Mss51p and Cox14p jointly regulate mitochondrial Cox1p expression in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Mutations in SURF1, the human homologue of yeast SHY1, are responsible for Leigh's syndrome, a neuropathy associated with cytochrome oxidase (COX) deficiency. Previous studies of the yeast model of this disease showed that mutant forms of Mss51p, a translational activator of COX1 mRNA, partially rescue the COX deficiency of shy1 mutants by restoring normal synthesis of the mitochondrially encoded Cox1p subunit of COX. Here we present evidence showing that Cox1p synthesis is reduced in most COX mutants but is restored to that of wild type by the same mss51 mutation that suppresses shy1 mutants. An important exception is a null mutation in COX14, which by itself or in combination with other COX mutations does not affect Cox1p synthesis. Cox14p and Mss51p are shown to interact with newly synthesized Cox1p and with each other. We propose that the interaction of Mss51p and Cox14p with Cox1p to form a transient Cox14p-Cox1p-Mss51p complex functions to downregulate Cox1p synthesis. The release of Mss51p from the complex occurs at a downstream step in the assembly pathway, probably catalyzed by Shy1p.     

Analysis of Leigh Syndrome Mutations in the Yeast SURF1 Homolog Reveals a New Member of the Cytochrome Oxidase Assembly Factor Family

