The allele-specific suppressor sup-39 alters use of cryptic splice sites in Caenorhabditis elegans

Mutations in the Caenorhabditis elegans sup-39 gene cause allele-specific suppression of the uncoordination defect of unc-73(e936). e936 is a point mutation that changes the canonical G at the 5' end of intron 16 to a U. This mutation activates three splice donors, two of which define introns beginning with the canonical GU. Use of these two cryptic splice sites causes loss of reading frame; interestingly these messages are not substrates for nonsense-mediated decay. The third splice donor, used in 10% of steady-state e936 messages, is the mutated splice donor at the wild-type position, which defines an intron beginning with UU. In the presence of a sup-39 mutation, these same three splice donors are used, but the ratio of messages produced by splicing at these sites changes. The percentage of unc-73(e936) messages containing the wild-type splice junction is increased to 33% with a corresponding increase in the level of UNC-73 protein. This sup-39-induced change was also observed when the e936 mutant intron region was inserted into a heterologous splicing reporter construct transfected into worms. Experiments with splicing reporter constructs showed that the degree of 5' splice site match to the splicing consensus sequence can strongly influence cryptic splice site choice. We propose that mutant SUP-39 is a new type of informational suppressor that alters the use of weak splice donors.     

Identical G+1 to A mutations in three different introns of the type III procollagen gene (COL3A1) produce different patterns of RNA splicing in three variants of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. IV. An explanation for exon skipping some mutations and not others

Identical G+1 mutations in three different introns of the gene for type III procollagen (COL3A1) that cause aberrant splicing of RNA were found in three probands with life-threatening variants of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. Because the three mutations were in a gene with multiple and homologous exons, they provided an interesting test for factors that influence aberrant splicing. The G+1 to A mutation in intron 16 caused extensive exon skipping, the G+1 to A mutation in intron 20 caused both use of a cryptic splice site and retention of all the intron sequences, and the G+1 to A mutation in intron 42 caused efficient use of a single cryptic splice site. The different patterns of RNA splicing were not explained by evaluation of potential cryptic splice sites in the introns by either their homology with 5'-splice sites from other genes or by their delta G(0)37 values for binding to U1 RNA. Instead, the results suggested that the patterns of aberrant RNA splicing were primarily determined by the relative rates at which adjacent introns were normally spliced.     

U5 snRNA interacts with exon sequences at 5' and 3' splice sites.

U5 snRNA is an essential pre-mRNA splicing factor whose function remains enigmatic. Specific mutations in a conserved single-stranded loop sequence in yeast U5 snRNA can activate cleavage of G1----A mutant pre-mRNAs at aberrant 5' splice sites and facilitate processing of dead-end lariat intermediates to mRNA. Activation of aberrant 5' cleavage sites involves base pairing between U5 snRNA and nucleotides upstream of the cleavage site. Processing of dead-end lariat intermediates to mRNA correlates with base pairing between U5 and the first two bases in exon 2. The loop sequence in U5 snRNA may therefore by intimately involved in the transesterification reactions at 5' and 3' splice sites. This pattern of interactions is strikingly reminiscent of exon recognition events in group II self-splicing introns and is consistent with the notion that U5 snRNA may be related to a specific functional domain from a group II-like self-splicing ancestral intron.     

A Genetic Screen for Suppressors of a Mutated 5′ Splice Site Identifies Factors Associated With Later Steps of Spliceosome Assembly

