Measurements of DNA damage on silver stained comets using free Internet software

Silver stain offers the possibility to stain comets permanently, but up to now it was impossible to measure the majority of the comet parameters, because the distinction between head and tail was not recognised by software. Here, we report a silver staining protocol that allows the measurement of comet parameters using the free Internet software CASP. We validated the silver stain protocol by comparing the behaviour of the parameter '% DNA in tail' in silver and fluorescent stained comets. The range of % DNA in tail for different visual categories of damage in silver stained comets was similar to that reported with fluorescence staining. The range was for category 0 (no damage), <1%; category 1 (low damage), 1-25%; category 2 (medium damage), >25-45%; category 3 (high damage), >45-70%; category 4 (very high damage), >70%. The mean of % DNA in tail in silver stained comets was also similar to that reported with fluorescence staining. The mean was for category 0, 0.4+/-0.34%; category 1, 12+/-7%; category 2, 37+/-4%; category 3, 57+/-5% and category 4, 83+/-6%. Others comet parameters such as tail length, tail moment and Olive tail moment can be also measured. The silver staining protocol reported here opens new opportunities for those working in the assay without fluorescent microscope as the measurement of comet parameters using free Internet software and conventional microscope becomes possible.     

Characterization of SYBR Gold nucleic acid gel stain: a dye optimized for use with 300-nm ultraviolet transilluminators

The highest sensitivity nucleic acid gel stains developed to date are optimally excited using short-wavelength ultraviolet or visible light. This is a disadvantage for laboratories equipped only with 306- or 312-nm UV transilluminators. We have developed a new unsymmetrical cyanine dye that overcomes this problem. This new dye, SYBR Gold nucleic acid gel stain, has two fluorescence excitation maxima when bound to DNA, one centered at approximately 300 nm and one at approximately 495 nm. We found that when used with 300-nm transillumination and Polaroid black-and-white photography, SYBR Gold stain is more sensitive than ethidium bromide, SYBR Green I stain, and SYBR Green II stain for detecting double-stranded DNA, single-stranded DNA, and RNA. SYBR Gold stain's superior sensitivity is due to the high fluorescence quantum yield of the dye-nucleic acid complexes ( approximately 0.7), the dye's large fluorescence enhancement upon binding to nucleic acids ( approximately 1000-fold), and its capacity to more fully penetrate gels than do the SYBR Green gel stains. We found that SYBR Gold stain is as sensitive as silver staining for detecting DNA-with a single-step staining procedure. Finally, we found that staining nucleic acids with SYBR Gold stain does not interfere with subsequent molecular biology protocols.     

Sensitivity and variability of visual scoring in the comet assay. Results of an inter-laboratory scoring exercise with the use of silver staining

Nineteen scorers from seven Cuban laboratories participated in this slide exercise designed to test the influence of the scorer on the accuracy, sensitivity and variability of the comet assay when a visual method of DNA damage evaluation is used. The assay was performed using human lymphocytes from a single donor exposed in vitro for 5 min at 0 degrees C to doses of 0, 5, 10, 25, 50, 100 and 200 microM of hydrogen peroxide. Each participant scored the same set of 14 coded slides with silver stained comets. The comets were classified visually into five categories according to the appearance resulting from the relative proportion of DNA in the tail. The extent of DNA damage was expressed in arbitrary units. At zero dose the median values of 12 scorers out of 19 were included between the values of the overall 25 and 75 per thousand. This proportion remains practically the same as the dose increases. The lowest dose detected by this method for the majority of scorers (11) was 10 microM. The coefficient of variation at the control dose was the highest (median value 26%), progressively declined to 20%, and starting from 25 microM, values are around 10%. The results of the exercise show the reliability of the silver staining and visual scoring for the comet method.     

