Telomere variability in the monocotyledonous plant order Asparagales

A group of monocotyledonous plants within the order Asparagales, forming a distinct clade in phylogenetic analyses, was reported previously to lack the 'typical' Arabidopsis-type telomere (TTTAGGG)(n). This stimulated us to determine what has replaced these sequences. Using slot-blot and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) to species within this clade, our results indicate the following. 1. The typical Arabidopsis-type telomeric sequence has been partly or fully replaced by the human-type telomeric sequence (TTAGGG)(n). Species in Allium lack the human-type variant. 2. In most cases the human variant occurs along with a lower abundance of two or more variants of the minisatellite sequences (of seven types evaluated), usually these being the consensus telomeric sequence of Arabidopsis, Bombyx (TTAGG)(n) and Tetrahymena (TTGGGG)(n). FISH shows that the variants can occur mixed together at the telomere. 3. Telomerases generate products with a 6 base pair periodicity and when sequenced they reveal predominantly a reiterated human-type motif. These motifs probably form the 'true telomere' but the error rate of motif synthesis is higher compared with 'typical' plant telomerases. The data indicate that the Asparagales clade is unified by a mutation resulting in a switch from synthesis of Arabidopsis-like telomeres to a low-fidelity synthesis of human-like telomeres.     

An evolutionary change in telomere sequence motif within the plant section Asparagales had significance for telomere nucleoprotein complexes

In association with a phylogenetic tree of Asparagales, our previous results showed that a distinct clade included plant species where the ancestral, Arabidopsis-type of telomeric repeats (TTTAGGG)n had been partially, or fully, replaced by the human-type telomeric sequence (TTAGGG)n. Telomerases of these species synthesize human repeats with a high error rate in vitro. Here we further characterize the structure of telomeres in these plants by analyzing the overall arrangement of major and minor variants of telomeric repeats using fluorescence in situ hybridization on extended DNA strand(s). Whilst the telomeric array is predominantly composed of the human variant of the repeat, the ancestral, Arabidopsis-type of telomeric repeats was ubiquitously observed at one of the ends and/or at intercalary positions of extended telomeric DNAs. Another variant of the repeat typical of Tetrahymena was observed interspersed in about 20% of telomerics. Micrococcal nuclease digestions indicated that Asparagales plants with a human-type of telomere have telomeric DNA organised into nucleosomes. However, unexpectedly, the periodicity of the nucleosomes is not significantly shorter than bulk chromatin as is typical of telomeric chromatin. Using electrophoretic mobility shift assays we detected in Asparagales plants with a human type of telomere a 40-kDa protein that forms complexes with both Arabidopsis- and human-type G-rich telomeric strands. However, the protein shows a higher affinity to the ancestral Arabidopsis-type sequence. Two further proteins were found, a 25-kDa protein that binds specifically to the ancestral sequence and a 15-kDa protein that binds to the human-type telomeric repeat. We discuss how the organisation of the telomere repeats in Asparagales may have arisen and stabilised the new telomere at the point of mutation.     

Characterization of nucleoprotein complexes in plants with human-type telomere motifs.

A conserved feature of telomeres is the 3'-overhang of their G-rich strand. These G-overhangs function as substrates for telomerase-mediated strand extension, and are critical for end-protection of telomeres. These functions and their regulations are mediated by specific G-overhang binding proteins. In species of the plant order Asparagales, telomere motifs have diverged from a type typical of the plant Arabidopsis thaliana (TTTAGGG)(n) to a type typical of human (TTAGGG)(n). Presumably, this change in motif had an impact on the structure of the telomere and/or the binding of telomeric proteins, including the G-overhang binding proteins. Therefore, we analyse here nucleoprotein complexes formed by protein extracts from plants possessing human-type telomeres (Muscari armeniacum and Scilla peruviana). Proteins were characterized that bind to the G-rich strand of both telomere motifs, or to the ancestral Arabidopsis-type motif alone, but none bound to double-stranded or C-rich complementary strand telomere motifs. We demonstrate the size, sequence-specificity and thermostability of these DNA-binding proteins. We also analysed the formation of complexes from renatured protein fractions after SDS-PAGE (sodium-dodecyl-sulphate polyacrylamide-gel-electrophoresis). We discuss the evolutionary consequences of protein binding flexibility, to act on both ancestral and present telomeric sequences. Of particular interest is that the ancestral repeat, which is thought not to form the telomere, binds the proteins most strongly. These data are discussed in line with other known plant telomere-binding proteins and with the complex nature of the telomere in Asparagales carrying a human-type motif.     

