Repair of MMS-induced DNA double-strand breaks in haploid cells of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which requires the presence of a duplicate genome.

Summary The formation and repair of double-strand breaks induced in DNA by MMS was studied in haploid wild type and MMS-sensitive rad6 mutant strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae with the use of the neutral and alkaline sucrose sedimentation technique. A similar decrease in average molecular weight of double-stranded DNA from 5–6x10⁸ to 1–0.7x10⁸ daltons was observed following treatment with 0.5% MMS in wild type and mutant strains. Incubation of cells after MMS treatment in a fresh drug-free growing medium resulted in repair of double-strand breaks in the wild type strain, but only in the exponential phase of growth. No repair of double-strand breaks was found when cells of the wild type strain were synchronized in G-1 phase by treatment with factor, although DNA single-strand breaks were still efficiently repaired. Mutant rad6 which has a very low ability to repair MMS-induced single-strand breaks, did not repair double-strand breaks regardless of the phase of growth.These results suggest that (1) repair of double-strand breaks requires the ability for single-strand breaks repair, (2) rejoining of double-strand breaks requires the availability of two homologous DNA molecules, this strongly supports the recombinational model of DNA repair.     

Disorder of the repair of DNA double-stranded breaks in radiosensitive mutants of Saccharomyces cerevisiae yeasts

DNA double-strand break repair and restoration of viability in X-irradiated diploid yeast cells homozygous for rad50, rad51, rad52, rad55 mutations were studies under conditions of keeping the cells in non-nutrient medium, after irradiation. All the cells were synchronized at the G1 stage of the cell cycle. In contrast to the wild-type yeast, this group of mutants are unable to repair DNA double-strand breaks and do not enhance viability, when kept in non-nutrient medium after irradiation.     

Repair of double-strand breaks in plasmid DNA in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Summary We studied the repair of double-strand breaks (DSB) in plasmid DNA introduced into haploid cells of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The efficiency of repair was estimated from the frequency of transformation of the cells by an autonomously replicated linearized plasmid. The frequency of lithium transformation of Rad⁺ cells was increased greatly (by 1 order of magnitude and more) compared with that for circular DNA if the plasmid was initially linearized at the XhoI site within the LYS2 gene. This effect is due to recombinational repair of the plasmid DNA. Mutations rad52, rad53, rad54 and rad57 suppress the repair of DSB in plasmid DNA. The kinetics of DSB repair in plasmid DNA are biphasic: the first phase is completed within 1 h and the second within 14–18 h of incubating cells on selective medium.     

Requirement for End-Joining and Checkpoint Functions, but Not RAD52-Mediated Recombination, after EcoRI Endonuclease Cleavage of Saccharomyces cerevisiae DNA

RAD52 and RAD9 are required for the repair of double-strand breaks (DSBs) induced by physical and chemical DNA-damaging agents in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Analysis of EcoRI endonuclease expression in vivo revealed that, in contrast to DSBs containing damaged or modified termini, chromosomal DSBs retaining complementary ends could be repaired in rad52 mutants and in G₁-phase Rad⁺ cells. Continuous EcoRI-induced scission of chromosomal DNA blocked the growth of rad52 mutants, with most cells arrested in G₂ phase. Surprisingly, rad52 mutants were not more sensitive to EcoRI-induced cell killing than wild-type strains. In contrast, endonuclease expression was lethal in cells deficient in Ku-mediated end joining. Checkpoint-defective rad9 mutants did not arrest cell cycling and lost viability rapidly when EcoRI was expressed. Synthesis of the endonuclease produced extensive breakage of nuclear DNA and stimulated interchromosomal recombination. These results and those of additional experiments indicate that cohesive ended DSBs in chromosomal DNA can be accurately repaired by RAD52-mediated recombination and by recombination-independent complementary end joining in yeast cells.     

