Quantitative assessment of various fixatives on nuclear and cytoplasmic areas in oral cytology

Summary Both nuclear and cytoplasmic areas are parameters known to be of significance in the diagnosis of malignancy. However, few studies have assessed the effect of fixation on exfoliative cytology and none has looked at such influences upon oral smears. Hence the method of fixation may influence directly diagnostic cytology. The effect of three methods of fixation upon the nuclear and cytoplasmic areas of cells removed from the buccal mucosa was quantitatively assessed. The three methods employed, prior to Papanicolaou staining, were: direct immersion in diethylether and ethanol (11 v/v), spray fixation (Vale Smear Fix) and air drying. Three smears from each of 21 patients were used, each slide being allocated randomly a, method of fixation. After 24h all smears were processed for Papanicolaou's stain.The nuclear and cytoplasmic areas were calculated using semi-automated image analysis. No significant differences were found in the two areas whichever method of fixation was used.     

The impact of liquid-based oral cytology on the diagnosis of oral squamous dysplasia and carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: Even though diagnostic oral exfoliative cytology is a useful, economical and practical tool in the diagnosis of oral dysplasia and carcinoma, it is not yet extensively used. The results of conventional exfoliative and liquid-based diagnostic cytology in oral potentially malignant lesions (PML) are herein reported and compared with the histological diagnosis. METHODS: Either conventional (89) or liquid-based (384) exfoliative cytology was used for the diagnosis of oral dysplasia/carcinoma in 473 subjects and the results were compared with scalpel biopsy histology. Cells were collected using a Cytobrush device for conventional smears and with a dermatological curette for the liquid-based cytology. The 'curette technique' also allowed for the collection of 'accidental' tissue fragments, utilized as microbiopsies. RESULTS: Histological diagnosis was squamous carcinoma in 96 of 473 cases, high-grade dysplasia (oral intraepithelial neoplasia two to three) in 24 and other lesions in 353 cases. The smears in the conventional cytology group were inadequate in 12.4%, with an 85.7% sensitivity and a 95.9% specificity. There were 8.8% of inadequate specimens in the liquid-based cytology group; sensitivity was 95.1% and specificity was 99.0%. CONCLUSIONS: Although conventional cytology is useful when diagnosing oral PML (better sensitivity and predictive positive value if compared with the cervical smear test with similar specificity) and can improve the accuracy of histological diagnosis, liquid-based cytology gives better results, as it not only enhances both sensitivity and specificity, but also provides material for further investigation (AgNORs, DNA, microbiopsies, etc.).     

Cytologic and DNA-cytometric early diagnosis of oral cancer.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this prospective study was to report on the diagnostic accuracy of conventional oral exfoliative cytology taken from white-spotted, ulcerated or other suspicious oral lesions in our clinic. In addition we checked DNA-image cytometry as an adjuvant diagnostic tool. Our hypothesis is that DNA-aneuploidy is a sensitive and specific marker for the early identification of tumor cells in oral brushings. STUDY DESIGN: 251 cytological diagnoses obtained from exfoliative smears of 181 patients from macroscopically suspicious lesions of the oral mucosa and from clinically seemingly benign oral lesions which were excised for establishing histological diagnoses were compared with histological and/or clinical follow-ups of the respective patients. Additionally nuclear DNA-contents were measured after Feulgen restaining using a TV image analysis system. RESULTS: Sensitivity of our cytological diagnosis on oral smears for the detection of cancer cells was 94.6%, specificity 99.5%, positive predictive value 98.1% and negative predictive value 98.5%. DNA-aneuploidy was assumed if abnormal DNA-stemlines or cells with DNA-content greater 9c were observed. On this basis the prevalence of DNA-aneuploidy in smears of oral squamous cell carcinomas in situ or invasive carcinomas was 96.4%. Sensitivity of DNA-aneuploidy in oral smears for the detection of cancer cells was 96.4%, specificity 100%, positive predictive value 100% and negative 99.0%. The combination of both techniques increased the sensitivity to 98.2%, specificity to 100%, positive predictive value to 100% and negative to 99.5%. CONCLUSIONS: Brush cytology of all visible oral lesions, if they are clinically considered as suspicious for cancer, are an easily practicable, cheap, non-invasive, painless, safe and accurate screening method for detection of oral precancerous lesions, carcinoma in situ or invasive squamous cell carcinoma in all stages. We conclude that DNA-image cytometry is a very sensitive, highly specific and objective adjuvant tool for the early identification of neoplastic epithelial cells in oral smears.     

