Association mapping of stem rust race TTKSK resistance in US barley breeding germplasm

Key message

Loci conferring resistance to the highly virulent African stem rust race TTKSK were identified in advanced barley breeding germplasm and positioned to chromosomes 5H and 7H using an association mapping approach.

Abstract

African races of the stem rust pathogen (Puccinia graminis f. sp. tritici) are a serious threat to barley production worldwide because of their wide virulence. To discover and characterize resistance to African stem rust race TTKSK in US barley breeding germplasm, over 3,000 lines/cultivars were assessed for resistance at the seedling stage in the greenhouse and also the adult plant stage in the field in Kenya. Only 12 (0.3 %) and 64 (2.1 %) lines exhibited a resistance level comparable to the resistant control at the seedling and adult plant stage, respectively. To map quantitative trait loci (QTL) for resistance to race TTKSK, an association mapping approach was conducted, utilizing 3,072 single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers. At the seedling stage, two neighboring SNP markers (0.8 cM apart) on chromosome 7H (11_21491 and 12_30528) were found significantly associated with resistance. The most significant one found was 12_30528; thus, the resistance QTL was named Rpg-qtl-7H-12_30528. At the adult plant stage, two SNP markers on chromosome 5H (11_11355 and 12_31427) were found significantly associated with resistance. This resistance QTL was named Rpg-qtl-5H-11_11355 for the most significant marker identified. Adult plant resistance is of paramount importance for stem rust. The marker associated with Rpg-qtl-5H-11_11355 for adult plant resistance explained only a small portion of the phenotypic variation (0.02); however, this QTL reduced disease severity up to 55.0 % under low disease pressure and up to 21.1 % under heavy disease pressure. SNP marker 11_11355 will be valuable for marker-assisted selection of adult plant stem rust resistance in barley breeding.     

Isolate-specific QTLs for partial resistance to Puccinia hordei in barley

By using a high-density AFLP marker linkage map, six QTLs for partial resistance to barley leaf rust (Puccinia hordei) isolate 1.2.1. have been identified in the RIL offspring of a cross between the partially resistant cultivar ’Vada’ and the susceptible line L94. Three QTLs were effective at the seedling stage, and five QTLs were effective at the adult plant stage. To study possible isolate specificity of the resistance, seedlings and adult plants of the 103 RILs from the cross L94×’Vada’ were also inoculated with another leaf rust isolate, isolate 24. In addition to the two QTLs that were effective against isolate 1.2.1. at the seedling stage, an additional QTL for seedling resistance to isolate 24 was identified on the long arm of chromosome 7. Of the eight detected QTLs effective at the adult plant stage, three were effective in both isolates and five were effective in only one of the two isolates. Only one QTL had a substantial effect at both the seedling and the adult plant stages. The expression of the other QTLs was developmental-stage specific. The isolate specificity of the QTLs supports the hypothesis of Parlevliet and Zadoks (1977) that partial resistance may be based on a minor-gene-for-minor-gene interaction. Received: 16 February 1999 / Accepted: 20 February 1999     

Genome-wide association mapping of Fusarium head blight resistance in contemporary barley breeding germplasm

Utilization of quantitative trait loci (QTL) identified in bi-parental mapping populations has had limited success for improving complex quantitative traits with low to moderate heritability. Association mapping in contemporary breeding germplasm may lead to more effective marker strategies for crop improvement. To test this approach, we conducted association mapping of two complex traits with moderate heritability; Fusarium head blight (FHB) severity and the grain concentration of mycotoxin associated with disease, deoxynivalenol (DON). To map FHB resistance in barley, 768 breeding lines were evaluated in 2006 and 2007 in four locations. All lines were genotyped with 1,536 SNP markers and QTL were mapped using a mixed model that accounts for relatedness among lines. Average linkage disequilibrium within the breeding germplasm extended beyond 4 cM. Four QTL were identified for FHB severity and eight QTL were identified for the DON concentration in two independent sets of breeding lines. The QTL effects were small, explaining 1–3% of the phenotypic variation, as might be expected for complex polygenic traits. We show that using breeding germplasm to map QTL can complement bi-parental mapping studies by providing independent validation, mapping QTL with more precision, resolving questions of linkage and pleiotropy, and identifying genetic markers that can be applied immediately in crop improvement.     