Many alleles of human disease genes have mutations within splicing consensus sequences that activate cryptic splice sites. In Caenorhabditis elegans, the unc-73(e936) allele has a G-to-U mutation at the first base of the intron downstream of exon 15, which results in an uncoordinated phenotype. This mutation triggers cryptic splicing at the −1 and +23 positions and retains some residual splicing at the mutated wild-type (wt) position. We previously demonstrated that a mutation in sup-39, a U1 snRNA gene, suppresses e936 by increasing splicing at the wt splice site. We report here the results of a suppressor screen in which we identify three proteins that function in cryptic splice site choice. Loss-of-function mutations in the nonessential splicing factor smu-2 suppress e936 uncoordination through changes in splicing. SMU-2 binds SMU-1, and smu-1(RNAi) also leads to suppression of e936. A dominant mutation in the conserved C-terminal domain of the C. elegans homolog of the human tri-snRNP 27K protein, which we have named SNRP-27, suppresses e936 uncoordination through changes in splicing. We propose that SMU-2, SMU-1, and SNRP-27 contribute to the fidelity of splice site choice after the initial identification of 5′ splice sites by U1 snRNP.PRE-mRNA splicing takes place in a large ribonucleoprotein complex called the spliceosome (Burge et al. 1999). Components of this splicing machinery assemble at conserved signal sequences within the pre-mRNA. The 5′ splice site consensus sequence M₋₃A₋₂G₋₁ | G₊₁U₊₂R₊₃A₊₄G₊₅U₊₆ and the 3′ splice site consensus sequence Y₋₃A₋₂G₋₁ | R₊₁ (M is either A or C; R is a purine, and Y is a pyrimidine) define the limits of the intron. Base-pairing interactions between the 5′ end of the U1 snRNA and the 5′ splice site consensus sequence occur early in spliceosome assembly. It is the nearly invariable GU dinucleotide at the first two positions of the 5′ end of the intron that defines the beginning of the intron. The 5′ consensus sequence is essential but insufficient for splice site selection, as 5′ splice sites with weaker consensus matches may require additional determinants for proper activation (Sanford et al. 2005).Mutations that disrupt the 5′ consensus splice signal can lead to genetic disease in humans (Nelson and Green 1990; Cohen et al. 1994). Approximately 15% of point mutations that cause genetic diseases affect pre-mRNA splicing consensus sequences (Krawczak et al. 1992). For some specific disease genes, as many as 50% of the known heritable alleles alter splicing (Teraoka et al. 1999; Ars et al. 2000; Roca et al. 2003; Pagenstecher et al. 2006). Among all the positions of the 5′ splice site consensus sequence, the highest proportion of human disease mutations occur at the +1G position (Buratti et al. 2007). The fidelity of pre-mRNA splice site choice is largely disrupted by this defect, since this mutation causes splicing at this site to be either abolished or outcompeted by the activation of nearby cryptic 5′ splice sites (Nelson and Green 1990; Cohen et al. 1994). Cryptic splice sites are used only when the wild-type splice donor is disrupted by mutation, as they tend to have very weak splice donor consensus sequences outside of a 5′-GU dinucleotide that defines the beginning of the intron (Roca et al. 2003). Suppression of mutations to the 5′ splice site consensus sequence in vivo has been achieved through the expression of U1 snRNAs containing compensatory base substitutions (Zhuang and Weiner 1986); however, suppression of mutations to the +1 position of the intron using reverse genetic approaches has not been successful (Newman et al. 1985; Nelson and Green 1990; Cohen et al. 1994).We have used a specific allele of the Caenorhabditis elegans unc-73 gene, e936, which contains a G-to-U mutation at the first nucleotide of intron 16 (Steven et al. 1998), as a model for studying cryptic splice site choice (Roller et al. 2000; Zahler et al. 2004). unc-73 encodes a RAC guanine nucleotide exchange factor that is expressed in neurons and is important for axon guidance (Steven et al. 1998). The e936 allele induces the use of three different cryptic 5′ splice sites (Figure 1A). Two of these 5′ splice sites, located at the −1 and +23 positions, define introns beginning with GU. The third 5′ splice site used is at the mutated wild-type (wt) position and is referred to as “wt” since splicing at this site still produces wild-type unc-73 mRNA and protein, even though the intron begins with UU (Roller et al. 2000). Use of either the −1 or the +23 cryptic site causes a shift in the reading frame and loss of gene function. In e936 animals, 90% of the stable messages of unc-73 are out-of-frame, yet the phenotype is not as severe as for other alleles in this gene. This indicates that the 10% of steady-state messages that are in frame have some functional role.Open in a separate windowFigure 1.—(A) Diagram of the unc-73 gene between exons 15 and 16. The positions of the −1 and +23 cryptic 5′ splice sites are indicated by arrows. The intronic e936 (+1G → U) point mutation is highlighted. (B) γ-³²P-labeled RT–PCR results across the cryptic splicing region of unc-73(e936) for different strains. Lanes 1, 2, and 3 are loaded with RT–PCR reactions from wild type (N2), unc-73(e936);sup-39(je5), and unc-73(e936) RNA, respectively. The lines carrying the suppressor alleles and e936 follow in lanes 4–10 as indicated. (C) The unc-73 genomic sequence from exon 15 (uppercase letters) and intron 15 (lowercase letters). The locations of the az23 and e936 mutational substitutions are indicated below. The position of the −9 cryptic splice donor activated in e936az23 is indicated by an arrow above.In a previous genetic screen for extragenic suppressors of e936 movement defects, Way and colleagues identified sup-39 (Run et al. 1996). It was subsequently shown that mutations in sup-39 alter cryptic splice site choice of e936 (Roller et al. 2000). sup-39 encodes a U1 snRNA gene with a compensatory mutation at the position that normally base pairs with the +1G. This allows sup-39 to base pair with an intron with a +1U (Zahler et al. 2004). This dominant suppressor increases usage of the mutated splice site and improves the fraction of in-frame messages from e936 from 10 to 33%, with a dramatic improvement in coordination. A similar mutant U1 snRNA suppressor with a different compensatory substitution, sup-6(st19), was found to suppress the intronic +1G to A transition of unc-13(e309) to allow for splicing at the mutated wild-type site, even though the intron begins with AU instead of GU (Zahler et al. 2004).We are interested in identifying additional factors that play a role in cryptic 5′ splice site choice. To do this, we took advantage of unc-73(e936), in which modest increases in the use of the wt splice site lead to dramatic increases in coordination, as a sensitive screen for changes in cryptic splice site choice. In this article we report that the proteins SMU-1 and SMU-2, which are nonessential factors previously shown to have a role in alternative splicing (Spartz et al. 2004), have a role in selection of cryptic 5′ splice sites. We also report the identification of a new dominant suppressor of cryptic splicing, snrp-27, which encodes a C. elegans homolog of the human tri-snRNP 27K protein.     

