The effect of localised eutrophication on competition between Ulva lactuca (Ulvaceae,Chlorophyta) and a commercial resource of Gracilaria verrucosa (Gracilariaceae,Rhodophyta)

In spring (August) 1993 a bloom of Ulva lactuca appeared for the first time in Saldanha Bay, South Africa, and persisted through summer. Ulva wash-ups contaminated the beach and part of the commercial Gracilaria beach-cast had to be discarded. The biomass and distribution of Gracilaria and Ulva are described in relation to the seasonal water chemistry of the bay. Gracilaria survives in deeper water in summer by the pulsing of nutrients on an approximately 6-day cycle of movement of the thermocline that separates nutrient-rich bottom water from warm oligotrophic surface water. Ammonium-rich fish-factory discharge into this surface layer in a sector of the bay provided localised conditions for Ulva to out-compete Gracilaria at depths of 2–5m, demonstrating the powerful disruptive effect of eutrophication in this strongly stratified system.     

The gracilarioids in South Africa: long-term monitoring of a declining resource

In South Africa, gracilarioid red algae have been collected as wash-up to be dried and sold for agar extraction for at least 50 years. Despite much research, there is currently no commercial mariculture of the algae locally although this has been carried out in neighboring Namibia for a number of years. The industry is traditionally confined to Saldanha Bay on the west coast, although small wash-ups of Gracilariopsis longissima have been collected in nearby St Helena Bay. In Saldanha Bay, wash-ups of Gracilaria. gracilis have been very sporadic over the last few decades, with human alteration of the bay configuration possibly responsible for an initial major decline in 1974. This unpredictability in the amounts of wash-up has made the industry unstable and increasingly unprofitable. We compiled the results of previous surveys (some unpublished) of gracilariod populations in St Helena Bay and the Saldanha-Langebaan sytem, and re-surveyed these populations to examine long-term fluctuations. In Saldanha Bay and Langebaan Lagoon, standing stock of G. gracilis was estimated at 538 tons fresh weight and 71 tons fresh weight respectively. Less than 4 tons of gracilarioids are estimated to remain in St Helena Bay. We discuss the fluctuations in biomass and distribution of these South African gracilarioid populations.     

Phycological research in the development of the Chinese seaweed industry

The term seaweed industry is employed in a broad sense and includes production both of commercial seaweeds such as Laminaria and Porphyra by phycoculture and of processed seaweed products, such as algin, agar and carrageenan.Before the founding of the People's Republic, China had a very insignificant seaweed industry, producing small quantities of the purple laver Porphyra and the glueweed Gloiopeltis by the primitive rock-cleaning method and the kelps Laminaria and Undaria by the primitive stone-throwing method, both aiming at enhancing the growth of the wild seaweeds. Also, a small quantity of agar was manufactured by the traditional Japanese method of gelling, freezing, thawing and drying the product. The small production was not sufficient to meet the demand of the Chinese people who for ages have appreciated seaweeds and their products for food. Therefore, large quantities of seaweeds and seaweed products had to be imported from various countries, for instance, Eucheuma and Gracilaria from Indonesia and other southeastern Asian countries, Laminaria and agar from Japan, even Porphyra from the USA. Annual Laminaria import from Japan generally amounted to over 10 000 tons and in some years approached 20 000–30 000 tons. Some quantities of the glueweed Gloiopeltis and the vermifuge weed Digenea simplex were exported, mainly to Japan.Since the founding of the People's Republic of China in October, 1949, China has exerted efforts to build up a self-supporting seaweed industry. Now after a lapse of 30-some years, a sizable seaweed industry has been developed. China is now able to produce by phycoculture more than one million tons of fresh seaweeds, including Laminaria, Undaria, Porphyra, Eucheuma, Gracilaria etc. and several thousand tons of seaweed extracts, including algin, agar, carrageenan, mannitol and iodine. At present, China still imports some quantities of seaweeds and seaweed products from various countries but is able to produce sufficient quantities to meet the people's need and even to export some quantities of the seaweeds Laminaria, Undaria and Porphyra and the seaweed products algin and mannitol.At the Tenth International Seaweed Symposium, I presented a paper on the Marine Phycoculture of China, in which I emphasized on the methods of cultivation (Tseng 1981b). Therefore I would like to take this opportunity to supplement the last lecture by presenting a paper on the role of phycological research in the development of China's seaweed industry.     

