Controlled 2D crystallization of membrane proteins using methyl-beta-cyclodextrin

High-resolution structural data of membrane proteins can be obtained by studying 2D crystals by electron crystallography. Finding the right conditions to produce these crystals is one of the major bottlenecks encountered in 2D crystallography. Many reviews address 2D crystallization techniques in attempts to provide guidelines for crystallographers. Several techniques including new approaches to remove detergent like the biobeads technique and the development of dedicated devices have been described (dialysis and dilution machines). In addition, 2D crystallization at interfaces has been studied, the most prominent method being the 2D crystallization at the lipid monolayer. A new approach based on detergent complexation by cyclodextrins is presented in this paper. To prove the ability of cyclodextrins to remove detergent from ternary mixtures (lipid, detergent and protein) in order to get 2D crystals, this method has been tested with OmpF, a typical beta-barrel protein, and with SoPIP2;1, a typical alpha-helical protein. Experiments over different time ranges were performed to analyze the kinetic effects of detergent removal with cyclodextrins on the formation of 2D crystals. The quality of the produced crystals was assessed with negative stain electron microscopy, cryo-electron microscopy and diffraction. Both proteins yielded crystals comparable in quality to previous crystallization reports.     

Use of detergents in two-dimensional crystallization of membrane proteins

Structure determination at high resolution is actually a difficult challenge for membrane proteins and the number of membrane proteins that have been crystallized is still small and far behind that of soluble proteins. Because of their amphiphilic character, membrane proteins need to be isolated, purified and crystallized in detergent solutions. This makes it difficult to grow the well-ordered three-dimensional crystals that are required for high resolution structure analysis by X-ray crystallography. In this difficult context, growing crystals confined to two dimensions (2D crystals) and their structural analysis by electron crystallography has opened a new way to solve the structure of membrane proteins. However, 2D crystallization is one of the major bottlenecks in the structural studies of membrane proteins. Advances in our understanding of the interaction between proteins, lipids and detergents as well as development and improvement of new strategies will facilitate the success rate of 2D crystallization. This review deals with the various available strategies for obtaining 2D crystals from detergent-solubilized intrinsic membrane proteins. It gives an overview of the methods that have been applied and gives details and suggestions of the physical processes leading to the formation of the ordered arrays which may be of help for getting more proteins crystallized in a form suitable for high resolution structural analysis by electron crystallography.     

Two-dimensional crystallization on lipid layer: A successful approach for membrane proteins.

A considerable interest exists currently in designing innovative strategies to produce two-dimensional crystals of membrane proteins that are amenable to structural analysis by electron crystallography. We have developed a protocol for crystallizing membrane protein that is derived from the classical lipid-layer two-dimensional crystallization at the air/water interface used so far for soluble proteins. Lipid derivatized with a Ni(2+)-chelating head group provided a general approach to crystallizing histidine-tagged transmembrane proteins. The processes of protein binding and two-dimensional crystallization were analyzed by electron microscopy, using two prototypic membrane proteins: FhuA, a high-affinity receptor from the outer membrane of Escherichia coli, and the F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase from thermophilic Bacillus PS3. Conditions were found to avoid solubilization of the lipid layer by the detergent present with the purified membrane proteins and thus to allow binding of micellar proteins to the functionalized lipid head groups. After detergent removal using polystyrene beads, membrane sheets of several hundreds of square micrometers were reconstituted at the interface. High protein density in these membrane sheets allowed further formation of planar two-dimensional crystals. We believe that this strategy represents a new promising alternative to conventional dialysis methods for membrane protein 2D crystallization, with the additional advantage of necessitating little purified protein.     

