Selecting with markers linked to the PPVres major QTL is not sufficient to predict resistance to Plum Pox Virus (PPV) in apricot

Sharka is one of the most serious viral diseases affecting stone fruit species and, in apricot, resistance to its viral agent, the Plum Pox Virus (PPV), is conferred by one major quantitative trait locus (QTL), named PPVres for PPV resistance. Previous studies indicated that PPV-resistant cultivars and breeding progenies can be selected by using a set of SSR markers (named PGS) targeting the PPVres locus. However, before these markers can be employed for marker-assisted selection, they were validated in a wide range of genetic backgrounds and environments. We used a total of 11 mapping populations issued from three distinct environments to confirm that this marker set located within the QTL adequately predicted PPV resistance. In this study, we show that selection of PPV-resistant material based only on markers co-localizing with the PPVres major locus is not fully reliable. Indeed, genotype-phenotype discrepancies were observed depending on the progeny and the PPV-resistant/susceptible parents. While most of the PPV-resistant individuals displayed the resistant alleles, a significant number of PPV-susceptible individuals showed the same resistant haplotype. An effect of the PPV strain used for phenotyping was also demonstrated. We thus hypothesize that the presence of other factors or genes involved in the mechanism of resistance to sharka in apricot could explain these unexpected results. Our work indicates that the current PGS marker set is not broadly applicable for MAS and that marker-assisted breeding based on the sole PPVres locus is not sufficient to unambiguously select PPV-resistant apricot cultivars.     

Opportunities of marker-assisted selection for Plum pox virus resistance in apricot breeding programs

Evaluation of Plum pox virus (PPV) resistance is a laborious and expensive task, and the development of new accurate methods, including the use of molecular markers, would be very useful for breeding programs for resistance. In this work, the Plum pox virus resistance of 80 apricot genotypes of different genetic origins was evaluated in controlled greenhouse and natural field conditions. The genotypes for five simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers described as linked to PPV resistance were also determined. Depending on their behavior, cultivars were classified as resistant, susceptible, and uncertain, and the genotype was identified for each SSR linked to different phenotypes. Twenty genotypes were resistant and 37 susceptible in the greenhouse and in the field. However, 23 genotypes did not show clear behavior, probably due to the complex plant-virus interaction, so they were classified as uncertain. In general, results showed a narrow relationship between the SSRs PGS1.21 and PGS1.24, and resistance to PPV, although some genotypes did not show this relationship. Most of the susceptible genotypes did not show the alleles of resistance. Therefore, in most cases, marker-assisted selection (MAS) could be used as a means of screening new seedlings for early selection, making it possible to remove those that are susceptible. However, in certain cases, MAS using these markers has not proven to be completely effective. The origin of such discrepancies could be the presence of a second locus involved in PPV resistance. In addition, other factors affecting efficiency of MAS discussed in the work are the presence of null alleles and recombinant events. Resistant seedlings would have to be evaluated in greenhouse and natural conditions to confirm their actual behavior against PPV. From the breeding point of view, the use of homozygous resistant parents for the SSR resistance alleles, with good agronomic characteristics, would increase the efficiency of breeding programs, since all seedlings would be resistant regardless of the other parent. Finally, new molecular markers should be developed to accurately select resistant seedlings regardless of the resistant progenitors involved.     

Development of a high-resolution melting approach for reliable and cost-effective genotyping of PPVres locus in apricot (<Emphasis Type="Italic">P</Emphasis>. <Emphasis Type="Italic">armeniaca</Emphasis>)

Sharka, caused by plum pox virus, is the most important viral disease of stone fruits. Important progresses have been recently achieved in apricot (Prunus armeniaca), identifying a major locus on chromosome 1 which explains most of the variability for plum pox virus (PPV) resistance trait. A set of molecular markers associated with the resistance has been developed and validated in different genetic backgrounds, endorsing their application for breeding purposes. Particularly for complex traits as the PPV resistance, requiring long and expensive phenotyping procedures, marker-assisted selection (MAS) bears a great potential to improve the efficiency of conventional breeding. In this work, novel HRM (high-resolution melting) assays were designed for the genotyping of resistant/susceptible alleles at PPV resistance (PPVres) locus. The assays were tested on 51 apricot cultivars and breeding selections already phenotyped for PPV resistance and cross-validated with standard short simple repeat marker data. We demonstrated that three HRM assays, PGS1.21_SNP, PGS1.24_SNP, and ZP002_DEL, represent a reliable, quick, and cost-effective genotyping approach, particularly suitable as high-throughput screening method for large-scale breeding programs.     