Comet assay: rapid processing of multiple samples

The present study describes modifications to the basic comet protocol that increase productivity and efficiency without sacrificing assay reliability. A simple technique is described for rapidly preparing up to 96 comet assay samples simultaneously. The sample preparation technique allows thin layers of agarose-embedded cells to be prepared in multiple wells attached to a flexible film of Gelbond, which improves the ease of manipulating and processing samples. To evaluate the effect of these modifications on assay sensitivity, dose-response curves are presented for DNA damage induced by exposure of TK6 cells to low concentrations of hydrogen peroxide (0-10 microM) and for exposure of human lymphocytes to X-irradiation (0-100 cGy). The limit of detection of DNA damage induced by hydrogen peroxide in TK6 cells was observed to be 1 uM for all parameters (tail ratio, tail moment, tail length and comet length) while the limit of detection of DNA damage in human lymphocytes was 10 cGy for tail and comet length parameters, but 50 cGy for tail ratio and tail moment parameters. These results are similar to those previously reported using the conventional alkaline comet assay. The application of SYBR Gold for detection of DNA damage was compared to that of propidium iodide. Measurements of matching samples for tail length and comet length were similar using both stains. However, comets stained with SYBR Gold persisted longer and were much brighter than those obtained with propidium iodide. SYBR Gold was found to be ideal for measuring tail length and comet length but, under present assay conditions, impractical for measuring tail ratio or tail moment due to saturation of staining in the head region of the comets.     

Laser scanning cytometry for comet assay analysis

BACKGROUND: The comet assay (single-cell gel electrophoresis) is a sensitive method for evaluating nuclear DNA damage. Previously used evaluation methods for the comet assay are time consuming and have an inherent risk of biased selection of comets due to manual selection and categorization of comet images. Laser scanning cytometry (LSC), the principle of which is equivalent to flow cytometry, enables quantification of fluorescence emitted from the cells on a microscope slide. In the present study, we explored whether LSC could be used to determine the degree of DNA damage demonstrated by the comet assay. METHODS: DNA damage was induced by ultraviolet A irradiation of keratinocytes and visualized by the comet assay. The evaluation included (a) LSC determination of DNA-specific fluorescence in 1,000 comet heads (undamaged DNA), (b) image acquisition of comets by rescanning of the microscope slide, and (c) digital image analysis and computation of tail moment and DNA content in the comet tails. RESULTS: Cells with damaged DNA were observed in a sub-G(1) area because the comet head loses DNA to the tail. We found a strong inverse correlation between tail moment and DNA content per nucleus. CONCLUSIONS: LSC enables an automated method for cell recognition and evaluation of the comets, thus providing quantitative information about nuclear DNA damage without subjective selection of analyzed comets.     

DBD-fish on neutral comets: simultaneous analysis of DNA single- and double-strand breaks in individual cells

Humanblood leukocytes exposed to X-rays were immersed in an agarose microgel on a slide, extensively deproteinized, and electrophoresed under neutral conditions. Following this single-cell gel electrophoresis assay, characteristics of DNA migration (i.e., area of the comet) are related to the DNA double-strand breaks (dsbs) yield. After electrophoresis, comets were briefly incubated in an alkaline unwinding solution, transforming DNA breaks and alkali-labile sites into restricted single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) motifs. These motifs behave as target sites for hybridization with a whole genome probe, following the DNA breakage detection-fluorescence in situ hybridization (DBD-FISH) procedure. As DNA breakage increases with dose, more ssDNA is produced in the comet by the alkali and more DNA probe hybridizes, resulting in an increase in the mean fluorescence intensity. Since radiation-induced DNA single-strand breaks (ssbs) are far more frequent than dsbs, the mean fluorescence intensity of the DBD-FISH signal from the comet is related to the ssb level, whereas the surface area of the same comet signal is indicative of the dsb yield. Thus, both DNA break types may be simultaneously analyzed in the same cell. This was confirmed in a repair assay performing the DBD-FISH on neutral comets from a human cell line defective in the repair of dsbs. Otherwise, treatment with hydrogen peroxide, a main inducer of ssbs, increased the mean fluorescence intensity, but not the surface, of X-ray-exposed human leukocytes.     

