Spatial memory during the tropism of maize (Zea mays L.) coleoptiles

Photo- or gravitropic stimulation of graminean coleoptiles involves the formation of putative tropistic transverse polarities. It had been postulated that these polarities can be extended by stabilization to developmentally active polarities. Such polarities are known from unicellular spores and zygotes of lower plants and regeneration experiments in dicotyledonous plants. In coleoptiles, photo- or gravitropic stimulation results in stability to counterstimulation of equal strength (with only transient bending in the direction of the second stimulus), as a result of a directional memory, if the time interval between both stimuli exceeds 90 min. This directional memory develops from a labile precursor, which is present from at least 20 min after induction. Once it is stable, spatial memory is conserved for many hours. The formation of spatial memory involves at least one step not present in the common tropistic transduction chain. The spatial expression of memory as curvature is restricted to three distinct responses: (i) curving in the direction of the first stimulus (for time intervals exceeding 90 min); (ii) curving in the direction of the second stimulus (for time intervals shorter than 65 min); and (iii) zero-curvature (for time intervals between 65 and 90 min). This can be interpreted in terms of a stable transverse polarity, which is not identical with the putative tropistic transverse polarity, but might be an extension of it.     

Interaction of gravi- and phototropic stimulation in the response of maize (Zea mays L.) coleoptiles

The influence of gravitropic stimulation upon blue-light-induced first positive phototropism for stimulations in the same (light source and center of gravity opposite to each other) and in opposing directions was investigated in maize cole-optiles by measuring fluence-response patterns. As a result of gravitropic counterstimulation, phototropic bending was transient with maximum curvature occurring 100 min after stimulation. On a horizontal clinostat, however, the seedlings curved for 20 h. Gravistimulation in the opposite direction acted additively upon blue-light curvature. Gravistimulation in the same direction as phototropic stimulation produced a complex behaviour deviating from simple additivity. This pattern can be explained by a gravitropically mediated sensitization of the phototropic reaction, an optimal dependence of differential growth on the sum of photo-and gravistimulation, and blue-light-induced inhibition of gravitropic curvature at high fluences. These findings indicate that several steps of photo-and gravitransduction are separate. Preirradiation with red light desensitized the system independently of applied gravity-treatment, indicating that the site of red-light interaction is common to both transduction chains.Abbreviations BL blue light - G⁺ stimulation by light and gravity in the same direction (i.e. light source and center of gravity opposite to each other) - G^- stimulation by light and gravity in opposing directions     

Induction of transverse polarity by blue light: An all-or-none response

Phototropic stimulation induces a spatial memory. This was inferred from experiments with maize (Zea mays L.) coleoptiles involving opposing blue-light pulses, separated by variable time intervals, and rotation on a horizontal clinostat (Nick and Schafer, 1988b, Planta 175, 380-388). In those experiments, individual seedlings either curved towards the first or towards the second pulse, or they remained straight. Bending, if it occurred, seemed to be an all-or-none response. Intermediates, i.e. plants, bending only weakly, were not observed. In the first part of the present study it was attempted to create such intermediates. For this purpose the strength of the first, inducing, and the second, opposing, pulse was varied. The result was complex: (i) Individual seedlings maintained the all-or-none expression of spatial memory. (ii) However, on the level of the whole population, the time intervals at which a given response type dominated depended on the fluence ratio. (iii) Furthermore, the final curvature was determined by the fluence ratio. These results are discussed in terms of a blue-light-induced transverse polarity. This polarity initiates from a labile precursor, which can be reoriented by an opposing stimulation (indicated by the strong bending towards the second pulse). The strong curvatures towards the first pulse over long time intervals reveal that, eventually, the blue-light-induced transverse polarity becomes stabilised and thus immune to the counterpulse. In the second part of the study, the relation between phototropic transduction and transverse polarity was characterised by a phenomenological approach involving the following points: (i) Sensory adaptation for induction of transverse polarity disappears with a time course similar to that for phototropic sensory adaptatation. (ii) The fluence response for induction of transverse polarity is a saturation curve and not bell-shaped like the curve for phototropism (iii) For strong counterpulses and long time intervals the clinostat-elicited nastic response (Nick and Schafer 1989, Planta 179, 123-131) becomes manifest and causes an "aiming error" towards the caryopsis. (iv) Temperature-sensitivity of polarity induction was high in the first 20 min after induction, then dropped sharply and rose again with the approach of polarity fixation. (v) Stimulus-summation experiments indicated that, for different inducing fluences, the actual fixation of polarity happened at about 2 h after induction. These experiments point towards an early separation of the transduction chains mediating phototropism and transverse polarity, possibly before phototrophic asymmetry is formed.     