Flanking the major Plum pox virus resistance locus in apricot with co-dominant markers (SSRs) derived from candidate resistance genes

Plum pox virus (PPV) is a potyvirus that causes sharka disease in infested stone fruit trees (Prunus species, peach, apricot, plum). In apricots, the resistance is controlled by a major quantitative trait locus that explains up to 70% of the phenotypic variance; it is localised in the upper part of linkage group 1. In this report, we transformed candidate genes that mapped in the region of the apricot resistance locus into polymerase chain reaction markers (SSCP and SSR) and tested for their co-localisation with the major PPV resistance locus in related and unrelated populations. Three populations of F1 and F2 individuals issued from crosses between the PPV-resistant cultivar ‘Stark Early Orange’ or ‘Goldrich’ and three susceptible parents were used in this study. Molecular-marker data were collected to determine the linkage relationship between the PPV resistance locus in apricots and markers that target candidate disease-resistance genes. In addition, SSR markers linked to resistance-gene candidates were mapped to positions flanking the PPV resistance locus in different apricot populations. Therefore, we demonstrate that this strategy helps to saturate the major genomic region controlling resistance to PPV in apricot with valuable co-dominant markers. O. Sicard and G. Marandel have contributed equally to this work.     

A genetic linkage map for an apricot (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Prunus armeniaca</Emphasis> L.) BC<Subscript>1</Subscript> population mapping <Emphasis Type="Italic">plum pox virus</Emphasis> resistance

Plum pox virus (sharka; PPV) can cause severe crop loss in economically important Prunus species such as peach, plum, apricot, and cherry. Of these species, certain apricot cultivars (‘Stark Early Orange’, ‘Goldrich’, ‘Harlayne’) display significant levels of resistance to the disease and are the genetic substrate for studies of several xlaboratories working cooperatively to genetically characterize and mark the resistance locus or loci for marker-assisted breeding. The goals of the work presented in this communication are the characterization of the genetics of PPV resistance in ‘Stark Early Orange’ and the development of co-dominant molecular markers for marker-assisted selection (MAS) in PPV resistance breeding. We present the first genetic linkage map for an apricot backcross population of ‘Stark Early Orange’ and the susceptible cultivar ‘Vestar’ that segregates for resistance to PPV. This map is comprised of 357 loci (330 amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLPs), 26 simple sequence repeats (SSRs), and 1 morphological marker for PPV resistance) assigned to eight linkage groups. Twenty-two of the mapped SSRs are shared in common with genetic reference map for Prunus (T × E; Joobeur et al. 1998) and anchor our apricot map to the general Prunus map. A PPV resistance locus was mapped in linkage group 1 and four AFLP markers segregating with the PPV resistance trait, identified through bulk segregant analysis, facilitated the development of SSRs in this region. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Lalli, D.A. and Salava, J. contributed equally to this work.     

Comparative Analysis of SSR Markers Developed in Exon,Intron, and Intergenic Regions and Distributed in Regions Controlling Fruit Quality Traits in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Prunus</Emphasis> Species: Genetic Diversity and Association Studies

Simple sequence repeats (SSRs) are genome domains located in both coding and non-coding regions in eukaryotic genomes. Although SSRs are often characterized by low polymorphism, their DNA-flanking sequences could be a useful source of DNA markers, which could help in genetic studies and breeding because they are associated with genes that control traits of interest. In this study, 56 genotypes from different Prunus species were used, including peach, apricot, plum, and almond (already phenotyped for several agronomical traits, including self-compatibility, flowering and ripening time, fruit type, skin and flesh color, and shell hardness). These Prunus genotypes were molecularly characterized using 28 SSR markers developed in exons, introns, and intergenic regions. All these genes were located in specific regions where quantitative trait loci (QTLs) for certain fruit quality traits were also located, including flowering and ripening times and fruit flesh and skin color. A sum of 309 SSR alleles were identified in the whole panel of analyzed cultivars, with expected heterozygosity values of 0.61 (upstream SSRs), 0.17 (exonic SSRs), 0.65 (intronic SSRs), and 0.58 (downstream SSRs). These values prove the low level of polymorphism of the exonic (gene-coding regions) markers. Cluster and structural analysis based on SSR data clearly differentiated the genotypes according to either specie (for the four species) and pedigree (apricot) or geographic origin (Japanese plum). In addition, some SSR markers mainly developed in intergenic regions could be associated with genes that control traits of interest in breeding and could therefore help in marker-assisted breeding. These findings highlight the importance of using molecular markers able to discriminate between the functional roles of the gene allelic variants.     

