Flow cytometric measurement of nuclear DNA content inCapsicum (Solanaceae)

Nuclei were isolated from leaf tissue of differentCapsicum species and the relative fluorescence intensity was measured by flow cytometry after propidium iodide staining.Pisum sativum nuclei with known nuclear genome size (9.07 pg) were used as internal standard to determine nuclear DNA content of the samples in absolute units. The 2C DNA contents ranged between 7.65 pg inC. annuum and 9.72 pg inC. pubescens, and the general mean of the genus was 8.42 pg. These values correspond, respectively, to 1C genome size of 3.691 (C. annuum), 4.690 (C. pubescens) and 4.063 (general mean) Mbp. In general, white-flowered species proved to have less DNA, with the exception ofC. praetermissum, which displayed a 2C DNA content of 9.23 pg. It was possible to divide the studied species into three main groups according to their DNA content, and demonstrate differences in DNA content within two of the three species complexes established on the basis of morphological traits.     

Reference standards for determination of DNA content of plant nuclei

Flow cytometry was used to compare 14 potential reference standards for plant DNA content determination. Both chicken and plant internal standards were used, as were propidium iodide (PI) and 4'-6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI) as fluorochromes. Means and standard errors of the means are presented for the 14 potential reference standards, and the means are compared to those obtained by Feulgen densitometry. Five species are recommended as an initial set of international standards for future plant DNA content determinations: Sorghum bicolor cv. Pioneer 8695 (2C = 1.74 pg), Pisum sativum cv. Minerva Maple (2C = 9.56 pg), Hordeum vulgare cv. Sultan (2C = 11.12 pg), Vicia faba (2C = 26.66 pg), and Allium cepa cv. Ailsa Craig (2C = 33.55 pg). It is recommended that the reference standard of choice be one with 2C and 4C nuclear DNA content peaks similar to, but not overlapping, the 2C and 4C peaks of the target species. We recommend PI as the fluorochrome of choice for flow cytometric determination of plant DNA content. DAPI should be used only if the estimated DNA value is corroborated by using a second stain that has no bias for AT- or GC-rich sequences within genomes.     

Nuclear DNA content of Pinus sylvestris (L.) as determined by laser flow cytometry

Nuclear DNA content was determined in nuclei isolated from needles, stems and roots of in vitro grown seedlings and from megagametophytes and embryo of mature seeds in three accessions of Pinus sylvestris L. One accession was from Inari, northern Finland at timber line, and two accessions were from the Alpine region in Italy. Nuclei were mechanically isolated by a chopping method, stained with propidium iodide, and DNA content was determined using an EPICS PROFILE laser flow cytometer. Nuclei isolated from leaves of barley (Hordeum vulgare L. cv. Sultan; 2C=11.12 pg) were used as an internal standard for measurement of pine nuclei. Mean 1C nuclear DNA content of P. sylvestris was 27.88 pg as determined from megagametophyte tissue. Mean 2C value was 52.25 pg as determined from stem and root tissue, and 55.58 pg as determined from embryo tissue. The ratio of 2C to 1C value was 1.87 and 1.99, respectively. Extracts of nuclei from needles contained propidium iodide-absorbing debris which may have interfered with measurements and resulted in lower 2C values than those obtained from stem and root.     

