The Fas/Fas ligand pathway is important for optimal tumor regression in a mouse model of CTL adoptive immunotherapy of experimental CMS4 lung metastases

The mechanisms of CTL-mediated tumor regression in vivo remain to be fully understood. If CTL do mediate tumor regression in vivo by direct cytotoxicity, this may occur via two major effector mechanisms involving the secretion of perforin/granzymes and/or engagement of Fas by Fas ligand (FasL) expressed by the activated CTL. Although the perforin pathway has been considered the dominant player, it is unclear whether Fas-mediated cytotoxicity is additionally required for optimal tumor rejection. Previously, we produced H-2L(d)-restricted CTL reactive against the CMS4 sarcoma, which expresses a naturally occurring rejection Ag recognized by these CTL and harbors a cytokine (IFN-gamma plus TNF)-inducible, Fas-responsive phenotype. The adoptive transfer of these CTL to syngeneic BALB/c mice with minimal (day 3 established) or extensive (day 10 established) experimental pulmonary metastases resulted in strong antitumor responses. Here we investigated whether a FasL-dependent CTL effector mechanism was important for optimal tumor regression in this adoptive immunotherapy model. The approach taken was to compare the therapeutic efficacy of wild-type to FasL-deficient (gld) CTL clones by adoptive transfer. In comparison with wild-type CTL, gld-CTL efficiently mediated tumor cytolysis and produced comparable amounts of IFN-gamma, after tumor-specific stimulation, as in vitro assessments of Ag recognition. Moreover, gld-CTL mediated comparably potent antitumor effects in a minimal disease setting, but were significantly less effective under conditions of an extensive tumor burden. Overall, under conditions of extensive lung metastases, these data revealed for the first time an important role for a FasL-dependent CTL effector mechanism in optimal tumor regression.     

Irradiation of tumor cells up-regulates Fas and enhances CTL lytic activity and CTL adoptive immunotherapy

CD8(+) CTL play important roles against malignancy in both active and passive immunotherapy. Nonetheless, the success of antitumor CTL responses may be improved by additional therapeutic modalities. Radiotherapy, which has a long-standing use in treating neoplastic disease, has been found to induce unique biologic alterations in cancer cells affecting Fas gene expression, which, consequently, may influence the overall lytic efficiency of CTL. Here, in a mouse adenocarcinoma cell model, we examined whether exposure of these tumor cells to sublethal doses of irradiation 1) enhances Fas expression, leading to more efficient CTL killing via Fas-dependent mechanisms in vitro; and 2) improves antitumor activity in vivo by adoptive transfer of these Ag-specific CTL. Treatment of carcinoembryonic Ag-expressing MC38 adenocarcinoma cells with irradiation (20 Gy) in vitro enhanced Fas expression at molecular, phenotypic, and functional levels. Furthermore, irradiation sensitized these targets to Ag-specific CTL killing via the Fas/Fas ligand pathway. We examined the effect of localized irradiation of s.c. growing tumors on the efficiency of CTL adoptive immunotherapy. Irradiation caused up-regulation of Fas by these tumor cells in situ, based on immunohistochemistry. Moreover, localized irradiation of the tumor significantly potentiated tumor rejection by these carcinoembryonic Ag-specific CTL. Overall, these results showed for the first time that 1) regulation of the Fas pathway in tumor cells by irradiation plays an important role in their sensitization to Ag-specific CTL; and 2) a combination regimen of tumor-targeted irradiation and CTL promotes more effective antitumor responses in vivo, which may have implications for the combination of immunotherapy and radiation therapy.     

