Synthesis of male sterile,triazine-resistant Brassica napus by somatic hybridization between cytoplasmic male sterile B. oleracea and atrazine-resistant B. campestris

Summary Fusion of leaf protoplasts from an inbred line of Brassica oleracea ssp. botrytis (cauliflower, n=9) carrying the Ogura (R1) male sterile cytoplasm with hypocotyl protoplasts of B. campestris ssp. oleifera (cv Candle, n=10) carrying an atrazine-resistant (ATR) cytoplasm resulted in the production of synthetic B. napus (n=19). Thirty-four somatic hybrids were produced; they were characterized for morphology, phosphoglucose isomerase isoenzymes, ribosomal DNA hybridization patterns, chromosome numbers, and organelle composition. All somatic hybrids carried atrazine-resistant chloroplasts derived from B. campestris. The mitochondrial genomes in 19 hybrids were examined by restriction endonuclease and Southern blot analyses. Twelve of the 19 hybrids contained mitochondria showing novel DNA restriction patterns; of these 12 hybrids, 5 were male sterile and 7 were male fertile. The remaining hybrids contained mitochondrial DNA that was identical to that of the ATR parent and all were male fertile.     

Analysis of chloroplast and mitochondrial segregation in three different combinations of somatic hybrids produced within Brassicaceae

Summary Mitochondrial and chloroplast DNA were characterized in three different combinations of somatic hybrids produced between different species within Brassicaceae. The fusions were made between B. campestris and B. oleracea, B. napus and B. nigra and between B. napus and Eruca sativa. The combinations represent interspecific hybridizations, but the phylogenetic distance between the species used in each instance is different. Whereas the B. campestris (+) B. oleracea and the B. napus (+)B. nigra hybrids are both examples of intrageneric hybrids, B. campestris is more closely related to B. oleracea than B. napus is to B. nigra. The fusion of B. napus and E. sativa represents an intergeneric hybridization. Since hybrids were produced with reproducible and uniform fusion and culture methods, a comparison of chloroplast and mitochondrial segregation and mitochondrial DNA (mt-DNA) rearrangements could be made between the combinations. The segregation of both chloroplasts and mitochondria was biased in the B. napus (+)B. nigra and the B. napus (+)E. sativa combination. The nonrandom segregation of chloroplasts and mitochondria could be due to the different ploidy levels of the fusion partners and/or reflect differences in organelle replication rate. Furthermore, segregation of mitochondria was correlated to the differences in phylogenetic distance between the species used in the fusions. However, mitochondrial segregation, in contrast to chloroplast segregation, could in all combinations also have been affected by the cell type used as protoplast source in the fusions. All different chloroplast types could be established within each combination. Hybrids containing chloroplast from one parent together with mitochondria from the other parent were found in two of the combinations, although the majority of the hybrids had mt-DNA that was altered compared to the parental species. The rearranged mt-DNA found in most hybrids was an effect of the heteroplasmic state following protoplast fusion rather than of the tissue culture methods, since no mt-DNA rearrangements were found in B. napus plants regenerated from protoplast culture. The mtDNA restriction patterns of the hybrids with rearranged mt-DNA indicated that specific regions of the mt-DNA were involved in the rearrangements following protoplast fusion.     

A high frequency of intergenomic mitochondrial recombination and an overall biased segregation of B. campestris or recombined B. campestris mitochondria were found in somatic hybrids made within Brassicaceae

