Clinical and genetic studies of Japanese homozygotes for the Gaucher disease L444P mutation

In patients originally genotyped as homoallelic for the Gaucher disease (GD) L444P (1448C) mutation, we sought to confirm previously reported phenotypic differences between Caucasians and Japanese, to determine the prevalence and phenotypic impact of recombinant alleles, and to explore the phenotypic influence of genetic background. We therefore analyzed data from longer-term clinical follow-up, more comprehensive genotyping and polymorphism and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) testing in all known Japanese L444P homozygotes (n=15). Our studies demonstrated that, of 12 patients in our series originally diagnosed with non-neuronopathic GD, 9 developed neurological signs/symptoms during follow-up (at a mean of 14 years 11 months±11 years 4 months). Of three patients originally diagnosed with acute neuronopathic (type 2) GD, all three were compound heterozygotes for L444P and the complex allele RecNci I. In the entire series, Pvu II and liver erythrocyte pyruvate kinase (PKLR) polymorphism and prevalence of the 9 bp mtDNA deletion were heterogeneous, and these background genetic factors could not predict phenotypic expression. Our data suggest that, in Japanese as in Caucasian patients, the L444P/L444P genotype is highly associated with subacute neuronopathic (type 3) GD, and the presence of a complex allele together with an L444P allele leads to type 2 disease. Our findings also underline the importance of comprehensive genotyping (particularly testing for recombinant alleles), long-term follow-up and careful neurological examination in patients with early-onset GD. Such measures ultimately may improve genotype/phenotype correlations and, with them, genetic counseling and therapeutic decision making. Electronic Publication     

Gaucher disease: heterologous expression of two alleles associated with neuronopathic phenotypes.

To investigate the molecular basis for the distinct neuronopathic phenotypes of Gaucher disease, acid beta-glucosidases expressed from mutant DNAs in Gaucher disease type 2 (acute) and type 3 (subacute) patients were characterized in fibroblasts and with the baculovirus expression system in insect cells. Expression of the mutant DNA encoding a proline-for-leucine substitution at amino acid 444 (L444P) resulted in a catalytically defective, unstable acid beta-glucosidase in either fibroblasts from L444P/L444P homozygotes or in insect cells. This mutation was found to be homoallelic in subacute neuronopathic (type 3) Gaucher disease. In comparison, expression of the mutant cDNA encoding an arginine-for-proline substitution at amino acid 415 (P415R) resulted in an inactive and unstable protein in insect cells. This allele was found only in a type 2 patient with the L444P/P415R genotype. The substantial variation in the type 3 phenotype (L444P homozygotes) suggests the complex nature of the molecular basis of phenotypic variation in Gaucher disease. Yet, the association of neuronopathic phenotypes with alleles producing severely compromised (L444P) or functionally null (P415R) enzymes indicates that the effective level of residual activity at the lysosome is likely to be a major determinant of the severity of Gaucher disease.     

Clinical and Molecular Characteristics of Japanese Gaucher Disease

Clinical signs and symptoms of Gaucher disease are more severe in Japanese than in Jewish and other non-Japanese patients. A higher percentage of bone crises and splenectomy was demonstrated by Japanese patients, and there were five fatalities among patients with type 1 Gaucher disease. Additionally, neonatal Gaucher disease, clinically characterized by hydrops foetalis, was observed. Japanese patients with type 2 and type 3 disease also demonstrate clinical heterogeneity. About 100 alleles of patients with Japanese Gaucher disease were examined for genotype determination with the PCR and SSCP methods. About 18 different mutations, including several novel mutations in Japanese patients, were identified. The most common mutations in Japanese patients were 1448C(L444P), accounting for 41 (41%) of alleles. The second most prevalent mutation was 754A(F2131), accounting for 14 (14%) of alleles. Other alleles identified included the 1324C, IVS2 and other mutations. Unidentified alleles comprised 16% of the total number of alleles studied. To date, neither the 1226G (N370S) nor the 84GG mutation has been identified in the Japanese population, although these mutations account for about 70% and 10% of the mutations in Jewish and other non-Japanese populations, respectively. The phenotype-genotype correlation in Japanese patients is more complex compared with that of the Jewish population. In Japanese patients, the 1448C mutation, in either heteroallelic or homoallelic forms, exhibits both neurological and non-neurological phenotypes. Japanese patients with the 754A mutation also exhibit both neuronopathic and non-neuronopathic disease. On the other hand, patients with the D409H mutation show only type 3 neurological disease, and those with the 1447–1466 del 20 ins TG mutation have the severe, neonatal neurological form of Gaucher disease. The 1503T allele was present only in patients with type 1 non-neurological disease. However, since this correlation was observed only in young patients, we do not as yet know the final phenotypic outcome of this mutation. Probably, Japanese patients with Gaucher disease have few mutations that exhibit non-neurological signs and symptoms.     

