Hardly a relict: freezing and the evolution of vesselless wood in Winteraceae

The Winteraceae are traditionally regarded as the least-specialized descendents of the first flowering plants, based largely on their lack of xylem vessels. Since vessels have been viewed as a key innovation for angiosperm diversification, Winteraceae have been portrayed as declining relicts, limited to wet forest habitats where their tracheid-based wood does not impose a significant hydraulic constraints. In contrast, phylogenetic analyses place Winteraceae among angiosperm clades with vessels, indicating that their vesselless wood is derived rather than primitive, whereas extension of the Winteraceae fossil record into the Early Cretaceous suggests a more complex ecological history than has been deduced from their current distribution. However, the selective regime and ecological events underlying the possible loss of vessels in Winteraceae have remained enigmatic. Here we examine the hypothesis that vessels were lost as an adaptation to freezing-prone environments in Winteraceae by measuring the responses of xylem water transport to freezing for a diverse group of Winteraceae taxa as compared to Canella winterana (Canellaceae, a close relative with vessels) and sympatric conifer taxa. We found that mean percent loss of xylem water transport capacity following freeze-thaw varied from 0% to 6% for Winteraceae species from freezing-prone temperate climates and approximately 20% in those taxa from tropical (nonfreezing) climates. Similarly, conifers exhibit almost no decrease in xylem hydraulic conductivity following freezing. In contrast, water transport in Canella stems is nearly 85% blocked after freeze-thaw. Although vessel-bearing wood of Canella possesses considerably greaterhydraulic capacity than Winteraceae, nearly 20% of xylem hydraulic conductance remains, a value that is comparable to the hydraulic capacity of vesselless Winteraceae xylem, if the proportion of hydraulic flow through vessels (modeled as ideal capillaries) is removed. Thus, the evolutionary removal of vessels may not necessarily require a deleterious shift to an ineffective vascular system. By integrating Winteraceae's phylogenetic relationships and fossil history with physiological and ecological observations, we suggest that, as ancestors of modern Winteraceae passed through temperate conditions present in Southern Gondwana during the Early Cretaceous, they were exposed to selective pressures against vessel-possession and returned to a vascular system relying on tracheids. These results suggest that the vesselless condition is advantageous in freezing-prone areas, which is supported by the strong bias in the ecological abundance of Winteraceae to wet temperate and tropical alpine habitats, rather than a retained feature from the first vesselless angiosperms. We believe that vesselless wood plays an important role in the ecological abundance of Winteraceae in Southern Hemisphere temperate environments by enabling the retention of leaves and photosynthesis in the face of frequent freeze-thaw events.     

CLADISTICS OF THE MAGNOLIIDAE

Abstract A cladistic resolution is presented for the origin of the angiosperms based on a parsimony analysis of 49 taxa of Magnoliidae. Hamamelidae and Alismatidae, with gymnospermous outgroup comparisons for the polarization of 104 characters. The Magnoliidae is recognized as a paraphyletic assemblage of nine orders: Calycanthales, Magnoliales, Laurales, Illiciales, Lactoridales. Ranunculales, Aristolochiales, Piperales and Nymphaeales. The Calycanthaceae and Idiospermaceae are segregated as the new order Calycanthales, which is hypothesized to be the archetype for angiosperms. Excluding Winteraceae and Lactoridaceae, the Magnoliales is monophyletic. The Austrobaileyaceae is a first branch of Magnoliales, rather than lauralean. Excluding Amborellaceae and Calycanthales, the Laurales is monophyletic. The Chloranthaceae is a first branch of Laurales, rather than piperalean. The Amborellaceae and Winteraceae are early branches of Illiciales. The Lactoridaceae is isolated as the Lactoridales. Including Papaveraceae, the Ranunculales is monophyletic, with Lardizabalaceae as a first branch. The Ranunculales is more closely related to the Hamamelidae, forming the clade Tricolpates. The Aristolochiales, Piperales and Nymphaeales are successively more closely related to the Alismatidae, forming the clade Paleoherbs. The Nelumbonaceae are nymphaealean Paleoherbs, rather than Tricolpates. The Lactoridaceae is not a Paleoherb. These results support many aspects of the strobilar-flower hypothesis for the origin of the angiosperms, as well as the plesiomorphic character states of woody shrubs with simple, pinnatelyveined leaves.     