Three missense SURF1 mutations identified in patients with Leigh syndrome (LS) were evaluated in the yeast homolog Shy1 protein. Introduction of two of the Leigh mutations, F²⁴⁹T and Y³⁴⁴D, in Shy1 failed to significantly attenuate the function of Shy1 in cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) biogenesis as seen with the human mutations. In contrast, a G¹³⁷E substitution in Shy1 results in a nonfunctional protein conferring a CcO deficiency. The G¹³⁷E Shy1 mutant phenocopied shy1Δ cells in impaired Cox1 hemylation and low mitochondrial copper. A genetic screen for allele-specific suppressors of the G¹³⁷E Shy1 mutant revealed Coa2, Cox10, and a novel factor designated Coa4. Coa2 and Cox10 are previously characterized CcO assembly factors. Coa4 is a twin CX₉C motif mitochondrial protein localized in the intermembrane space and associated with the inner membrane. Cells lacking Coa4 are depressed in CcO activity but show no impairment in Cox1 maturation or formation of the Shy1-stabilized Cox1 assembly intermediate. To glean insights into the functional role of Coa4 in CcO biogenesis, an unbiased suppressor screen of coa4Δ cells was conducted. Respiratory function of coa4Δ cells was restored by the overexpression of CYC1 encoding cytochrome c. Cyc1 is known to be important at an ill-defined step in the assembly and/or stability of CcO. This new link to Coa4 may begin to further elucidate the role of Cyc1 in CcO biogenesis.Leigh syndrome (LS) is a highly progressive neurological disorder of infancy characterized by necrotizing lesions in the midbrain and brain stem (32). Humans afflicted with LS have compromised oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) function due to mutations in nuclear or mitochondrial genes encoding respiratory chain components or their assembly factors. Although LS infants are born with a normal appearance, neurological lesions develop within months and dysfunction extends to other organs, resulting in a high mortality rate. LS patients typically have mutations affecting complex I or complex IV (cytochrome c oxidase [CcO]) of the OXPHOS pathway (14). Patients with a specific CcO deficiency most often have mutations in the SURF1 gene that encodes a CcO assembly factor (9, 15, 41).SURF1 is not absolutely required for CcO biogenesis in humans, since SURF1-deficient patient fibroblasts retain 10 to 15% of residual CcO activity (32). The yeast homolog of SURF1 is Shy1 (SURF1 homolog in yeast) and has a conserved function in CcO biogenesis (24). Yeast lacking Shy1 retain residual CcO activity, but growth of the mutant strain is compromised on respiratory, nonfermentable carbon sources (4).Insights into the function of SURF1 in human cells have been gleaned through the characterization of stalled CcO assembly intermediates in cells isolated from SURF1 LS patients using blue native (BN) gel electrophoresis. One intermediate, designated S2, which accumulates in SURF1-deficient patient fibroblasts, consists of Cox1 in association with two nuclear CcO subunits, CoxIV and Va (38, 45, 47). A similar stalled assembly intermediate accumulates in CcO-deficient patients with mutations in two other assembly factors, SCO1 and SCO2. These assembly proteins function in the maturation of the mitochondrially encoded Cox2 subunit and the binuclear copper (Cu_A) site within this subunit. In contrast, studies with patient fibroblasts harboring mutations in the genes encoding Cox10 and Cox15 proteins, which are involved in the biosynthesis of the heme a cofactor used exclusively by CcO (at the heme a and heme a₃:Cu_B sites), show only free Cox1 by BN analysis (1, 2). These data suggest that CcO biogenesis commences with the mitochondrial synthesis and maturation of Cox1, while the other two mitochondrially encoded subunits, Cox2 and Cox3, are added at later stages. The absence of the S2 intermediate in cells with mutations in COX10 or COX15 is consistent with the prediction that the S2 assembly intermediate contains Cox1 with at least the heme a center formed.The first major clue to the function of SURF1 came from studies with the bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides, in which surf1 mutant cells showed impairment in the formation of the heme a₃:Cu_B bimetallic center within Cox1 (33). Specifically, heme a and Cu_B were observed spectroscopically with surf1 mutant cells, but heme a₃ was not present. The Cu_B site had an altered spectroscopic signature to compensate for the loss of heme a₃, as the two cofactors typically coordinate with each other. This study suggests Surf1 is involved in the maturation of the heme a₃ site in CcO. In lower eukaryotes, impairment of CcO assembly results in proteolytic degradation of the stalled intermediates (16). Thus, it is not possible to isolate the CcO complex in shy1Δ yeast cells to identify any missing cofactors. However, Shy1 was shown to have a key role in formation of the heterobimetallic Cu_B:heme a₃ center in yeast Cox1 (18). Furthermore, it was recently shown that Surf1 in bacteria is a heme-binding protein (10), although these findings have yet to be confirmed in eukaryotes.Additional insights into the function of SURF1/Shy1 came from the isolation of genetic suppressors of shy1Δ respiratory deficiency in yeast (3). Respiratory function can be partially restored in shy1Δ cells by enhancing Cox1 translation through the overexpression of MSS51 (6), a dual-function protein that acts as a COX1 translational activator in addition to binding to the newly synthesized Cox1 polypeptide. Suppression of the shy1Δ respiratory defect is also observed with enhanced expression levels of the two CcO subunits Cox5a and Cox6 corresponding to the human S2-containing subunits CoxIV and Va (15). Overexpression of COA2, a recently identified CcO assembly factor shown to interact with Shy1, can also suppress the shy1Δ respiratory defect (30). Finally, overexpression of the COX10 gene that encodes the hydroxyfarnesyl transferase, which generates heme o as the first step in heme a biosynthesis, can partially restore respiratory function in shy1Δ cells. Although overexpression of COX10 has only very weak suppressor activity, a marked synergistic effect was apparent in the overexpression of both MSS51 and COX10 (29).Shy1 has a secondary function in yeast in the maintenance of the conserved mitochondrial copper storage pool that is used in the copper metallation of Cox1 and Cox2 during CcO biogenesis. Yeast cells lacking Shy1 contain mitochondria with a partially depleted matrix copper storage pool, and the respiratory defect of shy1Δ cells can be partially reversed by growth in the presence of exogenous copper (29). Similarly, liver and muscle samples from patients with SURF1 mutations exhibit a cellular copper deficiency (37). Maintenance of the matrix copper pool is postulated to be linked to active CcO biogenesis in general, as patient tissue with mutations to two other CcO assembly factors, SCO1 and SCO2, result in a cellular copper deficiency as well (22).Human SURF1 and yeast Shy1 are both mitochondrial proteins tethered to the inner membrane (IM) by two transmembrane (TM) helices with a large central domain projecting into the intermembrane space (IMS). Most LS patients with SURF1 mutations have gene deletions or rearrangements. Missense mutations in SURF1 are quite rare, with only a limited number being reported. These mutations tend to be associated with a mild clinical phenotype, and patient survival is prolonged (28). We selected a subset of known missense mutations, two of which lie within the IMS globular domain and a third that maps to the second TM domain. In an attempt to gain further insights into which functional step of SURF1 was compromised by the missense mutations, we engineered and characterized the corresponding mutations in conserved residues of yeast SHY1. In doing so, we have additionally identified a new member of the CcO assembly factor family, Coa4, that may be linked to the role of cytochrome c in CcO assembly. We show that the respiratory defect of cells lacking Coa4 is specifically suppressed by the overexpression of the IMS electron carrier cytochrome c (CYC1). This is the first time CYC1 has been found as a suppressor of a CcO assembly mutant.     

