On the difference in stability between horse and sperm whale myoglobins

The work in the literature on apomyoglobin is almost equally divided between horse and sperm whale myoglobins. The two proteins share high homology, show similar folding behavior, and it is often assumed that all folding phenomena found with one protein will also be found with the other. We report data at equilibrium showing that horse myoglobin was 2.1 kcal/mol less stable than sperm whale myoglobin at pH 5.0, and aggregated at high concentrations as measured by gel filtration and analytical ultracentrifugation experiments. The higher stability of sperm whale myoglobin was identified for both apo and holo forms, and was independent of pH from 5 to 8 and of the presence of sodium chloride. We also show that the substitution of sperm whale myoglobin residues Ala15 and Ala74 to Gly, the residues found at positions 15 and 74 in horse myoglobin, decreased the stability by 1.0 kcal/mol, indicating that helix propensity is an important component of the explanation for the difference in stability between the two proteins.     

A circularly permuted myoglobin possesses a folded structure and ligand binding similar to those of the wild-type protein but with a reduced thermodynamic stability

A circular permutein of sperm whale myoglobin in which the G helix is C-terminal, the H helix is N-terminal, and 16 amino acids link the H helix to the A helix has been expressed in Escherichia coli. The permutein sequence begins with Gly121 (using the numbering scheme for the wild-type protein) and terminates with Pro120. The ligand binding function of the permutein was assayed using stopped-flow methods and shown to be essentially identical to that of the wild-type protein. In addition, one- and two-dimensional NMR studies of the cyanomet isoform of the permutein show a nativelike structure with a heme binding pocket very similar to that of the wild-type myoglobin. Although the structure and function of the permutein resemble those of the wild-type myoglobin, the permutein is less stable to chemical denaturation by 5.2 kcal/mol.     

Structural characterization of non-native states of sperm whale myoglobin in aqueous ethanol or 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol media

The effects of aqueous ethanol or 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol media on the structure of sperm whale myoglobin have been investigated by absorption, CD, and NMR spectra. The structural properties of myoglobin such as heme environments, helix contents, protein folding, and interactions between heme and the protein moiety have been sharply manifested in these spectra. The characterization demonstrated that alcohol-induced conformational change of myoglobin depends on the nature of alcohol and its concentration. It was shown for the first time that, upon the alcohol-induced denaturation of myoglobin, heme is released from partially denatured protein of which helix contents is altered by only about 20% relative to that of native state. Myoglobin has shown to unfold and refold reversibly by controlling the alcohol concentration. Novel methods for the preparation of apomyoglobin and in situ reconstitution of apomyoglobin with heme, based on the alcohol-induced denaturation of the protein, were presented.     

The stabilities of mammalian apomyoglobins vary over a 600-fold range and can be enhanced by comparative mutagenesis

Apomyoglobins from 13 different mammals were examined for resistance to denaturation by guanidinium chloride. Unfolding was followed by circular dichroism and tryptophan fluorescence and analyzed globally using the two-step, three-state mechanism first described by Barrick and Baldwin (Barrick, D., and Baldwin, R. L. (1993) Biochemistry 32, 3790-3796). With one exception, the rise and fall of Trp fluorescence intensity correlates quantitatively with the native to intermediate to unfolded steps seen in the CD curves. Although the O(2) binding properties of the holoproteins are nearly identical, the unfolding transitions of the apomyoglobins show 600-fold differences in resistance to guanidinium chloride denaturation. Apomyoglobins from diving mammals, particularly from sperm whales, are the most stable, whereas the apoproteins from pig, horse, and sheep are the least stable, indicating selective pressure for resistance to denaturation in the whale proteins. Sequence comparisons suggest that the key stabilizing residues in whale globins are Ala(5), His(12), Ile(28), Thr(51), Ala(53), Ala(74), Lys(87), Lys(140), and Ile(142). Combinations of these residues were substituted into pig myoglobin. The resultant multiple mutants showed stabilities approaching that of recombinant sperm whale apomyoglobin. Thus, comparative mutagenesis can be used to increase heme protein stability and improve expression yields in bacteria without compromising function.     

Proton magnetic resonance characterization of the dynamic stability of the heme pocket in myoglobin by the exchange behavior of the labile proton of the proximal histidyl imidazole.