DNA repair and the genetic effects of thymidylate stress in yeast

Folate antagonists, such as aminopterin, methotrexate and various sulfonamides, block de novo thymidylate biosynthesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The resulting starvation for thymine nucleotides is lethal and recombinagenic in RAD wild-type strains. In this paper we report our studies of these effects in repair-deficient yeast. Antifolate treatment of various rad mutants revealed that repair defects influence the killing and recombination caused by thymidylate deprivation. Compared to a RAD wild-type strain, diploids homozygous for rad3, rad6 or rad18 were more resistant to cell killing. Thus, contrary to findings with conventional DNA-damaging agents, the lethal effects of thymidylate starvation appear to be ameliorated by certain DNA repair deficiencies. On the other hand, a rad50 strain was extremely sensitive to the antifolates. Within this series of diploids, increasing sensitivity to thymidylate starvation was accompanied by an increase in recombination frequencies. The degrees of lethality and recombination, induced by thymidylate depletion, were correlated with the severity of DNA-strand breakage in the RAD and rad50 strains. Experiments with diploids homozygous for rad52, rad54 or rad57 suggested that aborted recombination events, provoked by thymidylate deprivation, caused chromosome loss. Furthermore, the repair defects in these mutants indicated that double-strand breaks are among the lethal lesions induced by thymine nucleotide starvation. Finally, we discuss the possibility that the recombinagenicity of thymidylate stress may account for one type of acquired resistance to methotrexate in mammalian cells.     

Repair of DNA double-strand breaks in Escherichia coli, which requires recA function and the presence of a duplicate genome.

A method was devised for extracting, from cells of Escherichia coli K12, DNA molecules which sedimented on neutral sucrose gradients as would be expected for free DNA molecules approaching the genome in size. Gamma ray irradiation of oxygenated cells produced 0.20 DNA double-strand breaks per kilorad per 10⁹ daltons. Incubation after irradiation of cells grown in K medium, with four to five genomes per cell, showed repair of the double-strand breaks. No repair of double-strand breaks was found in cells grown in aspartate medium, with only 1.3 genomes per cell, although DNA single-strand breaks were still efficiently repaired. Cells which were recA^? or recA^?recB^? also did not repair double-strand breaks. These results suggest that repair of DNA double-strand breaks may occur by a recombinational event involving another DNA double helix with the same base sequence.     

Induction and repair of double- and single-strand DNA breaks in bacteriophage lambda superinfecting Escherichia coli

Induction and repair of double- and single-strand DNA breaks have been measured after decays of 125I and 3H incorporated into the DNA and after external irradiation with 4 MeV electrons. For the decay experiments, cells of wild type Escherichia coli K-12 were superinfected with bacteriophage lambda DNA labelled with 5'-(125I)iodo-2'-deoxyuridine or with (methyl-3H)thymidine and frozen in liquid nitrogen. Aliquots were thawed at intervals and lysed at neutral pH, and the phage DNA was assayed for double- and single-strand breakage by neutral sucrose gradient centrifugation. The gradients used allowed measurements of both kinds of breaks in the same gradient. Decays of 125I induced 0.39 single-strand breaks per double-strand break. No repair of either break type could be detected. Each 3H disintegration caused 0.20 single-strand breaks and very few double-strand breaks. The single-strand breaks were rapidly rejoined after the cells were thawed. For irradiation with 4 MeV electrons, cells of wild type E. coli K-12 were superinfected with phage lambda and suspended in growth medium. Irradiation induced 42 single-strand breaks per double-strand break. The rates of break induction were 6.75 x 10(-14) (double-strand breaks) and 2.82 x 10(-12) (single-strand breaks) per rad and per dalton. The single-strand breaks were rapidly repaired upon incubation whereas the double-strand breaks seemed to remain unrepaired. It is concluded that double-strand breaks in superinfecting bacteriophage lambda DNA are repaired to a very small extent, if at all.     

Roles of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAD17</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">CHK1</Emphasis> checkpoint genes in the repair of double-strand breaks in cycling cells