Development of a new SSR-based linkage map in apricot and analysis of synteny with existing Prunus maps

Linkage maps of the apricot accessions ‘Lito’ and ‘BO 81604311’ were constructed using a total of 185 simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers sampled from those isolated in peach, almond, apricot and cherry; 74 were derived from a new apricot genomic library enriched for AG/CT microsatellite repeats (UDAp series), and in total, 98 had never been mapped in Prunus before. Eight linkage groups putatively corresponding to the eight haploid apricot chromosomes were identified for each parent. The two maps were 504 and 620 cM long, respectively, with 96 anchor markers showing a complete co-linearity between the two genomes. As few as three gaps larger than 15 cM were present in ‘Lito’ and six in the male parent; the maps align well with all the available SSR-based Prunus maps through the many common anchor loci. Only occasionally inverted positions between adjacent markers were found, and this can be explained by the small size of cross populations analysed in these Prunus maps and in those reported in literature. The newly developed apricot SSRs will help saturating the existing Prunus maps and will extend the choice of markers in the development of genetic maps for new breeding populations.     

Construction of genetic linkage maps and QTL mapping for X-disease resistance in tetraploid chokecherry (Prunus virginiana L.) using SSR and AFLP markers

Chokecherry (Prunus virginiana L.) (2n = 4x = 32) is a unique Prunus species for both genetics and disease resistance research due to its tetraploid nature and known variations in X-disease resistance. X-disease is a destructive disease of stone fruit trees, causing yield loss and poor fruit quality. However, genetic and genomic information on chokecherry is limited. In this study, simple sequence repeat (SSR) and amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers were used to construct genetic linkage maps and to identify quantitative trait loci (QTLs) associated with X-disease resistance in chokecherry. A segregating population (101 progenies) was developed by crossing an X-disease-resistant chokecherry line (RC) with a susceptible chokecherry line (SC). A total of 498 DNA markers (257 SSR and 241 AFLP markers) were mapped on the two genetic maps of the two parental lines (RC and SC). The map of RC contains 302 markers assigned to 14 linkage groups covering 2,089 cM of the genome. The map of SC has 259 markers assigned to 16 linkage groups covering 1,562.4 cM of the genome. The average distance between two markers was 6.9 cM for the RC map and 6.0 cM for the SC map. One QTL located on linkage group 15 on the map of SC was found to be associated with X-disease resistance. Genetic linkage maps and the identified QTL linked to X-disease resistance will further facilitate genetic research and breeding of X-disease resistance in chokecherry and other Prunus species.     

Population structure analysis and association mapping of bacterial blight resistance in <Emphasis Type="Italic">indica</Emphasis> rice (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Oryza sativa</Emphasis> L.) accessions

Bacterial blight, caused by Xanthomonas oryzae pv. oryzae (Xoo), is a serious disease in rice production worldwide. To understand the genetic diversity of bacterial blight resistance a population consisting of 175 indica accessions from nine countries was collected and detected their association between SSR (Simple Sequence Repeat) markers and resistance to six bacterial races. The resistance phenotypes of various rice accessions were evaluated through artificial inoculation under controlled conditions in 2013 and 2014. Association analysis showed that 17 SSR markers were significantly associated with resistance to four bacterial races and the phenotypic variations explained (PVE) ranged from 7.43 to 15.05%. Among the 17 associated SSR markers, two SSR markers located in previously reported genes regions, and 15 SSR markers were newly identified in this study. These results validated a new approach to map resistance genes of rice to bacterial blight. These markers could be used for marker-assisted selection (MAS) in rice bacterial blight resistance breeding programs.     

