EFFECT OF FEEDBACK ON SENSORY TRAINING: A PRELIMINARY STUDY

Feedback in sensory training can facilitate performance in several ways. It can provide information about the type, the extent and the direction of errors so that they may be corrected. This paper shows the effects of immediate feedback over a three session training. Triangle test, familiar odor recognition and scaling test were used in training. The scaling test, specially designed for this study, was performed with solutions of mixtures of basic tastes in different proportions.
Prior sensory ability was taken into account by dividing 54 people into two groups according to their sensory ability. Each group was then split into an experimental group receiving feedback and into a control group.
The results showed that feedback has different effects depending on test: a positive effect for recognition test, no effect for triangle test and a probable negative effect for scaling.     

脱臭工艺对玉米油中反式脂肪酸含量的影响

目的:研究脱臭工艺对玉米油中反式脂肪酸含量的影响。方法:在实验室内对玉米油进行不同温度和时间的脱臭处理,利用气相色谱法分析处理后玉米油中的反式脂肪酸含量。结果:脱臭温度和脱臭时间均对玉米油中反式油酸的产生影响不显著。脱臭温度对玉米油中反式亚油酸含量影响显著,脱臭时间对玉米油中反式亚油酸含量影响不显著。在一定的脱臭时间,不同脱臭温度下,玉米油中总反式脂肪酸最多含量为最少含量的80倍以上;在一定的脱臭温度,而不同脱臭时间下,玉米油中总反式脂肪酸最多含量约为最少含量的1.5倍,且在255℃以下时,随脱臭时间延长,玉米油中总反式脂肪酸的形成速度缓慢、相对含量低。结论:玉米油精炼脱臭时,对脱臭工艺装备和工艺条件中的脱臭温度进行优化选择可有效减少玉米油反式脂肪酸的产生。     

Deodorizing effects of tea catechins on amines and ammonia

Deodorizing effects of tea catechins on amines were examined under alkaline conditions to eliminate the neutralization reaction. They showed deodorizing activity on ethylamine, but none on dimethylamine or trimethylamine. Deodorizing activity on ethylamine was found to be in the order of (-)-epigallocatechin gallate > gallic acid > (-)-epigallocatechin (EGC) > (-)-epicatechin gallate > ethyl gallate > (+)-catechin = (-)-epicatechin. Further, reaction products of EGC with methylamine, ethylamine, and ammonia were detected by HPLC, indicating that a deodorizing reaction other than neutralization occurs. From structural analysis of the reaction product with the methylamine isolated as a peracetylated derivative, the product was presumed to be methylamine substituted EGC, in which the hydroxyl group of EGC at the 4' position is replaced by the methylamino group. The same replacement reaction took place in the case of ethylamine and ammonia.     

LOGARITHMIC TRANSFORMATION OF MAGNITUDE ESTIMATION DATA AND COMPARISONS OF SCALING METHODS

Recent studies comparing magnitude estimation to other scaling methods have been criticized for failure to submit the data to logarithmic transformation before statistical analysis, a procedure which can improve the ability of magnitude estimation scaling to differentiate among products. Data from one of these studies was available for re-analysis, which was conducted both with and without logarithmic transformation of magnitude estimation, category scales and line scales. The ability of magnitude estimation to differentiate among products was improved by log transformation, while the other methods were not. Improvements were associated in pan with reductions in positive skew and improved approximation of the normal distribution. In spite of this improvement, magnitude estimation remained slightly inferior to the other methods especially in the hands of an untrained consumer sample.     

脱臭工艺对玉米油中反式脂肪酸含量的影响

目的：研究脱臭工艺对玉米油中反式脂肪酸含量的影响。方法：在实验室内对玉米油进行不同温度和时间的脱臭处理,利用气相色谱法分析处理后玉米油中的反式脂肪酸含量。结果：脱臭温度和脱臭时间均对玉米油中反式油酸的产生影响不显著。脱臭温度对玉米油中反式亚油酸含量影响显著,脱臭时间对玉米油中反式亚油酸含量影响不显著。在一定的脱臭时间,不同脱臭温度下,玉米油中总反式脂肪酸最多含量为最少含量的80倍以上;在一定的脱臭温度,而不同脱臭时间下,玉米油中总反式脂肪酸最多含量约为最少含量的1．5倍,且在255℃以下时,随脱臭时间延长,玉米油中总反式脂肪酸的形成速度缓慢、相对含量低。结论：玉米油精炼脱臭时,对脱臭工艺装备和工艺条件中的脱臭温度进行优化选择可有效减少玉米油反式脂肪酸的产生。     

COMPARISON OF RATING SCALES: SENSITIVITY, REPLICATES AND RELATIVE MEASUREMENT

The relative sensitivities of four scaling methods were assessed in central location tests with untrained judges. The scales included category scales, line scales, magnitude estimation, and a hybrid of the line and category scales. Approximate parity was observed among category scales, line scales and the hybrid scale in their ability to differentiate small physical differences. Magnitude estimation was used as efficiently as the other methods by a college population, but less efficiently by a heterogeneous sample of consumers. Judges used the scales with greater accuracy as they became familiar with the range of products to be judged. In spite of relatively small physical differences, subjects used wide ranges of the scales, supporting the view that rating scales are relative, not absolute, measuring instruments.     