A new glucocerebrosidase-gene missense mutation responsible for neuronopathic Gaucher disease in Japanese patients.

We have identified a new T-to-A single-base substitution at nucleotide 3548 (in the genomic sequence) in exon 6 in the glucocerebrosidase gene from a patient with Gaucher disease type 3. This mutation caused a substitution of isoleucine for phenylalanine at amino acid residue 213 (of 497 residues in the mature protein). By in vitro expression study in cultured mammalian cells, this mutation resulted in deficient activity of glucocerebrosidase. By allele-specific oligonucleotide hybridization of selectively PCR-amplified DNA from eight unrelated Japanese Gaucher disease patients, this mutant allele was observed in other neuronopathic Japanese Gaucher disease patients, in moderately frequent occurrence (three of six neuronopathic patients). This observation suggests that this allele was one of severe [corrected] alleles which were related to the development of neurological manifestations of Gaucher disease.     

Characterization of mutations in Gaucher patients by cDNA cloning.

Mutated cDNA clones containing the entire coding sequence of human glucocerebrosidase were isolated from libraries originated from Gaucher patients. Sequence analysis of a mutated cDNA derived from a type II Gaucher patient revealed a C-to-G transversion causing a substitution of an arginine for a proline at residue 415. This change creates a new cleavage site for the enzyme HhaI in the mutated cDNA. Allele-specific oligonucleotide hybridization made it possible to show that this mutation exists in the genomic DNA of the patient. From a cDNA library originated from a type I Gaucher patient, a mutated allele was cloned that contains a T-to-C transition causing a substitution of proline for leucine at residue 444 and creating a new NciI site. This mutation is identical to that described by S. Tsuji and colleagues in genomic DNA from type I, type II, and type III patients. Since the new NciI site generates RFLP, it was used to test the existence of this mutated allele in several Gaucher patients by Southern blot analysis. This allele was found in type I (Jewish and non-Jewish), type II, and type III Gaucher patients. These findings led us to conclude that the patient suffering from type II disease (denoted GM1260) carried both mutations described above. Any one of the amino acid changes described reduces the glucocerebrosidase activity as tested by transfection of COS cells with expression vectors harboring the mutated cDNAs. The base changes in the two mutated cDNAs do not affect the electrophoretic mobility of the corresponding polypeptides on an SDS polyacrylamide gel.     

Complex alleles of the acid beta-glucosidase gene in Gaucher disease.

