Adaptive amplification: an inducible chromosomal instability mechanism

Adaptive mutation is an induced response to environmental stress in which mutation rates rise, producing permanent genetic changes that can adapt cells to stress. This contrasts with neo-Darwinian views of genetic change rates blind to environmental conditions. DNA amplification is a flexible, reversible genomic change that has long been postulated to be adaptive. We report the discovery of adaptive amplification at the lac operon in Escherichia coli. Additionally, we find that adaptive amplification is separate from, and does not lead to, adaptive point mutation. This contradicts a prevailing alternative hypothesis whereby adaptive mutation is normal mutability in amplified DNA. Instead, adaptive mutation and amplification are parallel routes of inducible genetic instability allowing rapid evolution under stress, and escape from growth inhibition.     

In pursuit of a molecular mechanism for adaptive gene amplification

"Adaptive" or "stationary-phase" mutation is a collection of apparent stress responses in which cells exposed to a growth-limiting environment generate genetic changes, some of which can allow resumption of rapid growth. In the well-characterized Lac system of Escherichia coli, reversions of a lac frameshift allele give rise to adaptive point mutations. Also in this system, adaptive gene amplification has been documented as a separate and parallel response that allows growth on lactose medium without acquisition of a compensatory frameshift mutation. In amplification, the DNA region containing the weakly functional lac allele becomes amplified to multiple copies, which produce sufficient enzyme activity to allow growth on the otherwise growth-limiting lactose medium. The amplifications are "adaptive" in that they occur after cells encounter the growth-limiting environment. Adaptive amplification is a reversible genetic change that allows adaptation and growth. It may be similar to chromosomal instability observed in the origins and progression of many cancers. We explore possible molecular mechanisms of adaptive amplification in the bacterial system and note parallels to chromosomal instability in other systems.     

Gene amplification in a human osteosarcoma cell line results in the persistence of the original chromosome and the formation of translocation chromosomes.

Although gene amplification, a process that is markedly enhanced in tumor cells, has been studied in many different cell systems, there is still controversy about the mechanism(s) involved in this process. It is still unclear what happens to the DNA sequences that become amplified, whether they remain present at their original location (conservative gene amplification) or whether gene amplification necessarily results in a deletion at the original location (non-conservative gene amplification). We have studied gene amplification in a human osteosarcoma cell line, starting from a cell clone which contains only one copy of a plasmid integrate. Independent amplificants, originating from this clone and containing elevated plasmid copy numbers, were isolated and analyzed. Based on previous observations, encompassing the persistence of single-copy DNA sequences besides amplified DNA sequences clustered at a different location in the independent amplificants, we proposed an amplification pathway including a local duplication step and transposition of the duplicated DNA to other chromosomal positions. Now we have extended our study to more independent amplificants. We prove that the single-copy plasmid-containing chromosomes in the different amplificants and the single-copy plasmid-containing chromosome in the original parental cell clone are indeed identical, namely a translocation chromosome composed of at least three parts of which two originate from chromosomes 14 and 17. We show that the unit of amplification and the unit of the proposed transposition event are at least 1.5 Mb. We also demonstrate that the amplified DNA sequences, present at genomic locations other than the original single-copy DNA sequences, are preferentially associated with chromosome 16. We find that the amplified DNA sequences are often located at or near a site of chromosome translocation involving chromosome 16. In one cell clone we detect the amplified DNA sequences in most of the cells to be located within a complete chromosome 16 while in a minority of cells the amplified sequences are located at or near a breakpoint on a translocation chromosome 16. This indicates that this amplification region is highly unstable and frequently gives rise to translocation events.     

What limits the efficiency of double-strand break-dependent stress-induced mutation in Escherichia coli?