The ultrasensitive silver "protein" stain also detects nanograms of nucleic acids

The ultrasensitive silver staining procedure developed for proteins also stains nanogram quantities of RNA and DNA in polyacrylamide gels. A gradient polyacrylamide gel system is described which separates proteins from 10⁴ to 10⁶ M_r, RNA from 5S to 23S and DNA from 0.4 to 21 Kb. The sensitivity of nucleic acid silver staining in this gel system considerably exceeds that of commonly used DNA and RNA dye-binding stains.     

Ethidium bromide: a nucleic acid stain for tissue section

The phenanthridinium dye, ethidium bromide (EB), selectively intercalates into double-stranded regions of nucleic acids with a large and specific increase in fluorescence. When used for the staining of fixed tissue sections, the dye stains cellular nuclei with excellent resolution of microscopic detail. In some fixed tissues, particularly pancreatic acini, cytoplasm stains intensely and this staining can be abolished by digestion with trypsin and ribonuclease. The orange fluorescence of EB can be easily distinguished from the green fluorescence of fluorescein and EB is thus an excellent counterstain for immunofluorescence. Ethidium bromide is a useful and practical stain for the fluorescence microscopy of tissue sections and, in combination with enzymatic digestion of RNA, provides a simple way to differentially localize DNA and RNA.     

A comparative study of quantitative stains for DNA in image cytometry.

In this study we examined the reproducibility of several stains used to measure nuclear DNA by image cytometry. The specimens were touch preparations of liver and testis from mouse and liver, intestine and brain from rat, fixed in either neutral formalin or Carnoy's solution. The tested stains included four Feulgen methods (pararosaniline, azure-A, thionin and acriflavine), the gallocyanine-chromalum stain and two fluorescent stains (acridine orange and propidium iodide). Absorbance measurements employed a video image analysis system; fluorescence measurements were from a scanning microspectrophotometer. The acriflavine-Feulgen stain was analyzed for both absorbance and fluorescence. All seven stains were quantitative for DNA and gave reproducible results. The absorbance measurements had a lower coefficient of variation (CV) than the fluorescence values. In a nested analysis of variance of the pararosaniline Feulgen stains, cell-to-cell variability accounted for 67% of the total variance; slide-to-slide, 9%; and batch-to-batch, 24%. These values did not change significantly when the staining was performed in an automatic staining machine. For DNA analysis using image cytometry, we conclude that the Feulgen staining technique is the most useful. In particular, acriflavine-Feulgen-stained cells fixed in Carnoy's fluid give the least variation between measurement values and the most accurate ratios between the separate ploidy groups. For fluorescence cytometry we recommend Carnoy's fixation and the acriflavine-Feulgen stain because of its narrow CV as compared to acridine orange and propidium iodide.     

Supravital exposure to propidium iodide identifies apoptosis on adherent cells

BACKGROUND: Several studies indicate that plasma membrane changes during apoptosis are a general phenomenon. Among the flow cytometric methods to measure apoptosis, the Annexin V assay that detects the membrane exposure of phosphatidylserine (PS) is one of the most commonly used. However, the various treatments used for the detachment of adherent cells generally interfere with the binding of Annexin V to membrane PS, making apoptosis measurement a technical problem. Materials and Methods Apoptosis of different cell lines was investigated by fluorescence microscopy and multiple flow assays designed to assess loss of membrane integrity, translocation of PS, DNA fragmentation, and light scatter changes. Results and Conclusions We show that supravital propidium iodide (PI) assay stains adherent apoptotic cells, allowing flow cytometric quantification. Moreover, supravital exposure to PI without prior permeabilization identifies apoptotic cells as well as Annexin V and permits the simultaneous surface staining by FITC- and PE-conjugated monoclonal antibodies. As in the case of necrotic or permeabilized cells, fluorescence microscopy has revealed that PI staining of apoptotic cells is localized in the nucleus. This suggests that the binding of PI to the DNA/RNA structures is stable enough to withstand the trypsinization and/or washing procedures necessary to detach adherent cells.     

