Cumulative effects assessment for the Northern River Basins Study

The primary objective of the Northern Rivers Basins Study (NRBS)was to advance the understanding of how anthropogenic developments haveimpacted the ecology of the Peace, Athabasca and Slave rivers, Canada.To investigate these multiple stressor impacts, the NRBS used acumulative effects assessment (CEA) based upon a weight of evidenceapproach. This CEA determined the exposure and effects of multiplestressors on these systems and included experimental verification ofcausality and linkage of this understanding to field data. Fish studiesconfirmed that dioxins and furans occur in the food web at low levelsacross the basins; detection frequencies for all2,3,7,8-substituted dioxin/furan congeners (2,3,7,8 TCDD/TCDF)were highest near bleached kraft pulp mills. PCDD/Fs, rather thanPCBs or organochlorine pesticides, were the chemicals of concern forhuman exposure. In addition, the recent decline in concentrations ofdioxins and furans in fish was commensurate with improvements in pulpmill treatment technologies. Throughout the basins, enrichment occurredbelow pulp mill and municipal discharges. Multiple stressor effects ofpulp mill effluent were separated from one another by using experimentsthat demonstrated that the primary impact of the mill effluent wasnutrient enrichment. River state was also greatly influenced byhydrologic impacts. In particularly, the Bennett Dam changed the ecologyof the Peace-Slave river-delta systems more than 1500~km downstream,while climate variability was an important contributing factor for thesedelta impacts. Notable contributions of the NRBS model were thecooperation among governments, aboriginal peoples, non-governmentorganizations, industry and other stakeholders, and the two-waycommunications flow among the scientific community and these groups.NRBS science was also deemed relevant because 16 questions forwarded bystakeholders focused the Study's CEA on specific issues of importancewithin the basin. In summary, the NRBS model of CEA included four keycomponents: (1) communication of stakeholder priorities to producerelevant science questions; (2) pursuit of the best availablescientific understanding of ecosystem impacts by engaginginterdisciplinary science teams; (3) assessment of futureenvironmental condition through monitoring and follow-upinvestigation; and (4) communication of results to managers toproduce appropriate regulatory change. This CEA model combines theseelements with scientific rigor to generate meaningful information tostakeholders while also improving regional assessments of riverbasins.     

Contaminant sources, distribution and fate in the Athabasca, Peace and Slave River Basins, Canada

Northern river ecosystems worldwide are under increasing environmental stress from degrading developments that influence water quality and associated ecological integrity. In particular, contaminant-related threats to these systems are rising from enhanced industrial and municipal effluent discharges along with elevated non-point source inputs related to land-use activities such as forestry, agriculture, mining and long-range atmospheric transport. In this regard, the contaminants program of the Northern River Basins Study (NRBS) in western Canada identified key contaminant sources to the Athabasca, Slave and Peace river basins (particularly related to pulp-mill developments) and assessed their environmental fate and distribution in water and sediments. The study also developed and employed new analytical approaches and generated improved models to predict contaminant transport and fate in the aquatic environment and related food webs. Consequently the study focused on those contaminant families identified in characterization studies as arising from key point- and non-point sources within the basins or as being of greatest toxicological significance. These included resin acids, polychlorinated dioxins and furans, polychlorinated biphenyls, chlorinated phenolics, polyaromatic hydrocarbons and selected heavy metals such as mercury. Low or non-detectable concentrations of a number of contaminant groups were found in the ambient water phase including chlorinated phenolics, some chlorinated dioxins and furans and some resin acids. For both suspended and depositional sediments, significant declines were observed over the study period for the major chlorinated contaminant groups tested, correlating directly with the implementation of improved effluent treatment in many of the pulp mills located in the basins. In general, the environmental levels of chlorinated organic and metal contaminants in water or sediments were low and within Canadian health or environmental guidelines. It is hoped that the approaches used and lessons learned from the NRBS will be of use to others assessing contaminant and multiple stressor issues in other large river ecosystems.     

