Restriction and modification in B. subtilis

Summary The effects of restriction in vivo by competent B. subtilis R cells and in vitro by purified endonuclease BsuR on transformation and transfection with native and denatured DNA were investigated.The results show that transformation by either native, or denatured DNA is not affected by restriction, whereas transfection both with native and denatured SPP1 DNA is severely restricted.In contrast to the results obtained in vivo, the biological activity of native and denatured transforming DNA is destroyed by BsuR in vitro, as is the transfecting activity of native and denatured SPP1 DNA. The sensitivity of denatured DNA, either with mixtures of the complementary strands or with separated single strands¹ alone, is significantly lower than that of native DNA.The results are discussed in the context of possible mechanisms underlying the different responses of transforming and transfecting DNA to in vivo restriction by B. subtilis R cells.Abbreviations EGTA ethyleneglycolbis-(aminoethylether)tetraacetic acid - m⁺ modified - m^- non-modified - moi multiplicity of infection - r⁺ m⁺ restricting and modifying - r^- m^- mon-restricting and non-modifying - SSC 0.15M NaCl+0.015 M trisodium citrate - SDS sodium dodecyl sulphate     

Host-controlled modification and restriction in Bacillus subtilis: Bsu 168-system and BsuR-system in B. subtilis 168.

Summary A Bsu168-specific restriction deficient (r ₁₆₈ ^- ) mutant of Bacillus subtilis Marburg 168 was transformed to be BsuR-specific restriction proficient (r _R ⁺ ) with B. subtilis R DNA as efficiently as the Bsu168-specific restriction proficient (r ₁₆₈ ⁺ ) parental strain (hsrM ⁺, hsdR ^-).We constructed r _R ⁺ m _R ⁺ r ₁₆₈ ⁺ m ₁₆₈ ⁺ strain (ISMR 4), r _R ⁺ m _R ⁺ r ₁₆₈ ^- m ₁₆₈ ⁺ strain (ISR 11) and r _R ⁺ m _R ⁺ r ₁₆₈ ^- m ₁₆₈ ^- strain (ISR 6) from strain 101 (r ₁₆₈ ⁺ m ₁₆₈ ⁺ ), strain 1012 (r ₁₆₈ ^- m ₁₆₈ ⁺ ) and strain RM125 (r ₁₆₈ ^- m ₁₆₈ ^- ), respectively by transformation with B. subtilis R DNA, and tested their restriction and modification activities on phage 105C. The results show that the sites recognized by Bsu168-specific restriction and modification enzymes and the sites recognized by BsuR-specific ones are not overlapping.We conclude that the Bsu168-modification and restriction system and the BsuR-modification and restriction system are controlled independently by two distinct sets of genes in the r _R ⁺ m _R ⁺ transformant of r ₁₆₈ ⁺ m ₁₆₈ ⁺ strain B. subtilis 168.     

Construction of a colony bank of E. coli containing hybrid plasmids representative of the Bacillus subtilis 168 genome. Expression of functions harbored by the recombinant plasmids in B. subtilis.

Summary A collection of about 2500 clones containing hybrid plasmids representative of nearly the entire genome of B. subtilis 168 was established in E. coli SK1592 by using the poly(dA)·poly(dT) joining method with randomly sheared DNA fragments and plasmid pHV33, a bifunctional vector which can replicate in both E. coli and B. subtilis. Detection of cloned recombinant DNA molecules was based on the insertional inactivation of the Tc gene occurring at the unique BamHI cleavage site present in the vector plasmid.Thirty individual clones of the collection were shown to hybridize specifically with a B. subtilis rRNA probe. CCC-recombinant plasmids extracted from E. coli were pooled in lots of 100 and used to transform auxotrophic mutants of B. subtilis 168. Complementation of these auxotrophic mutations was observed for several markers such as thr, leuA, hisA, glyB and purB. In several cases, markers carried by the recombinant plasmids were lost from the plasmid and integrated into the chromosomal DNA. Loss of genetic markers from the hybrid plasmids did not occur when a rec ^- recipient strain of B. subtilis was used.Abbreviations Ap^R resistance to ampicillin - Tc^R resistance to tetracycline - Cm^R resistance to chloramphenicol - CCC covalently closed circular duplex - Mdal magadalton     

Restriction and modification in Bacillus subtilis Marburg 168: target sites and effects on plasmid transformation