Contrast and range effects for category, magnitude and labeled magnitude scales in judgements of sweetness intensity

The labeled magnitude scale (LMS) is a verbally anchored quasi-logarithmically spaced response scale with properties similar to magnitude estimation. Three experiments examined whether the LMS showed context effects similar to those found with magnitude estimation and category scales. Two versions of the LMS were used, one anchored at the high end to the strongest imaginable sweetness and the other to the strongest imaginable oral sensation. In a simple contrast experiment, subjects judged the sweetness of a 10% sucrose fruit beverage in the context of a less sweet (5%) beverage or a more sweet (20%) beverage. Consistent with previous literature, the sweetness was judged more intense in the low context and less intense in the high context, for all scaling methods. In a second experiment, this effect persisted (although was smaller) when the contextual item preceded the to-be-rated item, a so-called 'reversed-pair' design. Once again, the effect was highly significant for all scaling methods. In a third experiment, a range effect was examined using wide and narrow ranges of concentration. Psychophysical functions were flatter in a wide context and steeper in a narrow context, consistent with previous observations on range-mapping bias. This result was obtained for all scales. In three common contextual effects, the labeled magnitude scale behaved similarly to other scaling procedures. Its application to comparisons across individuals may be limited if those individuals have different experiential contexts within which they make their judgements.     

EVALUATION AND APPLICATIONS OF ODOR PROFILING

An odor profiling procedure was developed based on the ASTM odor profiling method. This modified procedure involved using approximately twenty panelists. Panel sessions and data collection were controlled by computer. The results obtained by this panel compared favorably to results obtained by the ASTM panel for which 150 panelists evaluated each compound, indicating that a small panel can be used to produce replicable results. Statistical methods of finding similarities and dissimilarities among compounds using profile data are discussed and compared to results from a multidimensional scaling (MDS) study in which degrees of differences among compounds were judged directly. These results indicate that profile data can be used to define and map the degree of similarity/dissimilarity among compounds, as well as to define the sensory dimensions on which these compounds differ. The use of factor analysis to study the underlying sensory dimensions of the odor space is also discussed. It is hoped that this type of research will lead to a better understanding of the underlying dimensions used to describe odorants.     

EVALUATION OF THREE SCALING METHODS FOR HEDONICS

A collaborative study of twenty-three laboratories was conducted to compare the relative effectiveness of three scales: two forms of magnitude estimation scaling and one form of a category scale in the measurement of hedonic response to a controlled stimulus. Responses from 553 individual judges show that all scales yield hedonic measurements that are very similar in both direction and magnitude of difference between the stimuli. No scale showed any clear superiority in reliability, precision, or discrimination. Selection of a scale must be based on considerations other than the simple form of response.     

Detectability and perceived intensity for formaldehyde in smokers and non-smokers

Formaldehyde emanating from cigarette smoke and emissions frombuilding materials is an important contaminant of indoor airand an interesting gaseous compound in the study of smokers'sensitivity to odor. With the aid of hood exposures to 18 formaldehydeconcentrations (7.5 to 1000 ppb), odor detection thresholds(method of constant stimuli) and perceived odor intensities(method of magnitude estimation) were determined among heavycigarette smokers (22 women) and non-smokers (22 aged-matchedwomen). To adjust for individual differences in response behavior,the odor thresholds were corrected for false alarms resultingfrom purified air presentations and the scale values of odorintensity were calibrated according to the master scale principleusing loudness of pink noise as a reference scale [42 to 96dB(A)]. The results showed significantly higher odor detectionthresholds for smokers than for non-smokers, 94 and 55 ppb,respectively, and significantly lower odor intensities reportedby smokers than non-smokers. In evaluating the observers' audiograms,the smokers displayed significantly higher thresholds of hearingthan the non-smokers. The results support the possibility thathabitual cigarette smoking may result in decreased sensitivityof sensory systems in general.     

DETERMINATION OF SENSORY OIL-WATER PARTITION COEFFICIENTS OF SINGLE AROMA COMPOUNDS COMBINING PANELIST FREE INTENSITY RATING AND THEORETICAL MODELING OF ODOR INTENSITY

Using an intensity rating with no external calibration, experiments were designed to measure the sensory oil-water partition coefficients of four aroma molecules (benzaldehyde, ethyl butyrate, linalool and acetophenone) as the ratios of concentration producing stimuli of equivalent intensities. Flavored water and oil phases were successively assessed for odor intensity by 24 panelists who were given total freedom regarding scaling strategy. Each session combined five concentration levels of three out of the four studied aromas in a solvent (water or oil). A predominant concentration effect was found for each aroma in both solvents and concentration dependencies of perceived intensity above water and oil were similar. Experimental data were modeled with Fechner, Stevens and Hill equations. Combining results above water and oil solutions to feed a common model led to the evaluation of an overall sensory oil-water partition coefficient for each aroma compound. All three models produced similar partition coefficient values for each aroma that were lower than the related instrumental partition coefficients. Biases previously detected when external calibration had been used were reduced in a large proportion while suggested enhancement of odor intensity by water vapor could not be excluded.     

