Detection of motional heterogeneities in lipid bilayer membranes by dual probe fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

We report the detection of heterogeneities in the diffusion of lipid molecules for the three-component mixture dipalmitoyl-PC/dilauroyl-PC/cholesterol, a chemically simple lipid model for the mammalian plasma membrane outer leaflet. Two-color fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) was performed on giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) using fluorescent probes that have differential lipid phase partition behavior--DiO-C18:2 favors disordered fluid lipid phases, whereas DiI-C20:0 prefers spatially ordered lipid phases. Simultaneously-obtained fluorescence autocorrelation functions from the same excitation volume for each dye showed that, depending on the lipid composition of this ternary mixture, the two dyes exhibited different lateral mobilities in regions of the phase diagram with previously proposed submicroscopic two-phase coexistence. In one-phase regions, both dyes reported identical diffusion coefficients. Two-color FCS thus may be detecting local membrane heterogeneities at size scales below the optical resolution limit, either due to short-range order in a single phase or due to submicroscopic phase separation.     

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy with single-molecule sensitivity on cell and model membranes.

We report on the successful application of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) to the analysis of single fluorescently labeled lipid analogue molecules diffusing laterally in lipid bilayers, as exemplified by time traces of fluorescence bursts of individual molecules entering and leaving the excitation area. FCS measurements performed on lipid probes in rat basophilic leukemia cell membranes showed deviations from two-dimensional Brownian motion with a single uniform diffusion constant. Giant unilamellar vesicles were employed as model systems to characterize diffusion of fluorescent lipid analogues in both homogeneous and mixed lipid phases with diffusion heterogeneity. Comparing the results of cell membrane diffusion with the findings on the model systems suggests possible explanations for the observations: (a) anomalous subdiffusion in which evanescent attractive interactions with disparate mobile molecules modifies the diffusion statistics; (b) alternatively, probe molecules are localized in microdomains of submicroscopic size, possibly in heterogeneous membrane phases.     

Probing lipid mobility of raft-exhibiting model membranes by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Confocal fluorescence microscopy and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) have been employed to investigate the lipid spatial and dynamic organization in giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) prepared from ternary mixtures of dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine/sphingomyelin/cholesterol. For a certain range of cholesterol concentration, formation of domains with raft-like properties was observed. Strikingly, the lipophilic probe 1,1'-dioctadecyl-3,3,3',3'-tetramethylindocarbocyanine perchlorate (DiI-C18) was excluded from sphingomyelin-enriched regions, where the raft marker ganglioside GM1 was localized. Cholesterol was shown to promote lipid segregation in dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine-enriched, liquid-disordered, and sphingomyelin-enriched, liquid-ordered phases. Most importantly, the lipid mobility in sphingomyelin-enriched regions significantly increased by increasing the cholesterol concentration. These results pinpoint the key role, played by cholesterol in tuning lipid dynamics in membranes. At cholesterol concentrations >50 mol%, domains vanished and the lipid diffusion slowed down upon further addition of cholesterol. By taking the molecular diffusion coefficients as a fingerprint of membrane phase compositions, FCS is proven to evaluate domain lipid compositions. Moreover, FCS data from ternary and binary mixtures have been used to build a ternary phase diagram, which shows areas of phase coexistence, transition points, and, importantly, how lipid dynamics varies between and within phase regions.     

Diffusion and Partitioning of Fluorescent Lipid Probes in Phospholipid Monolayers

The pressure-dependent diffusion and partitioning of single lipid fluorophores in DMPC and DPPC monolayers were investigated with the use of a custom-made monolayer trough mounted on a combined fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) and wide-field microscopy setup. It is shown that lipid diffusion, which is essential for the function of biological membranes, is heavily influenced by the lateral pressure and phase of the lipid structure. Both of these may change dynamically during, e.g., protein adsorption and desorption processes. Using FCS, we measured lipid diffusion coefficients over a wide range of lateral pressures in DMPC monolayers and fitted them to a free-area model as well as the direct experimental observable mean molecular area. FCS measurements on DPPC monolayers were also performed below the onset of the phase transition (Π < 5 mN/m). At higher pressures, FCS was not applicable for measuring diffusion coefficients in DPPC monolayers. Single-molecule fluorescence microscopy and differential scanning calorimetry clearly showed that this was due to heterogeneous partitioning of the lipid fluorophores in condensed phases. The results were compared with dye partitioning in giant lipid vesicles. These findings are significant in relation to the application of lipid fluorophores to study diffusion in both model systems and biological systems.     

