Role of the cell surface-exposed regions of outer membrane protein PhoE of Escherichia coli K12 in the biogenesis of the protein

To investigate the role of the cell surface-exposed regions of outer membrane protein PhoE of Escherichia coli K12 in the biogenesis of the protein, deletions were generated in two presumed cell surface-exposed regions of the protein. Intact cells expressing these mutant proteins were recognized by PhoE-specific monoclonal antibodies, which recognize conformational epitopes on the cell surface-exposed parts of the protein and/or were sensitive to a PhoE-specific phage. This shows that the polypeptides were normally incorporated into the outer membrane. When the deletions extended four amino acid residues into the seventh presumed membrane-spanning segment, the polypeptides accumulated in the periplasm. In conclusion, exposed regions of PhoE protein apparently do not play an essential role in outer membrane localization, which is consistent with the observation that these regions are hypervariable when PhoE is compared to the related proteins OmpF and OmpC. In contrast, the membrane-spanning segments are essential for the assembly process.     

Outer membrane protein PhoE as a carrier for the exposure of foreign antigenic determinants at the bacterial cell surface

PhoE protein is an abundant outer membrane protein of theEscherichia coli K-12 outer membrane. This protein can be used as an exposure system to produce foreign antigenic determinants and for their transport to the bacterial cell surface. The system is very flexible, since insertions varying in length and nature could be made in different cell surface-exposed regions of PhoE, without interfering with the assembly process of the mutant proteins into the outer membrane. Two antigenic determinants of the structural VP1 protein of foot-and-mouth disease virus were inserted in different combinations in four cell surface-exposed regions of PhoE. The epitopes were exposed at the bacterial cell surface and they keep their antigenic and immunogenic properties in this PhoE-associated conformation. Immunization of guinea pigs with one hybrid protein, containing a combination of the two epitopes inserted in the fourth exposed region, resulted in complete protection against challenge with the virus. A T-cell epitope of the 65 kDa heat shock protein ofMycobacterium tuberculosis was inserted in the fourth exposed region of PhoE and in vitro proliferation of two T-cell specific clones was demonstrated. Thus, the PhoE exposure system has been shown to be suitable for presentation of both B-cell and T-cell determinants to the immune system. Furthermore, good expression of the hybrid protein in attenuatedSalmonella strains, which can be used as live oral vaccines, was shown.Paper awarded the Kluyver Prize 1990 by the Netherlands Society of Microbiology to Dr. M.C. Agterberg     

Use of outer membrane protein PhoE as a carrier for the transport of a foreign antigenic determinant to the cell surface of Escherichia coli K-12

PhoE protein is an abundant transmembrane protein from the Escherichia coli K-12 outer membrane. A synthetic oligodeoxynucleotide corresponding to an antigenic determinant of the C-terminal part of the VP1 protein of foot-and-mouth disease virus was inserted into the phoE gene in an area corresponding to a cell surface-exposed region of the PhoE protein. The level of expression of the hybrid protein was normal and the protein was incorporated into the outer membrane. The VP1-epitope was exposed at the cell surface since intact cells were recognized by a monoclonal antibody which was raised against the virus.     

Topology of outer membrane pore protein PhoE of Escherichia coli. Identification of cell surface-exposed amino acids with the aid of monoclonal antibodies

Monoclonal antibodies which recognize the cell surface-exposed part of outer membrane protein PhoE of Escherichia coli were used to select for antigenic mutants producing an altered PhoE protein. The selection procedure was based on the antibody-dependent bactericidal action of the complement system. Using two distinct PhoE-specific monoclonal antibodies, seven independent mutants with an altered PhoE protein were isolated. Among these seven mutants, five distinct binding patterns were observed with a panel of 10 monoclonal antibodies. DNA sequence analysis revealed the following substitutions in the 330-residue-long PhoE protein: Arg-201----His (three isolates), Arg-201----Cys, Gly-238----Ser, Gly-275----Ser and Gly-275----Asp. It is argued that amino acid residues 201, 238, and 275 are most likely directly involved in antibody binding and, therefore, exposed at the cell surface. Together with Arg-158, which was previously shown to be cell surface exposed as it is changed in phage TC45-resistant phoE mutants, these four positions show a remarkably regular spacing, being approximately 40 residues apart. A model is suggested in which the PhoE polypeptide repeatedly traverses the outer membrane in an antiparallel beta-pleated sheet structure, exposing eight areas to the outside which are all separated by approximately 40 residues.     