Identification and mapping of a locus conferring plum pox virus resistance in two apricot-improved linkage maps

Sharka disease, caused by the plum pox virus (PPV), is one of the major limiting factors for stone fruit crops in Europe and America. In particular, apricot is severely affected suffering significant fruit losses. Thus, PPV resistance is a trait of great interest for the apricot breeding programs currently in progress. In this work, two apricot maps, earlier constructed with the F₁ ‘Goldrich × Currot’ (G×C) and the F₂ ‘Lito × Lito’-98 (L×L-98) populations, have been improved including 43 and 37 new simple sequence repeat (SSR) loci, respectively, to facilitate PPV resistance trait mapping. Screening of PPV resistance on the segregating populations classified seedling phenotypes into resistant or susceptible. A non-parametric mapping method, based on the Kruskal–Wallis (KW) rank sum test, was initially used to score marker–trait association, and results were confirmed by interval mapping. Contrary to the putative digenic model inferred from the phenotypic segregations, all significant markers for the KW statistic (P < 0.005) mapped in a unique region of ~21.0 and ~20.3 cM located on the upper part of the G1 linkage group in ‘G×C’ and ‘L×L-98’ maps, respectively. According to the data, PPV resistance is suggested to be controlled by at least one major dominant locus. The association between three SSRs distributed within this region and the PPV resistance was tested in two additional populations (‘Goldrich × Canino’ and ‘Lito × Lito’-00) and breeding program parents. The marker ssrPaCITA5 showed the highest KW value (P < 0.005) in all cases, pointing out its usefulness in marker-assisted selection. Electronic Supplementary Material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Microsatellite markers for powdery mildew resistance in pea (Pisum sativum L.)

Powdery mildew is a common disease of field pea, Pisum sativum L., and is caused by the ascomycete fungus Erysiphe pisi. It can cause severe damage in areas where pea is cultivated. Today breeders want to develop new pea lines that are resistant to the disease. To make the breeding process more efficient, it is desirable to find genetic markers for use in a marker-assisted selection (MAS) strategy. In this study, microsatellites (SSR) were used to find markers linked to powdery mildew resistance. The resistant pea cultivar '955180' and the susceptible pea cultivar 'Majoret' were crossed and F2 plants were screened with SSR markers, using bulked segregant analysis. A total of 315 SSR markers were screened out of which five showed linkage to the powdery mildew resistance gene. No single marker was considered optimal for inclusion in a MAS program. Instead, two of the markers can be used in combination, which would result in only 1.6% incorrectly identified plants. Thus SSR markers can be successfully used in marker-assisted selection for powdery mildew resistance breeding in pea.     

Genetic linkage maps of two apricot cultivars ( Prunus armeniaca L.), and mapping of PPV (sharka) resistance

Genetic linkage maps for two apricot cultivars have been constructed using AFLP, RAPD, RFLP and SSR markers in 81 F1 individuals from the cross 'Goldrich' x 'Valenciano'. This family segregated for resistance to 'plum pox virus' (PPV), the most-important virus affecting Prunus species. Of the 160 RAPD arbitrary primers screened a total of 44 were selected. Sixty one polymorphic RAPD markers were scored on the mapping population: 30 heterozygous in 'Goldrich', 19 heterozygous in 'Valenciano', segregating 1:1, and 12 markers heterozygous in both parents, segregating 3:1. A total of 33 and 19 RAPD markers were mapped on the 'Goldrich' and 'Valenciano' maps respectively. Forteen primer combinations were used for AFLPs and all of them detected polymorphism. Ninety five markers segregating 1:1 were identified, of which 62 were heterozygous in the female parent 'Goldrich' and 33 in the male parent 'Valenciano'. Forty five markers were present in both parents and segregated 3:1. A total of 82 and 48 AFLP markers were mapped on the 'Goldrich' and 'Valenciano' maps. Twelve RFLPs probes were screened in the population, resulting in five loci segregating in the family, one locus heterozygous for 'Valenciano' and four heterozygous for both, segregating 1:2:1. Of the 45 SSRs screened 17 segregated in the mapping family, resulting in seven loci heterozygous for the maternal parent and ten heterozygous for both, segregating 1:2:1 or 1:1:1:1. A total of 16 and 13 co-dominant markers were mapped in the female and male parent maps respectively. A total of 132 markers were placed into eight linkage groups on the 'Goldrich' map, defining 511 cM of the total map-length. The average distance between adjacent markers was 3.9 cM. A total of 80 markers were placed into seven linkage groups on the 'Valenciano' map, defining 467.2 cM of the total map-distance, with an average interval of 5.8 cM between adjacent markers. Thirty six marker loci heterozygous in both parents revealed straightforward homologies between five linkage groups in both maps. The sharka resistance trait mapped on linkage group 2. The region containing sharka resistance is flanked by two co-dominant markers that will be used for targeted SSR development employing a recently constructed complete apricot BAC library. SSRs tightly linked to sharka resistance will facilitate MAS in breeding for resistance in apricot.     

