Late domain function identified in the vesicular stomatitis virus M protein by use of rhabdovirus-retrovirus chimeras

Little is known about the mechanisms used by enveloped viruses to separate themselves from the cell surface at the final step of budding. However, small sequences in the Gag proteins of several retroviruses (L domains) have been implicated in this process. A sequence has been identified in the M proteins of rhabdoviruses that closely resembles the PPPPY motif in the L domain of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), an avian retrovirus. To evaluate whether the PPPY sequence in vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) M protein has an activity analogous to that of the retroviral sequence, M-Gag chimeras were characterized. The N-terminal 74 amino acids of the VSV (Indiana) M protein, including the PPPY motif, was able to replace the L domain of RSV Gag and allow the assembly and release of virus-like particles. Alanine substitutions in the VSV PPPY motif severely compromised the budding activity of this hybrid protein but not that of another chimera which also contained the RSV PPPPY sequence. We conclude that this VSV sequence is functionally homologous to the RSV L domain in promoting virus particle release, making this the first example of such an activity in a virus other than a retrovirus. Both the RSV and VSV motifs have been shown to interact in vitro with certain cellular proteins that contain a WW interaction module, suggesting that the L domains are sites of interaction with unknown host machinery involved in virus release.     

Positionally independent and exchangeable late budding functions of the Rous sarcoma virus and human immunodeficiency virus Gag proteins.

The Gag proteins of Rous sarcoma virus and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) each contain a function involved in a late step in budding, defects in which result in the accumulation of these molecules at the plasma membrane. In the Rous sarcoma virus Gag protein (Pr76gag), this assembly domain is associated with a PPPY motif, which is located at an internal position between the MA and CA sequences. This motif is not contained anywhere within the HIV Gag protein (Pr55gag), and the MA sequence is linked directly to CA. Instead, a late assembly function of HIV has been associated with the p6 sequence situated at the C terminus of Gag. Here we demonstrate the remarkable finding that the late assembly domains from these two unrelated Gag proteins are exchangeable between retroviruses and can function in a positionally independent manner.     

Equine infectious anemia virus utilizes a YXXL motif within the late assembly domain of the Gag p9 protein.

We have previously demonstrated that the Gag p9 protein of equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) is functionally homologous with Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) p2b and human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) p6 in providing a critical late assembly function in RSV Gag-mediated budding from transfected COS-1 cells (L. J. Parent et al., J. Virol. 69:5455-5460, 1995). In light of the absence of amino acid sequence homology between EIAV p9 and the functional homologs of RSV and HIV-1, we have now designed an EIAV Gag-mediated budding assay to define the late assembly (L) domain peptide sequences contained in the EIAV p9 protein. The results of these particle budding assays revealed that expression of EIAV Gag polyprotein in COS-1 cells yielded extracellular Gag particles with a characteristic density of 1.18 g/ml, while expression of EIAV Gag polyprotein lacking p9 resulted in a severe reduction in the release of extracellular Gag particles. The defect in EIAV Gag polyprotein particle assembly could be corrected by substituting either the RSV p2b or HIV-1 p6 protein for EIAV p9. These observations demonstrated that the L domains of EIAV, HIV-1, and RSV were interchangeable in mediating assembly of EIAV Gag particles in the COS-1 cell budding assay. To localize the L domain of EIAV p9, we next assayed the effects of deletions and site-specific mutations in the p9 protein on its ability to mediate budding of EIAV Gag particles. Analyses of EIAV Gag constructs with progressive N-terminal or C-terminal deletions of the p9 protein identified a minimum sequence of 11 amino acids (Q20N21L22Y23P24D25L26S27E28I29K30) capable of providing the late assembly function. Alanine scanning studies of this L-domain sequence demonstrated that mutations of residues Y23, P24, and L26 abrogated the p9 late budding function; mutations of other residues in the p9 L domain did not substantially affect the level of EIAV Gag particle assembly. These data indicate that the L domain in EIAV p9 utilizes a YXXL motif which we hypothesize may interact with cellular proteins to facilitate virus particle budding from infected cells.     

