Site-directed mutagenesis studies to probe the role of specific residues in the external loop (L3) of OmpF and OmpC porins in susceptibility of Serratia marcescens to antibiotics

Serratia marcescens is a nosocomial bacterium with natural resistance to a broad spectrum of antibiotics, making treatment challenging. One factor contributing to this natural antibiotic resistance is reduced outer membrane permeability, controlled in part by OmpF and OmpC porin proteins. To investigate the direct role of these porins in the diffusion of antibiotics across the outer membrane, we have created an ompF-ompC porin-deficient strain of S. marcescens. A considerable similarity between the S. marcescens porins and those from other members of Enterobacteriaceae was detected by sequence alignment, with the exception of a change in a conserved region of the third external loop (L3) of the S. marcescens OmpC protein. Serratia marcescens OmpC has aspartic acid instead of glycine in position 112, methionine instead of aspartic acid in position 114, and glutamine in position 124, while in S. marcescens OmpF this is a glycine at position 124. To investigate the role of amino acid positions 112, 114, and 124 and how the observed changes within OmpC porin may play a part in pore permeability, 2 OmpC sites were altered in the Enterobacteriaceae consensus (D112G and M114D) through site-directed mutagenesis. Also, Q124G in OmpC, G124Q in OmpF, and double mutants of these amino acid residues were constructed. Antibiotic accumulation assays and minimal inhibitory concentrations of the strains harboring the mutated porins were performed, while liposome swelling experiments were performed on purified porins. Our results demonstrate that the amino acid at position 114 is not responsible for either antibiotic size or ionic selection, the amino acid at position 112 is responsible for size selection only, and position 124 is involved in both size and ionic selection.     

Molecular and functional characterisation of the Serratia marcescens outer membrane protein Omp1

Serratia marcescens outer membrane contains three different general diffusion porins: Omp1, Omp2 and Omp3. Omp1 was cloned and sequenced and it shows a great homology to the family of outer membrane porins that comprises the general porins of enteric bacteria. The gene for Omp1 was transferred into an expression plasmid and was expressed in Escherichia coli UH302 (E. coli UH302 pOM100), a porin deficient strain. Its expression confers a higher susceptibility towards different antibiotics to this strain. Omp1 was purified to homogeneity from outer membrane of E. coli UH302 pOM100. Reconstitution of the purified protein into black lipid bilayers demonstrated that it is a channel-forming component with a single-channel conductance of approximately 2 nS in 1 M KCl similar to that of other porins from enteric bacteria. Omp1 is slightly cation-selective. Its homology to already crystallised members of the family of enteric porins whose three-dimensional-structures are known and allowed the design of a topology model for Omp1. The charge distribution within a porin monomer is similar as in other general diffusion pores. The positively charged amino acids localised at the beta-strands opposite the external loop L3, which restrict the pore diameter in the porin monomer.     

Outer membrane porins are important in maintenance of the surface structure of Escherichia coli cells.

Escherichia coli cells lacking the OmpF and OmpC proteins, porin proteins of the outer membrane, are often unstable and easily revert to strains which either have regained one or both of these proteins or contain a new outer membrane protein. The structural importance of porin proteins in the cell surface was studied in the present work. Tris-hydrochloride buffer at a concentration of 120 mM caused deformation of the cell surface of a strain lacking these porins; the undulated appearance of the negatively stained cell surface changed to a smooth and expanded form. The Tris-induced deformation was seldom observed with either the wild-type strain or a pseudorevertant that possessed the OmpF protein. The role of the OmpF protein in stabilizing the cell surface against Tris treatment could be slightly taken over by the LamB protein, which shares a number of unique properties with the former proteins. The deformation of the cell surface by Tris-hydrochloride buffer was accompanied by a loss of viability, the lethal damage being especially significant when the cells lacked porins. Upon induction with maltose, cells with the undulated appearance could absorb lambda phages, whereas the deformed cells could not. These results suggest that the instability of cells lacking porins is primarily due to a structural defect of the outer membrane.     