Two-dimensional crystallization of the ryanodine receptor Ca2+ release channel on lipid membranes

The ryanodine receptor (RyR) is the largest known membrane protein with a total molecular mass of 2.3 x 10(3) kDa. Well ordered, two-dimensional (2D) crystals are an essential prerequisite to enable RyR structure determination by electron crystallography. Conventionally, the 2D crystallization of membrane proteins is based on a 'trial-and-error' strategy, which is both time-consuming and chance-directed. By adopting a new strategy that utilizes protein sequence information and predicted transmembrane topology, we successfully crystallized the RyR on positively charged lipid membranes. Image processing of negatively stained crystals reveals that they are well ordered, with diffraction spots of IQ < or = 4 extending to approximately 20 angstroms, the resolution attainable in negative stain. The RyR crystals obtained on the charged lipid membrane have characteristics consistent with 2D arrays that have been observed in native sarcoplasmic reticulum of muscle tissues. These crystals provide ideal materials to enable structural analysis of RyR by high-resolution electron crystallography. Moreover, the reconstituted native-like 2D array provides an ideal model system to gain structural insights into the mechanism of RyR-mediated Ca2+ signaling processes, in which the intrinsic ability of RyR oligomers to organize into a 2D array plays a crucial role.     

Use of octyl beta-thioglucopyranoside in two-dimensional crystallization of membrane proteins

A great interest exists in producing and/or improving two-dimensional (2D) crystals of membrane proteins amenable to structural analysis by electron crystallography. Here we report on the use of the detergent n-octyl beta-d-thioglucopyranoside in 2D crystallization trials of membrane proteins with radically different structures including FhuA from the outer membrane of Escherichia coli, light-harvesting complex II from Rubrivivax gelatinosus, and Photosystem I from cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. We have analyzed by electron microscopy the structures reconstituted after detergent removal from lipid-detergent or lipid-protein-detergent micellar solutions containing either only n-octyl beta-d-thioglucopyranoside or n-octyl beta-d-thioglucopyranoside in combination with other detergents commonly used in membrane protein biochemistry. This allowed the definition of experimental conditions in which the use of n-octyl beta-d-thioglucopyranoside could induce a considerable increase in the size of reconstituted membrane structures, up to several micrometers. An other important feature was that, in addition to reconstitution of membrane proteins into large bilayered structures, this thioglycosylated detergent also was revealed to be efficient in crystallization trials, allowing the proteins to be analyzed in large coherent two-dimensional arrays. Thus, inclusion of n-octyl beta-d-thioglucopyranoside in 2D crystallization trials appears to be a promising method for the production of large and coherent 2D crystals that will be valuable for structural analysis by electron crystallography and atomic force microscopy.     

Structure determination of secondary transport proteins by electron crystallography: two-dimensional crystallization of the betaine uptake system BetP

Structure determination at high resolution is still a challenge for membrane proteins in general, but in particular for secondary transporters due to their highly dynamic nature. X-ray structures of ten secondary transporters have recently been determined, but a thorough understanding of transport mechanisms necessitates structures at different functional states. Electron cryo-microscopy of two-dimensional (2D) crystals offers an alternative to obtain structural information at intermediate resolution. Electron crystallography is a sophisticated way to study proteins in a natural membrane environment and to track conformational changes in situ. Furthermore, basic interactions between protein and lipids can be investigated. Projection and 3-dimensional maps of six secondary transporters from different families have been determined by electron crystallography of 2D crystals at a resolution of 8 A and better. In this review, we give an overview about the principles of 2D crystallization, in particular of secondary transporters, and summarize the important steps successfully applied to establish and improve the 2D crystallization of the high-affinity glycine betaine uptake system from Corynebacterium glutamicum, BetP.     

Rationalizing alpha-helical membrane protein crystallization

X-ray crystallography is currently the most successful method for determining the three-dimensional structure of membrane proteins. Nevertheless, growing the crystals required for this technique presents one of the major bottlenecks in this area of structural biology. This is especially true for the alpha-helical type membrane proteins that are of particular interest due to their medical relevance. To address this problem we have undertaken a detailed analysis of the crystallization conditions from 121 alpha-helical membrane protein structures deposited in the Protein Data Bank. This information has been analyzed so that the success of different parameters can be easily compared for different membrane protein families. Concurrent with this analysis, we also present the new sparse matrix crystallization screen MemGold.     

