Developmental anatomy and ultrastructure of early somatic embryos in European black pine (Pinus nigra Arn.)

Summary Embryogenic callus cultures of European black pine (Pinus nigra Arn.) were established on megagametophytes containing zygotic embryos in early developmental stage. In addition to many elongated cells and disorganized growing clumps they contained early somatic embryos at various stages of development. At all stages of embryogenesis the embryos were organized as bipolar structures. Cell pairs composed of one isodiametric cell with dense cytoplasm and a second large vacuolated cell were the simplest bipolar system. The vacuolated cell underwent senescence. The cytoplasm-rich cell and its derivates divided transversally, resulting in several cytoplasmic cells arranged in row. An early embryonal cylindrical mass was formed by longitudinal division of the cells in a filament. Proximally localized cells in the early embryonal mass became vacuolized and elongated gradually giving rise to the secondary suspensor. Distal cells remained cytoplasmic in character and formed an embryonal mass along the axis of long early somatic embryos. Differences in the proportion of organelles and heterochromatin clumps, thickness of cell walls and number of plasmodesmata between cells at various stages of early somatic embryogenesis were described.     

Recovery of somatic embryos and plantlets from protoplast cultures of Larix × eurolepis

Summary Somatic embryos and plantlets were regenerated from protoplasts of hybrid larch (Larix × eurolepis) isolated from two embryogenic callus and cell suspension culture lines (L1 and L2). L2, which was highly embryogenic, consistently yielded protoplasts that gave rise to somatic embryos. Centrifugation on a discontinuous medium/Percoll density gradient resulted in accumulation of embryogenic protoplasts in one of the Percoll interfaces. First division frequencies were in the range of 28–39% in line 1 and 18–20% in line 2 in both liquid and agarose-solidified culture media. The critical factor in maintaining high viability of cultures was lowering of osmotic pressure by dilution of the initial medium. The first somatic embryos were detected in 23- to 28-day-old cultures. Some of these developed into plants that were transferred to soil.     

Differences in protodermal cell wall structure in zygotic and somatic embryos of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Daucus carota</Emphasis> (L.) cultured on solid and in liquid media

The ultrastructure, cuticle, and distribution of pectic epitopes in outer periclinal walls of protodermal cells of Daucus carota zygotic and somatic embryos from solid and suspension culture were investigated. Lipid substances were present as a continuous layer in zygotic and somatic embryos cultured on solid medium. Somatic embryos from suspension cultures were devoid of cuticle. The ultrastructure of the outer walls of protodermis of embryos was similar in zygotic and somatic embryos from solid culture. Fibrillar material was observed on the surface of somatic embryos. In zygotic embryos, in cotyledons and root pectic epitopes recognised by the antibody JIM5 were observed in all cell walls. In hypocotyls of these embryos, these pectic epitopes were not present in the outer periclinal and anticlinal walls of the protodermis. In somatic embryos from solid media, distribution of pectic epitopes recognised by JIM5 was similar to that described for their zygotic counterparts. In somatic embryos from suspension culture, pectic epitopes recognised by JIM5 were detected in all cell walls. In the cotyledons and hypocotyls, a punctate signal was observed on the outside of the protodermis. Pectic epitopes recognised by JIM7 were present in all cell walls independent of embryo organs. In zygotic embryos, this signal was punctate; in somatic embryos from both cultures, this signal was uniformly distributed. In embryos from suspension cultures, a punctate signal was detected outside the surface of cotyledon and hypocotyl. These data are discussed in light of current models for embryogenesis and the influence of culture conditions on cell wall structure.     

Secondary embryogenesis in androgenic embryo cultures of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Aesculus hippocastanum</Emphasis> L.

Secondary somatic embryos appeared on the cotyledons and radiculi of embryos derived from suspension and anther cultures of Aesculus hippocastanum L. The highest number of secondary somatic embryos formed on a hormone-free medium.This work was supported by the Ministry of Science and Environment Protection of Serbia, grant N₀. 1573.     