Silver stains demonstrating neuroendocrine cells

During the preimmunohistochemical era, silver stains were an important part of the staining arsenal for identifying certain tissue structures and cell types in tissue sections. Some of them were useful for demonstrating endocrine cells, especially in the gastrointestinal tract. Until the late 1950s, silver stains, particularly those identifying endocrine cells, were accompanied by a number of technical difficulties resulting from uncontrolled staining factors. In the 1960s, new silver stains were developed for endocrine cell types and these stains gave reproducible results. One of the “older” silver stains and two of the “newer” ones are emphasized in this presentation, namely the Masson, the Grimelius and the Sevier-Munger techniques. The Masson stain demonstrates the enterochromaffin (EC, serotonin) cells, the Grimelius stain is a broad endocrine cell marker, and the Sevier-Munger technique demonstrates EC and EC-like cells and the C-cells of the thyroid. Especially in the preimmunohistochemical era, these staining methods often were used for histopathological diagnosis, particularly the Grimelius technique. The silver stains were developed empirically, and with few exceptions the chemical background is not known. Staining protocols are included.     

Cytochemical studies of metaphase chromosomes by flow cytometry

The cytochemical properties of metaphase chromosomes from Chinese hamster and human cells were studied by flow cytometry. This technique allows precise quantitation of the fluorescence properties of individual stained chromosome types. Chromosomes were stained with the following fluorescent DNA stains: Hoechst 33258, DAPI, chromomycin A₃, ethidium bromide, and propidium iodide. The relative fluorescence of individual chromosome types varied depending on the stain used, demonstrating that individual chromosome types differ in chemical properties. Flow measurements were performed as a function of stain and chromosome concentration to characterize the number and distribution of stain binding sites. Flow analysis of double stained chromosomes show that bound stains interact by energy transfer with little or no binding competition. For most hamster chromosomes, there is a strong correlation between relative fluorescence and stain base preference suggesting that staining differences may be determined primarily by differences in average base composition. A few hamster chromosome types exhibit anomalous staining which suggests that some other property, such as repetitive DNA sequences, also may be an important determinant of chromosomal staining.     

Single-cell gel electrophoresis assay monitors precise kinetics of DNA fragmentation induced during programmed cell death.

BACKGROUND: Single-cell gel electrophoresis, or the comet assay, a technique widely used for DNA damage analysis, has been used recently for detecting DNA fragmentation in cells undergoing apoptosis. However, the number of variants of this assay used thus far primarily detected the late stages of DNA fragmentation. Therefore, monitoring the progression of DNA fragmentation, which could greatly improve the analysis of cell death induction and progression at the single-cell level, has not been possible with this assay. METHODS: In the present study, a modification of the original neutral comet assay developed by Ostling and Johanson (Biochem Biophys Res Commun 123:291-298, 1984) was used to detect various stages of DNA fragmentation. This assay involves cell lysis with anionic detergents at nearly neutral pH (9.5) and does not include high salt concentration, unlike most other published methods. BMG-1 human glioma cells were induced to undergo programmed cell death by treating with a large dose (100 microM) of etoposide, and comets were prepared after different durations (1-24 h) of treatment. RESULTS: In contrast to results of previously published studies, comets with different shapes reflecting progressive stages of DNA fragmentation were observed. Of these, six distinct shapes were identified and divided into three different categories based on the extent of fragmentation. Type A comets had a large head separated by a narrow "neck" region from an oval bulging tail that indicated initiation of fragmentation. Type B and C comets had a constantly diminishing head associated with a corresponding expansion of the tail and reflected intermediate and late stages of fragmentation, respectively. Type A and B comets appeared at a high frequency during early time points (1-6 h), whereas type C comets that indicated late stages of fragmentation were observed only after extended treatment (24 h). As a result, an elaborate kinetics of the progression of DNA fragmentation could be obtained. CONCLUSION: The present single-cell gel electrophoresis assay offers a significant improvement in monitoring the kinetics of DNA fragmentation induced during programmed cell death. Coupled with its simplicity and the ability to detect responses of small cell subpopulations, this method can be used for a reliable and sensitive analysis of the progression of cell death in different cell types and treatment conditions.     

