Influence of sample size on image cytometry of DNA ploidy measurements

OBJECTIVE: To assess the number of nuclei required for significant image cytometry DNA ploidy measurements on one archival case of breast cancer. STUDY DESIGN: From one case of aneuploid DNA breast cancer, 18 subsets made up of 152-1,524 for the whole population of undamaged nuclei and made up of 74-735 epithelial nuclei had DNA measured. DNA ploidy type and five DNA ploidy indices, allowing DNA ploidy histogram interpretation were evaluated on each population. RESULTS: Three hundred nuclei were always sufficient for DNA typing, whereas reliable results for DNA ploidy indices required at least 750 nuclei. CONCLUSION: To DNA measure the above number of nuclei, fully automated image cytometry DNA ploidy measurements are required.     

Automatic morphological sieving: comparison between different methods, application to DNA ploidy measurements.

The aim of the present study is to propose alternative automatic methods to time consuming interactive sorting of elements for DNA ploidy measurements. One archival brain tumour and two archival breast carcinoma were studied, corresponding to 7120 elements (3764 nuclei, 3356 debris and aggregates). Three automatic classification methods were tested to eliminate debris and aggregates from DNA ploidy measurements (mathematical morphology (MM), multiparametric analysis (MA) and neural network (NN)). Performances were evaluated by reference to interactive sorting. The results obtained for the three methods concerning the percentage of debris and aggregates automatically removed reach 63, 75 and 85% for MM, MA and NN methods, respectively, with false positive rates of 6, 21 and 25%. Information about DNA ploidy abnormalities were globally preserved after automatic elimination of debris and aggregates by MM and MA methods as opposed to NN method, showing that automatic classification methods can offer alternatives to tedious interactive elimination of debris and aggregates, for DNA ploidy measurements of archival tumours.     

Plant DNA flow cytometry and estimation of nuclear genome size

BACKGROUND: DNA flow cytometry describes the use of flow cytometry for estimation of DNA quantity in cell nuclei. The method involves preparation of aqueous suspensions of intact nuclei whose DNA is stained using a DNA fluorochrome. The nuclei are classified according to their relative fluorescence intensity or DNA content. Because the sample preparation and analysis is convenient and rapid, DNA flow cytometry has become a popular method for ploidy screening, detection of mixoploidy and aneuploidy, cell cycle analysis, assessment of the degree of polysomaty, determination of reproductive pathway, and estimation of absolute DNA amount or genome size. While the former applications are relatively straightforward, estimation of absolute DNA amount requires special attention to possible errors in sample preparation and analysis. SCOPE: The article reviews current procedures for estimation of absolute DNA amounts in plants using flow cytometry, with special emphasis on preparation of nuclei suspensions, stoichiometric DNA staining and the use of DNA reference standards. In addition, methodological pitfalls encountered in estimation of intraspecific variation in genome size are discussed as well as problems linked to the use of DNA flow cytometry for fieldwork. CONCLUSIONS: Reliable estimation of absolute DNA amounts in plants using flow cytometry is not a trivial task. Although several well-proven protocols are available and some factors controlling the precision and reproducibility have been identified, several problems persist: (1) the need for fresh tissues complicates the transfer of samples from field to the laboratory and/or their storage; (2) the role of cytosolic compounds interfering with quantitative DNA staining is not well understood; and (3) the use of a set of internationally agreed DNA reference standards still remains an unrealized goal.     

Automated fluorescence image cytometry. DNA quantification and detection of chlamydial infections

Digitized fluorescence microscopy in conjunction with automated image segmentation is a promising approach for screening clinical specimens quickly and reliably. This paper describes the hardware and software of a prototype image-based cytometer that can identify fluorescent objects, discriminate true objects from artifacts and divide overlapping pairs of objects. The use of this image cytometer is discussed for: (1) the measurement of the DNA ploidy distribution of isolated mature rat liver nuclei labeled with 4',6-diamidine-2-phenylindole; (2) the comparison of the DNA ploidy distributions of the same samples measured by image cytometry (ICM) and flow cytometry (FCM); and (3) the quantification of chlamydial infection by double labeling cells with antichlamydiae antibody and Hoechst 33258 for nuclear DNA analysis. Ploidy distributions measured by the automated image cytometer compared favorably to those obtained by FCM. All pairs of overlapping nuclei were automatically detected by an additional computer algorithm, and those pairs that were clearly more than one nucleus by visual inspection were correctly divided. The irregular morphology of the chlamydiae-infected cells meant that 26% of them were not correctly identified in the fluorescein-stained images (as judged by manual inspection), but all cells were nevertheless detected correctly from the images of the Hoechst-stained samples. Automated fluorescence ICM yielded results similar to those obtained with FCM and had the additional benefit of maintaining cell and tissue architecture while preserving the opportunity for subsequent manual inspection of the specimen.     

