Lack of evidence on hybrid swarm in the sympatric population of Pinus mugo and P. sylvestris

Natural hybridisation between the taxa from Pinus mugo complex and P. sylvestris was postulated in several sympatric populations of the species in Europe. However, due to the absence of precise methods for identification of hybrid seeds and hybrid trees, the frequency of hybridisation and its influence on the genetic structure of relict P. mugo populations has not been clarified so far. In the present study, the species-specific chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) marker and isozymes were applied to test the hybridisation hypothesis in a postulated hybrid swarm population of the species from “Bór na Czerwonem” reserve at the northern foothills of Tatra Mts., Poland. The cpDNA marker was used to identify hybrids within two groups of polycormic (multi-stemmed) and monocormic (single-stemmed) pines from this population. Allelic frequencies at isozyme loci from both groups were compared to frequencies found in allopatric populations of the species. Additionally, cpDNA haplotypes of seedlings derived from open pollinated seeds were studied to detect the possibility of successful cross-pollination. The mixture of seedlings with P. sylvestris and P. mugo cpDNA haplotypes was derived from one parental tree that indicates hybridisation. However, all the mature polycormic pines had cpDNA haplotypes species specific to P. mugo and the isozyme frequencies were similar to frequencies found in three allopatric populations of P. mugo from Tatra Mts. (mean genetic distance, Dn=.027). The differences were much larger in comparisons with monocormic pines from this area (Dn=.085) and two P. sylvestris samples from distant allopatric populations (Dn=.077). Nearly all monocormic pines had cpDNA species specific to P. sylvestris and isozyme frequencies similar to other populations of this species (mean Dn=.004). Only one P. sylvestris-like monocormic tree had cpDNA of P. mugo and can be considered as a hybrid. The results do not provide evidence supporting the hybrid swarm hypothesis. Rather, the results suggest that mature hybrids have a low frequency within this population and (rare) hybridisation is not reciprocal but unidirectional with P. mugo as pollen donor.     

A critical evaluation of reproductive barriers between closely related species using DNA markers - a case study in Pinus

Former controlled crosses between twelve Pinus montana var. rostrata (Pinus mugo complex) and eight P. sylvestris clones revealed that only two P. sylvestris had efficiently fertilised P. montana. Two species-diagnostic chloroplast DNA markers were applied to verify the species purity of the parental clones. All maternal P. montana were unambiguously confirmed to belong to the P. mugo complex at both chloroplast DNA marker loci. Six P. sylvestris clones carried the `sylvestris' haplotypes. However, the same two P. sylvestris clones that had efficiently fertilised P. montana displayed the chloroplast haplotypes diagnostic to the P. mugo complex. The patterns of highly polymorphic cpDNA microsatellite markers in parents and offspring ruled out contamination by foreign pollen. We concluded that the two clones successful in the crosses represent fertile hybrids between the two species with P. mugo as the pollen donor. Consequently, DNA markers are proposed for verifying or falsifying the success of artificial fertilisation in general. The existence of crossing barriers between the two Pinus species, meaningful to the postulated natural hybridisation and the evolution of their populations in sympatric stands, was indicated and is newly discussed.     

Different patterns of genetic structure of relict and isolated populations of endangered peat-bog pine (Pinus uliginosa Neumann)

Recent changes in environmental conditions in populations of peat-bog pine (Pinus uliginosa Neumann) caused rapid decline or even extinction of the species in several stands in Central Europe. Conservation strategies forP. uliginosa require information about the evolutionary history and genetic structure of its populations. Using isozymes we assessed the genetic structure ofP. uliginosa from four isolated stands in Poland and compared the results to genetic structures of other closely related pine species including eight populations ofPinus mugo, ten ofPinus sylvestris and one ofPinus uncinata. The level of genetic variability ofP. uliginosa measured by the mean number of alleles per locus and average heterozygosity was similar to others related toP. uliginosa taxa from the reference group but it differs among populations. High genetic similarity was found between two populations ofP. uliginosa from Low Silesian Pinewood. The populations were genetically distinct as compared to other populations includinglocus classicus of the species from the peat bog at Batorów Reserve. Very low genetic distance (D_n = 0.002) and small genetic differentiation (GST = 0.003) were found betweenP. uliginosa andP. mugo in the sympatric populations of the species from Zieleniec peat bog suggesting the ongoing natural hybridisation and genetic contamination of peat-bog pine from this area. Some evidence for skew in allele frequency distribution potentially due to recent bottleneck was found in population from Low Silesian Pinewood. The analysed open pollinated progeny derived from twoP. uliginosa stands from Low Silesian Pine-wood showed the excess of homozygotes as compared to the maternal trees indicating high level of inbreeding (F = 0.105,F = 0.081). The results are discussed in the context of evolution ofP. uliginosa populations, taxonomic relationships between the analysed species and conservation strategies for active protection of peat-bog pine.     