Long-term development in a Baltic fish community exposed to bleached pulp mill effluent

Observations near a Swedish pulp mill at the Bothnian Sea during 1982-1992 revealed low fish abundance and a disturbed community structure. The presence of endocrine disrupting or toxic substances in effluent water was indicated by biomarker responses, impaired reproduction and stimulated growth in perch (Perca fluviatilis). In 1992 the bleaching process was altered and a secondary treatment system was installed, improving the quality and decreasing the amount of effluent. This paper presents the results of follow-up studies during 1995-1998 with the objective to analyse any recovery of the fish community due to changes in mill operations. Although abundance and diversity of the fish community did recover, an effect of enrichment, indicated by high catches of cyprinids, was still visible in the vicinity of the mill outlet. Sexual maturation was delayed, gonad development was retarded, average growth rate was faster, and the condition factor was higher in perch caught in the vicinity of the effluent outlet, than in perch captured elsewhere. It is concluded that substances inhibiting reproduction and causing growth disturbance were still present in the effluents in effective concentrations.     

PAH mineralization and bacterial organotolerance in surface sediments of the Charleston Harbor estuary

Semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs) in estuarine waters can adversely affect biota but watershed sources can be difficult to identify because these compounds are transient. Natural bacterial assemblages may respond to chronic, episodic exposure to SVOCs through selection of more organotolerant bacterial communities. We measured bacterial production, organotolerance and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) mineralization in Charleston Harbor and compared surface sediment from stations near a known, permitted SVOC outfall (pulp mill effluent) to that from more pristine stations. Naphthalene additions inhibited an average of 77% of bacterial metabolism in sediments from the more pristine site (Wando River). Production in sediments nearest the outfall was only inhibited an average of 9% and in some cases, was actually stimulated. In general, the stations with the highest rates of bacterial production also were among those with the highest rates of PAH mineralization. This suggests that the capacity to mineralize PAH carbon is a common feature amongst the bacterial assemblage in these estuarine sediments and could account for an average of 5.6% of bacterial carbon demand (in terms of production) in the summer, 3.3% in the spring (April) and only 1.2% in winter (December).     

Development of a sediment bioassay to determine bioavailability of PAHs to fish

Recent work has shown that MFO induction and loss of control of steroid hormone production occurs in fish after exposure to pulp mill effluents, PCBs, PAHs, and some pesticides. We had recently developed laboratory assays to evaluate the effluents on these responses, but were lacking a protocol for a sediment assay. This paper describes the development of a sediment test capable of demonstrating MFO induction in fish. MFO responses were evident in rainbow trout within 4 days of exposure to contaminated sediments. Further testing showed that fish were responding to chemicals from the sediments, but not from bottom water, and a survey of sediment from thirteen contaminated areas showed that MFO induction more closely paralleled PAH levels in the sediments than the observed PCB concentrations. The sites showing MFO induction were also the sites where sediment toxicity was demonstrated with laboratory bioassays using Daphnia magna and Hyalella azteca. The protocol has been further refined to describe the quantity of sediment required and duration of testing. This test will enable us to study the biochemical effects of exposure to contaminated sediments. The protocol could also be used to prioritize areas of contamination and to evaluate dredging impacts and remediation success.     

Bottom sediments and biocoenoses of northern Ladoga and their changes under human impact

Silty and clayey sediments predominate in the bottom sediments of the deep basin of northern Ladoga. Chemical fractionation of organic constituents of the sediments indicate prevalence of chemically stable fractions in most samples. The sedimentary diatom assemblages contain large numbers of littoral taxa, but more than 90% of the total counts of frustules belong to planktonic forms. The macro- and meiozoobenthic communities are characterized by a limited number of species, and the biomasses are low as a result of low temperatures and the small amount of organic matter entering the sediments. There are several restricted areas, e.g. shallow bays, in which pollution by pulp and paper mill or sewage effluents has led into significant changes in the benthic conditions, including increased organic content and heavy metal concentrations of the sediments. There is no apparent change in radioisotope activity, and maximum values do not exceed the natural activity of Karelian granites. Benthic biocoenoses have been affected especially near the sources of anthropogenic pollution, where extensive lifeless areas, polysaprobic zones, and morphological deformities of invertebrates have been observed. Some definite changes have taken place even in the deep profundal benthic communities (e.g. decline of Pallasea quadrispinosa and Gammaracanthus loricatus, increase of Potamothrix hammoniensis and Limnodrilus spp.) and sedimentary diatom assemblages in the open lake (increase of Diatoma elongatum, Asterionella formosa and Aulacoseira italica) since the 1960's. Since the closure of two of the pulp mills and diversion of effluents at a third site, the situation has locally improved, especially at those sites where water exchange is effective.     

