Phylogenetic Analysis of S-Locus Genes Reveals the Complicated Evolution Relationship of S Haplotypes in Brassica

Self-incompatibility (SI) is reported to play a key role in the evolution of species as it promotes their outcrossing through the recognition and rejection of self-pollen grains. In Brassica, two S-locus genes expressed in the stigma, S-locus glycoprotein (SLG) gene and S-locus receptor kinase (SRK) gene, and one expressed in the pollen, S-locus protein 11 (SP11) gene, were linked as an S haplotype. In order to analyze the evolutionary relationships of S haplotypes in Brassica, a total of 39 SRK, 37 SLG, and 58 SP11 sequences of Brassica oleracea, Brassica rapa and Brassica napus were aligned. Two phylogenetic trees with similar pattern were constructed based on the nucleotide sequences of SRK/SLG and SP11, respectively. Class I and class II alleles were clustered into two distinct groups, and alleles from different species, including all the interspecific pairs of S haplotypes, were closely related to each other. The S-locus genes identified in B. napus were intermingled in phylogenetic trees. All these observations showed that class I and class II S haplotypes diverged ahead of the species differentiation in Brassica. The evolution and the genetic diversity of S haplotypes in Brassica were discussed. Moreover, the relationships between S haplotypes and SI phenotypes in Brassica, especially in B. napus, were also discussed.     

Physical distances between S-locus genes in various S haplotypes of Brassica rapa and B. oleracea

In Brassica, self-incompatibility genes SLG (for S-locus glycoprotein) and SRK (for S-receptor kinase) are located in the S-locus complex region with several other S-linked genes. The S locus is a highly polymorphic region: polymorphism has been observed not only in sequences of SLG and SRK but also in the location of the S-locus genes. In order to compare the physical location of the S-locus genes in various S haplotypes, we used six class-I S haplotypes of B. rapa and seven class-I S haplotypes of B. oleracea in this study. DNA gel blot analysis using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) showed that the physical distances between SLG and SRK in B. rapa are significantly shorter than those in B. oleracea and that the sizes of MluI and BssHII fragments harboring SLG and SRK are less variable within B. rapa than within B. oleracea. We concluded that several large genomic fragments might have been inserted into the S-locus region of B. oleracea after allelic differentiation of S-locus genes. Received: 20 September 1999 / Accepted: 8 October 1999     

Polymorphism of the kinase domain of the S-locus receptor kinase gene (SRK) in Brassica oleracea L.

 DNA polymorphism of the S-locus receptor kinase gene (SRK) participating in self-incompatibility in Brassica was analyzed by PCR-RFLP and nucleotide sequencing. In the screening of primers for specific amplification of polymorphic DNA fragments of SRK, the best combination was that of a forward primer (PK1) having the nucleotide sequence of the second exon of S6 SRK and a reverse primer (PK4) having the complementary nucleotide sequence of the fifth exon of S6 SRK. PCR using this primer pair amplified DNA fragments of 0.9–1.0 kb from 36 S haplotypes out of 42 tested. These DNA fragments showed high polymorphism in polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis after digestion with restriction endonuclease(s): 25 types were found in a double digestion with MboI and AfaI. Nucleotide sequencing of the DNA fragments amplified from five S haplotypes showed that the third, fourth, and fifth exons of SRK are highly conserved, and that there are high variations of the second and third introns of SRK, which produced polymorphism of the band pattern in PCR-RFLPs. Another forward primer (PK5) having the nucleotide sequence of the second exon, which is derived from S2 SRK, amplified DNA fragments of almost the same region of SRK from 27 S haplotypes in combination with PK4. Although SRK alleles of the class-II S haplotypes were not amplified, all of the class-I S-haplotypes were amplified with a primer mixture of PK1, PK4 and PK5. The DNA fragments of both SRK alleles in S heterozygotes, or a 1 : 1 mixture of the genomic DNA of different S homozygotes, were amplified without exception, suggesting the usefulness of these primers for the identification of S heterozygotes. The DNA fragment sizes obtained by digestion with restriction endonucleases served as markers for the identification of S haplotypes. Received: 15 December 1996 / Accepted: 14 February 1997     

Molecular Characterization and Evolution of Self-Incompatibility Genes in Arabidopsis thaliana: The Case of the Sc Haplotype