PRESENCE OF VESSELS IN WOOD OF SARCANDRA (CHLORANTHACEAE); COMMENTS ON VESSEL ORIGINS IN ANGIOSPERMS

Sarcandra is the only genus of Chloranthaceae hitherto thought to be vesselless. Study of liquid-preserved material of S. glabra revealed that in root secondary xylem some tracheary elements are wider in diameter and have markedly scalariform end walls combined with circular pits on lateral walls. Examination of these wider tracheary elements with scanning electron microscope (SEM) demonstrated various degrees of pit membrane absence in the end walls. Commonly a few threadlike fibrils traverse the pits (perforations); these as well as intact nature of pit membranes in pits at ends of some perforation plates are evidence that lack of pit membranes does not result from damage during processing. Some perforations lack any remnants of pit membranes. Although perforation plates and therefore vessels are present in Sarcandra roots, no perforations were observed in tracheary elements of stems or lignotubers. Further, stem tracheids do not have the prominently scalariform end walls that the vessel elements in roots do. Presence of vessels in Sarcandra removes at least one (probably several) hypothetical events of vessel origin that must be postulated to account for known patterns of vessel distribution in angiosperms, assuming that they are primitively vesselless. Seven (perhaps fewer) vessel origin events in angiosperms could account for these patterns; two of those events (Nelumbo and monocotyledons) are different from the others in nature. Widely accepted data on trends of vessel specialization in woody dicotyledons yield an unappreciated implication: vessel specialization has happened in a highly polyphyletic manner in dicotyledons, and therefore multiple vessel origins represent a logical extension backward in time. If a group of vesselless dictyoledons ancestral to other angiosperms existed, they can be hypothesized to have had a relatively homogeneous floral plan now that Sarcandra-like plants no longer need be imagined within that group. Sarcandra and other Chloranthaceae show that the borderline between vessel absence and presence is less sharp than generally appreciated.     

Bordered pits in xylem of vesselless angiosperms and their possible misinterpretation as perforation plates

Vesselless wood represents a rare phenomenon within the angiosperms, characterizing Amborellaceae, Trochodendraceae and Winteraceae. Anatomical observations of bordered pits and their pit membranes based on light, scanning and transmission electron microscopy (SEM and TEM) are required to understand functional questions surrounding vesselless angiosperms and the potential occurrence of cryptic vessels. Interconduit pit membranes in 11 vesselless species showed a similar ultrastructure as mesophytic vessel‐bearing angiosperms, with a mean thickness of 245 nm (± 53, SD; n = six species). Shrunken, damaged and aspirated pit membranes, which were 52% thinner than pit membranes in fresh samples (n = four species), occurred in all dried‐and‐rehydrated samples, and in fresh latewood of Tetracentron sinense and Trochodendron aralioides. SEM demonstrated that shrunken pit membranes showed artificially enlarged, > 100 nm wide pores. Moreover, perfusion experiments with stem segments of Drimys winteri showed that 20 and 50 nm colloidal gold particles only passed through 2 cm long dried‐and‐rehydrated segments, but not through similar sized fresh ones. These results indicate that pit membrane shrinkage is irreversible and associated with a considerable increase in pore size. Moreover, our findings suggest that pit membrane damage, which may occur in planta, could explain earlier records of vessels in vesselless angiosperms.     

Early vessel evolution and the diverisification of wood function: Insights from Malagasy Canellales

Xylem vessels have long been proposed as a key innovation for the ecological diversification of angiosperms by providing a breakthrough in hydraulic efficiency to support high rates of photosynthesis and growth. However, recent studies demonstrated that angiosperm woods with structurally "primitive" vessels did not have greater whole stem hydraulic capacities as compared to vesselless angiosperms. As an alternative to the hydraulic superiority hypothesis, the heteroxylly hypothesis proposes that subtle hydraulic efficiencies of primitive vessels over tracheids enabled new directions of functional specialization in the wood. However, the functional properties of early heteroxyllous wood remain unknown. We selected the two species of Canellales from Madagascar to test the heteroxylly hypothesis because Canellaceae (represented by Cinnamosma madagascariensis) produces wood with vessels of an ancestral form, while Winteraceae, the sister clade (represented by Takhtajania perrieri) is vesselless. We found that heteroxylly correlated with increased wood functional diversity related predominantly to biomechanical specialization. However, vessels were not associated with greater stem hydraulic efficiency or increased shoot hydraulic capacity. Our results support the heteroxylly hypothesis and highlight the importance integrating a broader ecological context to understand the evolution of vessels.     