Ultrasensitive staining of nucleic acids with silver

A method for ultrasensitive detection of proteins on polyacrylamide gels by staining with silver, recently described by C. R. Merril, D. Goldman, S. A. Sedman, and M. H. Ebert (Science211, 1437–1438 (1981)), was applied with slight modifications to staining nucleic acids. Silver staining of double-stranded DNA was at least 100 times as sensitive as fluorescence staining with ethidium bromide, and at least 20 times as sensitive as staining with ammoniacal silver. The limit of detection of double-stranded DNA was approximately 25–50 pg/band with a cross-sectional area of 5 mm². The intensities of silver staining of double-stranded fragments 271 bp or longer from HaeIII endonuclease digests of φX174 RF DNA were linear over a concentration range of 0.25 to 4 ng DNA/band. RNA and single-stranded DNA species as short as 10 to 20 nucleotides were detected with high sensitivity after electrophoresis on denaturing gels containing urea, suggesting that silver staining may be applicable to the sequencing of a few micrograms of unlabeled DNA. Methods for staining DNA using ammoniacal silver were relatively insensitive for small DNA fragments.     

Silver stains demonstrating neuroendocrine cells

During the preimmunohistochemical era, silver stains were an important part of the staining arsenal for identifying certain tissue structures and cell types in tissue sections. Some of them were useful for demonstrating endocrine cells, especially in the gastrointestinal tract. Until the late 1950s, silver stains, particularly those identifying endocrine cells, were accompanied by a number of technical difficulties resulting from uncontrolled staining factors. In the 1960s, new silver stains were developed for endocrine cell types and these stains gave reproducible results. One of the “older” silver stains and two of the “newer” ones are emphasized in this presentation, namely the Masson, the Grimelius and the Sevier-Munger techniques. The Masson stain demonstrates the enterochromaffin (EC, serotonin) cells, the Grimelius stain is a broad endocrine cell marker, and the Sevier-Munger technique demonstrates EC and EC-like cells and the C-cells of the thyroid. Especially in the preimmunohistochemical era, these staining methods often were used for histopathological diagnosis, particularly the Grimelius technique. The silver stains were developed empirically, and with few exceptions the chemical background is not known. Staining protocols are included.     

Induced cell death of preimplantation mouse embryos cultured in vitro evaluated by comet assay

The occurrence of apoptosis in mouse preimplantation embryos was analyzed using DNA staining (Hoechst 33342, PI) for the visualization of nuclear changes and by the comet assay, a single-cell gel electrophoresis assay, modified for the analysis of blastocysts. Mouse preimplantation embryos isolated 56 h after superovulation were cultured in vitro for 64 h. Apoptosis was induced by treatment with camptothecin and actinomycin D during the first 15 h of culture. After culture in vitro, a number of embryos were stained and analyzed using morphological criteria. The remaining embryos were examined using the comet assay for the detection of DNA fragmentation. The proportion of damaged embryos in experimental groups, in comparison to controls, was dependent on the dose of apoptosis inductor. At high doses (camptothecin, microg/ml and actinomycin D, 0.05 microg/ml) over 90% (chi-square test, P<0.001) of embryos had apoptotic comets, at medium doses (camptothecin, 0.01 microg/ml and actinomycin D, 0.005 microg/ml) comets appeared only in 30-70% of embryos (camptothecin, P<0.01 and actinomycin D, P<0.001). At low doses (camptothecin, 0.001 microg/ml and actinomycin D, 0.0005 microg/ml) the increase in damaged embryos was not statistically significant. Hoechst/PI staining showed a higher percentage of damaged blastomeres at high doses. Morphological changes correlated with the outcome of the comet assay. Our results show that comet assay is an appropriate method for studying apoptosis in preimplantation embryos, and it appears to be more sensitive than the classically used morphological analyses.     