Summary The effects of the restriction system of Bacillus subtilis strain M on plasmid transformation were studied. Plasmid pHV1401 DNA prepared from B. subtilis transformed the restriction-proficient M strain 100 times more efficiently than the DNA prepared from Escherichia coli, while the two DNA preparations transformed restriction-deficient derivatives of that strain with similar efficiencies. This indicates that transformation with pHV1401 is sensitive to the M restriction system. pHV1401 contains three CTCGAG (XhoI sites). Successive removal of these abolished the effect of restriction. This indicates that the XhoI sites are the targets for the M restriction system.Abbreviations used Ap^r resistance to ampicillin - Cm^r resistance to chloramphenicol - R/M restriction and modification - Tc^r resistance to tetracycline     

DNA degradation in minicells of Escherichia coli K-12

Summary The properties of minicell producing mutants of Escherichia coli deficient in gentic recombination were examined. Experiments were designed to test recombinant formation in conjugal crosses, survival following UV-irradiation in cells, and the state of DNA metabolism in minicells. The REC^- phenotypes are unaffected by min ⁺/^- genotypes in whole cells. In contrast to minicells produced by rec ⁺ parental cells, minicells from a recB21 strain have limited capacity to degrade linear, Hfr transferred DNA. The lack of a functional recA gene product, presumably involved in inhibiting the recBC nuclease action(s), permits unrestricted Hfr DNA breakdown in minicells produced by a recA1 strain. This results in an increase in TCA soluble products and in the formation of small DNA molecules that sediment near the top of an alkaline sucrose gradient. Unlike the linear DNA, circular duplex DNA from plasmids R64-11 or dv, segregated into the minicells, is resistant to breakdown. By using in vitro criteria, and [³²P]-labelled linear DNA from bacteriophage T₇ for substrate, we found that the ATP-dependent exonuclease of the recBC complex (exo V) is present in rec ⁺ and recA^- minicells, and is lacking in the recB21 mutant. In fact, the absence of a functional exo V in recBC^- minicells results in isolation of larger than average Hfr DNA from minicells. We suggest that recombination (REC) enzymes segregate into the polar minicells at the time of minicell biogenesis. This system should be useful for studies on DNA metabolism and functions of the recBC and recA gene products.Paper 1 in series, see Khachatourians et al., 1974.     

Cloning and expression of Bacillus subtilis spore genes

Summary Two spore genes, spoOB and spoIIG have been cloned from the B. subtilis genome library, constructed by ligating Sau3A partially digested DNA to the dephosphorylated pHV33 plasmid vector at its BamH1 site.An hybrid plasmid pGsOB2, carrying a 1.7 Kb insert of B. subtilis DNA amplifiable in E. coli was cloned. This recombinant plasmid was capable of transforming the appropriate B. subtilis Rec⁺ and Rec^- recipients to Spo⁺ at very high efficiency. The pGsOB2 was further subcloned and four hybrid plasmids, pGsOB8, pGsOB9, pGsOB10 and pGsOB11 were selected and their restriction enzyme maps established. The four subcloned hybrid plasmids retained their entire transforming activity in both Rec⁺ and Rec^- recipients although two of them carry the insert in an inverse orientation, indicating thus, that the spoOB gene in these plasmids is being transcribed by the B. subtilis RNA polymerase using an internal promotor of the cloned DNA fragment. The adjacent genes spoIVF and pheA, mapped respectively to the right and left of the spoOB locus, that normally show 90% cotransformation, are absent on the cloned DNA fragments. The cloned hybrid plasmids have been expressed in E. coli minicells and it was shown that the spoOB locus encoded a polypeptide of 24 K.We have also cloned the spoIIG gene in two hybrid plasmids, pGsIIG24 and pGsIIG26, carrying respectively inserts of 2 and 3 Kb. From the transforming activity and the endonuclease cleavage maps it was shown that these two hybrid plasmids do not carry the entire spoIIG locus. The use of these plasmids for further cloning of this gene is discussed.     