Checkpoints are components of signalling pathways involved in genome stability. We analysed the putative dual functions of Rad17 and Chk1 as checkpoints and in DNA repair using mutant strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Logarithmic populations of the diploid checkpoint-deficient mutants, chk1Δ/chk1Δ and rad17Δ/rad17Δ, and an isogenic wild-type strain were exposed to the radiomimetic agent bleomycin (BLM). DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) determined by pulsed-field electrophoresis, surviving fractions, and proliferation kinetics were measured immediately after treatments or after incubation in nutrient medium in the presence or absence of cycloheximide (CHX). The DSBs induced by BLM were reduced in the wild-type strain as a function of incubation time after treatment, with chromosomal repair inhibited by CHX. rad17Δ/rad17Δ cells exposed to low BLM concentrations showed no DSB repair, low survival, and CHX had no effect. Conversely, rad17Δ/rad17Δ cells exposed to high BLM concentrations showed DSB repair inhibited by CHX. chk1Δ/chk1Δ cells showed DSB repair, and CHX had no effect; these cells displayed the lowest survival following high BLM concentrations. Present results indicate that Rad17 is essential for inducible DSB repair after low BLM-concentrations (low levels of oxidative damage). The observations in the chk1Δ/chk1Δ mutant strain suggest that constitutive nonhomologous end-joining is involved in the repair of BLM-induced DSBs. The differential expression of DNA repair and survival in checkpoint mutants as compared to wild-type cells suggests the presence of a regulatory switch-network that controls and channels DSB repair to alternative pathways, depending on the magnitude of the DNA damage and genetic background. Nelson Bracesco and Ema C. Candreva have contributed equally to this article.     

DNA repair in cells of the radiosensitive mutant of Drosophila rad(2)201GI after gamma-irradiation]

A radiosensitive mutant of Drosophila melanogaster rad(2)201GI was analysed for the capacity to repair DNA single- and double-strand breaks induced by gamma-rays. Analysis was performed on cell cultures derived from embryos of homozygous mutant stock and wild type strain Oregon R. The viability of irradiated cells was studied. It was shown that the mutant strain cells had increased lethality, just like a whole organism. Single-strand breaks were analysed by alkaline sucrose gradient centrifugation; double-strand breaks were monitored by neutral elution. The similarity of repair kinetics of single- and double-strand breaks in cells of rad(2)201GI and Oregon R was shown. Probable molecular mechanisms of rad(2)201GI mutant radiosensitivity are under discussion.     

Repair of 8-methoxypsoralen photoinduced cross-links in yeast

Summary The repair of interstrand cross-links induced by 8-methoxypsoralen plus UVA (365 nm) radiation DNA was analyzed in diploid strains of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The strains employed were the wild-type D₇ and derivatives homozygous for the rad18-1 or the rad3-12 mutation. Alkaline step-elution and electron microscopy were performed to follow the process of induction and removal of photoinduced crosslinks. In accordance with previous reports, the D₇ rad3-12 strain failed to remove the induced lesions and could not incise cross-links. The strain D₇ rad18-1 was nearly as efficient in the removal of 8-MOP photoadducts after 2 h of post-treatment incubation as the D₇ RAD⁺ wild-type strain. However, as demonstrated by alkaline step-elution and electron microscopic analysis, the first incision step at DNA cross-links was three times more effective in D₇ rad18-1 than in D₇ RAD⁺. This is consistent with the hypothesis that the RAD18 gene product is involved in the filling of gaps resulting from persistent non-informational DNA lesions generated by the endonucleolytic processing of DNA cross-links. Absence of this gene product may lead to extensive strand breakage and decreased recognition of such lesions by structural repair systems.     

RAD51 is required for the repair of plasmid double-stranded DNA gaps from either plasmid or chromosomal templates

DNA double-strand breaks may be induced by endonucleases, ionizing radiation, chemical agents, and mechanical forces or by replication of single-stranded nicked chromosomes. Repair of double-strand breaks can occur by homologous recombination or by nonhomologous end joining. A system was developed to measure the efficiency of plasmid gap repair by homologous recombination using either chromosomal or plasmid templates. Gap repair was biased toward gene conversion events unassociated with crossing over using either donor sequence. The dependence of recombinational gap repair on genes belonging to the RAD52 epistasis group was tested in this system. RAD51, RAD52, RAD57, and RAD59 were required for efficient gap repair using either chromosomal or plasmid donors. No homologous recombination products were recovered from rad52 mutants, whereas a low level of repair occurred in the absence of RAD51, RAD57, or RAD59. These results suggest a minor pathway of strand invasion that is dependent on RAD52 but not on RAD51. The residual repair events in rad51 mutants were more frequently associated with crossing over than was observed in the wild-type strain, suggesting that the mechanisms for RAD51-dependent and RAD51-independent events are different. Plasmid gap repair was reduced synergistically in rad51 rad59 double mutants, indicating an important role for RAD59 in RAD51-independent repair.     

