Aliphatic ionenes as gene delivery agents: elucidation of structure-function relationship through modification of charge density and polymer length

Polycation-based gene delivery agents are generally polydisperse populations whose properties are averaged among the different molecular weight species. Therefore, to understand the physicochemical properties of polycations and their relationships to cellular gene transfer, one needs to control the molecular weight of the polymer as well as its cationic charge density. To investigate the structure-function correlation of polycations with respect to the degree of polymerization (DP) and charge density, a series of model materials based on aliphatic ionenes was synthesized and fractionated into distinct molecular weight fractions with DP range from 14 to 32. The aliphatic ionene fractions and their polyelectrolyte complexes (PEC) with DNA were studied using physicochemical and biological methods. Ionene polymers were shown to possess low cytotoxicity (minimal viability of the P388D1 murine macrophage cells 80%). DP and charge density of the ionenes were shown to be the factors of effective control of PEC dissociation in water-salt solutions, with a diminished role of charge density upon lengthening the ionene chain. These polymer characteristics were also important for DNA-ionene PEC resistivity to DNase activity and the ability of ionenes to serve as gene delivery vectors in vitro and exhibited good correlation with the results of salt-induced dissociation of PEC. These data may be useful for developing correlations and mathematical models to predict synthetic gene delivery vector efficiency.     

Charge density and molecular weight of polyphosphoramidate gene carrier are key parameters influencing its DNA compaction ability and transfection efficiency

A series of polyphosphoramidates (PPAs) with different molecular weights (MWs) and charge densities were synthesized and examined for their DNA compaction ability and transfection efficiency. A strong correlation was observed between the transfection efficiency of PPA/DNA nanoparticles and the MW and net positive charge density of the PPA gene carriers in three different cell lines (HeLa, HEK293, and HepG2 cells). An increase in MW and net positive charge density of PPA carrier yielded higher DNA compaction capacity, smaller nanoparticles with higher surface charges, and higher complex stability against challenges by salt and polyanions. These favorable physicochemical properties of nanoparticles led to enhanced transfection efficiency. PPA/DNA nanoparticles with the highest complex stability showed comparable transfection efficiency as PEI/DNA nanoparticles likely by compensating the low buffering capacity with higher cellular uptake and affording higher level of protection to DNA in endolysosomal compartment. The differences in transfection efficiency were not attributed by any difference in cytotoxicity among the carriers, as all nanoparticles showed a minimal level of cytotoxicity under the transfection conditions. Using PPA as a model system, we demonstrated the structural dependence of transfection efficiency of polymer gene carrier. These results offer more insights into nanoparticle engineering for nonviral gene delivery.     

Gene delivery properties of end-modified poly(beta-amino ester)s

Here, we present the synthesis of a library of end-modified poly(beta-amino ester)s and assess their utility as gene delivery vehicles. Polymers were synthesized using a rapid, two-step approach that involves initial preparation of an acrylate-terminated polymer followed by a postpolymerization amine-capping step to generate end-functionalized polymers. Using a highly efficient poly(beta-amino ester), C32, we show that the terminal amine can greatly affect and improve polymer properties relevant to gene delivery. Specifically, the in vitro transfection levels can be increased by 30% and the optimal polymer:DNA ratio lowered 5-fold by conjugation of the appropriate end group. The most effective modifications were made by grafting primary diamine molecules to the chain termini. The added charge and hydrophobicity of some derivatives enhanced DNA binding and resulted in the formation of polymer-DNA complexes less than 100 nm in diameter. In addition, cellular uptake was improved 5-fold over unmodified C32. The end-modified poly(beta-amino ester)s presented here are some of the most effective gene-delivery polycations, superior to polyethylenimine and previously reported poly(beta-amino ester)s. These results show that the end-modification of poly(beta-amino ester)s is a general strategy to alter functionality and improve the delivery performance of these materials.     

