Separation and concentration of phytoplankton populations using centrifugal elutriation

Centrifugal elutriation is a technique for separating particles on the basis of their sedimentation velocity, an expression of size, shape, and specific gravity. Unialgal cultures, mixtures of two phytoplankton cultures, and natural seawater samples were elutriated to determine the feasibility of this technique for collecting fractions of different cell cycle phases, separating two phytoplankton species, and concentrating cells from dilute samples. Elutriation resulted in the separation of a culture of Dunaliella tertiolecta and Phaeodactylum tricornutum into homogeneous fractions of each species. Cells in the natural seawater sample were concentrated by nearly 2 orders of magnitude. Centrifugal elutriation provides an alternative cell separation and concentration technique when large numbers of cells are required.     

Theory and practice of centrifugal elutriation (CE). Factors influencing the separation of human blood cells

Centrifugal elutriation (CE) is currently a widely used preparative cell separation technique. In order to optimize the separation of cells that show only small differences in sedimentation velocity, several conditions that might influence the resolution capacity, such as rotor speed, counterflow, jetstream, cell load, density, and viscosity of the elutriation medium, were analyzed. Experiments carried out with human red blood cells (rbc) indicated that selective losses of rbc from the rotor caused by the jetstream, could be prevented if the separations were carried out at high rotor speeds, as predicted by the theory. In addition, high cell loads (5 X 10(8) rbc) resulted in better separations than low cell loads (5 X 10(7) rbc). Human monocytes were separated into subpopulations that differed only about 0.003 g/mL in density, but have virtually the same size. The separation was carried out either by increasing the density or viscosity of the elutriation medium or by decreasing the rotor speed. In all cases similar results were obtained. These results indicated that under optimal conditions CE can be applied for the separation of cells that differ only slightly in sedimentation velocity.     

Theory and practice of centrifugal elutriation (CE)

Centrifugal elutriation (CE) is currently a widely used preparative cell separation technique. In order to optimize the separation of cells that show only small differences in sedimentation velocity, several conditions that might influence the resolution capacity, such as rotor speed, counterflow, jetstream, cell load, density, and viscosity of the elutriation medium, were analyzed. Experiments carried out with human red blood cells (rbc) indicated that aselective losses of rbc from the rotor caused by the jetstream, could be prevented if the separations were carried out at high rotor speeds, as predicted by the theory. In addition, high cell loads (5×10⁸ rbc) resulted in better separations than low cell loads (5×10⁷ rbc). Human monocytes were separated into subpopulations that differed only about 0.003 g/mL in density, but have virtually the same size. The separation was carried out either by increasing the density or viscosity of the elutriation medium or by decreasing the rotor speed. In all cases similar results were obtained. These results indicated that under optimal conditions CE can be applied for the separation of cells that differ only slightly in sedimentation velocity.     

Isolation and characterization of cell cycle-enriched subpopulations of a murine macrophage cell line by centrifugal elutriation

The cell cycle of the P388D 1 murine macrophage line was delineated and suspensions of exponentially growing cells were separated by centrifugal elutriation into subpopulations enriched in the various phases of the cycle. Analysis of both growth and labelled mitoses curves disclosed that the doubling and cell-cycle times were essentially identical (18.4 and 18.3 h), indicating that all cells were in cycle. In addition, G1 + 1/2M was 4.3 h, whereas S phase and G2 + 1/2M lasted about 12 and 1.5 h. The most homogeneous subpopulations of phase-enriched cells obtained by elutriation were cells in G1 and S, where purities (estimated by both labelling indices and analyses of DNA histograms obtained by flow cytometry) exceeded 80%. Isolation of G2 + M-phase cells was not as efficient, although the purity of these subpopulations was consistently greater than of 50%, an approx. 10-fold enrichment over unseparated suspensions of cells. Comparison of IgG2a-Fc-receptor-mediated phagocytic activities among the phase-enriched subpopulations showed that cells in G2 had appreciably enhanced activity.     

