstruction of the developmental process commencing from either one or a group of metaplasied cells that gets transmitted through subsequent growth promoter-mediated cell expansion, until the commitment of the metaplastic cell and those in its neighbourhood enabling the start of ‘novel’ cell-cycle patterns, cell multiplication, programmed differentiation, and control is needed to explain symmetry - a morphogenetic phenomenon that makes the insect-induced galls distinct from the bacteria-induced tumors.     

Epigenetic control of cell specification during female gametogenesis

In flowering plants, the formation of gametes depends on the differentiation of cellular precursors that divide meiotically before giving rise to a multicellular gametophyte. The establishment of this gametophytic phase presents an opportunity for natural selection to act on the haploid plant genome by means of epigenetic mechanisms that ensure a tight regulation of plant reproductive development. Despite this early acting selective pressure, there are numerous examples of naturally occurring developmental alternatives that suggest a flexible regulatory control of cell specification and subsequent gamete formation in flowering plants. In this review, we discuss recent findings indicating that epigenetic mechanisms related to the activity of small RNA pathways prevailing during ovule formation play an essential role in cell specification and genome integrity. We also compare these findings to small RNA pathways acting during gametogenesis in animals and discuss their implications for the understanding of the mechanisms that control the establishment of the female gametophytic lineage during both sexual reproduction and apomixis.     

Functional aspects of cell patterning in aerial epidermis

Plants have evolved epidermal cells that have specialized functions as adaptations to life on land. Many of the functions of these specialized cells are dependent, to a significant extent, on their arrangement within the aerial epidermis. Considerable progress has been made over the past two years in understanding the patterning mechanisms of trichomes and stomata in Arabidopsis leaves at the molecular level. How universal are these patterning programmes, and how are they adjusted to meet the changing functions of specialized epidermal cells in different plant organs? In this review, we compare the patterning of stomata and trichomes in different plant species, describe environmental and developmental factors that alter cell patterning, and discuss how changes in patterning might relate to cell function. Patterning is an important aspect to the functioning of aerial epidermal cells, and a greater understanding of the processes that are involved will significantly enhance our understanding of how cellular activities are integrated in multicellular plants.     

PIN polarity maintenance by the cell wall in Arabidopsis

A central question in developmental biology concerns the mechanism of generation and maintenance of cell polarity, because these processes are essential for many cellular functions and multicellular development. In plants, cell polarity has an additional role in mediating directional transport of the plant hormone auxin that is crucial for multiple developmental processes. In addition, plant cells have a complex extracellular matrix, the cell wall, whose role in regulating cellular processes, including cell polarity, is unexplored. We have found that polar distribution of PIN auxin transporters in plant cells is maintained by connections between polar domains at the plasma membrane and the cell wall. Genetic and pharmacological interference with cellulose, the major component of the cell wall, or mechanical interference with the cell wall disrupts these connections and leads to increased lateral diffusion and loss of polar distribution of PIN transporters for the phytohormone auxin. Our results reveal a plant-specific mechanism for cell polarity maintenance and provide a conceptual framework for modulating cell polarity and plant development via endogenous and environmental manipulations of the cellulose-based extracellular matrix.     

Involvement of auxin and a homeodomain-leucine zipper I gene in rhizoid development of the moss Physcomitrella patens

Differentiation of epidermal cells is important for plants because they are in direct contact with the environment. Rhizoids are multicellular filaments that develop from the epidermis in a wide range of plants, including pteridophytes, bryophytes, and green algae; they have similar functions to root hairs in vascular plants in that they support the plant body and are involved in water and nutrient absorption. In this study, we examined mechanisms underlying rhizoid development in the moss, Physcomitrella patens, which is the only land plant in which high-frequency gene targeting is possible. We found that rhizoid development can be split into two processes: determination and differentiation. Two types of rhizoids with distinct developmental patterns (basal and mid-stem rhizoids) were recognized. The development of basal rhizoids from epidermal cells was induced by exogenous auxin, while that of mid-stem rhizoids required an unknown factor in addition to exogenous auxin. Once an epidermal cell had acquired a rhizoid initial cell fate, expression of the homeodomain-leucine zipper I gene Pphb7 was induced. Analysis of Pphb7 disruptant lines showed that Pphb7 affects the induction of pigmentation and the increase in the number and size of chloroplasts, but not the position or number of rhizoids. This is the first report on the involvement of a homeodomain-leucine zipper I gene in epidermal cell differentiation.     