Validation of SSR markers associated with rust (Uromyces fabae) resistance in pea (Pisum sativum L.)

Pea rust is a devastating disease of peas especially in the sub-tropical regions of the world and greatly influenced by the environmental conditions during disease development. Molecular markers associated with pea rust resistance would be useful in marker assisted selection (MAS). Utility of molecular markers associated with the pea rust resistance were evaluated in 30 diverse pea genotypes using four SSR markers (AA446 and AA505 flanking the major QTL Qruf; AD146 and AA416 flanking the minor QTL, Qruf1). QTL, Qruf flanking markers were able to identify all the resistant genotypes when used together, except Pant P 31. While, SSR markers AD146 and AA416 flanking the minor QTL, Qruf1 were able to identify all the pea resistant genotypes used for validation, except for HUDP-11 by AD146 and Pant P 31 by AA416. Similarly, SSR markers AA446 and AA505 were able to identify all the susceptible pea genotypes, except IPFD 99–13, HFP 9415 and S- 143. SSR markers AD146 and AA416 were together able to identify all the pea susceptible genotypes used for validation, except KPMR 526, KPMR 632 and IPFD 99–13. On the basis of marker allele analysis it may be concluded that SSR markers (AA446, AA505, AD146 and AA416) can be used in MAS of pea rust resistance.     

Origin of resistance to <Emphasis Type="Italic">plum pox virus</Emphasis> in Apricot: what new AFLP and targeted SSR data analyses tell

Amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLP) and targeted simple sequence repeats (SSR) were employed to assess genetic similarity of North American apricots having natural resistance to plum pox virus (PPV) within diversified germplasm including six nondomesticated apricot species. On a dendrogram constructed from 231 AFLP loci, the position of the North American cultivars reflects relatedness to the European apricots and introgression of non-European germplasm as well. The occurrence of diagnostic AFLP markers supports an introgression of Chinese germplasm into the North American PPV resistant assortment and supports a different breeding history for ‘Stark Early Orange’ (SEO) and Goldrich-Harlayne lineages. Five SSR loci linked to the PPV resistance region on G1 provided evidence that the investigated lineages (SEO and ‘Harlayne’–‘Goldrich’) have the same or related source of resistance introduced presumably from Northern China. Possible introgression of genetic material from nondomesticated apricots P. mandshurica sp, P. sibirica var. davidiana and P. mume sp. was detected and discussed. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Development and validation of functional marker targeting an InDel in the major rice blast disease resistance gene Pi54 (Pik h )

Rice blast is one of the most devastating diseases affecting the rice crop throughout the world. In molecular breeding for host plant resistance, functional markers are very useful for enhancing the precision and accuracy in marker-assisted selection (MAS) of target gene(s) with minimum effort, time and cost. Pi54 (which was earlier known as Pik ^h ) is one of the major blast resistance genes and has been observed to show resistance against many isolates of the blast pathogen in India. The gene has been cloned through map-based strategy and encodes a nucleotide-binding site?Cleucine-rich repeat (NBS?CLRR) domain-containing protein. In the present study, we carried out allele mining for this gene and identified a 144-bp insertion/deletion (InDel) polymorphism in the exonic region of the gene. A PCR-based co-dominant molecular marker targeting this InDel, named Pi54 MAS, was developed. Pi54 MAS was observed to perfectly co-segregate with blast resistance in a mapping population with no recombinants. Validation of this marker in 105 genotypes which are either susceptible or resistant to rice blast disease showed that the marker is polymorphic in most of the resistant?Csusceptible genotype combinations and is more accurate than the earlier reported markers for Pi54. Hence this functional, co-dominant marker is suggested for routine deployment in MAS of Pi54 in breeding programs.     