Restoration of correct splicing of thalassemic beta-globin pre-mRNA by modified U1 snRNAs

The T-->G mutation at nucleotide 705 in the second intron of the beta-globin gene creates an aberrant 5' splice site and activates a 3' cryptic splice site upstream from the mutation. As a result, the IVS2-705 pre-mRNA is spliced via the aberrant splice sites leading to a deficiency of beta-globin mRNA and protein and to the genetic blood disorder thalassemia. We have shown previously that in cell culture models of thalassemia, aberrant splicing of beta-thalassemic IVS2-705 pre-mRNA was permanently corrected by a modified murine U7 snRNA that incorporated sequences antisense to the splice sites activated by the mutation. To explore the possibility of using other snRNAs as vectors for antisense sequences, U1 snRNA was modified in a similar manner. Replacement of the U1 9-nucleotide 5' splice site recognition sequence with nucleotides complementary to the aberrant 5' splice site failed to correct splicing of IVS2-705 pre-mRNA. In contrast, U1 snRNA targeted to the cryptic 3' splice site was effective. A hybrid with a modified U7 snRNA gene under the control of the U1 promoter and terminator sequences resulted in the highest levels of correction (up to 70%) in transiently and stably transfected target cells.     

Mutations at the 3' splice site can be suppressed by compensatory base changes in U1 snRNA in fission yeast.

U1 snRNA is an essential splicing factor known to base pair with 5' splice sites of premessenger RNAs. We demonstrate that pairing between the universally conserved CU just downstream from the 5' junction interaction region and the 3' splice site AG contributes to efficient splicing of Schizosaccharomyces pombe introns that typify the AG-dependent class described in mammals. Strains carrying mutations in the 3' AG of an artificial intron accumulate linear precursor, indicative of a first step block. Lariat formation is partially restored in these mutants by compensatory changes in nucleotides C7 and U8 of U1 snRNA. Consistent with a general role in fission yeast splicing, mutations at C7 are lethal, while U8 mutants are growth impaired and accumulate linear, unspliced precursor to U6 snRNA. U1 RNA-mediated recognition of the 3' splice site may have origins in analogous intramolecular interactions in an ancestral self-splicing RNA.     

U11 snRNA interacts in vivo with the 5' splice site of U12-dependent (AU-AC) pre-mRNA introns.

A notable feature of the newly described U12 snRNA-dependent class of eukaryotic nuclear pre-mRNA introns is the highly conserved 8-nt 5'' splice site sequence. This sequence is virtually invariant in all known members of this class from plants to mammals. Based on sequence complementarity between this sequence and the 5'' end of the U11 snRNA, we proposed that U11 snRNP may play a role in identifying and/or activating the 5'' splice site for splicing. Here we show that mutations of the conserved 5'' splice site sequence of a U12-dependent intron severely reduce correct splicing in vivo and that compensatory mutations in U11 snRNA can suppress the effects of the 5'' splice site mutations to varying extents. This provides evidence for a required interaction between U11 snRNA and the 5'' splice site sequence involving Watson-Crick base pairing. This data, in addition to a report that U11 snRNP is bound transiently to the U12-dependent spliceosome, suggests that U11 snRNP is the analogue of U1 snRNP in splicing this rare class of introns.     

