Lambda repressor inactivation: properties of purified ind- proteins in the autodigestion and RecA-mediated cleavage reactions

Under physiological conditions, lambda repressor can be inactivated in vivo or in vitro by RecA-mediated cleavage of the polypeptide chain. The repressor protein is thought to cleave itself, with RecA acting to stimulate autodigestion. ind- repressor mutants are resistant to RecA-mediated inactivation in vivo. In this paper, we report the purification of 15 ind- repressor proteins and the behaviors of these proteins in the RecA-mediated and autodigestion cleavage reactions. None of these proteins undergoes substantial RecA-dependent cleavage. However, eight mutant proteins autodigest at the same rate as wild-type repressor, six mutants do not autodigest or autodigest slower, and one mutant autodigests faster than wild-type. We discuss these results with respect to repressor structure and RecA-binding, and suggest possible roles for the RecA protein in the cleavage reaction.     

Isolation and characterization of noncleavable (Ind-) mutants of the LexA repressor of Escherichia coli K-12.

The LexA repressor of Escherichia coli represses a set of genes that are expressed in the response to DNA damage. After inducing treatments, the repressor is inactivated in vivo by a specific cleavage reaction which requires an activated form of RecA protein. In vitro, specific cleavage requires activated RecA at neutral pH and proceeds spontaneously at alkaline pH. We have isolated and characterized a set of lexA mutants that are deficient in in vivo RecA-mediated cleavage but retain significant repressor function. Forty-six independent mutants, generated by hydroxylamine and formic acid mutagenesis, were isolated by a screen involving the use of operon fusions. DNA sequence analysis identified 20 different mutations. In a recA mutant, all but four of the mutant proteins functioned as repressor as well as wild-type LexA. In a strain carrying a constitutively active recA allele, recA730, all the mutant proteins repressed a sulA::lacZ fusion more efficiently than the wild-type repressor, presumably because they were cleaved poorly or not at all by the activated RecA protein. These 20 mutations resulted in amino acid substitutions in 12 positions, most of which are conserved between LexA and four other cleavable proteins. All the mutations were located in the hinge region or C-terminal domain of the protein, portions of LexA previously implicated in the specific cleavage reactions. Furthermore, these mutations were clustered in three regions, around the cleavage site (Ala-84-Gly-85) and in blocks of conserved amino acids around two residues, Ser-119 and Lys-156, which are believed essential for the cleavage reactions. These three regions of the protein thus appear to play important roles in the cleavage reaction.     

Autodigestion and RecA-dependent cleavage of Ind- mutant LexA proteins

The LexA repressor of Escherichia coli undergoes a specific cleavage reaction in vivo, an event that leads to derepression of the SOS regulon and requires an activated form of RecA protein. In vitro, cleavage requires RecA at neutral pH; at alkaline pH, a spontaneous cleavage reaction termed autodigestion takes place. Both autodigestion and RecA-mediated cleavage cut the same bond, and are observed for the same set of substrates, suggesting that RecA acts indirectly to stimulate LexA self-cleavage at neutral pH, perhaps binding to LexA and acting as an allosteric effector. We previously isolated a set of lexA(Ind-) mutants that are deficient in in vivo RecA-mediated cleavage but retain significant repressor function. Here, we describe the in vitro cleavage of purified mutant proteins. All of those tested were deficient in both cleavage reactions. Although most of them were equally deficient in both reactions, some were more deficient in one reaction than the other. Several mutant proteins appeared to have defects in binding to RecA. Autodigestion of all but one of the poorly cleavable mutant proteins reached a maximum rate at pH around 10, as does wild-type LexA. The exception was KR156, which changed Lys156, a residue previously implicated in the mechanism of cleavage, to Arg, another basic residue: for this protein, the rate of autodigestion increased with pH at values above 11. RecA-mediated cleavage of KR156 was 1% the wild-type rate at pH 7, but increased with increasing pH to a plateau at pH 9.5, where the rate was 40% the wild-type rate. In contrast, an essentially constant rate was observed for wild-type LexA over the pH range 6 to 11. We suggest, first, that deprotonation of Arg156 and, by inference, Lys156 in the wild-type protein, is required for both autodigestion and RecA-mediated cleavage: and second, that RecA acts to reduce the pKa of Lys156, allowing efficient cleavage of wild-type repressor under physiological conditions.     

