Cholinergic neuronotrophic factors: VI. Age-dependent requirements by chick embryo ciliary ganglionic neurons

During development, ciliary ganglionic neurons become postmitotic and extend neurites in apparent independence of the presence of their future intraocular innervation targets. After reaching their peripheral innervation territory, however, these neurons become target dependent and about half of them die. We have previously reported that chick embryo intraocular target tissues contain a ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF), which can be extracted and partially purified in a soluble form and which ensures near-total survival of 8-day chick embryo ciliary ganglionic neurons in monolayer cultures. In this study we have dissociated and cultured ciliary ganglia from embryonic Day (ED) 5 through 14, and examined dependence and responsiveness of their neurons to exogenously added CNTF. Two cell classes (dark and bright) could be distinguished by phase microscopy and differentially counted in cell dissociates from ED7–14, but not in ED5–6 ones. Dark cell number per ganglion increased from 6000 to 78,000 over this developmental time period. In contrast, bright cells (putative neurons) declined from a maximum of about 10,000 to 6000, suggesting a correlation with the expected neuronal cell death in vivo. Dissociated cells from ED5–14 ganglia were seeded on a polyornithine substratum coated with neurite promoting factor, cultured for 24 hr with or without added CNTF, and numerically examined for survival and neuritic development. Cultures from ED7–14 ganglia showed two cell categories: (i) flat nonneuronal elements dramatically increased in number with ganglionic age (thereby correlating with the increasing number of dark cells in the dissociates) and (ii) large, bright cells (often displaying neurite outgrowth) decreased in number in parallel with bright cell number in the dissociate. The survival of these neuronal elements was strictly dependent on exogenously added CNTF between ED7 and 10, but became progressively independent with older ages. ED14 neurons (fully capable of surviving for 24 hr without added CNTF) continued to require CNTF for neurite extension, thus displaying retained sensitivity to this factor. Although the ED5–6 cultures contained well-recognizable flat cells, the dominant category comprised cells with variable morphology, practically all of which exhibited neurite-like processes. Both the survival and neurite extension of these cells, which we tentatively interpret as immature neurons were independent of the presence of added CNTF.     

Neurotrophic effects of BDNF and CNTF,alone and in combination,on postnatal day 5 rat acoustic ganglion neurons

The neuronal survival promoting ability of brain derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), and ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF), individually and in combination, was evaluated in dissociated cell cultures of postnatal day 5 (P5) rat acoustic ganglia. The neuritogenic promoting effect of these same neurotrophic factors was examined in organotypic explants of P5 rat acoustic ganglia. The results showed that BDNF was maximally effective at a concentration of 10 ng/mL in promoting both survival and neuritogenesis of these postnatal auditory neurons in vitro. CNTF was maximally effective at a concentration of 0.01 ng/mL at promoting both survival and neuritogenesis in the acoustic ganglion cultures. BDNF had its strongest effect on neuronal survival while CNTF was most effective in stimulating neurite outgrowth. These two neurotrophic factors, when added together at their respective maximally effective concentrations, behave in an additive manner for promoting both survival and neuritic outgrowth by the auditory neurons. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

The culture of chick embryo dorsal root ganglionic cells on polylysine-coated plastic

Polylysine-coated culture surfaces are strongly adhesive for neural cells, restrict locomotion on nonneuronal elements, but do not inhibit neurite elongation. In the present study, culture dishes were pre-treated with poly-d-lysine (PDL) at various concentrations, seeded with dissociates from 8-day chick embryo dorsal root ganglia, and incubated under conditions that normally support both neuronal survival and nonneuronal proliferation. Pretreatment with low (0.1 mg/ml) PDL concentrations had no effect on neuronal survival and neuritic growth, but entirely prevented an increase in ganglionic nonneurons, yielding a numerically stable culture greatly enriched in neurons. Higher PDL concentrations caused increasing losses in both cell classes. The 50% levels of cell loss were achieved at about the same PDL dose, but earlier for neurons than nonneurons and still with no impairment of neuritic growth from the surviving neurons. A procedure was developed to compare acid-soluble and acid-precipitable accumulation of radioactivity under 1-hr pulses of [³H]uridine, which was applicable even to poorly attached cells. The cytotoxic effects of higher PDL pretreatments was revealed as early as 6 hr after seeding by 2- to 4-fold lower radioaccumulation. The data are discussed in terms of possible regulations of cell permeability and metabolism by adhesive interactions between cells and their substratum, or other cells.     