DNA quantitation of distal bile duct carcinoma measured by image and flow cytometry

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate discrepancies between flow cytometry (FCM) and image cytometry (ICM), ploidy incidence and relation between DNA ploidies and survival in distal bile duct carcinomas (DBDCs). STUDY DESIGN: Forty-four archival tumor samples from patients with DBDC who underwent subtotal pancreatoduodenectomy from 1985 to 1996 were examined for DNA ploidy using FCM and ICM. RESULTS: Overall, 59% (26/44) of the tumors were aneuploid by at least one of the two techniques. We detected more cases of aneuploidy with ICM than FCM in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded DBDCs, 62% (21/34) versus 33% (13/40), respectively. When results could be compared, moderate strength of agreement (kappa = .45) was demonstrated. No correlation was found between DNA ploidy by FCM, ICM or combined FCM-ICM and survival time (P = .80, P = .35, and P = .54, respectively). CONCLUSION: Approximately 59% of DNA histograms contained aneuploid cell populations. Although ICM, as compared to FCM, is more sensitive in assessing the ploidy status of DBDC, both methods were complementary. Most discrepancies between FCM and ICM were due to the dilution of aneuploid populations by non-neoplastic diploid cells. DNA ploidy assessment in DBDC did not offer the possibility of improving the ability to predict survival.     

Separation of sperm and vaginal cells based on ploidy, MHC class I-, CD45-, and cytokeratin expression for enhancement of DNA typing after sexual assault.

BACKGROUND: Successful DNA typing after rape is limited when only a few sperm and numerous vaginal cells are recovered from a swab, resulting in an extremely unfavorable ratio of male to female DNA. The goal of this study was to develop a protocol involving sperm cell sorting with flow cytometry based on differences in ploidy, major histocompatibility (MHC) class I, CD45 and cytokeratin expression. METHODS: Vaginal lavages were mixed with serially diluted ejaculate. After immunostaining and stoichiometric nuclear staining, spermatocytes were isolated by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. All sorted cells were used for DNA extraction and subsequent quantitative fluorescent multiplex polymerase chain reaction. The preferential lysis was performed for comparison. RESULTS: The sorting procedure was superior to the preferential lysis method within all tested dilutions. One documented case of rape was examined with both procedures and only after cell sorting with flow cytometry was the male DNA identified. CONCLUSIONS: We were able to show that separation of sperm and vaginal cells using cell sorting with flow cytometry may be crucial when there is only a few sperm detectable after rape.     

Determination of DNA ploidy in archival tissue from non-Hodgkin's lymphoma using flow and image cytometry.

Paraffin-embedded tissue from a series of 40 cases of diffuse, large cell lymphoma was analyzed by both flow and image cytometry to compare the ability of these techniques to detect DNA aneuploid populations. Image cytometry (ICM) was performed both on nuclear suspensions and tissue sections. Twenty cases (50%) were non-diploid by at least one method of analysis. Twenty-five percent of the cases were aneuploid by flow cytometry (FCM) alone. The majority of these cases were near-diploid tumors which could not be resolved by ICM. Peri-tetraploid peaks were identified by ICM of tissue sections alone in 15% of the cases. There was an apparent loss of these peri-tetraploid cells during the preparation of the nuclear suspensions. The remaining cases showed a good correlation between all three methods in the determination of DNA ploidy. Flow and image cytometry are complimentary techniques when applied to archival tissue, however aneuploid populations may be missed if ICM is not performed on tissue sections.     

Flow cytometric analysis of isolated rat liver nuclei during growth

The development of hepatocyte polyploidy in rats aged up to 4 months was analyzed by flow cytometry using both scatter and fluorescent parameters to distinguish DNA diploid and DNA tetraploid populations and to discriminate between parenchymal and non-parenchymal compartments. The precise origin of each class of nuclei was assessed in whole liver homogenate using purified hepatocytes, obtained by liver perfusion followed by separation on Percoll gradient, and identifying the peaks corresponding to parenchymal nuclei. The results indicate that preparative procedures involving homogenization of the rat liver tissue caused loss of the DNA octaploid population. Data on the relative proportion of the different DNA ploidy elements during rat liver development, which are in good agreement with those observed by cell analysis by means of microspectrophotometry, indicate the usefulness of flow cytometry as a choice method for the analysis of ploidy distribution.     

