Automixis in Artemia: solving a century‐old controversy

Parthenogenesis (reproduction through unfertilized eggs) encompasses a variety of reproduction modes with (automixis) or without (apomixis) meiosis. Different modes of automixis have very different genetic and evolutionary consequences but can be particularly difficult to tease apart. In this study, we propose a new method to discriminate different types of automixis from population‐level genetic data. We apply this method to diploid Artemia parthenogenetica, a crustacean whose reproductive mode remains controversial despite a century of intensive cytogenetic observations. We focus on A. parthenogenetica from two western Mediterranean populations. We show that they are diploid and that markers remain heterozygous in cultures maintained up to ~36 generations in the laboratory. Moreover, parallel patterns of population‐wide heterozygosity levels between the two natural populations strongly support the conclusion that diploid A. parthenogenetica reproduce by automictic parthenogenesis with central fusion and low, but nonzero recombination. This settles a century‐old controversy on Artemia, and, more generally, suggests that many automictic organisms harbour steep within‐chromosome gradients of heterozygosity due to a transition from clonal transmission in centromere‐proximal regions to a form of inbreeding similar to self‐fertilization in centromere‐distal regions. Such systems therefore offer a new avenue for contrasting the genomic consequences of asexuality and inbreeding.     

Mating systems and the evolutionary transition between haploidy and diploidy

According to the 'masking hypothesis', diploids gain an immediate fitness advantage over haploids because diploids, with two copies of every gene, are better able to survive the effects of deleterious recessive mutations. Masking in diploids is, however, a double-edged sword: it allows mutations to persist over tine. In contrast, deleterious mutations are revealed in haploid individuals and are more rapidly eliminated by selection, creating genetic associations that are favourable to haploidy. We model various mating schemes and show that assortative mating, selfing, and apomixis maintain the genetic associations that favour haploidy. These results suggest that a correlation should exist between mating system and ploidy level, with outcrossing favouring diploid life cycles and inbreeding or asexual reproduction favouring haploid life cycles. This prediction can be tested in groups, such as the Chlorophyta, with extensive variation both in life cycle and in reproductive system. Confirming or rejecting this prediction in natural populations would constitute the first empirical test of the masking hypothesis as a force shaping the evolution of life cycles.     

Frequency of induced mutations at the haploid and diploid levels inNicotiana tabacum L.

The frequencies of chlorophyll mutants were investigated in anther cultures derived from mutagen-treated plants ofN. tabacum cv. Samsun (haploid level) and in the seed offspring from the same treated plants (diploid level). Comparison of the induced mutation frequencies at the haploid and diploid levels demonstrated that selection existed against the haploid embryoids with induced chlorophyll deficient mutations. The diploid vegetative stage with phenotypic expression of the chlorophyll mutation was more vital than the haploid one. The suitability of anther cultures for studying induced mutagenesis is discussed.     

Haploidy, diploidy and evolution of antifungal drug resistance in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We tested the hypothesis that the time course of the evolution of antifungal drug resistance depends on the ploidy of the fungus. The experiments were designed to measure the initial response to the selection imposed by the antifungal drug fluconazole up to and including the fixation of the first resistance mutation in populations of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Under conditions of low drug concentration, mutations in the genes PDR1 and PDR3, which regulate the ABC transporters implicated in resistance to fluconazole, are favored. In this environment, diploid populations of defined size consistently became fixed for a resistance mutation sooner than haploid populations. Experiments manipulating population sizes showed that this advantage of diploids was due to increased mutation availability relative to that of haploids; in effect, diploids have twice the number of mutational targets as haploids and hence have a reduced waiting time for mutations to occur. Under conditions of high drug concentration, recessive mutations in ERG3, which result in resistance through altered sterol synthesis, are favored. In this environment, haploids consistently achieved resistance much sooner than diploids. When 29 haploid and 29 diploid populations were evolved for 100 generations in low drug concentration, the mutations fixed in diploid populations were all dominant, while the mutations fixed in haploid populations were either recessive (16 populations) or dominant (13 populations). Further, the spectrum of the 53 nonsynonymous mutations identified at the sequence level was different between haploids and diploids. These results fit existing theory on the relative abilities of haploids and diploids to adapt and suggest that the ploidy of the fungal pathogen has a strong impact on the evolution of fluconazole resistance.     