Regression of extensive pulmonary metastases in mice by adoptive transfer of antigen-specific CD8(+) CTL reactive against tumor cells expressing a naturally occurring rejection epitope

In this study, we developed a mouse model of adoptive immunotherapy reflecting immune recognition of syngeneic tumor cells naturally expressing an endogenous rejection Ag. Specifically, in a pulmonary metastases model, we examined the potency and maintenance of an antitumor CD8(+) CTL response in vivo, as well as its effectiveness against an "extensive" tumor burden. The approach taken was to first generate tumor-specific CTL from mice challenged with the CMS4 sarcoma coadministered with anti-CTLA4 mAb, which has been shown to facilitate the induction of Ag-specific T cell responses in vivo. An H-2L(d)-restricted nonamer peptide, derived from an endogenous murine leukemia provirus was identified as a CMS4-reactive CTL epitope based upon the following: CTL cross-recognition of another syngeneic tumor cell line (CT26 colon carcinoma) previously characterized to express that gene product; sensitization of Ag-negative lymphoblasts or P815 targets with the peptide; and by cold target inhibition assays. In vivo, the adoptive transfer of CMS4-reactive CTL (> or =1 x 10(6)) resulted in nearly the complete regression of 3-day established lung metastases. Furthermore, mice that rejected CMS4 following a single adoptive transfer of CTL displayed antitumor activity to a rechallenge 45 days later, not only in the lung, but also at a s.c. distal site. Lastly, the adoptive transfer of CTL to mice harboring extensive pulmonary metastases (> 150 nodules) led to a substantial reduction in tumor burden. Overall, these data suggest that the adoptive transfer of tumor-specific CTL may have therapeutic potential for malignancies that proliferate in or metastasize to the lung.     

Decitabine and vorinostat cooperate to sensitize colon carcinoma cells to Fas ligand-induced apoptosis in vitro and tumor suppression in vivo

The death receptor Fas and its physiological ligand (FasL) regulate apoptosis of cancerous cells, thereby functioning as a critical component of the host cancer immunosurveillance system. To evade Fas-mediated apoptosis, cancer cells often downregulate Fas to acquire an apoptosis-resistant phenotype, which is a hallmark of metastatic human colorectal cancer. Therefore, targeting Fas resistance is of critical importance in Fas-based cancer therapy and immunotherapy. In this study, we demonstrated that epigenetic inhibitors decitabine and vorinostat cooperate to upregulate Fas expression in metastatic human colon carcinoma cells. Decitabine also upregulates BNIP3 and Bik expression, whereas vorinostat decreased Bcl-x(L) expression. Altered expression of Fas, BNIP3, Bik, and Bcl-x(L) resulted in effective sensitization of the metastatic human colon carcinoma cells to FasL-induced apoptosis. Using an experimental metastasis mouse model, we further demonstrated that decitabine and vorinostat cooperate to suppress colon carcinoma metastasis. Analysis of tumor-bearing lung tissues revealed that a large portion of tumor-infiltrating CD8(+) T cells are FasL(+), and decitabine and vorinostat-mediated tumor-suppression efficacy was significantly decreased in Fas(gld) mice compared with wild-type mice, suggesting a critical role for FasL in decitabine and vorinostat-mediated tumor suppression in vivo. Consistent with their function in apoptosis sensitization, decitabine and vorinostat significantly increased the efficacy of CTL adoptive transfer immunotherapy in an experimental metastasis mouse model. Thus, our data suggest that combined modalities of chemotherapy to sensitize the tumor cell to Fas-mediated apoptosis and CTL immunotherapy is an effective approach for the suppression of colon cancer metastasis.     

Immunotherapy of melanoma: a dichotomy in the requirement for IFN-gamma in vaccine-induced antitumor immunity versus adoptive immunotherapy

The mechanism by which tumors are rejected following the adoptive transfer of tumor-specific T cells is not well characterized. Recent work has challenged the requirement for cytotoxicity mediated by either the perforin/granzyme or Fas/Fas ligand pathway in T cell-mediated tumor regression. Many reports, including ours, suggest that tumor-specific production of IFN-gamma is critical for T cell-mediated tumor regression. However, in most of these studies the evidence to support the role for IFN-gamma is only indirect. We have directly examined the requirement for IFN-gamma using IFN-gamma knockout (GKO) mice. The results show an interesting dichotomy in the requirement for IFN-gamma: Antitumor immunity induced by active-specific immunotherapy (vaccination) required IFN-gamma, whereas adoptive immunotherapy did not. In GKO mice vaccination with the GM-CSF gene-modified B16BL6-D5 tumor (D5-G6) failed to induce protective immunity against parental D5 tumor. However, adoptive transfer of effector T cells from GKO mice cured 100% of GKO mice with established pulmonary metastases and induced long term antitumor immunity and depigmentation of skin. Furthermore, in vivo neutralization of IFN-gamma by mAb treatment or adoptive transfer into IFN-gamma receptor knockout mice failed to block the therapeutic efficacy of effector T cells generated from wild-type or perforin knockout mice. Analysis of regressing metastases revealed similar infiltrates of macrophages and granulocytes in both wild-type and GKO mice. These results indicate that in this adoptive immunotherapy model, neither a direct effect on the tumor nor an indirect effect of IFN-gamma through activation of myeloid or lymphoid cells is critical for therapeutic efficacy.     