Estimation of the nuclear DNA content of gossypium species

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Gossypium is an economically important, globally distributed taxon comprising more than 50 species. DNA content estimates from about half of the species indicate over a 3-fold variation exists. However, the nine DNA content estimates for G. hirsutum reveal over a 2-fold difference for this species alone. Recent reports have shown that several plant compounds can bias DNA content estimates obtained by commonly used methods. The purpose of this research was to examine the standardization procedures used for DNA content determinations with flow cytometry as applied to Gossypium, and generate revised DNA content estimates for all available Gossypium species using best-standard practices. METHODS: Flow cytometry was used to measure fluorescence of isolated Gossypium nuclei stained with propidium iodide. Fluorescence values were converted to DNA content estimates based on the nuclear fluorescence of standard genotypes of barley, corn and rice. Various combinations of nuclei preparations relative to the standards were evaluated for their influence on the estimates. KEY RESULTS: Both external standardization and internal standardization with Oryza sativa 'IR36' yielded statistically similar DNA content estimates for Gossypium. Internal standardization with Hordeum vulgare 'Sultan' resulted in a high estimate of DNA content. Nuclear DNA content estimates were generated for 37 Gossypium species using external standardization. Estimates of ancestral genome sizes reveal that both increases and decreases in nuclear DNA content have occurred. Variation in intraspecific and intragenomic DNA content was low, and the allopolyploid AD-genome size was nearly the additive of its progenitor genomes. CONCLUSIONS: Due to unknown factors, internal standardization with H. vulgare 'Sultan' may not be appropriate for DNA content determinations of Gossypium. The current DNA content estimates support accepted cytogenetic divisions of the genus. Gossypium is a genus that exhibits genome constancy both through speciation within genomic groups and allopolyploidization.     

Sunflower (Helianthus annuus) Leaves Contain Compounds that Reduce Nuclear Propidium Iodide Fluorescence

Sunflower leaves have unidentified compounds that interferewith propidium iodide (PI) intercalation and/or fluorescence.Independently prepared pea leaf nuclei show greater PI fluorescencethan nuclei from pea leaves simultaneously processed (co-chopped)with sunflower leaves. Differences in fluorescence persist aftermixing the PI-stained pea and the co-chopped pea/sunflower samples,i.e. PI staining protects the nuclei from the effects of theinhibitor. The current results are significant to practicalflow cytometric determination of plant nuclear DNA content.They show: (1) simultaneous processing of nuclear samples fromthe target and the standard species is necessary to obtain reliableDNA estimates; (2) a test for the presence of inhibitors shouldbe conducted; and (3) when inhibitors are present caution shouldbe taken in interpreting differences in estimated DNA content.The previously reported environmentally-induced variation inDNA content in sunflower populations is most simply explainedby variation in the amount of environmentally-induced inhibitorthat interferes with intercalation and/or fluorescence of PI.Intraspecific variation of DNA content for Helianthus annuusneeds to be re-evaluated using best practice techniques comparingphysiologically uniform tissues that are free of inhibitors.The best estimate for 2C DNA content of H. annuus used in thisstudy is 7.3 pg. Copyright 2000 Annals of Botany Company Helianthus annuus, DNA content, flow cytometry, propidium iodide, endogenous inhibitors     

Nuclear DNA content of some important plant species

Nuclear DNA contents of more than 100 important plant species were measured by flow cytometry of isolated nuclei stained with propidium iodide.Arabidopsis exhibits developmentally regulated multiploidy and has a 2C nuclear DNA content of 0.30 pg (145 Mbp/1C), twice the value usually cited. The 2C value for rice is only about three times that ofArabidopsis. Tomato has a 2C value of about 2.0 pg, larger than commonly cited. This survey identified several horticultural crops in a variety of families with genomes only two or three times as large asArabidopsis; these include several fruit trees (a pricot, cherry, mango, orange, papaya, and peach). The small genome sizes of rice and the horticultural plants should facilitate molecular studies of these crops.     

Estimation of nuclear DNA content of various bamboo and rattan species

We determined the nuclear DNA content (genome size) of over 35 accessions each of bamboo and rattan species from Southeast Asia. The 2C DNA per nucleus was quantified by flow cytometry. The fluorescence of nuclei isolated from the leaves and stained with propidium iodide was measured. The genome size of the bamboo species examined was between 2.5 and 5.9 pg DNA per 2C nucleus. The genome size of the rattan species examined ranged from 1.8 to 10.5 pg DNA per 2C nucleus. This information will be useful for scientists working in diverse areas of plant biology such as biotechnology, biodiversity, genome analysis, plant breeding, physiology and molecular biology. Such data may be utilized to attempt to correlate the genome size with the ploidy status of bamboo species in cases where ploidy status has been reported.     