Gaucher disease is inherited in an autosomal recessive manner and is the most prevalent lysosomal storage disease. Gaucher disease has marked phenotypic variation and molecular heterogeneity, and seven point mutations in the acid beta-glucosidase (beta-Glc) gene have been identified. By means of sequence-specific oligonucleotides (SSO), mutation 6433C has been detected homozygously in neuronopathic type 2 (acute) and type 3 (subacute) patients, as well as in children with severe visceral involvement who are apparently free of neuronopathic disease. To investigate the molecular basis for this puzzling finding, amplified beta-Glc cDNAs from 6433C homozygous type 2 and type 3 Gaucher disease patients were cloned and sequenced. The Swedish type 3 Gaucher disease patient was truly homozygous for alleles only containing the 6433C mutation. In comparison, the type 2 patient contained a singly mutated 6433C allele and a "complex" allele with multiple discrete point mutations (6433C, 6468C, and 6482C). Each of the mutations in the complex allele also was present in the beta-Glc pseudogene. SSO hybridization of 6433C homozygotes revealed that both type 2 patients contained additional mutations in one allele, whereas the 6433C alone was detected in both type 3 and in young severe type 1 Gaucher disease patients. These results suggest that the presence of the complex allele influences the severity of neuronopathic disease in 6433C homozygotes and reveal the central role played by the pseudogene in the formation of mutant alleles of the beta-Glc gene. Analysis of additional cDNA clones also identified two new alleles in a type 3 patient, emphasizing the molecular heterogeneity of neuronopathic Gaucher disease.     

Two new Gaucher disease mutations

Recently, a mutation at nucleotide 1193 of the glucocerebrosidase gene was described in a patient with type 1 Gaucher disease. This mutation destroys a TaqI site in a polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-amplified fragment. We used digestion with this enzyme to screen DNA samples from Gaucher disease patients representing 23 previously unidentified alleles and discovered that this site had been destroyed in three samples. However, the mutation that caused this change proved to be a CT substitution at cDNA nucleotide 1192 (Genomic 5408; ³⁵⁹ArgEnd). Fortuitously, another TaqI site was destroyed by a different mutation, a GA mutation at nt 1312 (Genomic 5927; ³⁹⁹AspAsn). Both of these mutations were functionally severe in that they were associated with type 2 (acute neuronopathic) Gaucher disease.     

Detection of the frequencies of GBA gene major mutations in patients with Gaucher disease in Ukraine

The molecular diagnostics of 27 from 26 Ukrainian families has been performed. The common mutations in GBA gene (N370S, L444P and 84GG) accounted for up to 58% of all cases: mutation N370S was detected in 42.3% alleles, mutation L444P was observed in 15.4% alleles and mutation 84GG was not found at all. The other mutations were: P178S, W184R and Rec Nci I (in compounds with N370S) in the patients with nonneuronopathic form of Gaucher disease, and the genotypes G377S/c 999G --> A and D409H/R120W/G202R were detected in patients with chronic neuronopathic form of Gaucher disease. The data analysis of the genotype and disease progression in the patients allows confirming the known genotype-phenotype correlation.     

Mutation screening of 17 Japanese patients with neuropathic Gaucher disease

Using PCR and PCR-single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) we have identified gene mutations in 17 Japanese patients with neuropathic Gaucher disease (type 2, 9 cases; type 3, 8 cases). The L444P, F213I, D409H, and 1447 del 20 and 1447 ins TG mutations accounted for eight (type 2, 6; type 3, 2), seven (type 2, 2; type 3, 5), three (type 3), and three (type 2) alleles, respectively. Three alleles were unique. Ten alleles (type 2, 5; type 3, 5) could not be identified. The genotypes, D409H/?, L444P/?, L444P/F213I, and F213I/?, were identified in three, three, two, and two patients, respectively. Six patients had a unique genotype and none of the mutant alleles could be identified in one patient. The data indicate that the genotypes in Japanese patients with neuropathic Gaucher disease are found to be heterogeneous and the genotype prevalence and mutated alleles are unique.     