Poly (beta-amino ester) as an in vivo nanocarrier for therapeutic nucleic acids

Therapeutic nucleic acids are an emerging class of therapy for treating various diseases through immunomodulation, protein replacement, gene editing, and genetic engineering. However, they need a vector to effectively and safely reach the target cells. Most gene and cell therapies rely on ex vivo gene delivery, which is laborious, time-consuming, and costly; therefore, devising a systematic vector for effective and safe in vivo delivery of therapeutic nucleic acids is required to target the cells of interest in an efficient manner. Synthetic nanoparticle vector poly beta amino ester (PBAE), a class of degradable polymer, is a promising candidate for in vivo gene delivery. PBAE is considered the most potent in vivo vector due to its excellent transfection performance and biodegradability. PBAE nanoparticles showed tunable charge density, diverse structural characteristics, excellent encapsulation capacity, high stability, stimuli-responsive release, site-specific delivery, potent binding to nucleic acids, flexible binding ability to various conjugates, and effective endosomal escape. These unique properties of PBAE are an essential contribution to in vivo gene delivery. The current review discusses each of the components used for PBAE synthesis and the impact of various environmental and physicochemical factors of the body on PBAE nanocarrier.     

Use of locked nucleic acid oligonucleotides to add functionality to plasmid DNA

The available reagents for the attachment of functional moieties to plasmid DNA are limiting. Most reagents bind plasmid DNA in a non-sequence- specific manner, with undefined stoichiometry, and affect DNA charge and delivery properties or involve chemical modifications that abolish gene expression. The design and ability of oligonucleotides (ODNs) containing locked nucleic acids (LNAs) to bind supercoiled, double-stranded plasmid DNA in a sequence-specific manner are described for the first time. The main mechanism for LNA ODNs binding plasmid DNA is demonstrated to be by strand displacement. LNA ODNs are more stably bound to plasmid DNA than similar peptide nucleic acid (PNA) ‘clamps’ for procedures such as particle-mediated DNA delivery (gene gun). It is shown that LNA ODNs remain associated with plasmid DNA after cationic lipid-mediated transfection into mammalian cells. LNA ODNs can bind to DNA in a sequence-specific manner so that binding does not interfere with plasmid conformation or gene expression. Attachment of CpG-based immune adjuvants to plasmid by ‘hybrid’ phosphorothioate–LNA ODNs induces tumour necrosis factor-α production in the macrophage cell line RAW264.7. This observation exemplifies an important new, controllable methodology for adding functionality to plasmids for gene delivery and DNA vaccination.     

Protein-polymer nanoparticles for nonviral gene delivery

Protein-polymer conjugates were investigated as nonviral gene delivery vectors. BSA-poly(dimethylamino) ethyl methacrylate (PDMA) nanoparticles (nBSA) were synthesized using in situ atom transfer radical polymerization (in situ ATRP) and BSA as a macroinitiator. The diameter and charge of nBSA was a function of the ATRP reaction time and ranged from 5 to 15 nm and +8.9 to +22.5, respectively. nBSA were able to condense plasmid DNA (pDNA) and form polyplexes with an average diameter of 50 nm. nBSA/pDNA polyplexes transfected cells with similar efficiencies or better as compared to linear and branched PEI. Interestingly, the nBSA particle diameter and charge did not affect pDNA complexation and transgene expression, indicating that the same gene delivery efficiency can be achieved with lower charge ratios. We believe that with the use of protein-polymer conjugates additional functionality could be introduced to polyplexes by using different protein cores and, thus, they pose an interesting alternative to the design of nonviral gene delivery vectors.     

Development of multicomponent DNA delivery systems based upon poly(amidoamine)-PEG co-polymers

PEGylated polyamidoamine (PAA) polymers were investigated for the production of sterically stabilised DNA delivery systems. Comparison of a PEGylated polymer (NG47) with a non-PEGylated polymer (NG49) showed similar binding of co-polymer to DNA by displacement of ethidium bromide (EB) and DNA melting studies. Gel electrophoresis, turbidimetric analysis and PCS demonstrated differences in the colloidal properties of the complexes, which were attributable to the formation of soluble complexes by the PEGylated co-polymer. However, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) showed that the resulting complexes containing poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) were not well condensed, susceptible to degradation by nucleases, and thus not suited for in vivo delivery. The poor properties of the PEGylated co-polymer were attributed to an excess of PEG. However, polymer blends of NG47 and NG49 at defined ratios of polymer to co-polymer and total repeating units (RUs) to nucleotide, spontaneously formed complexes with a range of desirable properties. These included small size and polydispersity, high particle density, low surface charge and resistance to nuclease degradation. Complexes made with PEGylated polymer alone, and the polymer blends both suffered from a reduced polyfection activity. This was attributed to a low surface charge on the complex, which reduced interactions with the cell membrane and consequent uptake of the particles into the cell.     