Visualization of nucleolar organizer regions in mammalian chromosomes using silver staining

A simple ammoniacal silver staining procedure, designated Ag-AS, differentially stains the chromosomal locations of ribosomal DNA in certain mammalian species. This was critically demonstrated by Ag-AS staining of the nucleolus organizer regions in karyotypes of the same species and cell lines used for locating the ribosomal cistrons by DNA/RNA in situ hybridization. With Ag-AS, silver stained NORs (Ag-NORs) are visualized as black spherical bodies on yellow-brown chromosome arms. Ag-NORs were visualized throughout mitosis at the secondary constrictions in the rat kangaroo, Seba's fruit bat, Indian muntjac, and Rhesus monkey. The Chinese hamster and cattle have telomeric Ag-NORs, the mouse subcentromeric Ag-NORs, and the field vole Ag-NORs as minute short arms or choromosomal satellites. Ag-NORs occur at both secondary constrictions and at telomeres in the cotton rat. Variability in Ag-NOR pattern included differences in the number of Ag-NORs per cell within a cell population, size of Ag-NORs among chromosomes of a complement, and presence of Ag-NOR on particular chromosomes in two cell lines of the Chinese hamster. The available cytochemical data suggest that the Ag-AS reaction stains chromosomal proteins at the NOR rather than the rDNA itself.     

An evaluation of DNA fluorochromes, staining techniques, and analysis for flow cytometry. I. Unperturbed cell populations

Several preparative techniques (detergent treatment, ethanol fixation, and hypotonic cell lysis), DNA fluorochromes, and methods of numerical analysis (planimetric or curve-fitting) were compared for the estimation of cell-cycle kinetic parameters (G1, S, G2 + M) by flow cytometry. In addition, coefficients of variation (CV), relative fluorescence, and G1/chicken erythrocyte (CRBC) ratios were measured and the effects of the proportion of cycling cells and cellular RNA content were examined. DNA fluorochromes were ranked by relative fluorescence: 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole > ethidium bromide/mithramycin > Hoechst 33342 > mithramycin > ethidium bromide > acridine orange approximately equal to propidium iodide. The first four (DNA-specific stains) gave lower CVs than the remainder (DNA intercalators). Detergent treatment also increased relative fluorescence and slightly lowered CVs. Comparable results were obtained for the kinetic parameters independently of stain or staining procedure; intercalating dyes with cells of a high RNA content not treated with RNAse and acridine orange being the exceptions. Of the two methods of numerical analysis, the planimetric technique was more consistant. Although highly consistant G1/CRBC ratios were obtained for any one stain, independently of staining procedures, variations between stains were noted. It is suggested that the detergent treatment in combination with DNA-specific stains provide optimal results.     

A fast,low cost,and highly efficient fluorescent DNA labeling method using methyl green

The increasing need for multiple-labeling of cells and whole organisms for fluorescence microscopy has led to the development of hundreds of fluorophores that either directly recognize target molecules or organelles, or are attached to antibodies or other molecular probes. DNA labeling is essential to study nuclear-chromosomal structure, as well as for gel staining, but also as a usual counterstain in immunofluorescence, FISH or cytometry. However, there are currently few reliable red to far-red-emitting DNA stains that can be used. We describe herein an extremely simple, inexpensive and robust method for DNA labeling of cells and electrophoretic gels using the very well-known histological stain methyl green (MG). MG used in very low concentrations at physiological pH proved to have relatively narrow excitation and emission spectra, with peaks at 633 and 677 nm, respectively, and a very high resistance to photobleaching. It can be used in combination with other common DNA stains or antibodies without any visible interference or bleed-through. In electrophoretic gels, MG also labeled DNA in a similar way to ethidium bromide, but, as expected, it did not label RNA. Moreover, we show here that MG fluorescence can be used as a stain for direct measuring of viability by both microscopy and flow cytometry, with full correlation to ethidium bromide staining. MG is thus a very convenient alternative to currently used red-emitting DNA stains.     

Quantitation of protein and DNA in silver-stained agarose gels

A silver stain for both proteins and DNA in agarose gels is described. Quantitation of proteins with this stain is possible, with individual proteins exhibiting characteristic responses, as observed with other stains. The advantage of the silver stain over Coomassie blue is its increased (50- to 100-fold) sensitivity, which allows samples containing very low protein concentrations to be analyzed without prior concentration. This silver stain, when applied to DNA, is at least as sensitive as ethidium bromide, and gives a linear response for the type of DNA and fragment sizes studied.