Evaluation of a new modulus mapping technique to investigate microstructural features of human teeth

Teeth contain several calcified tissues with junctions that provide interfaces between dissimilar tissues. These junctions have been difficult to characterize because of their small size. In this work a new technique using a combination of atomic force microscopy (AFM) and a force-displacement transducer was used to simultaneously study the surface topography and map mechanical properties of the junctions and adjacent hard tissues. Prepared specimens from human third molars were scanned by an AFM piezo-tube in contact mode. To measure the dynamic viscoelastic properties of the material a small sinusoidal force was superimposed on the contact force and the resulting displacement amplitude and the phase shift between the force and amplitude were measured. This force modulation technique was used to map the local variation of nanomechanical properties of intertubular dentin, peritubular dentin, enamel, dentin-enamel junction (DEJ) and peritubular-intertubular dentin junction (PIJ). This new technique allowed us to measure the widths of these junctions in addition to local variation in dentin and enamel without causing plastic deformation to the material and with 2 orders of magnitude increase in spatial resolution compared with previous studies that used discrete nanoindentation techniques. Due to the ability to analyze the sample line-by-line, the distribution functions associated with the width of the DEJ and PIJ were conveniently obtained for specific intratooth locations. The data suggested, for three third molar specimens, a DEJ width of 2-3 microm with full-width half-maximum (FWHM) of 0.7 microm and PIJ width of 0.5-1.0 microm with 0.3 microm FWHM. The intertubular dentin storage modulus variation was between 17 and 23 GPa with a mean value of 21 GPa. The range of storage modulus for enamel near the DEJ was between 51 and 74 GPa with a mean value of 63 GPa.     

Synchrotron microComputed Tomography of the mature bovine dentinoenamel junction

The mature dentinoenamel junction (DEJ) is viewed by some investigators and the current authors, not as a fossilized, sharp transition between enamel and dentin, but as a relatively broad structural transition zone including the mantle dentin and the inner aprismatic enamel. In this study, the DEJ structure in bovine incisors was studied with synchrotron microComputed Tomography (microCT) using small cubes cut parallel to the tooth surface. The reconstructions revealed a zone of highly variable punctate contrast between bulk dentin and enamel; the mean linear attenuation coefficients and their standard deviations demonstrated that this zone averaged less mineral than dentin or enamel but had more highly variable structure than either. The region with the punctuate contrast is, therefore, the mantle dentin. The thickness of the mantle dentin seen in a typical data set was about 30 microm, and the mantle dentin-enamel interface deviated +/-15 microm from the average plane over a distance of 520 microm. In the highest resolution data ( approximately 1.5 microm isotropic voxels, volume elements), tubules in the dentin could be discerned in the vicinity of the DEJ. Contrast sensitivity was high enough to detect differences in mineral content between near-surface and near-DEJ volumes of the enamel. Reconstructions before and after two cubes were compressed to failure revealed cracks formed only in the enamel and did not propagate across the mantle dentin, regardless of whether loading was parallel to or perpendicular to the DEJ.     

Structure and mechanical properties of the soft zone separating bulk dentin and enamel in crowns of human teeth: insight into tooth function

The 200-300 microm soft zone of dentin, found beneath enamel in crowns of human teeth, is thought to fulfill important roles in tooth function, but little is known about its structure-mechanical relations. Scanning electron microscopy images of fracture surfaces showed that near the dentino-enamel junction (DEJ), a porous reticulate matrix of intertubular-dentin contains tubules with no peritubular lining. Peritubular-dentin however is found at some distance from the DEJ, and it gradually thickens with increasing depth into the bulk dentin. Concurrently, tighter packing of the collagen fibers is observed with a gradual increase in mineral deposits on and between the fibers. This structurally graded zone is known to be softer when tested for micro-hardness. It undergoes greater strain compared to bulk dentin, when measured using Moiré interferometry. We investigated the deformation and stiffness of this zone by means of non-contact laser-speckle interferometry (ESPI), and nanometer-scale deformations were tracked during compression-testing performed in water. We report a significantly reduced stiffness of this zone compared to bulk dentin, with mid-buccal regions of teeth averaging 3.5 GPa compared with 9.7 GPa in mid-lingual regions. Our results support and expand upon the hypothesis that the durability of the whole tooth relies upon a bucco-lingual asymmetric matching of stiffness by means of an interphase: a cushioning soft layer between enamel and bulk dentin.     

