Heat resistance, spore germination, and enterotoxigenicity of Clostridium perfringens

Heat resistance at 95 C, heat activation at 75 C, and germination response were determined for spores of 10 serotype strains of Clostridium perfringens type A, including five heat-resistant and five heat-sensitive strains. The D95-values ranged from 17.6 to 63.0 and from 1.3 to 2.8 for the heat-resistant and the heat-sensitive strains, respectively. The heat-activation values, the ratios between the heated and unheated viable counts of spore suspensions, ranged from 0.0035 to 0.65 and from 6.5 to 60.0 for the heat-sensitive and the heat-resistant strains, respectively. Spores of these strains were divided into two distinct germination types on the basis of their germination response; spores of the heat-resistant strains germinated in KC1 medium after heat activation (K-type), and spores of the heat-sensitive strains germinated in a mixture of L-alanine, inosine, and CaCl2 in the presence of CO2 without heat activation (A-type). The strains were tested for enterotoxigenicity by a reversed passive latex-agglutination (RPLA) test. All the heat-resistant strains were RPLA-positive, whereas the heat-sensitive strains were all RPLA-negative. A total of 37 strains of the organism isolated from food-poisoning outbreaks were tested for spore germination and enterotoxin formation. All of the 20 heat-resistant strains showed K-type spore germination and, except for three strains, were RPLA-positive, whereas all of the 17 heat-sensitive strains showed A-type spore germination and, except for only one strain, were RPLA-negative.     

Thermal resistance of wild-type and antibiotic-resistant Listeria monocytogenes in meat and potato substrates

AIMS: This study aimed to elucidate the relationship, if any, between the acquisition/possession of antibiotic resistance in strains of Listeria monocytogenes and the resistance of such strains to heat stress. METHODS AND RESULTS: D-values calculated using a linear survival model were used to compare the heat resistance of two wild-type (WT) and two antibiotic (streptomycin)-resistant (AR) mutant strains of L. monocytogenes measured in minced beef and potato substrates at 55 degrees C, with and without prior heat shock at 48 degrees C. In both minced beef and potato, no significant differences (P < 0.05) between D-values of AR and WT strains were noted. Heat shock did not significantly increase D-values of WT or AR strains in minced beef, while in potato slices, D-values in almost all cases were significantly higher in samples which had received heat-shock treatment. In minced beef, the use of a non-selective/overlay recovery medium did not result in higher D-values for any strains, while in potato, significantly higher (P < 0.05) D-values were obtained in most cases. CONCLUSION: The presence or absence of antibiotic resistance genes did not modulate the heat resistance of the strains examined in this study. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The study demonstrated that heat shock, and the type of media used to determine bacterial numbers during heat processing, can significantly affect the D-values obtained.     

Heat Resistance of Salmonella: the Uniqueness of Salmonella senftenberg 775W

Of approximately 300 cultures of Salmonella, representing 75 different serotypes, none was found to be as heat-resistant as S. senftenberg 775W. However, S. blockley 2004 was 5 times more heat-resistant and S. senftenberg 775W was 30 times more heat-resistant than S. typhimurium Tm-1, the reference strain in this study. All other strains of Salmonella tested, including 19 strains of S. senftenberg and 7 strains of S. blockley, had decimal reduction times at 57 C of about 1 min, equivalent to that of the reference organism, Tm-1. As observed in other bacterial species, strain 775W is more heat-sensitive in the log phase than in the stationary phase of growth. Cells from cultures grown at 44 C were more heat-resistant than those grown at either 35 or 15 C; the medium of growth, whether minimal or complex, made no appreciable difference in heat resistance. Cells from cultures limited by a carbon source were killed at a much slower rate than those limited by a nitrogen source and exhibited a 1-hr lag at 55 C before a significant rate of kill was attained. For any given set of growth conditions, strain 775W was always more heat-resistant than another strain of S. senftenberg, 197B, which has normal heat resistance.     