Nuclear DNA content of the whitefly Bemisia tabaci (Aleyrodidae: Hemiptera) estimated by flow cytometry

The nuclear DNA content of the whitefly Bemisia tabaci (Gennnadius) was estimated using flow cytometry. Male and female nuclei were stained with propidium iodide and their DNA content was estimated using chicken red blood cells and Arabidopsis thaliana L. (Brassicaceae) as external standards. The estimated nuclear DNA content of male and female B. tabaci was 1.04 and 2.06 pg, respectively. These results corroborated previous reports based on chromosome counting, which showed that B. tabaci males are haploid and females are diploid. Conversion between DNA content and genome size (1 pg DNA=980 Mbp) indicate that the haploid genome size of B. tabaci is 1020 Mbp, which is approximately five times the size of the genome of the fruitfly Drosophila melanogaster Meigen. These results provide an important baseline that will facilitate genomics-based research for the B. tabaci complex.     

Are seeds suitable for flow cytometric estimation of plant genome size?

BACKGROUND: Nuclear DNA content in plants is commonly estimated using flow cytometry (FCM). Plant material suitable for FCM measurement should contain the majority of its cells arrested in the G0/G1 phase of the cell cycle. Usually young, rapidly growing leaves are used for analysis. However, in some cases seeds would be more convenient because they can be easily transported and analyzed without the delays and additional costs required to raise seedlings. Using seeds would be particularly suitable for species that contain leaf cytosol compounds affecting fluorochrome accessibility to the DNA. Therefore, the usefulness of seeds or their specific tissues for FCM genome size estimation was investigated, and the results are presented here. METHODS: The genome size of six plant species was determined by FCM using intercalating fluorochrome propidium iodide for staining isolated nuclei. Young leaves and different seed tissues were used as experimental material. Pisum sativum cv. Set (2C = 9.11 pg) was used as an internal standard. For isolation of nuclei from species containing compounds that interfere with propidium iodide intercalation and/or fluorescence, buffers were used supplemented with reductants. RESULTS: For Anethum graveolens, Beta vulgaris, and Zea mays, cytometrically estimated genome size was the same in seeds and leaves. For Helianthus annuus, different values for DNA amounts in seeds and in leaves were obtained when using all but one of four nuclei isolation buffers. For Brassica napus var. oleifera, none of the applied nuclei isolation buffers eliminated differences in genome size determined in the seeds and leaves. CONCLUSIONS: The genome size of species that do not contain compounds that influence fluorochrome accessibility appears to be the same when estimated using specific seed tissues and young leaves. Seeds can be more suitable than leaves, especially for species containing staining inhibitors in the leaf cytosol. Thus, use of seeds for FCM nuclear DNA content estimation is recommended, although for some species a specific seed tissue (usually the radicle) should be used. Protocols for preparation of samples from endospermic and endospermless seeds have been developed.     

Flow cytometric analysis of genome size variation in some Passiflora species

Nuclear genome size variation was studied in eight taxa of Passiflora. Nuclear DNA content was estimated by flow cytometry of nuclei stained by propidium iodide. 2C DNA content ranged from 3.16-5.36 pg for diploids and 1.83 pg for tetraploid. Differences in nuclear genome size were observed among Passiflora species (pg): P. suberosa 1.83, P. edulis f. edulis 3.16, P. edulis f. flavicarpa (Brazil) 3.19, P. edulis f. flavicarpa (Mexico) 3.21, P. mucronata 3.40, Passiflora edmundoi 3.43, P. laurifolia 3.88, P. giberti 3.92, P. quadrangularis 5.36, the largest value being up to 192% greater than the smallest. The means of 2C DNA content were compared by the Tukey test, and the differences in genome size permitted the recognition of five taxa groups. The result was the same for the means 2C genome size (Mbp) values. The genetic parameters were studied with their respective estimators, phenotypic variance (sigma2F), genotypic variability (PhiG), and the genotypic determination index (H2). The genotypic determination index presented high magnitude estimates (greater than 99%) emphasizing the reliability of the results and demonstrating the efficiency of determining the DNA content in the species using only one leaf per plant. Passiflora species show great phenotypic variability and have different geographic distribution that might implicate in genetic diversity.     