Tim-3+ T-bet+ tumor-specific Th1 cells colocalize with and inhibit development and growth of murine neoplasms

Although T cells infiltrate many types of murine and human neoplasms, in many instances tumor-specific cytotoxicity is not observed. Strategies to stimulate CTL-mediated antitumor immunity have included in vitro stimulation and/or genetic engineering of T cells, followed by adoptive transfer into tumor-bearing hosts. In this model of B cell lymphoma in SJL/J mice, we used Tim-3(+) T-bet(+) Th1 cells to facilitate the development of tumor-specific CTL. Tumor-specific Th1 cell lines were polarized with IL-12 during in vitro stimulation and long term maintenance. As few as 5 million Tim-3(+) T-bet(+) Th1 cells enabled recipients to resist growth of malignant transplantable cells. In addition, similar numbers of Th1 cells injected into 2- to 3-mo-old mice inhibited development of the spontaneous primary lymphomas, which normally arise in 90% of aging mice. CFSE(+) Th1 cells colocalized with injected tumor cells in vivo and formed conjugates with the tumor cells within follicles, whereas in nontumor-challenged recipients the CFSE(+) Th1 cells localized only within the T cell zones of the spleen. These results provide evidence that adoptive immunotherapy with Tim-3(+) T-bet(+) tumor-specific Th1 cells can be used to induce host cytotoxic responses that inhibit the development and growth of neoplastic cells.     

Efficient chromosomal mapping of a methylcholanthrene-induced tumor antigen by CTL immunoselection.

It has been difficult to genetically map the genes encoding tumor Ags because they arise as a consequence of somatic mutational events. CTL-mediated immunoselection can impose potent immunoselective pressure against tumor cells, resulting in the survival of rare tumor Ag-loss variants. We subjected a heterozygous 3-methylcholanthrene-induced murine sarcoma cell line to CTL immunoselection, selecting for the loss of a tumor-specific Ag, recognized antigen from MCA-induced tumor 1 (Ram1). Several variants eluded CTL recognition by genetic loss of the hemizygously expressed tumor-specific Ag epitope. A frequently observed genetic escape mechanism was spontaneous mitotic recombination resulting in loss of heterozygosity on chromosome 4. Higher density genetic analyses along with functional confirmation with an independently produced chromosome 4 loss of heterozygosity variant positioned the Ram1 locus to a distal 7.1 cM interval on chromosome 4. This region of the mouse genome is rich in tumor-modifier genes and this positioning of Ram1 may thus provide insight into the genetic basis of 3-methycholanthrene-induced tumor Ags.     

TLR1/TLR2 agonist induces tumor regression by reciprocal modulation of effector and regulatory T cells

Using TLR agonists in cancer treatment can have either beneficial or detrimental effects. Therefore, it is important to determine their effect on the tumor growth and understand the underlying mechanisms in animal tumor models. In this study, we report a general immunotherapeutic activity of a synthetic bacterial lipoprotein (BLP), a TLR1/TLR2 agonist, on established lung carcinoma, leukemia, and melanoma in mice. Systemic treatment of 3LL tumor-bearing mice with BLP, but not LPS, led to a dose-dependent tumor regression and a long-lasting protective response against tumor rechallenge. The BLP-mediated tumor remission was neither mediated by a direct tumoricidal activity nor by innate immune cells, because it lacked therapeutic effect in immunodeficient SCID mice. Instead, BLP treatment reduced the suppressive function of Foxp3(+) regulatory T cells (Tregs) and enhanced the cytotoxicity of tumor-specific CTL in vitro and in vivo. Furthermore, adoptive cotransfer of BLP-pretreated but not untreated CTL and Tregs from wild-type but not from TLR2(-/-) mice was sufficient to restore antitumor immunity in SCID mice by reciprocally modulating Treg and CTL function. These results demonstrate that the TLR1/TLR2 agonist BLP may have a general tumor therapeutic property involving reciprocal downregulation of Treg and upregulation of CTL function. This property may play an important role in the development of novel antitumor strategies.     