Plant regeneration via somatic embryogenesis from protoplasts of six explants in Coker 201 (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Gossypium hirsutum</Emphasis>)

Fertile regenerated plants were obtained from protoplasts via somatic embryogenesis in Coker 201 (Gossypium hirsutum L.). Protoplasts were isolated from six different explantsleaves, hypocotyls, young roots, embryogenic callus, immature somatic embryos and suspension cultures and cultured in liquid thin layer KM8P medium. Callus-forming percentage of 20–50% was obtained in protoplast cultures from embryogenic callus, immature embryos and suspension cultures, and visible callus formed within 2 months. Callus-forming percentage of 5–20% in protoplast cultures from young roots, hypocotyls and leaves, and visible callus formed in 3 months. NAA 5.371 μM/kinetin 0.929 μM was effective to stimulate protoplast division and callus formation from six explants. Percentage of callus formation in the medium with 2,4-D 0.452 μM/kinetin 0.465 μM was over 40% from suspension cultures and immature embryos, 25% from embryogenic callus and 10% from hypocotyls. Callus from protoplasts developed into plantlets via somatic embryogenesis. Over 100 plantlets were obtained from protoplasts derived from 6 explants. Ten plants have been transferred to the soil, where they all have set seeds.     

Biological characterization of young and aged embryogenic cultures of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus pinaster</Emphasis> (Ait.)

Pinus pinaster (Ait.) somatic embryogenesis (SE) has been developed during the last decade, and its application in tree improvement programs is underway. Nevertheless, a few more or less important problems still exist, which have an impact on the efficiency of specific SE stages. One phenomenon, which had been observed in embryogenic tissue (embryonal mass, EM) initiated from immature seed, has been the loss of the ability to produce mature somatic embryos after the tissue had been cultured for several months. In an attempt to get insight into the differences between young cultures of EM (3-mo-old since the first subculture) of P. pinaster that produced mature somatic embryos and the same lines of significantly increased age (18-mo-old, aged EM) that stopped producing mature somatic embryos, we analyzed in both types of materials the levels of endogenous hormones, polyamines, the global DNA methylation, and associated methylation patterns. In addition, we included in the analysis secondary EM induced from mature somatic embryos. The analysis showed that the two tested genotypes displayed inconsistent hormonal and polyamine profiles in EM cultures of a similar phenotype and that it might be difficult to attribute one specific profile to a specific culture phenotype among genotypes. Experiments were also undertaken to determine if the global DNA methylation and/or the resulting methylation pattern could be manipulated by treatment of the cultures with a hypomethylating drug 5-azacytidine (5-azaC). An aged EM was exposed to different concentrations and durations of 5-azaC, and its response in culture was established by fresh mass increases and somatic embryo maturation potential. All of the analyses are new in maritime pine, and thus, they provide the first data on the biochemistry of EM in this species related to embryogenic potential.     

Efficient and stable regeneration from protoplasts of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cyclamen coum</Emphasis> Miller via somatic embryogenesis

Embryogenic cultures of Cyclamen coum were established on solid media and in suspension, and their growth characteristics in response to different concentrations of plant growth regulators (PGRs) were evaluated. Embryogenic cultures exhibited a high regeneration capacity of 876 somatic embryos per gram fresh mass. Up to 4.24 × 10⁵ protoplasts per gram of fresh mass were isolated from somatic embryos and embryogenic suspension cultures. Protoplasts derived from both embryos and suspension cultures were successfully cultured in vitro and regenerated into plants via somatic embryogenesis. Phenotypic analyses and flow cytometric measurements revealed that some regenerated plants were tetraploid. About 20% of the protoplast-derived calluses used for regeneration were tetraploid, while tetraploidy was found in 0.9% of the plants regenerated from the embryogenic cultures.     

AtSERK1 expression precedes and coincides with early somatic embryogenesis in Arabidopsis thaliana.