Quantitative cytomorphologic analyses of Papanicolaou-stained smears from oral lichen planus

OBJECTIVE: To apply quantitative techniques to cytologic smears in order to improve the diagnostic sensitivity of cytology in the detection of malignant change in the oral cavity. STUDY DESIGN: Eighty-two patients with lesions of oral lichen planus were investigated. A total of 247 Papanicolaou-stained buccal smears underwent nuclear and cytoplasmic area measurements using a TV image analyzer. RESULTS: The cytomorphologic results of this study suggest that lesions of oral lichen planus contain smaller cells and nuclei than those observed in clinically normal oral mucosal smears. There was a statistically significant reduction in nuclear area (P < .001) and cytoplasmic area (P < .05) for the oral lichen planus smears. CONCLUSION: The TV image analysis system could provide a valuable method of quantifying cell changes in oral smears collected from oral mucosa as a method of monitoring lesions of oral lichen planus.     

Exfoliative cytology of the oral mucosa in burning mouth syndrome: a cytomorphological and cytomorphometric analysis

doi:10.1111/j.1741‐2358.2009.00319.x
Exfoliative cytology of the oral mucosa in burning mouth syndrome: a cytomorphological and cytomorphometric analysis Objective: The aim of this study was to evaluate oral epithelial cells by exfoliative cytology in burning mouth syndrome (BMS). Material and methods: Oral smears were collected from clinically normal‐appearing mucosa by liquid‐based exfoliative cytology in 40 individuals (20 BMS patients and 20 healthy controls matched for age and gender) and analysed for cytological and cytomorphometric techniques. Results: Mean values of nuclear area (NA) for experimental and control groups were, respectively, 67.52 and 55.64 μm² (p < 0.05). Cytoplasmic area (CA) showed the following mean values: 1258.0 (experimental) and 2069.0 μm² (control). Nucleus‐to‐cytoplasm area ratio for the experimental group was 0.07, besides the control group was 0.03 (p < 0.05). Morphologically, oral smears exhibited normal epithelial cells in both experimental and control groups. There was a significant predominance of nucleated cells of the superficial layer in the smears of BMS patients (p = 0.00001). Conclusion: This study revealed that oral mucosa of BMS patients exhibited significant cytomorphometric changes in the oral epithelial cells. These changes probably are associated with epithelial atrophy and a deregulated maturation process that may contribute to the oral symptoms of pain and discomfort in BMS.     

Exfoliative cytology of lymphoepitheliomalike carcinoma of the uterine cervix. A report of two cases

BACKGROUND: Lymphoepitheliomalike carcinomas (LECs) are morphologically similar to undifferentiated nasopharyngeal carcinoma but occur at sites other than the nasopharynx. They rarely occur in the uterine cervix. Sixty-five cases of LEC of the cervix have been published to date, and the pitfalls of histopathologic interpretation have been discussed. This undifferentiated carcinoma with a prominent lymphocytic infiltrate represents a challenge for the pathologist examining a scant cervical biopsy or Pap smear. Distinguishing LEC as a separate entity is important. Despite the fact that the epithelial component is poorly differentiated, this neoplasm is associated with a lower frequency of lymph node metastases, is potentially radiosensitive and has a better prognosis. Although mentioned in passing in several papers, the exfoliative cytology of this cervical neoplasm has not been adequately discussed. We report the cytologic features of LEC in cervical smears obtained from two patients. CASES: The first patient presented with menometrorrhagia and postcoital bleeding. The cervical smear taken at the time of presentation was reported as unsatisfactory for evaluation. ASCUS was diagnosed on a vaginal smear obtained one year earlier. The second patient presented with a complaint of postcoital bleeding. A cervical smear and the cervical biopsy taken at the time of presentation were reported as ASCUS and high grade dysplasia versus carcinoma, respectively. A retrospective review of the cervical smears revealed rare malignant cells occurring singly or in small groups. The tumor cells had a high nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio, irregular nuclear membrane and hyperchromatic nuclei with coarse chromatin and were obscured by heavy inflammation and blood. The background resembled that of a menstrual smear. CONCLUSION: The diagnosis of LEC of the cervix is often made on a loop electrical excision procedure or on a hysterectomy specimen. The presence of heavy inflammation and blood, which can obscure the malignant nature of the cells, presents the cytopathologist with a challenging diagnosis of LEC in cervical smears. In view of the prognostic implications, it is desirable for the pathologist to classify LEC as a distinct entity.     