Shy1 couples Cox1 translational regulation to cytochrome c oxidase assembly

Cytochrome c oxidase (complex IV) of the respiratory chain is assembled from nuclear and mitochondrially-encoded subunits. Defects in the assembly process lead to severe human disorders such as Leigh syndrome. Shy1 is an assembly factor for complex IV in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and mutations of its human homolog, SURF1, are the most frequent cause for Leigh syndrome. We report that Shy1 promotes complex IV biogenesis through association with different protein modules; Shy1 interacts with Mss51 and Cox14, translational regulators of Cox1. Additionally, Shy1 associates with the subcomplexes of complex IV that are potential assembly intermediates. Formation of these subcomplexes depends on Coa1 (YIL157c), a novel assembly factor that cooperates with Shy1. Moreover, partially assembled forms of complex IV bound to Shy1 and Cox14 can associate with the bc1 complex to form transitional supercomplexes. We suggest that Shy1 links Cox1 translational regulation to complex IV assembly and supercomplex formation.     

Cytochrome oxidase assembly does not require catalytically active cytochrome C

Cytochrome c oxidase (COX), the terminal enzyme of the mitochondrial respiratory chain, catalyzes the transfer of electrons from reduced cytochrome c to molecular oxygen. COX assembly requires the coming together of nuclear- and mitochondrial-encoded subunits and the assistance of a large number of nuclear gene products acting at different stages of maturation of the enzyme. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, expression of cytochrome c, encoded by CYC1 and CYC7, is required not only for electron transfer but also for COX assembly through a still unknown mechanism. We have attempted to distinguish between a functional and structural requirement of cytochrome c in COX assembly. A cyc1/cyc7 double null mutant strain was transformed with the cyc1-166 mutant gene (Schweingruber, M. E., Stewart, J. W., and Sherman, F. (1979) J. Biol. Chem. 254, 4132-4143) that expresses stable but catalytically inactive iso-1-cytochrome c. The COX content of the cyc1/cyc7 double mutant strain harboring non-functional iso-1-cytochrome c has been characterized spectrally, functionally, and immunochemically. The results of these studies demonstrate that cytochrome c plays a structural rather than functional role in assembly of cytochrome c oxidase. In addition to its requirement for COX assembly, cytochrome c also affects turnover of the enzyme. Mutants containing wild type apocytochrome c in mitochondria lack COX, suggesting that only the folded and mature protein is able to promote COX assembly.     

Cytochrome c oxidase biogenesis: new levels of regulation

Eukaryotic cytochrome c oxidase (COX), the last enzyme of the mitochondrial respiratory chain, is a multimeric enzyme of dual genetic origin, whose assembly is a complicated and highly regulated process. COX displays a concerted accumulation of its constitutive subunits. Data obtained from studies performed with yeast mutants indicate that most catalytic core unassembled subunits are posttranslationally degraded. Recent data obtained in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae have revealed another contribution to the stoichiometric accumulation of subunits during COX biogenesis targeting subunit 1 or Cox1p. Cox1p is a mitochondrially encoded catalytic subunit of COX which acts as a seed around which the full complex is assembled. A regulatory mechanism exists by which Cox1p synthesis is controlled by the availability of its assembly partners. The unique properties of this regulatory mechanism offer a means to catalyze multiple-subunit assembly. New levels of COX biogenesis regulation have been recently proposed. For example, COX assembly and stability of the fully assembled enzyme depend on the presence in the mitochondrial compartments of two partners of the oxidative phosphorylation system, the mobile electron carrier cytochrome c and the mitochondrial ATPase. The different mechanisms of regulation of COX assembly are reviewed and discussed.     