The Arabidopsis thaliana primordia timing (pt) mutant was transformed with an AtSERK1::GUS construct. Liquid cultures of this line were used to study the relationship between somatic embryogenesis and the expression of SOMATIC EMBRYOGENESIS RECEPTOR-LIKE KINASE (AtSERK1) as a marker for cells competent to form embryos. In order to search for the expression of AtSERK1::GUS during early stages of somatic embryogenesis, histochemical as well as immunochemical approaches were used for the detection of beta-glucuronidase (GUS). Four sites of AtSERK1 expression were found in the embryogenic cultures: in embryogenic callus, where primary somatic embryos developed; in the basal parts of primary somatic embryos; in the outer layers of cotyledons of primary somatic embryos where secondary embryos were formed; and in provascular and vascular strands of developing somatic embryos. The in vitro expression of AtSERK1::GUS coincides with embryogenic development up to the heart-shaped stage. Prior to the expression in embryos, AtSERK1 was expressed in single cells and small cell clusters, indicating that AtSERK1 indeed marks embryogenic competence. Its expression in (pro)vascular strands, suggests that embryogenic cells in tissue culture retain at least in part their original identity.     

Origin of somatic embryos from repetitively embryogenic cultures of walnut (Juglans regia L.): Implications forAgrobacterium-mediated transformation

Early stages of somatic embryo development from embryogenic cultures ofJuglans regia (Persian or English walnut) are described. Histological examination reveals that secondary somatic embryos arise from cotyledons and hypocotyls of primary embryos cultured in the dark. The embryos originate by transverse to oblique divisions of surface cells. Single-cell origin of the secondary embryos confirms the potential of the repetitive embryogenesis system forAgrobacterium-mediated transformation and regeneration of non-chimeric, transgenic walnut plants.     

High-frequency plant regeneration through cyclic secondary somatic embryogenesis in black pepper (Piper nigrum L.)

A high-frequency plantlet regeneration protocol was developed for black pepper (Piper nigrum L.) through cyclic secondary somatic embryogenesis. Secondary embryos formed from the radicular end of the primary somatic embryos which were originally derived from micropylar tissues of germinating seeds on growth regulator-free SH medium in the absence of light. The process of secondary embryogenesis continued in a cyclic manner from the root pole of newly formed embryos resulting in clumps of somatic embryos. Strength of the medium and sucrose concentration influenced the process of secondary embryogenesis and fresh weight of somatic embryo clumps. Full-strength SH medium supplemented with 1.5% sucrose produced significantly higher fresh weight and numbers of secondary somatic embryos while 3.0 and 4.5% sucrose in the medium favored further development of proliferated embryos into plantlets. Ontogeny of secondary embryos was established by histological analysis. Secondary embryogenic potential was influenced by the developmental stage of the explanted somatic embryo and stages up to “torpedo” were more suitable. A single-flask system was standardized for proliferation, maturation, germination and conversion of secondary somatic embryos in suspension cultures. The system of cyclic secondary somatic embryogenesis in black pepper described here represents a permanent source of embryogenic material that can be used for genetic manipulations of this crop species.     

Evidence for somatic embryogenesis during plant regeneration from seedling-derived callus of dodder (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Cuscuta trifolii</Emphasis> Bab. et Gibs)

 In this paper comparative histological studies of embryo-like structures originating from callus cultures, and zygotic embryos originating from sexual seeds of Cuscuta trifolii are reported. The embryos of somatic cell and zygote origin showed similar morphological and anatomical features, such as a complete lack of cotyledon development and the differentiation of a developmentally unique root primordium specialised for water storage. Based on these findings, the regeneration of C. trifolii from callus cultures is shown to proceed along the pathway of somatic embryogenesis. Received: 9 November 1998 / Revision received: 22 April 1999 / Accepted: 29 June 1999     

Secondary somatic embryogenesis versus caulogenesis from somatic embryos of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Aesculus carnea</Emphasis> Hayne.: developmental stage impact