Correction of aberrant splicing of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene by antisense oligonucleotides

The CFTR splicing mutation 3849 + 10 kb C --> T creates a novel donor site 10 kilobases (kb) into intron 19 of the gene and is one of the more common splicing mutations that causes cystic fibrosis (CF). It has an elevated prevalence among patients with atypically mild disease and normal sweat electrolytes and is especially prominent in Ashkenazi Jews. This class of splicing mutations, reported in several genes, involves novel splice sites activated deep within introns while leaving wild-type splice elements intact. CFTR cDNA constructs that modeled the 3849 + 10 kb C --> T mutation were expressed in 3T3 mouse fibroblasts and in CFT1 human tracheal and C127 mouse mammary epithelial cells. In all three cell types, aberrant splicing of CFTR pre-mRNA was comparable to that reported in vivo in CF patients. Treatment of the cells with 2'-O-methyl phosphorothioate oligoribonucleotides antisense toward the aberrant donor and acceptor splice sites or to the retained exon-like sequence, disfavored aberrant splicing and enhanced normal processing of CFTR pre-mRNA. This antisense-mediated correction of splicing was dose- and sequence-dependent and was accompanied by increased production of CFTR protein that was appropriately glycosylated. Antisense-mediated correction of splicing in a mutation-specific context represents a potential gene therapy modality with applicability to many inherited disorders.     

Splicing removes the Caenorhabditis elegans transposon Tc1 from most mutant pre-mRNAs.

The transposable element Tc1 is responsible for most spontaneous mutations that occur in many Caenorhabditis elegans strains. We analyzed the abundance and sequence of mRNAs expressed from five different Tc1 insertions within either hlh-1 (a MyoD homolog) or unc-54 (a myosin heavy chain gene). Each of the mutants expresses substantial quantities of mature mRNA in which most or all of Tc1 has been removed by splicing. Such mRNAs contain small insertions of Tc1 sequences and/or deletions of target gene sequences at the resulting spliced junctions. Most of these mutant mRNAs do not contain premature stop codons, and many are translated in frame to produce proteins that are functional in vivo. The number and variety of splice sites used to remove Tc1 from these mutant pre-mRNAs are remarkable. Two-thirds of the Tc1-containing introns removed from hlh-1 and unc-54 lack either the 5'-GU or AG-3' dinucleotides typically found at the termini of eukaryotic introns. We conclude that splicing to remove Tc1 from mutant pre-mRNAs allows many Tc1 insertions to be phenotypically silent. Such mRNA processing may help Tc1 escape negative selection.     

Defining a 5' splice site by functional selection in the presence and absence of U1 snRNA 5' end

Pre-mRNA splicing in metazoans is mainly specified by sequences at the termini of introns. We have selected functional 5' splice sites from randomized intron sequences through repetitive rounds of in vitro splicing in HeLa cell nuclear extract. The consensus sequence obtained after one round of selection in normal extract closely resembled the consensus of natural occurring 5' splice sites, suggesting that the selection pressures in vitro and in vivo are similar. After three rounds of selection under competitive splicing conditions, the base pairing potential to the U1 snRNA increased, yielding a G100%U100%R94%A67%G89%U76%R83% intronic consensus sequence. Surprisingly, a nearly identical consensus sequence was obtained when the selection was performed in nuclear extract containing U1 snRNA with a deleted 5' end, suggesting that other factors than the U1 snRNA are involved in 5' splice site recognition. The importance of a consecutive complementarity between the 5' splice site and the U1 snRNA was analyzed systematically in the natural range for in vitro splicing efficiency and complex formation. Extended complementarity was inhibitory to splicing at a late step in spliceosome assembly when pre-mRNA substrates were incubated in normal extract, but favorable for splicing under competitive splicing conditions or in the presence of truncated U1 snRNA where transition from complex A to complex B occurred more rapidly. This suggests that stable U1 snRNA binding is advantageous for assembly of commitment complexes, but inhibitory for the entry of the U4/U6.U5 tri-snRNP, probably due to a delayed release of the U1 snRNP.     

Activation of a cryptic 5' splice site by U1 snRNA

In the course of analyzing 5' splice site mutations in the second intron of Schizosaccharomyces pombe cdc2, we identified a cryptic 5' junction containing a nonconsensus nucleotide at position +2. An even more unusual feature of this cryptic 5' junction was its pattern of activation. By analyzing the profile of splicing products for an extensive series of cdc2 mutants in the presence and absence of compensatory U1 alleles, we have obtained evidence that the natural 5' splice site participates in activation of the cryptic 5' splice site, and that it does so via base pairing to U1 snRNA. Furthermore, the results of follow-up experiments strongly suggest that base pairing between U1 snRNA and the cryptic 5' junction itself plays a dominant role in its activation. Most remarkably, a mutant U1 can activate the cryptic 5' splice site even in the presence of a wild-type sequence at the natural 5' junction, providing unambiguous evidence that this snRNA redirects splicing via base pairing. Although previous work has demonstrated that U5 and U6 snRNAs can activate cryptic 5' splice sites through base pairing interactions, this is the first example in which U1 snRNA has been implicated in the final selection of a cryptic 5' junction.     