Insertion of Capsid Proteins from Nonenveloped Viruses into the Retroviral Budding Pathway

Retroviral Gag proteins direct the assembly and release of virus particles from the plasma membrane. The budding machinery consists of three small domains, the M (membrane-binding), I (interaction), and L (late or "pinching-off") domains. In addition, Gag proteins contain sequences that control particle size. For Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), the size determinant maps to the capsid (CA)-spacer peptide (SP) sequence, but it functions only when I domains are present to enable particles of normal density to be produced. Small deletions throughout the CA-SP sequence result in the release of particles that are very large and heterogeneous, even when I domains are present. In this report, we show that particles of relatively uniform size and normal density are released by budding when the size determinant and I domains in RSV Gag are replaced with capsid proteins from two unrelated, nonenveloped viruses: simian virus 40 and satellite tobacco mosaic virus. These results indicate that capsid proteins of nonenveloped viruses can interact among themselves within the context of Gag and be inserted into the retroviral budding pathway merely by attaching the M and L domains to their amino termini. Thus, the differences in the assembly pathways of enveloped and nonenveloped viruses may be far simpler than previously thought.     

Genetic Determinants of Rous Sarcoma Virus Particle Size

The Gag proteins of retroviruses are the only viral products required for the release of membrane-enclosed particles by budding from the host cell. Particles released when these proteins are expressed alone are identical to authentic virions in their rates of budding, proteolytic processing, and core morphology, as well as density and size. We have previously mapped three very small, modular regions of the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) Gag protein that are necessary for budding. These assembly domains constitute only 20% of RSV Gag, and alterations within them block or severely impair particle formation. Regions outside of these domains can be deleted without any effect on the density of the particles that are released. However, since density and size are independent parameters for retroviral particles, we employed rate-zonal gradients and electron microscopy in an exhaustive study of mutants lacking the various dispensable segments of Gag to determine which regions would be required to constrain or define the particle dimensions. The only sequence found to be absolutely critical for determining particle size was that of the initial capsid cleavage product, CA-SP, which contains all of the CA sequence plus the spacer peptides located between CA and NC. Some regions of CA-SP appear to be more important than others. In particular, the major homology region does not contribute to defining particle size. Further evidence for interactions among CA-SP domains was obtained from genetic complementation experiments using mutant ΔNC, which lacks the RNA interaction domains in the NC sequence but retains a complete CA-SP sequence. This mutant produces low-density particles heterogeneous in size. It was rescued into particles of normal size and density, but only when the complementing Gag molecules contained the complete CA-SP sequence. We conclude that CA-SP functions during budding in a manner that is independent of the other assembly domains.     

Characterization of a small (25-kilodalton) derivative of the Rous sarcoma virus Gag protein competent for particle release.

Retroviral Gag proteins have the ability to induce budding and particle release from the plasma membrane when expressed in the absence of all of the other virus-encoded components; however, the locations of the functional domains within the Gag protein that are important for this process are poorly understood. It was shown previously that the protease sequence of the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) Gag protein can be replaced with a foreign polypeptide, iso-1-cytochrome c from a yeast, without disrupting particle assembly (R. A. Weldon, Jr., C. R. Erdie, M. G. Oliver, and J. W. Wills, J. Virol. 64:4169-4179, 1990). An unexpected product of the chimeric gag gene is a small, Gag-related protein named p25C. This product was of interest because of its high efficiency of packaging into particles. The goal of the experiments described here was to determine the mechanism by which p25C is synthesized and packaged into particles. The results demonstrate that it is not the product of proteolytic processing of the Gag-cytochrome precursor but is derived from an unusual spliced mRNA. cDNA clones of the spliced mRNA were obtained, and each expressed a product of approximately 25 kDa, designated p25M1, which was released into the growth medium in membrane-enclosed particles that were much lighter than authentic retrovirions as measured in sucrose density gradients. DNA sequencing revealed that the clones encode the first 180 of the 701 amino acids of the RSV Gag protein and no residues from iso-1-cytochrome c. This suggested that a domain in the carboxy-terminal half of Gag is important for the packaging of Gag proteins into dense arrays within the particles. In support of this hypothesis, particles of the correct density were obtained when a small segment from the carboxy terminus of the RSV Gag protein (residues 417 to 584) was included on the end of p25.     