Somatic embryos of red horse chestnut, derived from cultures maintained through repetitive somatic embryogenesis for a few years, were subjected to induction of secondary regeneration. The embryos were divided in four classes on the basis of their size (I-1, II-5, III-10 and IV-30 mm), and sub-cultured on MS media containing 0, 1, 5 or 10 μM kinetin (Kin) or benzyladenine (BA). The pathway of secondary regeneration, somatic embryogenesis or caulogenesis, depended on the primary somatic embryo (PSE) stage of development. The embryogenic capacity declined and bud-forming capacity increased with the degree of PSE maturity. The PSE of the Classes I and II produced only secondary somatic embryos (SSE), the Class III PSE formed both SSE and adventitious buds, whereas the Class IV PSE developed almost solely adventitious buds. The process of secondary somatic embryogenesis was most effective in the Class II PSE at 5 μM BA, and the process of adventive organogenesis was most effective in the Class IV PSE at 10 μM BA. On plant growth regulator (PGR)-free medium, PSE of A. carnea followed the same pattern of adventive regeneration, as those cultured on cytokinin containing media. The cytokinins only amplified the response, in a certain range of concentrations. BA promoted bud induction at a much higher rate than Kin, while their embryogenic effect was similar.     

Somatic embryogenesis and plantlet regeneration from cotyledon explants isolated from emblings and seedlings of hybrid firs

Embryogenic tissues have been initiated on cotyledon explants dissected from seedlings or emblings of hybrid firs. Cotyledons of seedling origin (Abies alba x A. cephalonica) gave a relatively low initiation frequency (1.94 percnt;). In embling-derived cotyledons (Abies alba x A. cephalonica, Abies alba x A. numidica), the initiation was cell-line dependent and reached values between 1.25 and 24.28 percnt;. The established embryogenic cell lines are being maintained in long-term cultures.The origin and development of the somatic embryos have been traced histologically. The early stages of somatic embryo development have been characterised by cell division activity (predominantly periclinal) in the epidermal and subepidermal layers of cotyledons and subsequently by development of nodular structures. Further differentiation led to the formation and emergence of somatic embryos on the surface of cotyledons.Somatic embryo development and plantlet regeneration occurred from proliferating tissues initiated from cotyledons of embling as well as seedling origin.     

Analysis of the genetic stability of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Eucalyptus globulus</Emphasis> Labill. somatic embryos by flow cytometry

Flow cytometry was used to measure the nuclear DNA content of Eucalyptus globulus Labill. somatic and zygotic embryos and leaves in order to determine if somatic embryogenesis induces DNA content and ploidy changes in this species. Mature zygotic embryos derived from open-pollination orchard families were collected from a location in the centre of Portugal. One group was kept for nuclear DNA content and ploidy analysis, and the other group was used for establishing embryogenic cultures. Mature zygotic embryos were grown on Murashige and Skoog (MS) medium supplemented with 3% (w/v) sucrose and 3 mg l^–1 -naphthaleneacetic acid (NAA) for 3 weeks and then transferred to MS medium without growth regulators. Globular somatic embryos from approximately 8-month-old embryogenic cultures were used in the assay. DNA ploidy levels and the nuclear DNA content of mature zygotic embryos, somatic embryos and leaves from the mother field tree were determined using flow cytometry combined with propidium iodide staining. Zygotic embryos had a nuclear DNA content of 1.32 pg/2C, somatic embryos had a nuclear DNA content of 1.39 pg/2C and leaves from the field tree had a nuclear DNA content of 1.40 pg/2C. The values estimated for the somatic embryos and mother plant did not differ statistically from each other (P0.05), but both differed from those of the zygotic embryos (P0.05). These results clearly indicate that no changes were induced during the embryogenic process. However, the differences found between the field plants and zygotic embryos did suggest that some aspects must be evaluated carefully, as propidium iodide fluorescence may potentially be influenced by the presence of secondary compounds (e.g. anthocyanins, tannins) in E. globulus somatic embryos and mature leaves. Therefore we believe that the somatic embryogenesis methodology used did not induce major genetic changes in the somatic embryos and that our primary goal of true-to-type propagation was assured.     