W-mutagenesis in competent cells of Bacillus subtilis

Summary The relative yield (N _m/N) of fluorescent mutants Ind^- after the transformation of Bacillus subtilis cells by means of UV-irradiated DNA is much higher in an uvr ^- recipient than in an uvr ⁺ strain, when compared at equal fluence, but practically identical at equal survival. Ind^- mutations are induced by UV-irradiation of separated single strands of transforming DNA. The H-strand is much more sensitive to the mutagenic action of UV light. Preliminary irradiation of competent recipient cells by moderate UV fluences increases the survival of UV-or -irradiated transforming DNA (W-reactivation) and the frequency of Ind^- mutations (W-mutagenesis). During transfection of B. subtilis cells by UV-irradiated prophage DNA isolated from lysogenic cells B. subtilis (Ø105 c ⁺) c-mutants of the phage are obtained in high yield only in conditions of W-mutagenesis, i.e. in UV-irradiated recipient cells. These data show that there is no substantial spontaneous induction of error-prone SOS-repair system in the competent cells of B. subtilis.     

Molecular cloning with bifunctional plasmid vectors in Bacillus subtilis

Summary Cloning in Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis was carried out using the bifunctional plasmid pDH5060. B. subtilis chromosomal DNA and pDH5060 DNA were digested with either BamHI or SalI, then annealed, ligated, and transformed into E. coli SK2267. Transformants containing sequences ligated into the BamHI or SalI sites in the Tc^r gene of pDH5060 were selected directly using a modification of the fusaric acid technique. The BamHI and SalI clone banks contain about 250 and 140 B. subtilis fragments, respectively, with an average insert size of 8–9 Kbp in the BamHI and 4–5 Kbp in the SalI bank. The inserts ranged in size from 0.3 Kbp to greater than 20 Kbp. The vector used here therefore accepts inserts which are significantly larger than previously reported for other B. subtilis cloning systems. All individual cloned B. subtilis sequences examined were stably propagated in E. coli SK2267. Eight of eighteen B. subtilis auxotrophic markers tested (aroG, gltA, glyB, ilvA, metC, purA, pyrD, and thrA) were transformed to prototrophy with BamHI or SalI clone bank DNA. All or part of the hybrid plasmid DNA recombined at the sites of homology in the chromosome of these Rec⁺ recipients. Loss of sequences from hybrid plasmids was not prevented in a r ^- m ^- recE4 recipient strain of B. subtilis. Although the recE4 background prevented recombination between homologous chromosomal DNA, a variety of cloned fragments were shown to be unstable and undergo deletions of both insert and plasmid sequences. In addition, B. subtilis sequences propagated in E. coli transformed B. subtilis recE4 recipients with a 500-1,000-fold reduced efficiency.     

Muscle Contraction : (Outline Studies in Biology) by C.R. Bagshaw Chapman & Hall; London,New York, 1982 79 pages. £2.75

On incubation of B. subtilis RM125(arg15 leuA8 r_M^? m_M^?) with DNA from alkalophilic Bacillus, the transformants (Arg⁺Leu^? or Leu^?Arg⁺) appeared at pH 10. The transformants were able to grow even at pH 7. Alkalophilic Bacillus was resistant to bacteriophages π105D1C2·1012 grown on B. subtilis 1012(r^-m_M⁺) and π105D1C2·ISMR4 grown on B. subtilis ISMR4r_M⁺r_R⁺m_M⁺m_R⁺), but the recipient B. subtilis and the transformant(Arg⁺Leu^?) were susceptible to both the of the bacteriophages. The results indicate that the transformant is a B. subtilis derivative and that alkalophilicity of alkalophilic Bacillus was transferred to B. subtilis.     

Simple,fast and high‐efficiency transformation system for directed evolution of cellulase in Bacillus subtilis

Bacillus subtilis can serve as a powerful platform for directed evolution, especially for secretory enzymes. However, cloning and transformation of a DNA mutant library in B. subtilis are not as easy as they are in Escherichia coli. For direct transformation of B. subtilis, here we developed a new protocol based on supercompetent cells prepared from the recombinant B. subtilis strain SCK6 and multimeric plasmids. This new protocol is simple (restriction enzyme‐, phosphatase‐ and ligase‐free), fast (i.e. 1 day) and of high efficiency (i.e. ～10⁷ or ～10⁴ transformants per µg of multimeric plasmid or ligated plasmid DNA respectively). Supercompetent B. subtilis SCK6 cells were prepared by overexpression of the competence master regulator ComK that was induced by adding xylose. The DNA mutant library was generated through a two‐round PCR: (i) the mutagenized DNA fragments were generated by error‐prone PCR and linearized plasmids were made using high‐fidelity PCR, and (ii) the multimeric plasmids were generated based on these two DNA templates by using overlap PCR. Both protein expression level and specific activity of glycoside hydrolase family 5 endoglucanse on regenerated amorphous cellulose were improved through this new system. To our limited knowledge, this study is the first report for enhancing secretory cellulase performance on insoluble cellulose.     