DNA ploidy as a prognostic factor in rhabdomyosarcoma. Analysis of 35 cases with image cytometry

OBJECTIVE: To correlate DNA ploidy in rhabdomyosarcoma (RMS) with other prognostic factors and patient survival and to search for possible reasons for inconsistent conclusions in similar, published studies. STUDY DESIGN: DNA content was measured in archival specimens obtained from 35 patients (23 children and 12 adults) with RMS. Cell suspensions were prepared by the modified Hedley technique, stained by the modified Feulgen-thionin method and analyzed by automated high-resolution image cytometry. DNA ploidy was assessed on the basis of DNA index values. We used the chi 2 test to correlate DNA ploidy with other prognostic factors, Kaplan-Meier procedure to estimate overall survival in terms of individual prognostic factors, log-rank test to calculate differences in survival between groups and Cox multivariate regression analysis to determine the independence of variables in relation to survival. RESULTS: A statistically significant correlation was found only between DNA ploidy and histologic subtype of RMS, patient sex and patient age. A hyperdiploid DNA pattern predominated among patients with embryonal RMS, and a tetraploid pattern dominated among patients with alveolar RMS. The highest 5-year survival rate was seen among patients with hyperdiploid RMS, followed by those with diploid, tetraploid and hypertetraploid RMS. Although DNA ploidy was a significant prognostic factor in univariate analysis, it did not retain its independent prognostic value in multivariate analysis, in which patient age, tumor size and histologic subtype were the only significant factors. We found 12 articles reporting on the association between DNA ploidy and survival of patients with RMS: 6 found a correlation, and 6 did not. The main reasons for the discrepancies seem to be the inclusion of chemotherapy-treated and nontreated patients, low number of patients and differences in grouping DNA histograms. CONCLUSION: The precise prognostic value of DNA ploidy in RMS remains equivocal. Larger, cooperative studies could give statistically more reliable results.     

Image cytometry in nonproliferative fibrocystic breast changes. Ploidy evaluation and epidemiologic study

OBJECTIVE: To determine the usefulness of image cytometry on fine needle aspirates from patients with fibrocystic changes (FCCs) to assess the subsequent risk of breast cancer. STUDY DESIGN: Thirty-five hundred archival cases with fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy were assessed to select nonproliferative FCCs of the breast (500 cases), also classified as type 1 (FCC I). DNA evaluation was analyzed by means of image cytometry on ductal epithelial cells and on apocrine metaplastic cells; 97 quantifications were performed. Cytometric variables investigated were: DNA ploidy, G0/G1 peak of diploid nuclei, S-phase fraction, 5cER, 2cDI and coefficient of variation. Two groups each with 15 years of follow-up were formed: Simple pathology (SP), fibrocystic changes alone; associated pathology (AP), FCCs plus breast cancer. Each was studied separately and compared. RESULTS: In SP cases the average ploidy was 2.2 for epithelial cells and 4.2 for apocrine cells. The proportion of G0G1 diploid nuclei was 100%. In the study of AP, the average ploidy was 2.2 for epithelial ductal cells and 4.1 for apocrine ones, for a slight increase in SPF. Ductal cells were diploid, while apocrine cells were tetraploid, with statistical significance of P < .05. For the epidemiologic study we calculated the proportion of patients with FCC I who developed cancer by referring to a historical cohort study, obtaining a relative risk of 0.7. CONCLUSION: Our results prove that DNA image cytometry applied on FNA cytology is a very useful, minimally invasive and reliable tool to determine higher activity and risk for development of breast cancer in FCC I and thus to establish the need for closer follow-up of these patients. In addition, apocrine metaplastic cells of the breast display a tetraploid DNA histogram, while the other karyometric variables remain in the range of normality.     

DNA ploidy analysis and cytologic examination of sorted cell populations from human breast tumors

Two different flow cytometric procedures were applied on cell samples from human breast tumors. One procedure involved DNA ploidy analysis on suspensions of isolated nuclei. The mean ploidy ratios of 27 benign breast lesions to chicken erythrocytes and rainbow trout erythrocytes were found to be 2.66 +/- 0.03 and 1.25 +/- 0.02, respectively. From the 45 stemlines found in a series of 43 carcinomas, 12 were diploid, 13 hyperdiploid and 20 near-tetraploid. No association was found between the lymph node status and the DNA ploidy level. The second procedure involved sorting fixed cells from DNA "windows" for the preparation of permanent cytologic specimens. The sorted cells appeared to be shrunken, but the morphologic quality was similar to that of imprint specimens from the same tumors, permitting discrimination between various types of normal cells and tumor cells. The combined use of both flow cytometric procedures may lead to greater insight into the relationship between the cytologic and cytogenetic heterogeneity of breast carcinomas.     