Analysis of silver binding nucleolar organizer regions in exfoliative cytology smears of potentially malignant and malignant oral lesions

Nucleolar organizer regions are nucleolar components that contain proteins that are stained selectively by silver methods; they can be identified as black dots throughout the nucleolus and are known as silver binding nucleolar organizer regions (AgNOR). The number of AgNOR is related to the cell cycle and the proliferative activity of the cells. We investigated AgNOR using exfoliative cytology smears of potentially malignant oral lesions. Eighty individuals were divided into four equal groups: healthy controls, oral leukoplakia, oral submucous fibrosis and oral squamous cell carcinoma. The mean number of AgNOR in each study group gradually increased from control to oral leukoplakia to oral submucous fibrosis to oral squamous cell carcinoma. The proliferative index was increased in the oral premalignant and malignant patients compared to normal subjects. The mean AgNOR size gradually increased from control to oral leukoplakia to oral submucous fibrosis to oral squamous cell carcinoma. Spherical shaped AgNOR were most common in controls, whereas large, clustered and kidney shapes were most common in oral squamous cell carcinoma. Multiparameter analysis of AgNOR in oral exfoliative smears is a simple, sensitive and cost-effective method for differentiating premalignant from malignant lesions and can be used in conjunction with routine cytomorphological evaluation.     

A morphometric study of the protective effect of cryotherapy on oral mucositis in cancer patients treated with 5-fluorouracil

We investigated cytological changes in oral mucosa smears from patients treated with cryotherapy to determine whether cryotherapy prevented mucositis caused by 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) therapy. Patients with gastrointestinal malignancies were divided into four groups; control patients before 5-FU therapy, patients after 5-FU therapy without cryotherapy, patients with cryotherapy before 5-FU therapy and patients with cryotherapy after 5-FU therapy. Oral mucosa samples from all patients were assessed at the beginning and on day 14 of chemotherapy. We used exfoliative cytology to evaluate cellular changes in the oral mucosa that were caused by 5-FU. Smears from each patient were stained using the Papanicolaou method and analyzed using stereology. Smears were taken from each group before and after 5-FU infusion. We found that nuclear volume was decreased significantly in cells of the 5-FU therapy after cryotherapy patients compared to the 5-FU therapy before cryotherapy patients. We also found significantly decreased cytoplasmic volumes in the 5-FU therapy after cryotherapy patients compared to the 5-FU therapy before cryotherapy patients. The results of cytomorphometric estimations revealed that cryotherapy may be used to prevent damage to oral tissue and may decrease the frequency and duration of oral mucositis caused by 5-FU.     

Cytobrush and wooden spatula for oral exfoliative cytology. A comparison.