Mutations in the spacer peptide and adjoining sequences in Rous sarcoma virus Gag lead to tubular budding

All orthoretroviruses encode a single structural protein, Gag, which is necessary and sufficient for the assembly and budding of enveloped virus-like particles from the cell. The Gag proteins of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) and human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) contain a short spacer peptide (SP or SP1, respectively) separating the capsid (CA) and nucleocapsid (NC) domains. SP or SP1 and the residues immediately upstream are known to be critical for proper assembly. Using mutagenesis and electron microscopy analysis of insect cells or chicken cells overexpressing RSV Gag, we defined the SP assembly domain to include the last 8 residues of CA, all 12 residues of SP, and the first 4 residues of NC. Five- or two-amino acid glycine-rich insertions or substitutions in this critical region uniformly resulted in the budding of abnormal, long tubular particles. The equivalent SP1-containing HIV-1 Gag sequence was unable to functionally replace the RSV sequence in supporting normal RSV spherical assembly. According to secondary structure predictions, RSV and HIV-1 SP/SP1 and adjoining residues may form an alpha helix, and what is likely the functionally equivalent sequence in murine leukemia virus Gag has been inferred by mutational analysis to form an amphipathic alpha helix. However, our alanine insertion mutagenesis did not provide evidence for an amphipathic helix in RSV Gag. Taken together, these results define a short assembly domain between the folded portions of CA and NC, which is essential for formation of the immature Gag shell.     

Budding of equine infectious anemia virus is insensitive to proteasome inhibitors

The only retrovirus protein required for the budding of virus-like particles is the Gag protein; however, recent studies of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) and human immunodeficiency virus have suggested that modification of Gag with ubiquitin (Ub) is also required. As a consequence, the release of these viruses is reduced in the presence of proteasome inhibitors, which indirectly reduce the levels of free Ub within the cell. Here we show that the budding of equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV) from infected equine cells is largely unaffected by these drugs, although use of one inhibitor (MG-132) resulted in a dramatic block to proteolytic processing of Gag. This lack of sensitivity was also observed in transiently transfected avian cells under conditions that greatly reduce RSV budding. Moreover, insensitivity was observed when the EIAV Gag protein was expressed in the absence of all the other virus products, indicating that they are not required for this phenotype. An activity that enables EIAV to tolerate exposure to proteasome inhibitors was mapped to the C-terminal p9 sequence, as demonstrated by the ability of an RSV Gag-p9 chimera to bud in the presence of the drugs. Intriguingly, the p9 sequence contains a short sequence motif that is similar to a surface-exposed helix of Ub, suggesting that EIAV Gag may have captured a function that allows it to bypass the need for ubiquitination. Thus, the mechanism of EIAV budding may not be substantially different from that of other retroviruses, even though it behaves differently in the presence of proteasome inhibitors.     

The membrane-binding domain of the Rous sarcoma virus Gag protein.

The Gag protein of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) can direct particle assembly and budding at the plasma membrane independently of the other virus-encoded products. A previous deletion analysis has suggested that the first 86 amino acids of RSV Gag constitute a large membrane-binding domain that is absolutely required for these processes. To test this hypothesis, we inserted these residues in place of the N-terminal membrane-binding domain of the pp60v-src, a transforming protein whose biological activity requires plasma membrane localization. The ability of the Src chimera to induce cellular transformation suggests that the RSV sequence indeed contains an independent, functional domain.     

