Arresting pore formation of a cholesterol-dependent cytolysin by disulfide trapping synchronizes the insertion of the transmembrane beta-sheet from a prepore intermediate

Perfringolysin O (PFO), a member of the cholesterol-dependent cytolysin family of pore-forming toxins, forms large oligomeric complexes comprising up to 50 monomers. In the present study, a disulfide bridge was introduced between cysteine-substituted serine 190 of transmembrane hairpin 1 (TMH1) and cysteine-substituted glycine 57 of domain 2 of PFO. The resulting disulfide-trapped mutant (PFO(C190-C57)) was devoid of hemolytic activity and could not insert either of its transmembrane beta-hairpins (TMHs) into the membrane unless the disulfide was reduced. Both the size of the oligomer formed on the membrane and its rate of formation were unaffected by the oxidation state of the Cys(190)-Cys(57) disulfide bond; thus, the disulfide-trapped PFO was assembled into a prepore complex on the membrane. The conversion of this prepore to the pore complex was achieved by reducing the C190-C57 disulfide bond. PFO(C190-C57) that was allowed to form the prepore prior to the reduction of the disulfide exhibited a dramatic increase in the rate of PFO-dependent hemolysis and the membrane insertion of its TMHs when compared with toxin that had the disulfide reduced prior mixing the toxin with membranes. Therefore, the rate-limiting step in pore formation is prepore assembly, not TMH insertion. These data demonstrate that the prepore is a legitimate intermediate during the insertion of the large transmembrane beta-sheet of the PFO oligomer. Finally, the PFO TMHs do not appear to insert independently, but instead their insertion is coupled.     

Staphylococcal alpha-toxin: a study of membrane penetration and pore formation

Cell lysis by staphylococcal alpha-toxin, a potent virulence factor of most pathogenic strains of Staphylococcus aureus, follows a three-step sequence: binding of toxin to the membrane, leaking of ions caused by membrane injury, and rupturing of the membrane caused by osmotic swelling. The membrane injury step is composed of two separate events, membrane penetration and membrane perturbation. The membrane penetration event involves conversion of the soluble toxin monomer into an amphipathic molecule, which inserts into the lipid bilayer of the membrane. The membrane perturbation event involves association of the toxin monomers, in the plane of the membrane, to form hexameric transmembrane pores. In this study, we demonstrate that, in an asolectin liposome system, controlling the pH of the external buffer permits these two events to be temporally resolved. Using Controlled-Pore Glass bead-purified alpha-toxin, four events are measured as a function of pH: (a) release of potassium from prelabeled asolectin vesicles, (b) conversion of the toxin to a globally hydrophobic molecule, (c) binding of detergent by the toxin, and (d) labeling of the toxin with photoactivable, radiolabeled, hydrophobic probes. Two of these events, potassium release and conversion to a net hydrophobic state, are paired in that, for the event to occur, each requires a pH of 4.6 or less. In contrast, photolabeling with the membrane probes PC I and PC II (where PC represents phosphatidylcholine) is easily detectable at pH values as high as 5.0 and 6.0. These results demonstrate that, as the pH is lowered, two distinct changes in the physical properties of alpha-toxin occur. The first, which occurs under mild acidic conditions, converts the toxin from a water-soluble molecule into an amphipathic molecule. The second, requiring relatively more acidic conditions, converts the amphipathic toxin molecule into a globally hydrophobic molecule. Correlated with these physical changes in the alpha-toxin molecule is the acquisition of two new biological properties. The conversion of alpha-toxin into an amphipathic conformation correlates with the acquisition of the biological property of the reversible penetration into the bilayer of the asolectin liposome membrane, as evidenced by labeling with the photoactivable probes. At lower pH, the conversion of the toxin into a globally hydrophobic molecule correlates with the biological property of causing damage to the cell membrane, as measured by the release of internal potassium ions, presumably by the formation of transmembrane hexamer pores.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Structural basis of pore formation by the bacterial toxin pneumolysin

The bacterial toxin pneumolysin is released as a soluble monomer that kills target cells by assembling into large oligomeric rings and forming pores in cholesterol-containing membranes. Using cryo-EM and image processing, we have determined the structures of membrane-surface bound (prepore) and inserted-pore oligomer forms, providing a direct observation of the conformational transition into the pore form of a cholesterol-dependent cytolysin. In the pore structure, the domains of the monomer separate and double over into an arch, forming a wall sealing the bilayer around the pore. This transformation is accomplished by substantial refolding of two of the four protein domains along with deformation of the membrane. Extension of protein density into the bilayer supports earlier predictions that the protein inserts beta hairpins into the membrane. With an oligomer size of up to 44 subunits in the pore, this assembly creates a transmembrane channel 260 A in diameter lined by 176 beta strands.     