Perforin and Fas cytolytic pathways coordinately shape the selection and diversity of CD8+-T-cell escape variants of influenza virus

Antigenic variation is a viral strategy exploited to promote survival in the face of the host immune response and represents a major challenge for efficient vaccine development. Influenza viruses are pathogens with high transmissibility and mutation rates, enabling viral escape from immunity induced by prior infection or vaccination. Intense selection from neutralizing antibody drives antigenic changes in the surface glycoproteins, resulting in emergence of new strains able to reinfect hosts immune to previously circulating viruses. CD8+ cytotoxic T cells (CTLs) also provide protective immunity from influenza virus infection and may contribute to the antigenic evolution of influenza viruses. Utilizing mice transgenic for an influenza virus NP366-374 peptide-specific T-cell receptor, we demonstrated that the respiratory tract is a suitable site for generation of escape variants of influenza virus selected by CTL in vivo. In this report the contributions of the perforin and Fas pathways utilized by influenza virus-specific CTLs in viral clearance and selection of CTL escape variants have been evaluated. While transgenic CTLs deficient in either perforin- or Fas-mediated pathways are efficient in initial pulmonary viral control, variant virus emergence was observed in all the mice studied, although the spectrum of viral CTL escape variants selected varied profoundly. Thus, a less-restricted repertoire of escape variants was observed in mice with an intact perforin cytotoxic pathway compared with a limited variant diversity in perforin pathway-deficient mice, although maximal variant diversity was observed in mice having both Fas and perforin pathways intact. We conclude that selection of viral CTL escape variants reflects coordinate action between the tightly controlled perforin/granzyme pathway and the more promiscuous Fas/FasL pathway.     

Differential effects of BCNU on T cell,macrophage, natural killer and lymphokine-activated killer cell activities in mice bearing a syngeneic tumor

Summary Chloroethylnitrosoureas have been used widely to treat human and experimental animal tumors. We have earlier observed that >90% of the mice transplanted with syngeneic tumors survive following treatment with nitrosoureas such as 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1-nitrosourea (BCNU) and furthermore, they resist subsequent challenge with the same tumor. The present investigation was initiated to determine the mechanism by which BCNU brings about this effect. Treatment of tumor cell targets in vivo or in vitro with BCNU, increased their susceptibility to macrophage (MØ)-mediated cytotoxicity as measured in a direct cytotoxicity assay or in an antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) assay. In contrast, the antitumor cytotoxicity caused by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), natural killer (NK) cells, or lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells, was not altered following BCNU treatment of tumor targets. Studies were also conducted to investigate the direct effect of BCNU in vivo on various cytotoxic effector cells. For this purpose, MØ, NK, LAK, and CTL activities from BCNU-treated-tumor-bearing mice were screened for cytotoxicity against untreated tumor targets in vitro. It was observed that tumor-specific CTL and LAK cell activity increased in BCNU-treated tumor-bearing mice when compared to untreated controls while the cytotoxic potential of NK cells and MØs was not altered. The present study suggests that antitumor drugs such as BCNU are not only tumoricidal but also selectively act in a variety of ways at both the effector and target cell level, leading to overall enhanced antitumor immunity and high rate of cures from the syngeneic tumor challenge.The work at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University was supported by NIH grants CA45009 and CA45010 and by a Biomedical Research Support Grant. The work at University of Kentucky was supported by NIH grants CA34052 and CA33629 and by a grant from the Tobacco and Health Institute     