The Mason-Pfizer monkey virus internal scaffold domain enables in vitro assembly of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Gag

The Mason-Pfizer monkey virus (M-PMV) Gag protein possesses the ability to assemble into an immature capsid when synthesized in a reticulocyte lysate translation system. In contrast, the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) Gag protein is incapable of assembly in parallel assays. To enable the assembly of HIV Gag, we have combined or inserted regions of M-PMV Gag into HIV Gag. By both biochemical and morphological criteria, several of these chimeric Gag molecules are capable of assembly into immature capsid-like structures in this in vitro system. Chimeric species containing large regions of M-PMV Gag fused to HIV Gag sequences failed to assemble, while species consisting of only the M-PMV p12 region, and its internal scaffold domain (ISD), fused to HIV Gag were capable of assembly, albeit at reduced kinetics compared to M-PMV Gag. The ability of the ISD to induce assembly of HIV Gag, which normally assembles at the plasma membrane, suggests a common requirement for a concentrating factor in retrovirus assembly. Despite the dramatic effect of the ISD on chimera assembly, the function of HIV Gag domains in that process was found to remain essential, since an assembly-defective mutant of HIV CA, M185A, abolished assembly when introduced into the chimera. This continued requirement for HIV Gag domain function in the assembly of chimeric molecules will allow this in vitro system to be used for the analysis of potential inhibitors of HIV immature particle assembly.     

Importance of Basic Residues in the Nucleocapsid Sequence for Retrovirus Gag Assembly and Complementation Rescue

The Gag proteins of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) contain small interaction (I) domains within their nucleocapsid (NC) sequences. These overlap the zinc finger motifs and function to provide the proper density to viral particles. There are two zinc fingers and at least two I domains within these Gag proteins. To more thoroughly characterize the important sequence features and properties of I domains, we analyzed Gag proteins that contain one or no zinc finger motifs. Chimeric proteins containing the amino-terminal half of RSV Gag and various portions of the carboxy terminus of murine leukemia virus (MLV) (containing one zinc finger) Gag had only one I domain, whereas similar chimeras with human foamy virus (HFV) (containing no zinc fingers) Gag had at least two. Mutational analysis of the MLV NC sequence and inspection of I domain sequences within the zinc-fingerless C terminus of HFV Gag suggested that clusters of basic residues, but not the zinc finger motif residues themselves, are required for the formation of particles of proper density. In support of this, a simple string of strongly basic residues was found to be able to substitute for the RSV I domains. We also explored the possibility that differences in I domains (e.g., their number) account for differences in the ability of Gag proteins to be rescued into particles when they are unable to bind to membranes. Previously published experiments have shown that such membrane-binding mutants of RSV and HIV (two I domains) can be rescued but that those of MLV (one I domain) cannot. Complementation rescue experiments with RSV-MLV chimeras now map this difference to the NC sequence of MLV. Importantly, the same RSV-MLV chimeras could be rescued by complementation when the block to budding was after, rather than before, transport to the membrane. These results suggest that MLV Gag molecules begin to interact at a much later time after synthesis than those of RSV and HIV.     

Incorporation of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Gag proteins into murine leukemia virus virions.

The retroviral Gag polyprotein is necessary and sufficient for assembly and budding of viral particles. However, the exact inter- and intramolecular interactions of the Gag polyproteins during this process are not known. To locate functional domains within Gag, we generated chimeric proviruses between human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) and murine leukemia virus (MuLV). In these chimeric proviruses, the matrix or capsid proteins of MuLV were precisely replaced with the matrix or capsid proteins of HIV-1. Although the chimeric proviruses were unable to efficiently assemble into mature viral particles by themselves, coexpression of wild-type MuLV Gag rescued the HIV proteins into virions. The specificity of the rescue of HIV proteins into MuLV virions shows that specific interactions involving homologous matrix or capsid regions of Gag are necessary for retroviral particle formation.     