Self-Calibrated Line-Scan STED-FCS to Quantify Lipid Dynamics in Model and Cell Membranes

Only a limited number of noninvasive techniques are available to directly measure the dynamic behavior of lipids in model and cell membranes. Here, we explored whether a commercial instrument could be used for fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) under pulsed stimulated emission depletion (STED). To overcome issues with photobleaching and poor distinction between confocal and STED signals, we implemented resonant line-scan STED with filtered FCS, which has the additional benefit of autocalibrating the dimensions of the point-spread function and obtaining spatially resolved molecular mobility at subdiffraction resolution. With supported lipid bilayers, we achieved a detection spot radius of 40 nm, although at the expense of decreased molecular brightness. We also used this approach to map the dynamics of Atto646N-labeled sphingomyelin and phosphatidylethanolamine in the plasma membrane. Despite the reliability of the method and the demonstration that photobleaching and the photophysical properties of the dye did not influence diffusion measurements, we found great heterogeneities even within one cell. For both lipids, regions of high local density correlated with slow molecular diffusion, indicating trapping of Atto646N-labeled lipids. Future studies with new dyes are needed to reveal the origin of the trapping.     

A stopped-flow kinetic study of the interaction of potential-sensitive oxonol dyes with lipid vesicles

The interaction of the dyes oxonol V and oxonol VI with unilamellar dioleoylphosphatidylcholine vesicles was investigated using a fluorescence stopped-flow technique. On mixing with the vesicles, both dyes exhibit an increase in their fluorescence, which occurs in two phases. According to the dependence of the reciprocal relaxation time on vesicle concentration, the rapid phase appears to be due to a second-order binding of the dye to the lipid membrane, which is very close to being diffusion-controlled. The slow phase is almost independent of vesicle concentration, and it is suggested that this may be due to a change in dye conformation or position within the membrane, possibly diffusion across the membrane to the internal monolayer. The response times of the dyes to a rapid jump in the membrane potential has also been investigated. Oxonol VI was found to respond to the potential change in less than 1 s, whereas oxonol required several minutes. This has been attributed to lower mobility of oxonol V within the lipid membrane.     

To Hop or not to Hop: Exceptions in the FCS Diffusion Law

Diffusion obstacles in membranes have not been directly visualized because of fast membrane dynamics and the occurrence of subresolution molecular complexes. To understand the obstacle characteristics, mobility-based methods are often used as an indirect way of assessing the membrane structure. Molecular movement in biological plasma membranes is often characterized by anomalous diffusion, but the exact underlying mechanisms are still elusive. Imaging total internal reflection fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (ITIR-FCS) is a well-established mobility-based method that provides spatially resolved diffusion coefficient maps and is combined with FCS diffusion law analysis to examine subresolution membrane organization. In recent years, although FCS diffusion law analysis has been instrumental in providing new insights into the membrane structure below the optical diffraction limit, there are certain exceptions and anomalies that require further clarification. To this end, we correlate the membrane structural features imaged by atomic force microscopy (AFM) with the dynamics measured using ITIR-FCS. We perform ITIR-FCS measurements on supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) of various lipid compositions to characterize the anomalous diffusion of lipid molecules in distinct obstacle configurations, along with the high-resolution imaging of the membrane structures with AFM. Furthermore, we validate our experimental results by performing simulations on image grids with experimentally determined obstacle configurations. This study demonstrates that FCS diffusion law analysis is a powerful tool to determine membrane heterogeneities implied from dynamics measurements. Our results corroborate the commonly accepted interpretations of imaging FCS diffusion law analysis, and we show that exceptions happen when domains reach the percolation threshold in a biphasic membrane and a network of domains behaves rather like a meshwork, resulting in hop diffusion.     

