Structural Evidence for a Copper-Bound Carbonate Intermediate in the Peroxidase and Dismutase Activities of Superoxide Dismutase

Copper-zinc superoxide dismutase (SOD) is of fundamental importance to our understanding of oxidative damage. Its primary function is catalysing the dismutation of superoxide to O₂ and H₂O₂. SOD also reacts with H₂O₂, leading to the formation of a strong copper-bound oxidant species that can either inactivate the enzyme or oxidise other substrates. In the presence of bicarbonate (or CO₂) and H₂O₂, this peroxidase activity is enhanced and produces the carbonate radical. This freely diffusible reactive oxygen species is proposed as the agent for oxidation of large substrates that are too bulky to enter the active site. Here, we provide direct structural evidence, from a 2.15 Å resolution crystal structure, of (bi)carbonate captured at the active site of reduced SOD, consistent with the view that a bound carbonate intermediate could be formed, producing a diffusible carbonate radical upon reoxidation of copper. The bound carbonate blocks direct access of substrates to Cu(I), suggesting that an adjunct to the accepted mechanism of SOD catalysed dismutation of superoxide operates, with Cu(I) oxidation by superoxide being driven via a proton-coupled electron transfer mechanism involving the bound carbonate rather than the solvent. Carbonate is captured in a different site when SOD is oxidised, being located in the active site channel adjacent to the catalytically important Arg143. This is the probable route of diffusion from the active site following reoxidation of the copper. In this position, the carbonate is poised for re-entry into the active site and binding to the reduced copper.     

Evolutionary Aspects of Superoxide Dismutase: The Copper/Zinc Enzyme

Copper/zinc superoxide dismutase is typically an enzyme of eukaryotes. The presence of the enzyme in the ponyfish symbiont Photobocterium leiognothi and some free living bacteria does not have an immediate explanation. Amino acid sequence alignment of 19 Cu/Zn superoxide disrnutases shows 21 invariant residues in key positions related to maintenance of the β-barrel fold, the active site structure including the electrostatic channel loop, and dimer contacts. Nineteen other residues are invariant in 18 of the 19 sequences. Thirteen of these nearly invariant residues show substitutions in Photobocterium Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase. Copper/zinc superoxide disrnutase from the trematode Schisiosoma mansoni shows an N-terminal sub-domain with a hydrophobic leader peptide. as in human extracellular superoxide dismutase which is a Cu/Zn enzyme. The latter also has a C-terminal sub-domain with preponderance of hydrophilic and positively charged residues. The amino acid sequence of this superoxide dismutase between the N-terminal and C-terminal regions shares many features of cytosolic Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase. including 20 of the 21 invariant residues found in 19 Cu/Zn enzymes, suggesting a similar type of β-barrel fold and active site structure for the extracellular enzyme.     

Evolution of CuZn superoxide dismutase and the Greek key beta-barrel structural motif

Detailed analysis of the CuZn superoxide dismutase (SOD) structure provides new results concerning the significance and molecular basis for sequence conservation, intron-exon boundary locations, gene duplication, and Greek key beta-barrel evolution. Using 15 aligned sequences, including a new mouse sequence, specific roles have been assigned to all 23 invariant residues and additional residues exhibiting functional equivalence. Sequence invariance is dominated by 15 residues that form the active site stereochemistry, supporting a primary biological function of superoxide dismutation. The beta-strands have no sequence insertions and deletions, whereas insertions occur within the loops connecting the beta-strands and at both termini. Thus, the beta-barrel with only four invariant residues is apparently over-determined, but dependent on multiple cooperative side chain interactions. The regions encoded by exon I, a proposed nucleation site for protein folding, and exon III, the Zn loop involved in stability and catalysis, are the major structural subdomains not included in the internal twofold axis of symmetry passing near the catalytic Cu ion. This provides strong confirmatory evidence for gene evolution by duplication and fusion followed by the addition of these two exons. The proposed evolutionary pathway explains the structural versatility of the Greek key beta-barrel through functional specialization and subdomain insertions in new loop connections, and provides a rationale for the size of the present day enzyme.     

Is the activity-linked electrostatic gradient of bovine Cu, Zn superoxide dismutases conserved in homologous enzymes irrespective of the number and distribution of charges?