Mitochondrial segregation and rearrangements were studied in regenerated somatic hybrids from seven different species combinations produced using reproducible and uniform methods. The interspecific hybridizations were made between closely or more distantly related species within the Brassicaceae and were exemplified by three intrageneric, two intergeneric and two intertribal species combinations. The intrageneric combinations were represented by Brassica campestris (+) B. oleracea, B. napus (+) B. nigra and B. napus (+) B. juncea (tournefortii) hybrids, the intergeneric combinations by B. napus (+) Raphanus sativus and B. napus (+) Eruca sativa hybrids, and the intertribal combinations by B. napus (+) Thlaspi perfoliatum and B. napus (+) Arabidopsis thaliana hybrids. In each species combination, one of the two mitochondrial genotypes was B. campestris since the B. napus cultivar used in the fusions contained this cytoplasm. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) analyses were performed using DNA hybridization with nine different mitochondrial genes as probes. Among the various species combinations, 43–95% of the hybrids demonstrated mtDNA rearrangements. All examined B. campestris mtDNA regions could undergo intergenomic recombination since hybrid-specific fragments were found for all of the mtDNA probes analysed. Furthermore, hybrids with identical hybrid-specific fragments were found for all probes except cox II and rrn18/rrn5, supporting the suggestion that intergenomic recombination can involve specific sequences. A strong bias of hybrids having new atp A-or atp9-associated fragments observed in the intra- and intergeneric combinations could imply that these regions contain sequences that have a high reiteration number, which gives them a higher probability of recombining. A biased segregation of B. campestris-or B. campestris-like mitochondria was found in all combinations. A different degree of phylogenetic relatedness between the fusion partners did not have a significant influence on mitochondrial segregation in the hybrids in this study.     

Correction of chlorophyll-defective male-sterile winter oilseed rape (Brassica napus) through organelle exchange: molecular analysis of the cytoplasm of parental lines and corrected progeny

Summary Cytoplasmic differences between male-fertile and male-sterile Brassica napus as well as Raphanus sativus were investigated. Plastids of the male-fertile B. napus were found to differ from those of male-sterile B. napus and R. sativus with respect to DNA restriction enzyme patterns. Differences between male-fertile and male-sterile B. napus mitochondria were detected not only in the restriction fragment patterns of their DNA, but also at the level of expression by in organello translation of mitochondrial polypeptides.The chlorophyll deficiency obtained upon transferral of the male-sterility-conferring radish cytoplasm to a winter variety of B. napus had been corrected earlier through protoplast fusion. The cytoplasmic composition of the corrected lines was analysed using DNA restriction analysis and in organello translation. The stability of the recombined cytoplasm in the corrected lines was confirmed by analysis of the subsequent seed-derived generation.     

Analysis of organelle genomes in a somatic hybrid derived from cytoplasmic male-sterile Brassica oleracea and atrazine-resistant B. campestris

Summary An atrazine-resistant, male-fertile Brassica napus plant was synthesized by fusion of protoplasts from the diploid species B. oleracea and B. campestris. Leaf protoplasts from B. oleracea var. italica carrying the Ogura male-sterile cytoplasm derived from Raphanus sativus were fused with etiolated hypocotyl protoplasts of atrazine-resistant B. campestris. The selection procedure was based on the inability of B. campestris protoplasts to regenerate in the media used, and the reduction of light-induced growth of B. oleracea tissue by atrazine. A somatic hybrid plant that differed in morphology from both B. oleracea and B. campestris was regenerated on medium containing 50 M atrazine. Its chromosome number was 36–38, approximately that of B. napus. Furthermore, nuclear ribosomal DNA from this hybrid was a mixture of both parental rDNAs. Southern blot analyses of chloroplast DNA and an assay involving tetrazolium blue indicated that the hybrid contained atrazine-resistant B. campestris chloroplasts. The hybrid's mitochondrial genome was recombinant, containing fragments unique to each parent, as well as novel fragments carrying putative crossover points. Although the plant was female-sterile, it was successfully used to pollinate B. napus.     

Cytoplasmic male sterility in rapeseed (Brassica napus L.)

Summary Restriction patterns of chloroplast (cp) and mitochondrial (mt) DNA in Brassica napus rapeseed reveal the alloplasmic nature of cytoplasmic male sterility in this crop. Both the Shiga and Bronowski systems probably exploit cytoplasmic diversity in B. napus cultivars arising from introgression of cytoplasm from the other rapeseed species, B. campestris. Nuclear genes specific to these systems do not cause sterility in maintainers (Bronowski and Isuzu-natane) because they have a campestris cytoplasm, but give rise to sterility in napus cytoplasms. In the course of hybridization to napus cultivars a line with the triazine resistant cytoplasm (a campestris cytoplasm) has undergone an alteration in the mt genome rendering its restriction pattern more similar than previously to that of napus. The alteration may be an inversion between 7.2 and 3.4 kb in length.     