The mechanism of pore assembly for a cholesterol-dependent cytolysin: formation of a large prepore complex precedes the insertion of the transmembrane beta-hairpins

Perfringolysin O (PFO) is a member of the cholesterol-dependent cytolysin (CDC) family of membrane-penetrating toxins. The CDCs form large homooligomers (estimated to be comprised of up to 50 CDC monomers) that are responsible for generating a large pore in cholesterol-containing membranes of eukaryotic cells. The assembly of the PFO cytolytic complex was examined to determine whether it forms an oligomeric prepore complex on the membrane prior to the insertion of its membrane-spanning beta-sheet. A PFO oligomeric complex was formed on liposomes at both 4 degrees C and 37 degrees C and shown by SDS-agarose gel electrophoresis to be comprised of a large, comparatively homogeneous complex instead of a distribution of oligomer sizes. At low temperature, the processes of oligomerization and membrane insertion could be resolved, and PFO was found to form an oligomer without significant membrane insertion of its beta-hairpins. Furthermore, PFO was found to increase the ion conductivity through a planar bilayer by large and discrete stepwise changes in conductance that are consistent with the insertion of a preassembled pore complex into the bilayer. The combined results of these analyses strongly support the hypothesis that PFO forms a large oligomeric prepore complex on the membrane surface prior to the insertion of its transmembrane beta-sheet.     

Conformational changes that effect oligomerization and initiate pore formation are triggered throughout perfringolysin O upon binding to cholesterol

Pore formation by the cholesterol-dependent cytolysins (CDCs) requires the presence of cholesterol in the target membrane. Cholesterol was long thought to be the cellular receptor for these toxins, but not all CDCs require cholesterol for binding. Intermedilysin, secreted by Streptococcus intermedius, only binds to membranes containing the human protein CD59 but forms pores only if the membrane contains sufficient cholesterol. In contrast, perfringolysin O (PFO), secreted by Clostridium perfringens, only binds to membranes containing substantial amounts of cholesterol. Given that different steps in the assembly of various CDC pores require cholesterol, here we have analyzed to what extent cholesterol molecules, by themselves, can modulate the conformational changes associated with PFO oligomerization and pore formation. PFO binds to cholesterol when dispersed in aqueous solution, and this binding triggers the distant rearrangement of a beta-strand that exposes an oligomerization interface. Moreover, upon binding to cholesterol, PFO forms a prepore complex, unfolds two amphipathic transmembrane beta-hairpins, and positions their nonpolar surfaces so they associate with the hydrophobic cholesterol surface. The interaction of PFO with cholesterol is therefore sufficient to initiate an irreversible sequence of coupled conformational changes that extend throughout the toxin molecule.     

Structural insights into the membrane-anchoring mechanism of a cholesterol-dependent cytolysin

Perfringolysin O (PFO), a cytolytic toxin secreted by pathogenic Clostridium perfringens, forms large pores in cholesterol-containing membranes. Domain 4 (D4) of the protein interacts first with the membrane and is responsible for cholesterol recognition. By using several independent fluorescence techniques, we have determined the topography of D4 in the membrane-inserted oligomeric form of the toxin. Only the short hydrophobic loops at the tip of the D4 beta-sandwich are exposed to the bilayer interior, whereas the remainder of D4 projects from the membrane surface and is surrounded by water, making little or no contact with adjacent protein monomers in the oligomer. Thus, a limited interaction of D4 with the bilayer core seems to be sufficient to accomplish cholesterol recognition and initial binding of PFO to the membrane. Furthermore, D4 serves as the fulcrum around which extensive structural changes occur during the formation and insertion of the large transmembrane beta-barrel into the bilayer.     