Nastic response of maize (Zea mays L.) coleoptiles during clinostat rotation

Rotation of unstimulated maize (Zea mays L.) seedlings on a horizontal clinostat is accompanied by a strong bending response of the coleoptiles towards the caryopsis, yielding curvatures exceding 100°. The corresponding azimuthal distribution shows two peaks, each of which is displayed by 30° from the symmetry axis connecting the shortest coleoptile and caryopsis cross sections. It is argued that this spatial pattern is not the result of two independent bending preferences, but caused by a one-peaked distribution encountering an obstacle in its central part and thus being split into the two subpeaks. The existence of one preferential direction justifies considering this response to be a nastic movement. Its time course consists of an early negative phase (coleoptiles bend away from the caryopsis) followed 2 h later by a longlasting positive bending towards the caryopsis. In light-interaction experiments, fluence-response curves for different angles between blue light and the direction of the nastic response were measured. These experiments indicate that blue light interacts with the nastic response at two levels: (i) phototonic inhibition, and (ii) addition of nastic and phototropic curvatures. It is concluded that phototropic and phototonic transduction bifurcate before the formation of phototropic transverse polarity. The additivity of nastic and phototropic responses was followed at the population level. At the level of the individual seedling, one observes, in the case of phototropic induction opposing nastic movement, three distinct responses: either strong phototropism, or nastic bending, or an avoidance response which involves strong curvature perpendicular to the stimulation plane. With time the nastic bending becomes increasingly stable against opposing phototropic stimulation. This can be seen from a growing proportion of seedlings exhibiting nastic bending when light is applied at variable intervals after the onset of clinostat rotation. At the transition from instability to stability, this type of experiment produces a high percentage of seedlings displaying the avoidance response. However, no cancelling resulting in zero curvature can be observed. It is concluded that the endogenous polarity underlying the nastic response is different in its very nature from the blue-light-elicited stable transverse polarity described earlier (Nick and Schäfer 1988 b).Abbreviation BL blue light (449 nm)     

Phototropic Stimulation can Shift the Gradient of Crown Root Emergence in Maize

The crown roots in the coleoptilar node of maize emerge asymmetrically: emergence at the dorsal flank of the node (opposite to the caryopsis) precedes emergence at the ventral flank (facing the caryopsis). This asymmetry can be altered by phototropic stimulation: emergence of crown roots is delayed in the lighted flank and promoted in the shaded flank causing an inversion of the endogenous asymmetry. The curvature induced by the phototropic stimulation is transient, the effect on crown root emergence, in contrast, persists. This stable effect is not a consequence of curvature per se and becomes irreversibly fixed between one and two hours after stimulation. The emergence of crown roots depends on directional signalling from the coleoptile to the node. The data are discussed in terms of a stable blue light induced transverse polarity of the coleoptile that can imprint a stable asymmetry upon the coleoptilar node guiding the emergence of crown roots.     

Inversion of gravitropism by symmetric blue light on the clinostat

Gravitropic stimulation of maize (Zea mays L.) seedlings resulted in a continuous curvature of the coleoptiles in a direction opposing the vector of gravity when the seedlings were rotated on a horizontal clinostat. The orientation of this response, however, was reversed when the gravitropic stimulation was preceeded by symmetric preirradiation with blue light (12.7 mol photons·m^–2). The fluence-response curve of this blue light exhibited a lower threshold at 0.5 mol·m^–2, and could be separated into two parts: fluences exceeding 5 mol·m^–2 reversed the direction of the gravitropic response, whereas for a range between the threshold and 4 mol·m^–2 a split population was obtained. In all cases a very strong curvature resulted either in the direction of gravity or in the opposite orientation. A minor fraction of seedlings, however, curved towards the caryopsis. Furthermore, the capacity of blue light to reverse the direction of the gravitropic response disappeared with the duration of gravitropic stimulation and it depended on the delay time between both stimulations. Thistonic blue-light influence appears to be transient, which is in contrast to the stability observed fortropistic blue-light effects.This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.     