Melanogenesis in cultures of peripheral nervous tissue. II. Environmental factors determining the fate of pigment-forming cells

Spinal ganglia from 4- to 7-day [Stage 23–30; Hamburger and Hamilton (1951) J. Morphol.88, 49–92] chicken embryos were cultured in vitro to investigate the effect of various environmental conditions on cell differentiation. Culture morphology (i.e., degree of dispersion of the explanted ganglia, survival of neurons, and outgrowth of axons) was observed to depend upon several factors including: (1) the age of the explanted ganglia, (2) the presence or absence of nerve growth factor (NGF), and (3) the nature of the substratum on which the cultured tissue resides. These observations enabled us to disturb the association of neurons with the other cells in ganglion cultures and thereby modulate the differentiation of adventitious melanocytes. Thus, in medium permissive for melanogenesis, melanocytes appear when the association between neurons and small stellate nonneuronal cells in the ganglion is disrupted. This disruption is most extensive (1) when young (Stage 26–27, 5-day) ganglia are explanted on plastic substrata, in the initial absence of NGF, and (2) when cells from enzyme-dissociated ganglia are cultured on plastic substrata. In comparable media, pigment cell differentiation is not observed when the association between neurons and small stellate cells is preserved. Such associations tend to endure (1) in developmentally older (Stage 30+, 7- to 8-day) ganglia or (2) when ganglia are cultured on agar or fibroblast substrata. We conclude that loss of association between neurons and the nonneuronal cells in young ganglia is necessary for the latter to undergo melanogenesis in vitro.     

Ouabain binding to preimplantation rabbit blastocysts

Ciliary ganglia (CG) from 8-day-old chick embryos were cultured as explants on a highly adhesive collagen substratum in the presence of the ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF). A remarkable correlation was found between the formation of an outgrowth of ganglionic nonneuronal cells and the timing and extent of neuritic development outside the ganglion. Neurites were not seen to emerge from the ganglion before the onset (24 hr after explantation) of a nonneuronal cell outgrowth. After nonneurons began to migrate over the collagen substratum, neurites could be seen to extend up to, but not beyond the distal limit of the nonneuronal outgrowth. Time-lapse analysis showed that neuritic growth cones could move in synchrony with a nonneuron with which they were in contact as well as over the nonneuronal cell surface, but not on the collagen located distally to the external edge of the nonneuronal outgrowth.Freshly dissected CGs were also grown as secondary explants on preformed host monolayers of ganglionic nonneurons. These secondary explants showed considerable neuritic development within 24 hr, while control ganglia explanted on collagen had not produced neurites. Autoradiographic experiments indicated that this neuritic outgrowth occurred on nonneuronal cells emerging precociously from the secondary explant, rather than on the preexisting host nonneurons. Electron microscopy of 24-hr explants demonstrated that, inside the ganglion, neurites were also very closely associated with the surface of nonneuronal cells.Neuritic behavior in this nonneuron/collagen terrain is compared with previously described observations of CG explants on polyornithine (PORN) or dissociated CG neurons on PORN or collagen. These observations led to the identification of a PORN-bindable neurite promoting factor (PNPF) which does not bind to, and is not active on, collagen. The hypothesis is discussed that PNPF molecules are present on the surface of nonneuronal cells and that the cells owe to those molecules their competence as a suitable terrain for the elongation of neuritic processes.     