WOOD ANATOMY OF BUBBIA (WINTERACEAE), WITH COMMENTS ON ORIGIN OF VESSELS IN DICOTYLEDONS

Quantitative and qualitative features of wood anatomy are reported for ten collections of seven species of Bubbia. Variations on the basic plan for Winteraceae can be interpreted in terms of taxonomic and ecological distinctions. Tracheid length is correlated with plant size and habit: tracheids are shortest in shrubs. Tracheid wall thickness and ray cell wall thickness distinguish species. Ray cell procumbency and multiseriate ray width increase with age. Growth rings occur only in a species from stream margins. SEM studies reveal absence of a warty layer within tracheids. Helical thickenings are absent. Presence of these two features in Pseudowintera may be correlated with the cool temperate habitats of that genus. Overlap areas of tracheids in Bubbia show various degrees of scalariform pitting, ranging from none (B. semecarpoides) to abundant presence (B. balansae). Perforation-like pits in tracheids of the latter prove, with SEM studies, to have pit membranes containing porosities less than 1 μm in diameter. Scalariform pitting on overlap areas is absent in earlier secondary xylem and increases during later secondary xylem. Scalariform lateral wall pitting can occur in abnormally wide tracheids formed after pauses in cambial activity. These facts show that primitive dicotyledon woods like those of Bubbia can activate genetic information for scalariform end wall patterns and lateral wall pitting such as primitive vessels show without the intervention of paedomorphosis. Paedomorphosis in dicotyledon woods is held still to apply only to special herbaceous and herblike growth forms, not to primarily woody plants. Progenesis (in xylem, loss of secondary xylem) is not held to be necessary to account for the scalariform patterns seen in tracheary elements of primitive dicotyledons. Reasons are given for rejection of the hypothesis that Winteraceae and other woody dicotyledons (Amborella, Sarcandra, Tetracentron, Trochodendron) are secondarily vesselless.     

Living Cells in Wood 3. Overview; Functional Anatomy of the Parenchyma Network

The very different evolutionary pathways of conifers and angiosperms are very informative precisely because their wood anatomy is so different. New information from anatomy, comparative wood physiology, and comparative ultrastructure can be combined to provide evidence for the role of axial and ray parenchyma in the two groups. Gnetales, which are essentially conifers with vessels, have evolved parallel to angiosperms and show us the value of multiseriate rays and axial parenchyma in a vessel-bearing wood. Gnetales also force us to re-examine optimum anatomical solutions to conduction in vesselless gymnosperms. Axial parenchyma in vessel-bearing woods has diversified to take prominent roles in storage of water and carbohydrates as well as maintenance of conduction in vessels. Axial parenchyma, along with other modifications, has superseded scalariform perforation plates as a safety mechanism and permitted angiosperms to succeed in more seasonal habitats. This diversification has required connection to rays, which have concomitantly become larger and more diverse, acting as pathways for photosynthate passage and storage. Modes of growth such as rapid flushing, vernal leafing-out, drought deciduousness and support of large leaf surfaces become possible, advantaging angiosperms over conifers in various ways. Prominent tracheid-ray pitting (conifers) and axial parenchyma/ray pitting to vessels (angiosperms) are evidence of release of photosynthates into conductive cells; in angiosperms, this system has permitted vessels to survive hydrologic stresses and function in more seasonal habitats. Flow in ray and axial parenchyma cells, suggested by greater length/width ratios of component cells, is confirmed by pitting on end walls of elongate cells: pits are greater in area, more densely placed, and are often bordered. Bordered pit areas and densities on living cells, like those on tracheids and vessels, represent maximal contact areas between cells while minimizing loss of wall strength. Storage cells in rays can be distinguished from flow cells by size and shape, by fewer and smaller pits and by contents. By lacking secondary walls, the entire surfaces of phloem ray and axial phloem parenchyma become conducting areas across which sugars can be translocated. The intercontinuous network of axial parenchyma and ray parenchyma in woods is confirmed; there are no “isolated” living cells in wood when three-dimensional studies are made. Water storage in living cells is reported anatomically and also in the form of percentile quantitative data which reveal degrees and kinds of succulence in angiosperm woods, and norms for “typically woody” species. The diversity in angiosperm axial and ray parenchyma is presented as a series of probable optimal solutions to diverse types of ecology, growth form, and physiology. The numerous homoplasies in these anatomical modes are seen as the informative results of natural experiments and should be considered as evidence along with experimental evidence. Elliptical shape of rays seems governed by mechanical considerations; unusually long (vertically) rays represent a tradeoff in favor of flexibility versus strength. Protracted juvenilism (paedomorphosis) features redirection of flow from horizontal to vertical by means of rays composed predominantly or wholly of upright cells, and the reasons for this anatomical strategy are sought. Protracted juvenilism, still little appreciated, occurs in a sizeable proportion of the world’s plants and is a major source of angiosperm diversification.     