In vitro analysis of mutant LexA proteins with an increased rate of specific cleavage.

Specific cleavage of LexA repressor plays a crucial role in the SOS response of Escherichia coli. In vivo, cleavage requires an activated form of RecA protein. However, previous work has shown that the mechanism of cleavage is unusual, in that the chemistry of cleavage is probably carried out by residues in the repressor, and not those in RecA; RecA appears to facilitate this reaction, acting as a coprotease. We recently described a new type of lexA mutation, a class termed lexA (IndS) and here called IndS, that confers an increased rate of in vivo cleavage. Here, we have characterized the in vitro cleavage of these IndS mutant proteins, and of several double mutant proteins containing an IndS mutation and one of several mutations, termed Ind-, that decrease the rate of cleavage. We found, first, that the autodigestion reaction for the IndS mutant proteins had a higher maximum rate and a lower apparent pKa than wild-type LexA. Second, the IndS mutations had little or no effect on the rate of RecA-mediated cleavage, measured at low protein concentrations, implying that the value of Kcat/Km was unaffected. Third, the rate of autodigestion for the double-mutant proteins, relative to wild-type, was about that rate predicted from the product of the effects of the two single mutations. Finally, by contrast, these proteins displayed the same rate of RecA-mediated cleavage as did the single Ind- mutant protein. We interpret these data to mean that the IndS mutations mimic to some extent the effect of RecA on cleavage, perhaps by favoring a conformational change in LexA. We present and analyze a model that embodies these conclusions.     

Phage lambda repressor revertants. Amino acid substitutions that restore activity to mutant proteins

We have isolated same-site and second-site revertants that restore partial activity, wild-type activity, or greater than wild-type activity, to lambda repressor proteins bearing different mutations in the DNA binding domain. In some cases the revertant repressors contain same-site substitutions that are similar to the wild-type side-chain (e.g. Tyr22----Phe, Ser77----Thr). The activity of these revertants makes it possible to assess the role of specific hydrogen bonds and/or packing interactions in repressor structure and function. In other same-site revertants, a very different type of residue is introduced (e.g. Ser35----Leu, Gly48----Asn). This indicates that the chemical and steric requirements at these side-chain positions are relaxed. Two of the second-site revertants, Glu34----Lys and Gly48----Ser, restore activity to more than one primary mutant. Both substitutions apparently increase the affinity of the repressor-operator interaction by introducing new contacts with operator DNA. These results suggest that reversion may be a generally applicable method for identifying sequence changes that increase the activity of a protein to greater than wild-type levels.     

Analysis of Escherichia coli RecA interactions with LexA, lambda CI, and UmuD by site-directed mutagenesis of recA

An early event in the induction of the SOS system of Escherichia coli is RecA-mediated cleavage of the LexA repressor. RecA acts indirectly as a coprotease to stimulate repressor self-cleavage, presumably by forming a complex with LexA. How complex formation leads to cleavage is not known. As an approach to this question, it would be desirable to identify the protein-protein interaction sites on each protein. It was previously proposed that LexA and other cleavable substrates, such as phage lambda CI repressor and E. coli UmuD, bind to a cleft located between two RecA monomers in the crystal structure. To test this model, and to map the interface between RecA and its substrates, we carried out alanine-scanning mutagenesis of RecA. Twenty double mutations were made, and cells carrying them were characterized for RecA-dependent repair functions and for coprotease activity towards LexA, lambda CI, and UmuD. One mutation in the cleft region had partial defects in cleavage of CI and (as expected from previous data) of UmuD. Two mutations in the cleft region conferred constitutive cleavage towards CI but not towards LexA or UmuD. By contrast, no mutations in the cleft region or elsewhere in RecA were found to specifically impair the cleavage of LexA. Our data are consistent with binding of CI and UmuD to the cleft between two RecA monomers but do not provide support for the model in which LexA binds in this cleft.     