DNA ploidy of bladder cancer using bladder biopsy supernate specimens

OBJECTIVE: To perform DNA image cytometry on 119 bladder biopsy supernate (BBS) specimens of transitional cell carcinoma (TCC) bladder to: (1) test the suitability of this cytologic specimen for use in DNA ploidy analysis, and (2) assess the value of DNA ploidy measured on this specimen as to the risk of tumor recurrence and survival. STUDY DESIGN: The histologic grade and cytologic grade were correlated, and the DNA ploidy produced was determined by image analysis of Feulgen-stained nuclei. Kaplan-Meier curves related age, sex, grade and DNA ploidy to recurrence of tumor and survival. Log rank analyses were used to ascertain the difference between the curves for each categorical variable. RESULTS: Urothelial cells derived from the BBS specimen were demonstrated to be representative of the tumor. The tumor recurrence rate was significantly higher (P = .0001) and the survival rate significantly lower (P = .0002) for patients with aneuploid tumors compared to those with diploid tumors. Patients with TCC 2 tumors had a significantly shorter time to recurrence (P = .003), although the relationship between ploidy and survival in this group was of marginal significance. CONCLUSION: The specimen was free of many of the problems associate with the other specimen types used for measuring DNA ploidy. The results show that the BBS specimen is diagnostically useful and suitable for DNA analysis, providing prognostically relevant information.     

Methodologic aspects of evaluating brush samples from biliary strictures by cytology and DNA flow cytometry

OBJECTIVE: To present a method of increasing the cell yield from brush samples of the biliary tree for measurement of DNA content by flow cytometry (FCM). STUDY DESIGN: One hundred eight cell specimens from 86 patients were studied by FCM for DNA ploidy and cell cycle composition. All specimens were cytologically classified into benign, suspicious for malignancy and malignant. Two methods for preparation of the cell material were compared. RESULTS: Enzymatic treatment of formalin-fixed brushes for release of cell nuclei was superior to mechanical removal of the cells. The fraction of samples not possible to assess was reduced from 27% to 4%, and good quality histograms increased from 21% to 62%. Aneuploidy was detected in 7% of benign and 57% of suspicious malignant samples. Using DNA analysis in addition to cytology as a diagnostic marker for cancer, the sensitivity increased from 12% to 31%. CONCLUSION: FCM of cells from biliary strictures can be used routinely as an adjunct to cytology for DNA analysis.     

A comparison between flow cytometric ploidy investigation and chromosome analysis of 32 human colorectal tumors

The correlation between flow cytometric ploidy investigation and classic chromosome analysis was studied in 32 human colorectal tumors. Flow cytometry was performed by nuclei isolation and DNA staining with ethidium bromide. Chromosome analysis was done after incubation with colcemid. In 12 cases, chromosome identification was possible by grouping according to the Denver system or by Q-banding. Generally, the measured DNA content corresponded well with the content expected from chromosome analysis, giving an average difference of 4%. In nine tumors, the measured DNA content was 4-18% higher than expected. Some of these discrepancies could be due to difficulties in identifying the corresponding cell populations in heterogeneous tumors. However, in general the number of cell populations and their quantitative representation by the two methods were statistically well correlated. The results indicate that flow cytometric ploidy investigation of colorectal tumors with the present technique is a reliable method, but also that a combination of both techniques may yield additional information about tumor cytogenetics.     

A method for determining ploidy distributions in liver tissue by stereological analysis of nuclear size calibrated by flow cytometric DNA analysis

A method is presented for determining ploidy distributions in mouse liver from image analysis with stereological estimations of nuclear size in tissue sections. Nuclear profile distributions obtained from profile measurements were subjected to a mathematical unfolding procedure in order to obtain the nuclear size distributions. Based on the assumption that nuclear size increases monotonically with nuclear DNA content, flow cytometric DNA analysis of suspensions of liver cell nuclei was used to calibrate the method, thus yielding the mean nuclear size of each ploidy class, i.e., diploid, tetraploid, and octaploid nuclei. After the size interval for each of the ploidy classes was determined, the method allowed determination of ploidy distributions in mouse liver by stereological image analysis alone. The method was established from combined stereological and flow cytometric measurements on liver tissue representing two different stages of liver regeneration after two-thirds partial hepatectomy, and it was tested against an independent set of data representing a marked increase in the portion of S-phase cells.     

Correlating cell cycle with metabolism in single cells: combination of image and metabolic cytometry.