Structure-activity examination of poly(glycoamidoguanidine)s: glycopolycations containing guanidine units for nucleic acid delivery

In this study we synthesized a new series of polymers known as poly(glycoamidoguanidine)s (PGAGs). These new polymer structures were synthesized by copolymerizing a carbohydrate monomer (diester; galatarate or tartarate) with a diamine incorporating guanidine or methylguanidine as a charge center to create a polyamide backbone. These materials were strategically designed and compared to our previously studied DNA delivery vehicles, poly(glycoamidoamine)s (PGAAs), which contain secondary amines as the charge groups along the polymer backbone to examine the effect of charge center type on the cellular delivery efficiency of plasmid DNA (pDNA). The guanidine moieties within the PGAGs facilitate electrostatic binding with the negatively charged phosphate backbone of plasmid DNA (pDNA). Stable polymer-pDNA complexes (polyplexes) with sizes in the range of 60-200 nm are formed at polymer/pDNA charge ratios (N/P) of 5 and above. When the PGAGs are complexed with Cy5-labeled pDNA (Cy5-pDNA) at N/P ratios of 10 and 25, between 80 and 95% of HeLa cells were positive for Cy5 fluorescence, indicating effective cellular internalization of the polyplexes. The toxicity of both PGAA and PGAG polyplexes was studied via MTT assays, and over 95% cell survival was observed at N/P ratios of 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, and 30 in HeLa cells. Transgene expression was examined via luciferase assays at various N/P ratios in the absence and presence of serum. In the absence of serum, the PGAG polyplexes revealed similar transgene expression when compared to polyplexes formed with their analogous PGAA structures. In the presence of serum, one analog (Gg) consisting of galactarate copolymerized with the guanidine monomer yielded gene expression similar to the positive control, Glycofect Transfection Reagent. This new series of guanidine-containing oligomers are promising as a new design strategy to incorporate an alternative charge center type within the backbone of glycopolymer-based nucleic acid delivery vehicles.     

Regulation of in vitro gene expression using antisense oligonucleotides or antisense expression plasmids transfected using starburst PAMAM dendrimers.

Starburst polyamidoamine (PAMAM) dendrimers are a new type of synthetic polymer characterized by a branched spherical shape and a high density surface charge. We have investigated the ability of these dendrimers to function as an effective delivery system for antisense oligonucleotides and 'antisense expression plasmids' for the targeted modulation of gene expression. Dendrimers bind to various forms of nucleic acids on the basis of electrostatic interactions, and the ability of DNA-dendrimer complexes to transfer oligonucleotides and plasmid DNA to mediate antisense inhibition was assessed in an in vitro cell culture system. Cell lines that permanently express luciferase gene were developed using dendrimer mediated transfection. Transfections of antisense oligonucleotides or antisense cDNA plasmids into these cell lines using dendrimers resulted in a specific and dose dependent inhibition of luciferase expression. This inhibition caused approximately 25-50% reduction of baseline luciferase activity. Binding of the phosphodiester oligonucleotides to dendrimers also extended their intracellular survival. While dendrimers were not cytotoxic at the concentrations effective for DNA transfer, some non-specific suppression of luciferase expression was observed. Our results indicate that Starburst dendrimers can be effective carriers for the introduction of regulatory nucleic acids and facilitate the suppression of the specific gene expression.     