Lambda repressor mutations that increase the affinity and specificity of operator binding

Intragenic, second-site reversion has been used to identify amino acid substitutions that increase the affinity and specificity of the binding of lambda repressor to its operator sites. Purified repressors bearing the second-site substitutions bind operator DNA from 3 to 600 fold more strongly than wild type; these affinity changes result from both increased rates of operator association and decreased rates of operator dissociation. Three of the revertant substitutions occur in the alpha 2 and alpha 3 DNA binding helices of repressor and seem to increase affinity by introducing new salt-bridges or hydrogen bonds with the sugar-phosphate backbone of the operator site. The fourth substitution alters the alpha 5 dimerization helix of repressor and appears to increase operator affinity indirectly.     

New recA mutations that dissociate the various RecA protein activities in Escherichia coli provide evidence for an additional role for RecA protein in UV mutagenesis.

To isolate strains with new recA mutations that differentially affect RecA protein functions, we mutagenized in vitro the recA gene carried by plasmid mini-F and then introduced the mini-F-recA plasmid into a delta recA host that was lysogenic for prophage phi 80 and carried a lac duplication. By scoring prophage induction and recombination of the lac duplication, we isolated new recA mutations. A strain carrying mutation recA1734 (Arg-243 changed to Leu) was found to be deficient in phi 80 induction but proficient in recombination. The mutation rendered the host not mutable by UV, even in a lexA(Def) background. Yet, the recA1734 host became mutable upon introduction of a plasmid encoding UmuD*, the active carboxyl-terminal fragment of UmuD. Although the recA1734 mutation permits cleavage of lambda and LexA repressors, it renders the host deficient in the cleavage of phi 80 repressor and UmuD protein. Another strain carrying mutation recA1730 (Ser-117 changed to Phe) was found to be proficient in phi 80 induction but deficient in recombination. The recombination defect conferred by the mutation was partly alleviated in a cell devoid of LexA repressor, suggesting that, when amplified, RecA1730 protein is active in recombination. Since LexA protein was poorly cleaved in the recA1730 strain while phage lambda was induced, we conclude that RecA1730 protein cannot specifically mediate LexA protein cleavage. Our results show that the recA1734 and recA1730 mutations differentially affect cleavage of various substrates. The recA1730 mutation prevented UV mutagenesis, even upon introduction into the host of a plasmid encoding UmuD* and was dominant over recA+. With respect to other RecA functions, recA1730 was recessive to recA+. This demonstrates that RecA protein has an additional role in mutagenesis beside mediating the cleavage of LexA and UmuD proteins.     

Isolation and characterization of LexA mutant repressors with enhanced DNA binding affinity.