Characterization of CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte/tumor cell interactions reflecting recognition of an endogenously expressed murine wild-type p53 determinant

p53 mutations are frequently found in human cancers and are often associated with the overexpression of wild-type (WT) protein or peptide sequences, supporting the notion that WT p53 epitopes may serve as potential targets for tumor immunotherapy. We have developed a cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL)/p53 tumor-associated antigen (TAA) model, based on immune recognition of a WT p53 determinant. WT p53-peptide-specific, major histocompatibility complex (MHC) classI-restricted CTL were produced from immunocompetent C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice after immunization with a previously defined WT p53 peptide (p53(232-240)) Epitope-specific CTL were then employed to identify syngeneic tumor cell populations expressing that antigenic determinant. Two syngeneic tumor cell lines, MC38 colon carcinoma and MC57G fibrosarcoma, were demonstrated to express the endogenous WT p53(232-240) determinant naturally, as defined by CD8 + CTL recognition. Cold-target inhibition assays confirmed that CTL-mediated lysis was due to immune recognition of the p53(232-240) peptide epitope. The p53(232-240)-specific CTL line did not lyse syngeneic normal cells (i.e., mitogen-activated splenocytes) in the absence of exogenous peptide, suggesting that the WT-p53-specific CTL could distinguish between tumor cells expressing self-TAA and normal host cells. We have demonstrated, for the first time, that the adoptive transfer of WT-p53-specific CTL to mice with established pulmonary metastasis resulted in antitumor activity in vivo. The ability to generate MHC-class-I-restricted CD8- CTL lines specific for a non-mutated p53 determinant from normal, immunocompetent mice, which display antitumor activity both in vitro and in vivo (by adoptive transfer), may have implications for the immunotherapy of certain p53-expressing malignancies.     

Generation of human autologous melanoma-specific cytotoxic T cells from tumor-involved lymph nodes

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) specific for autologous human melanoma have been successfully generated in vitro from tumor bearing lymph nodes without any stimulation by the autologous tumor. Tumor-involved lymph node cells (LNC) were cultured in serum free medium (AIM-V) containing 1,000 U/ml of recombinant interleukin-2. The best expansion and specific cytotoxicity of CTL were achieved in 4 to 6 weeks of culture. The predominant populations in cultured LNC-derived CTL were CD2+, CD3+, CD4-, CD8+, CD56-, and HLA-DR+ T cells. These data suggested that tumor-involved LNC may provide an alternative source for the generation of tumor-specific CTL in adoptive immunotherapy.     

In vivo functional efficacy of tumor-specific T cells expanded using HLA-Ig based artificial antigen presenting cells (aAPC)

Adoptive immunotherapy for treatment of cancers and infectious diseases is often hampered by a high degree of variability in the final T cell product and in the limited in vivo function and survival of ex vivo expanded antigen-specific cytotoxic T cells (CTL). This has stimulated interest in development of standardized artificial antigen presenting cells (aAPC) to reliably expand antigen specific CTL. However, for successful immunotherapy the aAPC ex vivo generated CTL must have anti-tumor activity in vivo. Here, we demonstrate that HLA-Ig based aAPC stimulated tumor-specific CTL from human peripheral blood T lymphocytes showed robust expansion and functional activity in a human/SCID mouse melanoma model. HLA-Ig based aAPC expanded CTL were detected in the peripheral blood up to 15 days after transfer. Non-invasive bioluminescence imaging of tumor bearing mice demonstrated antigen dependent localization of transferred CTL to the tumor site. Moreover, adoptive transfer of HLA-Ig based aAPC generated CTL inhibited the tumor growth both in prevention and treatment modes of therapy and was comparable to that achieved by dendritic cell expanded CTL. Thus, our data demonstrate potential therapeutic in vivo activity of HLA-Ig based aAPC expanded CTL to control tumor growth.     