Electrostatic potential calculations have been performed on three different Cu, Zn superoxide dismutases (superoxide: superoxide oxidoreductase, EC 1.15 1.1 ), in order to evaluate the degree of conservation of the pattern of the electrostatic interactions between O₂⁻ and the active site recently pointed out in bovine Cu Zn SOD. The three Cu, Zn SODs that have been selected for this study, namely the bovine, ovine, and porcine enzymes, are highly homologous as to reasonably assume identical three-dimensional structure but display large differences in their net charge, as shown by their pI's which span over a wide range pHrange: 8.0 (sheep), 6.5(pig), 5.2(ox). Despite such a large difference in the net protein charge and in the spatial arrangement of electrostatic charges, electrostatic potential calculations show that the electrostatic channel directing the negatively charged substrate toward the positive catalytic site is strictly preserved with the same features for the three proteins. This suggests that the electrostatic funnel for conducting small anions into the active site is a highly conservative property in the evolution of Cu, Zn SOD.     

Thermal stability and redox properties of M. tuberculosis CuSOD

The superoxide dismutase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis is the only Cu-containing superoxide dismutase that lacks zinc in the active site. To explore the structural properties of this unusual enzyme, we have investigated its stability by differential scanning calorimetry. We have found that the holo-enzyme is significantly more stable than the apo-protein or the partially metallated enzyme, but that its melting temperature is markedly lower than that of all the other characterized eukaryotic and prokaryotic Cu,Zn superoxide dismutases. We have also observed that, unlike the zinc-free eukaryotic or bacterial enzymes, the active site copper of the mycobacterial enzyme is not reduced by ascorbate, confirming that its redox properties are comparable to those typical of the enzymes containing zinc in the active site. Our findings highlight the role of zinc in conferring stability to Cu,Zn superoxide dismutases and indicate that the structural rearrangements observed in M. tuberculosis Cu,SOD compensate for the absence of zinc in achieving a fully active enzyme.     

Molecular dynamics studies on mutants of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase: The functional role of charged residues in the electrostatic loop VII

Molecular dynamics (MD) calculations have been performed on mutants of superoxide dismutase (SOD) on some residues present in the electrostatic loop. These calculations have provided the solution structures for the mutants Thr-137 → IIe and Arg; Lys-136 → Ala; Glu-132 → Gln; Glu-133 → Gln; Glu-132, Glu-133 → Gln-132, Gln-133 and → Gln-132, Lys-133. The structural and dynamic properties of these mutants have been correlated with the catalytic properties and available spectroscopic data. The water molecule present in the active site close to the copper ion in wild type (WT) SOD is missing in the MD average structure of the Thr-137 → IIe mutant, while this molecule is present in the MD average structures of all the other mutants and of WT SOD. This agrees with the experimental data. This is an important result that shows the validity of our calculations and their ability to reproduce even subtle structural features. Addition of one or more positive charges on the 132 and/or 133 positions does not sizably perturb the structure of the active site channel, while the introduction of a positively charged residue (Arg) on position 137 has a large effect on the structure of the electrostatic loop. Analysis of the MD average structures of these mutants has pointed out that the simple electrostatic effects of charged residues in the channel are not the only factor relevant for enzymatic behavior but that the structure of the electrostatic loop and the location of the charged residues also contribute to the catalytic properties of SOD. © 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Spectroscopic characterization of polyethyleneglycol modified superoxide dismutase: 1H NMR studies on its Cu2Co2 derivative

Spectroscopic methods have been employed in order to understand the molecular basis of the decrease in enzymatic activity of the antiinflammatory enzyme copper-zinc superoxide dismutase (SOD) following the covalent binding of polyethyleneglycol (PEG) chains to the protein amino-groups. The PEG modification is a general method recently proposed to improve the therapeutic index of enzymes. 1H NMR spectra on the cobalt substituted PEG-modified SOD, Cu2Co2-PEG-SOD, have been recorded. The signals are quite broad with respect to the unmodified enzyme. This has been interpreted on the basis of the effect of molecular weight on the linewidth. The analysis has shown that the histidine hydrogens involved in metal binding at the enzyme active site are the same in both native and PEG-modified SOD. Similarly, circular dichroism and absorption spectra indicate that the overall conformation of the metal clusters is not perturbed upon modification. On the other hand, azide titration shows that the affinity constant of N-3 for SOD is largely reduced upon PEG modification (K = 154 M-1 and 75 M-1 for the native and modified SOD, respectively). These results indicate that the decrease in enzymatic activity upon surface modification with PEG is not caused by a perturbation of the active site geometry, but to a decrease in the channeling of the O2- ion towards the enzyme active site.     