Functional alteration of cytochrome c oxidase by SURF1 mutations in Leigh syndrome

Subacute necrotising encephalomyopathy (Leigh syndrome) due to cytochrome c oxidase (COX) deficiency is often caused by mutations in the SURF1 gene, encoding the Surf1 protein essential for COX assembly. We have investigated five patients with different SURF1 mutations resulting in the absence of Surf1 protein. All of them presented with severe and generalised COX defect. Immunoelectrophoretic analysis of cultured fibroblasts revealed 85% decrease of the normal-size COX complexes and significant accumulation of incomplete COX assemblies of 90-120 kDa. Spectrophotometric assay of COX activity showed a 70-90% decrease in lauryl maltoside (LM)-solubilised fibroblasts. In contrast, oxygen consumption analysis in whole cells revealed only a 13-31% decrease of COX activity, which was completely inhibited by detergent in patient cells but not in controls. In patient fibroblasts ADP-stimulated respiration was 50% decreased and cytofluorometry showed a significant decrease of mitochondrial membrane potential DeltaPsi(m) in state 4, as well as a 2.4-fold higher sensitivity of DeltaPsi(m) to uncoupler. We conclude that the absence of the Surf1 protein leads to the formation of incomplete COX complexes, which in situ maintain rather high electron-transport activity, while their H(+)-pumping is impaired. Enzyme inactivation by the detergent in patient cells indicates instability of incomplete COX assemblies.     

Coa1 links the Mss51 post-translational function to Cox1 cofactor insertion in cytochrome c oxidase assembly

The assembly of cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) in yeast mitochondria is shown to be dependent on a new assembly factor designated Coa1 that associates with the mitochondrial inner membrane. Translation of the mitochondrial-encoded subunits of CcO occurs normally in coa1Delta cells, but these subunits fail to accumulate. The respiratory defect in coa1Delta cells is suppressed by high-copy MSS51, MDJ1 and COX10. Mss51 functions in Cox1 translation and elongation, whereas Cox10 participates in the biosynthesis of heme a, a key cofactor of CcO. Respiration in coa1Delta and shy1Delta cells is enhanced when Mss51 and Cox10 are coexpressed. Shy1 has been implicated in formation of the heme a3-Cu(B) site in Cox1. The interaction between Coa1 and Cox1, and the physical and genetic interactions between Coa1 and Mss51, Shy1 and Cox14 suggest that Coa1 coordinates the transition of newly synthesized Cox1 from the Mss51:Cox14 complex to the heme a cofactor insertion involving Shy1. coa1Delta cells also display a mitochondrial copper defect suggesting that Coa1 may have a direct link to copper metallation of CcO.     

Surf1, Associated with Leigh Syndrome in Humans, Is a Heme-binding Protein in Bacterial Oxidase Biogenesis

Biogenesis of mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase (COX) relies on a large number of assembly factors, among them the transmembrane protein Surf1. The loss of human Surf1 function is associated with Leigh syndrome, a fatal neurodegenerative disorder caused by severe COX deficiency. In the bacterium Paracoccus denitrificans, two homologous proteins, Surf1c and Surf1q, were identified, which we characterize in the present study. When coexpressed in Escherichia coli together with enzymes for heme a synthesis, the bacterial Surf1 proteins bind heme a in vivo. Using redox difference spectroscopy and isothermal titration calorimetry, the binding of the heme cofactor to purified apo-Surf1c and apo-Surf1q is quantified: Each of the Paracoccus proteins binds heme a in a 1:1 stoichiometry and with K_d values in the submicromolar range. In addition, we identify a conserved histidine as a residue crucial for heme binding. Contrary to most earlier concepts, these data support a direct role of Surf1 in heme a cofactor insertion into COX subunit I by providing a protein-bound heme a pool.Leigh syndrome (LS)³ is an autosomal recessive inherited neurodegenerative disorder characterized by focal, bilateral lesions in one or more areas of the central nervous system (1). Symptoms start in early childhood, and the disease usually progresses rapidly. Although mutations in various mitochondrial enzymes can result in LS, its most frequent trigger is deficiency of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) caused by mutations in the SURF1 gene, as identified in LS patients (2, 3). Human SURF1, the first gene of the SURFEIT gene locus on chromosome 9, encodes a 30-kDa protein related to COX assembly (2, 3).Mitochondrial COX consists of up to 13 subunits (SU). The three core SU encoded by the mitochondrial genome carry all of the redox-active cofactors, two heme a moieties, and three copper ions. These three SU are highly conserved among different organisms and represent the main components of bacterial oxidase complexes as well (4, 5). The assembly process of mitochondrial COX is only marginally understood, involving the interplay of a large number of auxiliary proteins (6–9).Despite intensive efforts over more than a decade to unravel Surf1 function, its exact role in COX assembly still remains unclear. Surf1 is not strictly essential for COX assembly because patients with LS have residuals of assembled oxidase with remaining activity of approximately 10–20% in all tissues (2, 3). Located in the inner mitochondrial membrane, Surf1 is predicted to form two transmembrane helices connected by a long loop facing the intermembrane space (10, 11). Sequence alignments confirm the presence of Surf1 homologs in many eukaryotes and prokaryotes (12).One of the best studied Surf1 proteins is the yeast homolog Shy1p, which has been discovered and characterized in the context of pet mutants (10). Deletion of the gene leads to a strongly decreased COX level, although the residual enzyme appears fully functional. This points to a role of Shy1p in assembly or stabilization of COX (13), most likely during the formation of an early assembly intermediate consisting of the highly conserved core SU I and II (14).So far, only three bacterial homologs have been inspected in closer detail (15, 16). In Paracoccus denitrificans, two Surf1 homologs were identified and named Surf1c and Surf1q for their specific role in serving a heme aa₃-type COX and a related heme ba₃-type quinol oxidase, respectively (15). With the function of Surf1 in COX assembly still being speculative, a role in heme a insertion into COX SU I seemed conceivable (15, 16).Here we show that P. denitrificans Surf1c and Surf1q are able to bind heme a both in vivo and in vitro. This novel finding suggests that Surf1 proteins promote heme a insertion into SU I of either cytochrome c oxidase or quinol oxidase. In addition, Surf1 may modulate heme a synthase activity and provide a heme a cofactor pool in a safe, chelated form for COX SU I biogenesis.     