Reduced outer membrane permeability of Escherichia coli O157:H7: suggested role of modified outer membrane porins and theoretical function in resistance to antimicrobial agents

Outer membrane permeability of Escherichia coli O157:H7 was determined by an in vivo kinetic model with the periplasmic enzyme alkaline phosphatase [Martinez et al. (1996) Biochemistry 35, 1179-1186]. p-Nitrophenyl phosphate (PNPP) substrate, added to intact bacteria, must diffuse through the outer membrane to reach the enzyme. At low substrate concentration the bacterium was in the perfectly reactive state where all molecules that entered the periplasm were captured and converted to product. Transmembrane diffusion was rate limiting, and the permeability of the outer membrane was determined from kinetic properties. The O157:H7 strain grown at 30 degrees C showed one-sixth the permeability of wild-type E. coli grown at 30 degrees C. Wild-type bacteria grown at >/=37 degrees C show a physiological response with a shift in expression of outer membrane porins that lowered permeability to PNPP by approximately 70%. The O157:H7 strain did not display this temperature-sensitive shift in permeability even though a change in porin expression could be visualized by staining intensity of Omp F and Omp C on acrylamide gels. Altered behavior of the O157:H7 membrane was also indicated by a several thousand-fold lower response to transformation relative to wild-type E. coli. Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time of flight mass spectrometry and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry confirmed the expression of the Omp F and Omp C variants that are unique to E. coli O157:H7. This reduced outer membrane permeability can contribute to enhanced resistance of O157:H7 to antimicrobial agents.     

Outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria. XVIII. Electron microscopic studies on porin insertion sites and growth of cell surface of Salmonella typhimurium.

Salmonella typhimurium contains three "major proteins" or "porins" (34K, 35K, and 36K) in the outer membrane. A mutant strain producing only the 35K porin was first grown in media containing high concentrations of NaCl to "repress" the porin synthesis and then was shifted into a medium without NaCl. The newly made porin molecules were then labeled with the ferritin-coupled antibody at various times after the shift, and the samples were examined by whole-mount, freeze-etching, and thin-section electron microscopy. These experiments showed that newly inserted porins appeared as discrete patches uniformly distributed over the surface of the cell and, furthermore, that the sites of adhesion between the inner and outer membrane were most probably the pathway by which the newly made porin molecules appeared on cell surface. The 34K and 36K porins were also inserted in the same manner, since the appearance of new porins at discrete sites all over the cell surface was also observed when cells with wild-type porin phenotype were treated with unlabeled antibody to block existing antigenic sites, subsequently regrown, and labeled with the ferritin-coupled antibody. Since porins comprise a major portion of the densely packed, relatively immobile, "protein framework" of the outer membrane, these results lead us to conclude that the outer membrane grows predominantly by diffuse intercalation rather than by the zonal growth mechanism.     

Transmembrane permeability channels in vesicles reconstituted from single species of porins from Salmonella typhimurium.

Aggregates of the "major" outer membrane proteins, "porins," of Salmonella typhimurium form diffusion channels in reconstituted vesicle membranes. The aggregate consists of three species of porins with apparent molecular weights of 34,000, 35,000, and 36,000 when active aggregates are subjected to sodium dodecyl sulfate-acrylamide gel electrophoresis after heating in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate (Nakae, J. Biol. Chem. 251:2176-2178, 1976). Single species of porins were isolated by solubilization of membranes and subsequent gel filtration in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate from the mutant strains of Salmonella typhimurium that produced only single species of porin. The single species of porins of either 34,000, 35,000, or 36,000 daltons formed diffusion channels when assayed for sucrose permeability in the vesicle membranes reconstituted from porins, phospholipids, and lipopolysaccharides. The exclusion limits of the pores made of single species of porins were not distinguishable from each other and from the exclusion limits of the pores made of the porin aggregates from the wild-type strain, when the permeability of vesicle membranes to radioactive di-, tri-, and tetrasaccharides and to various sizes of radioactive polyethylene glycol was determined. Porin-deficient mutants produced residual amounts of porin amounting to 1 to 5% that produced by the parent strain. This residual porin made diffusion channels when the isolated porins were incorporated into the vesicle membrane and assayed for permeability of saccharides.     

A model of maltodextrin transport through the sugar-specific porin, LamB, based on deletion analysis.

LamB facilitates the uptake of maltose and maltodextrins across the bacterial outer membrane and acts as a general porin for small molecules. Using directed deletion mutagenesis we removed several regions of the LamB polypeptide and identified a polypeptide loop that both constricts the maltoporin channel and binds maltodextrins. In conjunction with a second sugar binding site that we identified at the rim of the channel, these data clarify, for the first time, the mechanism of transport through a substrate-specific porin. Furthermore, unlike the transverse loops of general porins, which originate from a central location in their primary structure, the loop that regulates LamB permeability originates from a C-terminal site. Thus LamB represents a second distinct class of porins in the bacterial outer membrane that is differently organized and separately evolved from OmpF-type, general porins.     

