Differential Expression of Tomato Spotted Wilt Virus-Derived Viral Small RNAs in Infected Commercial and Experimental Host Plants

Background

Viral small RNAs (vsiRNAs) in the infected host can be generated from viral double-stranded RNA replicative intermediates, self-complementary regions of the viral genome or from the action of host RNA-dependent RNA polymerases on viral templates. The vsiRNA abundance and profile as well as the endogenous small RNA population can vary between different hosts infected by the same virus influencing viral pathogenicity and host response. There are no reports on the analysis of vsiRNAs of Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV), a segmented negative stranded RNA virus in the family Bunyaviridae, with two of its gene segments showing ambisense gene arrangement. The virus causes significant economic losses to numerous field and horticultural crops worldwide.

Principal Findings

Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV)-specific vsiRNAs were characterized by deep sequencing in virus-infected experimental host Nicotiana benthamiana and a commercial, susceptible host tomato. The total small (s) RNA reads in TSWV-infected tomato sample showed relatively equal distribution of 21, 22 and 24 nt, whereas N. benthamiana sample was dominated by 24 nt total sRNAs. The number of vsiRNA reads detected in tomato was many a magnitude (~350:1) higher than those found in N. benthamiana, however the profile of vsiRNAs in terms of relative abundance 21, 22 and 24 nt class size was similar in both the hosts. Maximum vsiRNA reads were obtained for the M RNA segment of TSWV while the largest L RNA segment had the least number of vsiRNAs in both tomato and N. benthamiana. Only the silencing suppressor, NSs, of TSWV recorded higher antisense vsiRNA with respect to the coding frame among all the genes of TSWV.

Significance

Details of the origin, distribution and abundance of TSWV vsiRNAs could be useful in designing efficient targets for exploiting RNA interference for virus resistance. It also has major implications toward our understanding of the differential processing of vsiRNAs in antiviral defense and viral pathogenicity.     

Structural and Functional Analysis of Viral siRNAs

A large amount of short interfering RNA (vsiRNA) is generated from plant viruses during infection, but the function, structure and biogenesis of these is not understood. We profiled vsiRNAs using two different high-throughput sequencing platforms and also developed a hybridisation based array approach. The profiles obtained through the Solexa platform and by hybridisation were very similar to each other but different from the 454 profile. Both deep sequencing techniques revealed a strong bias in vsiRNAs for the positive strand of the virus and identified regions on the viral genome that produced vsiRNA in much higher abundance than other regions. The hybridisation approach also showed that the position of highly abundant vsiRNAs was the same in different plant species and in the absence of RDR6. We used the Terminator 5′-Phosphate-Dependent Exonuclease to study the 5′ end of vsiRNAs and showed that a perfect control duplex was not digested by the enzyme without denaturation and that the efficiency of the Terminator was strongly affected by the concentration of the substrate. We found that most vsiRNAs have 5′ monophosphates, which was also confirmed by profiling short RNA libraries following either direct ligation of adapters to the 5′ end of short RNAs or after replacing any potential 5′ ends with monophosphates. The Terminator experiments also showed that vsiRNAs were not perfect duplexes. Using a sensor construct we also found that regions from the viral genome that were complementary to non-abundant vsiRNAs were targeted in planta just as efficiently as regions recognised by abundant vsiRNAs. Different high-throughput sequencing techniques have different reproducible sequence bias and generate different profiles of short RNAs. The Terminator exonuclease does not process double stranded RNA, and because short RNAs can quickly re-anneal at high concentration, this assay can be misleading if the substrate is not denatured and not analysed in a dilution series. The sequence profiles and Terminator digests suggest that CymRSV siRNAs are produced from the structured positive strand rather than from perfect double stranded RNA or by RNA dependent RNA polymerase.     

Genome-wide analysis of small RNAs from Odontoglossum ringspot virus and Cymbidium mosaic virus synergistically infecting Phalaenopsis