The switch from an outcrossing mode of mating enforced by self-incompatibility to self-fertility in the Arabidopsis thaliana lineage was associated with mutations that inactivated one or both of the two genes that comprise the self-incompatibility (SI) specificity-determining S-locus haplotype, the S-locus receptor kinase (SRK) and the S-locus cysteine-rich (SCR) genes, as well as unlinked modifier loci required for SI. All analyzed A. thaliana S-locus haplotypes belong to the SA, SB, or SC haplotypic groups. Of these three, the SC haplotype is the least well characterized. Its SRKC gene can encode a complete open-reading frame, although no functional data are available, while its SCRC sequences have not been isolated. As a result, it is not known what mutations were associated with inactivation of this haplotype. Here, we report on our analysis of the Lz-0 accession and the characterization of its highly rearranged SC haplotype. We describe the isolation of its SCRC gene as well as the subsequent isolation of SCRC sequences from other SC-containing accessions and from the A. lyrata S36 haplotype, which is the functional equivalent of the A. thaliana SC haplotype. By performing transformation experiments using chimeric SRK and SCR genes constructed with SC- and S36-derived sequences, we show that the SRKC and SCRC genes of Lz-0 and at least a few other SC-containing accessions are nonfunctional, despite SCRC encoding a functional full-length protein. We identify the probable mutations that caused the inactivation of these genes and discuss our results in the context of mechanisms of S-locus inactivation in A. thaliana.     

Characterization of the S locus genes, SLG and SRK, of the Brassica S3 haplotype: identification of a membrane-localized protein encoded by the S locus receptor kinase gene

The S locus, which controls the self-incompatibility response in Brassica, has been shown to contain at least two genes. SLG encodes a secreted S locus glycoprotein whilst SRK encodes a putative S locus receptor kinase. SRK has been shown potentially to encode a functional kinase and genetic evidence indicates that this gene is essential for the self-incompatibility response. Here the characterization of the SRK and SLG genes of a Brassica line homozygous for the S₃ haplotype is described. A 120 kDa glycoprotein was identified in stigmas and several lines of evidence indicated that this protein is encoded by the SRK₃ gene. First, the 120 kDa glycoprotein was recognized by antibodies raised against peptides based on the SRK₃ gene sequence. Secondly, this protein is polymorphic and, in an F₂ population segregating for the S₃ haplotype, was expressed only in plants possessing the S₃ haplotype. Thirdly, the 120 kDa protein was expressed specifically in stigmas. Finally, the 120 kDa protein was only extracted from stigmas in the presence of detergent indicating that it is anchored in the membrane. SRK has been predicted to encode a transmembrane glycoprotein based on the deduced amino acid sequence. Located on the membrane, SRK is in a position to interface between an extracellular recognition event between pollen and pistil and an intracellular signal transduction pathway which initiates the self-incompatibility response.     

Physical linkage of the SLG and SRK genes at the self-incompatibility locus of Brassica oleracea

Summary In Brassica oleracea, the pollen-stigma interaction of self-incompatibility is controlled by a single genetically defined locus designated S. Molecular studies have identified two genes that are tightly linked to the classically defined S locus: The S-Locus Glycoprotein (SLG) gene and the S-Receptor Kinase (SRK) gene. In previous RFLP linkage analyses with probes specific for SLG and SRK, we were unable to identify any recombination events between SLG, SRK, and self-incompatibility phenotype. In this paper, we use pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) in conjunction with DNA blot analysis to characterize the S-locus region from two highly divergent self-incompatibility genotypes, S ₂ and S ₆. We establish the physical linkage of SLG and SRK in each genotype, and demonstrate that the two genes are separated by a maximum distance of 220 kb in the S ₆ genotype and 350 kb in the S ₂ genotype. Furthermore, a comparison of the data from the two genotypes reveals that a high level of polymorphism exists across the entire S-locus region.     

Analysis of S-locus and expression of S-alleles of self-compatible rapid-cycling Brassica oleracea ‘TO1000DH3’

Brassica oleracea is a strictly self-incompatible (SI) plant, but rapid-cycling B. oleracea ‘TO1000DH3’ is self-compatible (SC). Self-incompatibility in Brassicaceae is controlled by multiple alleles of the S-locus. Three S-locus genes, S-locus glycoprotein (SLG), S-locus receptor kinase (SRK) and S-locus protein 11 or S-locus cysteine-rich (SP11/SCR), have been reported to date, all of which are classified into class I and II. In this study, we investigated the molecular mechanism behind alterations of SI to SC in rapid-cycling B. olerace ‘TO1000DH3’. Class I SRK were identified by genomic DNA PCR and PCR-RFLP analysis using SRK specific markers and found to be homozygous. Cloning and sequencing of class I SRK revealed a normal kinase domain without any S-domain/transmembrane domain. Moreover, S-locus sequencing analysis revealed only an SLG sequence, but no SP11/SCR. Expression analysis showed no SRK expression in the stigma, although other genes involved in the SI recognition reaction (SLG, MLPK, ARC1, THL) were found to have normal expression in the stigma. Taken together, the above results suggest that structural aberrations such as deletion of the SI recognition genes may be responsible for the breakdown of SI in rapid-cycling B. oleracea ‘TO1000DH3’.     