Allozyme investigations on the genetic differentiation between closely related pines —Pinus sylvestris, P. mugo, P. uncinata, andP. uliginosa (Pinaceae)

In eight natural European populations of four closely related taxa of pines (Pinus sylvestris, P. mugo, P. uncinata, andP. uliginosa) starch-gel electrophoreses revealed altogether 58 alleles at 15 loci from nine enzyme systems. With Nei's genetic distance (D) the largest mean genetic distance (D = 0.171) was found betweenP. sylvestris andP. mugo, a distance corresponding to that between other closely related pine species. Mean genetic distances between the other taxa were less than half that value and characteristic for subspecies or varieties rather than for species. On the basis of our results we suggest that both,P. uliginosa andP. uncinata, could be the result of the ancient hybridization betweenP. sylvestris andP. mugo.     

DNA marker based identification of spontaneous hybrids between Pinus mugo and P. sylvestris at the Lithuanian sea‐side

The objective was to identify spontaneous hybrids between P. mugo and P. sylvestris using organelle DNA markers in sympatric zones at the sea‐side spit of Kursiu Nerija in western Lithuania. A field inventory was carried out over the entire Lithuanian part of the spit and 203 individuals morphologically intermediate between P. sylvestris and P. mugo were tested for their male parent with chloroplast DNA PCR‐RFLP markers and for their female parent with mitochondrial DNA PCR markers. Unfortunately, the mitochondrial DNA Nad7 marker failed to identify the female parent species in our study. However, the chloroplast DNA PCR‐RFLP marker revealed that out of 203 tested individuals only 23 had a paternity different than that indicated by morphology. Of these, 13 individuals were morphologically identified as P. sylvestris but possessed cpDNA of P. mugo (putative hybrids with P. sylvestris (female) ×P. mugo (male parent), and 10 individuals morphologically identified as P. mugo possessed cpDNA of P. sylvestris and may be hybrids with P. mugo (female) ×P. sylvestris (male parent). The remainder of the 177 individuals identified in the field inventory were were considered as pure species. In conclusion, our study indicates ongoing spontaneous hybridization between P. mugo and P. syvestris in Kursiu Nerija. Human impact via seed transfer on altered hybridization rates as well as evolutionary consequences are discussed.     

Contribution to the taxonomy of Pinus uncinata (Pinaceae) based on cone characters

Eight natural populations of Pinus uncinata Ramond from the Spanish Pyrenees, five of P. mugo Turra from the Carpathians, the Sudethians and Abruzzian Apennines, three of P. sylvestris L. from the Central-European Lowland and the Iberian Peninsula and one of P. uliginosa Neumann from SW Poland have been compared biometrically in 16 cone characters. P. uncinata appears the most distant from all other taxa, differing by having the largest and most asymmetric cones and the thickest apophyses with the most prominent umbo. In cone characters, P. mugo is more similar to P. sylvestris than to P. uncinata. Nevertheless, P. mugo and P. sylvestris remain distant from each other in a number of morphological characters examined. P. uliginosa has cones intermediate between the other three taxa and is moreover very variable. The locality of P. uliginosa in the Silesian Lowland may be of a relict character and conserve genes from P. uncinata.     