Molecular characteristics in Japanese patients with lipidosis: Novel mutations in metachromatic leukodystrophy and Gaucher disease

The characterization of mutations in Japanese patients with lipidosis, particularly in metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) and Gaucher disease has been studied in detail. Metachromatic leukodystrophy is characterized by an accumulation of sulfatide in nervous tissues and kidney due to a deficiency of arylsulfatase A (ASA). We analyzed the presence of three known mutant arylsulfatase A alleles in Japanese patients with MLD. Among 10 patients of Japanese patients with MLD, we found that allele 445A mutation has moderately high incidence and also homozygosity of this mutation results in the late infantile form. Allele 2381T was not found in Japanese patients. Furthermore, we found novel mutation which is G- to A mutation at the 1070 nucleotide of the ASA gene (designated 1070 A) in Japanese patients with juvenile onset. This mutation results in a amino acid substitution of Gly245 by Arg and found in heterozygote form. Our studies of molecular analysis in 10 Japanese patients with MLD indicate that Japanese MLD patients have unique characteristics of ASA mutations compared with those of Caucasian patients. On the other hand, Gaucher disease is the most prevalent sphingolipidosis, characterized by an accumulation of glucocerebroside in macrophage derived cells due to a deficiency of lysosomal hydrolase glucocerebrosidase. To study the molecular basis of Gaucher disease in Japanese patients, we analyzed the presence of the two known mutations (6433C and 3548A) in the glucocerebrosidase gene of 15 patients with Gaucher disease. We found that the 6433C and 3548A mutations occur in all subtypes of Japanese patients with Gaucher disease. Most frequent mutations among them was the 6433C mutation, 40% of 30 chromosomes, whereas the novel mutation of the 3548A found in Japanese patients with neuronopathic Gaucher disease was found in 20% (6 out of 30 chromosomes). The characteristics of these mutations in Japanese patients with Gaucher disease is different from those of Caucasian populations reported previously.     

Analysis and classification of 304 mutant alleles in patients with type 1 and type 3 Gaucher disease

Gaucher disease results from the inherited deficiency of the enzyme glucocerebrosidase (EC 3.2.1.45). Although >100 mutations in the gene for human glucocerebrosidase have been described, most genotype-phenotype studies have focused upon screening for a few common mutations. In this study, we used several approaches-including direct sequencing, Southern blotting, long-template PCR, restriction digestions, and the amplification refraction mutation system (ARMS)-to genotype 128 patients with type 1 Gaucher disease (64 of Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry and 64 of non-Jewish extraction) and 24 patients with type 3 Gaucher disease. More than 97% of the mutant alleles were identified. Fourteen novel mutations (A90T, N117D, T134I, Y135X, R170C, W184R, A190T, Y304X, A341T, D399Y, c.153-154insTACAGC, c.203-204insC, c.222-224delTAC, and c.1122-1123insTG) and many rare mutations were detected. Recombinant alleles were found in 19% of the patients. Although 93% of the mutant alleles in our Ashkenazi Jewish type 1 patients were N370S, c.84-85insG, IVS2+1G-->A or L444P, these four mutations accounted for only 49% of mutant alleles in the non-Jewish type 1 patients. Genotype-phenotype correlations were attempted. Homozygosity or heterozygosity for N370S resulted in type 1 Gaucher disease, whereas homozygosity for L444P was associated with type 3. Genotype L444P/recombinant allele resulted in type 2 Gaucher disease, and homozygosity for a recombinant allele was associated with perinatal lethal disease. The phenotypic consequences of other mutations, particularly R463C, were more inconsistent. Our results demonstrate a high rate of mutation detection, a large number of novel and rare mutations, and an accurate assessment of the prevalence of recombinant alleles. Although some genotype-phenotype correlations do exist, other genetic and environmental factors must also contribute to the phenotypes encountered, and we caution against relying solely upon genotype for prognostic or therapeutic judgements.     