Altered antibiotic transport in OmpC mutants isolated from a series of clinical strains of multi-drug resistant E. coli

Antibiotic-resistant bacteria, particularly gram negative species, present significant health care challenges. The permeation of antibiotics through the outer membrane is largely effected by the porin superfamily, changes in which contribute to antibiotic resistance. A series of antibiotic resistant E. coli isolates were obtained from a patient during serial treatment with various antibiotics. The sequence of OmpC changed at three positions during treatment giving rise to a total of four OmpC variants (denoted OmpC20, OmpC26, OmpC28 and OmpC33, in which OmpC20 was derived from the first clinical isolate). We demonstrate that expression of the OmpC K12 porin in the clinical isolates lowers the MIC, consistent with modified porin function contributing to drug resistance. By a range of assays we have established that the three mutations that occur between OmpC20 and OmpC33 modify transport of both small molecules and antibiotics across the outer membrane. This results in the modulation of resistance to antibiotics, particularly cefotaxime. Small ion unitary conductance measurements of the isolated porins do not show significant differences between isolates. Thus, resistance does not appear to arise from major changes in pore size. Crystal structures of all four OmpC clinical mutants and molecular dynamics simulations also show that the pore size is essentially unchanged. Molecular dynamics simulations suggest that perturbation of the transverse electrostatic field at the constriction zone reduces cefotaxime passage through the pore, consistent with laboratory and clinical data. This subtle modification of the transverse electric field is a very different source of resistance than occlusion of the pore or wholesale destruction of the transverse field and points to a new mechanism by which porins may modulate antibiotic passage through the outer membrane.     

Molecular and Structural Characterization of the HMP-AB Gene Encoding a Pore-Forming Protein from a Clinical Isolate of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Acinetobacter baumannii</Emphasis>

The major outer membrane protein of Acinetobacter baumannii is the heat-modifiable protein HMP-AB, a porin with a large pore size allowing the penetration of solutes having a molecular weight of up to approximately 800 Da. Cross-linking experiments with glutardialdehyde failed to show any cross-linking between the monomers, a fact that proves again that this porin protein functions as a monomeric porin. The specific activity of this porin was found to be similar to that of other monomeric porins. Tryptic digestion of the outer membrane yielded a 23-kDa fragment of the HMP-AB protein that was resistant to further trypsin treatment. This observation indicates that HMP-AB is assembled in the membrane in a manner similar to monomeric porins. Cloning of the HMP-AB gene revealed an open reading frame of 1038 bp encoding a protein of 346 amino acids and a calculated molecular mass of 35,636 Da. The amino acid sequence and composition were typical of Gram-negative bacterial porins: a highly negative hydropathy index, absence of hydrophobic residue stretches, a slightly negative total charge, low instability index, high glycine content, and an absence of cysteine residues. Sequence comparison of HMP-AB with other outer membrane proteins revealed a clear homology with the monomeric outer membrane proteins, outer membrane protein A (OmpA) of Enterobacteria, and outer membrane protein F (OprF) of Pseudomonas sp. Secondary structure analysis indicated that HMP-AB has a 172-amino acid N-terminal domain that spans the outer membrane by eight amphiphilic beta strands and a C-terminal domain that apparently serves as an anchoring protein to the peptidoglycan layer. The results also indicate that HMP-AB belongs to the eight transmembrane beta-strand family of outer membrane proteins.     

Effect of outer membrane permeability on chemotaxis in Escherichia coli.

The relationship between outer membrane permeability and chemotaxis in Escherichia coli was studied on mutants in the major porin genes ompF and ompC. Both porins allowed passage of amino acids across the outer membrane sufficiently to be sensed by the methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins, although OmpF was more effective than OmpC. A mutant deleted for both ompF and ompC, AW740, was almost completely nonchemotactic to amino acids in spatial assays. AW740 required greater stimulation with L-aspartate than did the wild type to achieve full methylation of methyl-accepting chemotaxis protein II. Induction of LamB protein allowed taxis to maltose but not to L-aspartate, which indicates that the maltoporin cannot rapidly pass aspartate. Salt taxis was less severely inhibited by the loss of porins than was amino acid taxis, which implies an additional mechanism of outer membrane permeability. These results show that chemotaxis can be used as a sensitive in vivo assay for outer membrane permeability to a range of compounds and imply that E. coli can regulate chemotactic sensitivity by altering the porin composition of the outer membrane.     