The controversial telomeres of lily plants

The molecular structure of the exceptional telomeres of six plant species belonging to the order Asparagales and two species of the order Liliales was analyzed using Southern blot and fluorescence in situ hybridization. Three different situations were found, namely: i) In the two Liliales species, Tulipa australis (Liliaceae) and Merendera montana (Colchicaceae), the chromosome ends display hybridization signals with oligonucleotides resembling telomere repeats of both plants (TTTAGGG)n and vertebrates (TTAGGG)n. ii) Asparagales species such as Phormium tenax (Hemerocallidaceae), Muscari comosum (Hyacinthaceae), Narcissus jonquilla (Amaryllidaceae) and Allium sativum (Alliaceae) lack both the plant telomere repeats and the vertebrate telomere repeats. iii) Two other Asparagales species, Aloe vera (Asphodelaceae) and an Iris hybrid (Iridaceae), display positive hybridization with the vertebrate telomere repeats but not with the plant telomere repeats. Southern blot hybridization revealed concurring results. On this basis, the composition of the telomere structure in this plant group is discussed.     

Asparagales Telomerases which Synthesize the Human Type of Telomeres

The order of monocotyledonous plants Asparagales is attractive for studies of telomere evolution as it includes three phylogenetically distinct groups with telomeres composed of TTTAGGG (Arabidopsis-type), TTAGGG (human-type) and unknown alternative sequences, respectively. To analyze the molecular causes of these switches in telomere sequence (synthesis), genes coding for the catalytic telomerase subunit (TERT) of representative species in the first two groups have been cloned. Multiple alignments of the sequences, together with other TERT sequences in databases, suggested candidate amino acid substitutions grouped in the Asparagales TERT synthesizing the human-type repeat that could have contributed to the changed telomere sequence. Among these, mutations in the C motif are of special interest due to its functional importance in TERT. Furthermore, two different modes of initial elongation of the substrate primer were observed in Asparagales telomerases producing human-like repeats, which could be attributed to interactions between the telomerase RNA subunit (TR) and the substrate. Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available for this article at and is accessible for authorized users.     

A novel minisatellite at a cloned hamster telomere

The ends of eukaryotic chromosomes have special properties and roles in chromosome behavior. Selection for telomere function in yeast, using a Chinese hamster hybrid cell line as the source DNA, generated a stable yeast artificial chromosome clone containing 23 kb of DNA adjacent to (TTAGGG)n, the vertebrate telomeric repeat. The common repetitive element d(GT)n appeared to be responsible for most of the other stable clones. Circular derivatives of the TTAGGG-positive clone that could be propagated in E. coli were constructed. These derivatives identify a single pair of hamster telomeres by fluorescence in situ hybridization. The telomeric repeat tract consists of (TTAGGG)n repeats with minor variations, some of which can be cleaved with the restriction enzyme MnlI. Blot hybridization with genomic hamster DNA under stringent conditions confirms that the TTAGGG tracts are cleaved into small fragments due to the presence of this restriction enzyme site, in contrast to mouse telomeres. Additional blocks of (TTAGGG)n repeats are found 4–5 kb internally on the clone. The terminal region of the clone is dominated by a novel A-T rich 78 bp tandemly repeating sequence; the repeat monomer can be subdivided into halves distinguished by more or less adherence to the consensus sequence. The sequence in genomic DNA has the same tandem organization in probably a single primary locus of >20–30 kb and is thus termed a minisatellite.     

