Comparison of two serologically distinct ribonucleic acid bacteriophages. I. Properties of the viral particles

Overby, L. R. (University of Illinois, Urbana), G. H. Barlow, R. H. Doi, Monique Jacob, and S. Spiegelman. Comparison of two serologically distinct ribonucleic acid bacteriophages. I. Properties of the viral particle. J. Bacteriol. 91:442-448. 1966.-Two ribonucleic acid (RNA) coliphages, MS-2 and Qbeta, have been characterized physically and serologically. MS-2 has an S(20, w) value of 79, a molecular weight of 3.6 x 10(6), a density of 1.422, and pH 3.9 as its isoelectric point. Qbeta has an S(20, w) of 84, a molecular weight of 4.2 x 10(6), a density of 1.439, and an isoelectric point at pH 5.3. One host (Escherichia coli A-19) permits a distinction between the two on the basis of a marked difference in plaque size. They are distinct immunochemically, no serological cross-reaction being detectable.     

Physical, Biochemical, and Immunological Properties of Coliphage MS-2 Particles

H (heavy) and L (light) MS-2 particles differ in density, absorption spectrum, and infectivity. Studies on their sedimentation, ribonucleic acid (RNA) content and infectivity, appearance under the electron microscope, ribonuclease sensitivity, and A-protein content failed to demonstrate any difference between the two particle types. Studies on the size, RNA content, and density of the capsid and two smaller coat protein components were also conducted. The antigenic relatedness of five different viral and subviral particles of MS-2 were studied by using immunodiffusion and neutralization. Capsids and the H and L viral particles were shown to be antigenically related, whereas the coat protein monomers and dimers were shown to be unrelated to the higher-molecular-weight particles.     

Recognition of diverse RNAs by a single protein structural framework

The coat proteins of different single-strand RNA phages utilize a common structural framework to recognize different RNA targets, making them suitable models for studies of RNA-protein recognition generally, especially for the class of proteins that bind RNA on a beta-sheet surface. Here we show that structurally distinct molecules are capable of satisfying the requirements for binding to Qbeta coat protein. Although the predicted secondary structures of the RNAs differ markedly, we contend that they are approximately equivalent structurally in their complexes with coat protein. Based on our prior observations that the RNA-binding specificities of Qbeta and MS2 coat proteins can be interconverted with as few as one amino acid substitution each, and taking into account details of the structures of complexes of MS2 coat protein with wild-type and aptamer RNAs, we propose a model for the Qbeta coat protein-RNA complex.     

Polysomal Localization of R17 Bacteriophage-Specific Protein Synthesis

Synthesis of viral ribonucleic acid (RNA) polymerase, maturation protein, and coat protein in Escherichia coli infected with bacteriophage R17 occurs mainly on polysomes containing four or more ribosomes. The 30S ribosomal subunits through trimer-size polysomes, which are associated with all of the R17-specific proteins and are predominant in the infected cell, synthesize only coat protein. These structures may accumulate as products derived from larger polysomes as a result of failure in the release of nascent polypeptides after termination of chain growth. Appreciable amounts of viral coat protein remain attached to ribosomes and polysomes during R17 bacteriophage replication, supporting the hypothesis of the repressor role of this protein. The time course of synthesis of virus-specific proteins obtained from the polysomes of infected cells demonstrated regulated R17 messenger RNA translation consistent with the idea that coat protein is preferentially synthesized whereas the synthesis of noncoat proteins is suppressed.     

Refined molecular weights for phage, viral and ribosomal RNA.

The RNAs of the Escherichia coli bacteriophages MS2 and Qbeta as well as E. coli 16S ribosomal RNA were examined under identical conditions by electron microscopy using the protein-free benzyldimethylalkylammonium chloride (BAC) spreading technique. From the contour length ratios of the RNAs and the known number of nucleotides for MS2, the chain lengths for Qbeta RNA and 16S RNA were found to be 4790 +/- 150 and 1645 +/- 55 nucleotides. Correcting for the base composition of Qbeta RNA the molecular weight of the Na salt of this RNA is (1.64 +/- 0.06) . 10(6) daltons. Since published values on the relative lengths of Qbeta RNA and several other homogeneous RNAs (E. coli 23S rRNA, E. Coli bacteriophage R17 and f2 RNAs, Pseudomonas aeruginosa phage PP7 RNA and Newcastle disease virus RNA) are available, we are able to calculate the approximate number of nucleotides for these useful standards.     