Effect of <Emphasis Type="Italic">rad50</Emphasis> mutation on illegitimate recombination in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Saccharomyces cerevisiae</Emphasis>

Genes in the RAD52 epistasis group are involved in repairing DNA double-stranded breaks via homologous recombination. We have previously shown that RAD50 is involved in mitotic nonhomologous integration but not in homologous integration. However, the role of Rad50 in nonhomologous integration has not previously been examined. In the current work, we report that the rad50∆ mutation caused a tenfold decrease in the frequency of nonhomologous integration with the majority of nonhomologous integrants showing an unstable Ura⁺ phenotype. Sequencing analysis of the integration target sites showed that integration events of both ends of the integrating vector in the rad50∆ mutant occurred at different chromosomal locations, resulting in large deletions or translocations on the genomic insertion sites. Interestingly, 47% of events in the rad50∆ mutant were integrated into repetitive sequences including rDNA locus, telomeres and Ty elements and 27% of events were integrated into non-repetitive sequences as compared to 11% of events integrated into rDNA and 70% into non-repetitive sequences in the wild-type cells. These results showed that deletion of RAD50 significantly changes the distribution of different classes of integration events, suggesting that Rad50 is required for nonhomologous integration at non-repetitive sequences more so than at repetitive ones. Furthermore, Southern analysis indicated that half of the events contained deletions at one or at both ends of the integrating DNA fragment, suggesting that Rad50 might have a role in protecting free ends of double-strand breaks. In contrast to the rad50∆ mutant, the rad50S mutant (separation of function allele) slightly increases the frequency of nonhomologous integration but the distribution of integration events is similar to that of wild-type cells with the majority of events integrated into a chromosomal locus. Our results suggest that deletion of RAD50 may block the major pathway of nonhomologous integration into a non-repetitive chromosomal locus and Rad50 may be involved in tethering two ends of the integrating DNA into close proximity that facilitates nonhomologous integration of both ends into a single chromosomal locus.     

Repair of Double-Strand DNA Gaps in Yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae: Homology-Dependent Ligation and the Role of the RAD55 Gene

In our previous works, a mutation in the RAD57 gene was shown to induce the plasmid DNA double-strand gap (DSG) repair via a special recombinational repair mechanism: homology-dependent ligation responsible for reuniting disrupted plasmid ends without reconstructing the sequence lost because of the DSG. In this work, the role of the RAD55 gene in the plasmid DNA DSG repair was studied. A cold-sensitiverad55-3 mutation markedly decreased the precision of plasmid DNA DSG repair under conditions of restrictive temperature (23°C): only 5–7% of plasmids can repair DSG, whereas under permissive conditions (36°C), DSGs were repaired in approximately 50% of the cells. In the cold-sensitive mutation rad57-1, the proportion of plasmids in which DSGs were repaired was nearly the same under both permissive and restrictive conditions (5–10%). The results indicate that a disturbance in the function of the RAD55 gene, as in the RAD57 gene, leads to a drastic increase in the contribution of homology-dependent ligation to the repair of double-strand DNA breaks.     

Repair of DNA double-strand breaks requires two homologous DNA duplexes

DNA repair and cell survival in haploid and its diploid derivative strains ofSaccharomyces cerevisiae were studied after 100 krad X-ray irradiation. The cells were in theG ₁ stage of the cell cycle, where haploid cells had only one copy of genetic material per genome and diploid had two copies. It was found that diploid could repair double-strand breaks in its DNA after 48 hr of liquid holding which was accompanied by a four-fold rise in survival. In contrast a haploid strain failed to repair its DNA and showed no increase in survival after liquid holding. It is concluded that (1) repair of DNA double-strand breaks requires the availability of two homologous DNA duplexes, (2) restoration of cell viability during liquid holding is connected with repair of DNA double-strand breaks and (3) this repair is a slow process possibly associated with slow finding and conjugation of homologous chromosomes.     