Telomerase activity and telomere detection during early bovine development

The ends of mammalian chromosomes are composed of repeated DNA sequences of (TTAGGG)(n) known as telomeres. Telomerase is a ribonucleoprotein that synthesizes telomeric DNA to replenish the 50-200 bp lost during cell replication. Cellular aging and senescence are associated with a lack of telomerase activity and a critical shortening of the telomere. The objectives of this study were to confirm the presence of TTAGGG repeats on the chromosomes of bovine embryos using in situ hybridization and assess the relative amounts of telomerase activity using a telomeric repeat amplification protocol (TRAP) during oocyte maturation and early embryo development. Applying a telomere DNA probe to the chromosomes of blastocysts and adult fibroblasts, telomeres were identified on the terminal ends of the p and q arms of chromosomes in all cells examined. Immature oocytes, matured oocytes, zygotes, 2- to 5-cell embryos, 6- to 8-cell embryos, morulae, and blastocysts were lysed in NP-40 lysis buffer and telomerase activity was assayed using the TRAP assay. Telomerase activity was detected in all developmental stages examined. Relative telomerase activity (based on telomerase internal standards and positive controls) appeared to decrease during oocyte maturation and subsequent development to the 8-cell stage but significantly increased (P < 0.05) by approximately 40-fold at the morula and blastocyst stages. It was concluded that the telomeres of bovine chromosomes contain TTAGGG repeats and that telomerase activity is up-regulated in morulae and blastocysts.     

Sequence specificity of inter- and intramolecular G-quadruplex formation by human telomeric DNA

Human telomeric DNA consists of tandem repeats of the sequence 5'-d(TTAGGG)-3'. Guanine-rich DNA, such as that seen at telomeres, forms G-quadruplex secondary structures. Alternative forms of G-quadruplex structures can have differential effects on activities involved in telomere maintenance. With this in mind, we analyzed the effect of sequence and length of human telomeric DNA on G-quadruplex structures by native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and circular dichroism. Telomeric oligonucleotides shorter than four, 5'-d(TTAGGG)-3' repeats formed intermolecular G-quadruplexes. However, longer telomeric repeats formed intramolecular structures. Altering the 5'-d(TTAGGG)-3' to 5'-d(TTAGAG)-3' in any one of the repeats of 5'-d(TTAGGG)(4)-3' converted an intramolecular structure to intermolecular G-quadruplexes with varying degrees of parallel or anti-parallel-stranded character, depending on the length of incubation time and DNA sequence. These structures were most abundant in K(+)-containing buffers. Higher-order structures that exhibited ladders on polyacrylamide gels were observed only for oligonucleotides with the first telomeric repeat altered. Altering the sequence of 5'-d(TTAGGG)(8)-3' did not result in the substantial formation of intermolecular structures even when the oligonucleotide lacked four consecutive telomeric repeats. However, many of these intramolecular structures shared common features with intermolecular structures formed by the shorter oligonucleotides. The wide variability in structure formed by human telomeric sequence suggests that telomeric DNA structure can be easily modulated by proteins, oxidative damage, or point mutations resulting in conversion from one form of G-quadruplex to another.     

Telomeric DNA in chromosomes of five opisthorchid species

The analysis of telomere repeat distribution in chromosomes of five opisthorchid species (Opisthorchis felineus (Rivolta, 1884), Opisthorchis viverrini (Poirier, 1886), Metorchis xanthosomus (Creplin, 1846), Metorchis bilis (Braun, 1890), Clonorchis sinensis (Cobbold, 1875)) was performed with fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) of labeled (TTAGGG)n DNA-probe and PNA telomere probe on mitotic and meiotic chromosomes of these species. It was shown that chromosome telomeres of all studied species contain large clusters of (TTAGGG)n telomeric repeats. Interstitial clusters of the (TTAGGG)n repeats have not been revealed in the chromosomes of any studied species even when FISH of PNA telomere probe on pachytene chromosomes was performed. Furthermore interstitial clusters of the (TTAGGG)n repeats have not been detected in the chromosomes of O. viverrini, one of chromosomes of this species is the result of a fusion of two ancestral opisthorchid chromosomes.     