Stress-induced mutation is a collection of molecular mechanisms in bacterial, yeast and human cells that promote mutagenesis specifically when cells are maladapted to their environment, i.e. when they are stressed. Here, we review one molecular mechanism: double-strand break (DSB)-dependent stress-induced mutagenesis described in starving Escherichia coli. In it, the otherwise high-fidelity process of DSB repair by homologous recombination is switched to an error-prone mode under the control of the RpoS general stress response, which licenses the use of error-prone DNA polymerase, DinB, in DSB repair. This mechanism requires DSB repair proteins, RpoS, the SOS response and DinB. This pathway underlies half of spontaneous chromosomal frameshift and base substitution mutations in starving E. coli [Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2011;108:13659-13664], yet appeared less efficient in chromosomal than F' plasmid-borne genes. Here, we demonstrate and quantify DSB-dependent stress-induced reversion of a chromosomal lac allele with DSBs supplied by I-SceI double-strand endonuclease. I-SceI-induced reversion of this allele was previously studied in an F'. We compare the efficiencies of mutagenesis in the two locations. When we account for contributions of an F'-borne extra dinB gene, strain background differences, and bypass considerations of rates of spontaneous DNA breakage by providing I-SceI cuts, the chromosome is still ～100 times less active than F. We suggest that availability of a homologous partner molecule for recombinational break repair may be limiting. That partner could be a duplicated chromosomal segment or sister chromosome.     

A Mechanism of Gene Amplification Driven by Small DNA Fragments

DNA amplification is a molecular process that increases the copy number of a chromosomal tract and often causes elevated expression of the amplified gene(s). Although gene amplification is frequently observed in cancer and other degenerative disorders, the molecular mechanisms involved in the process of DNA copy number increase remain largely unknown. We hypothesized that small DNA fragments could be the trigger of DNA amplification events. Following our findings that small fragments of DNA in the form of DNA oligonucleotides can be highly recombinogenic, we have developed a system in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae to capture events of chromosomal DNA amplification initiated by small DNA fragments. Here we demonstrate that small DNAs can amplify a chromosomal region, generating either tandem duplications or acentric extrachromosomal DNA circles. Small fragment-driven DNA amplification (SFDA) occurs with a frequency that increases with the length of homology between the small DNAs and the target chromosomal regions. SFDA events are triggered even by small single-stranded molecules with as little as 20-nt homology with the genomic target. A double-strand break (DSB) external to the chromosomal amplicon region stimulates the amplification event up to a factor of 20 and favors formation of extrachromosomal circles. SFDA is dependent on Rad52 and Rad59, partially dependent on Rad1, Rad10, and Pol32, and independent of Rad51, suggesting a single-strand annealing mechanism. Our results reveal a novel molecular model for gene amplification, in which small DNA fragments drive DNA amplification and define the boundaries of the amplicon region. As DNA fragments are frequently found both inside cells and in the extracellular environment, such as the serum of patients with cancer or other degenerative disorders, we propose that SFDA may be a common mechanism for DNA amplification in cancer cells, as well as a more general cause of DNA copy number variation in nature.     

Intrastrand annealing leads to the formation of a large DNA palindrome and determines the boundaries of genomic amplification in human cancer

Amplification of large chromosomal regions (gene amplification) is a common somatic alteration in human cancer cells and often is associated with advanced disease. A critical event initiating gene amplification is a DNA double-strand break (DSB), which is immediately followed by the formation of a large DNA palindrome. Large DNA palindromes are frequent and nonrandomly distributed in the genomes of cancer cells and facilitate a further increase in copy number. Although the importance of the formation of large DNA palindromes as a very early event in gene amplification is widely recognized, it is not known how a DSB is resolved to form a large DNA palindrome and whether any local DNA structure determines the location of large DNA palindromes. We show here that intrastrand annealing following a DNA double-strand break leads to the formation of large DNA palindromes and that DNA inverted repeats in the genome determine the efficiency of this event. Furthermore, in human Colo320DM cancer cells, a DNA inverted repeat in the genome marks the border between amplified and nonamplified DNA. Therefore, an early step of gene amplification is a regulated process that is facilitated by DNA inverted repeats in the genome.     