Ecosystem health: an example of implications arising from regulations under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA), and the importance of setting precedent

Ecosystem health is a key principle which underlies the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA). This act is designed to protect human health and the environment from harmful and/or irreversible effects by providing a cradle-to-grave regulation of toxic substances.As an example of the application of this act, this contribution considers the most toxic dioxins and furans which are generally associated with Kraft pulp mill effluents. These are some of the first substances to come under the CEPA legislation. The proposed CEPA regulations for dioxins and furans are based on end-of-pipe control, which would effectively limit their concentrations in effluent to something close to measurable levels. Depending on sample matrix and methodology, however, measurable levels may differ considerably.Evidence presented at the Alberta-Pacific (ALPAC) pulp mill hearings in Alberta and the Northwest Territories during 1989 demonstrated that total loading are particularly important in dealing with the far-field effects of these extremely toxic, persistent, and bioaccumulating substances. Further, it was reported that there might be no threshold of effect for tetrachlorodibenzo-para-dioxin (2, 3, 7, 8, TCDD) or the companion furan. If such evidence is correct, the CEPA regulations should be designed to achieve zero discharge of these contaminants. Measurable levels, as presently defined in the CEPA regulations, may be in excess of zero discharge requirements.Clearly, such inconsistency may cause problems and should be addressed directly. Unfortunately, the first draft of the CEPA regulations represents a piecemeal approach. In this, it is unfair to industry, it is scientifically inadequate, and it may not be enforceable. The application of CEPA regulations for the pulp and paper industry will set a new precedent for Canada's approach to ecosystem health. It is therefore essential to base decisions on a good under-standing of the dynamics and effects of chemicals in ecosystems and to re-evaluate, carefully, the toxicities of key contaminants. Interim measures are likely appropriate.     

The occurrence of oligochaetes in lake chains receiving pulp mill waste and their relation to eutrophication on the trophic scale

Earlier conceptions of oligochaetes as indicators of trophy were somewhat enlarged to include more littoral, meiofaunal and naidid species. The amplitudes of different species on the oligotrophy-eutrophy axis seem to be generally large. Certain species which probably originally occur mainly in very humic environments seem also to be able to endure very strong organic loading caused by pulp mills. Species of this kind seem to be Dero digitata, Specaria josinae, Slavina appendiculata and Aulodrilus pluriseta. Chaetogaster langi and Arcteonais lomondi are also species which live in areas receiving pulp mill wastes. A. lomondi and D. digitata seem to be species living in greater depths than the naidids generally. Tubifex tubifex densities as high as 600000 ind · m^-2 were found near a pulp mill when the meiofauna method was used. A third of the T. tubifex were found deeper than 5 cm from the sediment surface. S. josinae and S. appendiculata may be found down to depths between 5 and 10 cm.     

Coliform bacteria and nitrogen fixation in pulp and paper mill effluent treatment systems

The majority of pulp and paper mills now biotreat their combined effluents using activated sludge. On the assumption that their wood-based effluents have negligible fixed N, and that activated-sludge microorganisms will not fix significant N, these mills routinely spend large amounts adding ammonia or urea to their aeration tanks (bioreactors) to permit normal biomass growth. N(2) fixation in seven Eastern Canadian pulp and paper mill effluent treatment systems was analyzed using acetylene reduction assays, quantitative nitrogenase (nifH) gene probing, and bacterial isolations. In situ N(2) fixation was undetectable in all seven bioreactors but was present in six associated primary clarifiers. One primary clarifier was studied in greater detail. Approximately 50% of all culturable cells in the clarifier contained nifH, of which >90% were Klebsiella strains. All primary-clarifier coliform bacteria growing on MacConkey agar were identified as klebsiellas, and all those probed contained nifH. In contrast, analysis of 48 random coliform isolates from other mill water system locations showed that only 24 (50%) possessed the nifH gene, and only 13 (27%) showed inducible N(2)-fixing activity. Thus, all the pulp and paper mill primary clarifiers tested appeared to be sites of active N(2) fixation (0.87 to 4.90 mg of N liter(-1) day(-1)) and a microbial community strongly biased toward this activity. This may also explain why coliform bacteria, especially klebsiellas, are indigenous in pulp and paper mill water systems.     