Centrifugal elutriation (counterstreaming centrifugation) of cells.

Lindahl first described the separation of cells by velocity sedimentation utilizing a special technique (counterstreaming centrifugation) that was later modified slightly and renamed centrifugal elutriation. Centrifugal elutriation has been applied, with variable degrees of success, to the separation of hemopoietic cells, mouse tumor cells, testicular cells, and a variety of other specialized cells as well as cells in particular phases of the cell cycle. The capacity of the elutriator to separate large numbers of cells is its chief advantage. The purities of the separated cells have not been compared with the purities of cells separated by other methods in most cases; such comparisons would permit more sophisticated comparison of elutriation with other techniques for velocity sedimentation.     

Centrifugal elutriation (counterstreaming centrifugation) of cells

Lindahl first described the separation of cells by velocity sedimentation utilizing a special technique (counterstreaming centrifugation) that was later modified slightly and renamed centrifugal elutriation. Centrifugal elutriation has been applied, with variable degrees of success, to the separation of hemopoietic cells, mouse tumor cells, testicular cells, and a variety of other specialized cells as well as cells in particular phases of the cell cycle. The capacity of the elutriator to separate large numbers of cells is its chief advantage. The purities of the separated cells have not been compared with the purities of cells separated by other methods in most cases; such comparisons would permit more sophisticated comparison of elutriation with other techniques for velocity sedimentation.     

Cell separation by countercurrent centrifugal elutriation: recent developments

Countercurrent centrifugal elutriation (CCE) is a cell separation technique that separates particles predominantly according to their size, and to some degree according to their specific density, without a need for antibodies or ligands tagging cell surfaces. The principles of this technique have been known for half a century. Still, numerous recent publications confirmed that CCE is a valuable supplement to current cell separation technology. It is mainly applied when homogeneous populations of cells, which mirror an in vivo situation, are required for answering scientific questions or for clinical transplantation, while antibodies or ligands suitable for cell isolation are not available. Currently, new technical developments are expanding its application toward fractionation of healthy and malignant tissue cells and the preparation of dendritic cells for immunotherapy.     

Endothelial cell subpopulations in vitro: cell volume, cell cycle, and radiosensitivity

Vascular endothelial cells (EC) are important clinical targets of radiation and other forms of free radical/oxidant stresses. In this study, we found that the extent of endothelial damage may be determined by the different cytotoxic responses of EC subpopulations. The following characteristics of EC subpopulations were examined: 1) cell volume; 2) cell cycle position; and 3) cytotoxic indexes for both acute cell survival and proliferative capacity after irradiation (137Cs, gamma, 0-10 Gy). EC cultured from bovine aortas were separated by centrifugal elutriation into subpopulations of different cell volumes. Through flow cytometry, we found that cell volume was related to the cell cycle phase distribution. The smallest EC were distributed in G1 phase and the larger cells were distributed in either early S, middle S, or late S + G2M phases. Cell cycle phase at the time of irradiation was not associated with acute cell loss. However, distribution in the cell cycle did relate to cell survival based on proliferative capacity (P less than 0.01). The order of increasing radioresistance was cells in G1 (D0 = 110 cGy), early S (135 cGy), middle S (145 cGy), and late S + G2M phases (180 cGy). These findings 1) suggest an age-related response to radiation in a nonmalignant differentiated cell type and 2) demonstrate EC subpopulations in culture.     

