Diagnostic problems of cancer of the lung

There are three techniques of primary significance to the diagnostic problems of cancer of the lung. Roentgenologic evidence is suggestive but not conclusive unless confirmed by other means. Because pulmonary cancer masquerades, morphologic proof is needed. In some cases bronchoscopy can provide proof, but its usefulness is limited to lesions in the major bronchi. For the third technique, cytologic study, to be effective, apparently it is necessary only that there be a free passageway between the trachea and the tumor body. Cytologic studies were carried out in 2,066 cases of all types of diseases of the chest. In 241 of these cases bronchogenic carcinoma was proved by one means or another; the presence of cancer was diagnosed by cytologic methods in 55 per cent of the 241 cases. When five specimens of sputum from each patient were examined, the efficiency of the technique rose to 90 per cent. Wider application of this simple and relatively inexpensive technique may greatly aid in the solution of diagnostic problems of pulmonary cancer.     

Ten years of respiratory cytopathology at Duke University Medical Center. II. The cytopathologic diagnosis of lung cancer during the years 1970 to 1974, with a comparison between cytopathology and histopathology in the typing of lung cancer

In 1975 Duke University Medical Center, a retrospective and prospective survey of respiratory cytopathologic specimens was undertaken for the ten-year period 1970 to 1979. The purpose of this study was to document the role of cytopathology in the diagnosis of lung cancer at this institution. This paper presents the results of the cytopathologic and histopathologic typing of cases of lung cancer seen at Duke University Medical Center from 1970 to 1974. During this period, 9,892 cytologic specimens from the lower respiratory tract were processed. Cytopathologic diagnoses of cancer with tissue confirmation were made on 483 specimens from 232 patients. Because original cytologic diagnoses, but not histopathologic diagnoses, had been made in conformity with a modified WHO classification of lung neoplasms, all histopathologic material was reviewed and reclassified when necessary. This was carried out by one of the authors (E.H.B.) as a blind review without benefit of knowledge of either preexisting cytopathologic or histopathologic diagnoses. Twenty-six patients were excluded from the current study because of lack of satisfactory histologic material. In 94 patients classified by histopathology as having squamous cell carcinoma, 76.4% of the positive cytologic specimens were also called squamous cell carcinoma; 18.6% were interpreted as large cell undifferentiated carcinoma. In 39 patients classified by tissue as having large cell undifferentiated carcinoma, the cytology agreed in 42.4% of the positive specimens. For the 29 patients thought histologically to have small cell undifferentiated carcinoma, the same diagnosis was rendered in 95.5% of the cytologically positive specimens from these patients. For the adenocarcinoma group of 43 patients, a cytopathologic diagnosis of adenocarcinoma was made in 67.8% of the positive specimens.     

Reliability of cytologic typing of lung cancer.

In a prospective study of 111 cases of lung cancer, cytopathologic diagnoses were compared with histologic diagnoses. In 77.5 per cent of the cases, histopathologic diagnoses were in concurrence with cytopathologic diagnoses. The discrepancies occurred mainly in poorly differentiated adeno and epidermoid carcinoma. Well differentiated adeno and epidermoid carcinoma were cell typed with 100 per cent accuracy and small cell carcinoma with 90 per cent accuracy.     

Diagnosis and typing of lung carcinomas by cytopathologic methods. A review of 108 cases