Properties of Caulobacter Ribonucleic Acid Bacteriophage φCb5

The ribonucleic acid (RNA) bacteriophage phiCb5, which specifically infects only one form of the dimorphic stalked bacterium Caulobacter crescentus, has been obtained in high yield. Since the phage is extremely salt-sensitive, a purification procedure was devised which avoided contact with solutions of high ionic strength. Phage phiCb5 was studied with respect to the physical and chemical properties of both the phage and its RNA. In an electron microscope, the phage particles appear as small polyhedra, 23 nm in diameter. The phage is similar to the Escherichia coli RNA phages in that it (i) sediments at an S(20, w) of 70.6S, (ii) is composed of a single molecule of single-stranded RNA and a protein coat, (iii) contains two structural proteins, and (iv) apparently contains the genetic capacity to code for a coat protein subunit, a maturation-like protein, and an RNA polymerase. Phage phiCb5 differs from the E. coli RNA phages in (i) host specificity, (ii) salt sensitivity, and (iii) the presence of histidine, but not methionine, in the coat protein.     

Analysis of six new genes encoding lysis proteins and coat proteins in Escherichia coli group A RNA phages

Group A RNA phages consist of four genes-maturation protein, coat protein, lysis protein and replicase genes. We analyzed six plasmids containing lysis protein genes and coat protein genes of Escherichia coli group A RNA phages and compared their amino acid sequences with the known proteins of E. coli(group A), Pseudomonas aeruginosa(PP7) RNA phages and Rg-lysis protein from Qbeta phage. The size of lysis proteins was different by the groups but the coat proteins were almost the same size among phages. The phylogenetic analysis shows that the sub-groups A-I and A-II of E. coli RNA phages were clearly dispersed into two clusters.     

Properties of the ribonucleic acid bacteriophage ZIK/1 coat protein and its synthesis in an Escherichia coli cell-free system

The coat protein subunit of the RNA bacteriophage ZIK/1 has a molecular weight of 12100 and does not contain histidine, methionine and cysteine. The amino acid composition of the coat protein is different from that of other RNA bacteriophage coat proteins. Bacteriophage ZIK/1 belongs to a class of RNA bacteriophages distinct from the f2 type, which lack histidine in their coat proteins, and the Qβ type, which lack histidine and methionine. Bacteriophage ZIK/1 RNA is an efficient template in the Escherichia coli cell-free system producing coat protein as the major product and a number of non-coat proteins. This result is similar to that obtained with RNA from f2-type bacteriophages. It is probable that the genomes of RNA bacteriophages are structurally similar and that differences between the types of RNA bacteriophage arise from minor differences in RNA sequence.     

Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S1 recognizes two sites in bacteriophage Qbeta RNA.

As a component of bacteriophage Qbeta replicase, S1 is required both for initiation of Qbeta minus strand RNA synthesis and for translational repression, which has been traced to the ability of the enzyme to bind to an internal site in the Qbeta RNA molecule. Previously, Senear and Steitz (Senear, A. W., and Steitz, J. A. (1976) J. Biol. Chem. 251, 1902-1912) found that isolated S1 protein binds specifically to an oligonucleotide spanning residues -38 to -63 from the 3' terminus of Qbeta RNA. Here we report that S1 also interacts strongly with a second oligonucleotide in Qbeta RNA, which is derived from the region recognized by replicase just 5' to the Qbeta coat protein cistron. Both sequences exhibit pyrimidine-rich regions.     

RNA recognition site of PP7 coat protein

The coat proteins of different single-strand RNA phages use a common protein tertiary structural framework to recognize different RNA hairpins and thus offer a natural model for understanding the molecular basis of RNA-binding specificity. Here we describe the RNA structural requirements for binding to the coat protein of bacteriophage PP7, an RNA phage of Pseudomonas. Its recognition specificity differs substantially from those of the coat proteins of its previously characterized relatives such as the coliphages MS2 and Qbeta. Using designed variants of the wild-type RNA, and selection of binding-competent sequences from random RNA sequence libraries (i.e. SELEX) we find that tight binding to PP7 coat protein is favored by the existence of an 8 bp hairpin with a bulged purine on its 5' side separated by 4 bp from a 6 nt loop having the sequence Pu-U-A-G/U-G-Pu. However, another structural class possessing only some of these features is capable of binding almost as tightly.     