Nutrient enrichment of northern rivers in response to pulp mill and municipal discharges

To evaluate the effects of pulp mill and municipal sewageeffluents on the nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) status of northernCanadian rivers, the Northern River Basins Study required an integratedresearch and assessment program consisting of field observation andexperimentation. Analysis of monitoring data collected over 3–13 yshowed that on an annual basis, pulp mills contributed 22% of theP and 20% of the N load discharged from the Wapiti to the Smokyriver, and 6 to 16% of the P load and 4 to 10% of the Nload in the Athabasca River. Despite these low contributions, N and Pconcentrations were elevated below pulp mill discharges on all threerivers during the low discharge period of September to April. Insitu experiments conducted with nutrient diffusing substrata showedthat periphyton biomass was maintained at low levels by insufficient Pin the upper reaches of the Athabasca River and insufficient N+P inthe Wapiti River upstream of point-source discharges. In contrast,effluent loading from pulp mill and sewage inputs alleviated nutrientlimitation downstream of major discharges on both rivers. Experimentsconducted in artificial streams located beside the Athabasca Riverupstream of the first pulp mill showed that P addition increasedperiphyton biomass (expressed as chlorophyll a content) suchthat biomass increased sharply at low P concentrations (2–5µg/L soluble reactive P) and approached saturation at 35µg/L soluble reactive P. As a result of recommendations fromthis integrated program of river monitoring and experimentation,nutrient loading has been reduced to the most affected river(Wapiti-Smoky) and federal and provincial departments of environment arereviewing loading limits for other river reaches.     

Transformation of Organic Matter by a Microbial Community in Sediments of Lake Baikal under Experimental Thermobaric Conditions of Protocatagenesis

Early diagenesis of organic matter in bottom sediments of Lake Baikal is a focus of many geochemical studies, because it is one of the few sites of petroleum formation in a nonmarine environment. Although Baikal is a rift lake and considered one of the prospective fields for deep biosphere investigations, the transformation processes of organic matter by microbial communities from deep bottom sediments and likely entering of the microorganisms from deep sediments into the near-surface sediments were not previously studied in Lake Baikal. The natural microbial community from near-surface sediments of the cold methane seep Goloustnoe (Southern Baikal Basin) was incubated with methane and the diatom Synedra acus at 80°C and 49.5 atm to simulate catagenesis. The 11-month incubation yielded the enrichment culture of viable thermophilic microorganisms. Their presence in low-temperature sediment layers may be indicative of their migration through fault zones together with gas-bearing fluids. After culturing, molecular biological methods allowed for the detection of both widespread microorganisms and unique clones whose phylogenetic status is currently unknown. The sediment after the experiment showed the formation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon, retene. Retene can be either a conifer or algal biomarker, thus, interpretation of paleoclimate data is tenuous.     

Changes in water quality in Lake Päijänne following decrease of effluent load from the pulp and paper industry in 1969–1989

Lake Päijänne, the second largest lake in Finland, has been seriously polluted since the 1960s due to the effluents from pulp and paper mills, notably the Äänekoski sulphate and sulphite pulp mills situated about 50 km north of the lake, and the sulphite pulp mill and paper mills of Jämsänkoski and Kaipola on Central Lake Päijänne.A sulphite lye evaporation and combustion plant installed at the Jämsänkoski sulphite pulp mill in 1969 reduced the organic pollution of Central Päijänne. Lignin concentration decreased and the oxygen balance improved. The sulphite pulp mill was closed in 1981 and replaced by a thermo-mechanical pulp mill. Eutrophication is the main threat to water quality in Central Lake Päijänne at present.A significant improvement in the water quality, especially in oxygen balance, was achieved in the watercourse of Äänekoski and in Northern Päijänne after replacement of the old sulphite and sulphate pulp mills at Äänekoski by a large sulphate pulp mill with a biological purification plant employing the activated sludge method. The BOD₇-loading dropped from 46 to 3–4 t d^–1, but the nutrient loading has not decreased sufficiently, and the Äänekoski watercourse and Northern Päijänne are still eutrophic.     