Environmental variation and large-scale Gracilaria production

Temporal and spatial abiotic variation in seaweed farms should be anticipated to maximize production through alternative exploitation strategies. This study describes the basic assumptions and the most relevant data used to empirically develop a production model aimed at improving prediction and increasing production of Gracilaria farms in northern Chile. Continuous light and temperature recordings since 1986 have allowed us to relate abiotic variations with high production seasons of Gracilaria or with the presence of pests and epiphytes. Much of the interannual variations in light and temperature appear as part of a predictable pattern of change between ENSO (El Niño/Southern Oscillation) and inter-ENSO years. Production has been found to be a function of stock density and harvesting frequency, two parameters that can be effectively manipulated in the field. Thus, the range of climatic change now can be anticipated to some extent which, in turn, suggests the best farming strategy. During seasons or growth periods anticipated to be highly productive, farming activities are oriented to maintain high percentage removal of the stock through frequent harvesting. During seasons anticipated to be low in production, activities are oriented to prevent biomass losses due to the blooms of epiphytes and pests and to secure stocks to renew through planting the damaged parts of the beds after the blooms.     

Growth rates and agar properties of three gracilarioids in suspended open-water cultivation in St. Helena Bay, South Africa

Relative growth rates (RGRs), yields and agar characteristics of threegracilarioid isolates (Gracilariopsis sp. from St. Helena Bay, and Gracilaria gracilis isolates from Langebaan Lagoon and Saldanha Bay) weremeasured to assess the suitability of a site in St. Helena Bay for suspendedcultivation. The gracilarioids were grown on polypropylene ropes and`netlon' lines, and the RGRs were 4.0–11.0% d<sup>-1</sup> and 5.0–7.0%d<sup>-1</sup>, respectively. The RGR of the Langebaan isolate of G. gracilis grown on ropes was significantly higher than the RGR of otherisolates. The mean net yield for the Langebaan isolate grown on `netlon'lines was 2.6 ± 0.9 kg wet wt m^-2 30 day^-1. Thecultured gracilarioids were extracted for native and alkali treated agars. Themean native agar yield over the entire period was 39.0% dry wt. Alkalipretreatment reduced the yield by 55%, but significantly increased gelstrength. High gel strengths (>750 g cm^-2) were measured inagars from Gracilariopsis sp. and Saldanha Gracilaria gracilis inmid-summer and winter. The dynamic gelling and melting temperatures ofnative and alkali treated agars varied among the gracilarioids. The meangelling and melting temperatures of agars were about 39.0 ^°C and86.0 ^°C, respectively. The 3,6-AG content ranged from 29% to38% for native agars and 34–45% for alkali treated agars. While theseresults indicate that this site is suitable for gracilarioid cultivation, occasionallow-oxygen events in St. Helena Bay lead to production of hydrogensulphide in the sea water (`black tides'). Such events killed most inshorebiota (including seaweeds) in 1994 and 1998. This frequency (on average1–2 per decade) and duration (maximum 2 weeks) would have to beconsidered in planning commercial seaweed farming in St. Helena Bay.     

Cultivation of Gracilaria in outdoor tanks and ponds

This review deals with the major problems of unattached Gracilaria intensive cultivation in outdoor tanks and ponds. These problems are presented through the main variables affecting the Gracilaria annual yield and the updated solutions evolved. The physical variables include tank and pond structure, seawater characteristics such as velocity, agitation practice, exchange rate, and salinity, light characteristics such as quantity and quality, and temperature modelling. The chemical variables include nutrient composition and regime of application, and inorganic carbon supply with the pH changes involved. The biological variables include seaweed density, epiphyte competition, grazer damage, bacterial disintegration, integrated mariculture and strain selection. The experience gained in the Israeli research on Gracilaria cultivation is discussed in view of other Gracilaria and seaweed intensive cultivation research.     

The presence of gigartinine in a New Zealand Gracilaria species

Gigartinine, 5-(3-amidinoureido)-2-aminovaleric acid, serves as achemotaxonomic marker to distinguish two species of Gracilaria withvery similar morphologies. Gigartinine was identified by ¹³C-NMRspectroscopy and amino acid analysis of a cold-water extract from Gracilaria sp. nov., collected from a sheltered harbour localityat Blockhouse Bay, Auckland, New Zealand. Levels of this amino acid,naturally ca. 5% by dry weight of seaweed, were able to be depleted andthen restored during a nitrogen pulsing experiment. In contrast, native andpulsed samples of Gracilaria chilensis from Point Arthur, Wellingtonshowed no extractable gigartinine. Although these two species are unableto be distinguished in the field by morphological characteristics, they canbe separated by the presence or absence of gigartinine.     