Phytochrome-mediated phototropism in maize seedling shoots

Unilateral irradiation with red light (R) or blue light (BL) elicits positive curvature of the mesocotyl of maize (Zea mays L.) seedlings raised under R for 2 d from sowing and kept in the dark for 1 d prior to curvature induction. The fluenceresponse curve for R-induced mesocotyl curvature, obtained by measuring curvature 100 min after phototropic induction, shows peaks in two fluence ranges, designated first positive range (from the threshold to the trough), and second positive range (above the trough). The fluence-response curve for BL is similar to that for R but shifted two orders of magnitude to higher fluences. Blue light elicits the classical first positive curvature of the coleoptile, whereas this response is not found with R. Positive mesocotyl curvature induced by either R or BL is eliminated by R given from above just before the unilateral irradiation, whereas BL-induced coleoptile curvature is not eliminated. The above results collectively offer evidence that phototropic curvature of the mesocotyl is induced by R-sensitive photosystem(s). Mesocotyl curvature in the second positive range is reduced by vertical far-red light (FR) applied after phototropic induction with R, but is not affected by FR applied before R. Unilateral irradiation with FR following vertical irradiation with a high R fluence leads to negative curvature of the mesocotyl. It is concluded that mesocotyl curvature in the second positive range results from a gradient in the amount of the FR-absorbing form of phytochrome (Pfr) established across the plant axis. Mesocotyl curvature in the first positive range is inhibited by vertical FR given either before or after phototropic induction with R. Since the FR used here is likely to produce more Pfr than the very low fluences of R eliciting the mesocotyl curvature in the first positive range, it is assumed that FR reduces the response in this case by adding Pfr at both sides of the plant axis. By rotating seedlings on a clinostat with its axis horizontal, the kinetics of mesocotyl curvature can be studied in the absence of a counteracting gravitropic response. On the clinostat, the R-induced mesocotyl curvature develops after a lag, through two successive phases having different curvature rates, the late phase is slower than the early phase. Negative curvature of the coleoptile can be induced by either R or BL; the BL-induced negative curvature is found at fluences higher than those giving positive curvature. The clinostat experiments show that the negative coleoptile curvature induced by either R or BL is a gravitropic compensation for positive mesocotyl curvature.Abbreviations BL blue light - FR far-red light - Pfr phytochrome in the far-red-absorbing form - Pr phytochrome in the red-absorbing form - R red light C.I.W.-D.P.B. Publication No. 824     

Red-light-induced positive phototropism in Arabidopsis roots

The interaction between light and gravity is critical in determining the final form of a plant. For example, the competing activities of gravitropism and phototropism can determine the final orientation of a stem or root. The results reported here indicate that, in addition to the previously described blue-light-dependent negative phototropic response in roots, roots of Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. display a previously unknown red-light-dependent positive phototropic response. Both phototropic responses in roots are considerably weaker than the graviresponse, which often masks phototropic curvature. However, through the use of mutant strains with impaired gravitropism, we were able to identify a red-light-dependent positive phototropic response in Arabidopsis roots. The red-induced positive phototropic response is considerably weaker than the blue-light response and is barely detectable in plants with a normal gravitropic response. Received: 22 May 2000 / Accepted: 3 July 2000     

Physical strain-mediated microtubule reorientation in the epidermis of gravitropically or phototropically stimulated maize coleoptiles

During gravitropic and phototropic curvature of the maize coleoptile, the cortical microtubules (MTs) adjacent to the outer epidermal cell wall assume opposite orientations at the two sides of the organ. Starting from a uniformly random pattern during straight growth in darkness, the MTs reorientate perpendicularly to the organ axis at the outer (faster growing) side and parallel to the organ axis at the inner (slower growing) side. As similar reorientations can be induced during straight growth by increasing or decreasing the effective auxin concentration, it has been proposed that these reorientations may be used as a diagnostic test for assessing the auxin status of the epidermal cells during tropic curvature. This idea was tested by determining the MT orientations in the coleoptile of intact maize seedlings in which the gravitropic or phototropic curvature was prevented or inversed by an appropriate mechanical counterforce. Forces that just prevented the coleoptile from curving in a gravity or light field prevented reorientations of the MTs. Forces strong enough to overcompensate the tropic stimuli by enforcing curvature in the opposite direction induced reorientations of the MTs opposite to those produced by tropic stimulation. These results show that the MTs at the outer surface of the coleoptile respond to changes in mechanical tissue strain rather than to gravitropic or phototropic stimuli and associated changes at the level of auxin or any other element in the signal transduction chain between perception of tropic stimuli and asymmetric growth response. It is proposed that cortical MTs can act as strain gauges in a positive feed-back regulatory circle utilized for amplification and stabilization of environmentally induced changes in the direction of elongation growth.     

