Temporal and spatial order of events during the induction of cortical cell divisions in white clover by Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii inoculation or localized cytokinin addition

We examined the timing and location of several early root responses to Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii infection, compared with a localized addition of cytokinin in white clover, to study the role of cytokinin in early signaling during nodule initiation. Induction of ENOD40 expression by either rhizobia or cytokinin was similar in timing and location and occurred in nodule progenitor cells in the inner cortex. Inoculation of rhizobia in the mature root failed to induce ENOD40 expression and cortical cell divisions (ccd). Nitrate addition at levels repressing nodule formation inhibited ENOD40 induction by rhizobia but not by cytokinin. ENOD40 expression was not induced by auxin, an auxin transport inhibitor, or an ethylene precursor. In contrast to rhizobia, cytokinin addition was not sufficient to induce a modulation of the auxin flow, the induction of specific chalcone synthase genes, and the accumulation of fluorescent compounds associated with nodule initiation. However, cytokinin addition was sufficient for the localized induction of auxin-induced GH3 gene expression and the initiation of ccd. Our results suggest that rhizobia induce cytokinin-mediated events in parallel to changes in auxin-related responses during nodule initiation and support a role of ENOD40 in regulating ccd. We propose a model for the interactions of cytokinin with auxin, ENOD40, flavonoids, and nitrate during nodulation.     

Rhizobia can induce nodules in white clover by "hijacking" mature cortical cells activated during lateral root development

We examined a range of responses of root cortical cells to Rhizobium sp. inoculation to investigate why rhizobia preferentially nodulate legume roots in the zone of emerging root hairs, but generally fail to nodulate the mature root. We tested whether the inability to form nodules in the mature root is due to a lack of plant flavonoids to induce the bacterial genes required for nodulation or a failure of mature cortical cells to respond to Rhizobium spp. When rhizobia were inoculated in the zone of emerging root hairs, changes in beta-glucuronidase (GUS) expression from an auxin-responsive promoter (GH3), expression from three chalcone synthase promoters, and the accumulation of specific flavonoid compounds occurred in cortical cells prior to nodule formation. Rhizobia failed to induce these responses when inoculated in the mature root, even when co-inoculated with nod gene-inducing flavonoids. However, mature root hairs remained responsive to rhizobia and could support infection thread formation. This suggests that a deficiency in signal transduction is the reason for nodulation failure in the mature root. However, nodules could be initiated in the mature root at sites of lateral root emergence. A comparison between lateral root and nodule formation showed that similar patterns of GH3:gusA expression, chalcone synthase gene expression, and accumulation of a particular flavonoid compound occurred in the cortical cells involved in both processes. The results suggest that rhizobia can "hijack" cortical cells next to lateral root emergence sites because some of the early responses required for nodule formation have already been activated by the plant in those cells.     

Accumulation of lipochitin oligosaccharides and NodD-activating compounds in an efficient plant--Rhizobium nodulation assay

During legume plant--Rhizobium spp. interactions, leading to the formation of nitrogen-fixing root nodules, the two major determinants of host plant-specificity are plant-produced nod gene inducers (NodD protein activating compounds) and bacterial lipochitin oligosaccharides (LCOs or Nod factors). In a time course, we describe the accumulation of LCOs in an efficient nodulation assay with Vicia sativa subsp. nigra and Rhizobium leguminosarum, in connection with the presence of NodD-activating compounds in the exudate of V. sativa roots. Relatively small amounts of both LCOs and NodD-activating compounds were found to be required for initiation of nodulation during the first days after inoculation. A strong increase in the amount of NodRlv-V[18:4,Ac] LCOs preceded root infection and nodule primordium formation. In contrast to the situation with non-nodulating rhizobia and nonmitogenic LCOs, the amount of NodD-activating compounds in the culture medium remained small after addition of nodulating rhizobia or mitogenic LCOs. Furthermore, addition of nodulating rhizobia or mitogenic LCOs resulted in nearly complete inhibition of root hair formation and elongation, whereas nonmitogenic LCOs stimulated root hair growth. Retention of NodD-activating compounds in the root may inhibit root hair growth.     