Reproductive competence: a recurrent logic module in eukaryotic development

Developmental competence is the ability to differentiate in response to an appropriate stimulus, as first elaborated by Waddington in relation to organs and tissues. Competence thresholds operate at all levels of biological systems from the molecular (e.g. the cell cycle) to the ontological (e.g. metamorphosis and reproduction). Reproductive competence, an organismal process, is well studied in mammals (sexual maturity) and plants (vegetative phase change), though far less than later stages of terminal differentiation. The phenomenon has also been documented in multiple species of multicellular fungi, mostly in early, disparate literature, providing a clear example of physiological differentiation in the absence of morphological change. This review brings together data on reproductive competence in Ascomycete fungi, particularly the model filamentous fungus Aspergillus nidulans, contrasting mechanisms within Unikonts and plants. We posit reproductive competence is an elementary logic module necessary for coordinated development of multicellular organisms or functional units. This includes unitary multicellular life as well as colonial species both unicellular and multicellular (e.g. social insects such as ants). We discuss adaptive hypotheses for developmental and reproductive competence systems and suggest experimental work to address the evolutionary origins, generality and genetic basis of competence in the fungal kingdom.     

Morphological evolution in land plants: new designs with old genes

The colonization and radiation of multicellular plants on land that started over 470 Ma was one of the defining events in the history of this planet. For the first time, large amounts of primary productivity occurred on the continental surface, paving the way for the evolution of complex terrestrial ecosystems and altering global biogeochemical cycles; increased weathering of continental silicates and organic carbon burial resulted in a 90 per cent reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide levels. The evolution of plants on land was itself characterized by a series of radical transformations of their body plans that included the formation of three-dimensional tissues, de novo evolution of a multicellular diploid sporophyte generation, evolution of multicellular meristems, and the development of specialized tissues and organ systems such as vasculature, roots, leaves, seeds and flowers. In this review, we discuss the evolution of the genes and developmental mechanisms that drove the explosion of plant morphologies on land. Recent studies indicate that many of the gene families which control development in extant plants were already present in the earliest land plants. This suggests that the evolution of novel morphologies was to a large degree driven by the reassembly and reuse of pre-existing genetic mechanisms.     

Algal-CAMs: isoforms of a cell adhesion molecule in embryos of the alga Volvox with homology to Drosophila fasciclin I.

Proof that plants possess homologs of animal adhesion proteins is lacking. In this paper we describe the generation of monoclonal antibodies that interfere with cell-cell contacts in the 4-cell embryo of the multicellular alga Volvox carteri, resulting in a hole between the cells. The number of following cell divisions is reduced and the cell division pattern is altered drastically. Antibodies given at a later stage of embryogenesis specifically inhibit inversion of the embryo, a morphogenetic movement that turns the embryo inside out. Immunofluorescence microscopy localizes the antigen (Algal-CAM) at cell contact sites of the developing embryo. Algal-CAM is a protein with a three-domain structure: an N-terminal extensin-like domain characteristic for plant cell walls and two repeats with homology to fasciclin I, a cell adhesion molecule involved in the neuronal development of Drosophila. Alternatively spliced variants of Algal-CAM mRNA were detected that are produced under developmental control. Thus, Algal-CAM is the first plant homolog of animal adhesion proteins.     

Cytomechanical control of morphogenesis

The role of mechanically strained state of cells and multicellular structures in morphogenesis regulating in vertebrate embryos is discussed. Regular changes in patterns of mechanical strain during embryonic development are described. Artificial relaxation of mechanical strain performed on definite developmental stages and retension of embryonic tissues in arbitrary directions considerably affects morphogenesis and cell differentiation patterns. Cytomechanical models of morphogenesis are reviewed and a concept of hyperrestoration of mechanical strain as a possible driving force of morphogeneiss is suggested.     