Inheritance and molecular mapping of a gene conferring seedling resistance against Puccinia hordei in the barley cultivar Ricardo

Genetic studies were undertaken to determine the inheritance and genomic location of uncharacterised seedling resistance to leaf rust, caused by Puccinia hordei, in the barley cultivar Ricardo. The resistance was shown to be conferred by a single dominant gene, which was tentatively designated RphRic. Bulk segregant analysis (BSA) and genetic mapping of an F₃ mapping population using multiplex-ready SSR genotyping and Illumina GoldenGate SNP assay located RphRic in chromosome 4H. Given that this is the first gene for leaf rust resistance mapped on chromosome 4H, it was designated Rph21. The presence of an additional gene, Rph2, in Ricardo, was confirmed by the test of allelism. The seedling gene Rph21 has shown effectiveness against all Australian pathotypes of P. hordei tested since at least 1992 and hence represents a new and useful source of resistance to this pathogen.     

Molecular mapping of a new gene in wild barley conferring complete resistance to leaf rust (Puccinia hordei Otth)

 A dominant gene conferring resistance to all known races of Puccinia hordei Otth was identified in two accessions of Hordeum vulgare ssp. spontaneum. Using restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) markers the gene was mapped on chromosome 2HS in doubled-haploid populations derived from crosses of both accessions to the susceptible cultivar L94. Until now, complete leaf rust resistance was not known to be conditioned by genetic factors on this barley chromosome. Therefore, the designation Rph16 is proposed for the gene described in this study. A series of sequence tagged site (STS) and cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (CAPS) markers were generated by conversion of RFLP probes which originate from the chromosomal region carrying the resistance gene. Two PCR-based markers were shown to co-segregate with the Rph16 gene in both populations thus providing the basis for marker-assisted selection. Received: 20 May 1998 / Accepted: 9 June 1998     

Isolate specificity of quantitative trait loci for partial resistance of barley to Puccinia hordei confirmed in mapping populations and near-isogenic lines

Partial resistance is considered race-nonspecific and durable, consistent with the concept of 'horizontal' resistance. However, detailed observations of partial resistance to leaf rust (Puccinia hordei) in barley (Hordeum vulgare) revealed small cultivar x isolate interactions, suggesting a minor-gene-for-minor-gene interaction model, similar to so-called 'vertical' resistance. Three consistent quantitative trait loci (QTLs), labelled Rphq2, Rphq3 and Rphq4, that were detected in the cross susceptible L94 x partially resistant Vada have been incorporated into the L94 background to obtain near-isogenic lines (NILs). Three isolates were used to map QTLs on seedlings of the L94 x Vada population and to evaluate the effect of each QTL on adult plants of the respective NILs under field conditions. Rphq2 had a strong effect in seedlings but almost no effect in adult plants, while Rphq3 was effective in seedlings and in adult plants against all three isolates. However, Rphq4 was effective in seedlings and in adult plants against two isolates but ineffective in both development stages against the third, demonstrating a clear and reproducible isolate-specific effect. The resistance governed by the three QTLs was not associated with a hypersensitive reaction. Those results confirm the minor-gene-for-minor-gene model suggesting specific interactions between QTLs for partial resistance and P. hordei isolates.     

Identification of QTLs for partial resistance to leaf rust (Puccinia hordei) in barley