Centrifugal elutriation of human lymphoid cells: synchronization and separation of aneuploid cells into diploid and tetraploid populations

Both normal and leukemic human lymphoid cell lines were separated into populations corresponding to different positions in the cell cycle by centrifugal elutriation. Each population was analyzed for cell concentration, cell volume, [3H]thymidine incorporation, percentage S phase by autoradiography, and percent G1, S, and G2/M phases by flow cytometry. The smallest cells, collected at the lowest flow rate, were in G1 phase. Cells collected at increasing flow rates progressively increased in volume and represented distinct positions in the cell cycle transition from G1 phase, through S phase, and into G2/M phase. The purity of the G1 population varied according to cell load. One hundred percent of cells were recovered and cells collected in G1- and S-phase populations proliferated in culture with patterns characteristic of synchronized cells. An aneuploidy leukemia cell line, CEM, was separated into near-diploid and near-tetraploid populations by centrifugal elutriation. This method of cell separation provides large numbers of human lymphoid cells at different positions in the cell cycle for investigating the relationship between the cell cycle and various surface membrane and metabolic properties of cells. Aneuploid leukemia and lymphoma cells can be separated by centrifugal elutriation into populations which contain different numbers of chromosomes for comparisons of their biologic properties.     

Isolation of human mononuclear cell subsets by counterflow centrifugal elutriation (CCE). I. Characterization of B-lymphocyte-, T-lymphocyte-, and monocyte-enriched fractions by flow cytometric analysis

Rapid separation of large numbers of human peripheral blood mononuclear cells into fractions enriched for B lymphocytes, T lymphocytes, or monocytes was accomplished by counterflow centrifugal elutriation (CCE). The first fraction contained 98% of the platelets. Ten additional fractions containing subpopulations of mononuclear cells were collected by sequential increases in the flow rate while maintaining a constant centrifuge speed. Analysis of the fractions using monoclonal antibodies revealed that fraction 2, which was free of esterase-positive monocytes, was highly enriched for B cells. T lymphocytes (OKT3+) were the predominant cell type found in fraction 4. No enrichment for T-lymphocyte-helper (OKT4+) or -suppressor (OKT8+) subpopulations was observed in the lymphocyte containing fractions. Three fractions (7-9), highly enriched for esterase-positive cells, were predominantly OKM1+ monocytes with no evidence of selective separation of monocyte subpopulations. Thus, cell fractions enriched for B cells, T cells, and monocytes could be obtained, by utilizing CCE, in large enough quantities to enable analysis of their functional properties. Of particular interest was the ability to separate small, resting B lymphocytes from monocytes.     

Protein factors in extracts of ribosomes isolated from L-929 cells during various phases of the cell cycle

Centrifugal elutriation has been utilized in order to separate cultures of L-929 fibroblasts into subpopulations containing cells at different stages of the cell cycle. The subpopulations were characterized by Coulter counter volume determination, [3H]thymidine label into DNA and flow cytometry. When a population of early G1 cells was returned to roller culture it was shown to progress through the cell cycle in a synchronous manner. Ribosomal factor extracts were prepared from cells at various phases during the cell cycle. The amounts of protein in the extracts varied greatly, being lowest in early G1 phase and showing a peak during S phase. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis demonstrated that there were differences in the protein species present in the extracts. Some proteins were present in the same amounts throughout the cell cycle, whereas others appeared to show a form of cyclical behaviour.     

Identification of subpopulations in mesenchymal stem cell-like cultures from human umbilical cord

Background

A variety of cell types can be identified in the adherent fraction of bone marrow mononuclear cells including more primitive and embryonic-like stem cells, mesenchymal stem cells (MSC), lineage-committed progenitors as well as mature cells such as osteoblasts and fibroblasts. Different methods are described for the isolation of single bone marrow stem cell subpopulations - beginning from ordinary size sieving, long term cultivation under specific conditions to FACS-based approaches. Besides bone marrow-derived subpopulations, also other tissues including human umbilical cord (UC) have been recently suggested to provide a potential source for MSC. Although of clinical importance, these UC-derived MSC populations remain to be characterized. It was thus the aim of the present study to identify possible subpopulations in cultures of MSC-like cells obtained from UC. We used counterflow centrifugal elutriation (CCE) as a novel strategy to successfully address this question.