Abortive embryogenesis in hybrid swarm populations of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus sylvestris</Emphasis> L. and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus muga</Emphasis> Turra

Comparative study on fertilization process in Pinus sylvestris, Pinus mugo and in their putative hybrid swarm individuals was done involving pre-zygotic and post-zygotic stages. The amount of surviving ovules from open pollination reflecting the mode of interaction between pollen grains and nucellar tissue of an ovule averaged at 8.1 of sound ovules per conelet in Pinus sylvestris, 7.3 ovules in the hybrid swarm population and at 4.9 ovules in Pinus mugo. A strong correlation was observed between the number of surviving ovules and the proportion of germinating seeds in the compared species and hybrids. Normal course of embryogenesis in Pinus sylvestris and Pinus mugo contrasted with increased frequency of disturbances observed in the hybrid swarm individuals. The differential survival rates of the ovules and deviations from typical pattern of embryogenesis are discussed from the standpoint of cross-ability relationship between Pinus sylvestris and Pinus mugo.     

Speciation history of three closely related pines Pinus mugo (T.), P. uliginosa (N.) and P. sylvestris (L.)

Nucleotide polymorphisms at genomic regions including 17 nuclear loci, two chloroplast and one mitochondrial DNA fragments were used to study the speciation history of three pine species: dwarf mountain pine (Pinus mugo), peat‐bog pine (P. uliginosa) and Scots pine (P. sylvestris). We set out to investigate three specific speciation scenarios: (I) P. uliginosa is a homoploid hybrid between the other two, (II) the species have evolved without gene flow after divergence and (III) there has been substantial gene flow between the species since their divergence. Overall, the genetic data suggest that P. mugo and P. uliginosa share the same gene pool (average net divergence of 0.0001) and that the phenotypic differences (e.g. growth form) are most likely due to very limited areas of the genome. P. mugo and P. uliginosa are more diverged from P. sylvestris than from each other (average net divergence of 0.0027 and 0.0026, respectively). The nucleotide patterns can best be explained by the divergence with migration speciation scenario, although the hybrid speciation scenario with small genomic contribution from P. sylvestris cannot be completely ruled out. We suggest that the large amount of shared polymorphisms between the pine taxa and the lack of monophyly at all loci studied between P. sylvestris and P. mugo–P. uliginosa can largely be explained by relatively recent speciation history and large effective population sizes but also by interspecific gene flow. These closely related pine taxa form an excellent system for searching for loci involved in adaptive variation as they are differentiated in phenotype and ecology but have very similar genetic background.     

Cryptic hybrids between Pinus uncinata and P. sylvestris

We tested the performance of molecular markers and biometric traits in the identification of hybrids between closely related mountain pine (Pinus uncinata) and Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris). A plastid DNA marker and a set of morphological and anatomical needle traits were applied in analyses of individuals from several sympatric stands of the species and a single‐species' population from southern Europe, used as a reference. A polymerase chain reaction‐restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR‐RFLP) marker from the plastid trnL–trnF region and morphological and anatomical traits clearly discriminated between the pure species. Significant differences were found between P. uncinata and P. sylvestris, mostly in the shape of epidermal cells and the number of stomata. Four putative hybrids with P. sylvestris morphology, but with P. uncinata plastid DNA haplotypes, were found in a population from Sierra de Gúdar near Valdelinares, the southernmost locality of the latter species in eastern Spain. Discrimination analyses between and within populations placed these individuals on the edge of an agglomeration of P. sylvestris individuals. The results suggest that hybridization between the species is rare, but can result in cryptic hybrids morphologically similar to the maternal species. © 2010 The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society, 2010, 163 , 473–485.     