The assigned exchangeable proton signals in the proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of sperm whale deoxy and Met-cyano myoglobin in H2O solution were found to exhibit pH-dependent saturation transfer from the bulk water, which allowed determination of the kinetics and mechanism of the labile proton exchange with solvent. The exchange rates are base catalyzed for both protein forms, with the rate eight times faster in Met-cyano than in deoxy myoglobin. The exchange rate is taken as a measure of the magnitude of the fluctuation in the protein conformation near the heme cavity. On the basis of tritium exchange methods, the greater stability of the unligated relative to the ligated state in myoglobin has also been reported for hemoglobin. The present study, however, localizes the differential kinetic stability on the F helix whose flexibility has been implicated in the mechanism of cooperativity. The observation that filling the hydrophobic vacancy on the proximal side of the heme near the proximal histidine in Met-cyano myoglobin wih cyclopropane increases the proton lability argues against the role for this hole in facilitating the flexibility of the F helix in the native protein.     

A 1H NMR comparison of the met-cyano complexes of elephant and sperm whale myoglobin. Assignment of labile proton resonances in the heme cavity and determination of the distal glutamine orientation from relaxation data

The met-cyano complex of elephant myoglobin has been investigated by high field 1H NMR spectroscopy, with special emphasis on the use of exchangeable proton resonances in the heme cavity to obtain structural information on the distal glutamine. Analysis of the distance dependence of relaxation rates and the exchange behavior of the four hyperfine shifted labile proton resonances has led to the assignment of the proximal His-F8 ring and peptide NHs and the His-FG3 ring NH and the distal Gln-E7 amide NH. The similar hyperfine shift patterns for both the apparent heme resonances as well as the labile proton peaks of conserved resonances in elephant and sperm whale met-cyano myoglobins support very similar electronic/molecular structures for their heme cavities. The essentially identical dipolar shifts and dipolar relaxation times for the distal Gln-E7 side chain NH and the distal His-E7 ring NH in sperm whale myoglobin indicate that those labile protons occupy the same geometrical position relative to the iron and heme plane. This geometry is consistent with the distal residue hydrogen bonding to the coordinated ligand. The similar rates and identical mechanisms of exchange with bulk water of the labile protons for the three conserved residues in the elephant and sperm whale heme cavity indicate that the dynamic stability of the proximal side of the heme pocket is unaltered upon the substitution (His----Gln). The much slower exchange rate (by greater than 10(4] of the distal NH in elephant relative to sperm whale myoglobin supports the assignment of the resonance to the intrinsically less labile amide side chain.     

Role of the B helix in early folding events in apomyoglobin: evidence from site-directed mutagenesis for native-like long range interactions

The folding pathways of four mutants in which bulky hydrophobic residues in the B helix of apomyoglobin (ApoMb) are replaced by alanine (I28A, L29A, I30A, and L32A) have been analyzed using equilibrium and kinetic methods employing NMR, CD, fluorescence and mass spectrometry. Hydrogen exchange pulse-labeling followed by mass spectrometry reveals detectable intermediates in the kinetic folding pathways of each of these mutants. Comparison of the quench-flow data analyzed by NMR for the wild-type protein and the mutants showed that the substitutions I28A, L29A and L32A lead to destabilization of the B helix in the burst phase kinetic intermediate, relative to wild-type apomyoglobin. In contrast, the I30A mutation apparently has a slight stabilizing effect on the B helix in the burst phase intermediate; under weak labeling conditions, residues in the C helix region were also relatively stabilized in the mutant compared to the wild-type protein. This suggests that native-like helix B/helix C packing interactions occur in the folding intermediate. The L32A mutant showed significantly lower proton occupancies in the burst phase for several residues in the G helix, specifically F106, I107, E109 and A110, which are in close proximity to L32 in the X-ray structure of myoglobin, providing direct evidence that native-like helix B/helix G contacts are formed in the apomyoglobin burst phase intermediate. The L29A mutation resulted in an increase in burst phase proton occupancies for several residues in the E helix. Since these regions of the B and E helices are not in contact in the native myoglobin structure, these effects suggest the possibility of non-native B/E packing interactions in the kinetic intermediate. The differing effects of these B helix mutations on the apomyoglobin folding process suggests that each side-chain plays a different and important role in forming stable structure in the burst phase intermediate, and points to a role for both native-like and non-native contacts in stabilization of the folding intermediate.     