Rescue of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes from activation-induced cell death enhances the antitumor CTL response in CD5-deficient mice

The CD5 coreceptor is expressed on all T cells and on the B1a B cell subset. It is associated with TCR and BCR, and modulates intracellular signals initiated by both Ag receptor complexes. Human CD5 contributes to regulation of the antitumor immune response and susceptibility of specific CTL to activation-induced cell death (AICD) triggered by the tumor. In this study, we compared the T cell response to the B16F10 melanoma engrafted into CD5-deficient and wild-type C57BL/6 mice. Compared with wild-type mice, CD5 knockout animals displayed delayed tumor growth, associated with tumor infiltration by T cell populations exhibiting a more activated phenotype and enhanced antitumor effector functions. However, control of tumor progression in CD5(-/-) mice was transient due to increased AICD of CD8(+) tumor-infiltrating T lymphocytes. Remarkably, in vivo protection of T cells from TCR-mediated apoptosis by an adenovirus engineered to produce soluble Fas resulted in a dramatic reduction in tumor growth. Our data suggest that recruitment of tumor-specific T cells in the tumor microenvironment occurs at early stages of cancer development and that tumor-mediated AICD of tumor-infiltrating T lymphocytes is most likely involved in tumor escape from the immune system.     

Effector phenotype and immunologic specificity of T-cell-mediated adoptive therapy for a murine tumor that lacks intrinsic immunogenicity

The MCA 102 sarcoma has been defined by a variety of immunologic studies as a tumor lacking intrinsic immunogenicity. Nevertheless, we have recently demonstrated the feasibility of generating therapeutically effective lymphocytes for adoptive immunotherapy of this tumor. Procedures to achieve this required in vivo priming of syngeneic mice to elicit preeffector cells followed by in vitro sensitization (IVS) with tumor cells in the presence of IL-2. By selective depletion of T cell subsets in vivo, we identified the involvement of both CD4+ (L3T4+) and CD8+ (Lyt-2+) T cells in mediating tumor regression. The CD4+ cells exerted their helper function via the secretion of IL-2 because antitumor effects abrogated by depletion of CD4+ cells could be reconstituted by exogenous IL-2. In order to elicit preeffector cells with reactivity against the MCA 102 tumor, we found that in vivo sensitization could be accomplished with either the MCA 102 or MCA 106 tumor but not with the MCA 101 or MCA 105 tumor. Analysis of specificity of tumor stimulation during IVS of MCA 102 tumor-primed preeffector cells demonstrated cross-reactivity between not only the MCA 102 and MCA 106 tumors but also the MCA 105 tumor whereas the MCA 101 tumor was ineffective. In adoptive immunotherapy, transfer of IVS cells generated from MCA 102 tumor-primed and stimulated lymph node cells was able to mediate reductions of pulmonary metastases established from the MCA 102, MCA 105, and MCA 106 tumors but not from the MCA 101 tumor. We conclude that regression of the MCA 102 tumor is probably mediated through T cell recognition of a set of common tumor-associated Ag shared by several other syngeneic tumors. Immunologically, the tumor-associated Ag are characteristically different from classical tumor-specific transplantation Ag (TSTA) because immunity to TSTA on the MCA 105 or MCA 106 tumor does not cross-react with the MCA 102 tumor. Thus, this study demonstrates that Ag other than TSTA on chemically induced tumors can serve as target molecules for T cell-mediated adoptive immunotherapy.     

Activation of dendritic cells that cross-present tumor-derived antigen licenses CD8+ CTL to cause tumor eradication

The fate of naive CD8(+) T cells is determined by the environment in which they encounter MHC class I presented peptide Ags. The manner in which tumor Ags are presented is a longstanding matter of debate. Ag presentation might be mediated by tumor cells in tumor draining lymph nodes or via cross-presentation by professional APC. Either pathway is insufficient to elicit protective antitumor immunity. We now demonstrate using a syngeneic mouse tumor model, expressing an Ag derived from the early region 1A of human adenovirus type 5, that the inadequate nature of the antitumor CTL response is not due to direct Ag presentation by the tumor cells, but results from presentation of tumor-derived Ag by nonactivated CD11c(+) APC. Although this event results in division of naive CTL in tumor draining lymph nodes, it does not establish a productive immune response. Treatment of tumor-bearing mice with dendritic cell-stimulating agonistic anti-CD40 mAb resulted in systemic efflux of CTL with robust effector function capable to eradicate established tumors. For efficacy of anti-CD40 treatment, CD40 ligation of host APC is required because adoptive transfer of CD40-proficient tumor-specific TCR transgenic CTL into CD40-deficient tumor-bearing mice did not lead to productive antitumor immunity after CD40 triggering in vivo. CpG and detoxified LPS (MPL) acted similarly as agonistic anti-CD40 mAb with respect to CD8(+) CTL efflux and tumor eradication. Together these results indicate that dendritic cells, depending on their activation state, orchestrate the outcome of CTL-mediated immunity against tumors, leading either to an ineffective immune response or potent antitumor immunity.     