Genes and signal molecules involved in the rhizobia-leguminoseae symbiosis

The symbiosis between Rhizobium bacteria and their host plants is dependent on the specific recognition of signal molecules produced by each partner. Many players in the signal exchange have been identified. Among them are signal molecules such as flavonoids, LCOs, auxin, cytokinin, ethylene and uridine and genes such as Enod40, Enod2 and Enod12. Their interconnection, however, is only starting to be understood. The most recent insights into their interconnection include: advances in the use of transgenic leguminous plants containing reporter gene constructs for studying the effect of the signal molecules; novel methods for delivery of signal molecules using ballistic microtargeting; and the discovery of the role of chitin oligosaccharides in animal embryogenesis.     

Comparison of characteristics of the nodX genes from various Rhizobium leguminosarum strains

We have analyzed the nucleotide sequences of the nodX genes from two strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae able to nodulate Afghan peas (strains A1 and Himalaya) and from two strains of R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii (ANU843 and CSF). The nodX genes of strains A1 and ANU843 were shown to be functional for the induction of nodules on Afghan peas. To analyze the cause of phenotypic differences of strain A1 and strain TOM we have studied the composition of the lipochitin-oligosaccharides (LCOs) produced by strain A1 after induction by the flavonoid naringenin or various pea root exudates. The structural analysis of the LCOs by mass spectrometry revealed that strain A1 synthesizes a family of at least 23 different LCOs. The use of exudates instead of naringenin resulted only in quantitative differences in the ratios of various LCOs produced.     

Genetic and Chemical Reductions in Protein Phosphatase Activity Alter Auxin Transport, Gravity Response, and Lateral Root Growth

Auxin transport is required for important growth and developmental processes in plants, including gravity response and lateral root growth. Several lines of evidence suggest that reversible protein phosphorylation regulates auxin transport. Arabidopsis rcn1 mutant seedlings exhibit reduced protein phosphatase 2A activity and defects in differential cell elongation. Here we report that reduced phosphatase activity alters auxin transport and dependent physiological processes in the seedling root. Root basipetal transport was increased in rcn1 or phosphatase inhibitor-treated seedlings but showed normal sensitivity to the auxin transport inhibitor naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA). Phosphatase inhibition reduced root gravity response and delayed the establishment of differential auxin-induced gene expression across a gravity-stimulated root tip. An NPA treatment that reduced basipetal transport in rcn1 and cantharidin-treated wild-type plants also restored a normal gravity response and asymmetric auxin-induced gene expression, indicating that increased basipetal auxin transport impedes gravitropism. Increased auxin transport in rcn1 or phosphatase inhibitor-treated seedlings did not require the AGR1/EIR1/PIN2/WAV6 or AUX1 gene products. In contrast to basipetal transport, root acropetal transport was normal in phosphatase-inhibited seedlings in the absence of NPA, although it showed reduced NPA sensitivity. Lateral root growth also exhibited reduced NPA sensitivity in rcn1 seedlings, consistent with acropetal transport controlling lateral root growth. These results support the role of protein phosphorylation in regulating auxin transport and suggest that the acropetal and basipetal auxin transport streams are differentially regulated.     

Involvement of auxin distribution in root nodule development of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Lotus japonicus</Emphasis>

The symbiosis between legume plants and rhizobia causes the development of new organs, nodules which function as an apparatus for nitrogen fixation. In this study, the roles of auxin in nodule development in Lotus japonicus have been demonstrated using molecular genetic tools and auxin inhibitors. The expression of an auxin-reporter GH3 fused to β-glucuronidase (GUS) was analyzed in L. japonicus roots, and showed a strong signal in the central cylinder of the root, whereas upon rhizobium infection, generation of GUS signal was observed at the dividing outer cortical cells during the first nodule cell divisions. When nodules were developed to maturity, strong GUS staining was detected in vascular tissues of nodules, suggesting distinct auxin involvement in the determinate nodule development. Numbers and the development of nodules were affected by auxin transport inhibitors (1-naphthylphthalamic acid, NPA and triindobenzoic acid, TIBA), and by a newly synthesized auxin antagonist, α-(phenyl ethyl-2-one)-indole-3-acetic acid (PEO-IAA). The common phenotypical alteration by these auxin inhibitors was the inhibition in forming lenticel which is normally developed on the nodule surface from the root outer cortex. The inhibition of lenticel formation was correlated with the inhibition of nodule vascular bundle development. These results indicate that auxin is required for the normal development of determinate nodules in a multidirectional manner.     