BACKGROUND: We coin two terms: First, chemical cytometry describes the use of high-sensitivity chemical analysis techniques to study single cells. Second, metabolic cytometry is a form of chemical cytometry that monitors a cascade of biosynthetic and biodegradation products generated in a single cell. In this paper, we describe the combination of metabolic cytometry with image cytometry to correlate oligosaccharide metabolic activity with cell cycle. We use this technique to measure DNA ploidy, the uptake of a fluorescent disaccharide, and the amount of metabolic products in a single cell. METHODS: A colon adenocarcinoma cell line (HT29) was incubated with a fluorescent disaccharide, which was taken up by the cells and converted into a series of biosynthetic and biodegradation products. The cells were also treated with YOYO-3 and Hoechst 33342. The YOYO-3 signal was used as a live-dead assay, while the Hoechst 33342 signal was used to estimate the ploidy of live cells by fluorescence image cytometry. After ploidy analysis, a cell was injected into a fused-silica capillary, where the cell was lysed. Fluorescent metabolic products were then separated by capillary electrophoresis and detected by laser-induced fluorescence. RESULTS: Substrate uptake measured with metabolic cytometry gave rise to results similar to those measured by use of laser scanning confocal microscopy. The DNA ploidy histogram obtained with our simple image cytometry technique was similar to that obtained using flow cytometry. The cells in the G(1) phase did not show any biosynthetic activity in respect to the substrate. Several groups of cells with unique biosynthetic patterns were distinguished within G(2)/M cells. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first report that combined metabolic and image cytometry to correlate formation of metabolic products with cell cycle. A complete enzymatic cascade is monitored on a cell-by-cell basis and correlated with cell cycle.     

Intracellular pH, esterase activity, and DNA measurements of human lung carcinomas by flow cytometry

An important intention of flow cytometric investigations is to obtain biochemical and biophysical information about cells which is suitable for automated tumor diagnosis. In this study, the ploidy status, the intracellular pH value, the intracellular esterase activity, and the cell volume of vital cells and the DNA and cell volume of dead cells were measured in cancerous tissue and normal lung tissue of 30 patients by flow cytometry. The cell samples were simultaneously stained with the pH and esterase indicator dye 1.4-diacetoxy-2,3-dicyanobenzene (ADB) and propidium iodide (PI). The flow cytometric measurements were performed in three-parameter list mode. The data were evaluated on an AT-compatible personal computer with the DIAGNOS1 program system for automated diagnosis of flow cytometric list mode data. Significant differences were found between normal and malignant tissue in DNA ploidy, in the intracellular esterase activity, in the cell, volume and in the percentage of inflammatory cells and parameters of necrosis. DNA-aneuploidy was observed in 38% of the lung carcinomas. The simultaneous detection of DNA-aneuploidy and tumor-associated properties in a multifactorial analysis led to correct automatic tumor diagnosis in 85% of cases. DNA-aneuploidy was found at a significant higher frequency in advanced tumors. Adenocarcinomas displayed DNA-aneuploidy more often (80%) than squamous cell carcinomas (33%).     

Characterization of diverse ploidy in the arctic‐alpine Arenaria ciliata species complex (Caryophyllaceae) using shoot meristem staining and flow cytometry analysis of archived frozen tissue

Ploidy levels were analyzed in 21 European populations of the Arenaria ciliata complex using baseline chromosome counts derived from Feulgen staining of HCl‐treated shoot meristems and calibrated flow‐cytometry analysis of fresh and archival frozen tissue. Calibration with two to three control samples of different ploidy facilitated rapid identification of ploidy states in unknown samples. Observed ploidy levels varied from 2N = 40–200, with the majority of populations showing 2N = 40–80. High‐altitude populations collectively showed the full range of ploidy states, but at low elevations only lower ploidy levels were observed. Populations with the highest observed ploidy contained the greatest observed phylogenetic diversity in the western and eastern Alps. Multiple polyploidization events are inferred in the continental European metapopulation, with lower, more stable ploidy characteristic of the west and north. The method deployed provides an effective approach to ploidy analysis for archival desiccated/frozen tissue samples from biogeographic collections.     

Flow cytometric analysis of polysomaty and in vitro genetic instability in potato

The analysis of nuclear DNA contents in various tissues of potato genotypes showed that flow cytometry is a rapid method to characterize large populations of cells for polysomaty, that is, the occurrence of cells with normal DNA levels together with cells containing endoreduplicated nuclei. The proportion of endoreduplicated nuclei varied in different tissues and genotypes of potato. The analysis of callus and cell cultures showed that the temporal changes in nuclear DNA contents during in vitro growth can be followed and the degree of polyploidization quantified. It is concluded that flow cytometry is a highly suitable method to detect ploidy changes in differentiated plant tissues and calli which are often not amenable for chromosome number determination.