Purification of the Chick Eye Ciliary Neuronotrophic Factor

Dissociated 8-day chick embryo ciliary ganglionic neurons will not survive for even 24 h in culture without the addition of specific supplements. One such supplement is a protein termed the ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF) which is present at very high concentrations within intraocular tissues that contain the same muscle cells innervated by ciliary ganglionic neurons in vivo. We describe here the purification of chick eye CNTF by a 2 1/2-day procedure involving the processing of intraocular tissue extract sequentially through DE52 ion-exchange chromatography, membrane ultrafiltration-concentration, sucrose density gradient ultracentrifugation, and preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gradient electrophoresis. An aqueous extract of the tissue from 300 eyes will yield about 10-20 micrograms of biologically active, electrophoretically pure CNTF with a specific activity of 7.5 X 10(6) trophic units/mg protein. Purified CNTF has an Mr of 20,400 daltons and an isoelectric point of about 5, as determined by analytical gel electrophoresis. In addition to supporting the survival of ciliary ganglion neurons, purified CNTF also supports the 24-h survival of cultured neurons from certain chick and rodent sensory and sympathetic ganglia. CNTF differs from mouse submaxillary nerve growth factor (NGF) in molecular weight, isoelectric point, inability to be inactivated by antibodies to NGF, ability to support the in vitro survival of the ciliary ganglion neurons, and inability to support that of 8-day chick embryo dorsal root ganglionic neurons. Thus, CNTF represents the first purified neuronotrophic factor which addresses parasympathetic cholinergic neurons.     

Nerve growth factor-independent development of embryonic mouse sympathetic neurons in dissociated cell culture

Although ganglia from neonatal mouse sympathetic ganglia require nerve growth factor (NGF) for survival in culture, explanted sympathetic ganglia from early embryonic stages do not require added NGF for survival and growth. To determine whether the change in growth factor requirement is due to changes in the neurons themselves, to variations in neuronal populations, or to changes in nonneuronal cells, we examined the response to growth factors by dissociated sympathetic neurons at various stages of development. Results indicate that neurons from the 14-day gestational (E14) superior cervical ganglion (SCG) do not require NGF for initial survival and neurite extension, but do require the conditioned medium neurite extension factor, CMF. By 2 to 3 days thereafter, whether in vivo or in culture, most neurons have developed a requirement for NGF for survival in culture. During the same period, there is a concomitant increase in responsiveness to NGF alone as a trophic agent. Changes in response to NGF are not due to changes in NGF content of ganglia, to interactions in culture with nonneuronal cells, or to age-related differences in NGF requirements for maximum survival. The changes in growth factor requirements may be related to mechanisms regulating specificity of nerve-target connections.     

Quantitative in vitro studies on the nerve growth factor (NGF) requirement of neurons. II. Sensory neurons

Studies were carried out in dissociated cell cultures on the nerve growth factor (NGF) requirement of chick embryo dorsal root ganglionic (DRG) neurons. Findings were: (i) The minimum level of 2.5 S NGF required to sustain the survival of maximal numbers of process-bearing cells derived from 8-day (E8) embryonic DRGs is 0.5 ng/ml (～2 × 10^?11M). (ii) Cultures derived from chick embryos of increasing ages (E8 to E18) showed a progressive increase in the proportion of process-bearing cells which survived in the absence of NGF. While few process-bearing cells survived in cultures of E8 ganglia in the absence of NGF, survival of neurons in cultures derived from E17 and E18 ganglia was not affected by the absence of the factor. Comparable results were obtained with cultures in which the number of non-neuronal cells was greatly reduced. (iii) Neurons derived from E8 ganglia lost their NGF requirement in culture at a conceptual age similar to that which they appear to do so in vivo. These results are discussed with respect to the role of NGF in development of sensory neurons.     

Neuronal differentiation from postmitotic precursors in the ciliary ganglion

In the chick ciliary ganglion, neuronal number is kept constant between St. 29 and St. 34 (E6-E8) despite a large amount of cell death. Here, we characterize the source of neurogenic cells in the ganglion as undifferentiated neural crest-derived cells. At St. 29, neurons and nonneuronal cells in the ciliary ganglion expressed the neural crest markers HNK-1 and p75(NTR). Over 50% of the cells were neurons at St. 29; of the nonneuronal cells, a small population expressed glial markers, whereas the majority was undifferentiated. When placed in culture, nonneuronal cells acquired immunoreactivity for HuD, suggesting that they had commenced neuronal differentiation. The newly differentiated neurons arose from precursors that did not incorporate bromodeoxyuridine. To test whether these precursors could undergo neural differentiation in vivo, purified nonneuronal cells from St. 29 quail ganglia were transplanted into chick embryos at St. 9-14. Subsequently, quail cells expressing neuronal markers were found in the chick ciliary ganglion. The existence of this precursor pool was transient because nonneuronal cells isolated from St. 38 ganglia failed to form neurons. Since all ciliary ganglion neurons are born prior to St. 29, these results demonstrate that there are postmitotic neural crest-derived precursors in the developing ciliary ganglion that can differentiate into neurons in the appropriate environment.     