Cymbidium mosaic virus (CymMV) and Odontoglossum ringspot virus (ORSV) are the two most prevalent viruses infecting orchids and causing economic losses worldwide. Mixed infection of CymMV and ORSV could induce intensified symptoms as early at 10 days post-inoculation in inoculated Phalaenopsis amabilis, where CymMV pathogenesis was unilaterally enhanced by ORSV. To reveal the antiviral RNA silencing activity in orchids, we characterized the viral small-interfering RNAs (vsiRNAs) from CymMV and ORSV singly or synergistically infecting P. amabilis. We also temporally classified the inoculated leaf-tip tissues and noninoculated adjacent tissues as late and early stages of infection, respectively. Regardless of early or late stage with single or double infection, CymMV and ORSV vsiRNAs were predominant in 21- and 22-nt sizes, with excess positive polarity and under-represented 5ʹ-guanine. While CymMV vsiRNAs mainly derived from RNA-dependent RNA polymerase-coding regions, ORSV vsiRNAs encompassed the coat protein gene and 3ʹ-untranslated region, with a specific hotspot residing in the 3ʹ-terminal pseudoknot. With double infection, CymMV vsiRNAs increased more than 5-fold in number with increasing virus titres. Most vsiRNA features remained unchanged with double inoculation, but additional ORSV vsiRNA hotspot peaks were prominent. The potential vsiRNA-mediated regulation of the novel targets in double-infected tissues thereby provides a different view of CymMV and ORSV synergism. Hence, temporally profiled vsiRNAs from taxonomically distinct CymMV and ORSV illustrate active antiviral RNA silencing in their natural host, Phalaenopsis, during both early and late stages of infection. Our findings provide insights into offence–defence interactions among CymMV, ORSV and orchids.     

vsiRNA18 derived from tobacco curly shoot virus can regulate virus infection in Nicotiana benthamiana

Virus-derived small interfering RNAs (vsiRNAs) play important roles in regulating host endogenous gene expression to promote virus infection and induce RNA silencing to suppress virus infection. However, to date, how vsiRNAs affect geminivirus infection in host plants has been less studied. In this study, we found that tobacco curly shoot virus (TbCSV)-derived vsiRNA18 (TvsiRNA18) can regulate TbCSV infection in Nicotiana benthamiana plants. The virus-mediated small RNA expression system and stable transformation technique were used to clarify the molecular role of TvsiRNA18 in TbCSV infection. The results indicate that TvsiRNA18 can aggravate disease symptoms in these plants and enhance viral DNA accumulation. ATP-dependent RNA helicase (ATP-dRH) was proven to be a target of TvsiRNA18, and down-regulation of ATP-dRH in plants was shown to induce virus-like leaf curling symptoms and increase TbCSV infection. These results suggest that TvsiRNA18 is an important regulator of TbCSV infection by suppressing ATP-dRH expression. This is the first report to demonstrate that TbCSV-derived vsiRNA can target host endogenous genes to affect symptom development, which helps to reveal the molecular mechanism of symptom occurrence after the virus infects the host.     

Efficient Dicer processing of virus-derived double-stranded RNAs and its modulation by RIG-I-like receptor LGP2

The interferon-regulated antiviral responses are essential for the induction of both innate and adaptive immunity in mammals. Production of virus-derived small-interfering RNAs (vsiRNAs) to restrict virus infection by RNA interference (RNAi) is a recently identified mammalian immune response to several RNA viruses, which cause important human diseases such as influenza and Zika virus. However, little is known about Dicer processing of viral double-stranded RNA replicative intermediates (dsRNA-vRIs) in mammalian somatic cells. Here we show that infected somatic cells produced more influenza vsiRNAs than cellular microRNAs when both were produced by human Dicer expressed de novo, indicating that dsRNA-vRIs are not poor Dicer substrates as previously proposed according to in vitro Dicer processing of synthetic long dsRNA. We report the first evidence both for canonical vsiRNA production during wild-type Nodamura virus infection and direct vsiRNA sequestration by its RNAi suppressor protein B2 in two strains of suckling mice. Moreover, Sindbis virus (SINV) accumulation in vivo was decreased by prior production of SINV-targeting vsiRNAs triggered by infection and increased by heterologous expression of B2 in cis from SINV genome, indicating an antiviral function for the induced RNAi response. These findings reveal that unlike artificial long dsRNA, dsRNA-vRIs made during authentic infection of mature somatic cells are efficiently processed by Dicer into vsiRNAs to direct antiviral RNAi. Interestingly, Dicer processing of dsRNA-vRIs into vsiRNAs was inhibited by LGP2 (laboratory of genetics and physiology 2), which was encoded by an interferon-stimulated gene (ISG) shown recently to inhibit Dicer processing of artificial long dsRNA in cell culture. Our work thus further suggests negative modulation of antiviral RNAi by a known ISG from the interferon response.     