Development of SCAR markers linked to self-incompatibility in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Brassica napus</Emphasis> L.

‘SI1300’ is a self-incompatible Brassica napus line generated by introgressing an S haplotype from B. rapa ‘Xishuibai’ into a rapeseed cultivar ‘Huayou No. 1’. Five S-locus specific primer pairs were employed to develop cleaved amplified polymorphic sequences (CAPS) markers linked the S haplotype of ‘SI1300’. Two segregating populations (F₂ and BC₁) from the cross between ‘SI1300’ and self-compatible European spring cultivar ‘Defender’, were generated to verify the molecular markers. CAPS analysis revealed no desirable polymorphism between self-incompatible and self-compatible plants. Twenty primer pairs were designed based on the homology-based candidate gene method, and six dominant sequence characterized amplified region (SCAR) markers linked with the S-locus were developed. Of the six markers, three were derived from the SRK and SP11 alleles of class II B. rapa S haplotypes and linked with S haplotype of ‘SI1300’. The other three markers were designed from the SLG-A10 and co-segregated with S haplotype of ‘Defender’. We successfully combined two pairs of them and characterized two multiplex PCR markers which could discriminate the homozygous and heterozygous genotypes. These markers were further validated in 24 F₃ and 22 BC₁F₂ lines of ‘SI1300 × Defender’ and another two segregating populations from the cross ‘SI1300 × Yu No. 9’. Nucleotide sequences of fragments linked with S-locus of ‘SI1300’ showed 99% identity to B. rapa class II S-60 haplotype, and fragments from ‘Defender’ were 97% and 94% identical to SLG and SRK of B. rapa class I S-47 haplotype, respectively. ‘SI1300’ was considered to carry two class II S haplotypes and the S haplotype on the A-genome derived from B. rapa ‘Xishuibai’ determines the SI phenotype, while ‘Defender’ carry a class I S haplotype derived from B. rapa and a class II S haplotype from B. oleracea. SCAR markers developed in this study will be helpful for improving SI lines and accelerating marker-assisted selection process in rapeseed SI hybrid breeding program.     

Characterization of self-incompatibility genes in the intergeneric hybrid xBrassicoraphanus

Brassica rapa and Raphanus sativus are strictly self-incompatible (SI) plants; however, xBrassicoraphanus (baemoochae) is an intergeneric hybrid synthesized following hybridization of B. rapa and R. sativus that is self-compatible (SC). Self-incompatibility in Brassicaceae is controlled by multiple alleles of the S-locus. Two S-locus genes, SRK (S-locus receptor kinase) and SP11/SCR (S-locus protein 11 or S-locus cysteine-rich), have been reported to date, both of which are classified into class I and II. In this study, we investigate if there is an alteration in the structure or the expression in SRK or SP11 genes behind the alteration of SI to SC in baemoochae. Class I and II SRK were identified by PCR of the genomic DNA of baemoochae using SRK-specific universal primers. Cloning and sequencing of both classes of SRK was conducted and compared with SRK genes of parental species. Comparison analysis showed no genomic alterations and both of them showed expression in the stigma. Similarly, SP11 genes also showed no genomic alterations and normally are expressed in the anther. Other SI-related genes (MLPK, ARC1, THL) also showed normal expression in the stigma and anther. Taken together, these results revealed that no structural/gene expression change in these genes was responsible for the breakdown of SI in baemoochae. Rather, the transformation from SI parents to SC descendants could be responding to epigenetic mechanisms.     