 The partial resistance to leaf rust in barley is a quantitative resistance that is not based on hypersensitivity. To map the quantitative trait loci (QTLs) for partial resistance to leaf rust, we obtained 103 recombinant inbred lines (RILs) by single-seed descent from a cross between the susceptible parent L94 and the partially resistant parent Vada. These RILs were evaluated at the seedling and adult plant stages in the greenhouse for the latent period (LP) of the rust fungus, and in the field for the level of infection, measured as area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC). A dense genetic map based on 561 AFLP markers had been generated previously for this set of RILs. QTLs for partial resistance to leaf rust were mapped using the “Multiple Interval Mapping” method with the putative QTL markers as cofactors. Six QTLs for partial resistance were identified in this population. Three QTLs, Rphq1, Rphq2 and Rphq3, were effective at the seedling stage and contributed approximately 55% to the phenotypic variance. Five QTLs, Rph2, Rphq3, Rphq4, Rphq5, and/or Rphq6 contributed approximtely. 60% of the phenotypic variance and were effective at the adult plant stage. Therefore, only the QTLs Rphq2 and Rhpq3 were not plant-stage dependent. The identified QTLs showed mainly additive effects and only one significant interaction was detected, i.e. between Rphq1 and Rphq2. The map positions of these QTLs did not coincide with those of the race-specific resistance genes, suggesting that genes for partial resistance and genes for hypersensitive resistance represent entirely different gene families. Also, three QTLs for days to heading, of which two were also involved in plant height, were identified in the present recombinant inbred population. These QTLs had been mapped previously on the same positions in different populations. The perspectives of these results for breeding for durable resistance to leaf rust are discussed. Received: 15 July 1997 / Accepted: 30 December 1997     

Mapping Rph20: a gene conferring adult plant resistance to Puccinia hordei in barley

A doubled haploid (DH) barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) population of 334 lines (ND24260?×?Flagship) genotyped with DArT markers was used to map genes for adult plant resistance (APR) to leaf rust (Puccinia hordei Otth) under field conditions in Australia and Uruguay. The Australian barley cultivar Flagship carries an APR gene (qRphFlag) derived from the cultivar Vada. Association analysis and composite interval mapping identified two genes conferring APR in this DH population. qRphFlag was mapped to the short arm of chromosome 5H (5HS), accounting for 64?C85% of the phenotypic variation across four field environments and 56% under controlled environmental conditions (CEC). A second quantitative trait locus (QTL) from ND24260 (qRphND) with smaller effect was mapped to chromosome 6HL. In the absence of qRphFlag, qRphND conferred only a low level of resistance. DH lines displaying the highest level of APR carried both genes. Sequence information for the critical DArT marker bPb-0837 (positioned at 21.2?cM on chromosome 5HS) was used to develop bPb-0837-PCR, a simple PCR-based marker for qRphFlag. The 245?bp fragment for bPb-0837-PCR was detected in a range of barley cultivars known to possess APR, which was consistent with previous tests of allelism, demonstrating that the qRphFlag resistant allele is common in leaf rust resistant cultivars derived from Vada and Emir. qRphFlag has been designated Rph20, the first gene conferring APR to P. hordei to be characterised in barley. The PCR marker will likely be effective in marker-assisted selection for Rph20.     

Genome-wide association mapping reveals genetic architecture of durable spot blotch resistance in US barley breeding germplasm

Spot blotch, an economically important disease of both barley and wheat, is caused by Cochliobolus sativus (anamorph: Bipolaris sorokiniana). The disease has been reported in many regions of the world, but is particularly severe on barley in the Upper Midwest region of the USA and adjacent areas of Canada. For over 50 years, spot blotch has been effectively controlled through the deployment of durable resistance in six-rowed malting cultivars. To characterize loci conferring spot blotch resistance in US barley germplasm, we employed an association mapping approach using 3,840 breeding lines and cultivars. Three quantitative trait loci (QTL), Rcs-qtl-1H-11_10764, Rcs-qtl-3H-11_10565 and Rcs-qtl-7H-11_20162, were found to confer both seedling and adult plant resistance. Together, these three QTL comprise the Midwest Six-rowed Durable Resistant Haplotype (MSDRH), which is present in all Midwest six-rowed cultivars released since the 1960s. Each QTL alone only partially reduced disease levels, but combining all three together reduced the seedling infection response and adult plant disease severity by 47 and 83 %, respectively. The identified MSDRH will be valuable for marker-assisted selection of breeding lines to deploy spot blotch resistance and can also be incorporated into genomic selection as one of the disease resistance traits.     