The YompC protein of<Emphasis Type="Italic">Yersinia enterocolitica</Emphasis>: Molecular and physiological characterization

The structural gene coding for YompC has been identified in the genome of a pathogenic strain of Yersinia enterocolitica O:9, and was subsequently cloned and sequenced. Detailed alignment of the deduced amino acid sequence showed that YompC is a member of the OmpC porin family with the highest degree of homology to Klebsiella pneumoniae. The mutant lacking YompC porin was constructed by insertional inactivation of the yompC gene which resulted from the integration of suicide vector at the yompC locus. In intact cells of Y. enterocolitica, loss of the YompC protein reduced the outer membrane permeability for beta-lactam antibiotics and tetracycline and resulted in a 2-5-fold increase in resistance to these compounds, depending on their chemical properties. Mutation in the ompR regulatory gene resulted in the loss of both YompC and YompF porins, which led to a greater increase of resistance to antibiotics, as compared with the YompC mutant strain. Moreover, the binding assay with HEp-2 cells suggests that YompC may play a role in the adhesion properties of Y. enterocolitica strains.     

Molecular Basis of Filtering Carbapenems by Porins from β-Lactam-resistant Clinical Strains of Escherichia coli

Integral membrane proteins known as porins are the major pathway by which hydrophilic antibiotics cross the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. Single point mutations in porins can decrease the permeability of an antibiotic, either by reduction of channel size or modification of electrostatics in the channel, and thereby confer clinical resistance. Here, we investigate four mutant OmpC proteins from four different clinical isolates of Escherichia coli obtained sequentially from a single patient during a course of antimicrobial chemotherapy. OmpC porin from the first isolate (OmpC20) undergoes three consecutive and additive substitutions giving rise to OmpC26, OmpC28, and finally OmpC33. The permeability of two zwitterionic carbapenems, imipenem and meropenem, measured using liposome permeation assays and single channel electrophysiology differs significantly between OmpC20 and OmpC33. Molecular dynamic simulations show that the antibiotics must pass through the constriction zone of porins with a specific orientation, where the antibiotic dipole is aligned along the electric field inside the porin. We identify that changes in the vector of the electric field in the mutated porin, OmpC33, create an additional barrier by “trapping” the antibiotic in an unfavorable orientation in the constriction zone that suffers steric hindrance for the reorientation needed for its onward translocation. Identification and understanding the underlying molecular details of such a barrier to translocation will aid in the design of new antibiotics with improved permeation properties in Gram-negative bacteria.     

Diffusion of beta-lactam antibiotics into proteoliposomes reconstituted with outer membranes of isogenic imipenem-susceptible and -resistant strains of Enterobacter cloacae.

The influence of outer membrane (OM) permeability on carbapenem susceptibility was studied in strains of Enterobacter cloacae, a species in which carbapenem resistance depends upon the conjunction of overproduction of the chromosomal cephalosporinase and reduction of OM permeability. Relative trans-OM diffusion rates were measured using the liposome swelling assay. Proteoliposomes were reconstituted with OM from the members of an isogenic set of E. cloacae strains, selected in vivo or in vitro, which produced either porins F and D (wild-type), or F or D only, or neither. For all but one mutant, and compared with the wild-type strain, the respective increases in MICs and decreases in trans-OM diffusion of carbapenems were: nil and 13 to 18%; 4- to 32-fold and 33 to 50%; > or = 64-fold and > or = 90%. Our results suggest (i) that carbapenems (and other beta-lactam antibiotics) diffuse through porins F and D, but more rapidly through porin F, and (ii) that OM permeability is the critical factor in determining the level of MICs of carbapenems for cephalosporinase-overproducing strains of E. cloacae. The OM of one particular low-level carbapenem-resistant and porin F- and D-deficient mutant was at least five times more permeable to carbapenems than the similarly porin-deficient high-level resistant mutants. We infer from this observation the possible existence of an alternative carbapenem penetration pathway which could be associated with two as yet uncharacterized overproduced OM proteins of about 22 and 47 kDa.     

Structure-function correlation of outer membrane protein porin from Paracoccus denitrificans

Porins from outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria have a highly stable structure. Our previous studies on porin from Paracoccus denitrificans showed that the outer membrane protein porin is extremely stable toward heat, pH, and chemical denaturants. The major question we have addressed in this paper is whether the high stability of porin is a consequence of the beta-barrel structure and whether it is required for its function. To explain this we have analyzed two cases: first, we used porin wild-type and mutants and compared their structure and function; second, we compared the activity of porin preheated to different temperatures. Structural changes were monitored by infrared spectroscopy. We observed that the structural stability of porin is not equivalent to functional activity as minor alteration in the structure can result in drastic differences in the activity of porins.     