DNA base sequence changes induced by ultraviolet light mutagenesis of a gene on a chromosome in Chinese hamster ovary cells

The DNA base sequence changes induced by mutagenesis with ultraviolet light have been determined in a gene on a chromosome of cultured Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The gene was the Escherichia coli gpt gene, of which a single copy was stably incorporated and expressed in the CHO cell genome. The cells were irradiated with ultraviolet light and gpt- colonies were selected by resistance to 6-thioguanine. The gpt gene was amplified from chromosomal DNA by use of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and the amplified DNA sequenced directly by the dideoxy method. Of the 58 sequenced mutants of independent origin 53 were base change mutations. Forty-one base substitutions were single base changes, ten had two adjacent (or tandem) base changes, and one had two base changes separated by a single base-pair. Only one mutant had a multiple base change mutation with two or more well separated base changes. In contrast much higher levels of such mutations were reported in ultraviolet mutagenesis of genes on a shuttle vector in primate cells. Two deletions of a single base-pair were observed and three deletions ranging from 6 to 37 base-pairs. The mutation spectrum in the gpt gene had similarities to the ultraviolet mutation spectra for several genes in prokaryotes, which suggests similarities in mutational mechanisms in prokaryotes and eukaryotes.     

Regularities of karyotypic evolution during stepwise amplification of genes determining drug resistance.

Analysis of chromosomal alterations during stepwise development of mdr1, dhfr, or CAD gene amplifications in a large number of independently selected Djungarian hamster DM-15 and murine P388 sublines revealed typical patterns of karyotypic evolution, specific for multiplication of each of these genes in each cell type. Some principal similarities of karyotypic evolution were noted in at least two different systems. They include: (i) appearance at the first selection step of a new chromosomal arm bearing the resident gene copy followed at the next selection steps by the formation in these specific chromosomal arms of amplified DNA tandem arrays; (ii) translocations of amplified DNA from its initial site to other, also non-random, chromosomal sites; and (iii) emergence in the cell variants with high degrees of gene amplification of multiple extra-chromosomal elements. The most prominent distinctions among the systems were as follows: (i) different structures, evidently containing amplified DNAs, appeared at the initial steps of amplification of different genes--additional heterogeneously staining regions in specific chromosomal segments in the case of amplification of dhfr or CAD genes in DM-15 cells, and mini-chromosomes in the case of mdr1 gene amplification in both DM-15 and P380 cells; (ii) distinct patterns of location of the amplified mdr1 gene copies are characteristic of Djungarian hamster DM-15 and murine P388 cell derivatives after subsequent steps of selection--at the site of resident gene localization or in some other, also non-random, chromosomal sites in DM-15 sublines, and predominantly extra-chromosomal in P388 sublines. We propose that different mechanisms are responsible for the initial steps of amplification of dhfr and CAD genes on the one hand and the mdr1 gene on the other: non-equal sister-chromatid exchanges and autonomous replication of the extra-chromosomal elements. It seems, however, that both mechanisms may be involved in further rounds of amplification of each of these three genes.     

DNA amplification in multidrug, cross-resistant Chinese hamster ovary cells: molecular characterization and cytogenetic localization of the amplified DNA

Vincristine-resistant (VCR) Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells have been established by stepwise selection in increasing concentrations of vincristine. These cells exhibit multidrug cross-resistance to a number of drugs that have no structural or functional similarities. Cytogenetic analyses of resistant cells revealed the presence of double minutes and expanded chromosomal segments, thus implicating gene amplification as a possible mechanism of resistance. An amplified DNA segment isolated from other multidrug cross-resistant CHO cell lines (Roninson, I. B., H. T. Abelson, D. E. Housman, N. Howell, and A. Varshavsky, 1984, Nature (Lond.), 309:626-628) is also amplified in our VCR lines. This DNA segment was used as a probe to screen a cosmid library of VCR genomic DNA, and overlapping clones were retrieved. All of these segments, totaling approximately 45 kilobases (kb), were amplified in VCR cells. Using in situ hybridization, we localized the amplification domain to the long arm of CHO chromosome 1 or Z1. Northern hybridization analysis revealed that a 4.3-kb mRNA was encoded by this amplified DNA domain and was over-produced in the VCR cells. Suggestions for the involvement of these amplified DNA segments in the acquisition of multidrug cross-resistance in animal cells are also presented.     