Loss and recovery of Arabidopsis-type telomere repeat sequences 5'-(TTTAGGG)(n)-3' in the evolution of a major radiation of flowering plants

Fluorescent in situ hybridization and Southern blotting were used for showing the predominant absence of the Arabidopsis-type telomere repeat sequence (TRS) 5'-(TTTAGGG)(n)-3' (the 'typical' telomere) in a monocot clade which comprises up to 6300 species within Asparagales. Initially, two apparently disparate genera that lacked the typical telomere were identified. Here, we used the new angiosperm phylogenetic classification for predicting in which other related families such telomeres might have been lost. Our data revealed that 16 species in 12 families of Asparagales lacked typical telomeres. Phylogenetically, these were clustered in a derived clade, thereby enabling us to predict that the typical telomere was lost, probably as a single evolutionary event, following the divergence of Doryanthaceae ca. 80--90 million years ago. This result illustrates the predictive value of the new phylogeny, as the pattern of species lacking the typical telomere would be considered randomly placed against many previous angiosperm taxonomies. Possible mechanisms by which chromosome end maintenance could have evolved in this group of plants are discussed. Surprisingly, one genus, Ornithogalum (Hyacinthaceae), which is central to the group of plants that have lost the typical telomere, appears to have regained the sequences. The mechanism(s) by which such recovery may have occurred is unknown, but possibilities include horizontal gene transfer and sequence reamplification.     

Structure and variability of human chromosome ends.

Mammalian telomeres are thought to be composed of a tandem array of TTAGGG repeats. To further define the type and arrangement of sequences at the ends of human chromosomes, we developed a direct cloning strategy for telomere-associated DNA. The method involves a telomere enrichment procedure based on the relative lack of restriction endonuclease cutting sites near the ends of human chromosomes. Nineteen (TTAGGG)n-bearing plasmids were isolated, two of which contain additional human sequences proximal to the telomeric repeats. These telomere-flanking sequences detect BAL 31-sensitive loci and thus are located close to chromosome ends. One of the flanking regions is part of a subtelomeric repeat that is present at 10 to 25% of the chromosome ends in the human genome. This sequence is not conserved in rodent DNA and therefore should be a helpful tool for physical characterization of human chromosomes in human-rodent hybrid cell lines; some of the chromosomes that may be analyzed in this manner have been identified, i.e., 7, 16, 17, and 21. The minimal size of the subtelomeric repeat is 4 kilobases (kb); it shows a high frequency of restriction fragment length polymorphisms and undergoes extensive de novo methylation in somatic cells. Distal to the subtelomeric repeat, the chromosomes terminate in a long region (up to 14 kb) that may be entirely composed of TTAGGG repeats. This terminal segment is unusually variable. Although sperm telomeres are 10 to 14 kb long, telomeres in somatic cells are several kilobase pairs shorter and very heterogeneous in length. Additional telomere reduction occurs in primary tumors, indicating that somatic telomeres are unstable and may continuously lose sequences from their termini.     

Intrachromosomal location of the telomeric repeat (TTAGGG)n

Eukaryotic telomeres are specialized DNA-protein structures that are thought to ensure chromosomal stability and complete replication of the chromosome ends. All telomeres which have been studied consist of a tandem array of G-rich repeats which seem to be sufficient for telomere function. Originally, the human telomeric repeat (TTAGGG)_n was assumed to be exclusively located at the very end of all human chromosomes. More recent evidence, however, suggests an extension into proterminal regions. Very little is known about the interstitial distribution of telomeric repeats. Here we present evidence for the presence of (TTAGGG)_n repeats in internal loci on the long and short arms of different human chromosomes. In addition, we studied the genomic organization of these repeats in more detail and discuss possible functions of interstitial telomeric repeats in the human genome.     

Telomere shortening associated with chromosome instability is arrested in immortal cells which express telomerase activity.

Loss of telomeric DNA during cell proliferation may play a role in ageing and cancer. Since telomeres permit complete replication of eukaryotic chromosomes and protect their ends from recombination, we have measured telomere length, telomerase activity and chromosome rearrangements in human cells before and after transformation with SV40 or Ad5. In all mortal populations, telomeres shortened by approximately 65 bp/generation during the lifespan of the cultures. When transformed cells reached crisis, the length of the telomeric TTAGGG repeats was only approximately 1.5 kbp and many dicentric chromosomes were observed. In immortal cells, telomere length and frequency of dicentric chromosomes stabilized after crisis. Telomerase activity was not detectable in control or extended lifespan populations but was present in immortal populations. These results suggest that chromosomes with short (TTAGGG)n tracts are recombinogenic, critically shortened telomeres may be incompatible with cell proliferation and stabilization of telomere length by telomerase may be required for immortalization.     