A bifunctional plasmid carrying the recA gene of E. coli

Summary To investigate the effect of an active, plasmid-carried recA gene on the stability and/or the expression of plasmid genes in different genetic backgrounds, we have constructed a bifunctional plasmid (able to replicate in Escherichia coli and in Bacillus subtilis). Chimeric plasmids were obtained by inserting pC194 (Ehrlich 1977) into pDR1453 (Sancar and Rupp 1979). pDR1453 is a 12.9 Kbp plasmid constructed by inserting an E. coli chromosome fragment carrying the recA gene into pBR322. The expected bifunctional recombinant (pMR22/1) (15.7 Kbp) was easily obtained but surprisingly the Cm resistance was expressed only at a very low level in E. coli (as compared, for example, to pHV14, pHV15). We attribute this effect to the presence of multiple recA genes in the cell. On the contrary, Cm^r E. coli transformants bear a recombinant plasmid (pMR22/n) containing tandemly repeated copies of pC194 in equilibrium with excised free pC194. Such amplification has never been observed in a Rec^- background and is therefore mediated by the recA genes. Growth of these clones in the absence of Cm causes the loss of the extra copies, yielding a plasmid with a single copy of pC194, indistingishable from pMR22/1. Interestingly, we have observed that deletions occur at high frequency in pC194, which drastically increase Cm^r in E. coli containing plasmids with a single copy of pC194. Two types of such deletions were detected: (a) large 1050 bp deletions covering about onethird of pC194 and (b) small 120–150 bp deletions (near the MspI site) in the region containing the replicative functions of pC194 (Horinouchi and Weisblum 1982). Both types of deletion render the recombinant plasmid unable to replicate in B. subtilis. pM22/1 replicates, although with a low copy-number, and is stable in B. subtilis wild type; the recA gene of E. coli does not complement any of the rec ^- mutations of B. subtilis. A strong instability, mainly of the E. coli and pBR322 sequences, was observed in many dna and rec mutants of B. subtilis yielding smaller plasmid with a much higher copy-number.     

Biological assay of prokaryotic genes in mouse cells following DNA mediated transformation

Summary Genes coding for leucine biosynthesis in Bacillus subtilis were introduced into mouse LTK^- cells by co-transformation with thymidine kinase⁺ (tk) DNA. Genomic DNA from the tk⁺ transformants was used to transform competent cultures of different B. subtilis leucine auxotrophs. Each auxotroph was transformed to prototrophy at a similar frequency and the number of leucine gene sequences per transformant genome as deduced by the B. subtilis bioassay strongly correlated with the number estimated by hybridization methods. Tk^- subclones were obtained by plating the transformants in 5-bromodeoxyuridine. One subclone still contained the non-selected leucine gene sequences and could transform auxotrophs of B. subtilis. No deletions or rearrangements in the linkage relationships of the leucine genes occurred in the LTK^- cells that inhibited transformation of B. subtilis.     

Interspecific plasmid transfer between Streptococcus pneumoniae and Bacillus subtilis