Advances in Seaweed Aquaculture Among Pacific Island Countries

Recent developments in the seaweed aquaculture industries of Pacific islands are reviewed from the perspective of technical, production, geographic, marketing, species-diversification, socio-economic and institutional-support advances. Successful commercial aquaculture of seaweeds in the Pacific island region is presently based on two species, Kappaphycus alvarezii in Kiribati, Fiji and Solomon Islands, and Cladosiphon sp. in Tonga. It is possible that other candidate species could be considered for aquaculture for food (e.g. Caulerpa racemosa or Meristotheca procumbens) or extraction of agar (Gracilaria), although further research on the technical feasibility of aquaculture methods to produce sufficient tonnage, and particularly on their marketing, is needed. While the Pacific island region may be environmentally ideal for seaweed aquaculture, the limitations of distance from main centres and distance from markets, vulnerability to world price fluctuations, and socio-economic issues, make it unlikely that the Pacific Island region will ever rival the scale of Asian seaweed production. Regional seaweed farming can nevertheless make a useful contribution to supplement other sources of income, and can be an important economic boost for isolated outer islands where few alternative income-generating opportunities exist.     

Application of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Gracilaria lichenoides</Emphasis> (Rhodophyta) for alleviating excess nutrients in aquaculture

A study was conducted in Xiangshan Bay, Ningbo, China, using red alga Gracilaria lichenoides to alleviate nutrient pollution in shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei) and fish (Epinephelus awoara) culture ponds. Our results showed that G. lichenoides was efficient at absorbing inorganic nitrogen (IN) and inorganic phosphate (IP), and maintained a more stable dissolved oxygen (DO) level. A total of 506.5 kg (1,013 kg ha⁻¹) of shrimp and 210.5 kg (421 kg ha⁻¹) of fish were harvested from the shrimp/algae (SA) and fish/algae (FA) ponds, respectively. Only 53.5 kg shrimp were harvested from the shrimp pond without Gracilaria (S) due to anoxic asphyxia, and 163 kg fish were harvested from the fish culture pond without Gracilaria (F). Compared with using microalgae, bioremediation by macroalgae has no risk of harmful algal blooms (HABs), and it is easy to control seaweed biomass. During the experiment, there was a better environmental condition (lower chemical oxygen demand, IN, IP and chlorophyll a concentrations) in the ponds with Gracilaria. Furthermore, Gracilaria spp. can be used as food for abalone or other aquacultured animals and thus enhance economic return.     

Eutrophication assessment and bioremediation strategy in a marine fish cage culture area in Nansha Bay,China

On the basis of field data measured during four cruises from January to November 2007, variations in the characteristics of dissolved inorganic nitrogen and phosphate were analyzed in Nansha marine fish cage culture area, Ningbo City, China. Dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) was selected as the parameter to balance seaweed absorption and fish DIN production. The contents of DIN and phosphate varied with different seasons, and eutrophication index (E) value ranged from 2.41 to 15.99, indicating serious eutrophication conditions; the annual average value of N/P of 32.95 indicates a nitrogen surplus in this system. The eutrophication condition in Nansha Bay was mainly caused by the fish cage culture activities. Based on their biological characteristics, Laminaria and Gracilaria were selected as the bioremediation species in winter and spring and summer and autumn, respectively. The optimal co-cultivation proportion of fish cage to Laminaria and Gracilaria in this bay was 1 cage, 450 m² and one cage, 690 m², respectively.     

Recent trends of seaweed production in Chile

In the last fourteen years the production of seaweeds in Chile has ranged from 74 000 to 229 000 wet metric tons per year and has included about twenty species belonging to Phaeophyta and Rhodophyta. The only source of this production has been the exploitation of natural beds, except for Gracilaria, which is the only case of commercial cultivation and contributes significant quantities to total production. Initially most of the raw material was exported but currently important quantities of Gracilaria and several carrageenophytes are being processed by local industry. Changes in production of the main resources are analyzed with consideration of potential demand, level of knowledge about natural beds, and the situation of total Gracilaria farming, in order to attempt predictions for the supply. Current possibilities of applying new technologies to cultivate other economically important Chilean seaweeds are also analyzed and discussed.     