The LexA repressor from Escherichia coli is a sequence-specific DNA binding protein that shows no pronounced sequence homology with any of the known structural motifs involved in DNA binding. Since little is known about how this protein interacts with DNA, we have selected and characterized a great number of intragenic, second-site mutations which restored at least partially the activity of LexA mutant repressors deficient in DNA binding. In 47 cases, the suppressor effect of these mutations was due to an Ind- phenotype leading presumably to a stabilization of the mutant protein. With one exception, these second-site mutations are all found in a small cluster (amino acid residues 80 to 85) including the LexA cleavage site between amino acid residues 84 and 85 and include both already known Ind- mutations as well as new variants like GN80, GS80, VL82 and AV84. The remaining 26 independently isolated second-site suppressor mutations all mapped within the amino-terminal DNA binding domain of LexA, at positions 22 (situated in the turn between helix 1 and helix 2) and positions 57, 59, 62, 71 and 73. These latter amino acid residues are all found beyond helix 3, in a region where we have previously identified a cluster of LexA (Def) mutant repressors. In several cases the parental LexA (Def) mutation has been removed by subcloning or site-directed mutagenesis. With one exception, these LexA variants show tighter in vivo repression than the LexA wild-type repressor. The most strongly improved variant (LexA EK71, i.e. Glu71----Lys) that shows an about threefold increased repression rate in vivo, was purified and its binding to a short consensus operator DNA fragment studied using a modified nitrocellulose filter binding assay. As expected from the in vivo data, LexA EK71 interacts more tightly with both operator and (more dramatically) with non-operator DNA. A determination of the equilibrium association constants of LexA EK71 and LexA wild-type as a function of monovalent salt concentration suggests that LexA EK71 might form an additional ionic interaction with operator DNA as compared to the LexA wild-type repressor. A comparison of the binding of LexA to a non-operator DNA fragment further shows that LexA interacts with the consensus operator very selectively with a specificity factor of Ks/Kns of 1.4 x 10(6) under near-physiological salt conditions.     

Analysis of mRNA synthesis following induction of the Escherichia coli SOS system

Escherichia coli responds to impairment of DNA synthesis by inducing a system of DNA repair known as the SOS response. Specific genes are derepressed through proteolytic cleavage of their repressor, the lexA gene product. Cleavage in vivo requires functional RecA protein in a role not yet understood. We used mRNA hybridization techniques to follow the rapid changes that occur with induction in cells with mutations in the recA operator or in the repressor cleavage site. These mutations allowed us to uncouple the induction of RecA protein synthesis from its role in inducing the other SOS functions. Following induction with ultraviolet light, we observed increased rates of mRNA synthesis from five SOS genes within five minutes, maximum expression ten to 20 minutes later and then a later decline to near the initial rates. The presence of a recA operator mutation did not significantly influence these kinetics, whereas induction was fully blocked by an additional mutation in the repressor cleavage site. These experiments are consistent with activation of RecA protein preceding repressor cleavage and derepression of SOS genes. The results also suggest that the timing and extent of induction of individual SOS genes may be different.     

Structure of a hyper-cleavable monomeric fragment of phage lambda repressor containing the cleavage site region

The key event in the switch from lysogenic to lytic growth of phage lambda is the self-cleavage of lambda repressor, which is induced by the formation of a RecA-ssDNA-ATP filament at a site of DNA damage. Lambda repressor cleaves itself at the peptide bond between Ala111 and Gly112, but only when bound as a monomer to the RecA-ssDNA-ATP filament. Here we have designed a hyper-cleavable fragment of lambda repressor containing the hinge and C-terminal domain (residues 101-229), in which the monomer-monomer interface is disrupted by two point mutations and a deletion of seven residues at the C terminus. This fragment crystallizes as a monomer and its structure has been determined to 1.8 A resolution. The hinge region, which bears the cleavage site, is folded over the active site of the C-terminal oligomerization domain (CTD) but with the cleavage site flipped out and exposed to solvent. Thus, the structure represents a non-cleavable conformation of the repressor, but one that is poised for cleavage after modest rearrangements that are presumably stabilized by binding to RecA. The structure provides a unique snapshot of lambda repressor in a conformation that sheds light on how its self-cleavage is tempered in the absence of RecA, as well as a framework for interpreting previous genetic and biochemical data concerning the RecA-mediated cleavage reaction.     