Copy Number Variation in Transcriptionally Active Regions of Sexual and Apomictic Boechera Demonstrates Independently Derived Apomictic Lineages

In asexual (apomictic) plants, the absence of meiosis and sex is expected to lead to mutation accumulation. To compare mutation accumulation in the transcribed genomic regions of sexual and apomictic plants, we performed a double-validated analysis of copy number variation (CNV) on 10 biological replicates each of diploid sexual and diploid apomictic Boechera, using a high-density (>700 K) custom microarray. The Boechera genome demonstrated higher levels of depleted CNV, compared with enriched CNV, irrespective of reproductive mode. Genome-wide patterns of CNV revealed four divergent lineages, three of which contain both sexual and apomictic genotypes. Hence genome-wide CNV reflects at least three independent origins (i.e., expression) of apomixis from different sexual genetic backgrounds. CNV distributions for different families of transposable elements were lineage specific, and the enrichment of LINE/L1 and long term repeat/Copia elements in lineage 3 apomicts is consistent with sex and meiosis being mechanisms for purging genomic parasites. We hypothesize that significant overrepresentation of specific gene ontology classes (e.g., pollen–pistil interaction) in apomicts implies that gene enrichment could be an adaptive mechanism for genome stability in diploid apomicts by providing a polyploid-like system for buffering the effects of deleterious mutations.     

Cis‐regulator runaway and divergence in asexuals

With the advent of new sequencing technologies, the evolution of gene expression is becoming a subject of intensive genomic research, with sparking debates upon the role played by these kinds of changes in adaptive evolution and speciation. In this article, we model expression evolution in species differing by their reproductive systems. We consider different rates of sexual versus asexual reproduction and the different type of parthenogenesis (apomixis and the various modes of automixis). We show that competition for expression leads to two selective processes on cis‐regulatory regions that act independently to organism‐level adaptation. Coevolution within regulatory networks allows these processes to occur without strongly modifying expression levels. First, cis‐regulatory regions such as enhancers evolve in a runaway fashion because they automatically become associated to chromosomes purged from deleterious mutations (“Enhancer Runaway process”). Second, in clonal or nearly clonal species, homologous cis‐regulatory regions tend to diverge, which leads to haploidization of expression, when they are sufficiently isolated from one another (“Enhancer Divergence process”). We show how these two processes cooccur and vary depending on the level of outcrossing, gene conversion, mitotic recombination, or recombination in automictic species. This study offers thus a baseline to understand patterns of expression evolution across the diversity of eukaryotic species.     

A novel mating system analysis for modes of self-oriented mating applied to diploid and polyploid arctic Easter daisies (Townsendia hookeri)

We have developed a new model for mating system analysis, which attempts to distinguish among alternative modes of self-oriented mating within populations. This model jointly estimates the rates of outcrossing, selfing, automixis and apomixis, through the use of information in the family structure given by dominant genetic marker data. The method is presented, its statistical properties evaluated, and is applied to three arctic Easter daisy populations, one consisting of diploids, the other two of tetraploids. The tetraploids are predominantly male sterile and reported to be apomictic while the diploids are male fertile. In each Easter daisy population, 10 maternal arrays of six progeny were assayed for amplified fragment length polymorphism markers. Estimates, confirmed with likelihood ratio tests of mating hypotheses, showed apomixis to be predominant in all populations (ca. 70%), but selfing or automixis was moderate (ca. 25%) in tetraploids. It was difficult to distinguish selfing from automixis, and simulations confirm that with even very large sample sizes, the estimates have a very strong negative statistical correlation, for example, they are not independent. No selfing or automixis was apparent in the diploid population, instead, moderate levels of outcrossing were detected (23%). Low but significant levels of outcrossing (2-4%) seemed to occur in the male-sterile tetraploid populations; this may be due to genotyping error of this level. Overall, this study shows apomixis can be partial, and provides evidence for higher levels of inbreeding in polyploids compared to diploids and for significant levels of apomixis in a diploid plant population.     