TNF-alpha levels and TNF-alpha gene polymorphism in type I Gaucher disease

The objective of this pilot study was to determine the levels of Tumor Necrosis Factor (TNF)-alpha and TNF-alpha gene polymorphism as a marker of inflammation among patients with type I Gaucher disease as well as to ascertain the relationship between this cytokine and parameters of disease severity and other measures of inflammation. Levels of TNF-alpha and genotyping for the -308 G-->A polymorphism in the promoter of the TNF-alpha gene were performed in 17 patients with type I Gaucher disease. TNF-alpha levels were compared with the promoter gene polymorphism, and with hematological and other clinical parameters of Gaucher disease. Eight patients (47.1%) were homozygotes (A/A) for the TNF-alpha polymorphism, six patients (35.3%) had the wild type (G/G), and three patients (17.6%) were heterozygotes (G/A). A significant correlation was found between serum TNF-alpha levels and TNF-alpha genotypes for homozygotes versus heterozygotes patients (p = 0.02), with patients homozygous for the polymorphism having the lower levels of serum TNF-alpha relative to heterozygotes with the highest levels. No correlation was found between TNF-alpha genotypes and chitotriosidase levels, a putative biochemical marker for Gaucher disease severity. Because a significant correlation was found between homozygosity for a common promoter polymorphism of TNF-alpha and milder expression i.e. non-neuronopathic form, of Gaucher disease (versus the neuronopathic forms), this may be suggestive of an association between genetic variability in TNF-alpha and phenotypic expression in Gaucher disease. Larger studies will be required.     

Determining the frequency of common mutations in the GBA gene in patients with Gaucher disease in Ukraine

A molecular-genetics investigation is conducted on 27 patients from 26 families. Common mutations in the GBA gene (N370S, L444P, and 84GG) are studied. The overall frequency of the common mutations is nearly 58%, with the percentage of alleles that carry the N370S mutation close to 42.3% and the proportion that carry the L444P mutation, 15.4%. No allele containing the 84GG mutation was found. Besides other mutations, the rare mutations P178S, W184R, and Rec Nci I (together with N370S) were also found in the GBA gene in patients with the nonneuronopathic form of the disease, along with the genotypes G377S/c 999GA and D409H/R 120W/G202R in patients with the chronic neuronopathic form. An analysis of the correlation between the genotype and the course of the disease in the patients showed that the genotype-phenotype correlations were close to that described for European populations.     

A mutation within the saposin D domain in a Gaucher disease patient with normal glucocerebrosidase activity

Only two Gaucher disease (GD) patients bearing mutations in the prosaposin gene (PSAP), and not in the glucocerebrosidase gene (GBA), have been reported. In both cases, one mutant allele remained unidentified. We report here the identification of the second mutation in one of these patients, being the first complete genotype described so far in a SAP-C-deficient GD patient. This mutation, p.Q430X, is the first one reported in the saposin D domain and probably produces a null allele by nonsense mediated mRNA decay.     

Gaucher disease type III (Norrbottnian type) is caused by a single mutation in exon 10 of the glucocerebrosidase gene.

Three major forms (types I-III) of Gaucher disease (GD) have been identified. The largest group of patients with type III GD has been reported from the province of Norrbotten in Sweden. In the present study the genomes from two GD patients of Norrbottnian origin were examined for abnormalities in the glucocerebrosidase gene. In both individuals, a single nucleotide substitution was found in exon 10. This mutation, which results in the substitution of proline for leucine, is identical to the NciI mutation described by Tsuji and co-workers in GD patients of other ethnic origins. Nine additional patients with Norrbottnian GD were shown to be homozygous for the same mutation by restriction-enzyme digestion of DNA amplified by PCR.     

Phenotypic heterogeneity in patients with Gaucher disease and the N370S/V394L genotype

Correlation between genotype and phenotype in Gaucher disease is limited. It is known that the most common mutation N370S is protective of neurological involvement, but for the V394L mutation, described as the fifth most common among Ashkenazi Jews, little data are available. This study reports all known patients from a large referral clinic and from the international registry with Gaucher disease who are documented to have the N370S/V394L genotype. Of 476 patients in the Gaucher Clinic, 7 patients (2.0%) had the N370S/V394L genotype; of 2,836 patients in the registry, there were 14 patients (0.8%) with this genotype. There was an overlap of 3 patients, making a total of 18 patients, reflecting the rarity of this genotype among the studied cohorts. Most of these patients had mild disease; only 8 patients required specific enzyme therapy, none was splenectomized. Only 3 patients had skeletal involvement, but other baseline parameters were very diverse. Although genotype-phenotype correlation in this case may be difficult, because the V394L mutation when seen in a compound heterozygote with a null allele results in neuronopathic disease, one cannot conclude that this mutation is protective of neuronopathic disease and hence this is important for counseling of at-risk populations.     