Use of site-directed mutagenesis to destabilize native apomyoglobin relative to folding intermediates

Site-directed mutagenesis has been used to study the effect on the stability of human apomyoglobin (apoMb) of modifying the size, hydrophobicity, and charge of a central residue in the G.B helix-helix packing interface. Some stability measurements have also been made on the corresponding holomyoglobins (heme present). Cys-110, a central helix pairing residue in the G helix, has been changed to Ala, Ser, Asp, and Leu. Stability to low-pH-induced unfolding has been measured for both native apoMb and the compact folding intermediate discovered by Griko et al. [Griko, Y. V., Privalov, P. L., Venyaminov, S. Y., & Kutyshenko, V. P. (1988) J. Mol. Biol. 202, 127-138]. As judged by its circular dichroism spectrum, this intermediate has a substantial helix content (about 35%). Whether or not this inferred helical structure is closely related to the myoglobin structure is not yet known. The mutational evidence shows that integrity of G.B helix pairing is important for the stability of apoMb as well as of myoglobin and that this helix pairing site is very sensitive to both steric and electrostatic disruption. Our results also suggest that G.B helix pairing does not stabilize the compact intermediate; hence, disrupting this site destabilizes the native protein relative to the compact intermediate. Such selective destabilization of the native state relative to equilibrium folding intermediates is not restricted to acid denaturation: urea denaturation of the Leu mutant appears to display at least one stable intermediate, while wild-type and the remaining mutant apoMbs undergo two-state urea unfolding transitions.     

Native protein sequences are designed to destabilize folding intermediates

Hydrophobic core mutants of sperm whale apomyoglobin were constructed to investigate the amino acid sequence features that determine the folding properties. Replacements of all of the Ile residues with Leu and of all of the Ile and Val residues with Leu decreased the thermodynamic stability of the folded states against the unfolded states but increased the stability of the folding intermediates against the unfolded states, indicating that the amino acid composition of the protein core is important for the protein stability and folding cooperativity. To examine the effect of the arrangement of these hydrophobic residues, mutant proteins were further constructed: 12 sites out of the 18 Leu, 9 Ile, and 8 Val residues of the wild-type myoglobin were randomly replaced with each other so that the amino acid compositions were similar to that of the wild-type protein. Four mutant proteins were obtained without selection of the protein properties. These residue replacements similarly resulted in the stabilization of both the intermediate and folded states against the unfolded states, as compared to the wild-type protein. Thus, the arrangements of the hydrophobic residues in the native amino acid sequence are selected to destabilize the folding intermediate rather than to stabilize the folded state. The present results suggest that the two-state transition of protein folding or the transient formation of the unstable intermediate, which seems to be required for effective production of the functional proteins, has been a major driving force in the molecular evolution of natural globular proteins.     

Identification of the titrating group in the heme cavity of myoglobin. Evidence for the heme-protein pi-pi interaction

The pH dependence of the proton NMR chemical shifts of met-cyano and deoxy forms of native and reconstituted myoglobins reflects a structural transition in the heme pocket modulated by a single proton with pK 5.1-5.6. Comparison of this pH dependence of sperm whale and elephant myoglobin and that of the former protein reconstituted with esterified hemin eliminates both the distal histidine as well as the heme propionates as the titrating residue. Reconstitution of sperm whale met-cyano myoglobin with hemin modified at the 2,4-positions leads to a systematic variation in the pK for the structural transition, thus indicating the presence of a coupling between the titrating group and the heme pi system. The results are consistent with histidine FG3 (His-FG3) being the titrating group, and a donor-acceptor pi-pi interaction between its imidazole and the heme is proposed.     

A primitive myoglobin from Tetrahymena pyriformis: its heme environment, autoxidizability, and genomic DNA structure

A myoglobin-like protein isolated from Tetrahymena pyriformis is composed of 121 amino acid residues. This is much smaller than sperm whale myoglobin by 32 residues, suggesting a distinct origin from the common globin gene. We have therefore examined this unique protein for its structural, spectral and stability properties. As a result, the rate of autoxidation of Tetrahymena oxymyoglobin (MbO(2)) was found to be almost comparable to that of sperm whale MbO(2) over a wide range of pH 4-12 in 0.1 M buffer at 25 degrees C. Moreover, both pH profiles exhibited the remarkable proton-assisted process, which can be performed in sperm whale myoglobin by the distal (E7) histidine as its catalytic residue. These kinetic observations are also in full accord with spectral examinations for the presence of a distal histidine in ciliated protozoa myoglobin. At the same time, we have isolated the globin genes both from T. pyriformis and Tetrahymena thermophila, and found that there is no intron in their genomic structures. This is in sharp contrast to previous reports on the homologous globin genes from Paramecium caudatum and Chlamydomonas eugametos. Rather, the Tetrahymena genes seemed to be related to the cyanobacterial globin gene from Nostoc commune. These contracted or truncated globins thus have a marked diversity in the cDNA, protein, and genomic structures.     