Functional significance of the microstructural detail of the primate dentino-enamel junction: a possible example of exaptation

In primate teeth, the dentino-enamel junction (DEJ) exhibits a scalloped appearance, the functional importance of which has been the subject of various suggestions and speculations. Simplified finite-element (FE) models of DEJ microanatomy were created, both in 2D and 3D, and their biomechanical behavior was tested and compared. Consistently, the models with the scalloped DEJ, although having higher maximum tensile stresses than the straight DEJ models, showed discontinuous concentrations of stress. In straight DEJ models, tensile stresses act at the DEJ over continuous areas in a direction, which would push the two tissues apart, thus leading to delamination of the DEJ. Perhaps even more important, in the scallop model, the net-compression towards the DEJ was consistently higher than net-tension away from it. As a consequence, dentine and enamel would be pushed towards each other during loading (i.e., during mastication). These findings suggest that the scalloped nature of the DEJ confers a biomechanical advantage to the integrity of the tooth during mastication. Furthermore, there exists a correlation between pronounced prism decussation and scallop magnitude, suggesting that scallops may have been selected for in response to high bite forces. However, given the equivocal relationship between scallops and presumed bite force across mammalian taxa, we propose that scallops could in fact be exaptations.     

High energy X-ray scattering quantification of in situ-loading-related strain gradients spanning the dentinoenamel junction (DEJ) in bovine tooth specimens

High energy X-ray scattering (80.7 keV photons) at station 1-ID of the Advanced Photon Source quantified internal strains as a function of applied stress in mature bovine tooth. These strains were mapped from dentin through the dentinoenamel junction (DEJ) into enamel as a function of applied compressive stress in two small parallelepiped specimens. One specimen was loaded perpendicular to the DEJ and the second parallel to the DEJ. Internal strains in enamel and dentin increased and, as expected from the relative values of the Young’s modulus, the observed strains were much higher in dentin than in enamel. Large strain gradients were observed across the DEJ, and the data suggest that the mantle dentin-DEJ-aprismatic enamel structure may shield the near-surface volume of the enamel from large strains. In the enamel, drops in internal strain for applied stresses above 40 MPa also suggest that this structure had cracked.     

Microscale frictional response of bovine articular cartilage from atomic force microscopy

The objective of this study was to compare micro- and macroscale friction coefficients of bovine articular cartilage. Microscale measurements were performed using standard atomic force microscopy (AFM) techniques, using a 5 microm spherical probe tip. Twenty-four cylindrical osteochondral plugs were harvested in pairs from adjacent positions in six fresh bovine humeral heads (4-6 months old), and divided into two groups for AFM and macroscopic friction measurements. AFM measurements of friction were observed to be time-independent, whereas macroscale measurements demonstrated the well-documented time-dependent increase from a minimum to an equilibrium value. The microscale AFM friction coefficient (mu(AFM), 0.152+/-0.079) and macroscale equilibrium friction coefficient (mu(eq), 0.138+/-0.036) exhibited no statistical differences (p=0.50), while the macroscale minimum friction coefficient (mu(min), 0.004+/-0.001) was significantly smaller than mu(eq) and mu(AFM) (p<0.0001). Variations in articular surface roughness (Rq= 462+/-216 nm) did not correlate significantly with mu(AFM), mu(eq) or mu(min). The effective compressive modulus determined from AFM indentation tests using a Hertz contact analysis was E*=45.8+/-18.8 kPa. The main finding of this study is that mu(AFM) is more representative of the macroscale equilibrium friction coefficient, which represents the frictional response in the absence of cartilage interstitial fluid pressurization. These results suggest that AFM measurements may be highly suited for exploring the role of boundary lubricants in diarthrodial joint lubrication independently of the confounding effect of fluid pressurization to provide greater insight into articular cartilage lubrication.     

Effect of prism orientation and loading direction on contact stresses in prismatic enamel of primates: implications for interpreting wear patterns

The ability of prisms to effectively dissipate contact stress at the surface will influence wear rates in teeth. The aim of this investigation was to begin to quantify the effect of prism orientation on surface stresses. Seven finite element models of enamel microstructure were created, each model differing in the angulation of prism orientation with regard to the wear surface. For validation purposes, the mechanical behavior of the model was compared with published experimental data. In order to test the enamel under lateral loads, a compressed food particle was dragged across the surface from the dentino-enamel junction (DEJ) towards the outer enamel surface (OES). Under these conditions, tensile stresses in the enamel model increased with increases in the coefficient of friction. More importantly, stresses were found to be lowest in models in which the prisms approach the surface at lower angles (i.e., more obliquely cut prisms), and highest when the prisms approached the surface at 60 degrees (i.e., less obliquely cut). Finally, the direction of travel of the simulated food particle was reversed, allowing comparison of the difference in behavior between trailing and leading edge enamels (i.e., when the food particle was dragged either towards or away from the DEJ). Stresses at the trailing edge were usually lower than stresses at the leading edge. Taken together with what is known about prism orientation in primate teeth, such findings imply greater wear resistance at the intercuspal region and less wear resistance at the lateral enamel at midcrown. Such findings appear to be supported by archeological evidence.     