Induced thermotolerance under nonisothermal treatments of a heat sensitive and a resistant strain of Staphylococcus aureus in media of different pH

AIMS: The aim was to assess the induced thermotolerance under nonisothermal treatments of two strains of Staphylococcus aureus in media of different pH. METHODS AND RESULTS: Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923 was more heat resistant than S. aureus ATCC 13565 at any pH investigated under isothermal conditions. At pH 7.4, the D58 value of the resistant strain was approx. 30 times greater. Both strains showed a higher heat resistance at pH 4.0 than at pH 7.4. In contrast, under nonisothermal treatments (0.5-2 degrees C min(-1)), both strains were more heat resistant when treated at pH 7.4 than at pH 4.0 due to heat adaptation at the higher pH. At the slowest heating up rate tested at pH 7.4, the initially heat-sensitive strain nearly reached the thermotolerance of the heat-resistant strain. CONCLUSIONS: The induced thermotolerance under nonisothermal treatments depended on the treatment medium pH and the microbial strain tested. The induced thermotolerance in a sensitive strain can be greater than in a heat-resistant strain, showing similar resistance under nonisothermal conditions. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: This work shows data of interest about mechanisms of microbial resistance and adaptation to heat. Moreover, it contributes to the development of more adequate combined processes for food preservation.     

Heat and ozone resistance of Bacillus spores isolated from laboratory animals

Heat resistance of free-spores of 78 Bacillus strains isolated from laboratory animals was examined. Spores of 41 out of 78 strains survived for 320 minutes at 70 degrees C, 27 for 160 min, at 100 degrees C, only one for 20 min. at 110 degrees C by autoclaving, and none for 5 min. at 120 degrees C. D-values at 100 degrees C of 9 strains determined were between 5.03 and 30.06 min. Spores of 9 strains from stock cultures were exposed to ozone gas at various conditions. Ozone resistance of spores was closely dependent upon relative humidity. D-values of the spores tested by treatment with 200 ppm ozone at 60% RH were over 200 min., especially over 1,000 min. in 4 strains, indicating that exposure to ozone at a moderate humidity for 6 hours could not sterilize Bacillus spores. At 90% RH, however, treatment with 200 ppm ozone for 6 hr. might be effective for a routine sterilization in laboratory animal facilities.     

Combined effect of growth medium,age of cells and phase of sporulation on heat resistance and recovery of Hansenula anomala

Effects of two growth media, age of cells and phase of sporulation on heat resistance of Hansenula anomala were determined. Cells were grown on two solid media, McClary's acetate and V8 juice agars, at 21 ° C for 16 days. Heat resistance of cells was determined in 0.06 M potassium phosphate buffer at 48 ° C. Heat-stressed cells were plated on four recovery media: yeast extract-malt extract-peptone-glucose (YMPG), pH 7.0; YMPG, pH 3.5; YMPG containing 6% NaCl, pH 7.0; and YMPG containing 20% sucrose, pH 7.0. The composition of sporulation medium influenced the extent of sporulation and the relative heat resistance of sporulating cells. One-day-old cells were the most sensitive to heat. The heat resistance of cells was generally increased as the incubation time was extended to 16 days. Heat treatment caused a greater increase in sensitivity to NaCl than to sucrose or acid pH in recovery media. Young cells were more sensitive to NaCl than were older cells.     

Effect of culture age, pre-incubation at low temperature and pH on the thermal resistance of Aeromonas hydrophila.

The thermal resistance of Aeromonas hydrophila strain NCTC 8049 was determined within the range 48 degrees-65 degrees C with a thermoresistometer TR-SC and McIlvaine buffer. The effects of culture age, pre-incubation at 7 degrees C and the pH of the heating menstruum were evaluated. The pattern of thermal death was dependent on culture age. Cells heated in the late logarithmic growth phase (15 h at 30 degrees C) were twice as resistant as those in the early stage (5 h at 30 degrees C), and the maximum D-value was obtained after 72 h incubation (5.5 total increase). The age of the cells did not affect z-values significantly. The heat resistance of cells incubated for 48 h at 30 degrees C increased (twice) after holding at 7 degrees C for 72 h. Pre-incubation at low temperature of older cultures (72 h, 30 degrees C) did not influence their D-values. Maximum heat resistance was found at pH 6.0 and minimal at pH 4.0. Decreasing the pH from 6.0 to 4.0 reduced D-values by a factor of 5. Although the strain studied was heat-sensitive (D55 degrees C = 0.17 min; z = 5.11 degrees C), survivor curves of cultures older than 50 h showed a significant tailing. Organisms surviving in the tails were only slightly more resistant than were the original population.     