WRN protects against topo I but not topo II inhibitors by preventing DNA break formation

The Werner syndrome helicase/3′-exonuclease (WRN) is a major component of the DNA repair and replication machinery. To analyze whether WRN is involved in the repair of topoisomerase-induced DNA damage we utilized U2-OS cells, in which WRN is stably down-regulated (wrn-kd), and the corresponding wild-type cells (wrn-wt). We show that cells not expressing WRN are hypersensitive to the toxic effect of the topoisomerase I inhibitor topotecan, but not to the topoisomerase II inhibitor etoposide. This was shown by mass survival assays, colony formation and induction of apoptosis. Upon topotecan treatment WRN deficient cells showed enhanced DNA replication inhibition and S-phase arrest, whereas after treatment with etoposide they showed the same cell cycle response as the wild-type. A considerable difference between WRN and wild-type cells was observed for DNA single- and double-strand break formation in response to topotecan. Topotecan induced DNA single-strand breaks 6 h after treatment. In both wrn-wt and wrn-kd cells these breaks were repaired at similar kinetics. However, in wrn-kd but not wrn-wt cells they were converted into DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) at high frequency, as shown by neutral comet assay and phosphorylation of H2AX. Our data provide evidence that WRN is involved in the repair of topoisomerase I, but not topoisomerase II-induced DNA damage, most likely via preventing the conversion of DNA single-strand breaks into DSBs during the resolution of stalled replication forks at topo I–DNA complexes. We suggest that the WRN status of tumor cells impacts anticancer therapy with topoisomerase I, but not topoisomerase II inhibitors.     

Repair of cellular radiation damage in space under microgravity conditions

The influence of microgravity on the repair of x-ray-induced DNA double-strand breaks was studied in the temperature-conditional repair mutant rad54–3 of diploid yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Cells were exposed on the ground and kept at a low temperature until microgravity conditions were achieved. In orbit, they were incubated at the permissive temperature to allow repair. Before re-entry they were again cooled down and kept at a low temperature until final analysis. The experiment, which was flown on the shuttle Atlantis on flight STS-76 (SMM-03), showed that repair of pre-formed DNA double-strand breaks in yeast is not impaired by microgravity. Received: 1 September 1998 / Accepted in revised form: 23 March 1999     

Mre11-Rad50 Promotes Rapid Repair of DNA Damage in the Polyploid Archaeon Haloferax volcanii by Restraining Homologous Recombination

Polyploidy is frequent in nature and is a hallmark of cancer cells, but little is known about the strategy of DNA repair in polyploid organisms. We have studied DNA repair in the polyploid archaeon Haloferax volcanii, which contains up to 20 genome copies. We have focused on the role of Mre11 and Rad50 proteins, which are found in all domains of life and which form a complex that binds to and coordinates the repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). Surprisingly, mre11 rad50 mutants are more resistant to DNA damage than the wild-type. However, wild-type cells recover faster from DNA damage, and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis shows that DNA double-strand breaks are repaired more slowly in mre11 rad50 mutants. Using a plasmid repair assay, we show that wild-type and mre11 rad50 cells use different strategies of DSB repair. In the wild-type, Mre11-Rad50 appears to prevent the repair of DSBs by homologous recombination (HR), allowing microhomology-mediated end-joining to act as the primary repair pathway. However, genetic analysis of recombination-defective radA mutants suggests that DNA repair in wild-type cells ultimately requires HR, therefore Mre11-Rad50 merely delays this mode of repair. In polyploid organisms, DSB repair by HR is potentially hazardous, since each DNA end will have multiple partners. We show that in the polyploid archaeon H. volcanii the repair of DSBs by HR is restrained by Mre11-Rad50. The unrestrained use of HR in mre11 rad50 mutants enhances cell survival but leads to slow recovery from DNA damage, presumably due to difficulties in the resolution of DNA repair intermediates. Our results suggest that recombination might be similarly repressed in other polyploid organisms and at repetitive sequences in haploid and diploid species.     