Hybrid incompatibilities in the parasitic wasp genus Nasonia: negative effects of hemizygosity and the identification of transmission ratio distortion loci

The occurrence of hybrid incompatibilities forms an important stage during the evolution of reproductive isolation. In early stages of speciation, males and females often respond differently to hybridization. Haldane's rule states that the heterogametic sex suffers more from hybridization than the homogametic sex. Although haplodiploid reproduction (haploid males, diploid females) does not involve sex chromosomes, sex-specific incompatibilities are predicted to be prevalent in haplodiploid species. Here, we evaluate the effect of sex/ploidy level on hybrid incompatibilities and locate genomic regions that cause increased mortality rates in hybrid males of the haplodiploid wasps Nasonia vitripennis and Nasonia longicornis. Our data show that diploid F(1) hybrid females suffer less from hybridization than haploid F(2) hybrid males. The latter not only suffer from an increased mortality rate, but also from behavioural and spermatogenic sterility. Genetic mapping in recombinant F(2) male hybrids revealed that the observed hybrid mortality is most likely due to a disruption of cytonuclear interactions. As these sex-specific hybrid incompatibilities follow predictions based on Haldane's rule, our data accentuate the need to broaden the view of Haldane's rule to include species with haplodiploid sex determination, consistent with Haldane's original definition.     

Characterization of Dominant Resistance to Cobalt Chloride in DICTYOSTELIUM DISCOIDEUM and Its Use in Parasexual Genetic Analysis

Strains of Dictyostelium discoideum resistant to cobaltous chloride have been isolated at a frequency of approximately 10^-6. The resistant strains have one of three phenotypes, recessive to wild type, dominant to wild type and dominant to wild type but requiring the presence of cobaltous chloride to maintain resistance. Strains carrying a dominant cobaltous chloride resistance mutation and a recessive growth temperature-sensitive mutation can be mixed with wild-type haploid lines and then subjected to selection so that only diploid lines survive. Differential sensitivity to cycloheximide has also been observed. Hypersensitivity to cycloheximide in combination with dominant cobaltous chloride resistance provides a means of selecting diploids without the use of temperature-sensitive mutations.     

GENETICS OF GRACILARIA TIKVAHIAE (RHODOPHYCEAE). X. STUDIES ON A BISEXUAL CLONE12

A male done of the red alga Gracilaria tikvahiae McLachlan spontaneously produced a bisexual frond which remained bisexual in subsequent subcultures. Both male and female components of bisexual fronds were functional; however, some unusual results were obtained in crosses. When bisexual fronds were crossed with a normal haploid male, the resulting carpospores all developed into diploid male gametophytes. When bisexual plants were self fertilized, all the carpospores yielded diploid bisexual gametophytes. Only when bisexual plants were crossed to normal haploid females, did carpospores develop into diploid tetrasporophytes as they normally do. The F₁ gametophyte generation obtained from these tetrasporophytes, however, included not only females and males but also bisexual plants, in a 2:1:1 ratio. These results are consistent with the interpretation that bisexual plants have a recessive mutation of a gene other than the primary sex determining locus, and that this mutation is expressed only in male plants. It is suggested that the altered gene may ordinarily have a regulatory function in the maintenance of the dioecious condition.     

Generating Autotetraploid Sporophytes and Their Use in Analyzing Mutations Affecting Gametophyte Development in the Fern Ceratopteris

The haploid gametophytes of the fern Ceratopteris richardii are autotrophic and develop independently of the diploid sporophyte plant. While haploid genetics is useful for screening and characterizing mutations affecting gametophyte development in Ceratopteris, it is difficult to assess whether a gametophytic mutation is dominant or recessive or to determine allelism by complementation analysis in a haploid organism. This report describes how apospory can be used to produce genetically marked polyploid sporophytes whose gametophyte progeny are heterozygous for mutations affecting sex determination in the gametophyte and a known recessive mutation affecting the phenotype of both the gametophyte and sporophyte. The segregation ratios of wild-type to mutant phenotypes in the gametophyte progeny of polyploid sporophyte plants indicate that all of the mutations examined are recessive. The presence of many multivalents and few univalents in meiotic chromosome preparations of spore mother cells confirm that the sporophyte plants assayed are polyploid. The DNA content of the sperm of their progeny gametophytes was also found to be approximately twice that of sperm from wild-type haploid gametophytes.     

Cultural inheritance of the desire for male offspring and the incidence of a sex‐linked lethal disease

Abstract

This paper studies the effect of having at least one male offspring on a sex‐linked recessive disease and the fraction of affected males due to fresh mutations. The equilibrium frequency of heterozygous females depends not only on the intensity of the reproductive compensation, but also on the time of mutational change. It has been shown that the frequency ranges from 4u without reproductive compensation to √2u or √3u with strict compensation, where u is the mutation rate from the wild type allele to lethal gene. The frequency √2u is achieved when mutation occurs in mature germ cells, whereas, √3u achieved when mutation occurs in early development of germ cells. This increased frequency of heterozygous females due to reproductive compensation reduces considerably the proportion of affected males due to fresh mutation.     