Mechanisms of DNA sequence amplification and their evolutionary consequences

DNA sequence amplification is a phenomenon that occurs predictably at defined stages during normal development in some organisms and has been shown to occur spontaneously, but sporadically, in a variety of cells, including mammalian cells, selected for overproduction of a gene product. Developmentally programmed gene amplification includes rDNA amplification during o?genesis in amphibia, chorion protein gene amplification in Drosophila and the chromosomal changes accompanying macronuclear formation in ciliates. Selected gene amplification is illustrated by mutant mammalian cells which have been selected in vitro or in vivo for the overproduction of a gene product. In these cells the unit of DNA that is amplified is much larger than the gene under selection, and appears to be formed by multiple recombination events, which bring together sequences not normally adjacent to each other. Often the product of amplification can be seen microscopically as aberrant chromosome forms. The vast majority of DNA amplification events occur in somatic nuclei, and thus would not have any direct effect on the evolution of a genome. However, the ability to amplify DNA in somatic cells does have consequences for the composition of the genomes of the organisms in which it can occur, and should DNA amplification occur, even sporadically, in germ-line cells the potential effect on evolution would be great.     

On the mechanism of gene amplification induced under stress in Escherichia coli

Gene amplification is a collection of processes whereby a DNA segment is reiterated to multiple copies per genome. It is important in carcinogenesis and resistance to chemotherapeutic agents, and can underlie adaptive evolution via increased expression of an amplified gene, evolution of new gene functions, and genome evolution. Though first described in the model organism Escherichia coli in the early 1960s, only scant information on the mechanism(s) of amplification in this system has been obtained, and many models for mechanism(s) were possible. More recently, some gene amplifications in E. coli were shown to be stress-inducible and to confer a selective advantage to cells under stress (adaptive amplifications), potentially accelerating evolution specifically when cells are poorly adapted to their environment. We focus on stress-induced amplification in E. coli and report several findings that indicate a novel molecular mechanism, and we suggest that most amplifications might be stress-induced, not spontaneous. First, as often hypothesized, but not shown previously, certain proteins used for DNA double-strand-break repair and homologous recombination are required for amplification. Second, in contrast with previous models in which homologous recombination between repeated sequences caused duplications that lead to amplification, the amplified DNAs are present in situ as tandem, direct repeats of 7–32 kilobases bordered by only 4 to 15 base pairs of G-rich homology, indicating an initial non-homologous recombination event. Sequences at the rearrangement junctions suggest nonhomologous recombination mechanisms that occur via template switching during DNA replication, but unlike previously described template switching events, these must occur over long distances. Third, we provide evidence that 3′-single-strand DNA ends are intermediates in the process, supporting a template-switching mechanism. Fourth, we provide evidence that lagging-strand templates are involved. Finally, we propose a novel, long-distance template-switching model for the mechanism of adaptive amplification that suggests how stress induces the amplifications. We outline its possible applicability to amplification in humans and other organisms and circumstances.     

Delayed chromosomal instability induced by DNA damage.