Exploring the role of a stigma-expressed plant U-box gene in the pollination responses of transgenic self-incompatible Arabidopsis thaliana

Recognition of “self” pollen in the self-incompatibility (SI) response of the Brassicaceae is determined by allele-specific interaction between the S-locus receptor kinase (SRK), a transmembrane protein of the stigma epidermis, and its ligand, the pollen coat-localized S-locus cysteine-rich (SCR) protein. The current model for SRK-mediated signaling proposes a central role for the plant U-box (PUB) Armadillo repeat-containing protein ARC1, an E3 ligase that interacts with, and is phosphorylated by, the kinase domain of SRK. According to the model, activated ARC1 causes the degradation of factors required for successful pollen tube growth. However, Arabidopsis thaliana plants transformed with functional SRK and SCR genes isolated from self-incompatible A. lyrata can express an intense SI response despite lacking a functional ARC1 gene. Here, we tested the possibility that a different member of the A. thaliana PUB protein family might have assumed the role of ARC1 in SI. Toward this end, we analyzed the AtPUB2 gene, which is annotated as being highly expressed in stigmas. Our functional analysis of a T-DNA insertion pub2 allele, together with yeast two-hybrid interaction assays and reporter analysis of AtPUB2 promoter activity, demonstrates that AtPUB2 does not function in SI. The results leave open the question of whether the proposed model of ARC1-mediated signaling applies to transgenic SRK–SCR self-incompatible A. thaliana plants.     

Development of Self-Compatible B. rapa by RNAi-Mediated S Locus Gene Silencing

The self-incompatibility (SI) system is genetically controlled by a single polymorphic locus known as the S-locus in the Brassicaceae. Pollen rejection occurs when the stigma and pollen share the same S-haplotype. Recognition of S-haplotype specificity has recently been shown to involve at least two S-locus genes, S-receptor kinase (SRK) and S-locus protein 11 or S locus Cysteine-rich (SP11/SCR) protein. Here, we examined the function of S₆₀, one SP11/SCR allele of B. rapa cv. Osome, using a RNAi-mediated gene silencing approach. The transgenic RNAi lines were highly self-compatible, and this trait was stable in subsequent generations, even after crossing with other commercial lines. These findings also suggested that the resultant self-compatibility could be transferred to commercial cultivars with the desired performances in B. rapa.     

Nucleotide sequence analysis of <Emphasis Type="Italic">S</Emphasis>-locus genes to unify <Emphasis Type="Italic">S</Emphasis> haplotype nomenclature in radish

Radish, belonging to the family Brassicaceae, has a self-incompatibility which is controlled by multiple alleles on the S locus. To employ the self-incompatibility in an F₁ breeding system, identification of S haplotypes is necessary. Since collection of S haplotypes and determination of nucleotide sequences of SLG, SRK, and SCR alleles in cultivated radish have been conducted by different groups independently, the same or similar sequences with different S haplotype names and different sequences with the same S haplotype names have been registered in public databases, resulting in confusion of S haplotype names for researchers and breeders. In the present study, we developed S homozygous lines from radish F₁ hybrid cultivars in Japan and determined the nucleotide sequences of SCR, the S domain and the kinase domain of SRK, and the SLG of a large number of S haplotypes. Comparing these sequences with our previously published sequences, the haplotypes were ordered into 23 different S haplotypes. The sequences of the 23 S haplotypes were compared with S haplotype sequences registered by different groups, and we suggested a unification of these S haplotypes. Furthermore, dot-blot hybridization using SRK allele-specific probes was examined for developing a standard method for S haplotype identification.     

Sexual incompatibility in Rosaceae fruit tree species: molecular interactions and evolutionary dynamics

Fruit crops have a growing economic importance worldwide and molecular genetics might be useful in solving many problems that arise during commercial production. One of the fields that have attracted intense attention is the molecular basis of self-incompatibility that may result in low fruit set. In tree fruits of the Rosaceae family, the incompatibility reactions take place between the pistil S-ribonuclease (S-RNase) and the pollen-expressed S-haplotype specific F-box (SFB) proteins. In most cases, the loss of self-incompatibility was associated with mutations in the S-RNase or SFB genes. A total of 27 non-functional S-haplotypes have been identified and characterized, most (24) of which emerged as a consequence of natural mutations. In the Prunoideae, most haplotypes are pollen-part mutants (50 %), while 8 are stylar-part mutants (36 %), one haplotype shows both pollen- and stylar-part mutations, and molecular changes for two haplotypes still have not been clarified. In contrast, non-functional natural haplotypes in the Maloideae are all stylar-part mutants. The analysis of such mutants may shed light on underlying molecular mechanisms as was the case with the establishment of the general inhibitor model that describes interactions between pollen and pistil S-proteins. However, several other molecules were supposed to contribute to the molecular interactions, at least in Solanaceae, a family with a similar self-incompatibility system. This review also endeavours to delineate the evolutionary implications of the S-locus mutations and collect limited data on non-S-locus molecular interactions and signaling events after self- and cross-pollination of fruit tree species.