In situ hybridization with species-specific DNA probes gives evidence for asymmetric nature of Brassica hybrids obtained by X-ray fusion

Summary We have previously reported production of somatic hybrids between B. oleracea and B. campestris by fusion of B. oleracea protoplasts with X-irradiated B. campestris protoplasts, in order to transfer a part of the B. campestris genome into B. Oleracea. Our previous analysis of morphology, chromosome number, and isozyme patterns of the hybrids suggested that they are asymmetric in nature. To obtain further evidence for the asymmetric nature of the hybrids, we isolated B. campestris-specific repetitive sequences and used them for in situ hybridization of the chromosomes of the hybrids. The repetitive DNA probes could specifically identify 8 out of 20 chromosomes of the B. campestris genome, and analysis of the hybrids indicates that 1–3 chromosomes of B. campestris are lacking in all five hybrids examined, giving clear evidence for the asymmetric nature of the hybrids. Furthermore, in situ hybridization revealed that some of the abnormal chromosomes observed in the hybrids are generated by rearrangements of B. Campestris chromosomes caused by X-irradiation. Altogether, our study indicates that in situ hybridization using species-specific repetitive sequences is a useful tool to analyze chromosomal compositions of various types of hybrids obtained by cell fusion or conventional methods.     

The Brassica mitochondrial plasmid can be sexually transmitted. Pollen transfer of a cytoplasmic genetic element

Summary The 11.3 kb mitochondrial (mt) plasmid was restored to rapeseed (Brassica napus) plants cured of the plasmid (by in vitro culture) by crossing to plasmid-containing males, but not by grafting plasmidless shoots onto plants containing the plasmid. Plasmid restoration is not associated with alterations in mt DNA restriction patterns nor is it likely the result of excision of plasmid sequences from the mt genome. Restoration of the mitochondrially-associated plasmid is probably the result of transmission of cytoplasm from the male parent through the pollen to the egg cell in the female. Pollen transfer of the plasmid also occurred in other crosses regardless of cytoplasmic or nuclear background and at an average rate of 50%. These experiments demonstrate that a cytoplasmic genetic element can be non-maternally inherited in Brassica and suggest that the mitochondria with which this element is associated are transmitted to the egg cell during fertilization.     

Effects of parental ploidy level and genetic divergence on chromosome elimination and chloroplast segregation in somatic hybrids within Brassicaceae

Summary Chromosome and organelle segregation after the somatic hybridization of related species with different degrees of genetic divergence were studied by comparing the interspecific somatic hybrids Brassica oleracea (CC) (+) B. campestris (AA), B. napus (AACC) (+) B. oleracea (CC) B. napus (AACC) (+) B. nigra (BB) and B. napus (AACC) (+) B. juncea (AABB) with the intergeneric somatic hybrids B. napus (AACC) (+) Raphanus sativus (RR) and B. napus (AACC) (+) Eruca sativa (EE). Within each combination, some hybrids were found whose DNA content was equal to the sum of parental chromosomes, others had a relatively higher DNA content and in most of the cases, some had a relatively lower content. However, the frequency distribution in these three classes differed significantly between the combinations. A positive correlation between the frequency of hybrids with eliminated chromosomes and the genetic distance between the species in each combination was found. Furthermore, by combining species with different ploidy levels we found a significantly higher degree of chromosome elimination compared to combinations of species with the same ploidy level. In the B. napus (+) B. Nigra, B. napus (+) R. sativus and B. napus (+) E. sativa combinations chromosomes from the B, R and E genomes appeared to be preferentially sorted out, as indicated by the fact that some of the nuclear markers from these genomes were missing in 7–46% of the plants, whereas no plants were lacking B. napus nuclear markers. Fertile hybrids were found in all but the B. napus (+) R. sativus fusion combination; the latter hybrids were male sterile, but female fertile. Hybrids between the A and C genomes were more fertile than hybrids obtained between the distantly related AC and B, R or E genomes, respectively. Analysis of the chloroplast RFLP pattern revealed that chloroplasts in the B. oleracea (+) B. campestris hybrids segregated randomly. A slightly biased segregation, favouring B. napus chloroplasts, was found in the B. napus (+) B. oleracea combination, whereas B. napus chloroplasts were strongly selected for in the B. napus (+) B. juncea, B. napus (+) B. nigra, B. napus (+) R. sativus and B. napus (+) E. sativa somatic hybrids.     