Design of imidazole-containing endosomolytic biopolymers for gene delivery

The development of safe and effective gene delivery agents poses a great challenge in the quest to make human gene therapy a reality. Cationic polymers represent one important class of materials for gene delivery, but to date they have shown only moderate efficiency. Improving the efficiency will require the design of new polymers incorporating optimized gene delivery properties. For example, inefficient release of the DNA/polymer complex from endocytic vesicles into the cytoplasm is one of the primary causes of poor gene delivery. Here we report the synthesis of a biocompatible, imidazole-containing polymer designed to overcome this obstacle. DNA/polymer polyplexes incorporating this polymer were shown to have desirable physico-chemical properties for gene delivery and are essentially nontoxic. Using this system, mammalian cells in vitro were transfected in the absence of any exogenous endosomolytic agent such as chloroquine.     

Physicochemical properties of polymers: An important system to overcome the cell barriers in gene transfection

Delivery of the macromolecules including DNA, miRNA, and antisense oligonucleotides is typically mediated by carriers due to the large size and negative charge. Different physical (e.g., gene gun or electroporation), and chemical (e.g., cationic polymer or lipid) vectors have been already used to improve the efficiency of gene transfer. Polymer‐based DNA delivery systems have attracted special interest, in particular via intravenous injection with many intra‐ and extracellular barriers. The recent progress has shown that stimuli‐responsive polymers entitled as multifunctional nucleic acid vehicles can act to target specific cells. These nonviral carriers are classified by the type of stimulus including reduction potential, pH, and temperature. Generally, the physicochemical characterization of DNA‐polymer complexes is critical to enhance the transfection potency via protection of DNA from nuclease digestion, endosomal escape, and nuclear localization. The successful clinical applications will depend on an exact insight of barriers in gene delivery and development of carriers overcoming these barriers. Consequently, improvement of novel cationic polymers with low toxicity and effective for biomedical use has attracted a great attention in gene therapy. This article summarizes the main physicochemical and biological properties of polyplexes describing their gene transfection behavior, in vitro and in vivo. In this line, the relative efficiencies of various cationic polymers are compared. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 103: 363–375, 2015.     

Effect of polymer ionization on the interaction with DNA in nonviral gene delivery systems

The optimization of DNA-cationic polymer complexation is crucial for nonviral gene delivery. Although physicochemical characterization of the interaction between DNA and cationic polymers has recently attracted more attention in the nonviral DNA delivery field, the literature on the effect of varying polycation charge density on DNA-cationic polymer complexation is still scarce. Thus, the aim of this study was to systematically assess the influence of the degree of ionization of a weak cationic polyelectrolyte (poly[2-(dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate] or DMAEMA homopolymer) on its ability to form complexes with DNA. This was achieved by varying the solution pH from 4.0 to 8.0 and analyzing the resulting effects on the binding affinity, thermodynamic properties, complex size, and morphology. Lowering the solution pH led to higher degrees of ionization for the cationic polymer and hence greater binding affinities with DNA, as judged by the increased propensity of the former to displace ethidium bromide from DNA and also by relatively low monomer:nucleotide molar ratio (0.8:1) required to retard the migration of free DNA. Isothermal titration microcalorimetry studies further confirmed that a stronger interaction occurred at low pH than at high pH. By decreasing the pH from 8.0 to 6.6, K(obs) increased from 7.8 x 10(5) to 20.4 x 10(5) M(-1). More efficient condensation at low pH was demonstrated by the reduction of ethidium bromide fluorescence in the loading wells from gel electrophoresis, decreased complex sizes without agglomeration occurring at high polymer/DNA ratios, together with discrete and dense spherical complexes observed in TEM studies. This may be attributed to the presence of electrostatic stabilization from excess cationic polymer chains, which provide a repulsive shell around the polymer/DNA complex. The physicochemical data indicate that the increased degree of ionization for the DMAEMA homopolymer at lower pH results in higher binding affinity, smaller and more compact complexes, and more efficient condensation. These findings therefore highlight the importance of the degree of ionization on DNA complex formation for weak cationic polyelectrolytes.     