A dominant negative mutant of Bacillus anthracis protective antigen inhibits anthrax toxin action in vivo

PA63, a proteolytically activated 63-kDa form of anthrax protective antigen (PA), forms heptameric oligomers and has the ability to bind and translocate the catalytic moieties, lethal factor (LF), and edema factor (EF) into the cytosol of mammalian cells. Acidic pH triggers oligomerization and membrane insertion by PA63. A disordered amphipathic loop in domain II of PA (2beta2-2beta3 loop) is involved in membrane insertion by PA63. Because conditions required for membrane insertion coincide with those for oligomerization of PA63 in mammalian cells, residues constituting the 2beta2-2beta3 loop were replaced with the residues of the amphipathic membrane-inserting loop of its homologue iota-b toxin secreted by Clostridium perfringens. It was hypothesized that such a molecule might assemble into hetero-heptameric structures with wild-type PA ultimately leading to the inhibition of cellular intoxication. The mutation blocked the ability of PA to mediate membrane insertion and translocation of LF into the cytosol but had no effect on proteolytic activation, oligomerization, or binding LF. Moreover, an equimolar mixture of purified mutant PA (PA-I) and wild-type PA showed complete inhibition of toxin activity both in vitro on J774A.1 cells and in vivo in Fischer 344 rats thereby exhibiting a dominant negative effect. In addition, PA-I inhibited the channel-forming ability of wild-type PA on the plasma membrane of CHO-K1 cells thereby indicating protein-protein interactions between the two proteins resulting in the formation of mixed oligomers with defective functional activity. Our findings provide a basis for understanding the mechanism of translocation and exploring the possibility of the use of this PA molecule as a therapeutic agent against anthrax toxin action in vivo.     

Structures of perfringolysin O suggest a pathway for activation of cholesterol-dependent cytolysins

Cholesterol-dependent cytolysins (CDCs), a large family of bacterial toxins, are secreted as water-soluble monomers and yet are capable of generating oligomeric pores in membranes. Previous work has demonstrated that large scale structural rearrangements occur during this transition but the detailed mechanism by which these changes take place remains a puzzle. Despite evidence of structural and functional couplings between domains 3 and 4, the crystal structure of the CDC, perfringolysin O (PFO), shows the two domains do not make direct contact. Here, we present crystal structures of PFO that demonstrate movements of domain 4 are sufficient to trigger conformational changes that are transmitted through the molecule to the distant domain 3. These coupled movements result in a loss of many contacts between domain 3 and rest of the molecule that would eventually lead to the exposure of transmembrane regions in preparation for membrane insertion. The structures reveal a detailed molecular pathway that may be the basis for the allosteric transition that occurs on initial membrane binding leading to the exposure of membrane-spanning regions in a domain distant from the initial site of interaction.     

Flexible programs for the prediction of average amphipathicity of multiply aligned homologous proteins: application to integral membrane transport proteins

Simple flexible programs (TREEMOMENT and PILEUPMOMENT) are described for depicting the average amphipathicity (hydrophobic moment) along multiply aligned sequences of a family of evolutionarily related proteins. The programs are applicable to any number of aligned sequences and can be set for any desired angle corresponding to a residue repeat unit in a protein secondary structural element such as 100 per residue for an alpha- helix or 180 per residue for a beta-strand. These programs can be used to identify amphipathic regions common to the members of a protein family. The use of these programs is exemplified by showing that some families of integral membrane transport proteins (i.e. permeases of the bacterial phosphotransferase system (PTS) and the anion exchangers of animals) exhibit strikingly amphipathic alpha-helical structures immediately preceding the first hydrophobic transmembrane segment of their membrane-embedded domain(s). Other families, such as the major facilitator superfamily of uniporters, symporters and antiporters, do not exhibit this structural feature. The amphipathic structures in PTS permeases have been implicated in membrane insertion during biogenesis.     

Flexible programs for the prediction of average amphipathicity of multiply aligned homologous proteins: application to integral membrane transport proteins.

Simple flexible programs (TREEMOMENT and PILEUPMOMENT) are described for depicting the average amphipathicity (hydrophobic moment) along multiply aligned sequences of a family of evolutionarily related proteins. The programs are applicable to any number of aligned sequences and can be set for any desired angle corresponding to a residue repeat unit in a protein secondary structural element such as 100 degrees per residue for an alpha-helix or 180 degrees per residue for a beta-strand. These programs can be used to identify amphipathic regions common to the members of a protein family. The use of these programs is exemplified by showing that some families of integral membrane transport proteins (i.e. permeases of the bacterial phosphotransferase system (PTS) and the anion exchangers of animals) exhibit strikingly amphipathic alpha-helical structures immediately preceding the first hydrophobic transmembrane segment of their membrane-embedded domain(s). Other families, such as the major facilitator superfamily of uniporters, symporters and antiporters, do not exhibit this structural feature. The amphipathic structures in PTS permeases have been implicated in membrane insertion during biogenesis.     

Monomer-monomer interactions drive the prepore to pore conversion of a beta-barrel-forming cholesterol-dependent cytolysin.

Perfringolysin O (PFO), a cholesterol-dependent cytolysin, forms large oligomeric pore complexes comprised of up to 50 PFO molecules. In the present studies a mutant of PFO (PFO(Y181A)) has been identified that traps PFO in a multimeric prepore complex that cannot insert its transmembrane beta-hairpins and therefore cannot form a pore. Remarkably, PFO(Y181A) can be induced to insert its transmembrane beta-hairpins if functional PFO is incorporated into the PFO(Y181A) oligomeric prepore complex. Furthermore, the transition from prepore to pore appears to be an "all or none" process; partial insertion of the transmembrane beta-barrel does not occur. Therefore, cooperative interactions between the monomers of the prepore drive the prepore to pore conversion that results in the formation of the transmembrane beta-barrel.     

Membrane-insertion fragments of Bcl-xL, Bax, and Bid

Apoptosis regulators of the Bcl-2 family associate with intracellular membranes from mitochondria and the endoplasmic reticulum, where they perform their function. The activity of these proteins is related to the release of apoptogenic factors, sequestered in the mitochondria, to the cytoplasm, probably through the formation of ion and/or protein transport channels. Most of these proteins contain a C-terminal putative transmembrane (TM) fragment and a pair of hydrophobic alpha helices (alpha5-alpha6) similar to the membrane insertion fragments of the ion-channel domain of diphtheria toxin and colicins. Here, we report on the membrane-insertion properties of different segments from antiapoptotic Bcl-x(L) and proapoptotic Bax and Bid, that correspond to defined alpha helices in the structure of their soluble forms. According to prediction methods, there are only two putative TM fragments in Bcl-x(L) and Bax (the C-terminal alpha helix and alpha-helix 5) and one in activated tBid (alpha-helix 6). The rest of their sequence, including the second helix of the pore-forming domain, displays only weak hydrophobic peaks, which are below the prediction threshold. Subsequent analysis by glycosylation mapping of single alpha-helix segments in a model chimeric system confirms the above predictions and allows finding an extra TM fragment made of helix alpha1 of Bax. Surprisingly, the amphipathic helices alpha6 of Bcl-x(L) and Bax and alpha7 of Bid do insert in membranes only as part of the alpha5-alpha6 (Bcl-x(L) and Bax) or alpha6-alpha7 (Bid) hairpins but not when assayed individually. This behavior suggests a synergistic insertion and folding of the two helices of the hairpin that could be due to charge complementarity and additional stability provided by turn-inducing residues present at the interhelical region. Although these data come from chimeric systems, they show direct potentiality for acquiring a membrane inserted state. Thus, the above fragments should be considered for the definition of plausible models of the active, membrane-bound species of Bcl-2 proteins.     