A novel point mutation in congenital erythropoietic porphyria in two members of Japanese family

The molecular basis of the uroporphyrinogen III synthase (UROIIIS) deficiency was investigated in two members of a Japanese family. This defect in heme biosynthesis is responsible for a rare autosomal recessive disease: congenital erythropoietic porphyria (CEP) or Günther’s disease. The first patient was homoallelic for a novel missense mutation: a T to C transition of nucleotide 634 that predicted a serine to proline substitution at residue 212 (S212P). The second patient appeared heteroallelic, carrying the same missense mutation and a nonsense mutation: a C to T change at nucleotide 745, resulting in a premature stop at codon 249, instead of a glutamine (Q249X). The corresponding mutated proteins were expressed in Escherichia coli and no residual activity was observed. A family study was also performed to determine the carrier status. Received: 18 July 1995     

Phenotype/genotype correlations in Gaucher disease type I: clinical and therapeutic implications.

Gaucher disease is the most frequent lysosomal storage disease and the most prevalent genetic disease among Ashkenazi Jews. Gaucher disease type 1 is characterized by marked variability of the phenotype and by the absence of neuronopathic involvement. To test the hypothesis that this phenotypic variability was due to genetic compounds of several different mutant alleles, 161 symptomatic patients with Gaucher disease type 1 (> 90% Ashkenazi Jewish) were analyzed for clinical involvement, and their genotypes were determined. Qualitative and quantitative measures of disease involvement included age at onset of the disease manifestations, hepatic and splenic volumes, age at splenectomy, and severity of bony disease. Highly statistically significant differences (P < .005) were found in each clinical parameter in patients with the N370S/N370S genotype compared with those patients with the N370S/84GG, N370S/L444P, and N370S/? genotypes. The symptomatic N370S homozygotes had onset of their disease two to three decades later than patients with the other genotypes. In addition, patients with the latter genotypes have much more severely involved livers, spleens, and bones and had a higher incidence of splenectomy at an earlier age. These predictive genotype analyses provide the basis for genetic care delivery and therapeutic recommendations in patients affected with Gaucher disease type 1.     

Genotype D399N/R463C in a Patient with Type 3 Gaucher Disease Previously Assigned Genotype N370S/R463C

A patient with type 3 Gaucher disease is described with a novel genotype, D399N/R463C, established by DNA sequencing. This patient was previously reported as having genotype N370S/R463C. This communication now establishes that no patients reported with mutation N370S have the neuronopathic forms of Gaucher disease and has important implications for genetic counseling.     

Molecular genetic analysis of neurologic diseases]

With the recent progress in molecular genetics, our understanding of neurologic diseases on molecular basis has improved tremendously. Molecular analyses of gene mutations in hereditary neurologic diseases bring us not only the identification of mutations but also better understanding of molecular mechanisms involved in the neurologic diseases. We have identified a missense mutation (444Leu----Pro) in glucocerebrosidase gene of a type 2 Gaucher patient. The mutant glucocerebrosidase carrying 444Pro is unstable and degraded rapidly before the mutant protein is targetted to lysosomes. Detailed analysis on the 444Leu----Pro mutations among three phenotypes (types 1, 2 and 3) of Gaucher disease, it has been demonstrated that patients homozygous for the mutation frequently have the neurologic involvement (types 1 and 2). Very recently we have identified a mutation in tRNA(Lys) gene of mitochondrial genome of patients with myoclonus epilepsy associated with ragged-red fibers. The pathophysiologic mechanism with the tRNA(Lys) mutation is considered to be based on the impaired function of tRNA(Lys).