The effect of salt concentration and pH on the heat resistance of Escherichia coli in tryptic soy broth

The effect of the acid and the osmotic stress on the heat resistance of Escherichia coli (EC1 and EC2) was studied at 63 degrees C in tryptic soy broth adjusted to various pHs (2.5, 4.5 and 6) and various NaCl concentrations (2, 4 and 8%). In the second study, the effect of pretreatment on thermotolerance of E. coli cells was determined. The heat resistance of both strains was low at pH 2.5, but strain EC1 was more resistant than strain EC2. On the contrary, the heat resistance increased with increasing the pH values. Addition of NaCl (2%) to TSB medium, was involved in the protection of cells against heat inactivation, this protective effect was, however, not observed by increasing the NaCl concentration up to 8%. The combined effect of the pH and NaCl on the thermal resistance of both strains was significantly lower at pH 2.5 and NaCl 8%, the number of viable cells decreased from approximately 10(8) CFU/ml to an undetectable number within 20 min for strain EC1 and 15 min for strain EC2, respectively. This study indicates that heat resistance of strain EC1 was enhanced after acid or thermal adaptation. Heat resistance of strain EC2 was, however, enhanced only after thermal adaptation. For both strains no relationship was found between salt adaptation and the ability to resist thermal stress.     

Thermal destruction of Clostridium botulinum spores suspended in tomato juice in aluminum thermal death time tubes.

The heat destruction characteristics of Clostridium botulinum spores suspended in tomato juice and phosphate buffer were determined by the survivor curve method with aluminum thermal death time tubes. Two type A strains of C. botulinum and a type B strain were evaluated. Strains A16037 and B15580 were implicated in outbreaks of botulism involving home-canned tomato products. Strain A16037 had a higher heat resistance than either 62A or B15580. The mean thermal resistance (D-values) for A16037 in tomato juice (pH 4.2) were: 115.6 degrees C, 0.4 min; 110.0 degrees C, 1.6 min; and 104.4 degrees C, 6.0 min. The mean D-values for A16037 in Sorensen 0.067 M phosphate buffer (pH 7) were: 115.6 degrees C, 1.3 min; 110.0 degrees C, 4.4 min; and 104.4 degrees C, 17.6 min. At each test temperature, the D-values were approximately three times higher in buffer than in tomato juice. The z-value for C. botulinum A16037 spores in tomato juice was 9.4 degrees C, and in buffer the z-value was 9.9 degrees C. The use of aluminum thermal death time tubes in a miniature retort system makes it possible to determine survivor curves for C. botulinum spores at 121.1 degrees C. This is possible because the lag correction factor for the aluminum tubes is only about 0.2 min, making possible heating times as short as 0.5 min.     

Bacillus sporothermodurans and other highly heat-resistant spore formers in milk

A recent example of a micro-organism causing undesired growth in consumer milk is Bacillus sporothermodurans producing highly heat-resistant spores (HRS) which may survive ultra-high temperature (UHT) treatment or industrial sterilization. Molecular typing showed a heterogeneous group of farm isolates (non-HRS strains), but a clonal group of UHT isolates from diverse European countries and other continents (HRS-clone) suggesting a common source. During a survey of Belgian dairy farms for the presence of potentially highly heat-resistant spore formers, high numbers of these spores were detected in filter cloth, green crop and fodder samples. The strain collection showed a high taxonomic diversity with 18 potentially new species and with Bacillus licheniformis and Geobacillus pallidus as predominating species overall. Seventeen B. sporothermodurans isolates were identified, mainly originating from feed concentrate. Heat resistance studies showed the UHT resistance of B. sporothermodurans spores present in industrially contaminated UHT milk, but a lower heat resistance of laboratory-grown strains (HRS and non-HRS). Hydrogen peroxide, used as sanitizer in the dairy industry, was found to induce higher heat resistance of laboratory-grown B. sporothermodurans strains to a certain level. This indicates that sublethal stress conditions may affect the heat resistance. By transmission electron microscopy, structural differences at the spore level were found between HRS and non-HRS strains. The data indicate that the attainment of extreme heat resistance is rather multifactorial.     