Primary and repetitive secondary somatic embryogenesis of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Lepidosperma drummondii</Emphasis> (Cyperaceae) and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Baloskion tetraphyllum</Emphasis> (Restionaceae) for land restoration and horticulture

Somatic embryogenesis was developed as a method of mass propagation for Lepidosperma drummondii (Cyperaceae), a difficult to propagate but important species for post-mining restoration in a region of high plant biodiversity, in the southwest of Western Australia. Cultures were initiated from excised zygotic embryos, shoot cultures to rhizomes. Only zygotic embryos of L. drummondii developed somatic embryos, with half strength Murashige and Skoog basal medium (BM) and 1 μM 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) being the most effective combination. The first culture cycle yielded a mean of 30 somatic embryos per excised zygotic embryo forming an embryo cluster. After a further 6 wk in culture (on fresh BM with 1 μM 2,4-D), approximately 350 somatic embryos per starting embryo cluster were recorded. Following regular sub-culturing of primary somatic embryo clusters onto fresh media (every 4 wk), more than 74,000 secondary somatic embryos were estimated to have been produced after eight subculture periods. This translates to between 1,000 and 2,000 somatic embryos produced from an estimated 45 mg of starting tissue per culture plate or potentially 22,0000–44,000 somatic embryos per gram of tissue. This is a significant improvement over all previous methods used to propagate L. drummondii, in which typical in vitro shoot multiplication rates are as low as 1.43 per 8 wk. This also compared favourably with published data and concurrent experiments undertaken in this study (as an extra control measure) on somatic embryo production for a related species Baloskion tetraphyllum (using the same BM with 1 μM 2,4-D and coleoptile segments as explants). Various media combinations were investigated for efficacy in converting somatic embryos into plants with best results ranging from 86% to 100% conversion for B. tetraphyllum on BM without plant growth regulators. Development of L. drummondii somatic embryos into plants was not observed on BM without plant growth regulators. However, a best result of 39% conversion to plants was observed on BM with 1 μM thidiazuron. This is the first report of successful development of somatic embryogenesis and conversion of somatic embryos into plants using thidiazuron for the Australian cyperale L. drummondii.     

Plate flooding as an alternative <Emphasis Type="Italic">Agrobacterium</Emphasis>-mediated transformation method for American chestnut somatic embryos

In an attempt to improve Agrobacterium-mediated transformation frequency of American chestnut somatic embryos, a novel method of inoculation/co-cultivation was developed. Plate flooding is a simple method where the Agrobacterium inoculum is poured onto the embryos while they remain on multiplication medium. This method tested the hypothesis that wounding tissues prior to co-cultivation was unnecessary or counterproductive. Two clones, WB296 and P1-1, were tested for differences in transformation efficiency as measured by the number of transformed embryogenic cell lines per Petri dish, the total number of transformed cell lines (embryos plus callus) and percentage of transformants that remained embryogenic. Plate flooding using clone WB296 produced significantly more transformed embryo cell lines and had a higher percentage of transformants remain embryogenic. The number of total transformed cell lines (embryos plus callus) was the same as obtained by other methods (desiccation, blot dry, sand abrasion, sonication and vacuum infiltration). With clone P1-1 there were no significant differences among the inoculation/co-cultivation treatments tested. Polymerase chain reaction and Southern hybridizations confirmed that the transgene of interest had been stably integrated into both American chestnut clones. Whole plants were regenerated from clone P1-1.     