Two combinatorial patterns of telomere histone marks in plants with canonical and non‐canonical telomere repeats

Telomeres, nucleoprotein structures at the ends of linear eukaryotic chromosomes, are crucial for the maintenance of genome integrity. In most plants, telomeres consist of conserved tandem repeat units comprising the TTTAGGG motif. Recently, non‐canonical telomeres were described in several plants and plant taxons, including the carnivorous plant Genlisea hispidula (TTCAGG/TTTCAGG), the genus Cestrum (Solanaceae; TTTTTTAGGG), and plants from the Asparagales order with either a vertebrate‐type telomere repeat TTAGGG or Allium genus‐specific CTCGGTTATGGG repeat. We analyzed epigenetic modifications of telomeric histones in plants with canonical and non‐canonical telomeres, and further in telomeric chromatin captured from leaves of Nicotiana benthamiana transiently transformed by telomere CRISPR‐dCas9‐eGFP, and of Arabidopsis thaliana stably transformed with TALE_telo C‐3×GFP. Two combinatorial patterns of telomeric histone modifications were identified: (i) an Arabidopsis‐like pattern (A. thaliana, G. hispidula, Genlisea nigrocaulis, Allium cepa, Narcissus pseudonarcissus, Petunia hybrida, Solanum tuberosum, Solanum lycopersicum) with telomeric histones decorated predominantly by H3K9me2; (ii) a tobacco‐like pattern (Nicotiana tabacum, N. benthamiana, C. elegans) with a strong H3K27me3 signal. Our data suggest that epigenetic modifications of plant telomere‐associated histones are related neither to the sequence of the telomere motif nor to the lengths of the telomeres. Nor the phylogenetic position of the species plays the role; representatives of the Solanaceae family are included in both groups. As both patterns of histone marks are compatible with fully functional telomeres in respective plants, we conclude that the described specific differences in histone marks are not critical for telomere functions.     

Human telomeres contain at least three types of G-rich repeat distributed non-randomly.

Using a combination of different oligonucleotides and restriction enzymes we have examined the gross organisation of repeats within the most distal region of human chromosomes. We demonstrate here that human telomeres do not contain a pure uniform 6 base pair repeat unit but that there are at least three types of repeat. These three types of repeat are present at the ends of most or all human chromosomes. The distribution of each type of repeat appears to be non-random. Each human telomere has a similar arrangement of these repeats relative to the ends of the chromosome. This could reflect differences in the functions that they perform, or might result from the mutation and correction processes occurring at human telomeres. The number of repeat units, the repeat types and arrangement differs at mouse telomeres. Analysing the change in length of the telomeric repeat region between an individuals blood and germline DNA reveals that this is due to variable amounts of the TTAGGG repeat and not the other repeat types. This organization of repeat units at human telomeres will only be confirmed upon the isolation and sequencing of full length (10-15 kb), intact human telomeres.     

The absence of Arabidopsis-type telomeres in Cestrum and closely related genera Vestia and Sessea (Solanaceae): first evidence from eudicots

Using slot-blot and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH), we found no evidence for the presence of the Arabidopsis-type telomeric sequence (TTTAGGG)n at the chromosome termini in any of the Cestrum species we investigated. Probing for the human-type telomere (TTAGGG)n also revealed no signal. However, polymerase chain reaction experiments indicated that there are short lengths of the sequence TTTAGGG dispersed in the genome but that these sequences are almost certainly too short to act as functional telomeres even if they were at the chromosome termini. An analysis of related genera Vestia and Sessea indicates that they too lack the Arabidopsis-type telomere, and the sequences were lost in the common ancestor of these genera. We found that the Cestrum species investigated had particularly large mean chromosome sizes. We discuss whether this is a consequence of alternative telomere end maintenance systems.