RNA-Dependent DNA Polymerase Activity of RNA Tumor Viruses II. Directing Influence of RNA in the Reaction

The role of ribonucleic acid (RNA) in deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) synthesis with the purified DNA polymerase from the avian myeloblastosis virus has been studied. The polymerase catalyzes the synthesis of DNA in the presence of four deoxynucleoside triphosphates, Mg(2+), and a variety of RNA templates including those isolated from avian myeloblastosis, Rous sarcoma, and Rauscher leukemia viruses; phages f2, MS2, and Qbeta; and synthetic homopolymers such as polyadenylate.polyuridylic acid. The enzyme does not initiate the synthesis of new chains but incorporates deoxynucleotides at 3' hydroxyl ends of primer strands. The product is an RNA.DNA hybrid in which the two polynucleotide components are covalently linked. Free DNA has not been detected among the products formed with the purified enzyme in vitro. The DNA synthesized with avian myeloblastosis virus RNA after alkaline hydrolysis has a sedimentation coefficient of 6 to 7S.     

The binding site for coat protein on bacteriophage Qbeta RNA.

The site of interaction of phage Qbeta coat protein with Qbeta RNA was determined by ribonuclease T1 degradation of complexes of coat protein and [32P]-RNA obtained by codialysis of the components from urea into buffer solutions. The degraded complexes were recovered by filtration through nitrocellulose filters, and bound [32P]RNA fragments were extracted and separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Fingerprinting and further sequence analysis established that the three main fragments obtained (chain lengths 88, 71 and 27 nucleotides) all consist of sequences extending from the intercistronic region to the beginning of the replicase cistron. These results suggest that in the replication of Qbeta, as in the case of R17, coat protein acts as a translational repressor by binding to the ribosomal initiation site of the replicase cistron.     

Serological Relatedness of the Ribonucleic Acid-Containing Coliphages

The serological relationship of the ribonucleic acid (RNA)-containing coliphages MS-2, M-12, R-17, f₂, β, fr, f₄, and Qβ was determined. Antisera against MS-2, R-17, f₂, fr, and Qβ neutralized the infectivity of all of these RNA phages to varying degrees. Although each phage was serologically distinct, the antisera cross-reacted with certain phages to approximately the same degree, indicating the antigenic relationship of the coat proteins of these phages. Adsorption of anti-MS-2 sera with varying concentrations of all of the phages demonstrated that these viruses contain similar yet unique antigenic determinants. It is suggested that these RNA phages are mutants of two related phages rather than of the same phage.     

Quantitative analysis of the bacteriophage Qbeta infection cycle

In this study, the infection cycle of bacteriophage Qbeta was investigated. Adsorption of bacteriophage Qbeta to Escherichia coli is explained in terms of a collision reaction, the rate constant of which was estimated to be 4x10(-10) ml/cells/min. In infected cells, approximately 130 molecules of beta-subunit and 2x10(5) molecules of coat protein were translated in 15 min. Replication of Qbeta RNA proceeded in 2 steps-an exponential phase until 20 min and a non-exponential phase after 30 min. Prior to the burst of infected cells, phage RNAs and coat proteins accumulated in the cells at an average of up to 2300 molecules and 5x10(5) molecules, respectively. An average of 90 infectious phage particles per infected cell was released during a single infection cycle up to 105 min.     

Synthesis of Black Beetle Virus Proteins in Cultured Drosophila Cells: Differential Expression of RNAs 1 and 2

Black beetle virus is an insect virus with a split genome consisting of two single-stranded, messenger-active RNA molecules with molecular weights of 1.0 x 10(6) (RNA 1) and 0.5 x 10(6) (RNA 2), respectively. Virions contained two proteins, beta with a molecular weight of 43,000 (43K) and gamma (5K), and traces of a third protein, alpha (47K). When translated in cell-free extracts of rabbit reticulocytes, RNA 1 directed the synthesis of protein A (104K), whereas RNA 2 synthesized protein alpha. The in vitro translation efficiency of the two RNAs was roughly equal. Infection of cultured Drosophila cells induced the synthesis of five new proteins: A, alpha, beta, gamma, and B (10K), detected by autoradiography of polyacrylamide gels after electrophoresis of extracts from [(35)S]methionine-labeled cultures. All but protein gamma could also be detected by staining with Coomassie brilliant blue, indicating vigorous synthesis of viral proteins. Pulse-chase experiments in infected cells revealed the disappearance of protein alpha and the coordinate appearance of proteins beta and gamma, supporting an earlier proposal that coat protein of mature virions is made by cleavage of precursor alpha. Proteins A and B were stable in such pulse-chase experiments. The three classes of virus-induced proteins, represented by A, B, and alpha, were synthesized in markedly different amounts and with different kinetics. Synthesis of proteins A and B peaked early in infection and then declined, whereas synthesis of coat protein precursor alpha peaked much later. These results suggest that RNA 1 controls early replication functions via protein A (and also possibly protein B), whereas RNA 2 controls synthesis of coat protein required later for virion assembly.     