Assembly of an in vitro synthesized Escherichia coli outer membrane porin into its stable trimeric configuration

The folding of in vitro synthesized outer membrane protein PhoE of Escherichia coli was studied in immunoprecipitation experiments with monoclonal antibodies which recognize cell surface-exposed conformational epitopes. The signal sequence appears to interfere with the formation of these conformational epitopes, since a mutant PhoE protein which lacks the majority of the signal peptide could be precipitated four times better than the wild type precursor. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of the immunoprecipitated PhoE protein revealed that part of the immunoprecipitated PhoE was present as a heat-modifiable form of the protein which migrated faster in the gels than the completely denatured protein. This form of the protein probably represents a folded monomer which might be an intermediate in the assembly of the protein. Outer membrane vesicles were required to induce the formation of small amounts of heat-stable trimers, the functional form of the protein in vivo.     

Subcellular localization of a PhoE-LacZ fusion protein in E. coli by protease accessibility experiments reveals an inner-membrane-spanning form of the protein

Protease accessibility experiments were employed to localize a PhoE-LacZ hybrid protein, encompassing a large N-terminal fragment of the outer membrane PhoE protein of E. coli, fused to beta-galactosidase, at the subcellular level. In previous studies, this protein was shown to co-fractionate with the outer membrane, whereas immunocytochemical methods suggested a cytoplasmic location. The present results confirm the latter localization. Moreover, it appears that a minor amount of hybrid protein spans the inner membrane, with the PhoE moiety in the periplasm and the beta-galactosidase moiety in the cytoplasm. These membrane-spanning proteins might be responsible for the lethal jamming of the export machinery, observed upon induction of synthesis of the protein.     

Localization of functional domains in E. coli K-12 outer membrane porins.

The genes ompC and phoE of Escherichia coli K-12 encode outer membrane pore proteins that are very homologous. To study the structure-function relationship of these proteins, we have constructed a series of ompC-phoE hybrid genes in which the DNA encoding part of one protein is replaced by the corresponding part of the other gene. These hybrid genes were easily obtained by using in vivo recombination. The fusion sites in the hybrid genes were localized by restriction enzyme mapping. The hybrid gene products were normally expressed and they were characterized with respect to functions and properties in which the native OmpC and PhoE proteins differ, such as pore characteristics, the receptor activity for phages and the binding of specific antibodies. Three regions within the N-terminal 130 amino acids were localized which determine pore characteristics and a segment between residues 75 and 110 contains amino acids which determine specificity for PhoE phages. A major cell surface-exposed region is located between residues 142 and 267. This region contains residues which are required for the binding of monoclonal antibodies directed against the cell surface-exposed part of PhoE and residues which determine specificity for OmpC phages.     

Topology of PhoE porin: the 'eyelet' region

A model for the topology of the PhoE porin has been proposed according to which the polypeptide traverses the outer membrane sixteen times mostly as amphipathic β-sheets, thereby exposing eight loops at the cell surface. Until now, no evidence has been obtained for the surface exposure of the third loop. Recently, the structure of porin of Rhodobacter capsulatus has been determined. The proposed model of PhoE is very similar to the structure of the R capsulatus porin, which has an ‘eyelet’ region, extending into the interior of the pore. The proposed third external loop of PhoE might form a similar ‘eyelet’ region. To determine the location of the predicted third external loop of PhoE, multiple copies of an oligonucleotide linker encoding an antigenic determinant of VP1 protein of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) were inserted. All hybrid proteins were properly inserted in the outer membrane. The monoclonal antibody MA11, directed against the linear FMDV epitope, was able to bind only to intact cells expressing a hybrid PhoE protein with at least three copies of the FMDV epitope present. Antibiotic sensitivity tests and single-channel conductance measurements revealed that the insertions influenced the channel size. These results are consistent with a location of the third loop of PhoE within the pore channel.     

Cloning of phoE, the structural gene for the Escherichia coli phosphate limitation-inducible outer membrane pore protein.