Polarity induction versus phototropism in maize: Auxin cannot replace blue light

In a previous study (Nick and Schäfer 1991, Planta 185, 415–424), unilateral blue light had been shown, in maize coleoptiles, to induce phototropism and a stable transverse polarity, which became detectable as stable curvature if counteracting gravitropic stimulation was removed by rotation on a horizontal clinostat. This response was accompanied by a reorientation of cortical microtubules in the outer epidermis (Nick et al. 1990, Planta 181, 162–168). In the present study, this stable transverse polarity is shown to be correlated with stability of microtubule orientation against blue light and changes of auxin content. The role of auxin in this stabilisation was assessed. Although auxin can induce reorientation of microtubules it fails to induce the stabilisation of microtubule orientation induced by blue light. This was even true for gradients of auxin able to induce a bending response similar to that ellicited by phototropic stimulation. Experiments involving partial irradiation demonstrated different perception sites for phototropism and polarity induction. Phototropism starts from the very coleoptile tip and involves transmission of a signal (auxin) towards the subapical elongation zone. In contrast, polarity induction requires local action of blue light in the elongation zone itself. This blue-light response is independent of auxin.This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft and two grants of the Studienstiftung des Deutschen Volkes and the Human Frontier Science Program Organization to P.N.     

Enhancement of phototropic response to a range of light doses in Triticum aestivum coleoptiles in clinostat-simulated microgravity

The phototropic dose-response relationship has been determined for Triticum aestivum cv. Broom coleoptiles growing on a purpose-built clinostat apparatus providing gravity compensation by rotation about a horizontal axis at 2 rev·min^-1. These data are compared with data sets obtained with the clinostat axis vertical and stationary, as a 1·g control, and rotating vertically to examine clinostat effects other than gravity compensation. Triticum at 1·g follows the wellestablished pattern of other cereal coleoptiles with a first positive curvature at low doses, followed by an indifferent response region, and a second positive response at progressively increasing doses. However, these response regions lie at higher dose levels than reported for Avena. There is no significant difference between the responses observed with the clinostat axis vertical in the rotating and stationary modes, but gravity compensation by horizontal rotation increases the magnitude of first and second positive curvatures some threefold at 100 min after stimulation. The indifferent response is replaced by a significant curvature towards the light source, but remains apparent as a reduced curvature response at these dose levels.     

Control of hypocotyl phototropism by phytochrome in a dicotyledonous seedling (Sesamum indicum L.)

Abstract The phototropic response in stems of higher plants is brought about by blue/UV light. The problem studied here is to what extent long-wavelength light, which is absorbed by phytochrome, affects the phototropic response. A refined measurement of phototropism — a curvature index — was applied to the hypocotyl of the sesame seedling (Sesamum indicum L.). The time course of the phototropic response was followed in continuous unilateral weak blue light (B, 460 nm, 8 mW m^?2). Long term red light (R) pretreatments, operating through phytochrome, strongly increase the rate and extent of the phototropic response once it is elicited by unilateral B, while the pretreatments decrease the sensitivity towards B. If a R pulse is given immediately prior to the onset of unilateral B, the rate of the response is strongly reduced compared to the time course of curvature observed when the pretreatment was terminated with a long wavelength far-red light (FR) pulse. R and FR were then applied simultaneously with unilateral B to manipulate the status of the phytochrome system during actual curvature. It was found that a low Pfr/P ratio (established by FR) stimulates the phototropic response far above the control (B alone), while a high Pfr/P ratio (established by R) reduces the response below the control. During bending a positive effect of phytochrome on the rate and extent of the phototropic response, which is saturated at a low level of Pfr, appears to be counteracted by an inhibitory effect which dominates at higher levels of Pfr, such as established by omnilateral R. However, if R is applied unilaterally from the same direction as B, R increases the rate of curvature. Apparently the sesame seedling is capable of detecting the direction of R relative to the direction of B. While a mechanistic explanation of these effects cannot be advanced at present, it is clear that the seedling is capable of super-imposing information about the actual light conditions during bending on a ‘memory’ of the light conditions prior to the onset of bending. Thus, the previous as well as the actual light conditions determine its phototropic responsiveness.     