Particle Size Determinants in the Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Gag Protein

The retroviral Gag protein plays the central role in the assembly process and can form membrane-enclosed, virus-like particles in the absence of any other viral products. These particles are similar to authentic virions in density and size. Three small domains of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Gag protein have been previously identified as being important for budding. Regions that lie outside these domains can be deleted without any effect on particle release or density. However, the regions of Gag that control the size of HIV-1 particles are less well understood. In the case of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), the size determinant maps to the CA (capsid) and adjacent spacer sequences within Gag, but systematic mapping of the HIV Gag protein has not been reported. To locate the size determinants of HIV-1, we analyzed a large collection of Gag mutants. To our surprise, all mutants with defects in the MA (matrix), CA, and the N-terminal part of NC (nucleocapsid) sequences produced dense particles of normal size, suggesting that oncoviruses (RSV) and lentiviruses (HIV-1) have different size-controlling elements. The most important region found to be critical for determining HIV-1 particle size is the p6 sequence. Particles lacking all or small parts of p6 were uniform in size distribution but very large as measured by rate zonal gradients. Further evidence for this novel function of p6 was obtained by placing this sequence at the C terminus of RSV CA mutants that produce heterogeneously sized particles. We found that the RSV-p6 chimeras produced normally sized particles. Thus, we present evidence that the entire p6 sequence plays a role in determining the size of a retroviral particle.     

In vivo interference of Rous sarcoma virus budding by cis expression of a WW domain

For all enveloped viruses, the actual mechanism by which nascent virus particles separate or "pinch off" from the cell surface is largely unknown. In the case of retroviruses, the Gag protein drives the budding process, and the virus release step is directed by the late (L) assembly domain within Gag. A PPPPY motif within the L domain of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) was previously characterized as being critical for the release of virions and shown to interact in vitro with the WW domain of Yes-associated protein (Yap). To determine whether WW domain-L domain interactions can occur in vivo, we attempted to interfere with the host cell machinery normally recruited to the site of budding by inserting this WW domain in different locations within Gag. At a C-terminal location, the WW(Yap) domain had no effect on budding, suggesting that the intervening I domains (which provide the major region of Gag-Gag interaction) prevent its access to the L domain. When positioned on the other side of the I domains closer to the L domain, the WW(Yap) domain resulted in a dramatic interference of particle release, and confocal microscopy revealed a block to budding on the plasma membrane. Budding was restored by attachment of the heterologous L domain of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Gag, which does not bind WW(Yap). These findings suggest that cis expression of WW domains can interfere with RSV particle release in vivo via specific, high-affinity interactions at the site of assembly on the plasma membrane, thus preventing host factor accessibility to the L domain and subsequent virus-cell separation. In addition, they suggest that L domain-specific host factors function after Gag proteins begin to interact.     

Genetic analysis of interactions between Gag proteins of Rous sarcoma virus.

The yeast two-hybrid system was used to characterize homomeric interactions between the Gag proteins of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV). The RSV Gag precursor was found to interact strongly with itself and not with various control proteins. The RSV Gag did not interact significantly with Gag proteins of a variety of other retroviruses, including murine leukemia viruses and primate lentiviruses. Deletion analysis suggested that two nonoverlapping regions are independently sufficient to mediate RSV Gag-Gag dimerization. One such region lies near the N terminus and contains p2, p10, and a large N-terminal part of the capsid (CA) domain; the other is localized in the C terminus and includes a small C-terminal portion of CA and the nucleocapsid protein. These interaction domains may play roles in viral assembly.     

Evidence for a second function of the MA sequence in the Rous sarcoma virus Gag protein.