Expression of a tolerizing tumor antigen in peripheral tissue does not preclude recovery of high-affinity CD8+ T cells or CTL immunotherapy of tumors expressing the antigen

Transgenic (TG) mice were generated selectively expressing the gag protein of Friend murine leukemia virus (FMuLV) in the liver. FMuLV(gag) is also expressed by the FBL leukemia, and is the immunodominant tumor Ag of the CD8(+) T cell response in C57BL/6 mice. gag-TG mice expressing FMuLV(gag) in the liver were tolerant to the protein and failed to generate a CTL response to either FBL or FMuLV(gag). This tolerance reflected anergy rather than deletion, as CTL responsiveness could be recovered after four cycles of in vitro stimulation. Adoptively transferred gag-specific T cells were not anergized in gag-TG recipients, as revealed by antitumor activity in vivo. Also, such T cells did not induce detectable autoimmune injury in gag-TG liver cells. These results suggest that the requirements for a tissue Ag to provide a tolerizing stimulus are distinct from those for being the target of a T cell-mediated autoimmune response and that the requirements for induction and maintenance of peripheral tolerance are distinct for naive and primed T cells. That anergic T cells reactive with tumor-associated Ags can be recovered by repetitive in vitro stimulation and can mediate tumor therapy suggests strategies that use such Ags to generate CTL for adoptive immunotherapy should be further developed.     

IL-2 during in vitro priming promotes subsequent engraftment and successful adoptive tumor immunotherapy by persistent memory phenotypic CD8(+) T cells

Adoptive T cell tumor immunotherapy potentially consists of two protective components by the transferred effector cells, the immediate immune response and the subsequent development of memory T cells. The extent by which adoptively transferred CD8(+) CTL are destined to become memory T cells is ambiguous as most studies focus on the acute effects on tumor shortly following adoptive transfer. In this study we show that a substantial fraction of the input CTL develop into memory cells that reject a s.c. tumor challenge. The use of exogenous IL-2 or a combination of IL-2 and IL-4, but not solely IL-4, during the ex vivo culture for the CTL inoculation was necessary for efficient development of CD8(+) memory T cells. Thus, an important component of adoptive immunotherapy using CTL is the production of CD8(+) Ag-specific memory cells which is primarily favored by IL-2 receptor signaling during ex vivo generation of the effector CTL.     

Turning on/off tumor-specific CTL response during progressive tumor growth

Therapeutic vaccinations used to induce CTLs and treat firmly established tumors are generally ineffective. To understand the mechanisms underlying the failure of therapeutic vaccinations, we investigated the fate of tumor-specific CD8+ T cells in tumor-bearing mice with or without vaccinations. Our data demonstrate that tumor-specific CD8+ T cells are activated at the early stage of tumor growth, tumor-specific CTL response reaches a maximal level during progressive tumor growth, and tumor-specific CD8+ T cells lose cytolytic function at the late stage of tumor growth. The early stage therapeutic vaccination induces efficient antitumor activity by amplifying the CTL response, whereas the late-stage therapeutic vaccination is invalid due to tumor-induced dysfunction of CD8+ T cells. However, at the late stage, tumor-specific CD8+ T cells are still present in the periphery. These tumor-specific CD8+ T cells lose cytolytic activity, but retain IFN-gamma secretion function. In contrast to in vitro cultured tumor cells, in vivo growing tumor cells are more resistant to tumor-specific CTL killing, despite an increase of tumor Ag gene expression. Both tumor-induced CD8+ T cell dysfunction at the late stage and immune evasion developed by in vivo growing tumor cells contribute to an eventual inefficacy of therapeutic vaccinations. Our study suggests that it is important to design a vaccination regimen according to the stages of tumor growth and the functional states of tumor-specific CD8+ T cells.