A correlative review was made of the type of cytology specimens (sputum, bronchial washing and bronchial brushing) together with the corresponding histopathologic specimens of 108 patients. One hundred patients had primary pulmonary carcinomas diagnosed histopathologically (84) or clinically (16); 5 had carcinomas metastatic to the lungs and 3 had apparently false-positive cytologic results for lung cancer. The correlative review was used to determine the diagnostic reliability of pulmonary cytopathologic techniques in the detection and classification of lung carcinomas (i.e., the sensitivity and accuracy). The overall sensitivities of sputum, bronchial washing and bronchial brushing cytology were 60%, 66% and 77%, respectively (p less than 0.05). Bronchial brushing had a higher sensitivity (80%) for peripheral and metastatic lesions than did sputum (37%) or bronchial washing (60%). The overall accuracies of sputum, bronchial washing and bronchial brushing cytology were 79%, 75% and 76%, respectively, which is not statistically different. Regardless of the sampling methods, cytologic typing of squamous-cell and small-cell carcinomas was highly accurate but was less satisfactory for the other types of lung carcinomas. In the 16 cases in which endoscopic biopsies were either not attempted or gave negative results, one or more pulmonary cytologic specimens showed malignant cells. It is concluded that: (1) pulmonary cytopathologic techniques have excellent sensitivity and accuracy in the diagnosis of lung carcinomas; (2) they may establish the diagnosis of pulmonary carcinomas when endoscopic biopsies give negative results; and (3) they are particularly helpful in cases in which endoscopic biopsies suffer from a low yield (peripheral lesions) or create a considerable danger to the patients (iatrogenic hemorrhage).     

Relationship between the cellular composition of sputum and the cytologic diagnosis of lung cancer

In 410 patients with either a primary or a metastatic malignant lung process, the cellular composition of the sputum specimens was analyzed in relation to the diagnostic accuracy of sputum cytology and in relation to anamnestic and clinical patient characteristics. In patients with primary lung cancer, sputum samples with true-positive cytologic diagnoses contained significantly more cells from the deeper airways, such as alveolar macrophages and bronchial columnar cells, than did sputum specimens with a false-negative diagnosis, even though these cell types were present in both types of specimens. In sputum samples from patients with metastatic lung malignancies, differences in cellular composition of specimens with true-positive and false-negative diagnoses were not significant.     

Efficacy and pattern of use of sputum cytology as a diagnostic test

Sputum cytology is regarded by many clinicians as a noninvasive, cheap and simple test for the diagnosis of bronchogenic carcinoma. Since the introduction of fibre-optic bronchoscopy and more easily obtained bronchial biopsies reliance on sputum cytology has diminished. However, in Edinburgh it was perceived that sputum samples were still being sent as well as, rather than instead of, bronchoscopic specimens. This retrospective study was undertaken to determine whether or not cytological examination of sputum is an efficient and sensitive test in the investigation of patients with suspected bronchogenic carcinoma. It demonstrated that the Lothian University Hospitals NHS Trust Pathology Directorate receives many sputa from departments not specializing in respiratory disease when there is no indication for the test. In addition, we have shown that the absolute sensitivity of the test is only 5% and that when there is a strong clinical suspicion of bronchogenic carcinoma the results of sputum cytology do not play a significant role in the management of the patient. We recommend that sputum cytology is restricted to those patients under the care of Respiratory Units in whom bronchoscopy is inappropriate or unsuccessful.     

The diagnostic reliability of cytologic typing in primary lung cancer with a review of the literature

To evaluate the growing tendency in recent years to attribute more diagnostic reliability to cytologic methods, we investigated the accuracy of cytologic typing in specimens obtained from bronchopulmonary material by five different clinical sampling methods, comparing the cytologic diagnoses with the known histologic diagnoses. The study consisted of 232 cytologic specimens from 157 cases of primary lung cancer. Of the 232 specimens, 173 (75%) were correctly typed and 59 (25%) incorrectly typed with respect to the appropriate histologic diagnoses. When all sampling methods were considered together, the study demonstrated that well-differentiated epidermoid carcinoma and "oat cell" and spindle-polygonal anaplastic carcinomas yielded high cytologic typing accuracies. In poorly differentiated tumors, bronchioloalveolar cell carcinoma and bronchogenic adenocarcinoma, the correct cytologic typing was much lower. The different tumor types and their degrees of differentiation seem to be the decisive factors in cytologic typing accuracy. The findings of this study were compared with those of others and were found to be consistent with the results of even larger series of cases. For some types the typing accuracy was higher than that reported in other series, whereas for other types, e.g., adenocarcinomas, it was lower.     