Effects of stock loading and planting distance on the growth and production ofGracilaria chilensis in rope culture

Through experimental manipulation of stock loading and planting distances in rope culture, this study evaluates the hypothesis that optimum density for growth and production ofGracilaria chilensis vary within a bed. Small packages ofGracilaria disposed at short distances exhibit higher growth and production rates in the landward ends of ropes than larger packages of seaweed disposed at longer distances. In these experiments, the landward end of ropes faces estuarine conditions, with reduced salinities and increased sediment loads during low tides. The interacting effects of stocks loading and position in the rope can affect growth and production rates so much as to nullify the 3.5-fold summer increments in production that occur in these estuarine beds of southern Chile. It is concluded that through manipulation of planting distances and stock loading, the production of this species could be increased up to 35% in some areas.     

Experimental investigations for the mariculture ofGracilaria in Saldanha bay,South Africa

Rope rafts were used to evaluate the growth of localGracilaria gracilis at Saldanha Bay, on the west coast of South Africa, over four years. The plants were grown on horizontally-suspended ropes or netting lines. Relative Growth Rates (RGR) of plants on ropes with low stocking weights often exceeded 10% d^–1 in (austral) summer, and fell to between 6 and 7.5% d^–1 in winter. Commercial-style lines of plastic netting stocked at 400 g m^–1 and placed 0.75 m apart yielded a mean of about 2 kg m^–2 30 d^–1, with a mean RGR of about 5% d^–1 over a two-year period. Various methods of improving yields were tested, including attaching floats to individual lines and optimising stocking weight. In Saldanha Bay in late summer, warm, oligotrophic water can severely reduce growth. Growth was optimised by growing the plants as close as possible to the surface (0.2 m), where water motion, and by implication, nutrient uptake, are higher. Agar content and gel strength generally remained high all year round. The potential for commercial production is evaluated in the light of these results.     

Experimental tank cultivation of Gracilaria sp. (Gracilariales,Rhodophyta) in Ecuador

This paper describes experiments to grow a local and still unidentified species of Gracilaria in shrimp hatcheries in Ecuador. The experiments used outdoor tanks of 1 and 18 m³ capacity, with continuous aeration and water renewal every two and five days, respectively. The sea water (salinity 34 ppt) was enriched with Guillard's f/2 medium; light and temperature were monitored but not controlled. One kg of fresh seaweed, inoculated into each tank, produced a biomass of ca. 3 kg in a period of 35 days in the 1 m3 tank and 18 kg in 43 days in the 18 m³ tank. We therefore believe that it is technically feasible to use the large infrastructure of existing shrimp hatcheries in Ecuador to produce Gracilaria.     

World-wide use and importance of Gracilaria

The world's first source of agar, from the middle of the seventeenth century, was Gelidium from Japan, but by the beginning of the twentieth century demand for the phycocolloid exceeded of the supply of this alga. Since then Gracilaria has played an important role in the production of agar. Currently agars are obtained from five genera in three orders of red algae and marketed as ‘natural agar’ in squares or strips or as ‘industrial agar’ in powder form. The development of production processes through alkaline hydrolysis of sulphates has allowed a good quality food agar to be obtained from Gracilaria. This does not show the synergistic reaction with locust bean gum apparent with Gelidium agar. The term ‘agaroids’ is applied to Gracilaria agars produced without alkaline hydrolysis of sulphates, with greater sulphate content and much less gel strength. Unlike Gelidium, Gracilaria has to be processed in a short period of time and cannot be allowed to remain in storage for use during years of lower availability. Statistics of imports of agarophytes to Japan during the last 10 years give an indication of the state of the market. During this period there was a marked reduction in Gracilaria imports, mainly from Chile, but also the Philippines, Indonesia and South Africa, mainly due to the overall increase in the capacity of agar production in Gracilaria-producing countries.     

Recent status of Gracilaria cultivation in Taiwan

The recent decrease in Gracilaria culture production and value in Taiwan were evaluated from statistical data and from interviews with local fishermen. Reasons are: 1) during 1986–87, many Gracilaria culture ponds were transformed to grow grass shrimp (Penaeus monodon) in monoculture, but disease of the shrimp occurring soon after stopped such production and Gracilaria culture took over, but 2) due to manpower shortage, Gracilaria-farmers prefer to sell their crops to abalone farmers and not to agar factories. Since Gracilaria as abalone feed is cheeper than for agar production, the value of algal crop decreased.     