Investigation of the biotransformation of pentachlorophenol and pulp paper mill effluent decolorisation by the bacterial strains in a mixed culture

Mixed culture of two bacterial strains Bacillus sp. and Serratia marcescens showed potential pentachlorophenol (PCP) degradation and decolorisation of pulp paper mill effluent. The physico-chemical quality of pulp paper mill effluent has been analyzed after 168 h incubation period degraded by mixed culture. The study revealed that it has decreased high load of BOD, COD, TS, TDS, TSS, sulphate, phosphate, total nitrogen, total phenols, metals and different salts (i.e. chloride, sodium, nitrate, potassium) at 168 h incubation period. PCP degradation in pulp paper mill effluent was confirmed by HPLC analysis. Mixed culture was found to degrade PCP up to (94%) present in pulp paper mill effluent with 1% glucose and 0.5% peptone (w/v) at 30 ± 1 °C, pH 8.0 ± 0.2 at 120 rpm in 168 h incubation period. The simultaneous release of chloride ion up to 1200 mg/l at 168 h emphasized the bacterial dechlorination in the medium. The pulp paper mill effluent degradation was also supported by decline in pH, AOX (absorbable organic halides), color, D.O., BOD, COD and PCP. The analysis of pulp paper mill effluent degradation products by GC–MS analysis revealed the formation of low molecular weight compound like 2-chlorophenol (RT = 3.8 min) and tetrachlorohydroquinone (RT = 11.86 min) from PCP extracted degraded sample. Further, mixed culture may be used for bioremediation of PCP containing pulp paper mill waste in the environment.     

Pulp and paper mill waste pollution in the Swale,a tidal channel on the east coast of England

The effect of pulp and paper mill waste discharges in the Swale, a tidal channel on the southeast coast of England, has been studied. A pulsing tidal movement in the Swale results in effluent being trapped within the estuary for up to 20 days. This has resulted in adverse effects on the quality of the water and sediment along a substantial part of the estuary with the greatest effect occurring east of the mill in the direction of the residual current. A reduction in the dissolved oxygen concentration occurred along a 13-km stretch of the estuary with mean values falling to 53 % saturation near the mill. High levels of organic matter in the sediment reflect the deposition of material from the mill effluent stream and loss on ignition values of up to 12 % were found east of the mill, falling to 5 % within 4 km northwest of the mill. The macrofauna of the intertidal mudflats was typical of a stressed environment with a low number of species and with a few being represented by large numbers of individuals. The dominant species was the sabellid polychaeteManayunkia aestuarina which reached peak numbers of over 1.5 million m⁻², 1.5 km east of the mill. An increase in the total biomass near the mill is thought to be associated with organic enrichment from the mill wastes.     

Application of P450RGS reporter gene system as a bioindicator of sediment PAH contamination in the vicinity of Incheon Harbor, Korea

Sixty seven sediment samples were collected from Kyeonggi Bay, Korea, including the mouth of Han River, Incheon Harbor, the Namdong industrial complex, and the open sea. Collections were conducted in December, 1995 and samples were maintained frozen (-20 °C) until analysis. Dichloromethane extracts were analysed for their content of CYP1A1-inducing compounds with a P450RGS (reporter gene system) assay, and for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Sediment samples were also analysed for organic carbon (OC) content and grain size, to aid in evaluating the relationship between contamination and physical nature of the sediments. The responses of the P450RGS assay to the sediment extracts were expressed as μg of benzo[a]pyrene toxic equivalents per g dry weight (μg g^-1 BaPTEQ), and these values correlated well (r² = 0.624 with total PAHs. BaPTEQ values were also highly correlated with the OC content of the sediments. The determination of P450RGS BaPTEQ is a useful tool, because it is both a rapid and inexpensive means of assessing the potential toxicity of organic compounds in environmental sediment samples. These values represent an estimate of the levels of compounds in the sediment that are potentially available to organisms through chronic exposure to pore water or ingestion of benthic species. We believe BaPTEQ values are more useful than tables of specific PAH concentrations, if the purpose of the investigation is to either obtain a rapid screening of an area or to develop some form of ecological or human health risk assessment.     