Correlations between proton-efflux patterns and growth patterns during geotropism and phototropism in maize and sunflower

By placing seedlings of sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) or maize (Zea mays L.) on agar plates containing a pH indicator dye it is possible to observe surface pH patterns along the growing seedling by observing color changes of the indicator dye. Using this method we find that in geotropically stimulated sunflower hypocotyls or maize coleoptiles there is enhanced proton efflux on the lower surface of the organ prior to the initiation of curvature. As curvature develops the pattern of differential acid efflux becomes more intense. A similar phenomenon is observed when these organs are exposed to unilateral illumination, i.e. enhanced acid efflux occurs on the dark side of the organ prior to the initiation of phototropic curvature and the pattern of differential acid efflux intensifies as phototropic curvature develops. These observations indicate that differential acid efflux occurs in response to tropistic stimuli and that the acid efflux pattern may mediate the development of tropistic curvatures.     

Control of hypocotyl gravitropism by photochrome in a dicotyledonous seedling (Sesamum indicum L.)

Abstract The present study was prompted by the question as to whether the strong effect of red and far-red light treatments on blue-light-mediated phototropism in the sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) hypocotyl (Woitzik & Mohr, 1988) should be attributed in part to changes initialed by light in the gravitropic counter-response. Light treatments, operating through phytochrome, do indeed strongly affect the gravitropic response. However, the direction of the light effect is the same in gravitropism, as in phototropism. Thus, the gravitropic counter-response leads to an underestimate, rather than an overestimate, of the importance of phytochrome action on phototropic responsiveness. The effect of red and far-red light, operating via phytochrome, on the gravitropic response of the sesame hypocotyl could be studied in the present paper without any interference due to phototropism or light control of longitudinal growth. It was found that the effects of red and far-red pretreatments (given prior to the onset of the stimulus) as well as the action of simultaneously applied red or far-red light (simultaneous to the phototropic or gravitropic stimulus) are very similar in both phototropism and gravitropism. In particular, the seedling is capable of superimposing information about the actual light conditions during bending on the ‘memory’ it has about the light conditions prior to the onset of phototropism or gravitropic stimulation, This striking similarity between the phototropic and gravitropic responses possibly indicates that phytochrome affects the signal-response-chain at a relatively late stage, after the phototropic and the gravitropic signal-response chains have merged. From a teleonomic point of view the action of red and far-red light on phototropic, as well as gravitropic, responsiveness can be conceived as part of a shade escape strategy.     

Phototropism of rice (Oryza sativa L.) coleoptiles: fluence-response relationships, kinetics and photogravitropic equilibrium

Phototropism of rice (Oryza sativa L.) coleoptiles induced by unilateral blue light was characterized using red-light-grown seedlings. Phototropic fluence-response relationships, investigated mainly with submerged coleoptiles, revealed three response types previously identified in oat and maize coleoptiles: two pulse-induced positive phototropisms and a phototropism that depended on stimulation time. The effective ranges of fluences and fluence rates were comparable to those reported for maize. Compared with oats and maize, however, curvature responses in rice were much smaller and coleoptiles straightened faster after establishing the maximal curvature. When stimulated continuously, submerged coleoptiles developed curvature slowly over a period of 6 h, whereas air-grown coleoptiles, which showed smaller phototropic responsiveness, established a photogravitropic equilibrium from about 4 h of stimulation. The plot of the equilibrium angle against log fluence rates yielded a bell-shaped optimum curve that spanned over a relatively wide fluence-rate range; a maximal curvature of 25° occurred at a fluence rate of 1 μmol · m⁻² · s⁻¹. This optimum curve apparently reflects the light sensitivity of the steady-state phototropic response. Received: 28 June 1996 / Accepted: 30 July 1996     