Analysis of self-incompatibility interactions in 30 resynthesized Brassica napus lines. II. Expression of S-locus glycoproteins (SLGs)

Thirty resynthesized Brassica napus lines with defined S-allele constitution and the ancestral B. oleracea and B. campestris lines were used for the analysis of S- locus glycoproteins (SLGs). The aim of this study was to investigate (1) whether the S-specific glycoproteins of the diploid ancestor lines were also expressed in the amphidiploid hybrids and (2) whether the occurrence of SLG bands was correlated with the activity of the respective S-alleles, which had been tested by means of diallele pollination tests in a previous study. Stigma proteins were separated by isoelectric focusing (IEF)-gel electrophoresis, and glycoprotein bands were identified by Western blotting and Con-A/peroxidase reaction. The SLG bands of the B. campestris parent could be detected in all 30 resynthesized B. napus lines. In contrast, B. oleracea SLG bands could only be detected in 12 resynthesized B. napus lines. Only B. napus lines which carried the dominant B. oleracea S-alleles S₈ and S₂₉ showed respective SLG bands in all cases. Nine B. napus lines showed only glycoprotein bands of the B. campestris parent, although the biological functioning of the B. oleracea S-alleles was demonstrated by test-pollinations. New SLG bands different from those of the B. oleracea and B. campestris parents occurred in 16 B. napus lines. The expression level of the SLGs in B. napus was not correlated with the self-incompatibility phenotype, not only in the case of recessive S-alleles (S₂, S₁₅), but also for dominant alleles (e.g. S₁₄, S₃₂, S₄₅). Received: 22 January 1999 / Accepted: 30 January 1999     

Intergeneric hybrids between Enarthrocarpus lyratus,a wild species,and crop brassicas

Summary Attempts were made to produce intergeneric hybrids between Enarthrocarpus lyratus, a wild species, and several species of crop brassicas: B. campestris, B. nigra, B. oleracea, B. juncea, B. napus and B. Carinata. Hybrids using E. lyratus as female parent were realized by means of embryo rescue in four combinations — E. lyratus x B. campestris, E. lyratus x B. oleracea, E. lyratus x B. napus and E. lyratus x B. carinata. Reciprocal crosses showed strong pre-fertilization barriers and yielded no hybrids except in one combination — B. Juncea x E. Lyratus — in which a single hybrid could be realized. All of the hybrids were multiplied in vitro through the multiplication of axillary shoots. Morphological and cytological studies confirmed hybridity. All hybrids were completely pollen sterile except for E. lyratus x B. carinata, which showed 2% pollen fertility. Attempts to double the chromosome number through the in vitro application of colchicine to axillary meristems of F₁ hybrids were successful in only one hybrid, E. lyratus x B. oleracea. Cytological studies of the hybrids indicated the presence of a partial homology between the genomes of E. lyratus and crop brassicas. Backcross progenies were raised from all of the five F₁ hybrids to develop malesterile alloplasmic lines.     

Fertility and chromosome stability in Brassica napus resynthesised by protoplast fusion

Summary Fertile somatic hybrids between Brassica campestris and B. oleracea have been produced by protoplast fusion. Fusion products were identified by their intermediate protoplast morphology. Heterokaryons were isolated either with micropipettes using a micromanipulator or by flow sorting. About 2% of the obtained calli differentiated to shoots. Of the shoots obtained from manually selected heterokaryons, 100% were true hybrids as confirmed by isozyme analysis while 87% of the flow sorted ones showed a hybrid pattern. Ploidy level of the hybrid plants was determined by chromosome counting and relative DNA-content analysis. The sum of the chromosome number (38) from the two fusion partners were found in 30% of the hybrids; 9% had fewer and 61% had more chromosomes. Pollen viability and seed set varied with ploidy level. Compared to natural B. napus, a pollen viability of 52%–93% and a fertility of 1%–40% was found for the somatic hybrids with normal chromosome number. Restriction enzyme analysis of chloroplast-DNA showed that either B. campestris or B. oleracea chloroplasts were present in the somatic hybrid plants. Of 11 hybrid plants 5 had the campestris and 6 had the oleracea type (11 ratio).     