The Cytobrush has been used frequently in cervical cytology, but as yet its value in oral exfoliative cytology has not been assessed. A study was undertaken to compare the efficiency of the Cytobrush with that of the wooden tongue spatula. For 26 patients, two smears were collected from clinically normal mucosa from four sites in the oral cavity (buccal mucosa, dorsal tongue, ventral tongue and hard palate). The smears were graded for cell yield and dispersion on a three-point scale. The results were analyzed using the chi 2 test. The Cytobrush was found to be significantly more efficient than the wooden spatula, in terms of both cell yield (P less than .005) and cell dispersion (P less than .005). When each site was examined separately, the Cytobrush produced significantly better dispersion for the dorsal tongue, ventral tongue and buccal mucosa and a better cell yield for the tongue surfaces. No significant difference for cell yield or dispersion was found for the hard palate. The study showed that the Cytobrush is an effective instrument for use in exfoliative cytology of normal oral mucosa.     

Comparison of Planimetry and Image Analysis For the Discrimination Between Normal and Abnormal Cells In Cytological Smears of Suspicious Lesions of the Oral Cavity

Light microscope analysis of cytological smears of suspicious lesions of the oral cavity is used as a method for detecting early cancer in the oral cavity. the sensitivity of this approach can be improved by quantitative analysis of the cells in the cytological smears. We have compared the efficiency of planimetry and the Vids V system of image analysis, as quantitative methods for discriminating between normal and abnormal cells in cytological smears of suspicious lesions in the oral cavity. Both methods detected an increase in nuclear area and a decrease in cytoplasmic area in abnormal epithelial cells from dysplastic lesions of increasing severity. However, image analysis was better able to discriminate between benign and malignant cells on the basis of nuclear size. Thus the Vids V system of image analysis is more appropriate than planimetry for quantitative analysis of cytological smears from the oral cavity.     

Atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance in cervical smears after conization. Cytologic features differentiating them from adenocarcinoma in situ

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the cytologic features of atypical glandular cells of undetermined significance (AGUS) smears following conization through a comparison with adenocarcinoma in situ (AIS) smears. STUDY DESIGN: Fifty cervical smears, diagnosed as AGUS based on groups of crowded glandular cells that raised the possibility of AIS, from 38 patients who had conization and 24 AIS smears, histologically confirmed, from 17 patients were reviewed. Subsequent follow-up biopsies or hysterectomies in 38 patients were evaluated. RESULTS: Nuclear atypia was a more reliable feature than architectural structure in differentiating postcone effect from AIS on cytology. The predominant cytologic features of the postcone smears were crowded glandular cells with a high nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio and relatively small, hyperchromatic nuclei with rather finely granular and uniformly dispersed chromatin, less distinct nuclear membranes, less frequent mitosis and presence of endometrial-type stromal cells in the background. The architecture of the crowded cells in the postcone smears was sometimes similar to that of AIS. No AIS or high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion histology was encountered in follow-up biopsies or hysterectomy specimens. CONCLUSION: The cytologic features distinguishing AGUS from AIS may be helpful in identifying the postcone effect. Since it is important to avoid miscalling the postcone effect as AIS, it is recommended that one check for a previous history of a cone biopsy.     

Cytologic analysis of alterations induced by Smoking and by alcohol consumption

OBJECTIVE: To analyze cytologically the buccal mucosa of smoking and nonsmoking volunteers to determine what cellular changes are induced by cigarettes and alcohol consumption. STUDY DESIGN: In order to evaluate cellular changes induced by smoking and alcohol consumption, exfoliative cytology was used for the analysis of mucosal smears obtained from the buccal mucosa of 25 smokers and 25 nonsmokers. The number of cigarettes consumed, duration of smoking, presence or absence of alcohol ingestion, ingested alcohol dose and frequency of consumption, and most frequently used type of alcoholic beverage were determined using a questionnaire. Three smears from each individual stained by the Papanicolaou method were analyzed quantitatively and qualitatively under a light microscope by 2 experienced examiners in terms of inflammatory and dysplastic alterations and of the degree of epithelial maturation. RESULTS: Although numerous alterations were observed in smokers they corresponded up to only Papanicolaou class II and were not significantly different from nonsmokers (Mann-Whitney and chi2 tests, p < 0.05). A higher proportion of inflammatory cells (polymorphonuclear and mononuclear cells) were obtained from smokers as compared to nonsmokers, while the proportion of bacteria was similar in the 2 groups. CONCLUSION: The findings indicate that even after a short period of cigarette use and alcohol consumption, inflammatory alterations were detectable on exfoliative cytology of the buccal mucosa in a young group, demonstrating the usefulness of cytology for early detection in smokers.     