[14C]Glucose Metabolism in Sympathetic Ganglia of Chicken Embryos and in Primary Cultures of Neurons and of Other Cells from These Ganglia

Metabolism of [1-14C]glucose and [6-14C]glucose was measured in sympathetic ganglia excised from chicken embryos 12-16 days old and in primary cultures of neurons or nonneurons prepared from these ganglia. Some metabolic rates tended to change with the tissue/medium ratio, so this variable had to be controlled. Less C-6 than C-1 od glucose was put out in CO2 by all three types of preparations, indicating operation of the hexosemonophosphate shunt. The C-6/C-1 ratio was greater for the neuronal cultures and for intact ganglia than for the nonneuronal cultures. The C-6/C-1 ratio for the neurons increased with the amount of tissue added to a given volume of incubation medium, in agreement with previous experiments on embryonic dorsal root ganglia (Larrabee, 1978). Per unit of protein, the output of C-1 of glucose in CO2 was higher in both the neuronal and the nonneural cultures than in intact ganglia, whereas that of C-6 was higher in the neuronal cultures and lower in the nonneuronal ones than in the ganglia. The rates of release in lactate of C-1 and C-6 of glucose were 3-5 times higher from both types of cultures than from intact ganglia. The average rates of incorporation of C-1 and C-6 of glucose into tissue constituents were lower in the cultures than in intact ganglia, significantly so for incorporation of C-6 in the nonneuronal cultures.     

Ciliary Neuronotrophic Factor Stimulates Choline Acetyltransferase Activity in Cultured Chicken Retina Neurons

It has been demonstrated that cultured cholinergic retinal neurons from 8-day-old chicken embryos respond to a polypeptide factor present in retinal cell-conditioned medium (RCM) and in retinal extracts. Compared with control cultures, the activity of acetyl-CoA:choline O-acetyltransferase (EC 2.3.1.6; ChAT) is enhanced more than twofold in neuronal retinal cultures grown for 7 days in the presence of RCM. The present study demonstrates that both ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF), which is characterized by its trophic activity on parasympathetic ciliary neurons, and RCM exhibit identical stimulatory effects on ChAT activity in retinal monolayer cultures. Similarly, RCM supports the in vitro survival of ciliary neurons to the same extent as CNTF. The active species in RCM has a molecular weight (20,900 +/- 1,000) identical to that of CNTF, as determined by preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis. The results indicate that cholinergic retinal neurons represent a central neuronal target for CNTF or a closely related protein.     

Stage-dependent stimulation of neurite outgrowth exerted by nerve growth factor and chick heart in cultured embryonic ganglia

The ability of embryonic chick heart to elicit neuritic outgrowth in different ganglia was tested to examine (1) whether stimulative activity is possessed by the heart only at specific stages and (2) whether the ability of the ganglionic neurons to respond is limited to certain periods of development. As an assay, ganglia were explanted into thin collagen gels with ventricular tissue placed at a distance of about 1 mm. Neuritic outgrowth was measured after 2 days. Control ganglia and ganglia cultured with added nerve growth factor (NGF) were also scored. Four types of tested ganglia, including the ciliary ganglion, showed a peak in neuritic outgrowth when cultured with heart of embryonic Day 18, at about which age the heart becomes sympathetically innervated in ovo. No age-related size differences that could account for this temporal pattern were found among the heart explants when measuring their protein content. A peak in neuronal susceptibility to heart tissue was evident in the 6-day ciliary ganglion and in the 8-day paravertebral, Remak, and spinal ganglia, roughly coinciding with the onset of fibre outgrowth in ovo. Neurite extension is concluded to have been triggered by a factor spread from the heart explants and being distinct from the mouse type of NGF since anti-NGF did not at any stage block the events and since added NGF at all stages failed to evoke neurite formation in the ciliary ganglia. A testable hypothesis is that this factor regulates the growth of sympathetic and possibly parasympathetic and sensory fibres in the developing chick heart.     