Control of the cell cycle.

Cell division is arguably the most fundamental developmental process for single-celled and multicellular organisms alike. The pathway from one cell division to the next is known as the cell cycle. A conserved biochemical regulatory network controls progress along this pathway in plants, animals, and yeasts. This review is intended to serve as a primer on the current state of the eukaryotic cell cycle regulatory model, an introduction to the special roles of cell division and its control in plant development, and a review of recent progress in applying the universal mitotic control paradigm to higher plant systems.     

ETOILE regulates developmental patterning in the filamentous brown alga Ectocarpus siliculosus

Brown algae are multicellular marine organisms evolutionarily distant from both metazoans and land plants. The molecular or cellular mechanisms that govern the developmental patterning in brown algae are poorly characterized. Here, we report the first morphogenetic mutant, étoile (etl), produced in the brown algal model Ectocarpus siliculosus. Genetic, cellular, and morphometric analyses showed that a single recessive locus, ETL, regulates cell differentiation: etl cells display thickening of the extracellular matrix (ECM), and the elongated, apical, and actively dividing E cells are underrepresented. As a result of this defect, the overrepresentation of round, branch-initiating R cells in the etl mutant leads to the rapid induction of the branching process at the expense of the uniaxial growth in the primary filament. Computational modeling allowed the simulation of the etl mutant phenotype by including a modified response to the neighborhood information in the division rules used to specify wild-type development. Microarray experiments supported the hypothesis of a defect in cell-cell communication, as primarily Lin-Notch-domain transmembrane proteins, which share similarities with metazoan Notch proteins involved in binary cell differentiation were repressed in etl. Thus, our study highlights the role of the ECM and of novel transmembrane proteins in cell-cell communication during the establishment of the developmental pattern in this brown alga.     

Acidic cell elongation drives cell differentiation in the Arabidopsis root

In multicellular systems, the control of cell size is fundamental in regulating the development and growth of the different organs and of the whole organism. In most systems, major changes in cell size can be observed during differentiation processes where cells change their volume to adapt their shape to their final function. How relevant changes in cell volume are in driving the differentiation program is a long‐standing fundamental question in developmental biology. In the Arabidopsis root meristem, characteristic changes in the size of the distal meristematic cells identify cells that initiated the differentiation program. Here, we show that changes in cell size are essential for the initial steps of cell differentiation and that these changes depend on the concomitant activation by the plant hormone cytokinin of the EXPAs proteins and the AHA1 and AHA2 proton pumps. These findings identify a growth module that builds on a synergy between cytokinin‐dependent pH modification and wall remodeling to drive differentiation through the mechanical control of cell walls.     

Stress relaxation property of the cell wall and auxin-induced cell elongation

A stress-relaxation method has been developed to measure the mechanical property of the plant cell wall, as a physically defined terms. In the method, the stress relaxation property of the cell wall is simulated with a Maxwell viscoelastic model whose character is represented by four parameters; the minimum relaxation time, To, the relaxation rate, b, the maximum relaxation time, Tm and the residual stress, c. Thus, the mechanical property of the cell wall is represented by the four parameters. Physical and physiological meanings of the parameters are discussed. Auxin effects on the parameters were also studied. The cell elongation is simply thought to be extension of the cell wall under a force. The extension of the cell wall can be simulated by the mechanical property of the cell wall. However, the calculated extension was found to be incomparable to the real cell growth, indicating that there has to be other factors limiting the rate of cell growth. Major factors governing cell growth are discussed to be the cell wall mechanical property, the osmotic potential and water movement in the apoplast. A possibility to predict cell expansion with the three factors was discussed and a novel equation representing cell growth was obtained: $$1/R = 1/R_w + 1/R_p $$ whereR is the rate of cell elongation,R _w is the rate of cell wall extension due to the osmotic pressure andR _p is the rate of cell elongation determined by water conductivity.     