Suppressors of Cleavage-Site Mutations in the p62 Envelope Protein of Semliki Forest Virus Reveal Dynamics in Spike Structure and Function

The E2 spike glycoprotein of Semliki Forest virus is produced as a p62 precursor protein, which is cleaved by host proteases to its mature form, E2. Cleavage is not necessary for particle formation or release but is necessary for infectivity. Previous results had shown that phenotypic revertants of cleavage-deficient p62 mutants are generated, and here we show that these may contain second-site suppressor mutations in the vicinity of the cleavage site. These hot-spot sites were mutated to abolish the generation of such suppressor mutations; however, secondary mutations in another distant domain of the E2 protein appeared instead, all of which still caused cleavage-deficient mutations. Such mutants grew very poorly and were inefficient in virus entry and release. The mutated sites define domains of the spike protein which probably interact to regulate its structure and function. Because of their highly attenuated phenotype and the lower probability of reversion, the new mutations close to the cleavage site were used to make new helper vectors for packaging of recombinant RNA into infectious particles, thus increasing further the biosafety of the vector system based on the Semliki Forest virus replicon.     

Combining thermostable mutations increases the stability of lambda repressor

We have combined three mutations previously shown to stabilize lambda repressor against thermal denaturation. Two of these mutations are in helix 3, where Gly-46 and Gly-48 have been replaced by alanines [Hecht, M. H., et al. (1986) Proteins: Struct., Funct., Genet. 1, 43-46]. The other mutation, which replaces Tyr-88 with cysteine, allows the protein to form an intersubunit disulfide bond [Sauer, R. T., et al. (1986) Biochemistry 25, 5992-5998]. Calorimetric measurements show that the two alanine substitutions stabilize repressor by about 8 degrees C, that the disulfide bond stabilizes repressor by about 8 degrees C, and that the triple mutant is 16 degrees C more stable than wild-type repressor.     

The structural stability of a protein is an important determinant of its proteolytic susceptibility in Escherichia coli

To investigate the relationship between the degradation rate of a protein in Escherichia coli and its thermal stability in vitro, we constructed a set of variants of the N-terminal domain of lambda repressor with a wide range of melting temperatures. Pulse-chase experiments showed that, within this set, the proteins that are most thermally stable have the longest intracellular half-lives and vice versa. Moreover, second-site mutations which act directly or indirectly to increase the thermodynamic stability of the native N-terminal domain were found to suppress the intracellular degradation of one of the unstable mutants. These data suggest that thermal stability is, indeed, a key determinant of the proteolytic susceptibility of this protein in the cell. It is not the sole determinant, however, as sequences at the extreme C terminus of the N-terminal domain can influence proteolytic sensitivity without affecting the stability of the native structure. We propose that the thermal stability of the N-terminal domain of lambda repressor is an important determinant of its proteolytic sensitivity because degradation proceeds primarily from the unfolded form and that sequence determinants within the unfolded chain influence whether the unfolded protein will be a good substrate for proteolytic enzymes.     

Role of the Cro repressor carboxy-terminal domain and flexible dimer linkage in operator and nonspecific DNA binding

A series of mutations comprising single and multiple substitutions, deletions, and extensions within the carboxy-terminal domain of the bacteriophage lambda Cro repressor have been constructed. These mutations generally affect the affinity of repressor for specific and nonspecific DNA. Additionally, substitution of the carboxy-terminal alanine with several amino acids capable of hydrogen-bonding interactions leads to improved specific binding affinities. A mutation is also described whereby cysteine links the two Cro monomers by a disulfide bond. As a consequence, a significant improvement in nonspecific binding and a concomitant reduction in specific binding are observed with this mutant. These results provide evidence that the carboxy terminus of Cro repressor is an important DNA binding domain and that a flexible connection between the two repressor monomers is a critical factor in modulating the affinity of wild-type repressor for DNA.     

Suppression of recA deficiency in plasmid recombination by bacteriophage lambda beta protein in RecBCD- ExoI- Escherichia coli cells.