Occurrence of Polysiphonia Epiphytes in Kappaphycus Farms at Calaguas Is., Camarines Norte, Phillippines

This paper describes the occurrence of an epiphyte infestation of Kappaphycus farms in Calaguas Is. Camarines Norte, Philippines. In particular, percentage cover of ‘goose bump’-Polysiphonia and ‘ice-ice’ disease, and some environmental parameters that influence the thallus condition of Kappaphycus alvarezii in Calaguas Is. were assessed during 3 separate visits and are discussed.Commercial cultivation of Kappaphycus at Calaguas Is. began in the early 1990s. After five years of farming, the stock was destroyed by a strong typhoon. The area was re-planted the following year and production increased annually and reached its peak in 1998–1999. However, the following year, the first occurrence of a Polysiphonia epiphyte infestation occurred concurrently with an ‘ice-ice’ disease. Consequently, annual production and the number of seaweed planters declined rapidly, and this situation persists to the present time. This paper highlights the etiological factors and their consequences.Results show that farm-site selection is critical for the success of Kappaphycus production. Characteristics of water movement and light intensity in farming areas contributed to the occurrence and detrimental effect of the phenomenon described as ‘goose bumps’: a morphological distortion of the host seaweed due to the presence of a Polysiphonia sp. epiphyte. A strong inverse correlation was observed between the occurrence of Polysiphonia and water movement: areas with low water motion registered a higher % cover (65%) of Polysiphonia than those in more exposed areas (17%). Although ‘goose bump’-Polysiphonia infestation and ‘ice-ice’ disease pose a tremendous problem to the seaweed farmers, the results of this limited assessment provide a useful baseline for future work.     

An overview of seaweed resources in Chile

The seaweed harvest in Chile has doubled during the past decade, and export values have increased by 300% because of diversification and increase in the volume of products with greater value added. The export value of seaweed products increased from US $18 million in 1980 to $52 million in 1991. During the past decade, the successful cultivation of Gracilaria was implemented, and this has compensated for the large decrease in yields from natural beds. In the short term, it will be necessary to develop techniques for the cultivation of other resources such as Iridaea, Gigartina, Lessonia and Gelidium. Alternative biotechnological methods must also be developed, such as the use of Gracilaria strains with increased quality and production for growth in cultivation centers.     

The role of herbivores in the collapse of the Gracilaria resource at Saldanha Bay,South Africa

At Saldanha bay on the west coast of South Africa, annual yields of beach-cast Gracilaria often exceeded 1000 metric tons, until the construction of an ore jetty and breakwater in 1974. Yields were then drastically reduced, recovered to 429 tons in 1988, then fell to zero. Diving surveys revealed a steady decline in the biomass of the remaining beds from 50 t in April to less than 1 t in August 1989. The presence of large numbers of herbivores suggested that grazing was the cause. This hypothesis was tested by experimental exclusions of fish and/or invertebrate herbivores (keyhole limpets and sea urchins). Results show that grazing by the fish in shallow water and the keyhole limpets and urchins in deep water prevented recovery of the resource and may have caused the initial decline.     

Interaction mechanisms between Gracilaria chilensis (Rhodophyta) and epiphytes

Epiphytes can have a considerable effect on Gracilaria production, and Ulva is one of the commonest algal species identified as an epiphyte, reaching loads of 60% (g of epiphytes per g of Gracilaria) in the intertidal cultures of southern Chile. This study evaluates the relative importance of light reduction, addition of weight to the host thalli and nutrient depletion, as mechanisms determining the interaction effects of Ulva epiphytes on Gracilaria cultivation. Using field experiments undertaken during the main Gracilaria growth season (spring), we evaluate the mechanisms of epiphyte-host algae interaction by manipulating artificial epiphytes. The results indicate that Ulva can significantly depress Gracilaria biomass production and that the addition of weight to the host algae and the consequent dislodgement increase, appear to be the main mechanisms involved in the Ulva-Gracilaria interaction. However, the light reduction caused by the epiphytes can also partially explain the reduction in Gracilaria production. Nutrients depletion would not appear to fully account for the detrimental effects of Ulva over Gracilaria in intertidal farming areas of southern Chile.