Dentin sialoprotein and dentin phosphoprotein overexpression during amelogenesis

The gene for dentin sialophosphoprotein produces a single protein that is post-translationally modified to generate two distinct extracellular proteins: dentin sialoprotein and dentin phosphoprotein. In teeth, dentin sialophosphoprotein is expressed primarily by odontoblast cells, but is also transiently expressed by presecretory ameloblasts. Because of this expression profile it appears that dentin sialophosphoprotein contributes to the early events of amelogenesis, and in particular to those events that result in the formation of the dentino-enamel junction and the adjacent "aprismatic" enamel. Using a transgenic animal approach we have extended dentin sialoprotein or dentin phosphoprotein expression throughout the developmental stages of amelogenesis. Overexpression of dentin sialoprotein results in an increased rate of enamel mineralization, however, the enamel morphology is not significantly altered. In wild-type animals, the inclusion of dentin sialoprotein in the forming aprismatic enamel may account for its increased hardness properties, when compared with bulk enamel. In contrast, the overexpression of dentin phosphoprotein creates "pitted" and "chalky" enamel of non-uniform thickness that is more prone to wear. Disruptions to the prismatic enamel structure are also a characteristic of the dentin phosphoprotein overexpressing animals. These data support the previous suggestion that dentin sialoprotein and dentin phosphoprotein have distinct functions related to tooth formation, and that the dentino-enamel junction should be viewed as a unique transition zone between enamel and the underlying dentin. These results support the notion that the dentin proteins expressed by presecretory ameloblasts contribute to the unique properties of the dentino-enamel junction.     

High-resolution electron-microscopic study of the relationship between human enamel and dentin crystals at the dentinoenamel junction

The development of dentin and of enamel share a common starting locus: the dentinoenamel junction (DEJ). In this study the relationship between enamel and dentin crystals has been investigated in order to highlight the guiding or modulating role of the previously mineralized dentin layer during enamel formation. Observations were made with a high-resolution electron microscope and, after digitalization, image-analysis software was used to obtain digital diffractograms of individual crystals. In general no direct epitaxial growth of enamel crystals onto dentin crystals could be demonstrated. The absence of direct contact between the two kinds of crystals and the presence of amorphous areas within enamel particles at the junction with dentin crystals were always noted. Only in a few cases was the relationship between enamel and dentin crystals observed, which suggested a preorganization of the enamel matrix influenced by the dentin surface structure. This could be explained either by the existence of a proteinaceous continuum between enamel and dentin or by the orientation of enamel proteins by dentin crystals.     

Ectopic expression of dentin sialoprotein during amelogenesis hardens bulk enamel

Dentin sialophosphpoprotein (Dspp) is transiently expressed in the early stage of secretory ameloblasts. The secretion of ameloblast-derived Dspp is short-lived, correlates to the establishment of the dentinoenamel junction (DEJ), and is consistent with Dspp having a role in producing the specialized first-formed harder enamel adjacent to the DEJ. Crack diffusion by branching and dissipation within this specialized first-formed enamel close to the DEJ prevents catastrophic interfacial damage and tooth failure. Once Dspp is secreted, it is subjected to proteolytic cleavage that results in two distinct proteins referred to as dentin sialoprotein (Dsp) and dentin phosphoprotein (Dpp). The purpose of this study was to investigate the biological and mechanical contribution of Dsp and Dpp to enamel formation. Transgenic mice were engineered to overexpress either Dsp or Dpp in their enamel organs. The mechanical properties (hardness and toughness) of the mature enamel of transgenic mice were compared with genetically matched and age-matched nontransgenic animals. Dsp and Dpp contributions to enamel formation greatly differed. The inclusion of Dsp in bulk enamel significantly and uniformly increased enamel hardness (20%), whereas the inclusion of Dpp weakened the bulk enamel. Thus, Dsp appears to make a unique contribution to the physical properties of the DEJ. Dsp transgenic animals have been engineered with superior enamel mechanical properties.