Regulation of plant morphogenesis by Lipo‐Chitin oligosaccharides

Lipo‐chitin oligosaccharides (LCOs), produced by rhizobia, are causative agents of the formation of root nodules in leguminous plants. As outlined in this review, the root nodulation process presents a valuable model system to study plant morphogenesis. The knowledge that resulted from the studies of the biological function and biosynthesis of the rhizobial LCOs is summarized. It has been postulated that LCOs are representatives of a general class of signal molecules involved in plant and animal morphogenesis. Discussed is how the present knowledge can be used for future studies on the function of LCOs in morphogenesis and in the search for analogue signal molecules produced by plants and animals.     

Rhizobium nodulation protein NodC is an important determinant of chitin oligosaccharide chain length in Nod factor biosynthesis.

Synthesis of chitin oligosaccharides by NodC is the first committed step in the biosynthesis of rhizobial lipochitin oligosaccharides (LCOs). The distribution of oligosaccharide chain lengths in LCOs differs between various Rhizobium species. We expressed the cloned nodC genes of Rhizobium meliloti, R. leguminosarum bv. viciae, and R. loti in Escherichia coli. The in vivo activities of the various NodC proteins differed with respect to the length of the major chitin oligosaccharide produced. The clearest difference was observed between strains with R. meliloti and R. loti NodC, producing chitintetraose and chitinpentaose, respectively. In vitro experiments, using UDP-[14C]GlcNAc as a precursor, show that this difference reflects intrinsic properties of these NodC proteins and that it is not influenced by the UDP-GlcNAc concentration. Analysis of oligosaccharide chain lengths in LCOs produced by a R. leguminosarum bv. viciae nodC mutant, expressing the three cloned nodC genes mentioned above, shows that the difference in oligosaccharide chain length in LCOs of R. meliloti and R. leguminosarum bv. viciae is due only to nodC. The exclusive production of LCOs which contain a chitinpentaose backbone by R. loti strains is not due to NodC but to end product selection by Nod proteins involved in further modification of the chitin oligosaccharide. These results indicate that nodC contributes to the host specificity of R. meliloti, a conclusion consistent with the results of several studies which have shown that the lengths of the oligosaccharide backbones of LCOs can strongly influence their activities on host plants.     

Heterologous rhizobial lipochitin oligosaccharides and chitin oligomers induce cortical cell divisions in red clover roots, transformed with the pea lectin gene

Division of cortical cells in roots of leguminous plants is triggered by lipochitin oligosaccharides (LCOs) secreted by the rhizobial microsymbiont. Previously, we have shown that presence of pea lectin in transgenic white clover hairy roots renders these roots susceptible to induction of root nodule formation by pea-specific rhizobia (C. L. Díaz, L. S. Melchers, P. J. J. Hooykaas, B. J. J. Lugtenberg, and J. W. Kijne, Nature 338:579-581, 1989). Here, we report that pea lectin-transformed red clover hairy roots form nodule primordium-like structures after inoculation with pea-, alfalfa-, and Lotus-specific rhizobia, which normally do not nodulate red clover. External application of a broad range of purified LCOs showed all of them to be active in induction of cortical cell divisions and cell expansion in a radial direction, resulting in formation of structures that resemble nodule primordia induced by clover-specific rhizobia. This activity was obvious in about 50% of the red clover plants carrying hairy roots transformed with the pea lectin gene. Also, chitopentaose, chitotetraose, chitotriose, and chitobiose were able to induce cortical cell divisions and cell expansion in a radial direction in transgenic roots, but not in control roots. Sugar-binding activity of pea lectin was essential for its effect. These results show that transformation of red clover roots with pea lectin results in a broadened response of legume root cortical cells to externally applied potentially mitogenic oligochitin signals.     