Pleomorphic adenoma of salivary gland: to what extent does fine needle aspiration cytology reflect histopathological features?

OBJECTIVE: The histological diversity encountered in pleomorphic adenoma may cause diagnostic difficulty in fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology due to limited and selective sampling. The present study based on 25 histologically confirmed pleomorphic adenoma cases attempts to find out to what extent FNA cytology reflects the histopathological features. METHODS: May-Grunwald-Giemsa and Papanicolaou stained smears, and haematoxylin and eosin stained paraffin sections of 25 pleomorphic adenomas of parotid and submandibular glands were reviewed. The cellularity, which was assessed in a sliding scale of 1+ to 4+, and proportions of epithelial to mesenchymal components in FNA smears and histology was determined and compared. The frequency of morphological features such as squamous metaplastic cells, cells with oncocytic change, acinus formation, mucus globules, papilla formation, giant cells, myxoid and chondroid matrix as well as specific nuclear features was compared between the two diagnostic methods, and the statistical significance was determined using Fisher's exact test of probability. RESULTS: There was complete concordance between cytology and histology with respect to overall cellularity in 14 (56.0%) cases and in the proportions of epithelial to mesenchymal components in 13 (52.0%). Epithelial cells and myxoid matrix were present in all cases. There was no significant difference between smear and tissue section with respect to frequency of squamous metaplasia, oncocytic change, acinus formation, papilla formation, mucus globules, giant cells, nuclear pleomorphism, nuclear chromatin pattern, and mitotic figures. Morphological parameters that were significantly higher in FNAC compared with histology included intranuclear cytoplasmic inclusions (36.0% versus 8.0%, p = 0.0374), nuclear grooves (84.0% versus 48.0%, p = 0.0090), and reniform nuclei (20.0% versus 0.0%, p = 0.0502). Chondroid matrix was the only parameter which was significantly more common in histology than in cytology (44.0% versus 4.0%, p = 0.019). CONCLUSION: FNA cytology demonstrates well most of the histological features of pleomorphic adenoma of salivary gland and may be considered a useful tool in initial assessment of the tumour.     

Multiple myeloma. The diagnostic role and prognostic significance of exfoliative cytology

The clinical significance and diverse cytomorphologic spectrum of exfoliative cytology in multiple myeloma are presented from our 20-year retrospective and continuing prospective studies and from an extensive review of the literature. Of 370 myeloma patients studied retrospectively, 126 had at least one exfoliative cytologic specimen but only 6 had one or more specimens positive for myeloma. These included six pleural and two ascitic fluids and one sputum. In Papanicolaou-stained smears, myeoloma cells varied from essentially normal-appearing plasma cells to dispersed large malignant cells with little or no plasmacytoid features. Whereas all 203 cervical or vaginal, cerebrospinal, urine and bronchial specimens were negative for myeloma, 40% and 50% of the pleural and ascitic fluids, respectively, were positive. Four prospectively studied patients produced a total of seven positive serous fluid specimens. Follow-up data was available for eight patients with cytology positive for myeoloma. Six were dead within three months of the first positive specimen.     

Contextual analysis complements single-cell analysis in the diagnosis of breast cancer in fine needle aspirates

Image analysis techniques were used to characterize individual nuclei of cells and entire clusters of cells in hematoxylin-and-eosin-stained smears of fine needle aspirates of the breast to determine the ability of these techniques to distinguish benign from malignant cases. Analysis of the individual nuclear features showed significant differences in nuclear area, shape (bending energy), texture and integrated darkness between benign and malignant samples. Analysis of the clusters demonstrated that the benign clusters were fewer in number, more cellular (average gray level) and larger than malignant clusters. A statistical classifier was constructed to test the discriminatory accuracy for benign and malignant cases. Good discrimination was found for both the individual nuclei and the clusters when analyzed separately, although a few cases were misclassified by each type of analysis. When combined, the two classifiers achieved a completely accurate classification. This suggests the complementary nature of high-resolution single-cell analysis and the more global cluster analysis techniques.     