Influence of arbuscular mycorrhiza on growth and reproductive response of plants under water deficit: a meta-analysis

Despite a large body of literature that describes the effects of arbuscular mycorrhizal colonization on plant response to water deficit, reviews of these works have been mainly in narrative form, and it is therefore difficult to quantify the magnitude of the effect. We performed a meta-analysis to examine the effect of mycorrhizal colonization on growth and yield of plants exposed to water deficit stress. Data were compared in the context of annual vs. perennial plants, herbaceous vs. woody plants, field vs. greenhouse conditions, degree of stress, functional group, regions of plant growth, and mycorrhizal and host species. We found that, in terms of biomass measurements, mycorrhizal plants have better growth and reproductive response under water stress compared to non-mycorrhizal plants. When variables such as habit, life cycle, or water stress level are considered, differences in mycorrhizal effect on plant growth between variables are observed. While growth of both annual and perennial plants is improved by symbiosis, perennials respond more favorably to colonization than annuals. Overall, our meta-analysis reveals a quantifiable corroboration of the commonly held view that, under water-deficit conditions, plants colonized by mycorrhizal fungi have better growth and reproductive response than those that are not.     

Plant glycoside hydrolases involved in cell wall polysaccharide degradation.

The cell wall plays a key role in controlling the size and shape of the plant cell during plant development and in the interactions of the plant with its environment. The cell wall structure is complex and contains various components such as polysaccharides, lignin and proteins whose composition and concentration change during plant development and growth. Many studies have revealed changes in cell walls which occur during cell division, expansion, and differentiation and in response to environmental stresses; i.e. pathogens or mechanical stress. Although many proteins and enzymes are necessary for the control of cell wall organization, little information is available concerning them. An important advance was made recently concerning cell wall organization as plant enzymes that belong to the superfamily of glycoside hydrolases and transglycosidases were identified and characterized; these enzymes are involved in the degradation of cell wall polysaccharides. Glycoside hydrolases have been characterized using molecular, genetic and biochemical approaches. Many genes encoding these enzymes have been identified and functional analysis of some of them has been performed. This review summarizes our current knowledge about plant glycoside hydrolases that participate in the degradation and reorganisation of cell wall polysaccharides in plants focussing particularly on those from Arabidopsis thaliana.     

Changes in cell wall biomechanical properties in the xyloglucan-deficient xxt1/xxt2 mutant of Arabidopsis

The main load-bearing network in the primary cell wall of most land plants is commonly depicted as a scaffold of cellulose microfibrils tethered by xyloglucans. However, a xyloglucan-deficient mutant (xylosyltransferase1/xylosyltransferase2 [xxt1/xxt2]) was recently developed that was smaller than the wild type but otherwise nearly normal in its development, casting doubt on xyloglucan's role in wall structure. To assess xyloglucan function in the Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) wall, we compared the behavior of petiole cell walls from xxt1/xxt2 and wild-type plants using creep, stress relaxation, and stress/strain assays, in combination with reagents that cut or solubilize specific components of the wall matrix. Stress/strain assays showed xxt1/xxt2 walls to be more extensible than wild-type walls (supporting a reinforcing role for xyloglucan) but less extensible in creep and stress relaxation processes mediated by α-expansin. Fusicoccin-induced "acid growth" was likewise reduced in xxt1/xxt2 petioles. The results show that xyloglucan is important for wall loosening by α-expansin, and the smaller size of the xxt1/xxt2 mutant may stem from the reduced effectiveness of α-expansins in the absence of xyloglucan. Loosening agents that act on xylans and pectins elicited greater extension in creep assays of xxt1/xxt2 cell walls compared with wild-type walls, consistent with a larger mechanical role for these matrix polymers in the absence of xyloglucan. Our results illustrate the need for multiple biomechanical assays to evaluate wall properties and indicate that the common depiction of a cellulose-xyloglucan network as the major load-bearing structure is in need of revision.