NodZ of Bradyrhizobium extends the nodulation host range of Rhizobium by adding a fucosyl residue to nodulation signals

The nodulation genes of rhizobia are involved in the production of the lipo-chitin oligosaccharides (LCO), which are signal molecules required for nodule formation. A mutation in nodZ of Bradyrhizobium japonicum results in the synthesis of nodulation signals lacking the wild-type 2- O -methylfucose residue at the reducing-terminal N -acetylglucosamine. This phenotype is correlated with a defective nodulation of siratro ( Macroptilium atropurpureum ). Here we show that transfer of nodZ to Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar (bv) viciae , which produces LCOs that are not modified at the reducing-terminal N -acetylglucosamine, results in production of LCOs with a fucosyl residue on C-6 of the reducing-terminal N -acetylglucosamine. This finding, together with in vitro enzymatic assays, indicates that the product of nodZ functions as a fucosyltransferase. The transconjugant R. leguminosarum strain producing fucosylated LCOs acquires the capacity to nodulate M. atropurpureum Glycine soja Vigna unguiculata and Leucaena leucocephala . Therefore, nodZ extends the narrow host range of R. leguminosarum bv. viciae to include various tropical legumes. However, microscopic analysis of nodules induced on siratro shows that these nodules do not contain bacteroids, showing that transfer of nodZ does not allow R. leguminosarum to engage in a nitrogen-fixing symbiosis with this plant.     

Development of functional symbiotic white clover root hairs and nodules requires tightly regulated production of rhizobial cellulase CelC2

The establishment of rhizobia as nitrogen-fixing endosymbionts within legume root nodules requires the disruption of the plant cell wall to breach the host barrier at strategic infection sites in the root hair tip and at points of bacterial release from infection threads (IT) within the root cortex. We previously found that Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii uses its chromosomally encoded CelC2 cellulase to erode the noncrystalline wall at the apex of root hairs, thereby creating the primary portal of its entry into white clover roots. Here, we show that a recombinant derivative of R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii ANU843 that constitutively overproduces the CelC2 enzyme has increased competitiveness in occupying aberrant nodule-like root structures on clover that are inefficient in nitrogen fixation. This aberrant symbiotic phenotype involves an extensive uncontrolled degradation of the host cell walls restricted to the expected infection sites at tips of deformed root hairs and significantly enlarged infection droplets at termini of wider IT within the nodule infection zone. Furthermore, signs of elevated plant host defense as indicated by reactive oxygen species production in root tissues were more evident during infection by the recombinant strain than its wild-type parent. Our data further support the role of the rhizobial CelC2 cell wall-degrading enzyme in primary infection, and show evidence of its importance in secondary symbiotic infection and tight regulation of its production to establish an effective nitrogen-fixing root nodule symbiosis.     

Basipetal auxin transport is required for gravitropism in roots of Arabidopsis

Auxin transport has been reported to occur in two distinct polarities, acropetally and basipetally, in two different root tissues. The goals of this study were to determine whether both polarities of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) transport occur in roots of Arabidopsis and to determine which polarity controls the gravity response. Global application of the auxin transport inhibitor naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) to roots blocked the gravity response, root waving, and root elongation. Immediately after the application of NPA, the root gravity response was completely blocked, as measured by an automated video digitizer. Basipetal [(3)H]IAA transport in Arabidopsis roots was inhibited by NPA, whereas the movement of [(14)C]benzoic acid was not affected. Inhibition of basipetal IAA transport by local application of NPA blocked the gravity response. Inhibition of acropetal IAA transport by application of NPA at the root-shoot junction only partially reduced the gravity response at high NPA concentrations. Excised root tips, which do not receive auxin from the shoot, exhibited a normal response to gravity. The Arabidopsis mutant eir1, which has agravitropic roots, exhibited reduced basipetal IAA transport but wild-type levels of acropetal IAA transport. These results support the hypothesis that basipetally transported IAA controls root gravitropism in Arabidopsis.     