Cytology of giant-cell glioblastoma

A case is presented in which smears and touch imprints of a parietal tumor in a 58-year-old female revealed two distinct and easily recognizable cellular populations. The first was predominant and consisted of densely packed cells of an astroglial nature. The other was made up of unusually large giant cells with highly malignant features. The cytology of these combined cell types allowed the correct diagnosis of giant-cell glioblastoma at the time of surgery. Their cytomorphology, which has seldom been reported, supported the interpretation of an astroglial nature of this tumor.     

Oral exfoliative cytology in the diagnosis of paracoccidioidomycosis

OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy of conventional oral exfoliative cytology as a diagnostic tool in paracoccidioidomycosis. STUDY DESIGN: Cytologic smears and incisional biopsies were obtained from 10 patients with a clinical suspicion and oral manifestations of paracoccidioidomycosis. Cytologic smears and sections of the incisional biopsy underwent methenamine silver staining for fungi according to the Gomori-Grocott method. The dry glass slides were examined at 400 or 1,000 x magnification, and the presence and shape of yeasts of Paracoccidioides brasiliensis were investigated. RESULTS: Yeasts of the fungus P brasiliensis were clearly identified in cytologic smears and sections from incisional biopsies in all cases analyzed (100.0%). CONCLUSION: Cytology of oral samples proved an effective diagnostic method for the detection of paracoccidioidomycosis in humans.     

Book review

Abstract

Exfoliative cytology is a minimally invasive technique for obtaining oral cell specimens from patients for diagnostic purposes. Classical applications of oral cytology studies, such as oral candidiasis, have been extended to include oral precancerous and cancerous lesions. A number of analytical methods are available for studying cytology specimens. The development of molecular analysis techniques, the oral cancer etiopathogenic process, and improvements in liquid-based exfoliative cytology are leading to renewed interest in exfoliative cytology. Results sometimes are disputed, so the aim of our review was to clarify the applicability of exfoliative cytology to the diagnosis of oral precancerous and cancerous lesions.     

Liquid-based vs. conventional smears in fine needle aspiration of bone and soft tissue tumors

OBJECTIVE: To compare the accuracy of fine needle aspiration cytology of bone and soft tissue tumors utilizing ThinPrep (TP) (Cytyc Corporation, Boxborough, Massachusetts, U.S.A.) vs. conventional smears (CS). STUDY DESIGN: Fine needle aspiration cytology from bone and soft tissue tumors was processed and assessed for cellularity, nuclear and cytoplasmic preservation, cellular architecture and stromal background with both the TP liquid-based smear technique and conventional methods. RESULTS: An accurate diagnosis was made in 13% of TP cases as compared to 64% in CS cases. CONCLUSION: CS of fine needle aspiration sample is far superior to TP in diagnosing tumors of bone and soft tissues. Preservation of cytoplasmic features and cellular architecture was superior in conventionally prepared smears.     

Exfoliative cytology in the evaluation of interferon treatment of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia

Local interferon injection in four patients with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) regularly elicited progressive regression of the lesions. The response was observed with exfoliative cytology after each injection, guided by colposcopic examination. The cytologic changes showed a cytocidal effect mainly on the dyskaryotic cells, preceded by cellular degeneration not unlike that of nonspecific inflammation and accompanied by an increase in neutrophil infiltration. The cytologic response was closely correlated with partial or complete clinical regression based on the absence of viable or degenerated dyskaryotic cells in the cervical smears. Three patients showed complete clinical regression after treatment. One patient showed recurrent viable dyskaryotic cells when the dosage was reduced, and treatment was suspended temporarily although her lesion had regressed completely after five injections. Clinical recurrence was noted one week after viable dyskaryotic cells reappeared in her smears. These observations suggest that cytology may be a useful means of monitoring interferon treatment in CIN.