Coliform Bacteria and Nitrogen Fixation in Pulp and Paper Mill Effluent Treatment Systems

The majority of pulp and paper mills now biotreat their combined effluents using activated sludge. On the assumption that their wood-based effluents have negligible fixed N, and that activated-sludge microorganisms will not fix significant N, these mills routinely spend large amounts adding ammonia or urea to their aeration tanks (bioreactors) to permit normal biomass growth. N₂ fixation in seven Eastern Canadian pulp and paper mill effluent treatment systems was analyzed using acetylene reduction assays, quantitative nitrogenase (nifH) gene probing, and bacterial isolations. In situ N₂ fixation was undetectable in all seven bioreactors but was present in six associated primary clarifiers. One primary clarifier was studied in greater detail. Approximately 50% of all culturable cells in the clarifier contained nifH, of which >90% were Klebsiella strains. All primary-clarifier coliform bacteria growing on MacConkey agar were identified as klebsiellas, and all those probed contained nifH. In contrast, analysis of 48 random coliform isolates from other mill water system locations showed that only 24 (50%) possessed the nifH gene, and only 13 (27%) showed inducible N₂-fixing activity. Thus, all the pulp and paper mill primary clarifiers tested appeared to be sites of active N₂ fixation (0.87 to 4.90 mg of N liter⁻¹ day⁻¹) and a microbial community strongly biased toward this activity. This may also explain why coliform bacteria, especially klebsiellas, are indigenous in pulp and paper mill water systems.     

Effect, distribution, and prevalence of Glugea stephani (Microspora) in winter flounder (Pleuronectes americanus) living near two pulp and paper mills in Newfoundland

A study was conducted to determine the effects, geographical distribution, and prevalence of a microsporan parasite, Glugea stephani, in winter flounder (Pleuronectes americanus) in Newfoundland. Fish were captured by SCUBA divers in several coastal areas, including 2 embayments where pulp and paper mill effluent was discharged, as well as a number of pristine sites. Fish health was assessed by comparing histological profiles, condition factors (K), organosomatic indices and blood values between infected and uninfected samples. Multifocal xenomas of G. stephani were observed in several organs of fish taken near contaminated sites, whereas infected samples captured at a pristine site harbored the cysts only in the wall of the digestive tract. Proliferative inflammation, granuloma formation, and focal necrosis were associated with the infection primarily in the liver and kidney. Condition factors and blood values were lower and ovarian development inhibited or delayed in infected flounder. The multifocal infection occurred only in flounder in 2 embayments in western Newfoundland where pulp and paper mill effluent was discharged. Prevalence varied seasonally, with a peak in autumn and a low in spring. It is likely that the multifocal infection was associated with immunodepression after exposure to the contaminant.     

Swimming performance and energy homeostasis in juvenile laboratory raised fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) exposed to uranium mill effluent

Research at the Key Lake uranium mill (Saskatchewan, Canada) suggests effluent discharged from the mill affects energy stores of resident fish, but the mechanisms by which energy homeostasis is affected and the subsequent effects on swimming performance are unknown. In the present study larvae were collected from laboratory raised adult fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) exposed to 5% diluted uranium mill effluent or control (dechlorinated municipal) water, and reared in the same treatments to 60 days post hatch (dph). Critical swimming speed (U_crit) was significantly lower in effluent exposed 60 dph fish compared to control fish. Fish used in tests were considered fatigued and compared to fish without swim testing (non-fatigued). There were no differences in whole body glycogen or triglyceride concentrations between effluent exposed versus control fish. However, fatigued fish from both treatments had significantly lower triglycerides, but not glycogen, compared to non-fatigued fish from the same treatment. Whole body β–hydroxyacyl coenzymeA dehydrogenase activity was similar in fish from both treatments, but citrate synthase activity was significantly lower in effluent exposed fish. Our results suggest uranium mill effluent exposure in the laboratory affects aerobic energy metabolism and swimming performance in juvenile fathead minnow, which could affect wild fish survivability.