Role of the Rad52 Amino-terminal DNA Binding Activity in DNA Strand Capture in Homologous Recombination

Saccharomyces cerevisiae Rad52 protein promotes homologous recombination by nucleating the Rad51 recombinase onto replication protein A-coated single-stranded DNA strands and also by directly annealing such strands. We show that the purified rad52-R70A mutant protein, with a compromised amino-terminal DNA binding domain, is capable of Rad51 delivery to DNA but is deficient in DNA annealing. Results from chromatin immunoprecipitation experiments find that rad52-R70A associates with DNA double-strand breaks and promotes recruitment of Rad51 as efficiently as wild-type Rad52. Analysis of gene conversion intermediates reveals that rad52-R70A cells can mediate DNA strand invasion but are unable to complete the recombination event. These results provide evidence that DNA binding by the evolutionarily conserved amino terminus of Rad52 is needed for the capture of the second DNA end during homologous recombination.     

Repair of uracil residues closely spaced on the opposite strands of plasmid DNA results in double-strand break and deletion formation

Summary The role of closely spaced lesions on both DNA strands in the induction of double-strand breaks and formation of deletions was studied. For this purpose a polylinker sequence flanked by 165 by direct repeats was inserted within the tet gene of pBR327. This plasmid was used to construct DNA containing one or two uracil residues which replaced cytosine residues in the Kpnl restriction site of the polylinker. Incubation of the plasmid DNA construct with Escherichia coli cell-free extracts showed that double-strand breaks occurred as a result of excision repair of the opposing uracil residues by uracil-DNA glycosylase (in extracts from ung ⁺ but not in extracts from ung ^– E. coli strains). Recombination of direct repeats, induced by double-strand breakage of plasmid DNA, can lead to the deletion of the polylinker and of one of the direct repeats, thus restoring the tet ⁺ gene function which can be detected by the appearance of tetracycline-resistant colonies of transformants. Transformation of E. coli cells with single or double uracil-containing DNAs demonstrated that DNA containing two closely spaced uracil residues was tenfold more effective in the induction of deletions than DNA containing only a single uracil residue. The frequency of deletions is increased tenfold in an ung ⁺ E. coli strain in comparison with an ung ^– strain, suggesting that deletions are induced by double-strand breakage of plasmid DNA which occurs in vivo as a result of the excision of opposing uracil residues.     

Toxicity and mutagenicity of X-rays and [I]dUrd or [H]TdR incorporated in the DNA of human lymphoblast cells

We measured the toxicity and mutagenicity induced in human diploid lymphoblasts by various radiation doses of X-rays and two internal emitters. [¹²⁵I]iododeoxyuridine ([¹²⁵I]dUrd) and [³H]thymidine ([³H]TdR), incorporated into cellular DNA. [¹²⁵I]dUrd was more effective than [³H]TdR at killing cells and producing mutations to 6-thioguanine resistance (6TG^R). No ouabain-resistant mutants were induced by any of these agents. Expressing dose as total disintegrations per cell (dpc), the D₀ for cell killing for [¹²⁵I]dUrd was 28 dpc and for [³H]TdR was 385 dpc. The D₀ for X-rays was 48 rad at 37°C. The slopes of the mutation curves were approximately 75 × 10⁻⁸ 6TG^R mutants per cell per disintegration for [¹²⁵I]dUrd and 2 × 10⁻⁸ for [³H]TdR. X-Rays induced 8 × 10⁻⁸ 6TG^R mutants per cell per rad. Normalizing for survival, [¹²⁵I]dUrd remained much more mutagenic at low doses (high survival levels) than the other two agents. Treatment of the cells at either 37°C or while frozen at −70°C yielded no difference in cytotoxicity or mutation for [¹²⁵I]dUrd or [³H]TdR, whereas X-rays were 6 times less effective in killing cells at −70°C.Assuming that incorporation was random throughout the genome, the mutagenic efficiencies of the radionuclides could be calculated by dividing the mutation rate by the level of incorporation. If the effective target size of the 6TG^R locus is 1000–3000 base pairs, then the mutagenic efficiency of [¹²⁵I]dUrd is 1.0–3.0 and of [³H]TdR is 0.02–0.06 total genomic mutations per cell per disintegration. ¹²⁵I disintegrations are known to produce localized DNA double-strand breaks. If these breaks are potentially lethal lesions, they must be repaired, since the mean lethal dose (D₀) was 28 dpc. The observations that a single dpc has a high probability of producing a mutation (mutagenic efficiency 1.0–3.0) would suggest, however, that this repair is extremely error-prone. If the breaks need not be repaired to permit survival, then lethal lesions are a subset of or are completely different from mutagenic lesions.