Plasmid recombination, like other homologous recombination in Escherichia coli, requires RecA protein in most conditions. We have found that the plasmid recombination defect in a recA mutant can be efficiently suppressed by the beta protein of bacteriophage lambda. beta protein is required for homologous recombination of lambda chromosomes during lytic phage growth in a recA host and is known to have a strand-annealing activity resembling that of RecA protein. The bioluminescence recombination assay was used for genetic analysis of beta-protein-mediated plasmid recombination. Efficient suppression of the recA mutation by beta protein required the absence of the E. coli nucleases exonuclease I and RecBCD nuclease. These nucleases inhibit a RecA-mediated plasmid recombination pathway that is more efficient than the pathway functioning in wild-type cells. Like RecA-mediated plasmid recombination in RecBCD- ExoI- cells, beta-protein-mediated plasmid recombination depended on concurrent DNA replication and on the activity of the recQ gene. However, unlike RecA-mediated plasmid recombination, beta-protein-mediated recombination in RecBCD- ExoI- cells was independent of recF and recJ activities. We propose that inactivation of exonuclease I and RecBCD nuclease stabilizes a recombination intermediate that is involved in RecA- and beta-protein-catalyzed homologous pairing reactions. We suggest that the intermediate may be linear plasmid DNA with a protruding 3' end, since these nucleases are known to interfere with the synthesis of such linear forms. The different recF and recJ requirements for beta-protein-dependent and RecA-dependent recombinations imply that the mechanisms of formation or processing of the putative intermediate differ in the two cases.     

Constitutive expression of the SOS response in recA718 mutants of Escherichia coli requires amplification of RecA718 protein.

In recA718 lexA+ strains of Escherichia coli, induction of the SOS response requires DNA damage. This implies that RecA718 protein, like RecA+ protein, must be converted, by a process initiated by the damage, to an activated form (RecA) to promote cleavage of LexA, the cellular repressor of SOS genes. However, when LexA repressor activity was abolished by a lexA-defective mutation [lexA(Def)], strains carrying the recA718 gene (but not recA+) showed strong SOS mutator activity and were able to undergo stable DNA replication in the absence of DNA damage (two SOS functions known to require RecA activity even when cleavage of LexA is not necessary). lambda lysogens of recA718 lexA(Def) strains exhibited mass induction of prophage, indicative of constitutive ability to cleave lambda repressor. When the cloned recA718 allele was present in a lexA+ strain on a plasmid, SOS mutator activity and beta-galactosidase synthesis under LexA control were expressed in proportion to the plasmid copy number. We conclude that RecA718 is capable of becoming activated without DNA damage for cleavage of LexA and lambda repressor, but only if it is amplified above its base-line level in lexA+ strains. At amplified levels, RecA718 was also constitutively activated for its roles in SOS mutagenesis and stable DNA replication. The nucleotide sequence of recA718 reveals two base substitutions relative to the recA+ sequence. We propose that the first allows the protein to become activated constitutively, whereas the second partially suppresses this capability.     

Suppression of tif-mediated induction of SOS functions in Escherichia coli by an altered dnaB protein.

The tif-1 mutation in the Escherichia coli recA gene is known to cause induction of the various "SOS" functions at high temperature, including massive synthesis of the recA protein, lethal filamentation, elevated mutagenesis, and, in lambda lysogens, induction of prophage. It is shown here that the deoxyribonucleic acid initiation mutation dnaB252 suppresses all these manifestations of tif expression. Induction of lambda by ultraviolet irradiation, however, is not affected by the dnaB252 mutation. No similar suppression of tif is observed with other dnaB mutations affecting deoxyribonucleic acid elongation or with other deoxyribonucleic acid initiation mutations at the dnaA and dnaC loci. The fact that an alteration of the dnaB protein specifically suppresses tif-mediated SOS induction implies a role of the replication apparatus in this process, as has been suggested for ultraviolet induction. The induction of lambda is known to proceed via repressor cleavage, presumably promoted by an activated (protease) form of the recA protein. Since lambda induction is normal after ultraviolet irradiation of the tif-1 dnaB252(lambda) strain, tif-mediated induction in this strain may be blocked in a tif-specific step leading to activation of the recA (tif) protein. It is possible that the recA (tif) mutant protein may be directly involved in the replication complex in processes leading to this activation.