An automated pipeline to screen membrane protein 2D crystallization

Electron crystallography relies on electron cryomicroscopy of two-dimensional (2D) crystals and is particularly well suited for studying the structure of membrane proteins in their native lipid bilayer environment. To obtain 2D crystals from purified membrane proteins, the detergent in a protein–lipid–detergent ternary mixture must be removed, generally by dialysis, under conditions favoring reconstitution into proteoliposomes and formation of well-ordered lattices. To identify these conditions a wide range of parameters such as pH, lipid composition, lipid-to-protein ratio, ionic strength and ligands must be screened in a procedure involving four steps: crystallization, specimen preparation for electron microscopy, image acquisition, and evaluation. Traditionally, these steps have been carried out manually and, as a result, the scope of 2D crystallization trials has been limited. We have therefore developed an automated pipeline to screen the formation of 2D crystals. We employed a 96-well dialysis block for reconstitution of the target protein over a wide range of conditions designed to promote crystallization. A 96-position magnetic platform and a liquid handling robot were used to prepare negatively stained specimens in parallel. Robotic grid insertion into the electron microscope and computerized image acquisition ensures rapid evaluation of the crystallization screen. To date, 38 2D crystallization screens have been conducted for 15 different membrane proteins, totaling over 3000 individual crystallization experiments. Three of these proteins have yielded diffracting 2D crystals. Our automated pipeline outperforms traditional 2D crystallization methods in terms of throughput and reproducibility.     

Assessing Two-dimensional Crystallization Trials of Small Membrane Proteins for Structural Biology Studies by Electron Crystallography

Electron crystallography has evolved as a method that can be used either alternatively or in combination with three-dimensional crystallization and X-ray crystallography to study structure-function questions of membrane proteins, as well as soluble proteins. Screening for two-dimensional (2D) crystals by transmission electron microscopy (EM) is the critical step in finding, optimizing, and selecting samples for high-resolution data collection by cryo-EM. Here we describe the fundamental steps in identifying both large and ordered, as well as small 2D arrays, that can potentially supply critical information for optimization of crystallization conditions.By working with different magnifications at the EM, data on a range of critical parameters is obtained. Lower magnification supplies valuable data on the morphology and membrane size. At higher magnifications, possible order and 2D crystal dimensions are determined. In this context, it is described how CCD cameras and online-Fourier Transforms are used at higher magnifications to assess proteoliposomes for order and size.While 2D crystals of membrane proteins are most commonly grown by reconstitution by dialysis, the screening technique is equally applicable for crystals produced with the help of monolayers, native 2D crystals, and ordered arrays of soluble proteins. In addition, the methods described here are applicable to the screening for 2D crystals of even smaller as well as larger membrane proteins, where smaller proteins require the same amount of care in identification as our examples and the lattice of larger proteins might be more easily identifiable at earlier stages of the screening.Download video file.^{(59M, mov)}     

Crystallization of the membrane protein hVDAC1 produced in cell-free system

Structural studies of membrane proteins are in constant evolution with the development of new improvements for their expression, purification, stabilization and crystallization. However, none of these methods still provides a universal approach to solve the structure of membrane proteins. Here we describe the crystallization of the human voltage-dependent anion channel-1 produced by a bacterial cell-free expression system. While VDAC structures have been recently solved, we propose an alternative strategy for producing the recombinant protein, which can be applied to other membrane proteins reluctant to expression, purification and crystallization by classical approaches. Despite a lot of efforts to crystallize a cell-free expressed membrane protein, this study is to our knowledge one of the first reports of a successful crystallization. Focusing on expression in a soluble and functional state, in a detergent environment, is the key to get crystals. Although the diffraction of VDAC crystals is limited, the simplicity and the rapidity to set-up and optimize this technology are drastic advantages in comparison to other methods.     