Results

UC-derived primary cells were separated by CCE and revealed differentially-sized populations in the fractions. Thus, a subpopulation with an average diameter of about 11 μm and a small flat cell body was compared to a large sized subpopulation of about 19 μm average diameter. Flow cytometric analysis revealed the expression of certain MSC stem cell markers including CD44, CD73, CD90 and CD105, respectively, although these markers were expressed at higher levels in the small-sized population. Moreover, this small-sized subpopulation exhibited a higher proliferative capacity as compared to the total UC-derived primary cultures and the large-sized cells and demonstrated a reduced amount of aging cells.

Conclusion

Using the CCE technique, we were the first to demonstrate a subpopulation of small-sized UC-derived primary cells carrying MSC-like characteristics according to the presence of various mesenchymal stem cell markers. This is also supported by the high proliferative capacity of these MSC-like cells as compared to whole primary culture or other UC-derived subpopulations. The accumulation of a self-renewing MSC-like subpopulation by CCE with low expression levels of the aging marker senescence-associated β-galactosidase provides a valuable tool in the regenerative medicine and an alternative to bone-marrow-derived MSC.     

Characterization of the efficiency of a cell separation process by the extent of elimination of a contaminating cell type

A stepwise approach to the selection of an appropriate technique for a cell separation problem is presented in which the preparative purification of cells is linked to their analytical separation. We have introduced the extent of elimination of a contaminating cell type from the cell type which one chooses to purify, as a separation parameter that characterizes the efficiency of a separation process independently of the relative cell composition of the starting material. In order to compare different separation techniques, a preparative fraction boundary needs to be chosen between the cell types. We defined this boundary in terms of the physical property on which the separation is based such that yield and purity of the isolated cell suspension are optimized simultaneously. With this analytical approach, it was found that a similar elutriation technique separated human and equine mononuclear cells equally well and that the separability of human monocytes and lymphocytes improved when the cells were separated by increasing the limiting sedimentation coefficient value of the elutriation chamber in small increments.     

Hepatocyte ploidy in normal young rat

The aim of the present study was to examine the relation between hepatocyte size and ploidy in Sprague-Dawley rat liver. Therefore, subpopulations of hepatocytes of various sizes were separated from the isolated crude hepatocyte population either mechanically or by using centrifugal elutriation. Hepatocyte size was determined on scanning electron microscopy photographs. Ploidy of hepatocytes was assessed by flow cytometry. The crude hepatocyte population was very heterogeneous in sizes, with diameters ranging from 8 to 39 microm. Hepatocyte ultrastructure was well preserved as demonstrated by transmission electron microscopy. The distribution of hepatocytes within the ploidy classes was the following: 19.6+/-3.6% diploid, 56.2+/-3.2% tetraploid and 3.4+/-0.6% octoploid mononucleated cells. Thus approximately 79% of hepatocytes appeared mononucleated. The binucleated hepatocytes (21%) had two diploid nuclei (18.7+/-2.9%) or two tetraploid nuclei (2.1+/-0.6%). A similar distribution of hepatocytes into ploidy classes was obtained in subpopulations of hepatocytes of various sizes. Our findings suggest that distribution into ploidy classes is not strictly correlated with hepatocyte size. In accordance with previous observations, our results on hepatocyte ploidy from periportal or perivenous origin using digitonin perfusion, is in favour of the existence of ploidy zonation within the rat hepatic lobule.     

Chemical protection and cell-cycle effects on radiation-induced mutagenesis

Chinese hamster ovary cells in the exponential phase of growth were harvested and separated by the method of centrifugal elutriation into subpopulations enriched with up to 95% G1 phase, 70% S phase and 65% G2 + M phase cells. Cell cycle distributions were routinely monitored by flow cytometry. Following elutriation, aliquots of cells from each of the enriched cell fractions were incubated in the presence or absence of 4 mM of 2-[(aminopropyl)amino] ethanethiol (WR-1065) for 30 min at 37 degrees C. The cells were then irradiated with 60Co gamma-rays or fission-spectrum neutrons from the JANUS research reactor. Both cell killing and mutagenesis were determined. Regardless of the radiation quality used, cells enriched in G1 phase were the most sensitive to radiation-induced mutagenesis at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase locus. The relative magnitude of protection exerted by WR-1065 differed for each of the elutriator separated cell populations. The greatest magnitude of protection, however, was observed for G1-enriched populations, regardless of the radiation quality used or the biological end-point tested.     