Mycoviruses of Botrytis cinerea isolates from different hosts

Botrytis cinerea (teleomorph Botryotinia fuckeliana) is a necrotrophic plant pathogenic fungus that causes grey mould and enormous economic losses worldwide in different crops. Control of B. cinerea is difficult due to the appearance of fungicide‐resistant isolates, and the diversity in virulence due to genetic variability and, perhaps, the infection with mycoviruses or fungal viruses. The discovery of mycoviruses and their possible application as biocontrol agents, as well as their use as tools to study the plant–pathogen interaction, has encouraged their study in B. cinerea. Herein, we have analysed the occurrence of mycoviruses in Spanish B. cinerea isolates to approach a better understanding of the interactions among viruses, fungi and plants in this pathosystem. Fifty‐five percent of the B. cinerea isolates analysed contained double‐stranded RNA (dsRNA) elements, and the number of dsRNA elements, their relative concentration and size were variable among isolates. Some of these dsRNAs were related to the presence of virus like rod or isometric particles, and to cellular degeneration and malformed mitochondria. We have also demonstrated that a 3 kb dsRNA present in 55% of the isolates having dsRNA elements was a mycovirus genome. Partial sequence of that mycovirus presented high identity in nucleotide and amino acid sequence with Botrytis cinerea mitovirus 1 (BcMV1). Analysis of the genetic distance within Spanish BcMV1 sequences showed the existence of different isolates of this mitovirus inside the Spanish B. cinerea population analysed. This is the first report of the variability of dsRNA elements and the partial genome sequence of a mitovirus associated with Spanish B. cinerea isolates and the genetic diversity within Spanish isolates of BcMV1.     

Evolution and Diversification of RNA Silencing Proteins in Fungi

Comprehensive phylogenetic analyses of fungal Argonaute, Dicer, and RNA-dependent RNA polymerase-like proteins have been performed to gain insights into the diversification of RNA silencing pathways during the evolution of fungi. A wide range of fungi including ascomycetes, basidiomycetyes, and zygomycetes possesses multiple RNA silencing components in the genome, whereas a portion of ascomycete and basidiomycete fungi apparently lacks the whole or most of the components. The number of paralogous silencing proteins in the genome differs considerably among fungal species, suggesting that RNA silencing pathways have diversified significantly during evolution in parallel with developing the complexity of life cycle or in response to environmental conditions. Interestingly, orthologous silencing proteins from different fungal clades are often clustered more closely than paralogous proteins in a fungus, indicating that duplication events occurred before speciation events. Therefore, the origin of multiple RNA silencing pathways seems to be very ancient, likely having occurred prior to the divergence of the major fungal lineages. Electronic Supplementary Material Electronic Supplementary material is available for this article at and accessible for authorised users. [Reviewing Editor: Dr. Rüdiger Cerff]     

Virus-derived small interfering RNAs at the core of plant-virus interactions

Once a virus enters a cell, viral double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) is targeted by the RNA silencing machinery to initiate a cascade of regulatory events directed by viral small interfering RNAs (vsiRNAs). Recent genetic and functional studies along with the high-throughput sequencing of vsiRNAs have shed light on the genetic and structural requirements for virus targeting, the origins and compositions of vsiRNAs and their potential for controlling gene expression. The precise nature of the triggering molecules of virus-induced RNA silencing or the targeting constraints for viral genome recognition and processing represent outstanding questions that will be discussed in this review. The contribution of vsiRNAs to antiviral defense and host genome modifications has profound implications for our understanding of viral pathogenicity and host specificity in plants.     

Investigating the role of dicer 2 (dcr2) in gene silencing and the regulation of mycoviruses in Botrytis cinerea

Botrytis cinerea, the fungus causing gray mould disease, is usually controlled by cultural and chemical methods. It would be interesting to see if mycoviruses were a feasible method for reducing fungal virulence thus controlling the disease, but first more has to be understood of the RNA silencing mechanism and whether mycoviruses can combat such defences. Analysis of the B. cinerea genome data identified two Dicer genes: dcr1 and dcr2. In other fungi, mutation or deletion of dcr2 usually leads to impaired gene silencing. Targeted gene disruption created two independent B. cinerea Δdcr2 mutants in a ku70 background. When the Δdcr2 mutants were transformed with an argininosuccinate synthetase (bcass1) silencing cassette, many of these transformants displayed arginine auxotrophy, suggesting that silencing was still functional in a Δdcr2 mutant. Transfection of the wild-type and dcr2-disrupted B. cinerea lines with Botrytis virus F (BVF) gave no readily detectable alteration in fungal growth rate or virulence. Expression of dcr2, but not dcr1, was suppressed in the wild-type at 7 days post infection with BVF, whereas in a Δdcr2 mutant, dcr1 expression was suppressed. By 28 days post BVF-infection, dcr1 and dcr2 were expressed to the elevated levels typically observed when gene silencing is induced. This shows that whilst dcr2 is not essential for gene silencing or for controlling mycovirus such as BVF, it would appear that the mycovirus BVF is able to suppress the normal expression of genes involved in the silencing pathway, at least during early stages of infection of B. cinerea.     