Species-specific RAPD fingerprints for the closely related Picea mariana and P. rubens

Species-specific molecular markers were designed to assist in the identification of closely related black spruce (Picea mariana [B.S.P.] Mill.) and red spruce (P. rubens Sarg.) in northeastern North America. Trees from six provenances of black spruce and three provenances of red spruce were sampled from outside the sympatric zone. They were first classified using a composite index of five qualitative morphological traits. The species-specific genetic markers were developed using random amplified polymorphic DNAs (RAPD) and a combination of bulk sample and individual tree analyses. Each species bulk sample was constructed from DNAs obtained from 12 trees that were from outside the sympatric zone and showed a morphological composite index specific of each species. A total of 161 primers were screened with the bulk samples. From these, 52 primers showing segregating fingerprints were further screened with the individual trees. Most of the markers observed were shared by the two species, and there was less diversity in P. rubens. A small number of markers were found to be monomorphic or nearly monomorphic and specific to either P. mariana or P. rubens. These markers remained species-specific when F₁ progenies derived from independent intraspecific crosses were screened, and they were subsequently found to co-segregate in hybrids derived from independent interspecific crosses here used as controls.     

Field-based artificial crossings indicate partial compatibility of reciprocal crosses between <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus sylvestris</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus mugo</Emphasis> and unexpected chloroplast DNA inheritance

Crossability relationships between Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) and mountain dwarf pine (Pinus mugo Turra) was studied, using artificial pollination approach. Partial compatibility of the reciprocal crossings of these species was proved experimentally, validating the idea of a spontaneous formation of their hybrid swarms under natural conditions. The hybrids were validated using organellar DNA markers and nuclear DNA microsatellites. Based on the percentage of filled seeds, the interspecific crossings were less efficient than the intraspecific cross-pollinations of P. sylvestris and P. mugo individuals. Both species were found to intercross readily with individuals of their putative hybrid swarm, P. mugo exhibiting a higher hybridological affinity towards putatively hybrid individuals than P. sylvestris. Validation of the hybrids confirmed the paternal inheritance of chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) in the combination P. sylvestris × P. mugo only. Surprisingly, in the reciprocal crossing P. mugo × P. sylvestris, maternal inheritance of cpDNA was revealed. Obtained results offer a new insight into the direction and intensity of gene flow within the hybrid swarms of Scots pine and mountain dwarf pine.     

RAPD variations among pure and hybrid populations ofPicea mariana, P. rubens, andP. glauca (Pinaceae), and cytogenetic stability ofPicea hybrids: Identification of species-specific RAPD markers

Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) analysis was used to determine genetic relationships amongP. mariana (black spruce),P. rubens (red spruce), andP. glauca (white spruce) and to assess the degree of polymorphism within populations from different provenances and among spruce hybrids. Eleven arbitrary decamer primers were used to amplify genomic DNAs extracted from embryogenic cultures and seedlings. Species-specific RAPD markers were identified.Picea mariana andP. rubens showed similar RAPD profiles confirming their close genetic relationship. Species-specific RAPD markers were identified and were useful in distinguishing white spruce from black and red spruces. RAPD differentiation between populations within each species was small. The level of polymorphism was much higher in spruce hybrid populations than in the pure species. Cytological analysis ofP. mariana ×P. rubens hybrids showed normal mitotic behaviour at prophase, metaphase, anaphase, and telophase. All the hybrids analyzed from different cross combinations were euploids.     

Maternal inheritance of chloroplast DNA in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus mugo</Emphasis> Turra: a case study of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus mugo</Emphasis> × <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus sylvestris</Emphasis> crossing

The opposite modes of chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) inheritance were found to operate in the reciprocal crossings of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) and mountain dwarf pine (Pinus mugo Turra). The crossings were found to be partially compatible. In P. sylvestris × P. mugo crossing, the paternal transmission of cpDNA to the offspring takes place corroborating the generally acknowledged concept of the paternal cpDNA inheritance in gymnosperms. On the contrary, in P. mugo × P. sylvestris crossing the seed progeny exhibited P. mugo haplotype of the mother tree deviating conspicuously from the above concept. In the open pollination offspring of the putatively hybrid individuals of the Scots and mountain dwarf pines, a biparental inheritance of cpDNA was revealed in mother tree with P. mugo haplotype indicating a loosened control of the maternal inheritance of cpDNA in the putative hybrids. Implications and impacts of this finding for further studies are discussed.     