The evidence for abundance of QTLs for partial resistance to Puccinia hordei on the barley genome

Using AFLP markers, a linkage map was constructed based on a recombinant inbred population of barley derived from a cross between a leaf rust susceptible line, L94, and a partially resistant line, 116-5. The constructed map showed a similar marker distribution pattern as the L94 × Vada map. However, it contained more large gaps, and for some chromosome regions no markers were identified. These regions are most likely derived from L94 because 116-5 was selected from the progeny of a cross of L94 × cv. Cebada Capa. Five QTLs for partial resistance to isolate 1.2.1. were mapped on the L94 × 116-5 map. Three QTLs were effective in the seedling stage, jointly contributing 42% to the total phenotypic variance. Three QTLs were effective in the adult plant stage, collectively explaining 35% of the phenotypic variance. Evidence for two additional linked minor-effect QTLs effective in the adult plant stage was also uncovered. The major-effect QTL, Rphq3, was the only one that was effective in both developmental stages. Moreover, Rphq3, was also identified in the L94 × Vada population, being effective to two rust isolates. The other QTLs were detected in either of the two populations, providing evidence for the existence of many loci for partial resistance to leaf rust on the barley genome. To date, 13 QTLs for partial resistance have been mapped, therefore, a strategy of accumulating many resistance genes in a single cultivar, resulting in a high level of partial resistance, is feasible.     

Mapping genes for resistance to barley stripe rust (Puccinia striiformis f. sp. hordei)

Two genes conferring resistance to the barley stripe rust found in Mexico and South America, previously identified as race 24, were mapped to the M arms of barley chromosomes 7 and 4 in a doubled haploid population using molecular markers and the quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping approach. The resistance gene on chromosome 7 had a major effect, accounting for 57% of the variation in disease severity. The resistance gene on chromosome 4 had a minor effect, accounting for 10% of the variation in trait expression. Two pairs of restriction fragment length polymorphism markers are being used to introgress the resistance genes to North American spring barley using molecular marker-assisted backcrossing.Ore. Agric Exp Stn J no. 10283     

Interactions of Puccinia hordei and Erysiphe graminis on seedling barley

The development of Puccinia hordei on the first leaf of barley seedlings previously inoculated with Erysiphe graminis was compared with that on uninoculated leaves of comparable age. On cv. Zephyr, more rust pustules developed when leaves were inoculated with both fungi within 24 h but fewer pustules if the period between the two inoculations was longer than 2 days. The reduction in numbers of rust pustules was especially marked where leaves were previously inoculated with many conidia of E. graminis. The size of rust pustules was reduced whatever the period between the two inoculations. Arresting mildew development by applying ethirimol as a soil drench to pots of seedlings inoculated with E. graminis 6 days previously, or floating segments of leaves inoculated with both fungi on 2% sucrose, in part counteracted these effects on rust pustule size. Similar effects were observed with cv. Mazurka where inoculations with E. graminis produced only small necrotic flecks but did induce premature loss of chlorophyll. On this cultivar (in contrast to Zephyr) the inoculation of one leaf surface affected the development of P. hordei on the other. In comparable experiments using Zephyr, E. graminis produced smaller colonies with fewer conidiophores on leaves previously inoculated with P. hordei. These effects could be alleviated by arresting rust development with a spray containing benodanil or by floating segments of leaves inoculated with both fungi on 2% sucrose. Germination of the conidia of E. graminis, formation of appressoria and initiation of colonies were not affected by the presence of P. hordei.     

The development of Puccinia hordei on barley cv. Zephyr

Germination of uredospores of Puccinia hordei was similar on cover-slips and on the first leaves of barley seedlings (cv. Zephyr) at 100 % r.h. over the range 5–25 °C, being greatest at 20 °C. At 15, 20 and 25 °C maximum germination was attained in 6 h. No uredospores germinated on coverslips in humidities below saturation. The numbers of pustules which subsequently developed on plants incubated at 5, 10, 15 or 18 °C and 100 % r.h. for varying periods up to 24 h, were directly related to rise in temperature and length of incubation. The time from inoculation to eruption of pustules (generation time) was 6 days at 25 °C, 8 days at 20 °C, 10 days at 15 °C, 15 days at 10 °C and 60 days at 5 °C. Pustule production on inoculated plants which had been kept at 5 °C was rapidly accelerated when they were transferred to 20 °C. Data obtained at constant temperatures were used to predict generation times of the fungus in the field. The productivity of pustules, determined as weight of uredospores, was examined at 10, 15 and 20 °C. Significantly more spores were produced at 15 than at 10 °C and most were produced at 20 °C. The results are discussed in relation to those obtained by other workers and to the development of brown rust in the field.     