Effect of Ploidy and Mutagens on Bromodeoxyuridine Resistance in Haploid and Diploid Frog Cells

THE frog embryo cell line ICR 2A is the first established haploid vertebrate cell line¹. In haploid cells recessive mutations should be detectable at a frequency 10⁶ to 10⁹ times greater than expected in diploid cells; mutagen treatment should increase the yield further. These predictions are useful to test whether variants arising in culture are the result of gene mutation. To apply this test to frog cells, mutations for thymidine kinase were sought. Such mutants were first obtained by exposing mouse L cells to the thymidine analogue 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR); a loss of thymidine kinase activity prevented the lethal incorporation of BUdR into DNA². The new phenotype was considered to be the result of gene mutation because of its heritability and eventually because of data from Luria-Delbrück fluctuation analyses³ (a test of the spontaneity or non-inducibility of a process, not its cause). The question of origin was further complicated by a number of factors: (1) the necessity of a long, repeated, exposure to BUdR²; (2) the high mutation rate (up to 10^?3) compared with bacterial mutants (10^?910^?6)^4,5; and (3) the presence of resistant clones with intermediate enzyme levels^4,5.     

Multiple direct transitions from sexual reproduction to apomictic parthenogenesis in Timema stick insects

Transitions from sexual reproduction to parthenogenesis may occur along multiple evolutionary pathways and involve various cytological mechanisms to produce diploid eggs. Here, we investigate routes to parthenogenesis in Timema stick insects, a genus comprising five obligate parthenogens. By combining information from microsatellites and karyotypes with a previously published mitochondrial phylogeny, we show that all five parthenogens likely evolved spontaneously from sexually reproducing species, and that the sexual ancestor of one of the five parthenogens was probably of hybrid origin. The complete maintenance of heterozygosity between generations in the five parthenogens strongly suggests that eggs are produced by apomixis. Virgin females of the sexual species were also able to produce parthenogenetic offspring, but these females produced eggs by automixis. High heterozygosity levels stemming from conserved ancestral alleles in the parthenogens suggest, however, that automixis has not generated the current parthenogenetic Timema lineages but that apomixis appeared abruptly in several sexual species. A direct transition from sexual reproduction to (at least functional) apomixis results in a relatively high level of allelic diversity and high efficiency for parthenogenesis. Because both of these traits should positively affect the demographic success of asexual lineages, spontaneous apomixis may have contributed to the origin and maintenance of asexuality in Timema .     

'Haldane's Sieve' in a metapopulation: sifting through plant reproductive polymorphisms

An important result of population genetics is that advantageous mutations will be fixed by selection in a population with a greater probability if they are dominant rather than recessive. This selective filter on new variants entering a population, termed 'Haldane's Sieve', has hitherto been invoked to account for the greater role of dominant than completely recessive mutations in adaptive evolution. Here, we suggest that a process similar to Haldane's Sieve will act on migrants into subpopulations of a metapopulation, and that the repeated action of Haldane's Sieve on alleles maintained by frequency-dependent selection, such as those responsible for many plant reproductive polymorphisms, is expected to bias their frequency distribution in favour of dominant alleles. The genetic and phenotypic signatures left by these processes might provide additional indirect support for the contentious idea that metapopulation dynamics have had an important role in shaping the ecology and evolution of some plant species.     

FURTHER SIMULATION STUDIES ON EVOLUTION BY GENE DUPLICATION

In order to understand the origin of multigene families, Monte Carlo simulations were performed to see how a genetic system evolves under unequal crossing-over, mutation, random genetic drift and natural selection, starting from a single gene copy. Both haploid and diploid models were examined. Beneficial, neutral, and detrimental mutations were incorporated, and “positive” selection favors those chromosomes (haploid) or individuals (diploid) with more beneficial mutations than others. The same model for haploids was previously investigated with special reference to the evolution of gene organization, and the ratio of the numbers of beneficial genes to pseudogenes was found to be a rough indicator of the relative strengths of positive and negative (against deleterious alleles) natural selection (Ohta, 1987b). In the present paper, the evolution of gene organization and of sequence divergence among genes in the multigene family is examined. It is shown that positive selection accelerates the accumulation of arrays containing different beneficial mutations, but that total divergence including both neutral and beneficial mutations is not very sensitive to positive selection, under this model. The proportion of beneficial mutations in the total mutations accumulated is a better indicator of positive selection than is the total divergence. It is pointed out that various observed examples in which amino-acid substitutions are accelerated, as compared with synonymous substitutions in duplicated genes (Li, 1985), may reflect the effect of selection similar to the present scheme. The diploid model is shown to be more efficient for accumulating beneficial mutations in duplicated genes than the haploid one, and the relevance of this finding to the advantage of sexual reproduction is discussed.     