Desensitization by red and blue light of phototropism in maize coleoptiles

The effects of pretreatments with red and blue light (RL, BL) on the fluence-response curve for the phototropism induced by a BL pulse (first positive curvature) were investigated with darkadapted maize (Zea mays L.) coleoptiles. A pulse of RL, giving a fluence sufficient to saturate phytochrome-mediated responses in this material, shifted the bell-shaped phototropic fluence-response curve to higher fluences and increased its peak height. A pulse of high-fluence BL given immediately prior to this RL treatment temporarily suppressed the phototropic fluence-response curve, and shifted the curve to higher fluences than induced by RL alone. The shift by BL progressed rapidly compared to that by RL. The results indicate (1) that first positive curvature is desensitized by both phytochrome and a BL system, (2) that desensitization by BL occurs with respect to both the maximal response and the quantum efficiency, and (3) that the desensitization responses mediated by phytochrome and the BL system can be induced simultaneously but develop following different kinetics. It is suggested that theses desensitization responses contribute to the induction of second positive curvature, a response induced by prolonged irradiation.Abbreviations BL blue light - RL red light CIW-DPB Publication No. 1001     

Tropic responses of hypocotyls from normal tomato plants and the gravitropic mutant Lazy-1

Abstract Etiolated hypocotyls from normal tomato plants show a negative gravitropic response within 20 min of stimulation. In contrast, etiolated hypocotyls from the gravitropic mutant Lazy-l do not reorientate after gravistimulation. Etiolated hypocotyls from both types of plant are positively phototropic, however, Lazy-l seedlings achieve a greater final angle of bending following phototropic stimulation compared to normal plants. Anatomical studies reveal that etiolated hypocotyls from normal plants contain sedimenting amyloplasts located within the endodermal cells. Such sedimenting amyloplasts are absent in Lazy-l tissue. It is hypothesized that the hypocotyl of Lazy-l is agravitropic since it is unable to perceive a gravistimulus.     

Unilateral reorientation of microtubules at the outer epidermal wall during photo- and gravitropic curvature of maize coleoptiles and sunflower hypocotyls

Auxin (indole-3-acetic acid) controls the orientation of cortical microtubes (MT) at the outer wall of the outer epidermis of growing maize coleoptiles (Bergfeld, R., Speth, V., Schopfer, P., 1988, Bot. Acta 101, 57-67). A detailed time course of MT reorientation, determined by labeling MT with fluorescent antibodies, revealed that the auxin-mediated movement of MT from the longitudinal to the transverse direction starts after less than 15 min and is completed after 60 min. This response was used for a critical test of the functional involvement of auxin in tropic curvature. It was found that phototropic (first phototropic curvature) as well as gravitropic bending are correlated with a change of MT orientation from transverse to longitudinal at the slower-growing organ flank whereas the transverse MT orientation is maintained (or even augmented) at the faster-growing organ flank. These directional changes are confined to the MT subjacent to the outer epidermal wall. The same basic results were obtained with sunflower hypocotyls subjected to phototropic or gravitropic stimulation. It is concluded that auxin is, in fact, involved in asymmetric growth leading to tropic curvature. However, our results do not allow us to discriminate between an uneven distribution of endogenous auxin or an even distribution of auxin, the activity of which is modulated by an unevenly distributed inhibitor of auxin action.     

Gravitropism in roots of intermediate-starch mutants of Arabidopsis

Gravitropism was studied in roots of wild type (WT) Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heynh. (strain Wassilewskija) and three starch-deficient mutants that were generated, by T-DNA insertional mutagenesis. One of these mutants was starchless while the other two were intermediate mutants, which had 51% and 60%, respectively, of the WT amount of starch as. determined by light and electron microscopy. The four parameters used to assay gravitropism were: orientation during vertical growth, time course of curvature, induction, and intermittent stimulation experiments. WT roots were much more responsive to gravity than were roots of the slarchless mutant, and the intermediate starch mutants exhibited an intermediate graviresponse. Our data suggest that lowered starch content in the mutants primarily affects gravitropism rather than differential growth because both phototropic curvature and growth rates were approximately equal among all four genotypes. Since responses of intermediate-starch mutants were closer to the WT response than to that of the starchless mutant, it appears that 51–60% of the WT level of starch is near the threshold amount needed for full gravitropic sensitivity. While other interpretations are possible, the data are consistent with the starch statolith hypothesis for gravity perception in that the degree of graviresponsiveness is proportional to the total mass of plastids per cell.