Consequences of cytochrome c oxidase assembly defects for the yeast stationary phase

The assembly of cytochrome c oxidase (COX) is essential for a functional mitochondrial respiratory chain, although the consequences of a loss of assembled COX at yeast stationary phase, an excellent model for terminally differentiated cells in humans, remain largely unexamined. In this study, we show that a wild-type respiratory competent yeast strain at stationary phase is characterized by a decreased oxidative capacity, as seen by a reduction in the amount of assembled COX and by a decrease in protein levels of several COX assembly factors. In contrast, loss of assembled COX results in the decreased abundance of many mitochondrial proteins at stationary phase, which is likely due to decreased membrane potential and changes in mitophagy. In addition to an altered mitochondrial proteome, COX assembly mutants display unexpected changes in markers of cellular oxidative stress at stationary phase. Our results suggest that mitochondria may not be a major source of reactive oxygen species at stationary phase in cells lacking an intact respiratory chain.     

A mutation in the Arabidopsis KT2/KUP2 potassium transporter gene affects shoot cell expansion

Potassium ions (K(+)) are the most abundant cations in plants and are necessary for cell growth. Arabidopsis shy3-1 mutant plants have a short hypocotyl, small leaves, and a short flowering stem, and these defects result from decreased cell expansion. The semidominant shy3-1 mutation changes an amino acid in KT2/KUP2, a K(+) transporter related to the Escherichia coli Kup protein. Second mutations in the KT2/KUP2/SHY3 gene, including presumed null mutations, suppress the shy3-1 phenotypes. Plants with these intragenic suppressor mutations appear similar to wild-type plants, suggesting that KT2/KUP2/SHY3 acts redundantly with other genes. Expression of the shy3-1 mutant version of KT2/KUP2/SHY3 in wild-type plants confers shy3-1-like phenotypes, indicating that shy3-1 probably either causes a gain of function or creates an interfering protein. The shy3-1 mutation does not eliminate the ability of the KT2/KUP2 cDNA to rescue the growth of a potassium transport-deficient E. coli mutant. A P(SHY3)::GUS fusion is expressed in growing portions of the plant. These results suggest that KT2/KUP2/SHY3 mediates K(+)-dependent cell expansion in growing tissues.     

Genetic defects of cytochrome c oxidase assembly

Cytochrome c oxidase (COX), the terminal enzyme of the mitochondrial respiratory chain, is one of the key functional and regulatory sites of the mammalian energy metabolism. Owing to the importance of the enzyme, pathogenetic mutations affecting COX frequently result in severe, often fatal metabolic disorders. No satisfactory therapy is currently available so that the treatment remains largely symptomatic and does not improve the course of the disease. While only few genetic defects of COX are caused by mutations in mitochondrial genome, during the last five years a large number of pathogenetic mutations in nuclear genes have been discovered. All these mutations are located in genes encoding COX-specific assembly proteins including SURF1, SCO1, SCO2, COX10, and COX15. Despite the identification of increasing number of mutations, their precise etiopathogenetic mechanisms, which are necessary for the development of future therapeutic protocols, still remain to be elucidated. This review summarizes recent developments, including our efforts in elucidation of the molecular basis of human mitochondrial diseases due to specific defects of COX with special focus on SURF1 assembly protein.     