Base pairing with U6atac snRNA is required for 5' splice site activation of U12-dependent introns in vivo.

The minor U12-dependent class of eukaryotic nuclear pre-mRNA introns is spliced by a distinct spliceosomal mechanism that requires the function of U11, U12, U5, U4atac, and U6atac snRNAs. Previous work has shown that U11 snRNA plays a role similar to U1 snRNA in the major class spliceosome by base pairing to the conserved 5'' splice site sequence. Here we show that U6atac snRNA also base pairs to the 5'' splice site in a manner analogous to that of U6 snRNA in the major class spliceosome. We show that splicing defective mutants of the 5'' splice site can be activated for splicing in vivo by the coexpression of compensatory U6atac snRNA mutants. In some cases, maximal restoration of splicing required the coexpression of compensatory U11 snRNA mutants. The allelic specificity of mutant phenotype suppression is consistent with Watson-Crick base pairing between the pre-mRNA and the snRNAs. These results provide support for a model of the RNA-RNA interactions at the core of the U12-dependent spliceosome that is strikingly similar to that of the major class U2-dependent spliceosome.     

The role of overlapping U1 and U11 5' splice site sequences in a negative regulator of splicing

Splicing of Rous sarcoma virus RNA is regulated in part by a cis-acting intronic RNA element called the negative regulator of splicing (NRS). An NRS mutant affecting nt 916-923 disrupts U11 snRNP binding and reduces NRS activity (Gontarek et al., 1993, Genes & Dev 7:1926-1936). However, we observed that a U15' splice site-like sequence, which overlapped the U11 site, was also disrupted by this mutation. To determine whether the U1 or the U11 site was essential for NRS activity, we analyzed twelve additional mutants involving nt 915-926. All mutations that disrupted the potential base pairing between U1 snRNA and the NRS reduced NRS activity, including single point mutations at nt 915, 916, and 919. The point mutation at nt 919 was partially suppressed by a compensatory base change mutation in U1 snRNA. In contrast, a mutation which strengthened the potential base pairing between the U1 site and the NRS increased NRS activity. Surprisingly, mutations that specifically targeted the U115' splice site consensus sequence increased the levels of unspliced RNA, suggesting U11 binding plays an antagonistic role to NRS activity. We propose that U1 snRNP binding to the NRS inhibits splicing and is regulated by U11 snRNP binding to the overlapping sequence. Competition between U1 and U11 snRNPs would result in the appropriate balance of spliced to unspliced RNAs for optimal viral replication. Further, a virus mutated in the U1/U11 region of the NRS was found to have delayed replication.     

Exon mutations uncouple 5' splice site selection from U1 snRNA pairing

It has previously been shown that a mutation of yeast 5' splice junctions at position 5 (GUAUGU) causes aberrant pre-mRNA cleavages near the correct 5' splice site. We show here that the addition of exon mutations to an aberrant cleavage site region transforms it into a functional 5' splice site both in vivo and in vitro. The aberrant mRNAs are translated in vivo. The results suggest that the highly conserved G at the 5' end of introns is necessary for the second step of splicing. Further analyses indicate that the location of the U1 snRNA-pre-mRNA pairing is not affected by the exon mutations and that the precise 5' splice site is selected independent of this pairing.     

Comparative analysis detects dependencies among the 5' splice-site positions

Human-mouse comparative genomics is an informative tool to assess sequence functionality as inferred from its conservation level. We used this approach to examine dependency among different positions of the 5' splice site. We compiled a data set of 50,493 homologous human-mouse internal exons and analyzed the frequency of changes among different positions of homologous human-mouse 5' splice-site pairs. We found mutual relationships between positions +4 and +5, +5 and +6, -2 and +5, and -1 and +5. We also demonstrated the association between the exonic and the intronic positions of the 5' splice site, in which a stronger interaction of U1 snRNA and the intronic portion of the 5' splice site compensates for weak interaction of U1 snRNA and the exonic portion of the 5' splice site, and vice versa. By using an ex vivo system that mimics the effect of mutation in the 5' splice site leading to familial dysautonomia, we demonstrated that U1 snRNA base-pairing with positions +6 and -1 is the only functional requirement for mRNA splicing of this 5' splice site. Our findings indicate the importance of U1 snRNA base-pairing to the exonic portion of the 5' splice site.