Lung Cancer—Improved Cytologic Detection by Inducing Production of Sputum

The principle of producing bronchial lavage by deposition of large amounts of heated aerosol has resulted in a significantly greater yield of positive cytologic diagnosis of bronchogenic carcinoma than with repeated “volunteer” specimens of sputum. Positive pressure plus bronchodilators augments greater sputum volume.Using this technique, cases in which results of bronchoscopy and aspiration biopsy were negative for malignant change, were diagnosed cytologically.Application of this technique can sometimes detect early lung carcinoma before roentgenographic changes are detectable. Positive tests in clinically far advanced disease may prevent unnecessary surgical intervention.The simplicity of the technique, the freedom from adverse reactions, and its wide acceptance by the subjects tested, make it valuable in the diagnosis of lung cancer.     

Sputum cytology of metastatic carcinoma of the lung.

The cytopathology of 47 cases of metastatic carcinoma of the lung and of 28 cases of recurrent or metastatic bronchogenic carcinoma is reviewed. The diagnostic yield was better for recurrent than for metastatic carcinoma but overall was comparable to that of primary bronchogenic carcinomas. The metastatic tumors were located in all areas of the lung and included single as well as multiple lesions. The positive yield did not differ significantly in relation to any of the pathologic features but was somewhat higher if the metastases were large and centrally located. A definite differentiation of the metastatic tumors, usually adenocarcinomas, from new primary bronchogenic carcinomas is often possible particularly if the cytopathology can be compared with that of the primary lesion. Specific cytologic features include the relative lack of cohesion and the formation of columns in metastatic breast carcinomas, the formation of larger cohesive well circumscribed nodules composed of tall columnar cells in metastatic colon carcinomas, clear cell features in some metastatic adenocarcinomas of the kidney, and the small cell size and uniform, regular nuclear features in the often cytologically well differentiated metastatic carcinomas of the prostate.     

Use of neostigmine to increase the rate of lung cancer detection by sputum cytology

Neostigmine induction was investigated as a method for increasing the rate of detection of lung cancer in respiratory cytology samples. Eleven patients with dry and essentially nonproductive cough were given neostigmine, 15 mg by mouth or 0.5 mg by hypodermic injection. The quality of sputum produced was increased in all cases; the sputum was also more easily expectorated. Eight patients suspected of having lung cancer had previously negative cytologic examinations of sputum obtained by conventional methods. Following the administration of neostigmine, malignant cells indicating squamous-cell carcinoma were found in the sputum samples of three of these patients while dysplastic cells were detected in the samples from two patients. It is postulated that neostigmine intake may increase the excretion of mucous glands in the bronchial submucosa as well as the bronchial epithelium itself.     

Diagnosis of bronchial carcinoma on sections of paraffin-embedded sputum. Sensitivity and specificity of an alternative to routine cytology.

The diagnostic accuracy of sputum cytology for the diagnosis of bronchial carcinoma using paraffin-embedded, serially sectioned and hematoxylin and eosin-stained specimens was tested in 4,297 sputum samples from 1,889 patients, 219 of whom had bronchial carcinoma. The diagnostic sensitivity depended mainly on the number of investigated samples and was 85.4% with three sufficient sputa. The sensitivity was not influenced by the histologic types, location or TNM stage of the tumor. The specificity of the method was 99.5%. In three cases localization of sputum cytologically diagnosed bronchial carcinomas was not possible immediately (occult carcinomas, pTx); in two of these cases the bronchial carcinomas were located during follow-up. The third patient died without verification of the cytologic diagnosis. According to our results, sputum cytology on serial sections is a valuable instrument for mass screening of high-risk groups for the early detection of bronchial carcinoma. Lower sensitivities of sputum cytology in mass screening programs for the early diagnosis of lung cancer are discussed critically.     

Preoperative brush and impression cytology in ocular surface squamous neoplasms

OBJECTIVE: Preoperative cytologic diagnoses of ocular surface squamous neoplasms were evaluated and compared with histologic diagnoses. STUDY DESIGN: Impression cytology (Millipore filter paper) and brush cytology were applied to 32 patients who had conjunctival neoplasms. Papanicolaou-stained cytologic preparations and hematoxylin and eosin-stained histologic sections were examined by light microscopy. RESULTS: The brush technique was used on 27 patients; impression cytology was applied in 5 cases. Cytologic and histologic diagnoses were concordant in 26 cases. Squamous cell carcinoma or carcinoma in situ was diagnosed in 18 and dysplasia in 4 cases. Squamous metaplasia and normal-appearing conjunctival epithelial cells were diagnosed cytologically in four cases; of those histologic diagnoses, one was pterygium and three, conjunctival nevus. Four cases revealed discrepancies between the cytologic and histologic preparations. There was one false positive result, and one case was subconjunctival invasion of basal cell carcinoma of the eyelid. CONCLUSION: Impression and brush cytology are fast, cost-effective, reliable and noninvasive diagnostic tools for ocular surface squamous neoplasms. However, the brush technique has several advantages over impression cytology.     

Role of biliary brush cytology in primary sclerosing cholangitis

OBJECTIVE: To assess the role of brush cytology in the routine evaluation of patients with primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC). STUDY DESIGN: From January 1995 to June 2000, 64 brush cytology specimens were obtained from 21 patients who had at least one cytologic sample obtained during endoscopic retrograde cholangiography. All patients had a diagnosis of primary sclerosing cholangitis. Cases were classified as benign, atypical or malignant according to major cytologic criteria (nuclear contour and chromatin irregularities) and minor cytologic criteria (polarity, cellularity, nuclear enlargement, mitosis, increased nuclear/cytoplasmic ratio) used by us to diagnose biliary brush cytology. Follow-up was available in all cases. RESULTS: Diagnoses were benign (13), atypical (5) and malignant (3) on cytology. Follow-up of the 13 benign cases showed bile duct stones (2), gallbladder adenocarcinoma at cholecystectomy (1), ascending cholangitis (1) and clinically/cytologically by benign follow-up (9). Five of 13 benign cases had subsequent liver transplantation for liver failure, with explants showing changes of primary sclerosing cholangitis. Of the 3 malignant cases, 1 had carcinoma in situ on biopsy, with the explanted liver showing high grade dysplasia; the second patient had cholangiocarcinoma on explant; and the third had hepatocellular carcinoma on liver five needle aspiration. The 5 patients with atypical cytology were reclassified on review as reactive (3) and atypical not otherwise specified (2). Follow-up showed benign disease in 3 of 3 atypical cases reclassified as reactive; 2 of 2 reclassified as atypical not otherwise specified showed low grade dysplasia in the explant. CONCLUSION: The overall incidence of malignancy was low (3 of 21) in patients with PSC. Bile duct brushing is a sensitive method of detecting neoplasia in the setting of PSC when well-defined cytologic criteria are applied.     

Cytologic diagnosis of lung tumors from bronchial brushings of Chinese patients in Hong Kong

In 1,156 single or multiple specimens obtained from fiberoptic bronchoscopy on 1,016 Chinese patients in Hong Kong, a positive diagnosis of malignancy was made on cytologic examination in 288 and a histologic type assigned. On histologic examination of tissue, malignant tumors were diagnosed in 284 cases. The total positive yield by cytology was 88%, and the overall cytologic accuracy in correlation with histology was 73%. Comparing cases typed by cytology and by histology, the diagnostic accuracy of cytology was 83% in squamous-cell carcinoma, 81% in small-cell carcinoma, 69% in adenocarcinoma and 46% in large-cell carcinoma. The detection rate of nonbronchogenic tumors was 50%. Bronchogenic tumors showed a low male:female ratio, 1.96:1, whereas 80% of squamous-cell carcinomas and 45% of adenocarcinomas occurred in males. All seven cases of bronchogenic carcinoma in patients under 40 years of age occurred in males.     

Factors significant in the diagnostic accuracy of lung cytology in bronchial washing and sputum samples. II. Sputum samples

Some factors influencing the detection of malignant cells in sputum samples were evaluated in 449 consecutive cases of primary lung carcinoma seen between 1959 and 1974. Diagnostic accuracy increased during the years under study; the reasons are discussed. The overall accuracy was 82.8%. Detection of malignant cells was 85% for small-cell carcinoma, squamous-cell carcinoma and large-cell carcinoma, 75% for adenocarcinoma, bronchioloalveolar carcinoma and adenosquamous carcinoma and 64% for the uncommon tumors. Accuracy was 87% for central tumors and 42% for peripheral lesions. Tumors less than 2 cm in diameter yielded only 39% accuracy as compared to 90% for larger tumors. The specificity of diagnosis of cell type in those specimens with malignant cells was 95% for small-cell carcinoma and squamous-cell carcinoma, more than 80% for adenocarcinoma and large-cell carcinoma, 65% for bronchioloalveolar-cell carcinoma and adenosquamous carcinoma and less than 30% for the uncommon tumors. Diagnostic accuracy was optimal in those cases with three or more sputum samples: 83% for those with three samples and 90% for those with five or more samples per case. The use of both sputum and bronchial specimens was complementary and increased the accuracy further. Reasons for unsatisfactory specimens included no deep cough, limited cellular material, excessive blood or leukocytes and drying artifacts; the first two were the most common causes.     

Canine mastocytoma: report of 8 cases diagnosed by fine needle cytology and clinicopathologic correlations

BACKGROUND: Mast cell proliferations are commoner in dogs than in humans; mass forming lesions in the former are apt to fine needle sampling and the obtained cytopathological picture might be informing to enhance recognition of similar proliferations in humans. CASE: Clinical and cytopathologic data were collected from 8 cases of canine mastocytomas diagnosed by fine needle cytology. The cytopathologic presentation was correlated with the individual therapy performed and with the clinical stage. In all cases the cytopathological diagnosis was confirmed by histopathologic examination of the excised mass, by necropsy or by response to therapy. CONCLUSION: There are marked similarities between canine and human mastocytomas, despite possible differences in the clinical course of the disease in both species. Canine mastocytomas may hence be used as an animal model of a human disease and, as such, familiarity with their cytologic presentation may be useful for recognizing mast cell proliferations in humans.     

A novel method of sputum processing for cytologic diagnosis of lung cancer

OBJECTIVE: To compare the diagnostic sensitivity and cytologic findings of the sputum-processing method with those of the traditional sputum smear method. STUDY DESIGN: From May to December 2001, 300 consecutive sputum samples were collected from 168 patients suspected of having lung cancer in the Chest Department, Taipei Veterans General Hospital. After the sputum smear method, the remaining sputum material was processed by homogenization, filtration and fixation. All the slides were stained with Papanicolaou stain and reviewed by 2 cytologists. RESULTS: Of the 300 sputum samples, 141 from 79 patients were finally diagnosed as lung malignancies. The mean number of sputum samples was 1.78 per patient. Among the 79 patients, 46 had peripheral lung malignancies (58.2%). The overall diagnostic sensitivities of sputum smear and sputum-processing methods were 29% and 31%, respectively (P = .776). Tumor location and cell types did not change the difference significantly; however, among patients with small cell lung cancer, there was a higher detection rate with the sputum-processing method (50% vs. 20%, P = .350). Eight patients with negative results with the sputum smear had positive results with the sputum-processing method (8 of 79 = 10.1%). Microscopic morphologic differences between the 2 methods were described. CONCLUSION: There was no significant difference in diagnostic sensitivity between the sputum smear and sputum-processing methods. However, the sputum-processing method may play a role in patients with small cell lung carcinoma.     

Comparison of two preparation methods for endocervical evaluation

OBJECTIVE: To assess the validity of SurePath liquid-based preparation method for examination of endocervical brush specimens as a substitute for conventionally prepared cytology methods for evaluating the endocervical canal during colposcopic examination and biopsy. STUDY DESIGN: Paired SurePath liquid-based test slides and conventional smears were obtained using an endocervical brush in a split sample protocol before biopsy at the time of colposcopy. The level of agreement between cytologic results obtained was assessed. Accuracy and operating characteristics were evaluated compared to histologic follow-up. RESULTS: Agreement between cytology results for the methods was excellent. The overall kappa was 0.924 (p = 0.0000). There was exact agreement on interpretation between the methods in 283 of 299 cases (94.6%). Cytohistologic follow-up results correlation were: SurePath liquid-based Pap test results and conventional smear results agreed with histology results in 47.8% and 49.2% of cases, respectively. Allowing for a discrepancy within 1 level of severity of cytologic grade, agreements were 76.6% and 77.2%, respectively. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that the SurePath method is equivalent to conventional endocervical brush cytology preparation and performs well for detection of cervical intraepithelial lesions and cancer. SurePath is acceptable for endocervical evaluation as a substitute for endocervical curettage at colposcopic biopsy.     

Fine needle aspiration biopsy versus sputum and bronchial material in the diagnosis of lung cancer. A comparative study of 168 patients

A group of 168 consecutive lung cancer patients in whom a definitive diagnosis of primary lung cancer was established either in a conventional cytologic specimen of sputum or bronchial material or in a specimen obtained by fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy was reviewed to compare the relative accuracies between the modalities of sputum and bronchial material on one hand versus FNA cytology on the other in the diagnosis of lung cancer. The patients included in the study were selected from a total of 1,093 patients who had been diagnosed and treated for lung cancer at Duke University Medical Center over the five-year period of January 1, 1980, through December 31, 1984. In 325 (29.8%) of the 1,093 patients, a definitive cancer diagnosis was established from histopathologic study alone, without any cytologic diagnoses. In 420 patients (38.4%), both histologic and cytologic material had been interpreted as being conclusively diagnostic for lung cancer. In 348 patients (31.8%), a cytologic diagnosis of lung cancer was made without a histologic confirmation. Thus, in a total of 768 (70.3%) of the 1,093 cases, a definitive cytologic diagnosis of cancer had been made. Of these 768 patients, 168 had been evaluated by both conventional respiratory cytologic methods (examination of sputum and bronchial material) and with FNA biopsy cytology. In 9 patients (5.4%), only conventional respiratory cytologic specimens were conclusively diagnostic for cancer. In 122 patients (72.6%), only the FNA biopsy specimen was diagnostic. In 37 patients (22.0%), both conventional respiratory specimens and FNA specimens yielded a definitive lung cancer diagnosis. The FNA specimen was the only positive cytologic specimen in 90.2% of large cell undifferentiated carcinomas, 79.5% of adenocarcinomas, 66.7% of small cell undifferentiated carcinomas and 58.2% of squamous cell carcinomas. In 26.5% of the patients, a diagnosis of cancer could have been established on conventional cytologic specimens, without the necessity of proceeding to percutaneous FNA biopsy. From this study, it is concluded that the techniques of conventional respiratory cytology and FNA biopsy cytology are complementary in the diagnosis of lung cancer. While the percentage of lung cancers diagnosed by FNA biopsy cytology alone is much greater than that obtained by conventional respiratory cytology alone, more than one-fourth of these cancers could be detected by the less invasive techniques of sputum collection and bronchoscopy.