Origins and nature of vessels in Monocotyledons. 14. Vessellessness in Orontioideae (Araceae): adaptation or relictualism?

SEM studies of tracheary elements of subfamily Orontioideae (Lysichiton, Orontium, Symplocarpus) of Araceae show unexpected features. The plants are entirely vesselless. There are small pores in pit membranes of end walls of tracheids in roots and stems, but pit membranes remain intact. End wall pit membranes of stems have a coarse fibrillar texture, somewhat reminiscent of (but different from) those of Nymphaeaceae and Cabombaceae. Acoraceae, which are also vesselless, represent the first branch of the monocot tree, according to phylogenies, and the orontioids form the next branch. Vessellessness is therefore a potentially plesiomorphic feature in monocots, but it may also be related to the highly mesic habitats of Acoraceae and the orontioids. Various other non‐submersed monocots have vesselless or near‐vesselless xylem. Sectioned xylem of Orontioideae is also very suggestive of stages in the development of the pit membranes of both end walls and lateral walls of tracheids: open networks of cellulosic fibrils apparently precede the addition of denser fibrillar meshes, key information in assessing to what extent perforations in scalariform perforation plates of vascular plants may stop formation at the open network stage, and to what extent a thicker pit membrane experiences lysis and disintegration as the vessel element matures.     

Wood anatomy of Polygonaceae: analysis of a family with exceptional wood diversity

Quantitative and qualitative data are presented for woods of 30 species of woody Polygonaceae. Wood features that ally Polygonaceae with Plumbaginaceae include nonbordered perforation plates, storeying in narrow vessels and axial parenchyma, septate or nucleate fibres, vasicentric parenchyma, pith bundles that undergo secondary growth, silica bodies, and ability to form successive cambia. These features are consistent with pairing of Plumbaginaceae and Polygonaceae as sister families. Wood features that ally Polygonaceae with Rhabdodendraceae include nonbordered perforation plates, presence of vestured pits in vessels, presence of silica bodies and dark-staining compounds in ray cells, and ability to form successive cambia. Of the features listed above, nonbordered perforation plates and ability to form successive cambia may be symplesiomorphies basic to Caryophyllales sensu lato . The other features are more likely to be synapomorphies. Wood data thus support molecular cladograms that show the three families near the base of Caryophyllales s.l. Chambered crystals are common to three genera of the family and may indicate relationship. Ray histology suggests secondary woodiness in Antigonon, Atraphaxis, Bilderdykia, Dedeckera, Eriogonum, Harfordia, Muehlenbeckia, Polygonum , and Rumex . Other genera of the family show little or no evidence of secondary woodiness. Molecular data are needed to confirm this interpretation and to clarify the controversial systematic groupings within the family proposed by various authors. Vessel features of Polygonaceae (lumen diameter, element length, density, degree of grouping) show an extraordinary range from xeromorphy to mesomorphy, indicating that wood has played a key role in ecological and habital shifts within the family; the diversity in ecology and habit are correlated with quantitative wood data.  © 2003 The Linnean Society of London. Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society , 2003, 141 , 25−51.     

DNA C-values in seven families fill phylogenetic gaps in the basal angiosperms

The evolutionary significance of the c . 1000-fold range of DNA C-values in angiosperms (1C =  c . 0.1–127.4 pg) has often attracted interest. A recent analysis, which superimposed available C-value data onto the angiosperm phylogeny, that placed Ceratophyllaceae as the most basal angiosperm family led to the conclusion that ancestral angiosperms were characterized by small genomes (defined as 1C £ 3.5 pg). However, with the recent increase in DNA sequence data and large-scale phylogenetic analyses, strong support is now provided for Amborellaceae and/or Nymphaeaceae as the most basal angiosperm families, followed by Austrobaileyales (comprising Schisandraceae, Trimeniaceae and Austrobaileyaceae). Together these five families comprise the ANITA grade. The remaining basal angiosperm families (Ceratophyllaceae, Chloranthaceae and magnoliids), together with monocotyledons and eudicotyledons, form a strongly supported clade. A survey showed that C-value data were scarce in the basal angiosperm families, especially the ANITA grade. The present paper addresses these phylogenetic gaps by providing C-value estimates for each family in ANITA, together with C-values for species in Chloranthaceae, Ceratophyllaceae and a previously unrepresented family in the magnoliids, the Winteraceae.  © The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society , 2002, 140 , 175–179.