Intra- and interspecific genetic differentiation in closely related pines fromPinus subsectionSylvestres (Pinaceae) in the former Soviet Union

Thirty-seven natural populations of four closely related species ofPinus subsect.Sylvestres, P. mugo, P. funebris, P. pallasiana, andP. sylvestris, occurring in the former Soviet Union were investigated by starch-gel electrophoresis. In the populations assayed 127 allelic variants at 25 loci were revealed.Nei's distance coefficient (Dn) was used to estimate the level of genetic differentiation amongP. sylvestris races and among closely related species. A dendrogram constructed using Dn values shows that of the fiveP. sylvestris races analyzed only the geographically isolated var.hamata exhibited sufficient differences at theDia-2 locus (a mean Dn value relative to the other four races is 0.025) to recognize it as a distinct taxon. The remaining races, sylvestris, cretacea, lapponica, and sibirica, have a similar gene pool (Dn values are not greater than 0.010), and they should be regarded as a single taxon,P. sylvestris var.sylvestris. Interspecific comparisons revealed thatP. sylvestris andP. mugo have the closest genetic affinities to each other withNei's genetic distance of 0.108. The dendrogram demonstrates thatP. funebris is closer toP. sylvestris andP. mugo thanP. pallasiana. The available paleontologic data allowed us to conclude thatNei's (1975) time scale estimate for the time of divergence of the taxa was more accurate thanNei's (1971) time scale estimate.     

Comparing EST-based genetic maps between <Emphasis Type="BoldItalic">Pinus sylvestris</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="BoldItalic">Pinus taeda</Emphasis>

A genetic map of Pinus sylvestris was constructed using ESTP (expressed sequence tag polymorphism) markers and other gene-based markers, AFLP markers and microsatellites. Part of the ESTP markers (40) were developed and mapped earlier in Pinus taeda, and additional markers were generated based on P. sylvestris sequences or sequences from other pine species. The mapping in P. sylvestris was based on 94 F₁ progeny from a cross between plus-tree parents E635C and E1101. AFLP framework maps for the parent trees were first constructed. The ESTP and other gene sequence-based markers were added to the framework maps, as well as five published microsatellite loci. The separate maps were then integrated with the aid of AFLPs segregating in both trees (dominant segregation ratios 3:1) as well as gene markers and microsatellites segregating in both parent trees (segregation ratios 1:1:1:1 or 1:2:1). The integrated map consisted of 12 groups corresponding to the P. taeda linkage groups, and additionally three and six smaller groups for E1101 and E635C, respectively. The number of framework AFLP markers in the integrated map is altogether 194 and the number of gene markers 61. The total length of the integrated map was 1,314 cM. The set of markers developed for P. sylvestris was also added to existing maps of two P. taeda pedigrees. Starting with a mapped marker from one pedigree in the source species resulted in a mapped marker in a pedigree of the other species in more than 40% of the cases, with about equal success in both directions. The maps of the two species are largely colinear, even if the species have diverged more than 70 MYA. Most cases of different locations were probably due to problems in identifying the orthologous members of gene families. These data provide a first ESTP-containing map of P. sylvestris, which can also be used for comparing this species to additional species mapped with the same markers.Communicated by C. Möllers     

Analyses of Phaseolus vulgaris L. and P. coccineus Lam. hybrids by RFLP: preferential transmission of P. vulgaris alleles

Summary Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) was determined among P. vulgaris genotypes and Phaseolus species using 19 probes. The incidence of polymorphism was high (70–86%) between species, but relatively low (22–26%) between genotypes of P. vulgaris. Suitable probes were identified for the analysis of P. vulgaris and P. coccineus hybrids. The segregation pattern in F₂ populations was Mendelian for two probes (LHB and VEE20) and non-Mendelian for GS-g, CHS, and CHI. Statistical analyses indicated gametic selection with preferential transmission of the P. vulgaris alleles, which may account for the selective recovery of P. vulgaris progeny types observed earlier. The available hybrids of P. vulgaris and P. coccineus and the high degree of interspecific RFLP will facilitate the construction of a linkage map for Phaseolus.     