Design of Ca2+‐independent Staphylococcus aureus sortase A mutants

The catalytic activity of Staphylococcus aureus sortase A (SaSrtA) is dependent on Ca²⁺, because binding of Ca²⁺ to Glu residues distal to the active site stabilizes the substrate binding site. To obtain Ca²⁺‐independent SaSrtA, we substituted two Glu residues in the Ca²⁺‐binding pocket (Glu¹⁰⁵ and Glu¹⁰⁸). Although single mutations decreased SaSrtA activity, mutations of both Glu¹⁰⁵ and Glu¹⁰⁸ resulted in Ca²⁺‐independent activity. Kinetic analysis suggested that the double mutations affect the substrate binding site, without affecting substrate specificity. This approach will allow us to develop SaSrtA variants suitable for various applications, including in vivo site‐specific protein modification and labeling. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2012; 109: 2955–2961. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Nickel superoxide dismutase structure and mechanism

The 1.30 A resolution crystal structure of nickel superoxide dismutase (NiSOD) identifies a novel SOD fold, assembly, and Ni active site. NiSOD is a hexameric assembly of right-handed 4-helix bundles of up-down-up-down topology with N-terminal hooks chelating the active site Ni ions. This newly identified nine-residue Ni-hook structural motif (His-Cys-X-X-Pro-Cys-Gly-X-Tyr) provides almost all interactions critical for metal binding and catalysis, and thus will likely be diagnostic of NiSODs. Conserved lysine residues are positioned for electrostatic guidance of the superoxide anion to the narrow active site channel. Apo structures show that the Ni-hook motif is unfolded prior to metal binding. The active site Ni geometry cycles from square planar Ni(II), with thiolate (Cys2 and Cys6) and backbone nitrogen (His1 and Cys2) ligands, to square pyramidal Ni(III) with an added axial His1 side chain ligand, consistent with electron paramagentic resonance spectroscopy. Analyses of the three NiSOD structures and comparisons to the Cu,Zn and Mn/Fe SODs support specific molecular mechanisms for NiSOD maturation and catalysis, and identify important structure-function relationships conserved among SODs.     

Mechanism and Atomic Structure of Superoxide Dismutase

The active site Cu ion in Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase is alternately oxidized and reduced during the enzymatic dismutation of superoxide to hydrogen peroxide and molecular oxygen. For oxidized Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase, an atomic structure has been determined for the human enzyme at 2.5 A resolution. The resolution of the bovine enzyme structure has been extended to 1.8 A. Atomic resolution data has been, collected for reduced and inhibitor-bound Cu,Zn superoxide dismutases. and the interpretation of the' electron density difference maps is in progress. The geometry and molecular surfaces of the active sites in these structures, together with biochemical data, suggest a specific model for the enzyme mechanism. Similarities in the active site geometry of the Mn and Fe superoxide dismutases with the Cu.Zn enzyme suggest that dismutation in these enzymes may follow a similar mechanism.     

Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase from Trematomus bernacchii: functional conservation and erratic molecular evolution in Antarctic teleosts

In the present study, we describe the purification and molecular characterization of Cu,Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD) from Trematomus bernacchii, a teleost widely distributed in many areas of Antarctica, that plays a pivotal role in the Antarctic food chain. The amino acid and cDNA sequences have been obtained using both biochemical and molecular biology approaches and are compared with Cu,Zn SODs from other fishes. Assessment of the primary sequences highlights that the catalytically important residues are fully conserved in Cu,Zn SOD from T. bernacchii. Phylogenetic analyses performed on Cu,Zn SOD amino acid sequences permit speculation regarding the evolution of this protein. In particular, the data confirms the erratic differentiation of these proteins and concurs with the theory of the "unclock-like" behaviour of Cu,Zn SOD evolution.     