THE DISRIMINATIVE EFFICIENCY OF COMMON SCALING METHODS

Four types of rating scales, nine-point category scales, line marking, magnitude estimation, and a hybrid of the category and line scale, were employed to assess visual, tactile and olfactory characteristics of products by consumers. The scales were compared for their ability to discriminate differences among products, for variability, for reliability, and for ease of use. All methods were able to generate highly significant differences among products. However, a modest advantage for category scales was observed in almost all comparisons.     

Development of a smell identification test using a novel stick-type odor presentation kit

The odor identification is strongly influenced by the social and cultural factors; therefore, the odorants used in a smell identification test should be familiar to the test population. In addition, the device used in the test is desired to be simply handled and retain odor quality over time. We developed a novel stick-type odor presentation kit that consists of microcapsules of odorant incorporated into stable cream and the smell identification test using it. Thirteen odorants were selected to be familiar to the test population. In the test, we used two identification methods: one was a modified forced-choice paradigm with "detectable but not recognizable" and "no smell detected" added as choices and the other was a two-step identification paradigm where the participant first selected one of eight odor categories and then chose the specific odor name from the selected category. We verified the performance of the odor stick and the test by stability, using a test-retest paradigm, comparing this test with another smell test, and testing Japanese people from a range of age groups. We conclude that this kit is a useful odor presentation device, and the test using it works effectively as a smell identification test.     

APPLICATIONS OF SENSORY SCIENCE WITHIN THE TOBACCO INDUSTRY

Sensory testing of cigarette smoke presents some unique problems to the sensory specialist. This is due to a variety of reasons including the high degree of similarity between blended cigarettes and a high degree of variability between individual cigarettes. In the cigarette industry, a large effort has been placed on adapting and developing new methods of collecting and analyzing sensory-data on both flavorants and cigarette smoke. These methods include odor profiling and multidimensional scaling based on attributes and acceptability scales. In addition, extensive research has been conducted to determine the number of relevent dimensions to smoking and the types of changes that could affect consumer acceptance or purchase behavior.     

Behavioral strategies underlying pheromone-modulated flight in moths: lessons from simulation studies

Several mechanisms have been proposed to underlie the characteristic `zigzag' tracks produced by moths flying up an odor plume. To test which, if any, of these are capable of reproducing the animals' behavior, we constructed behavioral-level simulations. The simulations are as tightly constrained as possible by the known biology, and incorporate realistic physical effects such as air turbulence, and delays due to sensory transduction and axonal condition, to mimic the dynamics of sensory information encountered by real moths. Formulated as schemas, the models all share a common set of sensory and motor systems, but differ in the interposed control systems. We analyzed the behavior of the models with the same methods we use for real moths. Even the simplest of the models was capable of successful orientation some of the time, and of producing flight tracks similar to those of moths. Individuals which succeeded in tracking the odor plume produced average behavior not significantly different from that of real moths. As a population, however, none of the models was as successful as the moths. The best of the models had a success rate in tracking the plume of about 30%, compared to the average of 70% seen in the insects. Accepted: 25 March 1998     

IMPROVEMENT OF TRIANGLE TEST DATA BY USE OF INCENTIVES

The objectives of this study were to determine the distribution of the sensory panelists' ability to detect differences and to improve the triangle test by minimizing unnecessary guessing. The triangle test was modified to include the use of economic incentives through which panelists voluntarily revealed their ability to detect differences. Panelists were asked to estimate their ability to detect differences and the probability of identifying the odd sample in a triangle test. They were then organized into three ability groups according to their responses. Double triangle tests, followed by triangle tests with economic incentives, were used to evaluate a cereal product and a beverage. The ability to detect differences was modeled as a probability, and the distribution of panelists was estimated. The economic incentives test was more effective when used with the beverage in which differences were less difficult to detect. We found that the economic incentive test discouraged the panelists from guessing unnecessarily, thus increasing the motivation of the panelists to detect differences, and allowing researchers to determine the distribution of discrimination ability.     

THE ROLE OF THE KNOWLEDGE OF COLOR AND BRAND NAME ON THE CONSUMER'S HEDONIC RATINGS OF TOMATO PUREES

The objective of study was to assess the influence of the knowledge of color and brand name on consumer response to tomato purees. From focus group interviews it was found that taste and odor of fresh tomato were the most important drivers of consumer choice. To quantify that information a questionnaire was developed and it was submitted to fifty consumers of tomato puree. The questionnaires answers confirmed those coming from the focus group, although same discrepancies were found with those derived from the consumer test. Results showed that color and brand name seemed to be more important than taste and odor of fresh tomato, in fact those attributes, when consumers were tasting samples, affected not only hedonic judgments but sensory perception as well. Finally physico-chemical parameters derived from instrumental measurements have been compared to sensory data by means of PCA in order to validate the consumers'assessment of sensory attributes of tomato puree.