A comparison of two phage coat protein-RNA interactions.

The interaction between the coat protein of the group I bacteriophage fr with its translational operator site is compared with the previously studied R17 interaction. The sequence of the two RNA binding sites differ by 2 of 20 nucleotides and two coat proteins by 17 of 129 amino acids. An analysis of the binding of fr coat protein to 24 operator variants revealed that the two proteins recognize operator sequences in virtually the same way. However, fr coat protein binds to nearly every RNA 6 to 14-fold tighter than R17 coat protein. Since the fr operator is a weaker binding variant and the fr coat protein shows a different temperature dependence of binding, it is unlikely that the two systems have different Kas in vivo. RNA fragments containing the operator sequences can initiate the capsid assembly with both fr and R17 coat protein. Surprisingly, the two coat proteins can form a mixed capsid in vitro.     

Translation of Virus mRNA: Synthesis of Bacteriophage Qβ Proteins in a Cell-Free Extract from Wheat Embryo

The RNA from bacteriophage Qbeta can be translated by cell-free extracts from wheat embryos. This translation, by 80S ribosomes, occurs at a low magnesium ion concentration. Three products are synthesized which coelectrophorese with Qbeta proteins synthesized in Escherichia coli extracts. The smallest of these has been identified as coat protein. Although the polycistronic bacteriophage message is translated with fidelity, the efficiency is much less than when the monocistronic brome mosaic virus coat protein message is translated.     

Translational repression and specific RNA binding by the coat protein of the Pseudomonas phage PP7

PP7 is a single-strand RNA bacteriophage of Pseudomonas aeroginosa and a distant relative to coliphages like MS2 and Qbeta. Here we show that PP7 coat protein is a specific RNA-binding protein, capable of repressing the translation of sequences fused to the translation initiation region of PP7 replicase. Its RNA binding activity is specific since it represses the translational operator of PP7, but does not repress the operators of the MS2 or Qbeta phages. Conditions for the purification of coat protein and for the reconstitution of its RNA binding activity from disaggregated virus-like particles were established. Its dissociation constant for PP7 operator RNA in vitro was determined to be about 1 nm. Using a genetic system in which coat protein represses translation of a replicase-beta-galactosidase fusion protein, amino acid residues important for binding of PP7 RNA were identified.     

Translation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa Bacteriophage PP7 RNA by a Cell-Free Amino Acid Incorporating System from Escherichia coli

We have compared the activities of the RNA genomes of Pseudomonas aeruginosa phage PP7 and coliphages Qbeta and f2 in a cell-free amino acid incorporating system derived from Escherichia coli. The rate of incorporation of [(14)C]leucine in the PP7 RNA-directed system is greater than in the systems directed by either Qbeta or f2 RNA. The response to changes in phage RNA concentrations is similar in all the systems, reaching a saturation level at 0.75 to 1.0 mg of RNA per ml of reaction mixture. Analysis of complete reaction mixtures of the PP7 RNA and of the Qbeta RNA systems by sucrose gradient centrifugation shows generally similar patterns for both RNAs. The principal differences are that in the PP7 system a slightly higher percentage of RNA forms ribosome complexes and that the polysomes are somewhat smaller. PP7 RNA is also degraded more extensively during the reaction than is Qbeta RNA. Analysis of the products of the reactions by acrylamide gel electrophoresis shows that PP7 coat protein is the only identifiable product of the PP7 RNA-directed system, suggesting that only the coat protein cistron is translated by E. coli ribosomes.     

MS2 coat protein mutants which bind Qbeta RNA.

The coat proteins of the RNA phages MS2 and Qbetaare structurally homologous, yet they specifically bind different RNA structures. In an effort to identify the basis of RNA binding specificity we sought to isolate mutants that convert MS2 coat protein to the RNA binding specificity of Qbeta. A library of mutations was created which selectively substitutes amino acids within the RNA binding site. Genetic selection for the ability to repress translation from the Qbetatranslational operator led to the isolation of several MS2 mutants that acquired binding activity for QbetaRNA. Some of these also had reduced abilities to repress translation from the MS2 translational operator. These changes in RNA binding specificity were the results of substitutions of amino acid residues 87 and 89. Additional codon- directed mutagenesis experiments confirmed earlier results showing that the identity of Asn87 is important for specific binding of MS2 RNA. Glu89, on the other hand, is not required for recognition of MS2 RNA, but prevents binding of QbetaRNA.