Cadaverine inhibition of porin plays a role in cell survival at acidic pH

When grown at acidic pH, Escherichia coli cells secrete cadaverine, a polyamine known to inhibit porin-mediated outer membrane permeability. In order to understand the physiological significance of cadaverine excretion and the inhibition of porins, we isolated an OmpC mutant that showed resistance to spermine during growth and polyamine-resistant porin-mediated fluxes. Here, we show that the addition of exogenous cadaverine allows wild-type cells to survive a 30-min exposure to pH 3.6 better than cells expressing the cadaverine-insensitive OmpC porin. Competition experiments between strains expressing either wild-type or mutant OmpC showed that the lack of sensitivity of the porin to cadaverine confers a survival disadvantage to the mutant cells at reduced pH. On the basis of these results, we propose that the inhibition of porins by excreted cadaverine represents a novel mechanism that provides bacterial cells with the ability to survive acid stress.     

Characterisation of channels induced in planar bilayer membranes by detergent solubilised Escherichia coli porins

Purified OmpF, OmpC, NmpC, PhoE and Lc (Protein 2) porins from the Escherichia coli outer membrane were incorporated into planar phospholipid bilayer membranes and the permeability properties of the pores studied. Triton X-100 solubilised porin samples showed large and reproducible increases in membrane conductivity composed of discreet single-channel events. The magnitude of the cation selectivity found for the porins was in the order OmpC greater than OmpF greater than NmpC = Lc; PhoE was anion selective. For the cation selective porins the cation/anion permeability ratios in a variety of solutes ranged from 6 to 35. Further information on the internal structure of the porins was obtained by examination of the single-channel conductance and this was used to interpret macroscopic observations and to estimate single-channel diameters. The same porins solubilised in SDS exhibited slight conductance increase with no observable single-channel activity. Use of on-line microcomputer techniques confirmed the ohmic current vs. voltage behaviour for all the single porin channels examined.     

Determinants of OmpF porin antigenicity and structure.

Sixty-six murine hybridomas raised to Escherichia coli B/r porin were used to identify and differentiate the epitopes of this outer membrane protein. Anti-porin monoclonal antibodies (mAb) were raised against outer membrane fragments, purified native trimeric porin (trimer), and purified sodium dodecyl sulfate-denatured monomeric porin (monomer). Immunochemical and flow cytometric methods identified five distinct cell surface-exposed determinants on OmpF. The peptide composition of porin epitopes was determined by analysis of mAb reactivity with cyanogen bromide-generated peptide fragments. Four of 43 anti-monomer mAb reacted with surface exposed sites on OmpF, defining epitopes that consist of residues within CNBr peptides d2, d3, and B. The anti-porin mAb panel was also used to evaluate changes in porin antigenic structure in strains with short ompF deletions. Flow cytometric experiments indicated that despite changes in porin permeability, little if any alteration of surface epitopes occurred in these strains. Western immunoblot analysis of the mutant porins showed loss of reactivity with numerous mAb, which was caused by changes in three spatially distinct epitopes at residues 108-111, 118-123, and 124-129. Our findings indicate that in these ompF mutants the residues responsible for altering porin permeability are not exposed on the cell surface, but are buried within the tertiary structure of the protein. One of these regions, which is apparently involved in the determination of channel permeability characteristics, is conserved among 15 of 16 different porin molecules which were screened with the anti-OmpF mAb panel.     

The porin and the permeating antibiotic: a selective diffusion barrier in Gram-negative bacteria

Gram-negative bacteria are responsible for a large proportion of antibiotic-resistant bacterial diseases. These bacteria have a complex cell envelope that comprises an outer membrane and an inner membrane that delimit the periplasm. The outer membrane contains various protein channels, called porins, which are involved in the influx of various compounds, including several classes of antibiotics. Bacterial adaptation to reduce influx through porins is an increasing problem worldwide that contributes, together with efflux systems, to the emergence and dissemination of antibiotic resistance. An exciting challenge is to decipher the genetic and molecular basis of membrane impermeability as a bacterial resistance mechanism. This Review outlines the bacterial response towards antibiotic stress on altered membrane permeability and discusses recent advances in molecular approaches that are improving our knowledge of the physico-chemical parameters that govern the translocation of antibiotics through porin channels.