A high-throughput strategy to screen 2D crystallization trials of membrane proteins

Electron microscopy of two-dimensional (2D) crystals has demonstrated potential for structure determination of membrane proteins. Technical limitations in large-scale crystallization screens have, however, prevented a major breakthrough in the routine application of this technology. Dialysis is generally used for detergent removal and reconstitution of the protein into a lipid bilayer, and devices for testing numerous conditions in parallel are not readily available. Furthermore, the small size of resulting 2D crystals requires electron microscopy to evaluate the results and automation of the necessary steps is essential to achieve a reasonable throughput. We have designed a crystallization block, using standard microplate dimensions, by which 96 unique samples can be dialyzed simultaneously against 96 different buffers and have demonstrated that the rate of detergent dialysis is comparable to those obtained with conventional dialysis devices. A liquid-handling robot was employed to set up 2D crystallization trials with the membrane proteins CopA from Archaeoglobus fulgidus and light-harvesting complex II (LH2) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. For CopA, 1 week of dialysis yielded tubular crystals and, for LH2, large and well-ordered vesicular 2D crystals were obtained after 24 h, illustrating the feasibility of this approach. Combined with a high-throughput procedure for preparation of EM-grids and automation of the subsequent negative staining step, the crystallization block offers a novel pipeline that promises to speed up large-scale screening of 2D crystallization and to increase the likelihood of producing well-ordered crystals for analysis by electron crystallography.     

Strategies for crystallizing membrane proteins

Crystallizing membrane proteins remains a challenging endeavor despite the increasing number of membrane protein structures solved by X-ray crystallography. The critical factors in determining the success of the crystallization experiments are the purification and preparation of membrane protein samples. Moreover, there is the added complication that the crystallization conditions must be optimized for use in the presence of detergents although the methods used to crystallize most membrane proteins are, in essence, straightforward applications of standard methodologies for soluble protein crystallization. The roles that detergents play in the stability and aggregation of membrane proteins as well as the colloidal properties of the protein-detergent complexes need to be appreciated and controlledbefore and during the crystallization trials. All X-ray quality crystals of membrane proteins were grown from preparations of detergent-solubilized protein, where the heterogeneous natural lipids from the membrane have been replaced by ahomogeneous detergent environment. It is the preparation of such monodisperse, isotropic solutions of membrane proteins that has allowed the successful application of the standard crystallization methods routinely used on soluble proteins. In this review, the issues of protein purification and sample preparation are addressed as well as the new refinements in crystallization methodologies for membrane proteins. How the physical behavior of the detergent, in the form of micelles or protein-detergent aggregates, affects crystallization and the adaptation of published protocols to new membrane protein systems are also addressed. The general conclusion is that many integral membrane proteins could be crystallized if pure and monodisperse preparations in a suitable detergent system can be prepared.In memory of Glenn D. Garavito.     

Growth of Large and Highly Ordered 2D Crystals of a K+ Channel,Structural Role of Lipidic Environment

2D crystallography has proven to be an excellent technique to determine the 3D structure of membrane proteins. Compared to 3D crystallography, it has the advantage of visualizing the protein in an environment closer to the native one. However, producing good 2D crystals is still a challenge and little statistical knowledge can be gained from literature. Here, we present a thorough screening of 2D crystallization conditions for a prokaryotic inwardly rectifying potassium channel (>130 different conditions). Key parameters leading to very large and well-organized 2D crystals are discussed. In addition, the problem of formation of multilayers during the growth of 2D crystals is also addressed. An intermediate resolution projection map of KirBac3.1 at 6 Å is presented, which sheds (to our knowledge) new light on the structure of this channel in a lipid environment.     