During retrovirus assembly, Gag proteins bind to the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane to initiate the budding process. The molecular basis of this protein-lipid interaction is poorly understood. For the human, immunodeficiency virus type 1 Gag protein, we recently reported that the membrane-binding domain resides within the N-terminal 31 amino acids and consists of two components: myristate and a cluster of basic residues, which together promote membrane binding in vitro and budding in vivo (W. Zhou, L. J. Parent, J. W. Wills, and M. D. Resh, J. Virol. 68:2556-2569, 1994). The positively charged residues associate electrostatically with acidic phospholipids to stabilize membrane binding, while myristate provides membrane-binding energy via hydrophobic interactions. Here we demonstrate that the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Gag membrane-binding domain can fully replace the membrane-targeting function of the N-terminal 100 residues of the non-myristylated Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) Gag protein. To further explore the importance of myristate and basic residues in membrane binding, we developed a gain-of-function assay whereby budding was restored to defective mutants of RSV Gag. Detailed mutational analysis revealed that the position, number, and context of charged residues are crucial to budding. Myristate provides additional membrane-binding energy, which is critical when a Gag protein is near the threshold of stable membrane association. Finally, viruses with altered matrix (MA) proteins that are noninfectious, even though they produce particles with high efficiency, were identified. Thus, we present the first evidence that the RSV MA sequence plays two distinct roles, membrane binding during particle assembly and a second, as yet undefined function required for viral infectivity.     

Mutations in the PPPY motif of vesicular stomatitis virus matrix protein reduce virus budding by inhibiting a late step in virion release

The N terminus of the matrix (M) protein of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) and of other rhabdoviruses contains a highly conserved PPPY sequence (or PY motif) similar to the late (L) domains in the Gag proteins of some retroviruses. These L domains in retroviral Gag proteins are required for efficient release of virus particles. In this report, we show that mutations in the PPPY sequence of the VSV M protein reduce virus yield by blocking a late stage in virus budding. We also observed a delay in the ability of mutant viruses to cause inhibition of host gene expression compared to wild-type (WT) VSV. The effect of PY mutations on virus budding appears to be due to a block at a stage just prior to virion release, since electron microscopic examination of PPPA mutant-infected cells showed a large number of assembled virions at the plasma membrane trapped in the process of budding. Deletion of the glycoprotein (G) in addition to these mutations further reduced the virus yield to less than 1% of WT levels, and very few particles were assembled at the cell surface. This observation suggested that G protein aids in the initial stage of budding, presumably during the formation of the bud site. Overall, our results confirm that the PPPY sequence of the VSV M protein possesses L domain activity analogous to that of the retroviral Gag proteins.     

Human foamy virus capsid formation requires an interaction domain in the N terminus of Gag

Retroviral Gag expression is sufficient for capsid assembly, which occurs through interaction between distinct Gag domains. Human foamy virus (HFV) capsids assemble within the cytoplasm, although their budding, which mainly occurs in the endoplasmic reticulum, requires the presence of homologous Env. Yet little is known about the molecular basis of HFV Gag precursor assembly. Using fusions between HFV Gag and a nuclear reporter protein, we have identified a strong interaction domain in the N terminus of HFV Gag which is predicted to contain a conserved coiled-coil motif. Deletion within this region in an HFV provirus abolishes viral production through inhibition of capsid assembly.     

An assembly domain of the Rous sarcoma virus Gag protein required late in budding.

The Gag protein of Rous sarcoma virus has the ability to direct particle assembly at the plasma membrane in the absence of all the other virus-encoded components. An extensive deletion analysis has revealed that very large regions of this protein can be deleted without impairing budding and has suggested that the essential functions map to three discrete regions. In the studies reported here, we establish the location of assembly domain 2 (AD2) within the proline-rich p2b sequence of this Gag protein. AD2 mutants lacking the p2b sequence were completely defective for particle release even though their Gag proteins were tightly associated with the membrane fraction and exhibited high levels of protease activity. Mutations that inactivate the viral protease did not restore budding to wild-type levels for these mutants, indicating that the defect is not due simply to a loss of protease regulation. AD2 mutants could be rescued into dense particles in genetic complementation assays, indicating that their defect is not due to a gross alteration of the overall conformation of the protein and that the assembly function is not needed on every Gag molecule in the population. Several mutants with amino acid substitutions in the p2b sequence were found to have an intermediate capacity for budding. Inactivation of the protease of these mutants stabilized the Gag polyprotein within the cells and allowed an increase in particle release; however, the rate of budding remained slow. We favor the idea that AD2 is a dynamic region of movement, perhaps serving as a molecular hinge to allow the particle to emerge from the surface of the cell during budding.