Temperature dependence of diffusion in model and live cell membranes characterized by imaging fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

The organization of the plasma membrane is regulated by the dynamic equilibrium between the liquid ordered (L_o) and liquid disordered (L_d) phases. The abundance of the L_o phase is assumed to be a consequence of the interaction between cholesterol and the other lipids, which are otherwise in either the L_d or gel (S_o) phase. The characteristic lipid packing in these phases results in significant differences in their respective lateral dynamics. In this study, imaging total internal reflection fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (ITIR-FCS) is applied to monitor the diffusion within supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) as functions of temperature and composition. We show that the temperature dependence of membrane lateral diffusion, which is parameterized by the Arrhenius activation energy (E_Arr), can resolve the sub-resolution phase behavior of lipid mixtures. The FCS diffusion law, a novel membrane heterogeneity ruler implemented in ITIR-FCS, is applied to show that the domains in the S_o–L_d phase are static and large while they are small and dynamic in the L_o–L_d phase. Diffusion measurements and the subsequent FCS diffusion law analyses at different temperatures show that the modulation in membrane dynamics at high temperature (313 K) is a cumulative effect of domain melting and rigidity relaxation. Finally, we extend these studies to the plasma membranes of commonly used neuroblastoma, HeLa and fibroblast cells. The temperature dependence of membrane dynamics for neuroblastoma cells is significantly different from that of HeLa or fibroblast cells as the different cell types exhibit a high level of compositional heterogeneity.     

Cholesterol Depletion Mimics the Effect of Cytoskeletal Destabilization on Membrane Dynamics of the Serotonin1A Receptor: A zFCS Study

Single-point fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) of membrane-bound molecules suffers from a number of limitations leading to inaccurate estimation of diffusion parameters. To overcome such problems and with the overall goal of addressing membrane heterogeneities, we performed z-scan FCS (zFCS) of the serotonin_1A receptor. We analyzed the results according to FCS diffusion laws that provide information on the organization of the diffusing species. Analysis of our results shows that the diffusion coefficients of the receptor and a fluorescently labeled phospholipid are similar when probed at length scales ∼210 nm. We discuss the significance of the spatiotemporal evolution of dynamics of membrane-bound molecules in the overall context of membrane domains and heterogeneity. Importantly, our results show that the serotonin_1A receptor exhibits confinement in cell membranes, possibly due to interaction with the actin cytoskeleton. Surprisingly, depletion of membrane cholesterol appears to reduce receptor confinement in a manner similar to that observed in the case of cytoskeletal destabilization, implying possible changes in the actin cytoskeleton induced upon cholesterol depletion. These results constitute the first report on G-protein-coupled receptor dynamics utilizing a combination of zFCS and the FCS diffusion laws, and present a convenient approach to explore cell membrane heterogeneity at the submicron level.     

The photophysics of a Rhodamine head labeled phospholipid in the identification and characterization of membrane lipid phases

The organization of lipids and proteins into domains in cell membranes is currently an established subject within biomembrane research. Fluorescent probes have been used to detect and characterize these membrane lateral heterogeneities. However, a comprehensive understanding of the link between the probes' fluorescence features and membrane lateral organization can only be achieved if their photophysical properties are thoroughly defined. In this work, a systematic characterization of N-(lyssamine Rhodamine B sulfonyl)-1,2-dioleoyl-sn-3-phosphatidylehanolamine (Rhod-DOPE) absorption and fluorescence behavior in gel, liquid-ordered (l(o)) and liquid-disordered (l(d)) model membranes was performed. In agreement with a previous study, it was found that Rhod-DOPE fluorescence lifetimes present a strong sensitivity to lipid phases, becoming significantly shorter in l(o) membranes as the probe membrane concentration increases. The sensitivity of Rhod-DOPE absorption and fluorescence properties to the membrane phase was further explored. In particular, the fluorescence lifetime sensitivity was shown to be a consequence of the enhanced Rhod-DOPE fluorescence dynamic self-quenching, due to the formation of probe-rich membrane domains in these condensed phases that cannot be considered as typical probe aggregates, as excitonic interaction is not observed. The highly efficient dynamic self-quenching was shown to be specific to l(o) phases, pointing to an important effect of membrane dipole potential in this process. Altogether, this work establishes how to use Rhod-DOPE fluorescence properties in the study of membrane lipid lateral heterogeneities, in particular cholesterol-enriched lipid rafts.     