Reconstructing the plant mitochondrial genome for marker discovery: a case study using Pinus

Whole‐genome‐shotgun (WGS) sequencing of total genomic DNA was used to recover ~1 Mbp of novel mitochondrial (mtDNA) sequence from Pinus sylvestris (L.) and three members of the closely related Pinus mugo species complex. DNA was extracted from megagametophyte tissue from six mother trees from locations across Europe, and 100‐bp paired‐end sequencing was performed on the Illumina HiSeq platform. Candidate mtDNA sequences were identified by their size and coverage characteristics, and by comparison with published plant mitochondrial genomes. Novel variants were identified, and primers targeting these loci were trialled on a set of 28 individuals from across Europe. In total, 31 SNP loci were successfully resequenced, characterizing 15 unique haplotypes. This approach offers a cost‐effective means of developing marker resources for mitochondrial genomes in other plant species where reference sequences are unavailable.     

Volatiles as Chemosystematic Markers for Distinguishing Closely Related Species within the Pinus mugo Complex

Headspace solid‐phase microextraction (HS‐SPME) coupled to GC/MS analysis was used to identify the constituents of pine‐needle volatiles differentiating three closely‐related pine species within the Pinus mugo complex, i.e., P. uncinata Ramond ex DC., P. uliginosa G.E.Neumann ex Wimm ., and P. mugo Turra . Moreover, chemosystematic markers were proposed for the three analyzed pine species. The major constituents of the pine‐needle volatiles were α‐pinene (28.4%) and bornyl acetate (10.8%) for P. uncinata, δ‐car‐3‐ene (21.5%) and α‐pinene (16.1%) for P. uliginosa, and α‐pinene (20%) and δ‐car‐3‐ene (18.1%) for P. mugo. This study is the first report on the application of the composition of pine‐needle volatiles for the reliable identification of closely‐related pine species within the Pinus mugo complex.     

Effect of tree age on needle morphology and anatomy of Pinus uliginosa and Pinus silvestris – species-specific character separation during ontogenesis

Differences in morphological and anatomical characters of needles between seedlings, saplings and adult trees of the endangered Pinus uliginosa from the Węgliniec Nature Reserve in SW Poland were examined biometrically and statistically assessed using the Student's t-test, Tukey–Kramer test, step-wise discrimination and agglomeration on Euclidean distances according to Ward's method. Pinus sylvestris adults and seedlings were used as comparative material. The results show that needles of all three P. uliginosa generations differ significantly from each other. In seedling needles, several anatomical characters were similar to those of P. sylvestris growing in the vicinity of the reserve. However, P. uliginosa had a lower number of resin canals, lower frequency of fibre-like sclerenchyma cells and higher frequency of thin-walled sclerenchyma cells with large lumens in the spaces between vascular bundles. Needle characters of saplings and adult trees of both species were distinctly more different than it was the case in the seedling stage.     

The fate of recombinant chromosomes and genome interaction in Nicotiana asymmetric somatic hybrids and their sexual progeny

Genomic in-situ hybridization (GISH) was used to monitor the behaviour of parental genomes, and the fate of intergenomic chromosome translocations, through meiosis of plants regenerated from asymmetric somatic hybrids between Nicotiana sylvestris and N. plumbaginifolia. Meiotic pairing in the regenerants was exclusively between chromosomes or chromosome segments derived from the same species. Translocation (recombinant) chromosomes contained chromosome segments from both parental species, and were detected at all stages of meiosis. They occasionally paired with respectively homologous segments of N. sylvestris or N. plumbaginifolia chromosomes. Within hybrid nuclei, the meiotic division of N. plumbaginifolia lagged behind that of N. sylvestris. However, normal and recombinant chromosomes were eventually incorporated into dyads and tetrads, and the regenerants were partially pollen fertile. Recombinant chromosomes were transmitted through either male or female gametes, and were detected by GISH in sexual progeny obtained on selfing or backcrossing the regenerants to N. sylvestris. A new recombinant chromosome in one plant of the first backcross generation provided evidence of further chromosome rearrangements occurring at, or following, meiosis in the original regenerants. This study demonstrates the stable incorporation of chromosome segments from one parental genome of an asymmetric somatic hybrid into another, via intergenomic translocation, and reveals their transmission to subsequent sexual progeny.