The amino- and carboxyl-terminal fragments of the Bacillus thuringensis Cyt1Aa toxin have differential roles in toxin oligomerization and pore formation

The Cyt toxins produced by the bacteria Bacillus thuringiensis show insecticidal activity against some insects, mainly dipteran larvae, being able to kill mosquitoes and black flies. However, they also possess a general cytolytic activity in vitro, showing hemolytic activity in red blood cells. These proteins are composed of two outer layers of α-helix hairpins wrapped around a β-sheet. With regard to their mode of action, one model proposed that the two outer layers of α-helix hairpins swing away from the β-sheet, allowing insertion of β-strands into the membrane forming a pore after toxin oligomerization. The other model suggested a detergent-like mechanism of action of the toxin on the surface of the lipid bilayer. In this work, we cloned the N- and C-terminal domains form Cyt1Aa and analyzed their effects on Cyt1Aa toxin action. The N-terminal domain shows a dominant negative phenotype inhibiting the in vitro hemolytic activity of Cyt1Aa in red blood cells and the in vivo insecticidal activity of Cyt1Aa against Aedes aegypti larvae. In addition, the N-terminal region is able to induce aggregation of the Cyt1Aa toxin in solution. Finally, the C-terminal domain composed mainly of β-strands is able to bind to the SUV liposomes, suggesting that this region of the toxin is involved in membrane interaction. Overall, our data indicate that the two isolated domains of Cyt1Aa have different roles in toxin action. The N-terminal region is involved in toxin aggregation, while the C-terminal domain is involved in the interaction of the toxin with the lipid membrane.     

Trapping of Vibrio cholerae Cytolysin in the Membrane-bound Monomeric State Blocks Membrane Insertion and Functional Pore Formation by the Toxin

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) is a potent membrane-damaging cytolytic toxin that belongs to the family of β barrel pore-forming protein toxins. VCC induces lysis of its target eukaryotic cells by forming transmembrane oligomeric β barrel pores. The mechanism of membrane pore formation by VCC follows the overall scheme of the archetypical β barrel pore-forming protein toxin mode of action, in which the water-soluble monomeric form of the toxin first binds to the target cell membrane, then assembles into a prepore oligomeric intermediate, and finally converts into the functional transmembrane oligomeric β barrel pore. However, there exists a vast knowledge gap in our understanding regarding the intricate details of the membrane pore formation process employed by VCC. In particular, the membrane oligomerization and membrane insertion steps of the process have only been described to a limited extent. In this study, we determined the key residues in VCC that are critical to trigger membrane oligomerization of the toxin. Alteration of such key residues traps the toxin in its membrane-bound monomeric state and abrogates subsequent oligomerization, membrane insertion, and functional transmembrane pore-formation events. The results obtained from our study also suggest that the membrane insertion of VCC depends critically on the oligomerization process and that it cannot be initiated in the membrane-bound monomeric form of the toxin. In sum, our study, for the first time, dissects membrane binding from the subsequent oligomerization and membrane insertion steps and, thus, defines the exact sequence of events in the membrane pore formation process by VCC.     

Vertical collapse of a cytolysin prepore moves its transmembrane beta-hairpins to the membrane

Perfringolysin O (PFO) is a prototype of the large family of pore-forming cholesterol-dependent cytolysins (CDCs). A central enigma of the cytolytic mechanism of the CDCs is that their membrane-spanning beta-hairpins (the transmembrane amphipathic beta-hairpins (TMHs)) appear to be approximately 40 A too far above the membrane surface to cross the bilayer and form the pore. We now present evidence, using atomic force microscopy (AFM), of a significant difference in the height by which the prepore and pore protrude from the membrane surface: 113+/-5 A for the prepore but only 73+/-5 A for the pore. Time-lapse AFM micrographs show this change in height in real time. Moreover, the monomers in both complexes exhibit nearly identical surface features and these results in combination with those of spectrofluorimetric analyses indicate that the monomers remain in a perpendicular orientation to the bilayer plane during this transition. Therefore, the PFO undergoes a vertical collapse that brings its TMHs to the membrane surface so that they can extend across the bilayer to form the beta-barrel pore.     