Association mapping of spot blotch resistance in wild barley

Spot blotch, caused by Cochliobolus sativus, is an important foliar disease of barley. The disease has been controlled for over 40 years through the deployment of cultivars with durable resistance derived from the line NDB112. Pathotypes of C. sativus with virulence for the NDB112 resistance have been detected in Canada; thus, many commercial cultivars are vulnerable to spot blotch epidemics. To increase the diversity of spot blotch resistance in cultivated barley, we evaluated 318 diverse wild barley accessions comprising the Wild Barley Diversity Collection (WBDC) for reaction to C. sativus at the seedling stage and utilized an association mapping (AM) approach to identify and map resistance loci. A high frequency of resistance was found in the WBDC as 95% (302/318) of the accessions exhibited low infection responses. The WBDC was genotyped with 558 Diversity Array Technology (DArT^®) and 2,878 single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers and subjected to structure analysis before running the AM procedure. Thirteen QTL for spot blotch resistance were identified with DArT and SNP markers. These QTL were found on chromosomes 1H, 2H, 3H, 5H, and 7H and explained from 2.3 to 3.9% of the phenotypic variance. Nearly half of the identified QTL mapped to chromosome bins where spot blotch resistance loci were previously reported, offering some validation for the AM approach. The other QTL mapped to unique genomic regions and may represent new spot blotch resistance loci. This study demonstrates that AM is an effective technique for identifying and mapping QTL for disease resistance in a wild crop progenitor.     

Investigating successive Australian barley breeding populations for stable resistance to leaf rust

Key message

Genome-wide association studies of barley breeding populations identified candidate minor genes for pairing with the adult plant resistance gene Rph20 to provide stable leaf rust resistance across environments.

Abstract

Stable resistance to barley leaf rust (BLR, caused by Puccinia hordei) was evaluated across environments in barley breeding populations (BPs). To identify genomic regions that can be combined with Rph20 to improve adult plant resistance (APR), two BPs genotyped with the Diversity Arrays Technology genotyping-by-sequencing platform (DArT-seq) were examined for reaction to BLR at both seedling and adult growth stages in Australian environments. An integrated consensus map comprising both first- and second-generation DArT platforms was used to integrate QTL information across two additional BPs, providing a total of four interrelated BPs and 15 phenotypic data sets. This enabled identification of key loci underpinning BLR resistance. The APR gene Rph20 was the only active resistance region consistently detected across BPs. Of the QTL identified, RphQ27 on chromosome 6HL was considered the best candidate for pairing with Rph20. RphQ27 did not align or share proximity with known genes and was detected in three of the four BPs. The combination of RphQ27 and Rph20 was of low frequency in the breeding material; however, strong resistance responses were observed for the lines carrying this pairing. This suggests that the candidate minor gene RphQ27 can interact additively with Rph20 to provide stable resistance to BLR across diverse environments.

     

Characterising seedling and adult plant resistance to Puccinia hordei in Hordeum vulgare

A set of 113 genotypes of barley (Hordeum vulgare subsp. vulgare), along with the susceptible control genotype Gus, was tested for response to the barley leaf rust pathogen Puccinia hordei in the greenhouse (as seedlings) and field (as adult plants). The tests revealed that 68 lines carried adult plant resistance (APR), 23 lines carried uncharacterised seedling resistance (USR) and that three lines carried the seedling resistance gene Rph3. Nineteen lines lacked detectable seedling resistance and were also susceptible in the field at adult plant growth stages. The presence of marker bPb‐0837, linked to the APR gene Rph20, in 35 of the 68 lines carrying APR, suggested they carry this gene. The remaining 33 lines, which lacked the Rph20 linked marker, are likely sources of new uncharacterised APR. Pedigree analysis of the 68 lines found to carry APR revealed that 32 were related to cv. Gull and to Hordeum laevigatum; two were related to cv. Bavaria and one related to cvv. Manchuria and Taganrog, suggesting that these genotypes may be the ancestral sources of the APR carried by each.     