The hybrid plasmid pLC44-11 from the Clarke and Carbon collection, which was known to carry the proA gene, was shown also to contain the phoE gene. In vitro recombination techniques were used to subclone a 4.9-kilobase-pair DNA fragment of pLC44-11 into the plasmid vectors pACYC184 and pBR322. Expression of this fragment in a minicell system showed that it codes for the PhoE protein and for polypeptides with apparent molecular weights of 47,000 and 17,000. These results supply definite proof for the earlier supposition that the phoE gene is the structural gene for the outer membrane PhoE protein. Overproduction of the PhoE protein in a phoS strain resulted in reduced amounts of OmpF and LamB proteins.     

Gene encoding a hybrid OmpF-PhoE pore protein in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli K12

Summary To study the structure-function relationship of outer membrane pore proteins of E. coli K12, a hybrid gene was constructed in which the DNA encoding amino acid residues 2–73 of the mature PhoE protein is replaced by the homologous part of the related ompF gene. The product of this gene is incorporated normally into the outer membrane. It was characterized with respect to its pore activity and its phage receptor and colicin receptor properties. It is concluded (i) that the preference of the PhoE protein pore for negatively charged solutes is partly determined by the amino terminal 73 amino acids, (ii) that part of the receptor site of PhoE protein for phage TC45 is located in this part of the protein, (iii) that colicin N uses OmpF protein as (part of) its receptor, (iv) that the specificity of OmpF protein as a colicin N receptor is completely located within the 80 amino terminal amino acid residues, whereas the specificity of this protein as a colicin A receptor is completely located within the 260 carboxy terminal amino acid residues, and (v) that the amino terminal 73 amino acid residues of PhoE protein span the membrane at least once.     

Analysis of structure-function relationships in Escherichia coli K12 outer membrane porins with the aid of ompC-phoE and phoE-ompC hybrid genes

Summary To study structure-function relationships in the outer membrane pore proteins OmpC and PhoE of Escherichia coli K12, we have constructed a series of phoE-ompC hybrid genes in which DNA encoding part of one protein is replaced by the homologous part of the other gene. The hybrid gene products were incorporated normally into the outer membrane, allowing their functional characterization. Combined with previous studies, the present results permit the identification of regions involved in determining functions and properties in which the native PhoE and OmpC proteins differ, such as pore characteristics, receptor activity for phages and binding of monoclonal antibodies. Most of these properties were found to be determined by multiple regions clearly separated in the primary structure. The combined phage and antibody binding data have demonstrated that at least five distinct regions in PhoE and OmpC are exposed at the cell surface. The locations of these regions are in agreement with a previously proposed model for porin topology.     

Carboxy-terminal phenylalanine is essential for the correct assembly of a bacterial outer membrane protein

Bacterial outer membrane proteins are supposed to span the membrane repeatedly, mostly in the form of amphipathic beta-sheets. The last ten C-terminal amino acid residues of PhoE protein are supposed to form such a membrane-spanning segment. Deletion of this segment completely prevents incorporation into the outer membrane. Comparison of the last ten amino acid residues of other outer membrane proteins from different Gram-negative bacteria revealed the presence of a potential amphipathic beta-sheet with hydrophobic residues at positions 1 (Phe), 3 (preferentially Tyr), 5, 7 and 9 from the C terminus, in the vast majority of these proteins. Since such sequences were not detected at the C termini of periplasmic proteins, it appears to be possible to discriminate between the majority of outer membrane proteins and periplasmic proteins on the basis of sequence data. The highly conserved phenylalanine at the C termini of outer membrane proteins suggests an important function for this amino acid in assembly into the outer membrane. Site-directed mutagenesis was applied to study the role of the C-terminal Phe in PhoE protein assembly. All mutant proteins were correctly incorporated into the outer membrane to some extent, but the efficiency of the process was severely affected. It appears that both the hydrophobicity and the aromatic nature of Phe are of importance.     

PhoE protein pore of the outer membrane of Escherichia coli K12 is a particularly efficient channel for organic and inorganic phosphate

This study was undertaken to investigate the proposed in vivo pore function of PhoE protein, an Escherichia coli K12 outer membrane protein induced by growth under phosphate limitation, and to compare it with those of the constitutive pore proteins OmpF and OmpC. Appropriate mutant strains were constructed containing only one of the proteins PhoE, OmpF or OmpC, or none of these proteins at all. By measuring rates of nutrient uptake at low solute concentrations, the proposed pore function of PhoE protein was confirmed as the presence of the protein facilitates the diffusion of P_i through the outer membrane, such that a pore protein deficient strain behaves as a K_m mutant. Comparison of the rates of permeation of P_i, glycerol 3-phosphate and glucose 6-phosphate through pores formed by PhoE, OmpF and OmpC proteins shows that PhoE protein is the most effective pore in facilitating the diffusion of P_i and phosphorus-containing compounds. The three types of pores were about equally effective in facilitating the permeation of glucose and arsenate. Possible reasons for the preference for P_i and P_i-containing solutes are discussed.     