Room to move: crystallizing membrane proteins in swollen lipidic mesophases

The cubic phase or in meso crystallization method is responsible for almost 40 solved integral membrane protein structures. Most of these are small and compact proteins. A model for how crystals form by the in meso method has been proposed that invokes a transition between mesophases. In light of this model, we speculated that a more hydrated and open mesophase, of reduced interfacial curvature, would support facile crystallization of bigger and bulkier proteins. The proposal was explored here by performing crystallization in the presence of additives that swell the cubic phase. The additive concentration inducing swelling, as quantified by small-angle X-ray diffraction, coincided with a "crystallization window" in which two, very different transmembranal proteins produced crystals. That the swollen mesophase can grow structure-grade crystals was proven with one of these, the light-harvesting II complex. In most regards, the structural details of the corresponding complex resembled those of crystals grown by the conventional vapour diffusion method, with some important differences. In particular, packing density in the in meso-grown crystals was dramatically higher, more akin to that seen with water-soluble proteins, which accounts for their enhanced diffracting power. The layered and close in-plane packing observed has been rationalized in a model for nucleation and crystal growth by the in meso method that involves swollen mesophases. These results present a rational case for including mesophase-swelling additives in screens for in meso crystallogenesis. Their use will contribute to broadening the range of membrane proteins that yield to structure determination.     

Determination and application of empirically derived detergent phase boundaries to effectively crystallize membrane proteins

Elucidating the structures of membrane proteins is essential to our understanding of disease states and a critical component in the rational design of drugs. Structural characterization of a membrane protein begins with its detergent solubilization from the lipid bilayer and its purification within a functionally stable protein‐detergent complex (PDC). Crystallization of the PDC typically occurs by changing the solution environment to decrease solubility and promote interactions between exposed hydrophilic surface residues. As membrane proteins have been observed to form crystals close to the phase separation boundaries of the detergent used to form the PDC, knowledge of these boundaries under different chemical conditions provides a foundation to rationally design crystallization screens. We have carried out dye‐based detergent phase partitioning studies using different combinations of 10 polyethylene glycols (PEG), 11 salts, and 11 detergents to generate a significant amount of chemically diverse phase boundary data. The resulting curves were used to guide the formulation of a 1536‐cocktail crystallization screen for membrane proteins. We are making both the experimentally derived phase boundary data and the 1536 membrane screen available through the high‐throughput crystallization facility located at the Hauptman‐Woodward Institute. The phase boundary data have been packaged into an interactive Excel spreadsheet that allows investigators to formulate grid screens near a given phase boundary for a particular detergent. The 1536 membrane screen has been applied to 12 membrane proteins of unknown structures supplied by the structural genomics and structural biology communities, with crystallization leads for 10/12 samples and verification of one crystal using X‐ray diffraction.     

Structure of membrane-bound annexin A5 trimers: a hybrid cryo-EM - X-ray crystallography study

Annexins constitute a family of phospholipid- and Ca(2+)-binding proteins involved in a variety of membrane-related processes. The property of several annexins, including annexin A5, to self-organize at the surface of lipid membranes into 2D ordered arrays has been proposed to be functionally relevant in cellular contexts. To further address this question, we investigated the high-resolution structure of annexin A5 trimers in membrane-bound 2D crystals by cryo-electron microscopy (Cryo-EM). A new 2D crystal form was discovered, with p32(1) symmetry, which is significantly better ordered than the 2D crystals reported before. A 2D projection map was obtained at 6.5 A resolution, revealing protein densities within each of the four domains characteristic of annexins. A quantitative comparison was performed between this structure and models generated from the structure of the soluble form of annexin A5 in pseudo-R3 3D crystals. This analysis indicated that both structures are essentially identical, except for small local changes attributed to membrane binding. As a consequence, and contrary to the common view, annexin A5 molecules maintain their bent shape and do not flatten upon membrane binding, which implies either that the four putative Ca(2+) and membrane-binding loops present different types of interaction with the membrane surface, or that the membrane surface is locally perturbed. We propose that the trimerization of annexin A5 molecules is the relevant structural change occurring upon membrane binding. The evidence that 2D arrays of annexin A5 trimers are responsible for its in vitro property of blood coagulation inhibition supports this conclusion.     