Silencing of the Host Factor eIF(iso)4E Gene Confers Plum Pox Virus Resistance in Plum

Plum pox virus (PPV) causes the most economically-devastating viral disease in Prunus species. Unfortunately, few natural resistance genes are available for the control of PPV. Recessive resistance to some potyviruses is associated with mutations of eukaryotic translation initiation factor 4E (eIF4E) or its isoform eIF(iso)4E. In this study, we used an RNA silencing approach to manipulate the expression of eIF4E and eIF(iso)4E towards the development of PPV resistance in Prunus species. The eIF4E and eIF(iso)4E genes were cloned from plum (Prunus domestica L.). The sequence identity between plum eIF4E and eIF(iso)4E coding sequences is 60.4% at the nucleotide level and 52.1% at the amino acid level. Quantitative real-time RT-PCR analysis showed that these two genes have a similar expression pattern in different tissues. Transgenes allowing the production of hairpin RNAs of plum eIF4E or eIF(iso)4E were introduced into plum via Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Gene expression analysis confirmed specific reduced expression of eIF4E or eIF(iso)4E in the transgenic lines and this was associated with the accumulation of siRNAs. Transgenic plants were challenged with PPV-D strain and resistance was evaluated by measuring the concentration of viral RNA. Eighty-two percent of the eIF(iso)4E silenced transgenic plants were resistant to PPV, while eIF4E silenced transgenic plants did not show PPV resistance. Physical interaction between PPV-VPg and plum eIF(iso)4E was confirmed. In contrast, no PPV-VPg/eIF4E interaction was observed. These results indicate that eIF(iso)4E is involved in PPV infection in plum, and that silencing of eIF(iso)4E expression can lead to PPV resistance in Prunus species.     

Narrowing down the apricot Plum pox virus resistance locus and comparative analysis with the peach genome syntenic region

Sharka disease, caused by the Plum pox virus (PPV), is one of the main limiting factors for stone fruit crops worldwide. Only a few resistance sources have been found in apricot (Prunus armeniaca L.), and most studies have located a major PPV resistance locus (PPVres) on linkage group 1 (LG1). However, the mapping accuracy was not sufficiently reliable and PPVres was predicted within a low confidence interval. In this study, we have constructed two high-density simple sequence repeat (SSR) improved maps with 0.70 and 0.68 markers/cm, corresponding to LG1 of 'Lito' and 'Goldrich' PPV-resistant cultivars, respectively. Using these maps, and excluding genotype-phenotype incongruent individuals, a new binary trait locus (BTL) analysis for PPV resistance was performed, narrowing down the PPVres support intervals to 7.3 and 5.9 cm in 'Lito' and 'Goldrich', respectively. Subsequently, 71 overlapping oligonucleotides (overgo) probes were hybridized against an apricot bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) library, identifying 870 single BACs from which 340 were anchored onto a map region of approximately 30-40 cm encompassing PPVres. Partial BAC contigs assigned to the two allelic haplotypes (resistant/susceptible) of the PPVres locus were built by high-information content fingerprinting (HICF). In addition, a total of 300 BAC-derived sequences were obtained, and 257 showed significant homology with the peach genome scaffold_1 corresponding to LG1. According to the peach syntenic genome sequence, PPVres was predicted within a region of 2.16 Mb in which a few candidate resistance genes were identified.     

Accumulation of quantitative trait loci conferring broad-spectrum clubroot resistance in Brassica oleracea

Throughout the world, clubroot disease is one of the most damaging diseases affecting Brassica oleracea. To develop marker-assisted selection (MAS) that could assist the incorporation of durable clubroot resistance (CR) into cultivars, previous genetic analyses have identified several CR quantitative trait loci (CR–QTL). However, the independent and cumulative effects of each CR locus against various isolates have rarely been tested. Previously, we identified one major CR–QTL and four minor CR–QTL in the F2 plants from broccoli doubled haploid (DH) line × cabbage DH line of B. oleracea. In the present study, to clarify their effectiveness for controlling disease involving various isolates, inoculation testing was conducted in genotypes with various combinations of the CR genes, which were selected using the DNA markers closely associated with each CR–QTL. In exploring the overall disease incidence, it was apparent that a single involvement of the major CR gene located in the PbBo(Anju)1 locus, or accumulation of CR genes in the minor CR–QTL, is not enough to confer sufficient resistance. One major CR gene in the QTL PbBo(Anju)1 locus plus two to three minor CR genes conferred moderate resistance. The genotype in which all of the CR genes locating in the five QTL including PbBo(Anju)1 were accumulated showed the highest resistance, and it was broadly resistant against six isolates. Accumulation of several CR genes by MAS is necessary to conduct CR breeding in B. oleracea. Our developed DNA markers can be used efficiently to make selections of required loci for the acquisition of resistance, and use of these markers will be a powerful tool for CR breeding in B. oleracea.