The Cholesterol-dependent Cytolysin Membrane-binding Interface Discriminates Lipid Environments of Cholesterol to Support β-Barrel Pore Insertion

The majority of cholesterol-dependent cytolysins (CDCs) utilize cholesterol as a membrane receptor, whereas a small number are restricted to the GPI-anchored protein CD59 for initial membrane recognition. Two cholesterol-binding CDCs, perfringolysin O (PFO) and streptolysin O (SLO), were found to exhibit strikingly different binding properties to cholesterol-rich natural and synthetic membranes. The structural basis for this difference was mapped to one of the loops (L3) in the membrane binding interface that help anchor the toxin monomers to the membrane after receptor (cholesterol) binding by the membrane insertion of its amino acid side chains. A single point mutation in this loop conferred the binding properties of SLO to PFO and vice versa. Our studies strongly suggest that changing the side chain structure of this loop alters its equilibrium between membrane-inserted and uninserted states, thereby affecting the overall binding affinity and total bound toxin. Previous studies have shown that the lipid environment of cholesterol has a dramatic effect on binding and activity. Combining this data with the results of our current studies on L3 suggests that the structure of this loop has evolved in the different CDCs to preferentially direct binding to cholesterol in different lipid environments. Finally, the efficiency of β-barrel pore formation was inversely correlated with the increased binding and affinity of the PFO L3 mutant, suggesting that selection of a compatible lipid environment impacts the efficiency of membrane insertion of the β-barrel pore.     

Mutational analysis of tetracycline resistance protein transmembrane segment insertion

The tetracycline resistance proteins (TetA) of gram-negative bacteria are secondary active transport proteins that contain buried charged amino acids that are important for tetracycline transport. Earlier studies have shown that insertion of TetA proteins into the cytoplasmic membrane is mediated by helical hairpin pairs of transmembrane (TM) segments. However, whether helical hairpins direct spontaneous insertion of TetA or are required instead for its interaction with the cellular secretion (Sec) machinery is unknown. To gain insight into how TetA proteins are inserted into the membrane, we have investigated how tolerant the class C TetA protein encoded by plasmid pBR322 is to placement of charged residues in TM segments. The results show that the great majority of charge substitutions do not interfere with insertion even when placed at locations that cannot be shielded internally within helical hairpins. The only mutations that frequently block insertion are proline substitutions, which may interfere with helical hairpin folding. The ability of TetA to broadly tolerate charge substitutions indicates that the Sec machinery assists in its insertion into the membrane. The results also demonstrate that it is feasible to engineer charged residues into the interior of TetA proteins for the purpose of structure-function analysis.     

Membrane insertion by anthrax protective antigen in cultured cells

The enzymatic moieties of anthrax toxin enter the cytosol of mammalian cells via a pore in the endosomal membrane formed by the protective antigen (PA) moiety. Pore formation involves an acidic pH-induced conformational rearrangement of a heptameric precursor (the prepore), in which the seven 2beta2-2beta3 loops interact to generate a 14-strand transmembrane beta-barrel. To investigate this model in vivo, we labeled PA with the fluorophore 7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazole (NBD) at cysteine residues introduced into the 2beta2-2beta3 loop. Each labeled PA was bound to CHO cells, and NBD fluorescence was monitored over time in stirred cell suspensions or by confocal microscopy. A strong increase was observed with NBD at positions 305, 307, 309, and 311, sites where side chains are predicted to face the bilayer, and little change was seen at residues 304, 306, 308, 310, and 312, sites where side chains are predicted to face the pore lumen. The increase at position 305 was inhibited by membrane-restricted quenchers, low temperature, or various reagents known to affect toxin action. Of the 24 NBD attachment sites examined, all but three gave results qualitatively consistent with the beta-barrel model. Besides supporting the beta-barrel model of membrane insertion, our results describe the time course of insertion and identify PA residues where NBD gives a strong signal upon membrane insertion in vivo.     

Asn- and Asp-mediated interactions between transmembrane helices during translocon-mediated membrane protein assembly

Inter-helix hydrogen bonding involving asparagine (Asn, N), glutamine (Gln, Q), aspartic acid (Asp, D) or glutamic acid (Glu, E) can drive efficient di- or trimerization of transmembrane helices in detergent micelles and lipid bilayers. Likewise, Asn-Asn and Asp-Asp pairs can promote the formation of helical hairpins during translocon-mediated membrane protein assembly in the endoplasmic reticulum. By in vitro translation of model integral membrane protein constructs in the presence of rough microsomes, we show that Asn- or Asp-mediated interactions with a neighbouring transmembrane helix can enhance the membrane insertion efficiency of a marginally hydrophobic transmembrane segment. Our observations suggest that inter-helix hydrogen bonds can form during Sec61 translocon-assisted insertion and thus could be important for membrane protein assembly.