Self-assembly of soluble proteins on functionalized lipid layers: a tentative correlation between the fluidity properties of the lipid film and protein ordering

New series of amphiphilic structures are designed to exhibit various fluidity properties when spread at the air-water interface. The influence of the molecular structure of these lipids on the process of two-dimensional (2D) crystallization of the B subunit of DNA gyrase, a soluble protein, is investigated in terms of size of the crystals produced, protein ordering, and crystallization kinetics. Whereas no difference is observed concerning the mean size of the protein 2D crystals obtained on the different lipid supports, the ultimate protein ordering observable by electron microscopy using the negative-staining technique is more regularly attained with some of these new lipids. The most interesting point results from large discrepancies in crystallization kinetics as highly-ordered protein 2D crystals form within 6-24 h depending on the lipid layer structure. Thus, these new lipids reveal of special interest when studying proteins that suffer from extended incubation time at 4 degrees C or higher temperature and lose their functionality.     

Crystallization of intrinsic membrane proteins

After many years of discouraging failures, it is now possible to crystallize the intrinsic membrane proteins and to obtain structural information from diffraction studies on the crystals. The strategy for the crystallization consists of depletion of boundary phospholipids from the protein and complex formation with specific ligands.     

The active ring-like structure of SecA revealed by electron crystallography: conformational change upon interaction with SecB

SecA is a multifunctional protein involved in protein translocation in bacteria. The structure of SecA on membrane is dramatically altered compared with that in solution, accompanying with functional changes. We previously reported the formation of a novel ring-like structure of SecA on lipid layers, which may constitute part of the preprotein translocation channel. In the present work, two-dimensional crystallization of Escherichia coli SecA on lipid monolayers was performed to reveal the structural details of SecA on lipid layers and to investigate its function. The 2D crystals composed of ring-like structures were obtained by specific interaction between SecA and negatively charged lipid. The 2D projection map and 3D reconstruction from negative stained 2D crystals exhibited a distinct open channel-like structure of SecA, with an outer diameter of 7 nm and an inner diameter of 2 nm, providing the structural evidence for SecA importance in forming the part of the translocation channel. This pore structure is altered after transferring crystals to the SecB solution, indicating that the lipid-specific SecA structure has the SecB binding activity. The strategy developed here provides a promising technique for studying structure of SecA complex with its ligand on membrane.     

Two-dimensional crystallization and preliminary structure analysis of LHC-II from cucumber and spinach

Ｔｈｅｌｉｇｈｔｈａｒｖｅｓｔｉｎｇｃｈｌｏｒｏｐｈｙｌｌａ/ｂｐｒｏｔｅｉｎｃｏｍｐｌｅｘ(ＬＨＣＩＩ)ａｓｓｏｃｉａｔｅｄｗｉｔｈｐｈｏｔｏｓｙｓｔｅｍＩＩｉｓｔｈｅｍｏｓｔａｂｕｎｄａｎｔｐｉｇｍｅｎｔｐｒｏｔｅｉｎｃｏｍｐｌｅｘｉｎｃｈｌｏｒｏｐｌａｓｔｔｈｙｌａｋｏｉｄｏｆａｌｌｇｒｅｅｎｐｌａｎｔｓ.Ｉｔｃｏｎｔａｉｎｓａｂｏｕｔ50%ｏｆｔｈｅｔｏｔａｌａｍｏｕｎｔｏｆｐｉｇｍｅｎｔｓｉｎｖｏｌｖｅｄｉｎｐｌａｎｔｐｈｏｔｏｓｙｎｔｈｅｓｉｓ.ＬＨＣＩＩｐｅｒｆｏｒｍｓｉｍｐｏｒｔａｎｔｆ…