Sequence conservation from human to prokaryotes of Surf1, a protein involved in cytochrome c oxidase assembly, deficient in Leigh syndrome

The human SURF1 gene encoding a protein involved in cytochrome c oxidase (COX) assembly, is mutated in most patients presenting Leigh syndrome associated with COX deficiency. Proteins homologous to the human Surf1 have been identified in nine eukaryotes and six prokaryotes using database alignment tools, structure prediction and/or cDNA sequencing. Their sequence comparison revealed a remarkable Surf1 conservation during evolution and put forward at least four highly conserved domains that should be essential for Surf1 function. In Paracoccus denitrificans, the Surf1 homologue is found in the quinol oxidase operon, suggesting that Surf1 is associated with a primitive quinol oxidase which belongs to the same superfamily as cytochrome oxidase.     

Cox25 teams up with Mss51, Ssc1, and Cox14 to regulate mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 expression and assembly in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase (COX) biogenesis is translationally regulated. Mss51, a specific COX1 mRNA translational activator and Cox1 chaperone, drives the regulatory mechanism. During translation and post-translationally, newly synthesized Cox1 physically interacts with a complex of proteins involving Ssc1, Mss51, and Cox14, which eventually hand over Cox1 to the assembly pathway. This step is probably catalyzed by assembly chaperones such as Shy1 in a process coupled to the release of Ssc1-Mss51 from the complex. Impaired COX assembly results in the trapping of Mss51 in the complex, thus limiting its availability for COX1 mRNA translation. An exception is a null mutation in COX14 that does not affect Cox1 synthesis because the Mss51 trapping complexes become unstable, and Mss51 is readily available for translation. Here we present evidence showing that Cox25 is a new essential COX assembly factor that plays some roles similar to Cox14. A null mutation in COX25 by itself or in combination with other COX mutations does not affect Cox1 synthesis. Cox25 is an inner mitochondrial membrane intrinsic protein with a hydrophilic C terminus protruding into the matrix. Cox25 is an essential component of the complexes containing newly synthesized Cox1, Ssc1, Mss51, and Cox14. In addition, Cox25 is also found to interact with Shy1 and Cox5 in a complex that does not contain Mss51. These results suggest that once Ssc1-Mss51 are released from the Cox1 stabilization complex, Cox25 continues to interact with Cox14 and Cox1 to facilitate the formation of multisubunit COX assembly intermediates.     

Assembly of cytochrome-c oxidase in the absence of assembly protein Surf1p leads to loss of the active site heme

Surf1p is a protein of the inner membrane of mitochondria that functions in the assembly of cytochrome-c oxidase. The specifics of the role of Surf1p have remained unresolved. Numerous mutations in human Surf1p lead to severe mitochondrial disease. A homolog of human Surf1p is encoded by the genome of the alpha-proteobacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides, which synthesizes a mitochondrial-like aa(3)-type cytochrome-c oxidase. The gene for Surf1p was deleted from the genome of R. sphaeroides. The resulting aa(3)-type oxidase was purified and analyzed by biochemical methods plus optical and EPR spectroscopy. The oxidase that assembled in the absence of Surf1p was composed of three subpopulations with structurally distinct heme a(3)-Cu active sites. 50% of the oxidase lacked heme a(3), 10-15% contained heme a(3) but lacked Cu(BB), and 35-40% had a normal heme a(3) -Cu(B) active site with normal activity. Cu(A) assembly was unaffected. All of the oxidase contained low-spin heme a, but the environment of the heme a center was slightly altered in the 50% of the enzyme that lacked heme a(3). Introduction of a normal copy of the gene for Surf1p on an exogenous plasmid resulted in a single population of normally assembled, highly active enzyme. The data indicate that Surf1p plays a role in facilitating the insertion of heme a(3) into the active site of cytochrome-c oxidase. The results suggest that maturation of the heme a(3)-Cu(B) center is a step that limits the association of subunits I and II in the assembly of mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase.