Expression of the Bacillus subtilis TasA signal peptide leads to cell death in Escherichia coli due to inefficient cleavage by LepB

Bacillus subtilis has five type I signal peptidases, one of these, SipW, is an archaeal-like peptidase. SipW is expressed in an operon (tapA-sipW-tasA) and is responsible for removing the signal peptide from two proteins: TapA and TasA. It is unclear from the signal peptide sequence of TasA and TapA, why an archaeal-like signal peptidase is required for their processing. Bioinformatic analysis of TasA and TapA indicates that both contain highly similar signal peptide cleavage sites, both predicted to be cleaved by Escherichia coli signal peptidase I, LepB. We show that expressing full length TasA in E. coli is toxic and leads to cell death. To determine if this phenotype is due to the inability of the E. coli LepB to process the TasA signal peptide, we fused the TasA signal peptide and two amino acids of mature TasA (up to P2′) to both maltose binding protein (MBP) and β-lactamase (Bla). We observed a defect in secretion, indicated by an abundance of unprocessed protein with both TasA-MBP and TasA-Bla fusions. A series of mutations in both TasA-MBP and TasA-Bla were made around the junction of the TasA signal peptide and the fusion protein. Both of these studies indicate that residues around the predicted TasA signal sequence cleavage site, particularly the sequence from P3 to P2′, inhibit processing by LepB. The cell death observed when TasA and TasA signal sequence fusion proteins are expressed is likely due to the TasA signal peptide blocking LepB and thereby the general secretion pathway.     

Thirty-three amino acids of the mature moiety of an unprocessed maltose-binding protein are sufficient for export in Escherichia coli.

Maltose-binding protein (MBP) is translocated across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli; successful export depends on information in both the signal peptide and the mature moiety of the protein. To determine the shortest portion of the mature region that would maintain detectable entry of MBP into the export pathway, we took advantage of the properties of an MBP species with proline substituted in the +1 position relative to the cleavage site (MBP27-P). This protein efficiently crosses the cytoplasmic membrane but is not processed and acts as a competitive inhibitor of signal peptidase I (leader peptidase). Export of MBP27-P is measured by the inhibition of processing of other proteins, such as ribose-binding protein (RBP). A series of truncated derivatives of MBP27-P were tested for the ability to inhibit processing of RBP. An MBP27-P species with only 33 amino acids of the mature moiety inhibited processing of RBP, indicating that this truncated polypeptide was probably exported and interacted with signal peptidase I.     

Artificial insertion of peptides between signal peptide and mature protein: effect on secretion and processing of hybrid thermostable alpha-amylases in Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli cells

To study the effect of inserted peptides on the secretion and processing of exported proteins in Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli, pBR322-derived DNA fragments coding for small peptides were inserted between the DNA coding for the 31 amino acid B. subtilis alpha-amylase signal peptide and that coding for the mature part of the extracellular thermostable alpha-amylase of B. stearothermophilus. Most of the inserted peptides (21 to 65 amino acids) decreased the production of the enzyme in B. subtilis and E. coli, the effect of each peptide being similar in the two strains. In contrast, with one peptide (a 21 amino acid sequence encoded by the extra DNA in pTUBE638), the production of alpha-amylase was enhanced more than 1.7-fold in B. subtilis in comparison with that of the parent strain. The molecular masses of the thermostable alpha-amylases in the periplasm of the E. coli transformants varied for each peptide insert, whereas those in the culture supernatants of the B. subtilis transformants had molecular masses similar to that of the mature enzyme. Based on the NH2-terminal amino acid sequence of the hybrid protein from pTUBE638, it was shown that in E. coli, the NH2-terminally extended thermostable alpha-amylase was translocated and remained in the periplasm after the 31 amino acid signal sequence was removed. In the case of B. subtilis, after the removal of a 34-amino acid signal sequence, the hybrid protein was secreted and processed to the mature form.     

Export of unprocessed precursor maltose-binding protein to the periplasm of Escherichia coli cells.

The Escherichia coli maltose-binding protein (MBP) R2 signal peptide is a truncated version of the wild-type structure that still facilitates very efficient export of MBP to the periplasm. Among single amino acid substitutions in the R2 signal peptide resulting in an export-defective precursor MBP (pMBP) were two that replaced residues in the consensus Ala-X-Ala sequence (residues -3 to -1) that immediately precedes the cleavage site. It was suggested that the functional hydrophobic core and signal peptidase recognition sequence of this signal peptide substantially overlap and that these two alterations affect both pMBP translocation and processing. In this study, the export of pMBP by the mutants, designated CC15 and CC17, with these two alterations was investigated further. The pMBP of mutant CC17 has an Arg substituted for Leu at the -2 position. It was found that CC17 cells exported only a very small amount of MBP, but that which was exported appeared to be correctly processed. This result was consistent with other studies that have concluded that virtually any amino acid can occupy the -2 position. For mutant CC15, which exhibits a fully Mal+ phenotype, an Asp is substituted for the Ala at the -3 position. CC15 cells were found to export large quantities of unprocessed, soluble pMBP to the periplasm, although such export was achieved in a relatively slow, posttranslational manner. This result was also consistent with other studies that suggested that charged residues are normally excluded from the -3 position of the cleavage site. Using in vitro oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis, we constructed a new signal sequence mutant in which Asp was substituted for Arg at the -3 position of an otherwise wild-type MBP signal peptide. This alteration had no apparent effect on pMBP translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane, but processing by signal peptidase was inhibited. This pMBP species with its full-length hydrophobic core remained anchored to the membrane, where it could still participate in maltose uptake. The implications of these results for models of protein export are discussed.     

SecB-independent export of Escherichia coli ribose-binding protein (RBP): some comparisons with export of maltose-binding protein (MBP) and studies with RBP-MBP hybrid proteins.

The efficient export of the Escherichia coli maltose-binding protein (MBP) is known to be SecB dependent, whereas ribose-binding protein (RBP) export is SecB independent. When the MBP and RBP signal peptides were exchanged precisely at the signal peptidase processing sites, the resultant RBP-MBP and MBP-RBP hybrid proteins both were efficiently exported in SecB+ cells. However, only MBP-RBP was efficiently exported in SecB- cells; RBP-MBP exhibited a significant export defect, a finding that was consistent with previous proposals that SecB specifically interacts with the mature moiety of precursor MBP to promote export. The relatively slow, totally posttranslational export mode exhibited by certain mutant RBP and MBP-RBP species in SecB+ cells was not affected by the loss of SecB. In contrast, MBP and RBP-MBP species with similarly altered signal peptides were totally export defective in SecB- cells. Both export-defective MBP and RBP-MBP interfered with SecB-mediated protein export by depleting cells of functional SecB. In contrast, neither export-defective RBP nor MBP-RBP elicited such an interference effect. These and other data indicated that SecB is unable to interact with precursor RBP or that any interaction between these two proteins is considerably weaker than that of SecB with precursor MBP. In addition, no correlation could be established between a SecB requirement for export and PrlA-mediated suppression of signal peptide export defects. Finally, previous studies have established that wild-type MBP export can be accomplished cotranslationally, whereas wild-type RBP export is strictly a posttranslational process. In this study, cotranslational export was not detected for either MBP-RBP or RBP-MBP. This indicates that the export mode exhibited by a given precursor protein (cotranslational versus posttranslational) is determined by properties of both the signal peptide and the mature moiety.     

Proteolytic processing of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Escherichia coli</Emphasis> twin-arginine signal peptides by LepB

The twin-arginine translocation (Tat) apparatus is a protein targeting system found in the cytoplasmic membranes of many prokaryotes. Substrate proteins of the Tat pathway are synthesised with signal peptides bearing SRRxFLK ‘twin-arginine’ amino acid motifs. All Tat signal peptides have a common tripartite structure comprising a polar N-terminal region, followed by a hydrophobic region of variable length and a polar C-terminal region. In Escherichia coli, Tat signal peptides are proteolytically cleaved after translocation. The signal peptide C-terminal regions contain conserved AxA motifs, which are possible recognition sequences for leader peptidase I (LepB). In this work, the role of LepB in Tat signal peptide processing was addressed directly. Deliberate repression of lepB expression prevented processing of all Tat substrates tested, including SufI, AmiC, and a TorA-23K reporter protein. In addition, electron microscopy revealed gross defects in cell architecture and membrane integrity following depletion of cellular LepB protein levels.     

Export pathway selectivity of Escherichia coli twin arginine translocation signal peptides

The Escherichia coli genome encodes at least 29 putative signal peptides containing a twin arginine motif characteristic of proteins exported via the twin arginine translocation (Tat) pathway. Fusions of the putative Tat signal peptides plus six to eight amino acids of the mature proteins to three reporter proteins (short-lived green fluorescent protein, maltose-binding protein (MBP), and alkaline phosphatase) and also data from the cell localization of epitope-tagged full-length proteins were employed to determine the ability of the 29 signal peptides to direct export through the Tat pathway, through the general secretory pathway (Sec), or through both. 27/29 putative signal peptides could export one or more reporter proteins through Tat. Of these, 11 signal peptides displayed Tat specificity in that they could not direct the export of Sec-only reporter proteins. The rest (16/27) were promiscuous and were capable of directing export of the appropriate reporter either via Tat (green fluorescent protein, MBP) or via Sec (PhoA, MBP). Mutations that conferred a >or=+1 charge to the N terminus of the mature protein abolished or drastically reduced routing through the Sec pathway without affecting the ability to export via the Tat pathway. These experiments demonstrate that the charge of the mature protein N terminus affects export promiscuity, independent of the effect of the folding state of the mature protein.     

Maturation of Escherichia coli maltose-binding protein by signal peptidase I in vivo. Sequence requirements for efficient processing and demonstration of an alternate cleavage site

Comparative analyses of a number of secretory proteins processed by eukaryotic and prokaryotic signal peptidases have identified a strongly conserved feature regarding the residues positioned -3 and -1 relative to the cleavage site. These 2 residues of the signal peptide are thought to constitute a recognition site for the processing enzyme and are usually amino acids with small, neutral side chains. It was shown previously that the substitution of aspartic acid for alanine at -3 of the Escherichia coli maltose-binding protein (MBP) signal peptide blocked maturation by signal peptidase I but had no noticeable effect or MBP translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane of its biological activity. This identified an excellent system in which to undertake a detailed investigation of the structural requirements and limitations for the cleavage site. In vitro mutagenesis was used to generate 14 different amino acid substitutions at -3 and 13 different amino acid substitutions at -1 of the MBP signal peptide. The maturation of the mutant precursor species expressed in vivo was examined. Overall, the results obtained agreed fairly well with statistically derived models of signal peptidase I specificity, except that cysteine was found to permit efficient processing when present at either -3 and -1, and threonine at -1 resulted in inefficient processing. Interestingly, it was found that substitutions at -1 which blocked processing at the normal cleavage site redirected processing, with varying efficiencies, to an alternate site in the signal peptide represented by the Ala-X-Ala sequence at positions -5 to -3. The substitution of aspartic acid for alanine at -5 blocked processing at this alternate site but not the normal site. The amino acids occupying the -5 and -3 positions in many other prokaryotic signal peptides also have the potential for constituting alternate processing sites. This appears to represent another example of redundant information contained within the signal peptide.     

A second lysine-specific serine protease from Lysobacter sp. strain IB-9374

A second lysyl endopeptidase gene (lepB) was found immediately upstream of the previously isolated lepA gene encoding a highly active lysyl endopeptidase in Lysobacter genomic DNA. The lepB gene consists of 2,034 nucleotides coding for a protein of 678 amino acids. Amino acid sequence alignment between the lepA and lepB gene products (LepA and LepB) revealed that the LepB precursor protein is composed of a prepeptide (20 amino acids [aa]), a propeptide (184 aa), a mature enzyme (274 aa), and a C-terminal extension peptide (200 aa). The mature enzyme region exhibited 72% sequence identity to its LepA counterpart and conserved all essential amino acids constituting the catalytic triad and the primary determining site for lysine specificity. The lepB gene encoding the propeptide and mature-enzyme portions was overexpressed in Escherichia coli, and the inclusion body produced generated active LepB through appropriate refolding and processing. The purified enzyme, a mature 274-aa lysine-specific endopeptidase, was less active and more sensitive to both temperature and denaturation with urea, guanidine hydrochloride, or sodium dodecyl sulfate than LepA. LepA-based modeling implies that LepB can fold into essentially the same three-dimensional structure as LepA by placing a peptide segment, composed of several inserted amino acids found only in LepB, outside the molecule and that the Tyr169 side chain occupies the site in which the indole ring of Trp169, a built-in modulator for unique peptidase functions of LepA, resides. The results suggest that LepB is an isozyme of LepA and probably has a tertiary structure quite similar to it.     

Export and processing of MalE-LacZ hybrid proteins in Escherichia coli

Five classes of MalE-LacZ hybrid proteins have previously been characterized. These proteins differ in the amount of the maltose-binding protein (MBP) that is attached to beta-galactosidase. Although none of these proteins is secreted into the periplasm, the four larger classes of hybrid proteins, those that include an intact MBP signal peptide, are inserted into the cytoplasmic membrane, suggesting that the secretion process has at least been initiated. In this study, we demonstrated that some portion of the four larger hybrid proteins can be translocated across the cytoplasmic membrane, thus permitting processing of the signal peptide. We have found that hybrid proteins that include only a small portion of the mature MBP are inefficiently recognized as exported proteins, and translocation and processing of these appear to be relatively slow, posttranslational events. In marked contrast, hybrid proteins that include a substantial portion of the mature MBP are efficiently recognized, and translocation and processing of these occur very rapidly, possibly cotranslationally. Our results complement other studies and very strongly suggest a role for the mature MBP in the export process.     

Peptide products of the cleavage of bovine preprolactin by signal peptidase

Cleavage of preprolactin (pPL) by detergent-solubilized signal peptidase produced mature prolactin and two small peptides derived from the signal peptide region of the pPL molecule. The production of both peptides was dependent on functional signal peptidase; the peptides were not generated at detergent concentrations that abolished signal peptidase activity. The amount of both peptides was proportional to the concentration of signal peptidase in the assay. The appearance of both peptides was insensitive to protease inhibitors, as was signal peptidase activity. The size, labeling characteristics, and amino acid sequence of the larger peptide, peptide 1, corresponded to those of the intact signal peptide of pPL. The smaller peptide, peptide 2, lacked the carboxy terminus of the signal peptide, and was, therefore, a fragment of intact signal peptide. These results demonstrate the endoproteolytic nature of signal peptidase.     

The role of signal sequence proximal residues in the mature region of bacterial secreted proteins in E. coli

Secreted proteins contain an N-terminal signal peptide to guide them through the secretion pathway. Once the protein is translocated, the signal peptide is removed by a signal peptidase, such as signal peptidase I. The signal peptide has been extensively studied and reviewed; however, the mature region has not been the focus of review. Here we cover the experimental evidence that highlights the important role of the mature region amino acid residues in both the efficiency and the ability of secreted proteins to be successfully exported via secretion pathways and cleaved by signal peptidase I.     

Synthesis of precursor maltose-binding protein with proline in the +1 position of the cleavage site interferes with the activity of Escherichia coli signal peptidase I in vivo.

The residues occupying the -3 and -1 positions relative to the cleavage site of secretory precursor proteins are usually amino acids with small, neutral side chains that are thought to constitute the recognition site for the processing enzyme, signal peptidase. No restrictions have been established for residues positioned +1 to the cleavage site, although there have been several indications that mutant precursor proteins with a proline at +1 cannot be processed by Escherichia coli signal peptidase I (also called leader peptidase). A maltose-binding protein (MBP) species with proline at +1, designated MBP27-P, was translocated efficiently but not processed when expressed in E. coli cells. Unexpectedly, induced expression of MBP27-P was found to have an adverse effect on the processing kinetics of five different nonlipoprotein precursors analyzed, but not precursor Lpp (the major outer membrane lipoprotein) processed by a different enzyme, signal peptidase II. Cell growth also was inhibited following induction of MBP27-P synthesis. Substitutions in the MBP27-P signal peptide that blocked MBP translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane and, hence, access to the processing enzyme or that altered the signal peptidase I recognition site at position -1 restored both normal growth and processing of other precursors. Since overproduction of signal peptidase I also restored normal growth and processing to cells expressing unaltered MBP27-P, it was concluded that precursor MBP27-P interferes with the activity of the processing enzyme, probably by competing as a noncleavable substrate for the enzyme's active site. Thus, although signal peptidase I, like many other proteases, is unable to cleave an X-Pro bond, a proline at +1 does not prevent the enzyme from recognizing the normal processing site. When the RBP signal peptide was substituted for the MBP signal peptide of MBP27-P, the resultant hybrid protein was processed somewhat inefficiently at an alternate cleavage site and elicited a much reduced effect on cell growth and signal peptidase I activity. Although the MBP signal peptide also has an alternate cleavage site, the different properties of the RBP and MBP signal peptides with regard to the substitution of proline at +1 may be related to their respective secondary structures in the processing site region.     

Secretion of interleukin-1 beta and Escherichia coli galactokinase by Streptomyces lividans.

The functionality of the Streptomyces lividans beta-galactosidase signal peptide to direct heterologous protein export was examined. The signal peptide plus eight amino acids of mature protein were sufficient to export not only a naturally exported protein, interleukin-1 beta, but also a naturally occurring cytoplasmic protein, Escherichia coli galactokinase. Interestingly, cells which expressed yet exported galactokinase were phenotypically Gal-. The potential use of the exported galactokinase system for the isolation and characterization of mutations within signal peptides and the export machinery of the host is discussed.     

Type I signal peptidases of Gram-positive bacteria

Proteins that are exported from the cytoplasm to the periplasm and outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria, or the cell wall and growth medium of Gram-positive bacteria, are generally synthesized as precursors with a cleavable signal peptide. During or shortly after pre-protein translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane, the signal peptide is removed by signal peptidases. Importantly, pre-protein processing by signal peptidases is essential for bacterial growth and viability. This review is focused on the signal peptidases of Gram-positive bacteria, Bacillus and Streptomyces species in particular. Evolutionary concepts, current knowledge of the catalytic mechanism, substrate specificity requirements and structural aspects are addressed. As major insights in signal peptidase function and structure have been obtained from studies on the signal peptidase LepB of Escherichia coli, similarities and differences between this enzyme and known Gram-positive signal peptidases are highlighted. Notably, while the incentive for previous research on Gram-positive signal peptidases was largely based on their role in the biotechnologically important process of protein secretion, present-day interest in these essential enzymes is primarily derived from the idea that they may serve as targets for novel anti-microbials.     

Intragenic suppressor mutations that restore export of maltose binding protein with a truncated signal peptide

A deletion mutation, malE delta 12-18, removes seven residues from the hydrophobic core of the maltose binding protein (MBP) signal peptide and thus prevents secretion of this protein to the periplasm of E. coli. Intragenic suppressor mutations of malE delta 12-18 have been obtained, some highly efficient in their ability to restore proper MBP export. Twelve independently isolated suppressors represent six unique mutational events. Five result in alterations within the MBP signal peptide; one changes the amino acid at residue 19 of the mature MBP. Analysis of these suppressors indicates that the length of the hydrophobic core is a major determinant of signal peptide function. The experiments further suggest that the hydrophobic core region serves primarily a structural role in mediating protein secretion, and that other sequences outside of this region may be responsible for providing the initial recognition of the MBP nascent chain as a secreted protein.     

Defective Escherichia coli signal peptides function in yeast

To investigate structural characteristics important for eukaryotic signal peptide function in vivo, a hybrid gene with interchangeable signal peptides was cloned into yeast. The hybrid gene encoded nine residues from the amino terminus of the major Escherichia coli lipoprotein, attached to the amino terminus of the entire mature E. coli beta-lactamase sequence. To this sequence were attached sequences encoding the nonmutant E. coli lipoprotein signal peptide, or lipoprotein signal peptide mutants lacking an amino-terminal cationic charge, with shortened hydrophobic core, with altered potential helicity, or with an altered signal-peptide cleavage site. These signal-peptide mutants exhibited altered processing and secretion in E. coli. Using the GAL10 promoter, production of all hybrid proteins was induced to constitute 4-5% of the total yeast protein. Hybrid proteins with mutant signal peptides that show altered processing and secretion in E. coli, were processed and translocated to a similar degree as the non-mutant hybrid protein in yeast (approximately 36% of the total hybrid protein). Both non-mutant and mutant signal peptides appeared to be removed at the same unique site between cysteine 21 and serine 22, one residue from the E. coli signal peptidase II processing site. The mature lipo-beta-lactamase was translocated across the cytoplasmic membrane into the yeast periplasm. Thus the protein secretion apparatus in yeast recognizes the lipoprotein signal sequence in vivo but displays a specificity towards altered signal sequences which differs from that of E. coli.     

Two regions of mature periplasmic maltose-binding protein of Escherichia coli involved in secretion.

Six mutations in malE, the structural gene for the periplasmic maltose-binding protein (MBP) from Escherichia coli, prevent growth on maltose as a carbon source, as well as release of the mutant proteins by the cold osmotic-shock procedure. These mutations correspond to insertion of an oligonucleotide linker, concomitant with a deletion. One of the mutations (malE127) affects the N-terminal extension (the signal peptide), whereas the five others lie within the mature protein. As expected, the export of protein MalE127 is blocked at an early stage. This protein is neither processed to maturity nor sensitive to proteinase K in spheroplasts. In contrast, in the five other mutants, the signal peptide is cleaved and the protein is accessible to proteinase K added to spheroplasts. This indicates that the five mutant proteins are, at least in part, exported through the inner membrane. We propose that the corresponding mutations define two regions of the mature protein (between residues 18 and 42 and between residues 280 and 306), which are important for release of the protein from the inner membrane into the periplasm. We discuss the results in terms of possible conformational changes at this late step of export to the periplasm.     

Mutational alterations affecting the export competence of a truncated but fully functional maltose-binding protein signal peptide.

The wild-type maltose-binding protein (MBP) signal peptide is 26 amino acids in length. A mutationally altered MBP signal peptide has been previously described that is missing one of the basic residues from the hydrophilic segment and seven residues from the hydrophobic core; however, it still facilitates MBP secretion to the periplasm at a rate and efficiency comparable to those of the wild-type structure. Thus, this truncated signal peptide (designated the R2 signal peptide) must retain all of the essential features required for proper export function. In this study, alterations were obtained in the R2 signal peptide that resulted in an export-defective MBP. For the first time, signal sequence mutations were obtained that resulted in the synthesis of a totally export-defective MBP. As was previously the case for the wild-type signal peptide, the introduction of either charged residues or helix-breaking proline residues adversely affected export function. Despite these similarities, the position of these alterations within the R2 signal peptide, their relative effects on MBP secretion and processing, and an analysis of the ability of various extragenic prl mutations to suppress the secretion defects provide additional insight into the minimal requirements for a functional MBP signal peptide.     

Sec-Mediated Transport of Posttranslationally Dehydrated Peptides in Lactococcus lactis

Nisin is a lanthionine-containing antimicrobial peptide produced by Lactococcus lactis. Its (methyl)lanthionines are introduced by two posttranslational enzymatic steps involving the dehydratase NisB, which dehydrates serine and threonine residues, and the cyclase NisC, which couples these dehydrated residues to cysteines, yielding thioether-bridged amino acids called lanthionines. The prenisin is subsequently exported by the ABC transporter NisT and extracellularly processed by the peptidase NisP. L. lactis expressing the nisBTC genes can modify and secrete a wide range of nonlantibiotic peptides. Here we demonstrate that in the absence of NisT and NisC, the Sec pathway of L. lactis can be exploited for the secretion of dehydrated variants of therapeutic peptides. Furthermore, posttranslational modifications by NisB and NisC still occur even when the nisin leader is preceded by a Sec signal peptide or a Tat signal peptide 27 or 44 amino acids long, respectively. However, transport of fully modified prenisin via the Sec pathway is impaired. The extent of NisB-mediated dehydration could be improved by raising the intracellular concentration NisB or by modulating the export efficiency through altering the signal sequence. These data demonstrate that besides the traditional lantibiotic transporter NisT, the Sec pathway with an established broad substrate range can be utilized for the improved export of lantibiotic enzyme-modified (poly)peptides.