Characterization of the Citrobacter freundii phoE gene and development of C. freundii-specific oligonucleotides

The phoE gene of Citrobacter freundii, encoding a pore-forming outer membrane protein, was cloned and its nucleotide sequence was determined. The homologies in terms of identical amino acids between the C. freundii PhoE protein and those of Escherichia coli, E. cloacae and Klebsiella pneumoniae were 90%, 86% and 84%, respectively. Two synthetic oligonucleotides, corresponding to hypervariable, cell surface-exposed regions of the protein, were tested for their specificity in polymerase chain reactions. They were specific for the species C. freundii, i.e., no reaction was detected with 35 non-C. freundii strains tested, including 17 Salmonella, two C. amalonaticus and three C. diversus strains, whereas all five C. freundii strains tested were correctly recognized.     

Outer Membrane Protein PhoE Takes the Place of OmpC/OmpF in Maintenance of the Surface Structure of Escherichia coli Cells

OmpC and OmpF, outer membrane porin proteins, are important in the maintenance of the cell surface structure of Escherichia coli cells [T. Nogami and S. Mizushima, J. Bacteriol., 156, 402 (1983)]. Mutants lacking both proteins are unstable and frequently revert or mutate to strains which either have regained one or both of the proteins or constitutively produce PhoE, another porin protein. In the present work, the structural importance of PhoE was studied in relation to OmpC. and OmpF. The strain devoid of both OmpC and OmpF was highly susceptible to Tris-HCl buffer at a concentration of 120 mm in terms of viability and cell structure. This strain was also susceptible to osmotic shock. In contrast, the strain possessing PhoE in place of OmpC/OmpF was as stable as the strain possessing OmpC/OmpF against these treatments. PhoE, like OmpC and OmpF, was assembled into a hexagonal lattice with lipopolysaccharide that covered the peptidoglycan sacculus. These results suggest that PhoE can take the place of OmpC/OmpF in the maintenance of the cell surface structure. The importance of porins in general in the maintenance of the cell structure is discussed.     

The early interaction of the outer membrane protein phoe with the periplasmic chaperone Skp occurs at the cytoplasmic membrane

Spheroplasts were used to study the early interactions of newly synthesized outer membrane protein PhoE with periplasmic proteins employing a protein cross-linking approach. Newly translocated PhoE protein could be cross-linked to the periplasmic chaperone Skp at the periplasmic side of the inner membrane. To study the timing of this interaction, a PhoE-dihydrofolate reductase hybrid protein was constructed that formed translocation intermediates, which had the PhoE moiety present in the periplasm and the dihydrofolate reductase moiety tightly folded in the cytoplasm. The hybrid protein was found to cross-link to Skp, indicating that PhoE closely interacts with the chaperone when the protein is still in a transmembrane orientation in the translocase. Removal of N-terminal parts of PhoE protein affected Skp binding in a cumulative manner, consistent with the presence of two Skp-binding sites in that region. In contrast, deletion of C-terminal parts resulted in variable interactions with Skp, suggesting that interaction of Skp with the N-terminal region is influenced by parts of the C terminus of PhoE protein. Both the soluble as well as the membrane-associated Skp protein were found to interact with PhoE. The latter form is proposed to be involved in the initial interaction with the N-terminal regions of the outer membrane protein.     

Failure of E. coli K-12 to transport PhoE-LacZ hybrid proteins out of the cytoplasm.

A phoE-lacZ hybrid gene encoding the N-terminal 300 amino acid residues of pre-PhoE protein, fused to an almost complete beta-galactosidase molecule was constructed in vitro. Cell fractionation experiments suggested that the hybrid gene product is transported to the outer membrane. However, by using immuno-cytochemical labelling on ultra-thin cryosections it was shown that the hybrid protein accumulated in the cytoplasm. Thus, it appears that: (i) data on the localization of hybrid proteins merely based on cell fractionation experiments are not reliable, and (ii) either the C-terminal 15% of PhoE protein contain information which is essential for transport, or PhoE-LacZ hybrid proteins can never be transported out of the cytoplasm. The implications of these results for current models on the translocation of outer membrane proteins are discussed.     