Genetic mapping of a new race specific resistance allele effective to Puccinia hordei at the Rph9/Rph12locus on chromosome 5HL in barley

Background

Tea is one of the most popular beverages in the world. Many species in the Thea section of the Camellia genus can be processed for drinking and have been domesticated. However, few investigations have focused on the genetic consequence of domestication and geographic origin of landraces on tea plants using credible wild and planted populations of a single species. Here, C. taliensis provides us with a unique opportunity to explore these issues.

Results

Fourteen nuclear microsatellite loci were employed to determine the genetic diversity and domestication origin of C. taliensis, which were represented by 587 individuals from 25 wild, planted and recently domesticated populations. C. taliensis showed a moderate high level of overall genetic diversity. The greater reduction of genetic diversity and stronger genetic drift were detected in the wild group than in the recently domesticated group, indicating the loss of genetic diversity of wild populations due to overexploitation and habitat fragmentation. Instead of the endangered wild trees, recently domesticated individuals were used to compare with the planted trees for detecting the genetic consequence of domestication. A little and non-significant reduction in genetic diversity was found during domestication. The long life cycle, selection for leaf traits and gene flow between populations will delay the emergence of bottleneck in planted trees. Both phylogenetic and assignment analyses suggested that planted trees may have been domesticated from the adjacent central forest of western Yunnan and dispersed artificially to distant places.

Conclusions

This study contributes to the knowledge about levels and distribution of genetic diversity of C. taliensis and provides new insights into genetic consequence of domestication and geographic origin of planted trees of this species. As an endemic tea source plant, wild, planted and recently domesticated C. taliensis trees should all be protected for their unique genetic characteristics, which are valuable for tea breeding.     

Incidence, importance and virulence of Puccinia hordei on barley in New Zealand

Brown rust of barley (Puccinia hordei) is widespread in New Zealand and causes crop losses in some years. The cultivars presently grown lack adequate genetic resistance but a highly resistant line has been produced. Twelve different virulence combinations were identified in the pathogen population using the Welsh differential lines; there were differences between North Island and South Island isolates; and no virulence was observed for resistance conferred by factors Pa 3 and Pa 7.     

A high-density consensus map of barley to compare the distribution of QTLs for partial resistance to Puccinia hordei and of defence gene homologues

A consensus map of barley was constructed based on three reference doubled haploid (DH) populations and three recombinant inbred line (RIL) populations. Several sets of microsatellites were used as bridge markers in the integration of those populations previously genotyped with RFLP or with AFLP markers. Another set of 61 genic microsatellites was mapped for the first time using a newly developed fluorescent labelling strategy, referred to as A/T labelling. The final map contains 3,258 markers spanning 1,081 centiMorgans (cM) with an average distance between two adjacent loci of 0.33 cM. This is the highest density of markers reported for a barley genetic map to date. The consensus map was divided into 210 BINs of about 5 cM each in which were placed 19 quantitative trait loci (QTL) contributing to the partial resistance to barley leaf rust (Puccinia hordei Otth) in five of the integrated populations. Each parental barley combination segregated for different sets of QTLs, with only few QTLs shared by any pair of cultivars. Defence gene homologues (DGH) were identified by tBlastx homology to known genes involved in the defence of plants against microbial pathogens. Sixty-three DGHs were located into the 210 BINs in order to identify candidate genes responsible for the QTL effects. Eight BINs were co-occupied by a QTL and DGH(s). The positional candidates identified are receptor-like kinase, WIR1 homologues and several defence response genes like peroxidases, superoxide dismutase and thaumatin. Electronic supplementary material Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at and is accessible for authorized users.