Cell cycle responses of heterogeneous human colon adenocarcinoma subpopulations to X-irradiation

The cell cycle responses of two exponentially growing subpopulations of cells (clones A and D), originally obtained from a human colon adenocarcinoma to X-irradiation, were studied using centrifugal elutriation. Cell suspensions were separated by changing counter-current flow rate while keeping the rotor speed constant (1600 rpm) and the composition of eluted fractions was determined using flow cytometry. The X-ray sensitivity of unseparated clone D cells was somewhat greater than that of clone A cells (e.g. 10% greater at the 10% level of survival). This difference appeared to be due to a greater value of the alpha parameter (one-hit cell killing), using the linear-quadratic equation in which the relative survival S/S0 = exp - (alpha D + beta D2) with dose (D) in Gy. This finding was confirmed in the cell cycle studies where the alpha parameter was always greater for the clone D cells than for the clone A cells. The beta parameter was essentially the same for both cell lines through the cell cycle.     

Allocation of the suppressive activity of normal peripheral blood lymphocytes induced by diffusion chamber culture and Con A stimulation to the G2 phase of the cell cycle

Peripheral blood mononuclear cells stimulated either by diffusion chamber culture or by a high Con A concentration exhibit suppressive activity under conditions where no increase in cell number takes place. Instead an accumulation of large cells is observed which, according to their DNA contents, are classified as cells in the G2 phase of the cell cycle. By elutriation separation the suppressive activity is shown to be confined to this cell cycle phase.     

Analysis of MOPC-315 plasmacytoma by elutriation and flow cytometry

Intravenously transplanted murine plasmacytoma MOPC-315 cells were separated from normal spleen cells from a tumour-bearing mouse by elutriation and characterized according to morphology, immunologic properties and clonogenicity. Morphologically, both lymphocytoid and plasmacytoid cells were separable by elutriation. Flow cytometry correlated DNA content and intracytoplasmic IgA content and demonstrated two distinct populations, both in cell cycle, but with markedly different cellular IgA levels. Density gradient separation characterized the lower-density cells with lower IgA content and higher clonogenicity. From these studies a model of cellular differentiation is proposed.     

Synchronization of mouse 3T3 and SV40 3T3 cells by way of centrifugal elutriation

Populations of G1 phase 3T3 and SV40 3T3 mouse fibroblasts have been isolated from exponentially growing cultures by the technique of centrifugal elutriation. Return of the G1 phase cells to growth conditions results in their synchronous passage through the cell cycle, as determined from monitoring of cell number, [³H]thymidine ([³H]TdR) incorporation and fraction of [³H]TdR labeled nuclei. The durations of G1, S and G2 phases are consistent with values obtained by previous investigators using conventional induction techniques for synchronization. The method for isolation of the G1 phase cells is rapid, the yield is high and the process does not appear to alter the temporal aspects of the cell cycle in either cell type.     

Analysis of Mopc-315 Plasmacytoma By Elutriation and Flow Cytometry

ABSTRACT Intravenously transplanted murine plasmacytoma MOPC-315 cells were separated from normal spleen cells from a tumour-bearing mouse by elutriation and characterized according to morphology, immunologic properties and clonogenicity. Morphologically, both lymphocytoid and plasmacytoid cells were separable by elutriation. Flow cytometry correlated DNA content and intracytoplasmic IgA content and demonstrated two distinct populations, both in cell cycle, but with markedly different cellular IgA levels. Density gradient separation characterized the lower-density cells with lower IgA content and higher clonogenicity. From these studies a model of cellular differentiation is proposed.