Circular permutation and deletion studies of myoglobin indicate that the correct position of its N-terminus is required for native stability and solubility but not for native-like heme binding and folding

We studied the effect of deleted and circularly permuted mutations in sperm whale myoglobin and present here results on three classes of mutants: (i) a deletion mutant, Mb(1)(-)(99), in which the C-terminal helices, G and H, were removed; (ii) two circular permutations, Mb-B_GHA, in which helix B is N-terminal and helix A is C-terminal, and Mb-C_GHAB, in which helix C is N-terminal and helices A and B are C-terminal; and (iii) a deleted circular permutation, Mb-HAB_F, in which helix H is N-terminal, helix F is C-terminal, and helix G is deleted. The conformational characteristics of the apo and holo forms of these mutants were determined at neutral pH, by spectroscopic and hydrodynamic methods. The apo form of the deleted and permuted mutants exhibited a stronger tendency to aggregate and had lower ellipticity than the wild type. The mutants retained the ability to bind heme, but only the circularly permuted holoproteins had native-like heme binding and folding. These results agree with the theory that myoglobin has a central core that is able to bind heme, but also indicate that the presence of N- and C-terminal helices is necessary for native-like heme pocket formation. Because the holopermuteins were less stable than the wild-type protein and aggregated, we propose that the native position of the N-terminus is important for the precise structural architecture of myoglobin.     

Fluorescence and energy transfer of tryptophans in Aplysia myoglobin.

The fluorescence decay of tryptophan residues in apo and met Aplysia limacina myoglobin and sperm whale myoglobin were measured in aqueous solution at 10 degrees-15 degrees C. In all species, multiexponential behavior was observed in which the individual components displayed unique frequency-dependent emission characteristics. The results suggest that the tryptophan fluorescence in all met samples are quenched by rapid Forster energy transfer to the heme as predicted from the crystal geometry. Fluorescence from the apo protein is similar to that in solutions of free tryptophans. In addition, the fluorescence properties of the reversible thermal denaturation of Aplysia limacina met myoglobin was investigated between 25 degrees and 75 degrees C.     

The myoglobin protein radical. Coupling of Tyr-103 to Tyr-151 in the H2O2-mediated cross-linking of sperm whale myoglobin

Sperm whale metmyoglobin, which has tyrosine residues at positions 103, 146, and 151, dimerizes in the presence of H2O2. Equine metmyoglobin, which lacks Tyr-151, and red kangaroo metmyoglobin, which lacks Tyr-103 and Tyr-151, do not dimerize in the presence of H2O2. The dityrosine content of the sperm whale myoglobin dimer shows that it is primarily held together by dityrosine cross-links, although more tyrosine residues are lost than are accounted for by dityrosine formation. Digestion of the myoglobin dimer with chymotrypsin yields a peptide with the fluorescence spectrum of dityrosine. The amino acid composition, amino acid sequence, and mass spectrum of the peptide show that cross-linking involves covalent bond formation between Tyr-103 of one myoglobin chain and Tyr-151 of the other. Replacement of the prosthetic group of sperm whale myoglobin with zinc protoporphyrin IX prevents H2O2-induced dimerization even when intact horse metmyoglobin is present in the incubation. This suggests that the tyrosine radicals required for the dimerization reaction are generated by intra- rather than intermolecular electron transfer to the ferryl heme. Rapid electron transfer from Tyr-103 to the ferryl heme followed by slower electron transfer from Tyr-151 to Tyr-103 is most consistent with the present results.     

Folding of Aplysia limacina apomyoglobin involves an intermediate in common with other evolutionarily distant globins

In the globin family, similarities in the folding mechanism have been found among different mammalian apomyoglobins (apoMb). The best-characterized intermediate of sperm whale apoMb, called I(AGH), is mainly stabilized by nativelike contacts among the A, G, and H helices involving a cluster of hydrophobic residues that includes two conserved tryptophans. To verify the hypothesis of a common intermediate in the folding of all members of the globin family, we have extensively studied a site-directed mutant of the myoglobin from Aplysia limacina, distantly related to the mammalian counterpart, in which one of the two tryptophans in the A-G-H cluster [i.e., Trp(H8)130] has been mutated to tyrosine. The results presented here show that this mutation destabilizes both the native state and the acid intermediate I(A) but exerts little or no effect on the thermally stable core of an intermediate species (called I(T)) peculiar to Aplysia apomyoglobin. Dynamic quenching of Trp emission by acrylamide provides information on the accessibility of the chromophores at the native and the intermediate states of wild-type and mutant Aplysia apomyoglobin, consistent with the thermodynamics. Our results agree well with those obtained for the corresponding topological position of apomyoglobin from sperm whale and clearly show that the H8 position is involved in the stabilization of the main intermediate in both apoproteins. This residue thus plays a role which is evolutionarily conserved in the globin family from invertebrates to mammals; our results support the contention that the A-G-H cluster is important in the folding pathway of different globins.     