Cu,Zn-Superoxide Dismutase without Zn Is Folded but Catalytically Inactive

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis has been linked to the gain of aberrant function of superoxide dismutase, Cu,Zn-SOD1 upon protein misfolding. The mechanism of SOD1 misfolding is thought to involve mutations leading to the loss of Zn, followed by protein unfolding and aggregation. We show that the removal of Zn from SOD1 may not lead to an immediate unfolding but immediately deactivates the enzyme through a combination of subtle structural and electronic effects. Using quantum mechanics/discrete molecular dynamics, we showed that both Zn-less wild-type (WT)-SOD1 and its D124N mutant that does not bind Zn have at least metastable folded states. In those states, the reduction potential of Cu increases, leading to the presence of detectable amounts of Cu(I) instead of Cu(II) in the active site, as confirmed experimentally. The Cu(I) protein cannot participate in the catalytic Cu(I)–Cu(II) cycle. However, even without the full reduction to Cu(I), the Cu site in the Zn-less variants of SOD1 is shown to be catalytically incompetent: unable to bind superoxide in a way comparable to the WT-SOD1. The changes are more radical and different in the D124N Zn-less mutant than in the Zn-less WT-SOD1, suggesting D124N being perhaps not the most adequate model for Zn-less SOD1. Overall, Zn in SOD1 appears to be influencing the Cu site directly by adjusting its reduction potential and geometry. Thus, the role of Zn in SOD1 is not just structural, as was previously thought; it is a vital part of the catalytic machinery.     

Purification,N-Terminal Amino Acid Sequence and Partial Characterization of A Cu,Zn Superoxide Dismutase From the Pathogenic Fungus Aspergillusfumiga Tus

A superoxide dismutase (SOD) has been purified to homogeneity from the fungal pathogen Aspergillus fumigatus using a combination of cell homogenization, isoelectric focusing and gel filtration FPLC. The N-terminal amino acid sequence of the purified enzyme demonstrated substantial homology to known Cu, Zn superoxide dismutases for a range of organisms, including Neurospora crassa and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The enzyme subunit has a pl of 5.9, a relative molecular mass of 19 kDa and a spectral absorbance maximum of 550nm. The non reduced enzyme has a relative molecular mass of 95 kDa. The enzyme remained active after prolonged incubation at 70°C and was pH insensitive in the range 7-11. Potassium cyanide and diethyldithiocarbamate, known Cu, Zn SOD inhibitors, caused inhibition of the purified enzyme at working concentrations of 0.25 mM, whilst sodium azide and o-phenanthroline demonstrated inhibition at higher concentrations (10-30 mM). SOD activity was also detectable in culture filtrate of A. fumigatus. This enzyme may have a potential role as a virulence factor in the avoidance of neutrophil and phagocyte oxidative burst killing mechanisms.     

Oxidation of histidine residues in copper-zinc superoxide dismutase by bicarbonate-stimulated peroxidase and thiol oxidase activities: pulse EPR and NMR studies

In this work, we investigated the oxidative modification of histidine residues induced by peroxidase and thiol oxidase activities of bovine copper-zinc superoxide dismutase (Cu-ZnSOD) using NMR and pulse EPR spectroscopy. 1D NMR and 2D-NOESY were used to determine the oxidative damage at the Zn(II) and Cu(II) active sites as well as at distant histidines. Results indicate that during treatment of SOD with hydrogen peroxide (H(2)O(2)) or cysteine in the absence of bicarbonate anion (HCO(3)(-)), both exchangeable and nonexchangeable protons were affected. Both His-44 and His-46 in the Cu(II) active site were oxidized based on the disappearance of NOESY cross-peaks between CH and NH resonances of the imidazole rings. In the Zn(II) site, only His-69, which is closer to His-44, was oxidatively modified. However, addition of HCO(3)(-) protected the active site His residues. Instead, resonances assigned to the His-41 residue, 11 ? away from the Cu(II) site, were completely abolished during both HCO(3)(-)-stimulated peroxidase activity and thiol oxidase activity in the presence of HCO(3)(-) . Additionally, ESEEM/HYSCORE and ENDOR studies of SOD treated with peroxide/Cys in the absence of HCO(3)(-) revealed that hyperfine couplings to the distal and directly coordinated nitrogens of the His-44 and His-46 ligands at the Cu(II) active site were modified. In the presence of HCO(3)(-), these modifications were absent. HCO(3)(-)-mediated, selective oxidative modification of histidines in SOD may be relevant to understanding the molecular mechanism of SOD peroxidase and thiol oxidase activities.     

Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Substrate-Enzyme Interactions in the Active Site Channel of Superoxide Dismutase

Abstract

Molecular dynamics simulations of the diffusion of superoxide ion down the active site channel of the enzyme superoxide dismutase were performed with a parallelized version of GROMOS on the Intel iPSC/860. Our model consisted of a spherical assembly of 6968 atoms centered at a copper ion in the enzyme. Trajectory analysis revealed that the anion is directed toward the copper ion through the cooperative motions of several active site residues. Other mechanistic and structural motifs recurring through five full trajectories are examined. In addition to these qualitative results, an upper bound has been calculated for the rate constant for displacement by substrate of the water molecule that is coordinated to the copper. This required an analysis of the dynamics of crossing a free energy barrier that has been characterized in previous work. Strong frictional effects due to Coulombic interactions lead to a rather small rate constant; the transmission coefficient is less than 0.01. The mechanism of the enzyme therefore may involve diffusion of substrate up to the bound water followed by electron transfer mediated by this water, rather than displacement of the water by substrate with subsequent electron transfer.     

Point charge distributions and electrostatic steering in enzyme/substrate encounter: Brownian dynamics of modified copper/zinc superoxide dismutases

The electrostatic steering mechanism of bovine erythrocyte Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD) was investigated through the use of Brownian dynamics. Simulations of enzyme/substrate encounter were carried out on 14 different SOD models defined by simple changes in the enzyme's point charge distribution. The magnitude and ionic strength dependence of reaction rates, rates for collision anywhere on the enzyme surface, and collision efficiency factors were analyzed to elucidate both the general and specific roles for point charges associated with amino acid residues. Collision rates for the general enzyme surface appear to be solely determined by the net charge on the enzyme. At physiological ionic strength this effect is negligible, with only 6% variation in collision rates observed as the net charge ranges from +2e to -10e. With the exception of a few charged residues in the active-site channel of SOD, point charge modifications had modest effects on reaction rates. For a large region within and surrounding the channel, reaction rates increased or decreased by only 10-15% with the addition or subtraction of a protonic unit of charge, respectively. This effect simply disappeared with increasing distance from the active site. More dramatic effects were seen at only three residues: arginine-141, glutamate-131, and lysine-134. Implications for rate enhancement through site-directed mutagenesis are discussed.     

Novel mechanisms for superoxide-scavenging activity of human manganese superoxide dismutase determined by the K68 key acetylation site

Superoxide is the primary reactive oxygen species generated in the mitochondria. Manganese superoxide dismutase (SOD2) is the major enzymatic superoxide scavenger present in the mitochondrial matrix and one of the most crucial reactive oxygen species-scavenging enzymes in the cell. SOD2 is activated by sirtuin 3 (SIRT3) through NAD⁺-dependent deacetylation. However, the exact acetylation sites of SOD2 are ambiguous and the mechanisms underlying the deacetylation-mediated SOD2 activation largely remain unknown. We are the first to characterize SOD2 mutants of the acetylation sites by investigating the relative enzymatic activity, structures, and electrostatic potential of SOD2 in this study. These SOD2 mutations affected the superoxide-scavenging activity in vitro and in HEK293T cells. The lysine 68 (K68) site is the most important acetylation site contributing to SOD2 activation and plays a role in cell survival after paraquat treatment. The molecular basis underlying the regulation of SOD2 activity by K68 was investigated in detail. Molecular dynamics simulations revealed that K68 mutations induced a conformational shift of residues located in the active center of SOD2 and altered the charge distribution on the SOD2 surface. Thus, the entry of the superoxide anion into the coordinated core of SOD2 was inhibited. Our results provide a novel mechanistic insight, whereby SOD2 acetylation affects the structure and charge distribution of SOD2, its tetramerization, and p53–SOD2 interactions of SOD2 in the mitochondria, which may play a role in nuclear–mitochondrial communication during aging.     