Construction of phoE-caa, a novel PCR- and immunologically detectable marker gene for Pseudomonas putida.

In this paper we describe the construction and use in Pseudomonas putida WCS358 of phoE-caa, a novel hybrid marker gene, which allows monitoring both at the protein level by immunological methods and at the DNA level by PCR. The marker is based on the Escherichia coli outer membrane protein gene phoE and 75 bp of E. coli caa, which encode a nonbacteriocinic fragment of colicin A. This fragment contains an epitope which is recognized by monoclonal antibody (MAb) 1C11. As the epitope is contained in one of the cell surface-exposed loops of PhoE, whole cells of bacteria expressing the protein can be detected by using the MAb. The marker gene contains only E. coli sequences not coding for toxins and therefore can be considered environmentally safe. The hybrid PhoE-ColA protein was expressed in E. coli under conditions of phosphate starvation, and single cells could be detected by immunofluorescence microscopy with MAb 1C11. Using a wide-host-range vector the phoE-caa gene was introduced into P. putida WCS358. The gene appeared to be expressed under phosphate limitation in this species, and the gene product was present in the membrane fraction and reacted with MAb 1C11. The hybrid PhoE-ColA protein could be detected on whole cells of WCS358 mutant strains lacking (part of) the O-antigen of the lipopolysaccharide but not on wild-type WCS358 cells, unless these cells had previously been washed with 10 mM EDTA. In addition to immunodetection, the phoE-caa marker gene could be specifically detected by PCR with one primer directed to a part of the phoE sequence and a second primer that annealed to the caa insert.     

Analysis of Surface-Exposed Outer Membrane Proteins in Helicobacter pylori

More than 50 Helicobacter pylori genes are predicted to encode outer membrane proteins (OMPs), but there has been relatively little experimental investigation of the H. pylori cell surface proteome. In this study, we used selective biotinylation to label proteins localized to the surface of H. pylori, along with differential detergent extraction procedures to isolate proteins localized to the outer membrane. Proteins that met multiple criteria for surface-exposed outer membrane localization included known adhesins, as well as Cag proteins required for activity of the cag type IV secretion system, putative lipoproteins, and other proteins not previously recognized as cell surface components. We identified sites of nontryptic cleavage consistent with signal sequence cleavage, as well as C-terminal motifs that may be important for protein localization. A subset of surface-exposed proteins were highly susceptible to proteolysis when intact bacteria were treated with proteinase K. Most Hop and Hom OMPs were susceptible to proteolysis, whereas Hor and Hof proteins were relatively resistant. Most of the protease-susceptible OMPs contain a large protease-susceptible extracellular domain exported beyond the outer membrane and a protease-resistant domain at the C terminus with a predicted β-barrel structure. These features suggest that, similar to the secretion of the VacA passenger domain, the N-terminal domains of protease-susceptible OMPs are exported through an autotransporter pathway. Collectively, these results provide new insights into the repertoire of surface-exposed H. pylori proteins that may mediate bacterium-host interactions, as well as the cell surface topology of these proteins.     

Expression of the pspA gene stimulates efficient protein export in Escherichia coli

Expression of several mutant forms of outer membrane protein PhoE of Escherichia coli, which are disturbed in normal biogenesis, resulted in high expression of a 26kDa protein. This 26kDa protein fractionated as a peripherally bound inner membrane protein. It appeared to be identical to a previously identified protein (PspA = phage shock protein A) of unknown function that is induced upon infection of E. coli with filamentous phages. PspA was not expressed upon synthesis of mutant PhoE proteins in a secB mutant, nor upon expression of a PhoE mutant that lacks the signal sequence, suggesting that entrance into the export pathway of prePhoE is essential for induction. PspA synthesis was also induced under other conditions that are known to block the export apparatus, i.e. in secA, secD and secF mutants when grown at their non-permissive temperature or upon induction of the synthesis of MalE-LacZ or LamB-LacZ hybrid proteins. The inducing conditions for PspA synthesis suggested a rote for this protein in export. In vivo pulse-chase experiments showed that the translocation of (mutant) prePhoE and of the precursors of other exported proteins was retarded in a pspA mutant strain. Also, in in vitro translocation assays, a role for PspA in protein transport could be demonstrated.