New transient species of sperm whale myoglobin in photodissociation of dioxygen from oxymyoglobin

We carried out the flash photolysis of oxy complexes of sperm whale myoglobin, cobalt-substituted sperm whale myoglobin, and Aplysia myoglobin. When the optical absorption spectral changes associated with the O2 rebinding were monitored on the nanosecond to millisecond time scale, we found that the transient spectra of the O2 photoproduct of sperm whale myoglobin were significantly different from the static spectra of deoxy form. This was sharply contrasted with the observations that the spectra of the CO photoproduct of sperm whale myoglobin and of the O2 photoproducts of cobalt-substituted sperm whale myoglobin and Aplysia myoglobin are identical to the corresponding spectra of their deoxy forms. These results led us to suggest the presence of a fairly stable transient species in the O2 photodissociation from the oxy complex of sperm whale myoglobin, which has a protein structure different from the deoxy form. We denoted the O2 photo-product to be Mb*. In the time-resolved resonance Raman measurements, the nu Fe-His mode of Mb* gave the same value as that of the deoxy form, indicating that the difference in the optical absorption spectra is possibly due to the structural difference at the heme distal side rather than those of the proximal side. The structure of Mb* is discussed in relation to the dynamic motion of myoglobin in the O2 entry to or exit from the heme pocket. Comparing the structural characteristics of several myoglobins employed, we suggested that the formation of Mb* relates to the following two factors: a hydrogen bonding of O2 with the distal histidine, and the movement of iron upon the ligation of O2.     

Putative interhelix ion pairs involved in the stability of myoglobin.

An earlier theoretical study predicted that specific ion pair interactions between neighboring helices should be important in stabilizing myoglobin. To measure these interactions in sperm whale myoglobin, single mutations were made to disrupt them. To obtain reliable DeltaG values, conditions were found in which the urea induced unfolding of holomyoglobin is reversible and two-state. The cyanomet form of myoglobin satisfies this condition at pH 5, 25 degrees C. The unfolding curves monitored by far-UV CD and Soret absorbance are superimposable and reversible. None of the putative ion pairs studied here makes a large contribution to the stability of native myoglobin. The protein stability does decrease somewhat between 0 and 0.1 M NaCl, however, indicating that electrostatic interactions contribute favorably to myoglobin stability at pH 5.0. A previous mutational study indicated that the net positive charge of the A[B]GH subdomain of myoglobin is an important factor affecting the stability of the pH 4 folding intermediate and potential ion pairs within the subdomain do not contribute significantly to its stability. One of the assumptions made in that study is tested here: replacement of either positively or negatively charged residues outside the A[B]GH subdomain has no significant effect on the stability of the pH 4 molten globule.     

The complete amino acid sequence of the major component myoglobin of Amazon river dolphin (Inia geoffrensis).

The complete amino acid sequence of the major component myoglobin from Amazon River dolphin, Inia geoffrensis, was determined by specific cleavage of the protein to obtain large peptides which are readily degraded by the automatic sequencer. Three easily separable peptides were obtained by cleaving the protein with cyanogen bromide at the methionine residues and four peptides were obtained by cleaving the methyl-acetimidated protein with trypsin at the arginine residues. From these peptides over 85% of the sequence was completed. The remainder of the sequence was obtained by fragmentation of the large cyanogen bromide peptide with trypsin. This protein differs from that of the common porpoise, Phocoena phocoena, at seven positions, from that of the common dolphin, Delphinus delphis, at 11 positions, and from that of the sperm whale, Physeter catodon, at 15 positions. By comparison of this sequence with the three-dimensional structure of sperm whale myoglobin it appears that those residues close to the heme group are most conserved followed by those in nonhelical regions and lastly by those in the helical segments. All of the substitutions observed in this sequence fit easily into the three-dimensional structure of the sperm whale myoglobin.     

Stabilization of myoglobin by multiple alanine substitutions in helical positions.

We have carried out a series of multiple Xaa-->Ala changes at nonadjacent surface positions in the sequence of sperm whale myoglobin. Although the corresponding single substitutions do not increase the thermal stability of the protein, multiple substitutions enhance the stability of the resulting myoglobins. The effect observed is an increase in the observed Tm (midpoint unfolding temperature) relative to that predicted from assuming additivity of the free energy changes corresponding to single mutations. The stabilization occurs in the presence of urea, as measured by the dependence of the unfolding temperature on urea concentration. The sites that have been altered occur in different helices and are not close in sequence or in the native structure of myoglobin. The observed effect is consistent with a role of multiple alanines in residual interactions in the unfolded state of the mutant proteins.