Recombination and loss of complementation: a more than two-fold cost for parthenogenesis

Certain types of asexual reproduction lead to loss of complementation, that is unmasking of recessive deleterious alleles. A theoretical measure of this loss is calculated for apomixis, automixis and endomitosis in the cases of diploidy and polyploidy. The effect of the consequent unmasking of deleterious recessive mutations on fitness is also calculated. Results show that, depending on the number of lethal equivalents and on the frequency of recombination, the cost produced by loss of complementation after few generations of asexual reproduction may be greater than the two-fold cost of meiosis. Maintaining complementation may, therefore, provide a general short-term advantage for sexual reproduction. Apomixis can replace sexual reproduction under a wide range of parameters only if it is associated with triploidy or tetraploidy, which is consistent with our knowledge of the distribution of apomixis.     

Mechanism of facultative parthenogenesis in the ant <Emphasis Type="Italic">Platythyrea punctata</Emphasis>

Thelytokous parthenogenesis, the production of diploid female offspring from unfertilized eggs, can be caused by several cytological mechanisms, which have a different impact on the genetic variation on the offspring. The ponerine ant Platythyrea punctata is widely distributed throughout the Caribbean Islands and Central America and exhibits facultative parthenogenesis. Workers in many field colonies from the Caribbean Islands have identical multilocus genotypes and are thus probably clonal, but the occurrence of males makes an ameiotic mechanism of thelytoky unlikely. To clarify the details of thelytoky in this species we compared the multilocus genotypes of mothers and their offspring in experimental colonies and analyzed the genotypes of haploid and diploid males. Additionally, we screened a large number of field colonies from thelytokous populations for the occurrence of recombination events. According to these data, automixis with central fusion and a reduced recombination rate is the most likely mechanism of thelytoky, as in the Cape honeybee and the ant Cataglyphis cursor.     

DOES HYBRIDIZATION DRIVE THE TRANSITION TO ASEXUALITY IN DIPLOID BOECHERA?

Gametophytic apomixis is a common form of asexual reproduction in plants. Virtually all gametophytic apomicts are polyploids, and some view polyploidy as a prerequisite for the transition to apomixis. However, any causal link between apomixis and polyploidy is complicated by the fact that most apomictic polyploids are allopolyploids, leading some to speculate that hybridization, rather than polyploidy, enables apomixis. Diploid apomixis presents a rare opportunity to isolate the role of hybridization, and a number of diploid apomicts have been documented in the genus Boechera (Brassicaceae). Here, we present the results of a microsatellite study of 1393 morphologically and geographically diverse diploid individuals, evaluating the hypothesis that diploid Boechera apomicts are hybrids. This genus‐wide dataset was made possible by the applicability of a core set of microsatellite loci in 69 of the 70 diploid Boechera species and by our ability to successfully genotype herbarium specimens of widely varying ages. With few exceptions, diploid apomicts exhibited markedly high levels of heterozygosity resulting from the combination of disparate genomes. This strongly suggests that most apomictic diploid Boechera lineages are of hybrid origin, and that the genomic consequences of hybridization allow for the transition to gametophytic apomixis in this genus.     

The characterization of color mutations in Bangiaceae (Bangiales, Rhodophyta)

The color mutations in Bangiaceae were investigated by treating the blades, conchocelis and conchospores phase of Bangia sp., Porphyra yezoensis, and P. haitanensis sampled in China with mutagen N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG). A high percentage of mutation in different expression characteristics in all three phases were shown within optimum mutagen concentrations. Among mutagenized blades, mutations occurred on single cells, which is a direct outcome of mutation of haploid cells. The mutation of mutagenized conchocelis resulted in a two-step process: low-level expression in conchocelis phase, and high-level expression in progeny, explaining that mutation took place in diploid cells. The mutations of conchospores were expressed immediately at germination of spores, indicating a change in ploidy. This paper reports the process of meiosis and its effect on frond development, and the relation between color mutations and morphological characteristics expressed by mutations in Bangiaceae.