AtLTP1 luciferase expression during carrot somatic embryogenesis

The carrot (Daucus carota L.) EP2 gene encodes a Lipid Transfer Protein (LTP) which is expressed during protoderm formation in developing embryos. To develop a vital reporter system for gene expression during somatic embryo development a 1.1 kB fragment of the Arabidopsis thaliana LTP1 promoter was fused to the firefly luciferase (LUC) coding sequence. The AtLTP1 luciferase expression pattern in transformed carrot suspension cultures was identical to the expression pattern of the endogenous carrot EP2 gene. Cell tracking experiments revealed that all somatic embryos were derived from AtLTP1 luciferase expressing cell clusters. However, not all cell clusters that expressed the AtLTP1 luciferase reporter gene developed into a somatic embryo, suggesting that initiation of an embryogenic pathway in tissue culture does not always lead to development of a somatic embryo.     

Secondary somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration in cassava

Somatic embryos isolated from mature seed-derived cotyledon cultures of cassava (Mannihot esculenta Crantz) underwent direct secondary somatic embryogenesis or plant development under appropriate incubation conditions. Isolated somatic embryos were subjected to a two-stage culture procedure similar to that which induced their development on cotyledon explants. This involved incubation for 24–30 days on Murashige and Skoog basal medium supplemented with 2–8 mgl^-1 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) (Stage I medium) before transfer to medium supplemented with 0.01 mgl^-1 2,4-D and 0.1 mgl^-1 6-benzylamino purine (BAP) (Stage II medium). Under these conditions, secondary somatic embryos developed directly from the cotyledons and shoot-tip region of primary somatic embryos by a developmental process morphologically very similar to that occurring on zygotic cotyledon explants. Apical shoot extension and adventitious root formation occurred when somatic embryos were isolated from parental cultures and incubated on Stage II medium. Somatic embryo-derived plants growing in greenhouse conditions appeared morphologically normal when compared with non-regenerated plants.     

Indirect somatic embryogenesis and morphohistological analysis in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Capsicum chinense</Emphasis>

Capsicum chinense is recalcitrant in in vitro morphogenesis. No efficient, reproducible somatic embryogenesis regeneration system exists for this species, impeding regeneration from transformed cells. An indirect somatic embryogenesis protocol is developed using mature C. chinense zygotic embryo segments (ZES). The ZES cultured in semi-solid Murashige-Skoog (MS) medium supplemented with 8.9 μM naphthaleneacetic acid, 11.4 μM indoleacetic acid and 8.9 μM 6-benzylaminopurine, developed an embryogenic callus and 8% of the calli developed somatic embryos. Torpedo-stage somatic embryos were detached from the callus and subcultured in semi-solid MS medium without growth regulators, producing a 75% conversion rate to plantlets with well-formed root tissue. Histological analysis showed the developed structures to have no vascular connection with the callus and to be bipolar, confirming that this protocol induced formation of viable somatic embryos from mature C. chinense ZES. All acclimated plantlets survived under greenhouse conditions. This protocol will facilitate regeneration of genetically transformed plants using either biolistics or Agrobacterium tumefaciens approach.     

Growth regulators affect primary and secondary somatic embryogenesis in Madagaskar periwinkle (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Catharanthus roseus</Emphasis> (L.) G. Don) at morphological and biochemical levels

An efficient somatic embryogenesis system has been established in Catharanthus roseus (L.) G. Don in which primary and secondary embryogenic calluses were developed from hypocotyls and primary cotyledonary somatic embryos (PCSEs), respectively. Two types of calluses were different in morphology and growth behaviour. Hypocotyl-derived embryogenic callus (HEC) was friable and fast-growing, while secondary callus derived from PCSE was compact and slow-growing. HEC differentiated into somatic embryos which proliferated quickly on medium supplemented with NAA (1.0 mg l⁻¹) and BA (1.5 mg l⁻¹). Although differentiation and proliferation of somatic embryos were faster in primary HEC, maturation and germination efficiency were better in somatic embryos developed from primary cotyledonary somatic embryo-derived secondary embryogenic callus (PCSEC). At the biochemical level, two somatic embryogenesis systems were different. Both primary and secondary/adventive somatic embryogenesis and the role of plant growth regulators in two modes of somatic embryo formation have been discussed.