Real-Time Nanopore-Based Recognition of Protein Translocation Success

A growing number of new technologies are supported by a single- or multi-nanopore architecture for capture, sensing, and delivery of polymeric biomolecules. Nanopore-based single-molecule DNA sequencing is the premier example. This method relies on the uniform linear charge density of DNA, so that each DNA strand is overwhelmingly likely to pass through the nanopore and across the separating membrane. For disordered peptides, folded proteins, or block copolymers with heterogeneous charge densities, by contrast, translocation is not assured, and additional strategies to monitor the progress of the polymer molecule through a nanopore are required. Here, we demonstrate a single-molecule method for direct, model-free, real-time monitoring of the translocation of a disordered, heterogeneously charged polypeptide through a nanopore. The crucial elements are two “selectivity tags”—regions of different but uniform charge density—at the ends of the polypeptide. These affect the selectivity of the nanopore differently and enable discrimination between polypeptide translocation and retraction. Our results demonstrate exquisite sensitivity of polypeptide translocation to applied transmembrane potential and prove the principle that nanopore selectivity reports on biopolymer substructure. We anticipate that the selectivity tag technique will be broadly applicable to nanopore-based protein detection, analysis, and separation technologies, and to the elucidation of protein translocation processes in normal cellular function and in disease.     

Tailoring charge density and hydrogen bonding of imidazolium copolymers for efficient gene delivery

Conventional free radical polymerization with subsequent postpolymerization modification afforded imidazolium copolymers with controlled charge density and side chain hydroxyl number. Novel imidazolium-containing copolymers where each permanent cation contained one or two adjacent hydroxyls allowed precise structure-transfection efficiency studies. The degree of polymerization was identical for all copolymers to eliminate the influence of molecular weight on transfection efficiency. DNA binding, cytotoxicity, and in vitro gene transfection in African green monkey COS-7 cells revealed structure-property-transfection relationships for the copolymers. DNA gel shift assays indicated that higher charge densities and hydroxyl concentrations increased DNA binding. As the charge density of the copolymers increased, toxicity of the copolymers also increased; however, as hydroxyl concentration increased, cytotoxicity remained constant. Changing both charge density and hydroxyl levels in a systematic fashion revealed a dramatic influence on transfection efficiency. Dynamic light scattering of the polyplexes, which were composed of copolymer concentrations required for the highest luciferase expression, showed an intermediate DNA-copolymer binding affinity. Our studies supported the conclusion that cationic copolymer binding affinity significantly impacts overall transfection efficiency of DNA delivery vehicles, and the incorporation of hydroxyl sites offers a less toxic and effective alternative to more conventional highly charged copolymers.     

Effect of thiol pendant conjugates on plasmid DNA binding, release, and stability of polymeric delivery vectors

Polymers have attracted much attention as potential gene delivery vectors due to their chemical and structural versatility. However, several challenges associated with polymeric carriers, including low transfection efficiencies, insufficient cargo release, and high cytotoxicity levels have prevented clinical implementation. Strong electrostatic interactions between polymeric carriers and DNA cargo can prohibit complete cargo release within the cell. As a result, cargo DNA never reaches the cell's nucleus where gene expression takes place. In addition, highly charged cationic polymers have been correlated with high cytotoxicity levels, making them unsuitable carriers in vivo. Using poly(allylamine) (PAA) as a model, we investigated how pH-sensitive disulfide cross-linked polymer networks can improve the delivery potential of cationic polymer carriers. To accomplish this, we conjugated thiol-terminated pendant chains onto the primary amines of PAA using 2-iminothiolane, developing three new polymer vectors with 5, 13, or 20% thiol modification. Unmodified PAA and thiol-conjugated polymers were tested for their ability to bind and release plasmid DNA, their capacity to protect genetic cargo from enzymatic degradation, and their potential for endolysosomal escape. Our results demonstrate that polymer-plasmid complexes (polyplexes) formed by the 13% thiolated polymer demonstrate the greatest delivery potential. At high N/P ratios, all thiolated polymers (but not unmodified counterparts) were able to resist decomplexation in the presence of heparin, a negatively charged polysaccharide used to mimic in vivo polyplex-protein interactions. Further, all thiolated polymers exhibited higher buffering capacities than unmodified PAA and, therefore, have a greater potential for endolysosomal escape. However, 5 and 20% thiolated polymers exhibited poor DNA binding-release kinetics, making them unsuitable carriers for gene delivery. The 13% thiolated polymers, on the other hand, displayed high DNA binding efficiency and pH-sensitive release.     