Genome size variation in Arachis hypogaea and A. monticola re-evaluated.

Genome size variation within species is a frequently reported, but still a controversial problem. In the present study, we re-evaluated recently published Feulgen densitometric data on genome size and its infraspecific variation in Arachis hypogaea, and also conducted measurements in one accession of its wild relative A. monticola. The methods applied were propidium iodide flow cytometry and Feulgen densitometry using Pisum sativum as an internal standard. The 2C DNA contents previously published cannot be confirmed, but values obtained in this study are about half as large. Additionally, we could not reproduce the previously reported 1.15-fold variation within A. hypogaea; our data indicate genome size stability between respective accessions of this species. Based on 8.84 pg (2C) for Pisum sativum the DNA amounts (2C) were: 5.914 pg in A. hypogaea, and 5.979 pg in A. monticola.     

Nuclear DNA Content of 26 Orchid (Orchidaceae) Genera with Emphasis onDendrobium

2C DNA content values for 70 orchid species from 26 genera,including 37Dendrobiumspecies from eight taxonomic sections,were analysed using flow cytometry. The resulting nuclear DNAcontent values for species other thanDendrobiumranged from 1.91pg 2C^-1to 15.19 pg 2C^-1nuclei forCadetia tayloriandVanilla phaeantha,respectively.Dendrobiumnuclear DNA content values ranged from1.53 pg 2C^-1to 4.23 pg 2C^-1nuclei forD. cruentumandD. spectabile,respectively. DNA content measurements varied greatly withinDendrobiumsectionsLatouria and Spatulata. Nuclear DNA content values for the sixspecies analysed within Latouria ranged from 1.88 pg 2C^-1nucleiforD. macrophyllumto 4.23 pg 2C^-1nuclei forD. spectabile. NuclearDNA content values for the 16 species analysed within Spatulataranged from 1.69 pg 2C^-1nuclei forD. discolorto 4.05 pg 2C^-1nucleiforD. samoense. The least variation in DNA content was foundwithin the section Phalaenanthe, with nuclear DNA content valuesof 1.79 pg  2C^-1, 1.86 pg 2C^-1and 1.98 pg 2C^-1forD. bigibbum,D.affineandD. phalaenopsis, respectively.Copyright 1998 Annalsof Botany Company Orchidaceae,Dendrobium, flow cytometry, propidium iodide, nuclear DNA, genome size, 2C values.     

Determination of ploidy level and nuclear DNA content in blueberry by flow cytometry

The technique of DNA flow cytometry was used to study variation in DNA content among different ploidy levels, as well as among diploid species, of Vaccinium section Cyanococcus. In a sample of plants of varying ploidy level, the relative fluorescence intensity (RFI) of nuclei stained with propidium iodide was a function of the number of chromosome sets (x), as represented by the linear equation RFI=3.7x-2.3 (r²=95%). The data indicated that DNA flow cytometry could be useful for the determination of ploidy level at the seedling stage in blueberry. They also suggest that conventional polyploid evolution has occurred in this section of the genus Vaccinium with an increase in nuclear DNA content concurrent with the increase in chromosome number. The nuclear DNA content of diploid species of Vaccinium section Cyanococcus was estimated from the relationship of the observed RFI to an internal known DNA standard (trout red blood cells). A nested analysis of variance indicated significant variation among species, as well as among populations within species, in nuclear DNA content, although this variation was small compared to the variation among ploidy levels. The variation in nuclear DNA content corresponded to the phylogenetic relationships among species determined from previous studies.     