Analysis of the Brassica oleracea genome by the generation of B. campestris-oleracea chromosome addition lines: characterization by isozymes and rDNA genes

Summary This study aimed at generating chromosome addition lines and disclosing genome specific markers in Brassica. These stocks will be used to study genome evolution in Brassica oleracea L., B. campestris L. and the derived amphidiploid species B. napus L. B. campestris-oleracea monosomic and disomic chromosome addition plants were generated by crossing and backcrossing the natural amphidiploid B. napus to the diploid parental species B. campestris. The pollen viability of the derived sesquidiploid and hyperploid ranged from 63% to 88%, while the monosomic and disomic addition plants had an average pollen fertility of 94% and 91%, respectively. The addition lines were genetically characterized by genome specific markers. The isozymes for 6PGD, LAP, PGI and PGM, and rDNA Eco RI restriction fragments were found to possess the desired genome specificity. Duplicated loci for several of these markers were observed in B. campestris and B. oleracea, supporting the hypothesis that these diploid species are actually secondary polyploids. A total of eight monosomic and eight disomic addition plants were identified and characterized on the basis of these markers. Another 51 plants remained uncharacterized due to the lack of additional markers. rDNA genes were found to be distributed in more than one chromosome, differing in its restriction sites. Intergenomic recombination for some of the markers was detected at frequencies between 6% and 20%, revealing the feasibility of intergenomic gene transfer.     

The morphology, cytology, and C-banded karyotypes of Brassica campestris, B. oleracea, and B. napus plants regenerated from protoplasts

The behaviour of Brassica campestris (2n=20, AA), B. oleracea (2n=18, CC), and B. napus (2n=38, AACC) were studied during a tissue-culturing process. Hypocotyl-protoplasts were cultivated into calli from which new plants were regenerated. The regenerated plants were compared, and mitotic root-tip cells were C-banded and karyotyped. A majority of the plants were tetraploid. The meioses were studied in the PMCs. A number of abberations were observed, mainly due to faulty spindle function. There was a difference between the three species in that B. campestris performed the most poorly with many fewer regenerated plants. These plants were more morphologically disturbed and had more problems during pollen production than B. oleracea and B. napus plants.     

Mitochondrial DNA polymorphism induced by protoplast fusion in Cruciferae

Summary The mitochondrial genomes of five rapeseed somatic hybrid plants, which combine in a first experimentBrassica napus chloroplasts and a cytoplasmic male sterility trait coming fromRaphanus sativus, and in a second experiment chloroplasts of a triazine resistantB. compestris and a cytoplasmic male sterility trait fromR. sativus, were analyzed by restriction endonucleases. Restriction fragment patterns indicate that these genomes differ from each other and from both parents. The presence of new bands in the somatic hybrid mitochondrial DNA restriction patterns is evidence of mitochondrial recombination in somatic hybrid cells. In both parental and somatic hybrid plants large quantitative variations in a mitochondrial plasmid-like DNA have been observed. Our results suggest that the cytoplasmic support for male sterility is located in the chromosomal mitochondrial DNA instead of the plasmid-like DNA.     

Somatic hybrids between Brassica oleracea and B. campestris: selection by the use of iodoacetamide inactivation and regeneration ability

Summary An efficient procedure for obtaining somatic hybrids between B. oleracea and B. campestris has been developed. Hypocotyl protoplasts of B. oleracea were fused with mesophyll protoplasts from three different varieties of B. campestris by the polyethylene glycoldimethylsulfoxide method. The selection of somatic hybrids utilized the inactivation of B. oleracea protoplasts by iodoacetamide (IOA) and the low regeneration ability of B. campestris. The efficiency of recovery of somatic hybrids depended upon the IOA concentration, and when 15 mM IOA was used, 90% of the regenerated plants were found to be hybrid. The somatic hybrids were examined for i) leaf morphology, ii) leucine aminopeptidase (LAP) isozyme and iii) chromosome number. All the hybrids had intermediate leaf morphology and possessed LAP isozymes of both parental species. The chromosome analysis revealed a considerable variation in chromosome number of somatic hybrids, showing the occurrence of multiple fusion and chromosome loss during the culture. Some of the hybrids flowered and set seeds.     