Lipid diffusion in planar membranes investigated by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Investigation of lipid lateral mobility in biological membranes and their artificial models provides information on membrane dynamics and structure; methods based on optical microscopy are very convenient for such investigations. We focus on fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS), explain its principles and review its state of the art versions such as 2-focus, Z-scan or scanning FCS, which overcome most artefacts of standard FCS (especially those resulting from the need for an external calibration) making it a reliable and versatile method. FCS is also compared to single particle tracking and fluorescence photobleaching recovery and the applicability and the limitations of the methods are briefly reviewed. We discuss several key questions of lateral mobility investigation in planar lipid membranes, namely the influence which membrane and aqueous phase composition (ionic strength and sugar content), choice of a fluorescent tracer molecule, frictional coupling between the two membrane leaflets and between membrane and solid support (in the case of supported membranes) or presence of membrane inhomogeneities has on the lateral mobility of lipids. The recent FCS studies addressing those questions are reviewed and possible explanations of eventual discrepancies are mentioned.     

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy in membrane structure elucidation

This review describes the application of fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) for the study of biological membranes. Monitoring the fluorescence signal fluctuations, it is possible to obtain diffusion constants and concentrations for several membrane components. Focusing the attention on lipid bilayers, we explain the technical difficulties and the new FCS-based methodologies introduced to overcome them. Finally, we report several examples of studies which apply FCS on both model and biological membranes to obtain interesting insight in the topic of lateral membrane organization.     

Liquid-ordered microdomains in lipid rafts and plasma membrane of U-87 MG cells: a time-resolved fluorescence study

Lipid rafts, the functional microdomains in the cell membrane, are believed to exist as liquid-ordered (Lo) phase domains along with the liquid-disordered (Ld) phase of the bulk of the cell membranes. We have examined the lipid order in model and natural membranes by time-resolved fluorescence of trimethylammonium-1,6-diphenylhexatriene incorporated into the membranes. The lipid phases were discerned by the limiting anisotropy, rotational diffusion rate and distribution of the fluorescence lifetime. In dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC)-cholesterol mixtures the gel phase exhibited higher anisotropy and a two-fold slower rotational diffusion rate of the probe as compared to the Ld phase. On the other hand, the Lo phase exhibited higher limiting anisotropy but a rotational diffusion rate comparable to the Ld phase. The Ld and Lo phases elicited unimodal distribution of lifetimes with distinct mean values and their co-existence in phospholipid-cholesterol mixtures was reflected as a biphasic change in the width of the lifetime distribution. Global analysis of the lifetimes yielded a best fit with two lifetimes which were identical to those observed in single Lo or Ld phases, but their fractional contribution varied with cholesterol concentration. Attributing the shorter and longer lifetime components to the Ld and Lo phases, respectively, the extent of the Lo/Ld phase domains in the membranes was estimated by their fractional contribution to the fluorescence decay. In ternary mixtures of egg PC-gangliosides-cholesterol, the gangliosides induced heterogeneity in the membrane but the Ld phase prevailed. The Lo phase properties were observed only in the presence of cholesterol. Results obtained in the plasma membrane and detergent-resistant membrane fractions (DRMs) isolated from U-87 MG cells revealed that DRMs mainly possess the Lo phase; however, a substantially large proportion of plasma membrane also exists in the Lo phase. Our data show that, besides cholesterol, the membrane proteins play a significant role in the organization of lipid rafts and, furthermore, a considerable amount of heterogeneity is present among the lipid rafts.     

Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy Measurements of the Membrane Protein TetA in Escherichia coli Suggest Rapid Diffusion at Short Length Scales

Structural inhomogeneities in biomembranes can lead to complex diffusive behavior of membrane proteins that depend on the length or time scales that are probed. This effect is well studied in eukaryotic cells, but has been explored only recently in bacteria. Here we used fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) to study diffusion of the membrane protein TetA-YFP in E. coli. We find that the diffusion constant determined from FRAP is comparable to other reports of inner membrane protein diffusion constants in E. coli. However, FCS, which probes diffusion on shorter length scales, gives a value that is almost two orders of magnitude higher and is comparable to lipid diffusion constants. These results suggest there is a population of TetA-YFP molecules in the membrane that move rapidly over short length scales (∼ 400 nm) but move significantly more slowly over the longer length scales probed by FRAP.     

Partitioning, diffusion, and ligand binding of raft lipid analogs in model and cellular plasma membranes

Several simplified membrane models featuring coexisting liquid disordered (Ld) and ordered (Lo) lipid phases have been developed to mimic the heterogeneous organization of cellular membranes, and thus, aid our understanding of the nature and functional role of ordered lipid-protein nanodomains, termed "rafts". In spite of their greatly reduced complexity, quantitative characterization of local lipid environments using model membranes is not trivial, and the parallels that can be drawn to cellular membranes are not always evident. Similarly, various fluorescently labeled lipid analogs have been used to study membrane organization and function in vitro, although the biological activity of these probes in relation to their native counterparts often remains uncharacterized. This is particularly true for raft-preferring lipids ("raft lipids", e.g. sphingolipids and sterols), whose domain preference is a strict function of their molecular architecture, and is thus susceptible to disruption by fluorescence labeling. Here, we analyze the phase partitioning of a multitude of fluorescent raft lipid analogs in synthetic Giant Unilamellar Vesicles (GUVs) and cell-derived Giant Plasma Membrane Vesicles (GPMVs). We observe complex partitioning behavior dependent on label size, polarity, charge and position, lipid headgroup, and membrane composition. Several of the raft lipid analogs partitioned into the ordered phase in GPMVs, in contrast to fully synthetic GUVs, in which most raft lipid analogs mis-partitioned to the disordered phase. This behavior correlates with the greatly enhanced order difference between coexisting phases in the synthetic system. In addition, not only partitioning, but also ligand binding of the lipids is perturbed upon labeling: while cholera toxin B binds unlabeled GM1 in the Lo phase, it binds fluorescently labeled GM1 exclusively in the Ld phase. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) by stimulated emission depletion (STED) nanoscopy on intact cellular plasma membranes consistently reveals a constant level of confined diffusion for raft lipid analogs that vary greatly in their partitioning behavior, suggesting different physicochemical bases for these phenomena.     

Lateral Membrane Diffusion Modulated by a Minimal Actin Cortex

Diffusion of lipids and proteins within the cell membrane is essential for numerous membrane-dependent processes including signaling and molecular interactions. It is assumed that the membrane-associated cytoskeleton modulates lateral diffusion. Here, we use a minimal actin cortex to directly study proposed effects of an actin meshwork on the diffusion in a well-defined system. The lateral diffusion of a lipid and a protein probe at varying densities of membrane-bound actin was characterized by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS). A clear correlation of actin density and reduction in mobility was observed for both the lipid and the protein probe. At high actin densities, the effect on the protein probe was ∼3.5-fold stronger compared to the lipid. Moreover, addition of myosin filaments, which contract the actin mesh, allowed switching between fast and slow diffusion in the minimal system. Spot variation FCS was in accordance with a model of fast microscopic diffusion and slower macroscopic diffusion. Complementing Monte Carlo simulations support the analysis of the experimental FCS data. Our results suggest a stronger interaction of the actin mesh with the larger protein probe compared to the lipid. This might point toward a mechanism where cortical actin controls membrane diffusion in a strong size-dependent manner.     

Measuring surface dynamics of biomolecules by total internal reflection fluorescence with photobleaching recovery or correlation spectroscopy.