Developmental potentialities in the nonneuronal population of quail sensory ganglia

Sensory ganglia taken from quail embryos at E4 to E7 were back-transplanted into the vagal neural crest migration pathway (i.e., at the level of somites 1 to 6) of 8- to 10-somite stage chick embryos. Three types of sensory ganglia were used: (i) proximal ganglia of cranial sensory nerves IX and X forming the jugular-superior ganglionic complex, whose neurons and nonneuronal cells both arise from the neural crest; (ii) distal ganglia of the same nerves, i.e., the petrosal and nodose ganglia in which the neurons originate from epibranchial placodes and the nonneuronal cells from the neural crest; (iii) dorsal root ganglia taken in the truncal region between the fore- and hindlimb levels. The question raised was whether cells from the graft would be able to yield the neural crest derivatives normally arising from the hindbrain and vagal crest, such as carotid body type I and II cells, enteric ganglia, Schwann cells located along the local nerves, and the nonneuronal contingent of cells in the host nodose ganglion. All the grafted cephalic ganglia provided the host with the complete array of these cell types. In contrast, grafted dorsal root ganglion cells gave rise only to carotid body type I and II cells, to the nonneuronal cells of the nodose ganglion, and to Schwann cells; the ganglion-derived cells did not invade the gut and therefore failed to contribute to the host's enteric neuronal system. Coculture on the chorioallantoic membrane of aneural chick gut directly associated with quail sensory ganglia essentially reinforced these results. These data demonstrate that the capacity of peripheral ganglia to provide enteric plexuses varies according to the level of the neuraxis from which they originate.     

Survival and maturation of cerebral neurons on poly(l-lysine) surfaces in the absence of serum

Several phenotypic properties of dissociated rat embryo cerebral cells cultivated in the absence of serum on poly(l-lysine) coated surfaces were investigated. A great enrichment of neuronal cells is attained after 3–4 weeks in culture as a result of cessation of nonneuronal cell proliferation. The monolayer pattern of cell-cell reassociation and neuritic sprouting is promoted by poly(l-lysine) and it is independent of serum presence or the existence of a layer of nonneuronal cells. Synaptic profiles and typical regions of neuropil are prominent. The neuronal plasma membrane is often characterized by irregular foldings at points of cell-cell contacts. A few biochemical parameters investigated lend support to the suggestion that the cerebral neurons acquire a certain state of functional maturation. It is proposed that substances secreted by the cells or released as a result of cell death may be conspicuous components for long-term survival of the cerebral neurons.     

Differentiation of postmitotic neuroblasts into substance P-immunoreactive sensory neurons in dissociated cultures of chick dorsal root ganglion

Counts performed on dissociated cell cultures of E10 chick embryo dorsal root ganglia (DRG) showed after 4-6 days of culture a pronounced decline of the neuronal population in neuron-enriched cultures and a net gain in the number of ganglion cells in mixed DRG cell cultures (containing both neurons and nonneuronal cells). In the latter case, the increase in the number of neurons was found to depend on NGF and to average 119% in defined medium or 129% in horse serum-supplemented medium after 6 days of culture. The lack of [3H]thymidine incorporation into the neuronal population indicated that the newly formed ganglion cells were not generated by proliferation. On the contrary, the differentiation of postmitotic neuroblasts present in the nonneuronal cell compartment was supported by sequential microphotographs of selected fields taken every hour for 48-55 hr after 3 days of culture. Apparently nonneuronal flat dark cells exhibited morphological changes and gradually evolved into neuronal ovoid and refringent cell bodies with expanding neurites. The ultrastructural organization of these evolving cells corresponded to that of primitive or intermediate neuroblasts. The neuronal nature of these rounding up cell bodies was indeed confirmed by the progressive expression of various neuronal cell markers (150 and 200-kDa neurofilament triplets, neuron specific enolase, and D2/N-CAM). Besides a constant lack of immunoreactivity for tyrosine hydroxylase, somatostatin, parvalbumin, and calbindin-D 28K and a lack of cytoenzymatic activity for carbonic anhydrase, all the newly produced neurons expressed three main phenotypic characteristics: a small cell body, a strong immunoreactivity to MAG, and substance P. Hence, ganglion cells newly differentiated in culture would meet characteristics ascribed to small B sensory neurons and more specifically to a subpopulation of ganglion cells containing substance P-immunoreactive material.     