DNA damage induced by ionizing radiation can result in gene mutation, gene amplification, chromosome rearrangements, cellular transformation, and cell death. Although many of these changes may be induced directly by the radiation, there is accumulating evidence for delayed genomic instability following X-ray exposure. We have investigated this phenomenon by studying delayed chromosomal instability in a hamster-human hybrid cell line by means of fluorescence in situ hybridization. We examined populations of metaphase cells several generations after expanding single-cell colonies that had survived 5 or 10 Gy of X rays. Delayed chromosomal instability, manifested as multiple rearrangements of human chromosome 4 in a background of hamster chromosomes, was observed in 29% of colonies surviving 5 Gy and in 62% of colonies surviving 10 Gy. A correlation of delayed chromosomal instability with delayed reproductive cell death, manifested as reduced plating efficiency in surviving clones, suggests a role for chromosome rearrangements in cytotoxicity. There were small differences in chromosome destabilization and plating efficiencies between cells irradiated with 5 or 10 Gy of X rays after a previous exposure to 10 Gy and cells irradiated only once. Cell clones showing delayed chromosomal instability had normal frequencies of sister chromatid exchange formation, indicating that at this cytogenetic endpoint the chromosomal instability was not apparent. The types of chromosomal rearrangements observed suggest that chromosome fusion, followed by bridge breakage and refusion, contributes to the observed delayed chromosomal instability.     

The very large amplifiable element AUD2 from Streptomyces lividans 66 has insertion sequence-like repeats at its ends.

In a spontaneous, chloramphenicol-sensitive (Cms), arginine-auxotrophic (Arg-) mutant of Streptomyces lividans 1326, two amplified DNA sequences were found. One of them was the well-characterized 5.7-kb ADS1 sequence, amplified to about 300 copies per chromosome. The second one was a 92-kb sequence called ADS2. ADS2 encoding the previously isolated mercury resistance genes of S. lividans was amplified to around 20 copies per chromosome. The complete ADS2 sequence was isolated from a genomic library of the mutant S. lividans 1326.32, constructed in the phage vector lambda EMBL4. In addition, the DNA sequences flanking the corresponding amplifiable element called AUD2 in the wild-type strain were isolated by using another genomic library prepared from S. lividans 1326 DNA. Analysis of the ends of AUD2 revealed the presence of an 846-bp sequence on both sides repeated in the same orientation. Each of the direct repeats ended with 18-bp inverted repeated sequences. This insertion sequence-like structure was confirmed by the DNA sequence determined from the amplified copy of the direct repeats which demonstrated a high degree of similarity of 65% identity in nucleic acid sequence to IS112 from Streptomyces albus. The recombination event leading to the amplification of AUD2 occurred within these direct repeats, as shown by DNA sequence analysis. The amplification of AUD2 was correlated with a deletion on one side of the flanking chromosomal region beginning very near or in the amplified DNA. Strains of S. lividans like TK20 and TK21 which are mercury sensitive have completely lost AUD2 together with flanking chromosomal DNA on one or both sides.     

Elimination of introns from the interleukin 1 beta genome by DNA amplification and expression of interleukin 1 beta in Escherichia coli]

The use of the polymerase chain reaction was proposed for intron excision from genomic genes with known nucleotide sequences. Three exons (5, 6 and 7) of genomic interleukin 1 beta gene were amplified by means of thermostable DNA polymerase TthI from Thermus thermophilus on the base of cloned in M13 phage human genomic interleukin 1 beta gene. Synthetic oligonucleotides complementary to sequences flanking exons were used as primers. The fragments obtained by exon DNA amplification were joined in the correct order due to reciprocal complementation of end sequences, that was foreseen during synthesis of oligonucleotide primers followed by amplification of the enlarged fragments. As a result the structural interleukin-1 beta gene consisting of three exons was assembled. DNA sequences carrying the ATG initiation codon and XbaI recognition site at the 5'-end, and PstI recognition site at the 3'-end (essential for insertion into the expression vector) were formed by the additional end sequences of primers. The nucleotide sequence analysis of the obtained structural gene revealed its complete identity with natural interleukin 1 beta human gene. We created the expression vector pPR114 with phage lambda promoter PR thermo-inducible in case of the cIts857 repressor presence in cells. It was used for expression of the present gene. The interleukin 1 beta synthesized in E. coli had biological activity.     