Auxin distribution in Lotus japonicus during root nodule development

For this work, Lotus japonicus transgenic plants were constructed expressing a fusion reporter gene consisting of the genes beta-glucuronidase (gus) and green fluorescent protein (gfp) under control of the soybean auxin-responsive promoter GH3. These plants expressed GUS and GFP in the vascular bundle of shoots, roots and leafs. Root sections showed that in mature parts of the roots GUS is mainly expressed in phloem and vascular parenchyma of the vascular cylinder. By detecting GUS activity, we describe the auxin distribution pattern in the root of the determinate nodulating legume L. japonicus during the development of nodulation and also after inoculation with purified Nod factors, N-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) and indoleacetic acid (IAA). Differently than white clover, which forms indeterminate nodules, L. japonicus presented a strong GUS activity at the dividing outer cortical cells during the first nodule cell divisions. This suggests different auxin distribution pattern between the determinate and indeterminate nodulating legumes that may be responsible of the differences in nodule development between these groups. By measuring of the GFP fluorescence expressed 21 days after treatment with Nod factors or bacteria we were able to quantify the differences in GH3 expression levels in single living roots. In order to correlate these data with auxin transport capacity we measured the auxin transport levels by a previously described radioactive method. At 48 h after inoculation with Nod factors, auxin transport showed to be increased in the middle root segment. The results obtained indicate that L. japonicus transformed lines expressing the GFP and GUS reporters under the control of the GH3 promoter are suitable for the study of auxin distribution in this legume.     

Medicago truncatula NIN is essential for rhizobial-independent nodule organogenesis induced by autoactive calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase

The symbiotic association between legumes and nitrogen-fixing bacteria collectively known as rhizobia results in the formation of a unique plant root organ called the nodule. This process is initiated following the perception of rhizobial nodulation factors by the host plant. Nod factor (NF)-stimulated plant responses, including nodulation-specific gene expression, is mediated by the NF signaling pathway. Plant mutants in this pathway are unable to nodulate. We describe here the cloning and characterization of two mutant alleles of the Medicago truncatula ortholog of the Lotus japonicus and pea (Pisum sativum) NIN gene. The Mtnin mutants undergo excessive root hair curling but are impaired in infection and fail to form nodules following inoculation with Sinorhizobium meliloti. Our investigation of early NF-induced gene expression using the reporter fusion ENOD11::GUS in the Mtnin-1 mutant demonstrates that MtNIN is not essential for early NF signaling but may negatively regulate the spatial pattern of ENOD11 expression. It was recently shown that an autoactive form of a nodulation-specific calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase is sufficient to induce nodule organogenesis in the absence of rhizobia. We show here that MtNIN is essential for autoactive calcium/calmodulin-dependent protein kinase-induced nodule organogenesis. The non-nodulating hcl mutant has a similar phenotype to Mtnin, but we demonstrate that HCL is not required in this process. Based on our data, we suggest that MtNIN functions downstream of the early NF signaling pathway to coordinate and regulate the correct temporal and spatial formation of root nodules.     

Flavone-enhanced accumulation and symbiosis-related biological activity of a diglycosyl diacylglycerol membrane glycolipid from Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar trifolii.

Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. trifolii is the bacterial symbiont which induces nitrogen-fixing root nodules on the leguminous host, white clover (Trifolium repens L.). In this plant-microbe interaction, the host plant excretes a flavone, 4',7-dihydroxyflavone (DHF), which activates expression of modulation genes, enabling the bacterial symbiont to elicit various symbiosis-related morphological changes in its roots. We have investigated the accumulation of a diglycosyl diacylglycerol (BF-7) in wild-type R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii ANU843 when grown with DHF and the biological activities of this glycolipid bacterial factor on host and nonhost legumes. In vivo labeling studies indicated that wild-type ANU843 cells accumulate BF-7 in response to DHF, and this flavone-enhanced alteration in membrane glycolipid composition was suppressed in isogenic nodA::Tn5 and nodD::Tn5 mutant derivatives. Seedling bioassays performed under microbiologically controlled conditions indicated that subnanomolar concentrations of purified BF-7 elicit various symbiosis-related morphological responses on white clover roots, including thick short roots, root hair deformation, and foci of cortical cell divisions. Roots of the nonhost legumes alfalfa and vetch were much less responsive to BF-7 at these low concentrations. A structurally distinct diglycosyl diacylglycerol did not induce these responses on white clover, indicating structural constraints in the biological activity of BF-7 on this legume host. In bioassays using aminoethoxyvinylglycine to suppress plant production of ethylene, BF-7 elicited a meristematic rather than collaroid type of mitogenic response in the root cortex of white clover. These results indicate an involvement of flavone-activated nod expression in membrane accumulation of BF-7 and a potent ability of this diglycosyl diacylglycerol glycolipid to perform as a bacterial factor enabling R. leguminosarum bv. trifolii to activate segments of its host's symbiotic program during early development of the root nodule symbiosis.     