Promotion of survival and neurite outgrowth of cultured peripheral neurons by exogenous lipids and detergents

Gangliosides, in particular the monosialoglycosphingolipids Gtet 1 (GM1), have previously been implicated in the mediation of neuronal rescue and restitutional axonal growth, both in vitro and subsequent to brain and peripheral nerve lesions. In the present study it is shown that the bis-sialosyl gangliosides Gtet2b and Gtet3b, but not the gangliosides Gtet2a and Gtet1, promote the survival of dissociated dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons cultured from Embryonic Day (E) 8 chicks (DRG8) almost to the same extent as nerve growth factor (NGF). Ciliary ganglion (CG) neurons from E8 chicks (CG8) and DRG10 neurons were virtually not supported suggesting considerable specificity in terms of neuronal targets and developmental stages being addressed. Moreover, a variety of other lipids including cerebroside (Cb), dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and -serine (DPPS), sulfatide (Sf), and sphingomyelin (Sm) were tested for putative survival promoting activity toward chick CG, DRG, and lumbar sympathetic ganglion (SG11) neurons. At the highest concentration employed (2.5 x 10(-5) M), Sm, DPPC, and DPPS maintained between 45 and 65% of the plateau survival with CG8 (maximally supported by ciliary neuronotrophic factor (CNTF], DRG8, and DRG10 neurons, and 30 to 40% with SG11 neurons. Cb supported CG8 neurons at about 55% of the plateau value achieved with CNTF, but had hardly any effect on the other neuron populations tested. Control experiments using highly enriched neurons and serum-free conditions assured that the effects were unlikely to be mediated by serum components or nonneuronal cells. A variety of detergents, in particular Triton X-100, also promoted the survival of CG8 and DRG10 neurons. Ganglioside Gtet1, Sm, and Triton X-100 shifted the NGF titration curve for DRG10 neurons between 6- and 15-fold in a dose-dependent manner suggesting synergisms between NGF and lipids for neuronal maintenance. These results document the neuronotrophic potency of certain gangliosides, a heterogeneous group of structurally unrelated lipids, and detergents. The mechanisms by which these agents modulate neuronal survival still await clarification.     

Growth factor dependent cholinergic function and survival in primary mouse spinal cord cultures

In primary embryonic spinal cord cultures, synaptic transmission can be conveniently studied by monitoring radiolabeled neurotransmitter release or by recording of electrophysiological responses. However, while the mature spinal cord contains an appreciable number of cholinergic motoneurons, cultures of embryonic spinal cord have a paucity of these neurons and release little or no acetylcholine upon stimulation. To determine whether the proportion of cholinergic neurons in primary mouse spinal cord cultures can be augmented, the effects of several classes of growth factors were examined on depolarization- and Ca(2+)-evoked release of choline/acetylcholine (Ch/ACh). In the absence of growth factors, little or no evoked release of radiolabeled Ch/ACh could be demonstrated. Media supplemented with brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) or basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) were examined for their ability to preserve the population of neurons in culture. CNTF was found to increase the number of surviving neurons and to enhance the release of radiolabeled Ch/ACh; the other factors were without effect. The action of CNTF was transient, and the neuronal population decreased to levels observed in cultures lacking growth factor after 20 days in vitro. The correlation between enhanced neuron survival and increased Ch/ACh release suggests that CNTF protected cholinergic neurons, albeit transiently, from cell death.     

Early commitment of precursor cells from the rat superior cervical ganglion to neuronal or nonneuronal fates

To determine whether postmigratory neural crest cells retain the capacity to give rise to multiple cell types, the clonal progeny of embryonic rat superior cervical ganglion (SCG) cells were examined in culture. Double labeling with BrdU and neurofilament antibodies demonstrated that neuron precursors from the E14.5 SCG continued to proliferate for several days in culture. Using the BAG retrovirus to examine the progeny of single cells, we obtained several kinds of distinct clones from SCG cultures after 3 days. At E14.5, during peak neurogenesis in vivo, neuron-containing clones composed of one to seven cells were common. At E17.5, after neurons have been born in vivo, most clones in vitro contained flat cells, primarily reflecting glial cell division. Even in cultures from E13.5 ganglia, mixed clones containing neurons and flat cells were rarely observed. These observations suggest that neuronal and nonneuronal cell precursors are specified during or before early gangliogenesis.