Estimation of nuclear DNA content of plants by flow cytometry

A rapid and simple protocol for estimation of nuclear DNA content of plants is described. Suspensions of intact nuclei are prepared either by chopping plant tissues or lysing protoplasts in a MgSO₄ buffer, mixed with DNA standards, and stained with propidium iodide in a solution containing DNAase-free RNAase. Fluorescence intensities of the stained nuclei are measured by a flow cytometer. Values for nuclear DNA content are estimated by comparing fluorescence intensities of the nuclei of the test population with those of appropriate internal DNA standards. The same procedure can also be used for rapid determination of ploidy in plant tissues.     

Nuclear DNA contents of all species of Helleborus (Ranunculaceae) discriminate between species and sectional divisions

 Genome size (C-values) and pollen viability staining were applied as new criteria to investigate the species of the genus Helleborus Linnaeus (Ranunculaceae). All species have the same chromosome number (2n=32). However, the nuclear DNA content, as measured by flow cytometry with propidium iodide, could be demonstrated to range between 19 pg to 35.7 pg. The different genome sizes of the species coincided to a large extent with earlier determined section boundaries based on morphology. Flow cytometry can be a convenient method to discriminate between some species. Received April 17, 2001 Accepted May 7, 2001     

Genome Size and Pollen Viability as Taxonomic Criteria: Application to the Genus Hosta

Abstract: Genome size (C values) and pollen viability staining were applied as new criteria to investigate the taxonomy of the genus Hosta Tratt. (Hostaceae). Nearly all species of the genus Hosta have the same basic chromosome number (2n = 2x = 60). However, the nuclear DNA contents, as measured by flow cytometry with propidium iodide, could be demonstrated to range between 17.2 to 26.6 pg. This implies that the largest genome contains roughly 10¹⁰ more base pairs than the smallest. Therefore, nuclear DNA content is a very relevant taxonomic trait that can be measured simply by flow cytometry. In addition, differences in overall DNA composition were demonstrated by comparing to DAPI fluorescence. In general, genome size data confirmed the division into three subgenera. The geographical distribution of genome sizes indicates the migration pattern of Hosta throughout East Asia. The species belonging to the mainly Korean subgenus Bryocles, with a low nuclear DNA content (17.2 - 19.3 pg), can now largely be distinguished from the mainly Japanese species of the subgenus Giboshi (21.3 - 26.5 pg). The exception is H. longissima, that with only 19.6 pg provides a nice example of a decrease in DNA content. On the mainland, as well as on Honshu, species with increased and decreased DNA content have evolved independently. The usefulness of pollen viability to detect hybrids in Hosta was demonstrated in a large series of artificial crosses between bona fide species. Consequently, pollen viability was measured in all available Hosta described as species. Several had low pollen viability and were concluded to be hybrids. Morphology and DNA content confirmed this in most cases. The resulting 23 species approximate the number of Hosta species that follows from the combined studies by Fujita (1976¹⁸) on the Japanese species and Chung (1991 a¹¹) on the Korean species.     

Two new nuclear isolation buffers for plant DNA flow cytometry: a test with 37 species

Background and Aims: After the initial boom in the application of flow cytometryin plant sciences in the late 1980s and early 1990s, which wasaccompanied by development of many nuclear isolation buffers,only a few efforts were made to develop new buffer formulas.In this work, recent data on the performance of nuclear isolationbuffers are utilized in order to develop new buffers, generalpurpose buffer (GPB) and woody plant buffer (WPB), for plantDNA flow cytometry. Methods: GPB and WPB were used to prepare samples for flow cytometricanalysis of nuclear DNA content in a set of 37 plant speciesthat included herbaceous and woody taxa with leaf tissues differingin structure and chemical composition. The following parametersof isolated nuclei were assessed: forward and side light scatter,propidium iodide fluorescence, coefficient of variation of DNApeaks, quantity of debris background, and the number of particlesreleased from sample tissue. The nuclear genome size of 30 selectedspecies was also estimated using the buffer that performed betterfor a given species. Key Results: In unproblematic species, the use of both buffers resulted inhigh quality samples. The analysis of samples obtained withGPB usually resulted in histograms of DNA content with higheror similar resolution than those prepared with the WPB. In morerecalcitrant tissues, such as those from woody plants, WPB performedbetter and GPB failed to provide acceptable results in somecases. Improved resolution of DNA content histograms in comparisonwith previously published buffers was achieved in most of thespecies analysed. Conclusions: WPB is a reliable buffer which is also suitable for the analysisof problematic tissues/species. Although GPB failed with someplant species, it provided high-quality DNA histograms in speciesfrom which nuclear suspensions are easy to prepare. The resultsindicate that even with a broad range of species, either GPBor WPB is suitable for preparation of high-quality suspensionsof intact nuclei suitable for DNA flow cytometry.     