Paternal inheritance of mitochondria in rapeseed (Brassica napus)

Summary Transfer of a mitochondrially associated plasmid following sexual crosses in Brassica napus rapeseed suggested that paternal mitochondria were being transferred to the cytoplasm of the egg. To examine this possibility further, plants carrying the chloroplast (cp) marker of triazine resistance, but which had lost the plasmid associated with the mitochondria of this cytoplasm, were crossed as females to males carrying the polima cytoplasm. The males carried a nuclear fertility restorer gene on an extra chromosome to overcome the male sterility marker conferred by the mitochondria of this cytoplasm. Approximately 10% of the F₁ progeny displayed the male sterility and flower morphology of the male parent. Mitochondrial (mt) DNA from the progeny showed the combined restriction patterns of both parents, but this rut heterogeneity did not continue into subsequent generations. All progeny retained the cp DNA restriction patterns of the maternal plant as well as resistance to the herbicide atrazine. To date, sexually mediated cybrid plants have shown no morphological abnormalities and have maintained their unique combination of cp and mt traits through several sexual generations.     

Production of wide hybrids and backcross progenies between Diplotaxis erucoides and crop brassicas

Intergeneric hybrids were produced between D. erucoides (), a wild species, and four cultivated species of Brassica, B. campestris, B. juncea, B. napus and B. oleracea, through embryo rescue. The hybrid nature of these plants was confirmed through morphological and cytological studies. Backcross pollinations with the pollen of the respective cultivars yielded BC progenies in the hybrids D. erucoides x B. juncea and D. erucoides x B. napus but not in D. erucoides x B. campestris and D. erucoides x B. oleracea. The hybrid D. erucoides x B. campestris was also used as a bridge species and crossed with B. juncea to raise the hybrid and backcross progenies. F₂ progenies were more amenable than f₁ hybrids for raising backcross progenies. Although D. erucoides is considered to be a close relative of B. campestris and B. oleracea, incompatibility barriers of this species with different cultivars do not reflect this relationship.     

Analysis of chloroplast and mitochondrial DNAs in asymmetric somatic hybrids between tobacco and carrot

Summary Chloroplast and mitochondrial DNAs have been examined by comparison of restriction enzyme patterns in asymmetric hybrid plants, resulting from the fusion between leaf mesophyll protoplasts of Nicotiana tabacum (Solanaceae), and irradiated cell culture protoplasts of Daucus carota (Umbellifereae). These somatic hybrids with normal tobacco morphology were selected as a consequence of the transfer of methotrexate and 5-methyltryptophan resistance from carrot to tobacco. The restriction patterns of chloroplast DNAs in somatic hybrids were indistinguishable from the tobacco parent. However, we found somatic hybrids with mitochondrial DNA significantly different from either parent, as judged by analysis of fragment distribution after restriction enzyme digestion. The possible formation of altered mitochondrial DNA molecules as the result of parasexual hybrid production between two phylogenetically highly divergent plant species will be discussed.     

Transfer of resistance to Xanthomonas campestris pv campestris into Brassica oleracea L. by protoplast fusion

Black rot caused by the bacterium Xanthomonas campestris pv campestris is one of the most serious diseases of Brassica oleracea. Since sources of resistance to the disease within B. oleracea are insufficient and control means are limited, the development of resistant breeding lines is extremely desirable. Certain lines of B. napus contain very high resistance controlled by a dominant gene, but crossing the two species sexually is very difficult. Therefore, somatic hybrids were produced by protoplast fusion between rapid cycling B. oleracea and a B. napus line highly resistant to X. campestris pv campestris. Hybrid identity was confirmed by morphological studies, flow cytometric estimation of nuclear DNA content, and analysis of random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD). Inoculations with the pathogen identified four somatic hybrids with high resistance. The resistant hybrid plants were fertile and set seed when selfed or crossed reciprocally to the bridge line 15 (Quazi 1988). Direct crosses to B. oleracea were unsuccessful, but embryo rescue facilitated the production of a first-backcross generation. The BC₁ plants were resistant to the pathogen. Progeny from the crosses to line 15 were all susceptible. Embryo rescue techniques were not obligatory for the development of a second-backcross generation, and several resistant BC₂ plants were obtained.