Unstable and stable CAD gene amplification: importance of flanking sequences and nuclear environment in gene amplification.

We analyzed the amplification of the CAD gene in independently isolated N-(phosphonacetyl)-L-aspartate-resistant clones derived from single parental clones in two mouse cell lines. We report for the first time that the CAD gene is amplified unstably in mouse cells, that the degree of instability varies greatly between clones, and that minute chromosomes and highly unstable chromosomelike structures contain the amplified sequences. These data are most consistent with the idea that the amplified unit in each clone consists of different flanking DNA and that such differences engender amplified sequences with unequal stability. We also introduced the mouse chromosome containing the CAD gene into hamster cells by microcell-mediated chromosome transfer to determine whether the propensity for unstable extrachromosomal amplification of the mouse CAD gene would prevail in the hamster cell nuclear environment. We report that the mouse CAD gene was amplified stably in expanded chromosomal regions in each of seven hybrids that were analyzed. This observation is consistent with the idea that the nuclear environment influences whether mutants containing intra- or extrachromosomally amplified sequences will be isolated.     

RNA-driven genetic changes in bacteria and in human cells

As recently demonstrated in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae model organism using synthetic RNA-containing oligonucleotides (oligos), RNA can serve as a template for DNA synthesis at the chromosomal level during the process of double-strand break (DSB) repair. Herein we show that the phenomenon of RNA-mediated DNA modification and repair is not limited to yeast cells. A tract of six ribonucleotides embedded in single-strand DNA oligos corresponding to either lagging or leading strand sequences could serve as a template to correct a defective lacZ marker gene in the chromosome of the bacterium Escherichia coli. In order to test the capacity of RNA to modify DNA in mammalian cells, we utilized DNA oligos containing an embedded tract of six ribonucleotides, as well as oligos mostly made of RNA. These oligos were designed to repair a chromosomal break generated within a copy of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene randomly integrated into the genome of human HEK-293 cells. We show that these RNA-containing oligos can serve as templates to repair a DSB in human cells and can introduce base changes into genomic or plasmid DNA. In both E. coli and human cells, the strand bias of chromosomal gene correction by the single-strand RNA-containing oligos was the same as that obtained for the corresponding DNA molecules. Therefore, the RNA-containing oligos are not converted into a cDNA before annealing with complementary DNA. Overall, we demonstrate that in both bacterial and human cells, as in yeast, RNA sequences can have a direct role in DNA genetic modification and remodeling.     

Detection of chromosomal structural alterations in single cells by SNP arrays: a systematic survey of amplification bias and optimized workflow

Background

In single-cell human genome analysis using whole-genome amplified product, a strong amplification bias involving allele dropout and preferential amplification hampers the quality of results. Using an oligonucleotide single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) array, we systematically examined the nature of this amplification bias, including frequency, degree, and preference for genomic location, and we assessed the effects of this amplification bias on subsequent genotype and chromosomal copy number analyses.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We found a large variability in amplification bias among the amplified products obtained by multiple displacement amplification (MDA), and this bias had a severe effect on the genotype and chromosomal copy number analyses. We established optimal experimental conditions for pre-screening for high-quality amplified products, processing array data, and analyzing chromosomal structural alterations. Using this optimized protocol, we successfully detected previously unidentified chromosomal structural alterations in single cells from a lymphoblastoid cell line. These alterations were subsequently confirmed by karyotype analysis. In addition, we successfully obtained reproducible chromosomal copy number profiles of single cells from the cell line with a complex karyotype, indicating the applicability and potential of our optimized workflow.

Conclusions/Significance

Our results suggest that the quality of amplification products should be critically assessed before using them for genomic analyses. The method of MDA-based whole-genome amplification followed by SNP array analysis described here will be useful for exploring chromosomal alterations in single cells.