DNA amounts of roses (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Rosa</Emphasis> L.) and their use in attributing ploidy levels

The aims of the investigation were to characterise variability among the DNA amounts of roses and assess the predictability of ploidy levels from DNA amounts. Chromosome numbers in the genus Rosa range from 2n = 2x = 14 to 2n = 8 x = 56 and aneuploidy is rare. Published 2C DNA amounts range from 0.78 pg in R. xanthina Lindl. and R. sericea Lindl. (2n = 2x = 14) to 2.91 pg in R. canina L. (2n = 5x = 35). In this investigation, DNA amounts were estimated by flow cytometry of leaf nuclei stained with propidium iodide, using Petroselinum crispum (2C DNA amount = 4.46 pg) as the internal calibration standard. Ploidy levels based on DNA amounts (DNA ploidy) were assigned by comparing their DNA amounts with published DNA amounts and identifying peaks and intervening discontinuities in frequency distributions of DNA amounts. 2C DNA amounts ranged from 0.83 pg in R. ecae (2x = 2x = 14) to 3.99 pg in R. acicularis (2n = 8 x = 56). Differences in the 1Cx-values (2C DNA amount/ploidy values) were found among the taxonomic sections of Rosa. Ploidy levels could be confidently assigned to most species and cultivars, but the ploidy of some specimens in the section Caninae was uncertain for reasons attributed to genomic diversity and aneuploidy. Cytochimerism was detected in three cultivars of R. x alba. DNA ploidy was determined in 384 specimens representing 74 species and 5 horticultural classes.     

Genome size variation inCajanus cajan (Fabaceae): A reconsideration

A recent investigation of genome size in certain samples of the pigeonpea,Cajanus cajan, indicates values from 1.55 pg to 1.99 pg (1C level), which is 1.29-fold variation between accessions. In the present analysis those of these accessions which had particularly high or low DNA contents in that study were subjected to a reanalysis using propidium iodide and DAPI flow cytometry and Feulgen densitometry. Only minor differences in genome size, not more than 1.047-fold, were found with flow cytometry, and no significant differences were obtained with Feulgen densitometry. The previously reported genome size cannot be confirmed. It is about half as large and was determined in the present study as 0.825 pg (1C, propidium iodide flow cytometry,Glycine max as standard) and 0.853 pg (1C, Feulgen densitometry,Allium cepa andPisum sativum as standards), respectively.     

Nuclear DNA content variation and species relationships in the genus Lupinus (Fabaceae)

The 2C nuclear DNA content has been estimated by flow cytometry in 18 species and botanical forms of the genus Lupinus (family Fabaceae), using propidium iodide as a fluorescent dye. They represented distinct infrageneric taxonomic groups and differed in somatic chromosome numbers. Estimated 2C DNA values ranged from 0.97 pg in L. princei to 2.44 pg in L. luteus, which gives a more than 2.5-fold variation. Statistical analysis of the data obtained resulted in a grouping that supports the generally accepted taxonomic classification of the Old World lupins. The rough-seeded L. princei turned out to be an interesting exception, getting closer to smooth-seeded species. Results of DNA content analyses are discussed with regards to the phylogenetic relationships among the Old World lupins and some aspects of the evolution of the genus.