Characterization of a new class of DNA delivery complexes formed by the local anesthetic bupivacaine

Bupivacaine, a local anesthetic and cationic amphiphile, forms stable liposomal-like structures upon direct mixing with plasmid DNA in aqueous solutions. These structures are on the order of 50-70 nm as determined by scanning electron microscopy, and are homogeneous populations as analyzed by density gradient centrifugation. The DNA within these structures is protected from nuclease degradation and UV-induced damage in vitro. Bupivacaine:DNA complexes have a negative zeta potential (surface charge), homogeneous nature, and an ability to rapidly assemble in aqueous solutions. Bupivacaine:DNA complexes, as well as similar complexes of DNA with other local anesthetics, have the potential to be a novel class of DNA delivery agents for gene therapy and DNA vaccines.     

Surface functionalized cationic lipid-DNA complexes for gene delivery: PEGylated lamellar complexes exhibit distinct DNA-DNA interaction regimes

Cationic lipid-DNA (CL-DNA) complexes are abundantly used in nonviral gene therapy clinical applications. Surface functionality is the next step in developing these complexes as competent, target-specific gene carriers. Poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) is the natural choice to serve as a protective coat or act as a tether for a specific ligand on the surface of these complexes due to its biocompatibility and ability to convey stealth-like properties. Understanding the effect of PEG on the internal structure and surface properties of CL-DNA complexes is essential in developing vectors with more complex derivatives of PEG, such as Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD)-based peptide-PEG-lipids. We report on x-ray diffraction studies to probe the internal structure of CL-DNA complexes consisting of a ternary mixture of cationic lipids, neutral lipids, and PEG-lipids. The PEG-coated complexes are found to exhibit a structure consistent with the lamellar phase. In addition, three distinct DNA interchain interaction regimes were found to exist, due to a), repulsive long-range electrostatic forces; b), short-range repulsive hydration forces; and c), novel polymer-induced depletion attraction forces in two dimensions. Optical microscopy and reporter gene assays further demonstrate the incorporation of the PEG-lipids into the lamellar CL-DNA complexes under biologically relevant conditions, revealing surface modification. Both techniques show that PEG-lipids with a polymer chain of molecular weight 400 do not provide adequate shielding of the PEGylated CL-DNA complexes, whereas PEG-lipids with a polymer chain of molecular weight 2000 confer stealth-like properties. This surface functionalization is a crucial initial step in the development of competent vectors for in vivo systemic gene delivery and suggests that a second type of surface functionality can be added specifically for targeting by the incorporation of peptide-PEG-lipids.     

Structural modification of siRNA for efficient gene silencing

Small interfering RNA (siRNA) holds a great promise for the future of genomic medicine because of its highly sequence-specific gene silencing and universality in therapeutic target. The medical use of siRNA, however, has been severely hampered by the inherent physico-chemical properties of siRNA itself, such as low charge density, high structural stiffness and rapid enzymatic degradation; therefore, the establishment of efficient and safe siRNA delivery methodology is an essential prerequisite, particularly for systemic administration. For an efficient systemic siRNA delivery, it is a critical issue to obtain small and compact siRNA polyplexes with cationic condensing reagents including cationic polymers, because the size and surface properties of the polyplexes are major determinants for achieving desirable in vivo fate. Unfortunately, synthetic siRNA is not easily condensed with cationic polymers due to its intrinsic rigid structure and low spatial charge density. Accordingly, the loose siRNA polyplexes inevitably expose siRNA to the extracellular environment during systemic circulation, resulting in low therapeutic efficiency and poor biodistribution. In this review, we highlight the innovative approaches to increase the size of siRNA via structural modification of the siRNA itself. The attempts include several methodologies such as hybridization, chemical polymerization, and micro- and nano-structurization of siRNA. Due to its increased charge density and flexibility, the structured siRNA can produce highly condensed and homogenous polyplexes compared to the classical monomeric siRNA. As a result, stable and compact siRNA polyplexes can enhance serum stability and target delivery efficiency in vivo with desirable biodistribution. The review specifically aims to provide the recent progress of structural modification of siRNA. In addition, the article also briefly and concisely explains the improved physico-chemical properties of structured siRNA with respect to stability, condensation ability and gene silencing efficiency.