Oxidation-induced misfolding and aggregation of superoxide dismutase and its implications for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

The presence of intracellular aggregates that contain Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD1) in spinal cord motor neurons is a pathological hallmark of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Although SOD1 is abundant in all cells, its half-life in motor neurons far exceeds that in any other cell type. On the basis of the premise that the long half-life of the protein increases the potential for oxidative damage, we investigated the effects of oxidation on misfolding/aggregation of SOD1 and ALS-associated SOD1 mutants. Zinc-deficient wild-type SOD1 and SOD1 mutants were extremely prone to form visible aggregates upon oxidation as compared with wild-type holo-protein. Oxidation of select histidine residues that bind metals in the active site mediates SOD1 aggregation. Our results provide a plausible model to explain the accumulation of SOD1 aggregates in motor neurons affected in ALS.     

A Second Superoxide Dismutase Gene in the Medfly, Ceratitis Capitata

We report the first case of two Cu/Zn Sod genes (ccSod1 and ccSod2) that have been cloned and sequenced from an insect, the medfly, Ceratitis capitata. Biochemical evidence suggested the presence of two Sod genes in the medfly. The two genes are isolated using different molecular strategies: ccSod1 via cross-hybridization to a genomic library using a heterologous probe and ccSod2 from cDNA using a homologous probe generated by PCR. Sequence analysis shows that ccSod1 and ccSod2 are different genes. The inferred amino sequences show that all essential residues of the active site are strictly conserved, which suggests both genes encode functional Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD). Phylogenetic analysis by the maximum parsimony method with bootstrap resampling of previously known Cu/Zn SOD reveals two monophyletic groups, vertebrates and insects. The position of ccSOD2 in this phylogeny is undefined with respect to dipteran ccSOD1, vertebrate, plant, fungal, and extracellular Cu/Zn SOD, which suggests that the duplication detected in Ceratitis is ancient, perhaps as old as the origins of the arthropod phylum in the Cambrian more than 500 million years ago. In situ hybridization to polytene chromosomes places the genes on different chromosomes, which is consistent with an ancient gene duplication.     

Structural characterization of zinc-deficient human superoxide dismutase and implications for ALS

Over 130 mutations to copper, zinc superoxide dismutase (SOD) are implicated in the selective death of motor neurons found in 25% of patients with familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Despite their widespread distribution, ALS mutations appear positioned to cause structural and misfolding defects. Such defects decrease SOD's affinity for zinc, and loss of zinc from SOD is sufficient to induce apoptosis in motor neurons in vitro. To examine the importance of the zinc site in the structure and pathogenesis of human SOD, we determined the 2.0-A-resolution crystal structure of a designed zinc-deficient human SOD, in which two zinc-binding ligands have been mutated to hydrogen-bonding serine residues. This structure revealed a 9 degrees twist of the subunits, which opens the SOD dimer interface and represents the largest intersubunit rotational shift observed for a human SOD variant. Furthermore, the electrostatic loop and zinc-binding subloop were partly disordered, the catalytically important Arg143 was rotated away from the active site, and the normally rigid intramolecular Cys57-Cys146 disulfide bridge assumed two conformations. Together, these changes allow small molecules greater access to the catalytic copper, consistent with the observed increased redox activity of zinc-deficient SOD. Moreover, the dimer interface is weakened and the Cys57-Cys146 disulfide is more labile, as demonstrated by the increased aggregation of zinc-deficient SOD in the presence of a thiol reductant. However, equimolar Cu,Zn SOD rapidly forms heterodimers with zinc-deficient SOD (t1/2 approximately 15 min) and prevents aggregation. The stabilization of zinc-deficient SOD as a heterodimer with Cu,Zn SOD may contribute to the dominant inheritance of ALS mutations. These results have general implications for the importance of framework stability on normal metalloenzyme function and specific implications for the role of zinc ion in the fatal neuropathology associated with SOD mutations.