Summary The streptococcal plasmids pMV158 and pLS1, grown in Streptococcus pneumoniae, were transferred to Bacillus subtilis by DNA-mediated transformation. The plasmids were unchanged in the new host; no deletions were observed in 80 instances of transfer. Their copy number was similar to that in S. pneumoniae. Two B. subtilis plasmids, pUB110 and pBD6, could not be transferred to S. pneumoniae. Hybrid plasmids were produced by recombining the EcoRI fragment of pBD6 that confers Km^r with EcoRI-cut pLS1, which confers Tc^r. The simple hybrid, pMP2, was transferable to both species and expressed Tc^r and Km^r in both. A derivative, pMP5, which contained an insertion in the pBD6 component, expressed a higher level of kanomycin resistance and was more easily selected in S. pneumoniae. Another derivative, pMP3, which contained an additional EcoRI fragment, presumably of pneumococcal chromosomal DNA, could not be transferred to B. subtilis. Previous findings that monomeric plasmid forms could transform S. pneumoniae but not B. subtilis were confirmed using single plasmid preparations. Although plasmids extracted from either species were readily transferred to S. pneumoniae, successive passage in B. subtilis increased the ability of plasmid extracts to transfer the plasmid to a B. subtilis recipient. This adaptation was tentatively ascribed to an enrichment of multimeric forms in extracts of B. subtilis as compared to S. pneumoniae. A review of host ranges exhibited by plasmids of Gram-positive bacteria suggested differences in their ability to use particular host replication functions. The pMP5 plasmid, with readily selectable Km^r and Tc^r markers in both hosts, and with the potential for inactivation of Km^r by insertion in the Bg/II site, could be a useful shuttle vector for cloning in S. pneumoniae and B. subtilis.     

Plasmid transformation in Bacillus subtilis: effects of insertion of Bacillus subtilis DNA into plasmid pC194

Summary We have constructed a hybrid plasmid, pBC1, which consists of plasmid pC194 with an insert of B. subtilis DNA at its HindIII restriction site. This plasmid is stably maintained in B. subtilis. In contrast with pC194, monomeric ccc forms of pBC1 are active in transformation. Transformations with these monomeric molecules of pBC1 have a stringent requirement for recombination proficieny., as defined by recE in the recipient cell. The extent of dependence of the transforming activity of oligomeric pBC1 DNA on the recombination proficiency of the recipient cell decreases with increasing oligomer size. A model of DNA proccssing during plasmid transformation of B. subtilis is presented.     

Characterization of pTZ12, a Chloramphenicol-resistance Plasmid in Bacillus subtilis

The chloramphenicol-resistance (CP^r) plasmid pTZ12 (2.55 kb) in Bacillus subtilis was genetically analyzed in detail, and the CP^r determinant and the functional unit of replication were mapped. The plasmids pTZ12 and pBR322 were digested with suitable restriction endonucleases and ligated with T4 ligase. The ligated DNAs were introduced into E. coli by transformation and CP-resistant transformants were selected. In conclusion, the CP^r determinant was mapped between a TaqI site and a BclI site (about 900 base pairs) on pTZ12. A set of pTZ12–pBR322 recombinant plasmids isolated from E. coli was introduced into B. subtilis by transformation to test for ability to replicate in B. subtilis. From the results, the region of the functional unit of pTZ12 replication was mapped. It was also proved that the gene product of this CP^r determinant was chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) and the native CAT in the cells carrying pTZ12 was a dimeric protein with two identical subunits having a molecular weight of approximately 24,000 (24 K).     

Direct plasmid transfer from replica-plated E. coli colonies to competent B. subtilis cells. Identification of an E. coli clone carrying the hisH and tyrA genes of B. subtilis

Summary We have cloned the hisH tyrA wild-type genes of Bacillus subtilis with the aid of the chimeric plasmid pBJ194, which replicates both in B. subtilis and Escherichia coli. Primary cloning was done in E. coli. The original E. coli clone, carrying the recombinant plasmid (pGR1) which complements hisH tyrA mutants of B. subtilis, was selected directly from a mixture of plated E. coli clones by replicaplating these clones onto minimal agar plates without tyrosine spread just before with competent B. subtilis cells. After overnight incubation clusters of small colonies had developed exclusively in the E. coli [pGR1] colony prints.The Tyr⁺ minicolonies were shown to be B. subtilis carrying pGR1 because (i) their appearance depended linearly on the number of B. subtilis cells plated, (ii) they produced extracellular protease and amylase and (iii) plasmids could be reisolated from the minicolonies and used to transform B. subtilis recE4 tyrA1 both to Cm^r and Tyr⁺.Plasmid pGR1 transfer through replica plating was compared with plasmid transfer in liquid. Both systems depended on transformable B. subtilis strains and were sensitive to DNAseI. However, whereas integration of the tyrA ⁺ gene into the chromosome and concomittant loss of plasmids occurred frequently during regular plasmid transformation of Rec⁺ B. subtilis, this was a rare event during plasmid transfer through replica plating.     