CHARACTERIZATION OF HaRNAV,A SINGLE‐STRANDED RNA VIRUS CAUSING LYSIS OF HETEROSIGMA AKASHIWO (RAPHIDOPHYCEAE)1

HaRNAV, a novel virus that infects the toxic bloom‐forming alga Heterosigma akashiwo (Hada) Hada ex Hada et Chihara, was characterized based on morphology, pathology, nucleic acid type, structural proteins, and the range of host strains that it infects. HaRNAV is a 25‐nm single‐stranded RNA (ssRNA) virus with a genome size of approximately 9100 nucleotides. This is the first report of an ssRNA virus that causes lysis of a phytoplankton species. The virus particle is sensitive to chloroform and contains at least five structural proteins ranging in apparent size from 24 to 34 kDa. HaRNAV infection causes swelling of the endoplasmic reticulum and progeny virus particles assemble in the cytoplasm of the host, frequently in crystalline arrays. The infectivity of HaRNAV was tested against 15 strains of H. akashiwo isolated from Japanese waters, the Northeast Pacific, and the Northwest Atlantic. HaRNAV caused lysis of three strains from the Northeast Pacific and two strains from Japan but none from the Northwest Atlantic. The characterization of HaRNAV demonstrates that HaRNAV is a novel type of phytoplankton virus but has some similarities with plant viruses belonging to the Sequiviridae and to other known ssRNA viruses. Further genomic analysis, however, is necessary to determine any phylogenetic relationships. The discovery of HaRNAV emphasizes the diversity of H. akashiwo viral pathogens and, more importantly, algal–virus pathogens and the complexity of virus–host interactions in the environment.     

Aspergillus mycoviruses are targets and suppressors of RNA silencing

RNA silencing can function as a virus defense mechanism in a diverse range of eukaryotes, and many viruses are capable of suppressing the silencing machinery targeting them. However, the extent to which this occurs between fungal RNA silencing and mycoviruses is unclear. Here, three Aspergillus dsRNA mycoviruses were partially characterized, and their relationship to RNA silencing was investigated. Aspergillus virus 1816 is related to Agaricus bisporus white button mushroom virus 1 and suppresses RNA silencing through a mechanism that alters the level of small interfering RNA. Aspergillus virus 178 is related to RNA virus L1 of Gremmeniella abietina and does not appear to affect RNA silencing. The third virus investigated, Aspergillus virus 341, is distantly related to Sphaeropsis sapinea RNA virus 2. Detection of mycovirus-derived siRNA from this mycovirus demonstrates that it is targeted for degradation by the Aspergillus RNA silencing machinery. Thus, our results indicate that Aspergillus mycoviruses are both targets and suppressors of RNA silencing. In addition, they suggest that the morphological and physiological changes associated with some mycoviruses could be a result of their antagonistic relationship with RNA silencing.     

Mycoviruses and virocontrol

Viruses are widespread in all major groups of fungi. The transmission of fungal viruses occurs intracellularly during cell division, sporogenesis, and cell fusion. They apparently lack an extracellular route for infection. Recent searches of the collections of field fungal isolates have detected an increasing number of novel viruses and lead to discoveries of novel genome organizations, expression strategies and virion structures. Those findings enhanced our understanding of virus diversity and evolution. The majority of fungal viruses have dsRNA genomes packaged in spherical particles, while ssRNA mycoviruses, possessing or lacking the ability to form particles, have increasingly been reported. This review article discusses the current status of mycovirus studies and virocontrol (biocontrol) of phytopathogenic fungi using viruses that infect them and reduce their virulence. Selected examples of virocontrol-associated systems include the chestnut/chestnut blight/hypovirus and fruit trees/white root rot fungus/mycoviruses. Natural dissemination and artificial introduction of hypovirulent fungal strains efficiently contributed to virocontrol of chestnut blight in European forests. Attempts to control white root rot with hypovirulence-conferring mycoviruses are now being made in Japan.