Sporulation of Clostridium perfringens (welchii) in Four Laboratory Media

S ummary . Sporulation of 7 strains of Clostridium perfringens ( welchii ) was investigated in 4 laboratory media. A method to induce rapid and simultaneous sporulation was attempted which involved obtaining a purely vegetative culture to inoculate the test media. Heat resistance of spores produced in the individual media by each of 4 selected strains was investigated. The clean spores for the heating tests were obtained by a special procedure which included chilling to 6° for a minimum of 1 week immediately following the usual incubation period, then centrifuging, resuspending to volume in 0.85% NaCl solution and pasteurizing at 75° for 20 min before subjecting to the heating tests. Morphology of each strain was studied using stained microscopic preparations from the 24 h sporulating cultures.
In the Ellner medium spore counts approaching 10⁷/ml were recorded and this medium appeared to be the most efficient when judged in terms of numbers of spores produced. In other media the counts were in the range 10⁴-10⁵ spores/ml. Cooked meat medium yielded slightly higher spore counts than did either SEC broth or modified Wagenaar & Dack medium, the latter contained in a dialysis sac apparatus. A period of chilling to 6° for a minimum of 1 week following incubation enhanced maturation in all cultures except those grown in SEC broth for 24 h or 15 days and those grown 15 days in the modified Wagenaar & Dack medium.
Considerable heat resistance, expressed as percentage spore survival, was recorded for spores of 4 strains when heated at 80°, and heat resistance generally increased with lengthening of incubation time for the culture. Survival of spores heated at 100° for 10 min was usually less than 0.01% but spores in SEC broth after 15 days showed a somewhat greater heat resistance than the others. In no instance did total destruction of spores occur at 100°.     

Partial purification and characterization of phospholipase C from Yersinia enterocolitica

About 34% of the strains of Yersinia enterocolitica isolated from raw milk were found to produce lecithinase. A selected strain produced phospholipase C at 22 degrees C and 37 degrees C; production was optimum at 37 degrees C in the stationary phase (14-16 h). A decrease in phospholipase C activity at various storage temperatures (-5 degrees C, 4 degrees C, 37 degrees C) was also observed, although the enzyme was active over a wide range of temperature (5-65 degrees C) and pH (3.5-7.5). The phospholipase C was partially purified by ammonium sulphate precipitation and Sephadex column chromatography, and characterized.     

Relationship between the heat resistance of spores and the optimum and maximum growth temperatures of Bacillus species

Heat resistance of spores of Bacillus strains was compared with the temperature adaptation of each strain as measured by the optimum and maximum growth temperatures and the heat resistance of vegetative cells. Maximum growth temperatures ranged from 31 to 76 degrees C and were little affected by the nature of the growth medium. The temperature giving maximum growth rate was closely correlated to the maximum temperature for growth, and about 6 degrees C lower. Vetetative-cell heat resistance, determined on exponential-phase cells, was also correlated with maximum growth temperature. The temperature at which spores were inactivated with a decimal reduction time of 10 min was in the range of 75 to 121 degrees C. This temperature was 46 +/- 7 degrees C higher than the maximum growth temperature and correlated with it and the other cell parameters. Spore heat resistance can be considered to have two components, the temperature adaptation characteristic of the species and the stabilization conferred by the spore state.     

Effect of water activity and pH on growth and toxin production by Clostridium botulinum type G

The combined effect of water activity (aw) and pH on growth and toxin production by Clostridium botulinum type G strain 89 was investigated. The minimum aw at which growth and toxin formation occurred was 0.965, for media in which the pH was adjusted with either sodium chloride or sucrose. The minimum pH (at the optimum aw) for growth and toxin production of C. botulinum type G was found to be 5.6. Optimum conditions for toxin activation were a trypsin concentration of 0.1%, a pH of the medium of 6.5, and an incubation for 45 min at 37 degrees C. These data did not show evidence of heat-labile spores, since a heat shock of 75 degrees C for 10 min did not significantly decrease the spore count of strain 89G in media at pH 7.0 or 5.6. It was frequently observed that cells grown at reduced aw or pH experienced severe morphological changes.     

Effect of water activity and pH on growth and toxin production by Clostridium botulinum type G.

The combined effect of water activity (aw) and pH on growth and toxin production by Clostridium botulinum type G strain 89 was investigated. The minimum aw at which growth and toxin formation occurred was 0.965, for media in which the pH was adjusted with either sodium chloride or sucrose. The minimum pH (at the optimum aw) for growth and toxin production of C. botulinum type G was found to be 5.6. Optimum conditions for toxin activation were a trypsin concentration of 0.1%, a pH of the medium of 6.5, and an incubation for 45 min at 37 degrees C. These data did not show evidence of heat-labile spores, since a heat shock of 75 degrees C for 10 min did not significantly decrease the spore count of strain 89G in media at pH 7.0 or 5.6. It was frequently observed that cells grown at reduced aw or pH experienced severe morphological changes.     