Influence of 2,3,5-Triiodobenzoic Acid and 1-N-Naphthylphthalamic Acid on Indoleacetic Acid Transport in Carnation Cuttings: Relationship with Rooting

³H-IAA transport in excised sections of carnation cuttings was studied by using two receiver systems for recovery of transported radioactivity: agar blocks (A) and wells containing a buffer solution (B). When receivers were periodically renewed, transport continued for up to 8 h and ceased before 24 h. If receivers were not renewed, IAA transport decreased drastically due to immobilization in the base of the sections. TIBA was as effective as NPA in inhibiting the basipetal transport irrespective of the application site (the basal or the apical side of sections). The polarity of IAA transport was determined by measuring the polar ratio (basipetal/acropetal) and the inhibition caused by TIBA or NPA. The polar ratio varied with receiver, whereas the inhibition by TIBA or NPA was similar. Distribution of immobilized radioactivity along the sections after a transport period of 24 h showed that the application of TIBA to the apical side or NPA to the basal side of sections, increased the radioactivity in zones further from the application site, which agrees with a basipetal and acropetal movement of TIBA and NPA, respectively. The existence of a slow acropetal movement of the inhibitor was confirmed by using ³H-NPA. From the results obtained, a methodological approach is proposed to measure the variations in polar auxin transport. This method was used to investigate whether the variations in rooting observed during the cold storage of cuttings might be related to changes in polar auxin transport. As the storage period increased, a decrease in intensity and polarity of auxin transport occurred, which was accompanied by a delay in the formation and growth of adventitious roots, confirming the involvement of polar auxin transport in supplying the auxin for rooting. Received April 19, 1999; accepted December 2, 1999     

Expression of the early nodulin, ENOD40, in soybean roots in response to various lipo-chitin signal molecules

The lipo-chitin (LCO) nodulation signal (nod signal) purified from Bradyrhizobium japonicum induced nodule primordia on soybean (i.e. Glycine soja) roots. These primordia were characterized by a bifurcated vascular connection, cortical cell division, and the accumulation of mRNA of the early nodulin gene, ENOD40. A chemically synthesized LCO identical in structure to the Nod signal purified from B. japonicum cultures showed the same activity when inoculated on to soybean roots. Surprisingly, synthetic LCO or chitin pentamer, inactive in inducing root hair curling (HAD) or cortical cell division (NOI) in G. soja, induced the transient accumulation of ENOD40 mRNA. In roots inoculated with such LCO, ENOD40 mRNA was abundant at 40 h after inoculation but decreased to the background levels 6 days after inoculation. In contrast, nod signals active in inducing HAD and NOI induced high levels of ENOD40 accumulation at 40 h and 6 days after inoculation. In situ hybridization analysis showed that ENOD40 mRNA accumulated in the pericycle of the vascular bundle at 24 h after root inoculation with nod signal. At 6 days post-inoculation with nod signal, ENOD40 expression was seen in dividing subepidermal cortical cells. These results provide morphological and molecular evidence that nodule induction in soybean in response to purified or synthetic nod signal is similar, if not identical, to nodule formation induced by bacterial inoculation. Surprisingly, ENOD40 mRNA accumulation occurs in response to non-specific chitin signals. This suggests that, in the case of ENOD40, nodulation specificity is not determined at the level of initial gene expression.