Genetic studies on site-specific endodeoxyribonucleases in Bacillus subtilis: multiple modification and restriction systems in transformants of Bacillus subtilis 168

Summary We transformed B. subtilis 168 with DNA from B. subtilis IAM1231, IAM1192 and ATCC6633. When we examined the restriction activities of the transformants in vivo and in vitro using phage 105C we found the following: (1) Cells of either IAM1231 or IAM1192 have two modification and restriction systems (Bsu1231(1)-system and Bsu1231(II)-system in IAM1231, and Bsu1192(I)-system and Bsu1192(II)-systems in IAM1192), and cells of ATCC6633 have only one system (Bsu6633-system). (2) The restriction enzymes of all of these five systems are site-specific endonucleases. (3) The nucleotide sequence specificities of the enzymes involved in Bsu1231(I)-system, Bsu1192(I)-system and Bsu6633-system are the same; and those of Bsu1231(II)-system and Bsu1192(II)-system are the same. The sequence specificities of these two groups are different from each other and also different from those of the Bsu168-system of B. subtilis 168, the BsuR-system of B. subtilis R and the Bsu1247(I)-and Bsu1247(II)-systems which are systems of B. subtilis IAM1247. (4) Transformants possessing four different modification and restriction systems (Bsu1231(I)-, Bsu1247(I)-, BsuR- and Bsu168-systems) were constructed. (5) Transformation of two derivatives of 168 that were m _R ⁺ r _R ⁺ by DNA from IAM1231 produced 16 transformants that had the Bsu1231(II) restriction system, but had lost the BsuR system. Transformation of a derivative of 168 that was m _1247(II) ⁺ r _1247(II) ⁺ by DNA from m _1231(II) ⁺ r _1231(II) ⁺ -or m _R ⁺ r _R ⁺ -derivative of 168 produced about 100 each of transformants that had the Bsu1231(II)-restriction system or the BsuR-restriction system. But all these transformants lost the Bsu1247(II)-system.     

Cloning and expression inEscherichia coli of arecA-like gene fromZymomonas mobilis

Intergeneric complementation ofEscherichia coli recA mutants was used to identify recombinant plasmids, within a genomic library derived fromZymomonas mobilis, that carryZ. mobilis recA-like gene. Screening of 1100 individualE. coli strains revealed four clones expressing therecA⁺ character. On restriction analysis, all four recombinant plasmids were found to be related and to exhibit a common 6.7-kb fragment. Consequently, one of the four recombinant plasmids, pZR27, was selected for further characterization. When introduced intoE. coli recA mutants, pZR27 restored resistance to methyl methane sulfonate, mitomycin-C, and UV irradiation, as well as recombination proficiency when measured by standard Hfr-mediated conjugation. The clonedrecA-like gene also restored the spontaneous and mitomycin-C-induced phage production. The origin of the insert in pZR27 from the chromosome ofZ. mobilis was confirmed by Southern transfer and DNA hybridization. However, no homology was found between therecA ofE. coli andZ. mobilis chromosomal insert DNA. TheZ. mobilis recA-like gene also encoded a major polypeptide of 38-kDa on SDS-PAGE.     

A quantitative analysis of shotgun cloning in Bacillus subtilis protoplasts

Summary We used the Escherichia coli-Bacillus subtilis shuttle vector pHP13, which carries the replication functions of the cryptic B. subtilis plasmid pTA1060, to study the effects of BsuM restriction, plasmid size and DNA concentration on the efficiency of shotgun cloning of heterologous E. coli DNA in B. subtilis protoplasts. In a restriction-deficient strain, clones were obtained with low frequency (19% of the transformants contained a recombinant plasmid) and large inserts (>6 kb) were relatively rare (12% of the clones contained inserts in the range of 6–9 kb). The efficiency of shotgun cloning was severely reduced in restricting protoplasts: the class of large inserts (>6 kb) was under-represented in the clone bank (4% of the clones contained inserts in the range of 6–6.1 kb). Furthermore, BsuM restriction caused structural instability of some recombinant plasmids. Transformation of protoplasts with individual recombinant plasmids showed that plasmid size and transforming activity were negatively correlated. The size effect was most extreme with cut and religated plasmid DNA. The yield of clones was independent of the DNA concentration during transformation. It is therefore unlikely that clones were not detected because of simultaneous uptake of more than one plasmid. It is concluded that shotgun cloning in B. subtilis protoplasts is inferior to that in competent cells.