Partial purification and characterization of phospholipase C from Yersinia enterocolitica

About 34% of the strains of Yersinia enterocolitica isolated from raw milk were found to produce lecithinase. A selected strain produced phospholipase C at 22°C and 37°C; production was optimum at 37°C in the stationary phase (14–16 h). A decrease in phospholipase C activity at various storage temperatures (—5°C, 4°C, 37°C) was also observed, although the enzyme was active over a wide range of temperature (5–65°C) and pH (3mD5–7mD5). The phospholipase C was partially purified by ammonium sulphate precipitation and Sephadex column chromatography, and characterized.     

Improved Medium for Sporulation of Clostridium perfringens

An improved sporulation medium has been developed in which all five strains of Clostridium perfringens tested exhibited a 100- to 10,000-fold increase in numbers of spores when compared with spore yields in SEC medium under comparable conditions. In addition, three of five strains produced a 100- to 1,000-fold increase, with the remaining two strains yielding approximately the same numbers of spores, when compared with strains cultured in Ellner medium. At the 40-hr sampling time, 18 of 27 strains produced a 10- to 100-fold increase in numbers of spores in our medium, when compared to spore production obtained in a medium recently reported by Kim et al. The new medium contained yeast extract, 0.4%; proteose peptone, 1.5%; soluble starch, 0.4%; sodium thioglycolate, 0.1%; and Na(2)HPO(4). 7H(2)O, 1.0%. In some cases, the spore yield could be increased by the addition of activated carbon to the new medium. The inclusion of activated carbon in the medium resulted in spores with slightly greater heat resistance than spores produced in the new medium without added carbon or in SEC or in Ellner medium. The major differences in heat resistance of the various strains appeared to be genetically determined rather than reflections of a particular sporulation medium. A definite heat-shock requirement was shown for four of four strains, with the optimal temperature ranging from 60 C for a heat-sensitive strain to 80 C for a heat-resistant strain. Heating for 20 min at the optimal temperature resulted in a 100-fold increase over the viable count obtained after heating for 20 min at 50 C.     

Biochemical differentiation between enterotoxigenic heat-sensitive and heat-resistant Clostridium perfringens strains

Some biochemical characteristics of 37 enterotoxigenic Clostridium perfringens strains isolated from human feces, ground beef, and soil samples by heat-selection methods and of two NCTC strains were studied. Two different biochemical patterns closely related to the heat resistance of the strains were found. The strains placed into group 1 were trehalose, inositol, and sorbitol negative and synthesized heat-resistant spores, while those placed into group 2 were trehalose and inositol positive and synthesized heat-sensitive spores. Sorbitol fermentation was variable among the strains of this last group. The strains of group 1 were more cellobiose, melibiose, and salicin fermentative than those of group 2. Only the strains placed into group 2 synthesized toxins of sufficient levels for typing. In spite of having been isolated by mild heat treatment of the specimens, two strains showed the same biochemical and toxigenic characteristics of the strains of group 1. The heating of these two strains did not modify their characteristics. We conclude that enterotoxigenic C. perfringens strains showing the two different toxigenic and biochemical patterns are present in the human gut, ground beef, and, probably, in soil. These strains may be differentiated on the basis of their capacity to produce acid from trehalose, inositol, and sorbitol, heat resistance of the spores and grade of toxigenicity. The heat-selection methods used for isolation of C. perfringens strains from different sources exerted a selection of strains from one or another group, but had no influence on their toxigenic and biochemical properties.     

A rapid method for the determination of bacterial fatty acid composition

Heat treatment of spores of non-proteolytic strains of Clostridium botulinum at 75–90°C, and enumeration of survivors on a nutrient medium containing lysozyme gave biphasic survival curves. A majority of spores were inactivated rapidly by heating, and the apparent heat-resistance of these spores was similar to that observed by enumeration on medium without lysozyme. A minority of spores showed much greater heat-resistance, due to the fact that the spore coat was permeable to lysozyme, which diffused into the spore from the medium and replaced the heat-inactivated germination system. The proportion of heated spores permeable to lysozyme was between 0.2 and 1.4% for spores of strains 17B (type B) and Beluga (type E), but was about 20% for spores of strain Foster B96 (type E). After treatment of heated spores with alkaline thioglycolate, all were permeable to lysozyme. D-values for heated spores that were permeable to lysozyme (naturally and after treatment with thioglycolate) were: for strain 17B, D₈₅°C, 100 min; D₉₀°C, 18.7 min; D₉₅°C, 4.4 min; for strain Beluga, D₈₅°C, 46 min; D₉₀°C, 11.8 min; D₉₅°C, 2.8 min. The z-values for these spores of strains 17B and Beluga were 7.6°C and 8.3°C.