The theoretical basis of a new technique for measuring equilibrium adsorption/desorption kinetics and surface diffusion of fluorescent-labeled solute molecules at solid surfaces has been developed. The technique combines total internal reflection fluorescence (TIR) with either fluorescence photobleaching recovery (FPR) or fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS). A laser beam totally internally reflects at a solid/liquid interface; the shallow evanescent field in the liquid excites the fluorescence of surface adsorbed molecules. In TIR/FPR, adsorbed molecules are bleaching by a flash of the focused laser beam; subsequent fluorescence recovery is monitored as bleached molecules exchange with unbleached ones from the solution or surrounding nonilluminated regions of the surface. In TIR/FCS, spontaneous fluorescence fluctuations due to individual molecules entering and leaving a well-defined portion of the evanescent field are autocorrelated. Under appropriate experimental conditions, the rate constants and surface diffusion coefficient can be readily obtained from the TIR/FPR and TIR/FCS curves. In general, the shape of the theoretical TIR/FPR and TIR/FCS curves depends in a complex manner upon the bulk and surface diffusion coefficients, the size of the iluminated or observed region, and the adsorption/desorption/kinetic rate constants. The theory can be applied both to specific binding between immobilized receptors and soluble ligands, and to nonspecific adsorption processes. A discussion of experimental considerations and the application of this technique to the adsorption of serum proteins on quartz may be found in the accompanying paper (Burghardt and Axelrod. 1981. Biophys. J. 33:455).     

FCS Analysis of Protein Mobility on Lipid Monolayers

In vitro membrane model systems are used to dissect complex biological phenomena under controlled unadulterated conditions. In this context, lipid monolayers are a powerful tool to particularly study the influence of lipid packing on the behavior of membrane proteins. Here, monolayers deposited in miniaturized fixed area-chambers, which require only minute amounts of protein, were used and shown to faithfully reproduce the characteristics of Langmuir monolayers. This assay is ideally suited to be combined with single-molecule sensitive fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) to characterize diffusion dynamics. Our results confirm the influence of lipid packing on lipid mobility and validate the use of FCS as an alternative to conventional surface pressure measurements for characterizing the monolayer. Furthermore, we demonstrate the effect of lipid density on the diffusional behavior of membrane-bound components. We exploit the sensitivity of FCS to characterize protein interactions with the lipid monolayer in a regime in which the monolayer physical properties are not altered. To demonstrate the potential of our approach, we analyzed the diffusion behavior of objects of different nature, ranging from a small peptide to a large DNA-based nanostructure. Moreover, in this work we quantify the surface viscosity of lipid monolayers. We present a detailed strategy for the conduction of point FCS experiments on lipid monolayers, which is the first step toward extensive studies of protein-monolayer interactions.     

Zero mode waveguides for single-molecule spectroscopy on lipid membranes

Zero mode waveguides (ZMWs), subwavelength optical nanostructures with dimensions ranging from 50 to 200 nm, have been used to study systems involving ligand-receptor interactions. We show that under proper conditions, lipid membranes will invaginate into the nanostructures, which confine optical excitation to subattoliter volumes. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) was used to characterize the diffusion of fluorescently tagged lipids in liquid-disordered phase 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) and gel phase 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DSPC) membranes incubated on the nanostructured surface. In contrast to the POPC, DSPC membranes did not appear to enter the structures, suggesting that invagination is dependent on membrane rigidity. Although correlation curves obtained from POPC membranes conformed to previously derived models for diffusion in the evanescent field within the nanostructure, the diffusion constants obtained were systematically lower than expected. The validity of the one-dimensional diffusion model for membrane diffusion is discussed and it is concluded that the erroneous diffusion constants are a result of nontrivial membrane conformation within the ZMWs. Additionally, FCS was used to characterize the fraction of fluorescently labeled tetanus toxin C fragment bound to a ganglioside-populated POPC membrane within the ZMWs. This allowed the determination of the toxin's equilibrium binding constant at a concentration of 500 nM; higher than possible with diffraction-limited FCS. To our knowledge, the results presented here are the first reported for supported lipid bilayers in nanostructured devices. Furthermore, they open the possibility of studying membrane imbedded receptors and proteins at physiological concentrations with single-molecule resolution.